Na Yeon
Kwon‡
,
Haeun
Kwak‡
,
Ha Yeon
Kim‡
,
Su Hong
Park
,
Jin Young
Park
,
Min Ji
Kang
,
Chang Woo
Koh
,
Sungnam
Park
*,
Min Ju
Cho
* and
Dong Hoon
Choi
*
Department of Chemistry, Research Institute for Natural Sciences, Korea University, 145 Anam-ro, Seongbuk-gu, Seoul, 02841, Republic of Korea. E-mail: spark8@korea.ac.kr; chominju@korea.ac.kr; dhchoi8803@korea.ac.kr
First published on 6th July 2024
This paper introduces the design concept of a dual-functional molecular dyad tailored specifically for solution-processable organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs). Cy-tmCPBN, characterized by an asymmetric molecular dyad structure, integrates a host unit (tmCP) and a multiple-resonance (MR) emitter (CzBN) via a non-conjugated cyclohexane linker. Cy-tmCPBN exhibited efficient intramolecular energy transfers (EnTs) from tmCP to the CzBN unit, as confirmed by time-resolved fluorescence experiments. The fluorescence lifetime of the tmCP unit was approximately three times shorter in a highly diluted solution of Cy-tmCPBN than in a mixed solution of Cy-tmCP and Cy-CzBN. In addition, Cy-tmCPBN exhibited excellent solubility and film-forming ability, making it suitable for solution processing. Notably, OLEDs utilizing Cy-tmCPBN achieved over twice the brightness and improved external quantum efficiency of 12.3% compared to OLEDs using Cy-CzBN with the same concentration of CzBN in the emitting layer. The improved OLED performance can be explained by the increased EnT efficiency from Cy-tmCP to Cy-tmCPBN and the intramolecular EnT within Cy-tmCPBN. In our dual-functional dyad, incorporating both host and emitter units in an asymmetric molecular dyad structure, we induced a positive synergy effect with the host moiety, enhancing OLED performance through intramolecular EnT.
However, the past photophysical strategy of intramolecular EnT has been predominantly focused on research involving the formation of intermolecular heterojunctions between donors and acceptors in organic photovoltaics.14,15 In particular, the incorporation of both donors and acceptors within a single molecule to absorb solar energy in the active layer material has been studied, but the limitations in the performance of devices utilizing this approach have been recognized as challenging to overcome. Molecular dyads have been applied in various important applications, especially in the field of metal complexes and fluorescence molecules, serving as probes in biological research.16–18 However, if a molecular dyad incorporates both organic semiconductor-based donor and acceptor elements and maintains an appropriate distance between the two semiconductor moieties to achieve efficient intramolecular EnT, it is anticipated to function as a crucial component in the emissive layer (EML) of OLEDs. Specifically, adopting the conjugative moiety used as a host in OLEDs as the donor and combining it with a desired emitter as the acceptor through an appropriate linker to form a molecular dyad, utilizing it as an emitter, may yield different effects on OLED performance compared to traditional physically blended host-emitter EML systems.
Recently, organic boron-based multiple resonance (MR) TADF emitters have attracted significant attention for their potential applications in wide gamut and high-resolution displays of OLEDs.19–22 The MR effect, characterized by atomic-scale HOMO/LUMO separation, led to a minimal ΔEST and inhibited vibrational coupling between the S0 and S1 states. This resulted in a high photoluminescence quantum yield (PLQY) and narrowband emission with a reduced full-width-at-half-maximum (FWHM).23–26 Therefore, given these advantages, it might be feasible to employ the previously mentioned molecular dyad as a medium-sized molecular emitter to develop narrowband OLEDs by integrating an MR emitter onto one or both branches of the molecular dyad.
MR-TADF emitters have been predominantly developed for vacuum-deposited emissive layers. Among them, BCzBN is one of the most widely used second-generation MR cores, and its planar solid structure leads to a narrow FWHM, making it widely applied in bright blue and green MR emitter structures.27–31 However, the planar and rigid structure of MR-TADF emitters often facilitates the formation of weakly emitting aggregates or excimers.32 Consequently, applying MR-TADF emitters in OLEDs reduces efficiency, shifts in electroluminescent (EL) wavelengths, and broadens the emission peak.33 These undesirable issues become more pronounced when applied to solution-processed OLEDs. With growing interest in the benefits of solution processing for OLED fabrication, there is an urgent demand for comprehensive strategic research on MR-TADF emitters characterized by enhanced solubility and superior film-forming performance in organic solvents.
As previously stated, we opted for a structural approach employing a dual-functional molecular dyad with a nonconjugated linker to improve the solubility of the MR emitter and create an amorphous emitting layer. Based on earlier research employing this molecular design approach, both molecular dyad host materials and emitter molecules have demonstrated suitability as the EML in OLEDs fabricated via solution processes.34–36
Placing the same host moiety or MR emitter moiety on both branch locations enables the synthesis of a symmetric dyad. Through meticulous synthesis, it is possible to combine the host and emitter moieties on each branch to synthesize an asymmetric dyad.
By utilizing these three types of dyads, we can investigate the photoinduced intermolecular and intramolecular EnT phenomena through steady and time-resolved spectroscopic studies. By applying them to solution-processed OLEDs, we can compare the performance of an EML containing asymmetric molecular dyad emitters that exhibit intramolecular EnT with an asymmetric structure to that of a conventional EML based on a blend of molecular dyad hosts and emitters.
This study presents a dual-functional molecular dyad designed for efficient intramolecular EnT. More specifically, the recently developed Cy-tmCPBN utilizes a non-conjugated cyclohexane core to link the tmCP host and the CzBN emitter, preserving the distinct properties of both the host and emitter within the molecule. With a molecular weight exceeding 1000 g mol−1 and a three-dimensional structure, this dyad demonstrated enhanced solubility and excellent film-forming ability. Notably, Cy-tmCPBN efficiently exhibits intramolecular EnT from the tmCP moiety to the CzBN moiety. This feature is anticipated to have a significant impact on device performance when used in the EML of OLEDs. This advantage implies that both intramolecular and intermolecular EnT could occur in the subsequent device, suggesting that Cy-tmCP:Cy-tmCPBN-based OLEDs exhibiting unique narrowband emission could exhibit higher efficiencies than devices based on Cy-tmCP:Cy-CzBN, in which only intermolecular EnT occurs. As expected, Cy-tmCPBN-based OLEDs demonstrated superior device performance compared to OLEDs using the same concentration of Cy-CzBN.
This molecular dyad, proposed in this study, demonstrates intramolecular energy transfer and has the potential to exert positive synergy effects with the host within the EML of OLEDs, and enhancing energy transfer from the host moiety to the emitter (Fig. 1).
Fig. 1 Molecular design strategy for a solution-processable dual-functional molecular dyad with a cyclohexane linker. |
Consequently, the design of the molecular structure of Cy-tmCPBN aimed to maintain the independent features of the CzBN core without interference using a non-conjugated linker. In addition, we focused on preserving the unique properties associated with the MR emitter while facilitating intramolecular EnT within the molecular structure and ensuring narrowband emission. The key to achieving this goal is to maintain a close spatial proximity between tmCP and CzBN, allowing effective intramolecular EnT and ensuring the independent preservation of the emissive characteristics of the CzBN moiety within the molecule.
The synthetic routes to Cy-tmCP, Cy-CzBN, and Cy-tmCPBN are illustrated in Scheme S1.† The chemical structures of the three new molecular dyad materials were confirmed by 1H, 13C, and 11B NMR spectroscopy (Fig. S1–S12†) and mass spectrometry (Fig. S13–S15†). These three compounds exhibited high solubilities in common organic solvents and demonstrated excellent film-forming properties. This is achieved by introducing six or eight tert-butyl substituents and a cyclohexane linker to obtain the desired molecular weight and solubility. In particular, Cy-tmCPBN demonstrated exceptional solubility even in hexane (≥100 mg mL−1).
These dyad materials displayed high decomposition temperatures (Td, 5% weight loss) of 495 for Cy-tmCP, 523 for Cy-CzBN, and 529 °C for Cy-tmCPBN, respectively (Fig. S18a†). As shown in the DSC data in Fig. S20b,† both Cy-tmCP and Cy-tmCPBN exhibited glass transition temperatures (Tg) exceeding 240 °C, indicating that the cyclohexane bridge in the molecular dyad materials contributed to the enhancement of their thermal and morphological stabilities.
Fig. 2 Molecular structures and molecular orbitals of Cy-tmCP, Cy-tmCPBN, and Cy-CzBN obtained via DFT calculations (B3LYP/6-31G(d)). |
As confirmed by DFT calculations, the individual tmCP and CzBN units of the asymmetric molecular dyad tended to act independently because of their non-conjugated cyclohexane linkers. The energies of the four degenerate occupied molecular orbitals (from HOMO to HOMO−3) and the four unoccupied molecular orbitals (from LUMO to LUMO+3) of Cy-tmCP were almost identical, indicating that the four carbazole units in Cy-tmCP contributed equally to the frontier molecular orbitals (Fig. 2 and S16†). Similarly, Cy-CzBN exhibits equivalent energies for the frontier molecular orbitals (HOMO/HOMO−1 and LUMO/LUMO+1) because of the two identical CzBN units. Accordingly, the S1 and S2 energies of Cy-CzBN were identical; however, the two individual CzBN units contributed asymmetrically to the electronic transitions, as is clearly illustrated by the natural transition orbitals (HONTO and LUNTO; Fig. S18†). In particular, for Cy-CzBN, HONTO, and LUNTO, the S0 → S1 and S0 →S2 transitions were predominantly localized on the CzBN units.
In the case of Cy-tmCPBN, the electrochemical and photophysical properties of Cy-tmCPBN are primarily determined by the CzBN unit. Accordingly, the HOMO and LUMO energies, as well as the energies of the electronic states (S1, T1, and T2), are nearly identical to those of Cy-CzBN except for the degenerate states (Fig. 2 and S19†). The tmCP unit in Cy-tmCPBN is commonly used as a host (Cy-tmCP) and facilitates energy transfer from the host to the emitting CzBN unit. In fact, the intramolecular EnT from the tmCP unit to the CzBN unit is highly efficient, as explained in detail below. In short, DFT calculations imply that the CzBN units in Cy-CzBN and Cy-tmCPBN are responsible for their optical and electrochemical properties and can play an important role as an emitting core in Cy-CzBN and Cy-tmCPBN.
Compound | λ abs (nm) | λ PL (nm) | FWHMa (nm) | E S/ET/ΔESTb (eV) | E HOMO/ELUMOc (eV) | Φ PL (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Measured in toluene (1 × 10−5 M). b E S and ET energies were obtained from the onset of the fluorescence and phosphorescence spectra in toluene at 298 K and 77 K, respectively. c E HOMO (eV) = −e(4.8 eV + Eox − Eferrocene) and ELUMO (eV) = EHOMO (eV) + Eg (eV). d Overall absolute PLQY obtained in 4 mol% doped thin film with an Cy-tmCP host using an integrating sphere. | ||||||
Cy-tmCP | 298, 345 | 355 | 30 | 3.61/3.06/0.55 | −5.69/−2.19 | 11.7 |
Cy-CzBN | 299, 473 | 494 | 22 | 2.61/2.43/0.18 | −5.54/−3.08 | 57.3 |
Cy-tmCPBN | 297, 472 | 491 | 22 | 2.62/2.50/0.12 | −5.60/−3.13 | 65.4 |
We investigated the photophysical characteristics of BCzBN, Cy-CzBN, and Cy-tmCPBN neat films and doped films by measuring their PL spectra in more detail. In Fig. 3b, the neat film of BCzBN exhibits a broad shoulder peak at ∼570 nm, which was not observed in the neat films of Cy-CzBN and Cy-tmCPBN. This is interpreted as the mitigation of aggregation between emitter molecules facilitated by the introduction of a three-dimensional sp3 linker.
To investigate intramolecular EnT in Cy-tmCPBN, we prepared two diluted toluene solutions (1 × 10−7 M) containing only Cy-tmCPBN and a mixture of Cy-tmCP and Cy-CzBN in a 1:1 molar ratio. As shown in Fig. 4a, the PL spectra of a mixture of Cy-tmCP and Cy-CzBN in toluene revealed distinct individual PL peaks resulting from tmCP and CzBN, respectively. In contrast, the PL spectrum of Cy-tmCPBN in toluene displayed a negligibly small PL peak at 355 nm and a large PL peak at 491 nm, indicating efficient intramolecular EnT from the tmCP unit to the CzBN unit in Cy-tmCPBN.
To investigate the intramolecular EnT in more detail, we measured the time-resolved fluorescence (TRF) signals of Cy-tmCPBN and a mixture of Cy-tmCP and Cy-CzBN in toluene (1 × 10−7 M), as shown in Fig. 4b. Fig. 4b shows the TRF signals of the tmCP units in the two solutions, measured at 355 nm. The TRF signal of Cy-tmCPBN decayed much faster than that of the mixture of Cy-tmCP and Cy-CzBN, which resulted from intramolecular EnT from the tmCP unit to the CzBN unit in Cy-tmCPBN. The TRF signals were fitted using a bi-exponential function and the average lifetimes (τavg) were extracted. Using a simple kinetic model in Fig. 4c, the intramolecular EnT rate constants (kET) were determined. In Cy-tmCPBN, the intramolecular EnT from the tmCP unit to the CzBN unit was twice as fast as the fluorescence relaxation of the tmCP unit (kET = 3.9 × 108 s−1vs. k1 = 1.9 × 108 s−1). The TRF signals of the CzBN units in the two dilute solutions were almost identical (Fig. S24†).
To study the impact of emitter concentrations on the intramolecular EnT, over the range from 2 mol% to 12 mol% of doped Cy-CzBN and Cy-tmCPBN films were prepared in Cy-tmCP. Fig. S22a and d† show the emission spectra of the doped Cy-CzBN and Cy-tmCPBN films. The intensities of Cy-CzBN and Cy-tmCPBN decreased as the concentration increased up to 12%.
However, a difference was revealed in the normalized steady-state emission spectra of both films, which was a difference in intensity at approximately 350–400 nm. Unlike Cy-CzBN, Cy-tmCPBN exhibited a consistent intensity in the 350–400 nm range, regardless of the doping concentration, which was attributed to intramolecular EnT from tmCP to the CzBN unit.
In addition, the TRF signals of Cy-CzBN- and Cy-tmCPBN-doped Cy-tmCP films were measured at the PL peak (488 nm) of the CzBN units (Fig. S25†). The TRF signal of Cy-tmCPBN-doped films decayed slightly faster than that of Cy-CzBN-doped films, indicating that the PL of the CzBN units was more efficient in Cy-tmCPBN-doped Cy-tmCP films than Cy-CzBN-doped Cy-tmCP films. In the films, two nearby CzBN units in Cy-CzBN can undergo intramolecular energy exchange, which may slow the overall energy relaxation.
In the Cy-tmCP:Cy-CzBN system, the blended film of the two materials represented an interface between two molecules of medium-size, allowing for phase separation. Nevertheless, intermolecular EnT from tmCP to CzBN was quite efficient in the blend film prepared at room temperature. However, for the Cy-tmCP:Cy-tmCPBN blend film, the interface between the two medium-sized molecules in the film was expected to be exceptionally well formed because of the common inclusion of the tmCP moiety in both molecules, indicating outstanding miscibility. Therefore, based on the results of the steady-state emission and transient PL spectra, it was confirmed that both inter-and intramolecular EnTs were possible within the film in this case.
When the solvent was changed from nonpolar hexane to polar chloroform (Fig. S27†), Cy-tmCPBN exhibited a solvent-dependent shift in a manner similar to Cy-CzBN, with only a slight 10 nm bathochromic shift in emission (Table S1†). This suggests that, in the excited state, the tmCP unit does not significantly alter the MR emission characteristics of Cy-tmCPBN and Cy-CzBN.
Furthermore, cyclic voltammetry (CV) measurements were conducted to determine the HOMO energy levels of molecular dyads (Fig. S28 and Table S2†). In the solution state, the oxidation onset potential of Cy-tmCPBN was identical to that of Cy-CzBN (+1.00 V). However, in the film state, the oxidation potential of Cy-tmCPBN was measured at +1.13 V, which falls between the values for Cy-tmCP (+1.22 V) and Cy-CzBN (+1.07 V).
The HOMO energy level of Cy-tmCPBN was determined to be −5.60 eV, with the LUMO level calculated at −3.13 eV. The LUMO energy level was estimated from the optical bandgap and HOMO energy. These findings aligned with the DFT calculations illustrated in Fig. 2, suggesting a significant impact of the CzBN segment on the energy characteristics of Cy-tmCPBN, as corroborated by experimental observations.
Consequently, the thin film containing Cy-tmCPBN exhibited a fine surface morphology. The finer morphology suggested that effective CT was anticipated in the EML, which was attributed to the shared presence of tmCP and the facilitated compatibility between the Cy-tmCP and Cy-tmCPBN molecules.
Doping conc. (mol%) | V on (V) | η c,max (cd A−1) | η p,max (Lm W−1) | L (cd m−2) | η ext,max (%) | λ EL (nm) | FWHM (nm) | CIEg (x, y) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Turn-on voltage of 1 cd m−2. b Maximum CE. c Maximum PE. d Maximum luminance. e Maximum EQE. f EL peak wavelength. g CIE color coordinates at 1000 cd m−2. | ||||||||
2 | 4.07 | 23.94 | 16.08 | 809 | 11.21 | 492 | 32 | (0.10, 0.45) |
4 | 4.01 | 28.30 | 19.22 | 1291 | 12.33 | 496 | 36 | (0.11, 0.50) |
6 | 4.00 | 30.10 | 20.91 | 1444 | 12.26 | 496 | 38 | (0.12, 0.53) |
8 | 3.94 | 31.37 | 21.90 | 1711 | 12.14 | 496 | 40 | (0.13, 0.55) |
10 | 3.88 | 31.29 | 21.03 | 1745 | 11.86 | 500 | 41 | (0.14, 0.56) |
12 | 3.81 | 29.06 | 19.77 | 1732 | 10.74 | 500 | 43 | (0.14, 0.57) |
As the emitter (CzCN moiety) concentration increased from 2 to 12 mol%, no significant change was observed in the maximum external quantum efficiency (EQEmax) during measurement in both Cy-tmCP:Cy-CzBN and Cy-tmCP:Cy-tmCPBN devices, indicating that the molecular dyad structure of the emitters can suppress aggregation-induced quenching with increasing emitter concentration. Additionally, devices based on Cy-tmCPBN exhibited higher EQEmax and a smaller efficiency roll-off compared to those based on Cy-CzBN. The EQEmax of the Cy-tmCPBN-based device reached 12.33%, with efficiency roll-offs of 23.52% and 43.83% at luminances of 100 cd m−2 and 200 cd m−2, respectively. In contrast, the Cy-CzBN-based device showed an EQEmax of 10.90%, with efficiency roll-offs of 50.19% and 67.44% at the same luminances. When evaluating the molecular orientation of the EML, both systems displayed similar values (Fig. S32†). This suggests that the emitter orientation effects can be assumed to be similar in explaining the observed performance differences between the two devices. As a result, the enhanced performance and reduced efficiency roll-off of Cy-tmCPBN-based devices are attributed to shorter τd, more efficient EnT, and superior PLQY of the doped EML.
As shown in Fig. S22,† increasing the concentration of the emitter in the two different OLEDs resulted in an increase in the FWHM of the EML spectrum, and the emission wavelength shifted towards longer wavelengths. Upon closer examination, it was evident that the variation in the EML spectra of the blend films containing Cy-tmCP and Cy-CzBN was more pronounced with respect to the emitter concentration. This is particularly notable when high concentrations of Cy-CzBN, which contains two emitter moieties, are doped into the Cy-tmCP host. In such cases, the enhanced interaction between the neighboring CzBN emitters and host materials can influence electronic transitions, potentially having a more significant impact on the wavelength of the emitted light.
Thus, the introduction of various MR-TADF emitter units and a host moiety at the two branch positions within the asymmetric molecular dyad structure independently demonstrated dual functionality. Based on the results regarding the device performance mentioned above, this suggests a significant advantage in realizing high-efficiency, solution-processable OLEDs.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4sc02357a |
‡ N. Y. Kwon, H. Kwak, and H. Y. Kim have equally contributed to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |