Wenyan Dua,
Qi Huangb,
Xunwen Zhenga,
Yaokang Lvd,
Ling Miaoa,
Ziyang Songa,
Lihua Gan
ac and
Mingxian Liu
*ac
aShanghai Key Lab of Chemical Assessment and Sustainability, School of Chemical Science and Engineering, Tongji University, Shanghai, 1239 Siping Rd., 200092, P. R. China. E-mail: liumx@tongji.edu.cn
bInstitute for Electric Light Sources, School of Information Science and Technology, Fudan University, 2005 Songhu Rd., Shanghai 200438, P. R. China
cState Key Laboratory of Cardiovascular Diseases and Medical Innovation Center, Shanghai East Hospital, School of Medicine, Tongji University, 150 Jimo Rd., Shanghai 200120, P. R. China
dCollege of Chemical Engineering, Zhejiang University of Technology, 18 Chaowang Rd, Hangzhou 310014, P. R. China
First published on 9th April 2025
Six-electron I−/I5+ redox chemistry gives a promising platform to achieve high-capacity Zn–I2 batteries, but faces limited conversion efficiency and instability of IO3− species. Here, we design a thiazole-linked covalent organic framework (TZ-COF) hosted organic trimethylsulfonium iodide (C3H9IS/TZ-COFs) electrode in a 1-methyl-3-propylimidazolium bromide (MPIBr)-containing electrolyte to stimulate I−/I0/I+/I5+ iodine conversion chemistry with better electrochemical efficiency and stability. Compared with inorganic symmetric I2 molecules, the more easily exposed I− center of polar C3H9IS combines with the oxygen in H2O to form HIO3, which initiates 6e− I−/IO3− conversion through I+ activation of MPIBr, thus reducing the oxidation/reduction potential gap to achieve 97% iodine conversion efficiency. Meanwhile, thiazole units of TZ-COFs enable strong chemical adsorption with IO3− species to improve redox stability with high reversibility due to reduced energy barriers (−5.1 vs. −3.5 eV in activated carbon (AC) host) and upgraded conversion kinetics (activation energy: 0.21 vs. 0.38 eV in AC). Such a stable and high-efficiency 6e− iodine conversion gives C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrodes record high capacity (1296 mA h g−1) and energy density (1464 W h kg−1), and superior cycling stability (1200 cycles). These findings constitute a major advance in the design of iodine redox chemistry towards state-of-the-art Zn–I2 batteries.
Broader contextRecently, 6e− iodine conversion (I−/IO3−) chemistry has been achieved via hetero-halogen chemistry activation, which boosts iodine conversion kinetics and reversibility to achieve Zn–I2 batteries with high capacity and energy density. Nevertheless, the electrochemical formation of hypervalent iodine (I5+) is impeded by low conversion efficiency and unstable intermediates, limiting further exploration of multi-electron iodine electrochemistry in the realm of energy storage. In this work, we design a thiazole-linked covalent organic framework (TZ-COF) hosted organic trimethylsulfonium iodide (C3H9IS/TZ-COFs) electrode in a 1-methyl-3-propylimidazolium bromide (MPIBr)-containing electrolyte to stimulate I−/I0/I+/I5+ iodine conversion chemistry with better electrochemical efficiency and stability. The high iodine conversion efficiency (97%) and stable 6e− iodine conversion bring the capacity and energy density of Zn–I2 batteries to a new level. This work broadens the horizons of multielectron redox chemistry for building advanced Zn–I2 batteries. |
In this work, we report high-conversion-efficiency and stable 6e− Zn–I2 batteries enabled by organic iodide/thiazole-linked covalent organic frameworks (C3H9IS/TZ-COFs). The C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode in a 1-methyl-3-propylimidazolium bromide (MPIBr)-containing electrolyte stimulates I−/I0/I+/I5+ iodine conversion with superior electrochemical efficiency and stability. Compared with conventional I2, C3H9IS with a polar iodide center is more likely to combine with the oxygen in H2O to form IO3− species, initiating 6e− I−/I0/I+/I5+ iodine conversion chemistry through I+ activation of MPIBr, thereby reducing the potential gap between oxidation and reduction and improving the electrochemical efficiency. Moreover, CN/C–S motifs of thiazole units in TZ-COFs coordinate with IO3− solving the solubility and stability issues, and simultaneously catalyze reversible iodine conversion from I− to IO3− due to the reduced energy barriers and the boosted redox reaction kinetics. The high iodine conversion efficiency (97%) and stable 6e− iodine conversion bring the capacity and energy density of C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrodes to a new level. This work broadens the horizons of multielectron redox chemistry for building advanced Zn–I2 batteries.
Due to the exposed polar iodide center and high stability, C3H9IS is elaborately selected as the iodine source, which includes the C3H9S+ chain and the I− anion connected by a weak ionic bond (Fig. S3, ESI†). To solve the problems of inevitable dissolution in aqueous electrolytes and low conductivity, C3H9IS was encapsulated in porous TZ-COFs (Fig. S4, ESI†) via the fusion-diffusion method to obtain the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode. The electrochemical performances of the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode were studied using a three-electrode Swagelok cell with a Ti mesh as the counter electrode and Hg/HgCl2 as the reference electrode in an aqueous Zn(OTF)2-MPIBr electrolyte (Fig. S5, ESI†).
Galvanostatic charge–discharge (GCD) curves of the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode show an ultrahigh capacity of 1296 mA h g−1 (Fig. 2a), which exceeds those of C3H9IS/N-COFs (1202 mA h g−1), C3H9IS/activated carbon (AC) (1023 mA h g−1), and TZ-COFs (34 mA h g−1) electrodes (Fig. 2b and Fig. S6, S7, ESI†). A small voltage polarization of 0.28 V enabling 97% iodine conversion efficiency can be observed in the GCD curves of the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode, indicating a fast reduction/oxidation kinetics process. With the increase of current density from 1 to 5 A g−1, the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode still holds a high capacity of 762 mA h g−1, suggesting the inhibition of the iodine species shuttle and improved conversion kinetics during (dis)charging. The high capacity and average discharge voltage endow the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode with a record high energy density of 1464 W h kg−1 (based on the mass loading of C3H9IS in the electrode, Fig. 2c),7,8,14,15,17,18,26,42–48 rendering it the state-of-the-art Zn–I2 battery electrode (Table S1, ESI†). Significantly, the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode delivers a high-capacity retention of 83.6% over 1200 cycles (Fig. 2d), outperforming C3H9IS/N-COFs (30% over 540 cycles) and C3H9IS/AC electrodes (10% over 420 cycles). Compared with soluble C3H9IS/N-COFs and C3H9IS/AC electrodes, the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode prevents the iodine shuttle and thus promotes iodine conversion for activating better capacity storage. Furthermore, the electrochemical impedance spectra after cycling also display a small diffusion resistance (Rct) for the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode (Fig. S8, ESI†), implying rapid redox kinetics of iodine species in TZ-COFs.
The charge storage kinetics of the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode was further studied by Dunn's method.49–53 Cyclic voltammetry (CV) profiles distinctly exhibit three pairs of redox signals (denoted as PR1, PR2, PR3, PO1, PO2 and PO3, Fig. 2e), indicative of a multi-step electrochemistry. The peak shape is almost the same with the increase of the scan rate from 0.1 to 0.5 mV s−1, substantiating the superb electrochemical reversibility and ion diffusion kinetics. The relationship between current (i) and scan rate (v) can be expressed as i = kvb, where k is constant.54–56 Plotting log(i) against log
(v) yields high power-exponent b values of 0.92–0.84 for the eight redox peaks (Fig. S10, ESI†), signifying the fast surface-controlled charge-storage kinetics. Almost 95% of the total stored charge is contributed by the surface redox reaction at 0.5 mV s−1 (Fig. S11, ESI†), along with the slight diffusion-limited process (5%). With incremental scan rate, the capacitive contribution dominates the diffusion-limited contribution, and gradually increases from 83 to 95% (Fig. 2f). This contributes to the surface-dominated capacitive charge storage for fast charge carrier transport in the TZ-COFs/C3H9IS electrode, which well explains its superior high-rate capability as reflected in the GCD curves (Fig. 2a).
To verify the redox mechanism of the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode in the Zn(OTF)2-MPIBr electrolyte, ex situ Raman spectra were performed to reveal its structural evolution at different voltage states (Fig. 3a and b).18,57,58 At the initial state, a signal at 110 cm−1, the vibrational peak of C3H9S−I, corresponds to I−, which confirms the presence of C3H9IS in TZ-COFs. Upon increasing the voltage to 0.54 V, a new peak is identified at 182 cm−1 ascribed to I2,1,18,46 indicating the progress of the first redox stage for I−/I2 (corresponding to 0.54/0.41 V in CV profiles). When I− ions are oxidized into iodine at the electrode, it spontaneously reacts with I− forming I3− species (2I− − 2e− → I2, I2 + I− → I3−). Given the fact that I3− cannot be effectively distinguished by the Raman spectrum because it is roughly at the same position as the I− peak, we further confirm the generated I− through the UV-vis spectra (325 nm for I3−, Fig. 3c). As the voltage increases to 0.93 V, a distinctive peak appears at 214 cm−1, which is associated with the formation of IBr species, suggesting the I2/IBr redox reaction.17 During charging to 1.20 V, two new signals emerge at 310/320 cm−1 and 780 cm−1 ascribed to IO3− species, confirming the I+ to IO3− conversion.18,59,60 Overall, a multi-step multielectron redox reaction can be clarified for the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode, involving I−/I2 (0.54/0.41V), I2/I+ (0.93/0.80V) and I+/IO3− (1.20/1.03 V) conversions. During subsequent discharging, all peaks return to their initial levels, suggesting the highly reversible I−/I0/I+/I5+ conversion redox chemistry. In the ex situ UV-vis spectra of the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode at different states (Fig. 3c), a prominent peak at 225 nm at the initial state is observed, which corresponds to I− from C3H9IS. As the voltage increases to 0.54 V, new peaks at 287/445 nm appear, indicating the presence of I2 species.1 As the voltage increases to 0.93 V, new peaks at 254 and 205 nm appear, indicating the presence of IBr species and the formation of IO3− species, respectively.17,18 Furthermore, the charging of the cell gives rise to the formation of Br2 which is ascribed to the oxidation of IBr interhalogen. Upon charging to 1.20 V, the signal peak of IO3− at 205 nm becomes stronger, while the characteristic peak of I+ disappears, indicating I+ to IO3− conversion.
The valence states of iodine species in the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode were further evidenced by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) at different voltages (Fig. 3d). Two signals appearing at high binding energies of 628.4/619.6 eV at 0.54 V correspond to I2 species. With the deepening of the charging to 0.93 V, higher binding energy peaks at 630.1/622.4 eV can be observed, which originate from the I+ ion. Upon further charging to 1.20 V, the binding energy peaks of iodine species continuously shift, accompanied by suggesting the formation of I5+ ions. These results indicate a highly reversible I−/I2/I+/I5+ redox reaction, and are consistent with Raman spectral results. The changes on the surface of the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode during charging–discharging process were also inspected using ex situ SEM images (Fig. S12, ESI†). During initial charging to 0.54 V, bulk I2 particles can be observed on the electrode. Formed oil droplets upon further charging indicate the presence of IO3−. Upon further charging to 1.20 V, most IO3− droplets are converted into mist matter that covers the electrode surface. Upon discharge, the misty matter gradually disappears, and the bulk I2 species are regenerated. Ex situ Raman spectra (Fig. 3a) and XPS spectra (Fig. 3d) confirm the generation of I+ species, implying the formation of IBr intermediates (I− + Br− → I+Br− + 2e−) during multielectron I−/IO3− iodine conversion.
The CV curve of the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode based on the Zn(OTF)2-MPIBr electrolyte exhibits three pairs of redox peaks at 0.54/0.41, 0.93/0.80, and 1.20/1.03 V corresponding to the I−/I2, I2/I+, and I+/IO3− couples (Fig. 3e and Fig. S13, ESI†), respectively. Specifically, the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode initiates 2 e− conversion from I+ to I− to deliver a capacity of 330 mA h g−1 and 4 e− IO3−/I+ conversion to deliver an ultrahigh capacity of 966 mA h g−1 (Fig. 3f) with a discharge potential of 1.13 V of the Zn–I2 system, exhibiting 97% iodine conversion efficiency. The self-discharge behavior of the Zn–I2 battery is observed under the fully charged condition of 1.3 V, which shows a high-capacity retention of 93% after a rest step of 3 days, indicating good anti-dissolution and slight shuttle behavior (Fig. S14, ESI†). By contrast, three redox signals for I− to IO3−conversion in the C3H9IS/AC electrode were observed in the first curve, but this conversion is irreversible in the second cycle, highlighting the key role of TZ-COFs in catalyzing reversible 6e− conversion from I− to IO3− (Fig. S15–S17, ESI†). The CV curve of the Zn‖I2/TZ-COFs battery shows only a pair of redox peaks at 0.54/0.42 V (Fig. S18, ESI†), corresponding to a typical I−/I2 conversion reaction, which contributes a capacity of 154 mA h g−1 at 1 A g−1.[1e, 2c, 7a] The excellent performance of the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode highlights the key role of the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode in the MPIBr-containing electrolyte to stimulate I−/I0/I+/I5+ iodine conversion chemistry with high electrochemical efficiency and stability (Fig. 3g and Fig. S19–S21, ESI†).
The binding energies of I2 and C3H9IS with H2O were calculated (Fig. S22, ESI†). C3H9IS/H2O interaction (−0.81 eV) is stronger than that of I2/H2O (−0.42 eV). Compared with I2, C3H9IS in TZ-COFs can start multielectron iodine conversion with much lower binding energy due to the more easily exposed I− center to combine with the oxygen in H2O to form HIO3.61,62 Therefore, the difference in reaction energy barriers between I2 and C3H9IS is partly responsible for different redox voltages of the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode. However, the reasons for this large difference in iodine conversion voltages are complicated and still need a further extensive and in-depth study. Overall, a highly reversible I−/I2/I+/I5+ redox reaction is triggered in the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode (Fig. 3g), contributing to record high capacity and energy density. The whole conversion of iodine species can be expressed as follows:
I− − e− ↔ I0 0.54 V | (step 1) |
I0 + Br− − e− ↔ I+Br− 0.93 V | (step 2) |
I+ + 3H2O − 4 e− ↔ IO3− + 6H+ 1.20 V | (step 3) |
Generally, the dissolution and shuttling issues of soluble IO3− species from electrodes hinder the cycling durability of Zn–I2 batteries.63 In this regard, CN/C−S motifs of thiazole units in TZ-COFs are favorable for binding iodine species to relieve their loss during battery operation (Fig. S23, ESI†). TZ-COFs coordinate with IO3− through C
N/C−S motifs of thiazole units to ensure the redox reversibility, and catalyze a new reversible 6e− conversion of I− to IO3− to further boost capacity (Fig. S24 and S25, ESI†). Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed to understand in-depth the binding affinity between TZ-COFs and iodine species (Fig. 4a and b). The adsorption energies of TZ-COFs with I−, I2, I3−, I+ and IO3− (from −5.59 to −0.012 eV) are lower than those of N-COFs (from −5.22 to −0.011 eV), suggesting the strong interaction between TZ-COFs and iodine species. Of note, TZ-COFs show a more negative adsorption energy with IO3− than N-COFs, highlighting the significant effect of thiazole units of TZ-COFs in catalyzing reversible I−/IO3− conversion.
Fig. 4c shows the energy levels of the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) and the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) for TZ-COFs and N-COFs.40,64–66 N-COFs (only containing CN groups) with structures similar to TZ-COFs involving C
N/C−S groups were designed as an example for comparison to study the role of catalytic sites. The energy gap (ΔE) of TZ-COFs is calculated to be 3.14 eV (Fig. 4c), which is lower than that of N-COFs (3.31 eV). It indicates that synergistic C
N/C−S sites are more favorable for boosting iodine conversion with low energy barriers. Consequently, the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode delivers higher conversion efficiency/cycling stability (97%/1200 cycles, Fig. 2d) than C3H9IS/N-COFs (94%/540 cycles). Furthermore, MEP simulation and charge density difference isosurfaces suggest a strong chemical interaction between TZ-COF and IO3− (Fig. 4d and e), accompanied by electron accumulation (green area) and depletion (yellow area) to form a stable configuration for triggering improved electrochemical activity and durability.
The role of TZ-COFs in activating and stabilizing the 6e− transfer redox reaction from I− to IO3− can be further understood from DFT calculations.67,68 The Gibbs free energy (ΔG) values of iodine species in TZ-COFs at various electrochemical states are negative than that of AC (Fig. 4f), suggesting an energy-favorable 6e− I−/I2/I+/IO3− redox conversion with low energy barriers. Of note, TZ-COFs catalyze a reversible 6e− conversion from I− to IO3− due to reduced energy barriers (−5.1 vs. −3.5 eV in the AC host). Besides, the activation energy (Ea) is 0.21 eV for the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode (Fig. 4g and Fig. S26, S27, ESI†) based on the Arrhenius equation, which is much lower than that of the C3H9IS/AC electrode (0.38 eV). TZ-COFs activate high-kinetics interfacial charge mobility and redox reactions to catalyze a highly reversible I−/I2/I+/IO3− conversion reaction.
Overall, the C3H9IS/TZ-COFs electrode in the Zn(OTF)2-MPIBr electrolyte exhibits high-efficiency and stable 6e− iodine conversion chemistry. Compared with inorganic symmetric I2 molecules, the more easily exposed I− center of polar C3H9IS combines with the oxygen in H2O to form HIO3, due to the lower binding energy of C3H9IS/H2O (−0.81 vs. −0.42 eV for I2/H2O), which initiates I−/IO3− conversion. Meanwhile, thiazole units of TZ-COFs enable strong chemical adsorption with IO3− species to improve redox stability with high reversibility due to reduced energy barriers (−5.1 vs. −3.5 eV in the AC host) and upgraded conversion kinetics (activation energy: 0.21 vs. 0.38 eV in AC). Owing to the halogen reaction between I− species and Br− halides, MPIBr can effectively activate I+ to reduce the oxidation/reduction potential gap (0.39 V), which constitutes an important step to propel I−/I0/I+/I5+ conversion with a lower energy barrier (0.21 eV). The synergy of C3H9IS, TZ-COFs and MPIBr endows the Zn–I2 batteries with ultrahigh capacity and energy density, and superior cycling stability, constituting a major advance in the design of better Zn–I2 batteries.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5ee00365b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |