Xiyue
Cao
a,
Jiashi
Chen
a,
Yue
Chen
a,
Xuanfeng
Jiang
a,
Wen
Fan
a,
Huijuan
Ma
b,
Zhengguang
Sun
*a and
Yuan
Zhan
*a
aKey Laboratory for the Green Preparation and Application of Functional Materials, Ministry of Education, Hubei Key Laboratory of Polymer Materials, School of Materials Science and Engineering, Hubei University, Wuhan 430062, China. E-mail: sunshine@hubu.edu.cn; zy@hubu.edu.cn
bHubei Three Gorges Laboratory, Yichang 443000, China
First published on 17th November 2023
Carbon dots (CDs) have desirable prospects for replacing conventional fluorescent materials in the field of fingerprint powder due to their attractive fluorescence, environmental friendliness, and stability. Designing solid-state fluorescent CD-based composites with suitable sizes for accurate latent fingerprint identification is still a huge challenge. Herein, CDs embedded in organosilicon (CDs–OSi) composites were synthesized by utilizing the reaction between 3-ureidopropyl triethoxy silane and L-(−)-malic acid. The obtained CDs–OSi composites display tunable fluorescence from blue to green just by controlling the volume ratio of H2O and ethanol in a solvothermal process. In particular, CDs–OSi composites simultaneously exhibit a controllable and uniform size from 0.12 μm to 5 μm. The CDs–OSi composites with different emissions and sizes were further applied to detect latent fingerprints (LFPs). The results show that CDs–OSi composites can be easily adsorbed onto the grease of the fingerprint, and level 2 and level 3 characteristics can be clearly identified by a simple powder dusting method. Furthermore, CDs–OSi composites are validated for the collection and identification of LFPs on different substrates. The results prove that CDs–OSi composites have great development prospects as developers in LFP visualization for forensic investigations.
At present, various fluorescent materials have been developed for LFP recording and analysis, including organic fluorophores, aggregation-induced emission (AIE) materials, organometallics, and semiconductor quantum dots.15,16 But these materials also exhibit some inherent shortcomings. For example, organic fluorophores, like rhodamine composites, easily stain the surface of substrates, so that the lines of a fingerprint cannot be drawn clearly due to background interference.17 AIE materials usually involve the use of environmentally unfriendly organic solvents with long incubation time, which can easily cause damage to fingerprints.18 Organometallics and semiconductor quantum dots typically use expensive metal or toxic heavy metal ions.19 Therefore, it is highly desirable to design safe and excellent novel fluorescent materials to enhance LFP development.
Carbon dots (CDs) might be promising candidates for fingerprint analysis owing to their simple preparation, controlled fluorescence, low cost, environmental friendliness and easy functionalization.20–23 CDs have an abundance of surface functional groups, which can combine with fingermark residues by covalent coupling or electrostatic adsorption to develop the characteristics of fingermarks.24 Bandosz reported N-doped CDs for developing the recognition of LFPs.25 However, CDs frequently undergo fluorescence quenching in an agglomerated state. A spraying method is usually selected to capture a fingerprint. As a CD dispersal medium, H2O is usually difficult to adhere stably on smooth surfaces.26 But an organic solvent would be corrosive to most objects, such as rubber and paint layers.27 Subsequently, Xiong reported red-emissive CDs mixed with starch to form R-CDs/starch phosphors, and the bright red fluorescence of R-CDs/starch phosphors lit up LFPs, showing very clear ridge patterns with a typical powder dusting method.28 Very recently, Lu utilized molecular self-assembly to prepare four chlorosalicylaldehyde-functionalized CDs with tunable emission ranging from blue to yellow, as well as changing morphologies from three-dimensional to one-dimensional.29 The efficiency of developing latent fingerprints with fluorescent materials is determined by several main factors, including the emissive color and intensity, morphology, size, and powder dispersion of the developer.30 However, designing solid-state fluorescent CD-based composites with multicolored solid-state emission, uniform size and high dispersion for accurate latent fingerprint identification remains a great challenge.
In this paper, we provide a simple strategy to synthesize CDs embedded in organosilicon (CDs–OSi) composites with controllable fluorescence from blue to green, accompanied by increasing size from 0.12 μm to 5 μm by adjusting the volume ratio of H2O and ethanol in a solvothermal process. The CDs–OSi composites are used as developers to identify LFPs on several substrates by a powder-dusting method. It is found that CDs–OSi composites with different luminescent colors, and appropriate sizes can be selected for LFP display on different substrates, which can provide details of the fingermarks with effective definition and contrast. This work not only provides an efficient strategy for the preparation of CD-based materials with tunable solid-state fluorescence and size, but also provides a versatile, adaptable, nontoxic, and cheap solution suitable for fingermark development at crime scenes.
Fig. 1 (a) Synthesis route of the CDs–OSi composites. (b) Optical images of CDs–OSi composite synthesis at different volume ratios of H2O/EtOH. |
The chemical structure and composition of the CDs–OSi composites were first investigated using FT-IR and XPS spectra. The FT-IR spectra of the five CDs–OSi composites are similar (Fig. S1, ESI†), indicating their similar chemical compositions. Several sharp bands at 1563 cm−1, 1652 cm−1, and 1709 cm−1 should be noted, which can be attributed to the stretching band of the –N–CO group, and sharp bands at 3011–2824 cm−1, which can be assigned to stretching vibrations of the –NHCH2CH2– group.33 In addition, there is a peak at 1770 cm−1, which can be assigned to the CO stretching vibration of imide.34 These characteristic bands confirm that the reaction successfully took place between the –NH2 of the UPTES and the –COOH of L-(−)-malic acid during the synthesis process. The presence of obvious Si–O–Si and Si–O–C bond stretching vibrations is found at 1129 and 1027 cm−1, respectively. This proves that hydrolytic polycondensation of UPTES forms an “Si–O–Si” network structure to coat the CDs.35 The XPS spectrum of the CDs–OSi composites demonstrates the presence of carbon (C), silicon (Si), oxygen (O), and nitrogen (N) elements (Fig. S2a, ESI†). As shown as Fig. S2b (ESI†), the content of C, N, O, and Si elements approaches that of CDs–OSi composites prepared with different H2O/EtOH volume ratios, so it can be concluded that the content of doped element is not a factor causing the redshift of the emission wavelength of CDs–OSi composites. Analysis of the high-resolution scans (Fig. S2c–e, ESI†) reveals that the C 1s band can be divided into four peaks at around 283.88, 284.80, 285.85, and 287.50 eV, belonging to C–Si, C–C, C–N, and CO, respectively.36,37 The N 1s spectrum manifests peaks at around 399.05 and 400.35 eV that are attributed to N–H and N–C, respectively (Fig. S2f–h, ESI†).38 The Si 2p spectrum is fitted with two peaks at around 101.73 and 102.24 eV for Si–C and Si–O, respectively (Fig. S2i–k, ESI†).39 All the XPS spectra show that the five CDs–OSi composites possess the same chemical bonds, in agreement with the FT-IR analysis. According to the above results, we can see that the tunable H2O/EtOH volume ratio has a slight influence on the chemical structure and composition of CDs–OSi composites, with regard to their emission.
The morphology of the CDs–OSi composites was further observed using HRTEM and FESEM. It has been reported in the literature that the volume ratio of H2O/EtOH has a negligible effect on the size of CDs in a one-step solvothermal method to prepare CDs/SiO2 composites.40,41 CDs–OSi prepared with an H2O/EtOH volume ratio of 15:3 was selected to explore the structure of the CDs. The HRTEM image of 15:3 CDs–OSi reveals that spherical CDs (average particle size around 2.36 nm) can be observed with visible crystalline lattice fringes (Fig. 2a). The lattice spacings of the CDs are about 0.21 nm, indicating the (1 0 0) facet of graphite.42 The XRD pattern presents a broad peak centered at 2θ = 21.27°, indicating that the CDs–OSi composites are amorphous (Fig. S3, ESI†).43Fig. 2b–f show that the morphology of the composites is spherical, and the radius of the particles increases from 0.12 μm to 5 μm as the H2O/EtOH volume ratio decreases from 15:3 to 3:15. It has been reported that the proportion of H2O in the reaction mixed solvent plays a crucial role in the degree of hydrolysis and the subsequent condensation reaction of UPTES. The hydrolysis and polycondensation of UPTES compete in their reaction with CDs.44 Thus, the reduction of H2O content in the reaction may be profitable for inhibiting the hydrolysis of UPTES and advancing the reaction between UPTES and CDs, making the CDs–OSi more regular and larger in size due to the higher degree of crosslinking between the CDs and organosilicon.45 The increased degree of crosslinking indicates that the spacing between the CDs decreases, which will tend to induce a resonance energy transfer (RET) effect.46 CDs–OSi composites with tunable emission and size will have important application prospects in fingerprint analysis for different substrates.
The optical properties of the CDs–OSi composites are characterized in Fig. 3. The absorption spectra of the CDs–OSi composites (Fig. 3a) show that they exhibit a strong absorption band located at λmax ≈ 400 nm, which can be attributed to n–π* transitions of CO caused by the extended conjugation in their structure.47 The photoluminescent (PL) emission spectra are redshifted from 440 to 500 nm when the volume ratio of H2O/EtOH changes from 15:3 to 3:15, consistent with the fluorescent photographs shown in Fig. 1b. In addition, the fluorescence intensity first increases from 15:3 to 6:12, and then decreases to 3:15 (Fig. 3b). To explore the reason for the fluorescence redshift, control experiments treating L-(−)-malic acid or UPTES in ratios of H2O/EtOH of 15:3 or 3:15 were conducted under the same reaction conditions. As shown in Fig. S4 (ESI†), the CDs–OSi composites exhibit more pronounced redshift emission (about 50 nm) than that of a solution of CDs prepared with L-(−)-malic acid (about 14 nm) and fluorescent powder prepared from UPTES (about 0 nm), which proves that the redshifted emission of the CDs–OSi composites is caused by joint action between CDs and organosilicon rather than by the CDs. Therefore, the redshifted emission of CDs–OSi may be attributed to the following reason: the UPTES have a decreasing hydrolysis and polycondensation rate, and an increasing reaction rate with CDs as the volume ratio of H2O/EtOH changes from 15:3 to 3:15, which lead to the CDs–OSi composites having a more compact structure, bigger size and decreasing distance between CDs due to the higher crosslinking degree between CDs with organosilicon.48 It has been reported that the CDs would undergo an RET effect as the distance between CDs decreases to less than the Förster distance (R0), which will lead to their emission redshift.49,50 As Fig. 3c and Fig. S5 (ESI†) show, all the CDs–OSi composites exhibit similar excitation wavelength dependence behavior: that is, the emission peaks appear redshifted as the excitation wavelength increases. This indicates that the properties of CDs embedded in CDs–OSi composites are similar. As shown in Fig. 3d and Table S1 (ESI†), the fluorescence decay curve of the CDs–OSi composites are fitted with bi-exponential functions with average lifetimes of 17.90, 13.42, 12.94, 11.21 and 10.23 ns, respectively, indicating the singlet-state nature of the emission of the CDs–OSi composites.51 The gradually shortened average lifetimes of the CDs–OSi composites can also demonstrate the generation of RET, because the RET competes with radiative transition and thus shortens the fluorescence lifetime.52 The above results can prove that the redshifted emission of the CDs–OSi composites is caused by their different size due to the occurrence of RET. The PLQY of the five CDs–OSi composites is determined to be 18.07%, 18.8%, 12.6%, 10.8% and 6.47%, respectively. The bright solid-state emission intensity would meet the requirements for fingerprint recognition.
In criminal investigation at an actual crime scene, latent fingerprints sometimes exist in a matrix contaminated by impurities.53,54 Therefore, the corrosion resistance of developers under different complex conditions is very important. The CDs–OSi composites were soaked for three days in organic solvents of different polarities, such as bromobenzene, acetone, TM, CTC, methanol, and DMSO. As shown in Fig. 4a and b and Fig. S6 (ESI†), before and after soaking, none of the CDs–OSi composites dissolved, and the emission peak and PL intensity were basically unchanged, indicating that all of the CDs–OSi composites show good organic corrosion resistance. It is necessary to explore the stability of the CDs–OSi composites in terms of temperature and UV radiation, which are closely related to the effective preservation and actual practical operation for LFP development. Fig. 4c shows the trend of the relative PL intensities of CDs–OSi composites treated at different temperatures. Compared with their initial value at room temperature of 30 °C, the PL intensity of all the CDs–OSi remains as high as about 90% as the temperature rises from 30 to 105 °C. The five CDs–OSi composites were also exposed under 365 nm UV light for 24 h, 48 h, 72 h, and 96 h. The relative PL intensity of the CDs–OSi can also remain as high as about 90% (Fig. 4d). As shown in Fig. S7 (ESI†), the CDs–OSi composites were also treated with different pH, and the fluorescence emission peak and intensity are basically unchanged in the pH range 1–11 for 24 h. This is because the “Si–O–Si” network structure wraps the CDs, avoiding fluorescence quenching caused by the generation of hydrogen bonds in a strongly acidic environment and deprotonation in a strongly alkaline environment with the rich hydroxyl, carboxyl and other functional groups on the surface of the CDs.55 The fluorescence emission peak and intensity of CDs–OSi composites were also hardly changed in 1 mol⋅ L−1 or 3 mol ⋅L−1 of KCl solutions for 24 h (Fig. S8, ESI†), which proves that the surface functional groups of the CDs are not ionized. The above results indicate that CDs–OSi composites show excellent photobleaching resistance, organic solvent resistance, high temperature resistance, acid and alkali resistance and salt tolerance.
Thanks to their tunable emission and size, and good emission stability, the CDs–OSi composites were further used for fingerprint identification. As shown in Fig. 5a, five kinds of samples were coated on latent fingerprints with goose feather sticks. The fingerprint images were obtained by irradiating them with an LED lamp (Fig. 5b–f, left) and an ultraviolet lamp (Fig. 5b–f, right). Compared with the fingerprints obtained from a traditional ink pad (Fig. 5g, left) and non-fluorescent patterns (Fig. 5g, right), the fluorescent images from CDs–OSi composites under UV light are clearer, which indicates that the use of CDs–OSi composites is beneficial for displaying fingerprint images. It can be observed that the LFPs are formed by residual liquid from the fingers (Fig. 5g, right). To test whether the CDs–OSi composites can be used for LFP identification under higher temperature conditions, the glass plates with the LFPs were placed in a 40 °C oven for 5 days, and then coated with CDs–OSi composites (Fig. S9, ESI†). For observation of the appearance of latent fingerprints, the effect is similar to that at room temperature.
For identity authentication through fingerprints, it is necessary to achieve LFPs with level 2 and 3 characteristics.56–58 The details of LFPs can be successfully detected on glass with the five CDs–OSi composites. We take LFP detection using CDs–OSi composites at an H2O/EtOH volume ratio of 15:3 on glass as an example. As shown in Fig. 6, level 1 characteristics can be clearly identified, including loops, whorls, mixed patterns, and creases. As we all know, each fingerprint has different details, which makes it unique and provides important identification information for identity verification.59 The following featured points can be clearly observed and marked as level 2 characteristics: islands, hooks, bridges, short ridges, bifurcation, crossover, termination and deltas. More interestingly, CDs–OSi composites can even clearly develop level 3 characteristics with sweat holes, ridge edge shape, and scars. Both level 2 and level 3 characteristics can be clearly observed, indicating that LFPs are readily collected and identified by CDs–OSi composites. It is worth mentioning that the adsorption ability between the CDs–OSi composites and the LFP is also very important. Therefore, EtOH in a washing bottle was sprayed on an LFP dusted with CDs–OSi composites. Then the glass plate was dried with a hair dryer to observe the developing effect of the fingerprint. As shown in Fig. S10a (ESI†), CDs–OSi composites can remain present in the LFP (Fig. S10, left, ESI†) and maintain a fluorescence effect (Fig. S10a, right, ESI†). Fig. S10b and S10c (ESI†) show that the level 1, level 2 and level 3 characteristics are still clearly visible, which indicates that there is a strong adsorption ability between CDs–OSi composites and the LFP. These outcomes further extend the reliability and veracity of the new fluorescent powder for discriminating latent fingerprints in forensic analysis.
Fig. 6 The level 1, level 2 and level 3 characteristics developed by CDs–OSi composites at an H2O/EtOH volume ratio of 15:3 on glass using a stereoscopic microscope. |
Aged LFPs are vitally important in criminal investigations.60 Latent fingerprints from the same finger were left on many of the glass plates, and the glass plates were then exposed to room-temperature air for 2 h, 2 d, 5 d and 10 d under ventilation to obtain aged LFPs. Then the five CDs–OSi composites were individually coated on the series of aged LFPs. Finally, the characteristics were observed with a stereoscopic microscope under irradiation by an ultraviolet lamp (Fig. S11, ESI†). By comparing the detailed features of sweat holes, islands, and bifurcations at the same location and the clarity of the main structure, it can be found that the resolution decreased with an increase in preservation time, but the details on 10 days can be still recognized.
As is well known, crime scene environments are often complicated, and LFPs may be left on different surfaces and colors of various substrates.61 The same finger was selected to leave LFPs on the surface of different substrates, such as glass, aluminum foil, soft plastic bags, and hard plastic sheets (Fig. 7). The five kinds of CDs–OSi composites were painted on the different substrates to observe, capture and collect the LFPs by using a mobile phone under irradiation by an ultraviolet lamp (wavelength 365 nm). It can be seen that all five kinds of CDs–OSi composite could successfully obtain fingerprint patterns on different substrates. Importantly, the level 2 (crossover) and level 3 (sweat holes) characteristics also can be clearly observed. In addition, the five CDs–OSi composites show different detection effects on substrates with different roughness, colorfulness, and background fluorescence interference. For example, the fingerprint produced by the CDs–OSi composites using an H2O/EtOH volume ratio of 12:6 shows higher contrast on glass, and the fingerprints produced by CDs–OSi composites using H2O/EtOH volume ratios of 12:6 and 9:9 show higher contrast on aluminum. It can also be observed that the contrast of green fluorescence on plastic products is more pronounced than that of blue. Therefore, the appropriate emission and size of CDs–OSi composites can be selected for developers based on the characteristics of the substrates, which can effectively improve the efficiency of fingerprint detection. Therefore, the CDs–OSi composites prepared here exhibit some advantages compared to other fingerprint identification methods (Table S2, ESI†), like excellent fingerprint detection, simple preparation method, and environmental friendliness, making them an extremely likely substitute for traditional fluorescent powders.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3tc03570k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |