Zhihang
Wang
a,
Beatrice E.
Jones
a,
Larissa G.
Franca
a,
Takashi
Lawson
a,
Martyn
Jevric
b,
Kasper
Moth-Poulsen
*bcde and
Rachel C.
Evans
*a
aDepartment of Materials Science and Metallurgy, University of Cambridge, 27 Charles Babbage Road, Cambridge, CB3 0FS, UK. E-mail: rce26@cam.ac.uk
bDepartment of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Chalmers University of Technology, Kemivagen 4, Gothenburg 412 96, Sweden
cInstitute of Materials Science of Barcelona, ICMAB-CSIC, Bellaterra, Barcelona, 08193, Spain
dCatalan Institution for Research & Advanced Studies, ICREA, Pg. Lluıs Companys 23, Barcelona, Spain
eDepartment of Chemical Engineering, Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya, EEBE, Eduard Maristany 10–14, 08019 Barcelona, Spain. E-mail: kasper.moth-poulsen@upc.edu
First published on 26th November 2024
Photoswitchable materials are of significant interest for diverse applications from energy and data storage to additive manufacturing and soft robotics. However, the absorption profile is often a limiting factor for practical applications. This can be overcome using indirect excitation via complementary photophysical pathways, such as triplet sensitisation or photon upconversion. Here, we demonstrate the use of triplet–triplet annihilation upconversion (TTA-UC) to drive photoswitching of the energy storing photoswitch norbornadiene–quadricyclane (NBD–QC) in the solid-state. A photoswitchable bilayer polymer film, incorporating the TTA-UC sensitiser–emitter pair of platinum octaethylporphyrin (PtOEP) and 9,10-diphenylanthracene (DPA), was used to trigger the photoinduced [2+2] cycloaddition of NBD to form QC using visible instead of UV light. The isolated TTA-UC film showed green-to-blue upconversion, with a competitive upconversion efficiency of (1.9 ± 0.1%) for the solid-state in air. Direct photoswitching of the isolated NBD film was demonstrated with a narrow UV light source (340 nm). However, in the bilayer film, spectral overlap between the upconverted blue emission in the TTA-UC film and the absorbance band of the NBD film resulted in indirect photoswitching using visible green light (532 nm, 1 W cm−2), thus extending the spectral operational window of the photoswitching film. The results demonstrate proof-of-feasibility of TTA-UC-promoted photoswitching in the solid-state, paving the way for potential applications in light-harvesting devices and smart coatings, using a wider selection of irradiation wavelengths.
In recent years, photoswitchable norbornadiene (NBD) chromophores have demonstrated considerable promise for MOST, due to their red-shifted absorption spectrum (NBD onset of absorption up to 529 nm),23 high photoisomerisation quantum yield (up to 97%),24 significant energy storage capacity (up to 559kJ kg−1),25 and mechanical durability (up to 99% reversibility).26 NBDs can be converted to the corresponding quadricyclane (QC) photoisomer via a [2+2π] cycloaddition reaction under UV/blue irradiation. The back-conversion from QC to NBD can be triggered by heat or the use of a catalyst.27,28 Solid-state NBD systems could be used in various temperature regulation applications, including functional windows and thin films.29
While recent advances have shown that NBDs undergo efficient photoswitching upon direct excitation with UV light when incorporated within polymer films, this fails to exploit the visible region of the solar spectrum for energy harvesting and storage.23 One potential solution is to add an adjunct TTA-UC system, which absorbs light at wavelengths where the photoswitch is inactive and converts it to a higher energy where the photoswitch absorbs, thus expanding the useful spectral window.5 For instance, Albinson and coworkers selectively controlled both the ring-opening and ring-closing reactions of diarylethene photoswitches in toluene using a 532 nm laser light-triggered green-to-blue TTA-UC system.30 Börjesson et al. pioneered the use of a TTA-UC pair with a fulvalene diruthenium derivative, also in toluene, creating an artificial solar light-driven TTA-UC process, aiding in the charging of photoswitchable materials for MOST.31 Additionally, Castellano et al. used a Ru(II) chromophore as a sensitiser and anthracene as an emitter to convert UV light into visible light, enabling anthracene to undergo dimerisation.32 However, in these studies, either the TTA-UC system or the photoswitchable molecules were in the solution state. The combination of both solid-state TTA-UC and NBD films could broaden the spectral operational range for photoswitching, thus mitigating challenges with optical penetration depth. To our surprise, such systems have, to the best of our knowledge, not yet been reported. Here, we report the design and performance of a bilayer film architecture that, for the first time, demonstrates TTA-UC promoted photoisomerisation of a photoswitchable molecule in the solid state. The system was designed as a bilayer film architecture for two reasons. Firstly, photoswitchable molecules can act as quenchers, introducing an additional non-radiative decay in the TTA process, which potentially reduces the number of upconverted photons produced.33 Secondly, most available TTA-UC-based films are susceptible to degradation under long-term or intense irradiation, and mixing the systems could introduce recycling challenges for the NBD molecules.34
In our bilayer film architecture, the TTA-UC layer comprises the well-established green-to-blue TTA-UC sensitiser–emitter pair, platinum octaethylporphyrin (PtOEP) and 9,10-diphenylanthracene (DPA), incorporated into a thin poly(vinyl acetate)polymer (PVAc) film (TTA-UC@PVAc film, Fig. 2a, c and Fig. S1, ESI†). PVAc was chosen because it is soluble in common organic solvents and exhibits excellent optical transparency, making it ideal for film manufacture and luminophore compatibility. To effectively use the upconverted emission from the TTA-UC@PVAc film, a NBD molecule whose absorption spectrum fully or partially overlaps with it should be selected for fabrication of the bilayer system. Here, a PVAc film containing a donor–acceptor substituted NBD, 2-cyano-3-((4-(dimethylamino)phenyl)ethynyl)norbornadiene, which exhibits spectral overlap with PtOEP and whose cyclability was previously demonstrated,35,36 was prepared to demonstrate proof-of-concept (NBD@PVAc, Fig. 2b, c and Fig. S2, ESI†). For both the TTA-UC@PVAc and NBD@PVAc films, the upper limit on film thickness is determined by light penetration depth, which will be dependent on the concentrations and molar absorption coefficients of the chromophores at the laser excitation wavelength and the wavelengths of the upconverted DPA emission, respectively. With this in mind, both films were prepared via drop casting, resulting in a net thickness of approximately 0.8 mm (Fig. 2d).
Fig. 3a shows the optical properties of the individual chromophores, photoswitches, and the PVAc host. While the Q-bands of the PtOEP sensitiser absorb in the green region (∼470–560 nm), the fluorescence emission of DPA exhibits spectral overlap with the absorption profile of NBD, suggesting that it should be an effective sensitiser for the photoswitch (spectral overlap: J = 2.3 × 103 M−1cm−1, thus a spectral overlap of 0.1% with NBD in toluene, Section 2, ESI†).35,37 Importantly, the PVAc host also provides minimal contribution to the overall absorption, as supported by the transmittance spectrum, which is >95% across the spectral region of interest.
The performance of the TTA-UC film was first investigated in isolation. The DPA:PtOEP ratio was tailored to determine the optimum concentration that maximised the TTA-UC efficiency while limiting aggregation in the PVAc host (Fig. S4, ESI†). An emitter:sensitiser ratio of 180:1 (27 mM to 0.15 mM, respectively) was shown to deliver the best performance and was used for all further studies. Fig. 3b presents the corresponding absorption spectra for the optimised TTA-UC@PVAc film and its upconversion emission spectrum. The absorbance clearly shows the distinct bands originating from the DPA (around 350–380 nm) and PtOEP (around 483 to 545 nm) ground-state (S0 → S1) transitions. Laser excitation at 532 nm selectively excites the PtOEP sensitiser, resulting in UC emission around 440 nm, which is characteristic of DPA.38,39 The threshold intensity, Ith, for observing UC emission in the TTA-UC films was established to be 2 W cm−2 (Fig. S5, ESI†), much higher than other solid-state hosts (e.g. organic–inorganic hybrid ureasils40 – 27 mW cm−2), with a UC quantum yield of 1.9% ± 0.1% under ambient conditions (i.e. no oxygen removed).
The UC and phosphorescence decay curves (in air) are both best described by a biexponential decay function (see Sections 5 and 6, ESI†), with average lifetimes 〈τUC〉 = 8.5 ms (at 440 nm, Fig. S6 and Table S1, ESI†) and 〈τphos〉 = 89.8 μs (at 665 nm, Fig. S7 and Table S2, ESI†), respectively. Attribution of physical meaning to specific lifetime components is challenging, as several factors may contribute including oxygen quenching and a distribution of chromophore sites within the host. The phosphorescence of a control film in air, containing PtOEP only, also decayed biexponentially, with a short-lived lifetime, τ1 ∼23 μs, assigned to O2-quenched sites and a longer lifetime component, τ2 ∼ 61 μs, assigned to the natural phosphorescence lifetime (Fig. S7 and Table S2, ESI†), which is consistent with literature reports for PtOEP in polymer films in air.41 Interestingly, the corresponding lifetimes for the TTA-UC@PVAc film in air are longer lived (τ1 ∼ 37.7 μs, τ2 ∼ 100 μs) and do not exhibit monoexponential decay even in an N2 atmosphere (τ1 ∼ 60.5 μs, τ2 ∼ 110 μs), see Table S2 (ESI†), indicating that the biexponential behaviour is primarily a function of the film environment (e.g. availability of different chromophore sites), rather than O2 quenching. Moreover, the longer 〈τphos〉 for the TTA-UC@PVAc film reveals that the addition of DPA reduces the contribution of the quenched species (A1 ∼ 34.3%), which now compete for interaction with the emitter molecules. This results in a higher contribution of τ2, assigned to PtOEP triplet states in sites without accessible DPA neighbours, leading to the increased 〈τphos〉 in the TTA-UC@PVAc film.
The optical and kinetic properties of the NBD@PVAc photoswitchable film were examined next. In toluene solution, the absorption onset was at 456 nm, with a peak maximum at 398 nm (Fig. 3a). Upon integration into the PVAc film, the peak absorption of NBD remained essentially unchanged (λmax = 397 nm, Fig. 3c). The back-conversion kinetics for QC to NBD in the PVAc matrix were shown to have a half-life, t1/2 of 3.8 hours (226 minutes) at 25 °C, following the Eyring plot (Fig. S8, ESI†). This result is slightly shorter than the reported half-life for this photoswitch in toluene of 5.05 hours at room temperature.35 We note that the photoisomerisation quantum yield for NBD to QC in the film may be slightly lower than in solution, since NBD molecules tend to photoisomerise more readily when irradiated in solution compared to the solid state. However, such deviations are challenging to quantify accurately, as standard chemical actinometry methods used to measure the photoisomerisation quantum yield can lead to significant errors, particularly for films of such small size.24
Lastly, the photoswitchable and TTA-UC films were investigated in a bilayer architecture, with the two films physically attached to each other (Fig. S4, ESI†), to evaluate the potential for sensitisation of the NBD to QC photoconversion using the TTA-UC@PVAc film. Since the absorbance spectrum of the NBD absorption overlaps well with the UC emission spectrum of the TTA-UC system, wavelengths between 400 nm and 450 nm emitted by the DPA emitter should induce efficient NBD conversion in the photoswitchable film to the QC state following the sensitisation mechanism proposed for solution-state analogues (Section 8, ESI†).31 To illustrate the TTA-UC-assisted conversion in the photoswitchable film, a 532 nm laser at 1 W cm−2 was used to excite the sensitisers within the TTA-UC film (Fig. 4a). A control experiment was conducted to demonstrate that the laser alone would not trigger the photoconversion of NBD by replacing the slide with the TTA-UC film with an empty glass substrate. By tracking the absorbance at 397 nm, no significant change in the absorption was observed for the sample without the TTA-UC film (1 W cm−2 of a 532 nm laser, Fig. 4b). However, the presence of the TTA-UC film led to a significant increase in conversion rate upon irradiation (nearly 100% conversion after irradiating for 2 min). Although the emission signal of the TTA-UC@PVAc film was observed to decrease over time (Section 9, ESI†), a common issue associated with the photobleaching of organic dyes under prolonged light exposure, this clearly demonstrates that the TTA-UC film is able to drive the photoisomerisation of NBD, thus expanding the spectral operation window.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Materials and methods; optimisation of the sensitiser:emitter ratio in TTA-UC@PVAc films; threshold intensity study of the TTA-UC@PVAc film; UC and PtOEP phosphorescence lifetime studies; kinetic studies on the converted NBD@PVAc film, spectral overlap integral calculation and sensitization mechanism, and TTA-UC-assisted photoswitching mechanism. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4tc03513e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |