Chaojian
Ding
a,
Yonghui
Wang
a,
Chaobo
Li
a,
Jiawen
Wang
a,
Qichun
Zhang
*bc and
Weiwei
Huang
*a
aHebei Key Laboratory of Applied Chemistry, Yanshan University, Qinhuangdao 066004, Hebei, China. E-mail: huangweiwei@ysu.edu.cn
bDepartment of Materials Science and Engineering, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR 999077, China. E-mail: qiczhang@cityu.edu.hk
cCenter of Super-Diamond and Advanced Films (COSDAF), Department of Chemistry, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR 999077, China. E-mail: qiczhang@cityu.edu.hk
First published on 27th February 2024
Due to their sustainability, environmental friendliness, high specific capacity, and rapid reaction kinetics, quinone cathodes have broad application prospects in aqueous zinc-ion batteries (AZIBs). However, conventional small-molecule quinone cathodes usually suffer from unavoidable dissolution, resulting in terrible cycling stability. Herein, based on a strategy of molecular structure optimization, calix[8]quinone (C8Q) is for the first time used as a cathode in AZIBs. By extending the structure of the classical small-molecule quinone cathode calix[4]quinone (C4Q), C8Q further adds four p-benzoquinone structural units, which significantly suppresses the dissolution of its discharge products and greatly improves the cycle stability of the cathode. Specifically, the C8Q cathode displays a discharge specific capacity of 207.2 mA h g−1 at 1 A g−1 and a long-life cycle stability (93 mA h g−1/10 A g−1/10000th). Even with a high active material loading of 11 mg cm−2, the Zn‖C8Q battery also exhibits high redox reversibility and remarkable electrochemical stability. Furthermore, the belt-shaped Zn‖C8Q battery has high stability and outstanding flexibility, indicating its promising application in flexible wearable electronic devices.
Among various organic cathodes, quinone cathodes usually have wonderful electrochemical performances on account of their good electrochemical reversibility in the charge and discharge process.15–18 However, quinone cathodes (AQ, NQ, BQ, etc.) are deeply hampered by their solubility, causing their poor actual electrochemical performance.19,20 In 2018, C4Q was for the first time reported as a cathode for AZIBs. The strategy of cyclic polymerization of four benzoquinone structural units inhibited the dissolution of C4Q in aqueous electrolyte systems to a certain extent: the Zn‖C4Q battery delivered an initial capacity of 335 mA h g−1.21 However, during the subsequent cycle, the discharge products of C4Q (ZnxC4Q, x = 1∼3) exhibited a severe dissolution and shuttling phenomenon in aqueous electrolytes, leading the capacity of batteries to decay very fast. Although the dissolution and shuttling of active cathode materials were significantly improved after adopting the cation exchange membrane as the separator, this obviously increased the assembly cost of the Zn‖C4Q battery and weakened the competitiveness of the C4Q cathode in practical AZIBs. Nonetheless, this result has inspired us to further explore the application of quinone cathodes in AZIBs.
Up to now, many other methods have also been reported to solve the problem of the poor cycle stability of the above quinone cathodes, such as the combination of quinone compounds with mesoporous materials and activated carbon,22,23 modified separators,24–26 modified electrolytes,27,28etc. However, the external environment of active electrode materials is only considered, and the dissolution problem has not been fundamentally solved. Taking the molecule itself as the starting point, adopting a rational molecular structure design is undoubtedly a fundamental strategy for the dissolution problem of the small-molecule quinone cathode mentioned above.29–32
Herein, adopting a strategy of increasing the molecular weight to inhibit the dissolution of small-molecule quinone cathodes, we investigated the electrochemical properties of the C8Q cathode in AZIBs for the first time. With benzoquinone as the active structural unit, C8Q possessed a theoretical capacity of 447 mA h g−1. The further expanded long non-polar ring chain effectively inhibited the dissolution and shuttling of C8Q and its discharge products (ZnxC8Q, x = 1–4) in aqueous electrolytes, significantly improving the cycling durability of the electrode. Benefiting from these aforementioned characteristics, the C8Q cathode achieved a stable long–life cycle without using expensive Nafion membranes, whose cost is more than 17 times that of glass fiber membranes (Fig. S1†). In 3.0 M Zn(OTf)2, the C8Q cathode displayed an initial discharge capacity of 207.2 mA h g−1 at 1 A g−1 and an ultra-long cycle life over 10000 cycles at 10 A g−1 (0.0059% capacity decay/cycle). In addition, structural optimization gives the C8Q cathode the advantages of high-loading capability and flexibility as well. The high-mass loading C8Q cathode (11 mg cm−2) and the flexible belt-shaped Zn‖C8Q batteries both showed excellent cycle stability, demonstrating their potential application in diversified energy storage areas.
In addition to focusing on the solubility of the active molecules themselves, the tolerance of the discharge products of C8Q and C4Q in the aqueous electrolyte was also compared. In 3.0 M Zn(OTf)2 electrolyte soaked with the C4Q cathode (discharged to 0.20 V), the colour of the electrolyte was significantly deepened over time and the intensity of the corresponding UV absorption peak (250 nm) rose sharply. This unequivocally verified the high solubility of the discharge product of C4Q (ZnxC4Q, x = 1–3) in the aqueous electrolyte (Fig. S6c†). Remarkably, the considerable solubility of ZnxC4Q led to a severe shuttling effect in the actual charge–discharge process, thereby influencing the uniform deposition of zinc (Fig. S5†). Different from C4Q, the discharge products of C8Q (ZnxC8Q) still revealed ultralow solubility and good structural stability in aqueous electrolytes (Fig. S7c†).
In virtue of the high hydrophobicity of ZnxC8Q, the assembled Zn‖C8Q battery exhibited high stability as well in the visualized in situ dynamic charge–discharge dissolution experiments (Fig. S8†). In contrast, the dissolution and diffusion of C4Q and its discharge products (ZnxC4Q) were markedly more apparent in the actual process of the charge and discharge cycle under the influence of the internal electric field. This result suggests that reasonable molecular structure optimization can realize the low solubility of small-molecule quinone, thereby enhancing the cycle stability of the battery.
Building upon the aforementioned dissolution experiment analysis, a schematic illustration of the cyclic dissolution of C4Q and C8Q cathodes in 3.0 M Zn(OTf)2 electrolyte is presented (Fig. 1). Benefiting from the almost insoluble characteristics of C8Q and ZnxC8Q in aqueous electrolytes, the Zn‖C8Q battery achieved dual-effect optimization of the cost and electrochemical stability of AZIBs. The rationalized molecular design strategy for C8Q has a positive guiding significance to solving the dissolution problem of organic quinone cathodes.
As illustrated in Fig. 2a, the cyclic voltammetry (CV) test was implemented under the scan rate of 0.2 mV s−1. It could be observed that the C8Q cathode possessed two pairs of redox peaks with different intensities in 3.0 M Zn(OTf)2. Among them, a pair of weaker redox peaks were observed around 0.48/0.58 V, while a stronger pair was located around 0.96/1.07 V. Notably, the subsequent multiple cycles maintained a high level of consistency in the CV curves, revealing small polarization and splendid redox reversibility, whereafter the C8Q cathode was examined by constant current cycling and variable current cycling tests. At 1 A g−1, the initial discharge-specific capacity of the C8Q cathode was 207.2 mA h g−1. Over the subsequent 250 cycles, the discharge-specific capacity of the C8Q cathode gradually stabilized with the average coulombic efficiency near 100% (Fig. 2b and S10†).
Fig. 2c and S11a† show the rate performance of C8Q at various current densities. At 0.1, 0.5, 2, 5, 10, and 15 A g−1, the reversible discharge-specific capacity of the C8Q cathode reached 232.8, 176.6, 156.8, 147.3, 141.7, and 137.5 mA h g−1, respectively. As depicted in Fig. 2d, its rate performance surpasses that of most previously reported similar organic cathodes with p-benzoquinone unit structures for AZIBs. As the current density gradually decreased from 15 A g−1 to 0.1 A g−1, the specific discharge capacity of the Zn‖C8Q battery would increase correspondingly, indicating that the C8Q cathode showed superior rate performance. Due to the good operating voltage and distinguished rate performance, the C8Q cathode could deliver a high specific energy density of 189 W h kg−1 at 80 W kg−1. Even at 11623 W kg−1, its energy density could still remain at 107 W h kg−1 (Fig. S11b†). Remarkably, the Zn‖C8Q battery assembled with 3.0 M Zn(OTf)2 also displayed terrific cycle stability under the high current density of 10 A g−1. After 10
000 ultra-long cycles, the C8Q cathode still showed a discharge capacity of 93 mA h g−1 (0.0059% capacity decay/cycle) (Fig. 2e). In sharp contrast, after only 500 cycles at 10 A g−1, the discharge-specific capacity of the Zn‖C4Q battery rapidly decayed to 28 mA h g−1.
Based on the outstanding cycle stability of C8Q in aqueous electrolytes, and to pursue high energy density batteries at the same time, we further explored the electrochemical performance of the C8Q cathodes under different high-mass loadings (Fig. 2f). As depicted in Fig. 2g and S12,† after 250 cycles at 1 A g−1, the discharge-specific capacity of the C8Q cathodes with four different active material loadings gradually stabilized. The recorded discharge-specific capacities were as follows: 110.9 mA h g−1 (4 mg cm−2), 107.9 mA h g−1 (6 mg cm−2), 95.3 mA h g−1 (8 mg cm−2), and 75.6 mA h g−1 (11 mg cm−2), respectively. These values correspond to 86.8%, 84.4%, 74.6%, and 59.2% of the capacity (127.8 mA h g−1) achieved at 1 mg cm−2. Besides, the C8Q cathodes also suggested splendid rate performance at different active material loadings with variable current density, ranging from 0.25 A g−1 to 4 A g−1 (Fig. S13 and S14†). For instance, at 8 mg cm−2, the C8Q cathode displayed a capacity of 103.2 mA h g−1 at 4 A g−1, retaining 72.7% of that achieved at 0.25 A g−1 (142.0 mA h g−1). It is worth noting that, as the active material loadings were increased, the Zn‖C8Q batteries experienced a greater decline in capacity. Additionally, this capacity decay of AZIBs was further aggravated at a high current density. This occurrence was ascribed to the elevated mass loading, thereby leading to a much higher areal current density.37 Simultaneously, as the active material loading of C8Q cathodes increased, the limited electrode interface failed to achieve rapid interfacial charge transfer, leading to the decrease of its actual discharge-specific capacity. Nonetheless, the C8Q cathodes at active material loadings of 4, 6, and 8 mg cm−2 all maintained excellent cyclic stability in the large-current long-cycle test of 4 A g−1, with an average CE of 99.8% (Fig. S15†). Especially at an active material loading of 11 mg cm−2, the C8Q cathode could still achieve a stable and reversible charge–discharge cycle. Regrettably, the stability of the zinc anode was also greatly challenged when the C8Q cathode was under high active material loadings. In the actual test process, the growth of zinc dendrites was more serious under high active material loadings, which eventually led to a decrease in the overall battery cycle stability. In the follow-up research, while focusing on the development of high-performance organic cathodes, we will also explore some related research on the stability of the zinc anode.
The ion diffusion coefficient of Zn2+ (DZn2+) was determined through the application of the galvanostatic intermittent titration technique (GITT) (eqn (3) in the ESI†). In Fig. 3c, the diffusion coefficient DZn2+ of the C8Q cathode ranged from 10−10.5 to 10−7.5 cm2 s−1, which was relatively superior in aqueous zinc-organic batteries.39 Commonly, the capacitance behavior could deliver rapid interfacial charge transfer kinetics, thereby bolstering the rate performance of batteries.40 Consequently, the proportions between the contribution of diffusion and capacitance were further computed (eqn (3) in the ESI†). Fig. 3d and e show the value of pseudocapacitance contribution of the C8Q cathode was 57.9–80.2% at 0.2 to 1.0 mV s−1, implying the predominant role of interfacial charge transfer in energy storage. With the increasing scanning rate, the value of capacitance contribution rose and the influence of interfacial charge transfer control was further strengthened. The enhanced capacitance attribute of the C8Q cathode gives it the rapid charge transfer ability as the current density increases, making the capacity decay smaller at a large current density (5 A g−1 to 15 A g−1) (Fig. 2c). Notably, during the cycle, the interfacial charge transfer resistance (Rct) of the C8Q cathode decreased rapidly. The swift reduction in Rct facilitated fast interfacial charge conduction and accelerated the redox reaction, contributing to the long-period stability of the C8Q cathode (Fig. 3f). Clearly, the above kinetic studies suggested a close connection between interfacial charge transfer and the electrochemical performance properties of C8Q cathodes.
The SEM-EDS profile under TEM observation displayed no significant alteration in the distribution of C and O elements in the pristine, fully discharged, and fully charged C8Q cathodes (Fig. 4b–d). However, the changing trend of the Zn element remained consistent with the Zn 2p XPS spectrum described above, displaying a reversible increase and decrease. Notably, the micromorphology of the C8Q cathode was greatly changed under different charge and discharge states. The XRD analysis further demonstrated the transition of the crystal structure of the C8Q molecule during the intercalation and deintercalation events of Zn2+ (Fig. S17†). In the discharge state, the surface of the C8Q cathode predominantly exhibited a relatively smooth sheet layer structure. Nevertheless, in the initial state and the charging state, the electrode surface presented a nanosized multidimensional porous channel structure. These reversible structural changes greatly augmented the charge transfer interface area of the electrode, enhanced the accessibility of the electrolyte, and facilitated the rapid conduction of the interfacial charge. This, in turn, led to rapid reaction kinetics dominated by interfacial load transfer control, contributing to good electrochemical performance of C8Q at the high current density mentioned above.
Due to the hydrolysis reaction of Zn2+, a certain amount of free protons (H+) is typically generated in the aqueous solution of ZnSO4, Zn(OTf)2, or ZnCl2, resulting in the pH of the electrolyte being 4–5. Although some previous reports have verified that carbonyl-based organic cathodes can simultaneously combine with H+ and Zn2+ during the discharge process, this phenomenon does not seem to be universally applicable to all carbon-based organic cathode materials. To ascertain whether H+ is involved in the storage, the typical three-electrode method was employed to test the CV curves of C8Q cathodes across three distinct electrolytes: 3.0 M Zn(OTf)2/H2O electrolyte (pH = 4.35), CF3SO3H/H2O electrolyte (pH = 4.35), and saturated Zn(OTf)2/acetonitrile (AN) electrolyte. In 3.0 M Zn(OTf)2/H2O electrolyte containing both Zn2+ and H+, two pairs of redox peaks (I, II, III, IV) appeared, and the shape of the peaks highly matched the CV curve under the coin-cell system. When containing only H+ in CF3SO3H/H2O electrolyte (Fig. S18a†), discernible redox peaks for the C8Q cathode were absent. Additionally, the CV curve in CF3SO3H/H2O electrolyte differed greatly from that in 3.0 M Zn(OTf)2/H2O electrolyte. In contrast, when containing only Zn2+ in saturated Zn(OTf)2/AN electrolyte, the C8Q cathode displayed four distinct redox peaks (I′, II′, III′, IV′), which correspond to the four redox peaks (I, II, III, IV) observed in the 3.0 M Zn(OTf)2/H2O electrolyte (Fig. S18b†).
Remarkably, the shape and relative intensity of the redox peaks in the two CV curves in Fig. S19b† also corresponded one to one, indicating the absence of cooperative participation of H+ in the C8Q cathode in 3.0 M Zn(OTf)2/H2O electrolyte.
The above results confirmed that Zn2+ underwent reversible redox reactions with CO of C8Q, realizing energy storage and conversion. The C8Q cathode exhibited a reversible specific capacity of 232.8 mA h g−1 at 0.1 A g−1, corresponding to the redox process of 8 electrons. Therefore, C8Q could be reversible to combine/separate with four Zn2+ for energy storage and transformation.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 (a) Bending test of the belt-shaped battery at different angles. (b) Cycle stability through consecutive and repeated bending states at 1 A g−1. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4sc00491d |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |