Pingxuan
Liu
a,
Ziyang
Song
*a,
Qi
Huang
c,
Ling
Miao
a,
Yaokang
Lv
d,
Lihua
Gan
*ab and
Mingxian
Liu
*ab
aShanghai Key Lab of Chemical Assessment and Sustainability, School of Chemical Science and Engineering, Tongji University, 1239 Siping Rd., Shanghai, 200092, P. R. China. E-mail: 21310240@tongji.edu.cn; ganlh@tongji.edu.cn; liumx@tongji.edu.cn
bState Key Laboratory of Cardiovascular Diseases and Medical Innovation Center, Shanghai East Hospital, School of Medicine, Tongji University, 150 Jimo Rd., Shanghai 200120, P. R. China
cInstitute for Electric Light Sources, School of Information Science and Technology, Fudan University, 2005 Songhu Rd., Shanghai 200438, P. R. China
dCollege of Chemical Engineering, Zhejiang University of Technology, 18 Chaowang Rd., Hangzhou 310014, P. R. China
First published on 23rd April 2025
All-organic ammonium-ion batteries (AOBs), utilizing lightweight organic electrodes and small, hydrated NH4+ charge carriers, are promising candidates for next-generation energy storage. However, the limited NH4+-accessible redox-active motifs in organics with high coordination barriers present significant challenges to the advancement of AOBs. Here, we designed multi-H-bonded donor–acceptor self-assembled ultralow-coordination-barrier organic superstructures (OSs) by integrating six-electron melem modules (H-bond donors) and three-electron cyanuric acid units (H-bond acceptors) via in-plane hydrogen bonding and out-of-plane π–π stacking. These OSs, featuring a low-energy-bandgap conjugated planar configuration and long-range π-electron delocalization pathways, enabled nearly complete utilization (99.3%) of intrinsic redox-active carbonyl/imine motifs with an ultralow activation energy (0.16 eV). Consequently, a high-kinetics and ultrastable 15-e− NH4+ coordination mechanism was activated within the OSs cathode, delivering an ultrahigh capacity (393 mA h g−1cathode) and exceptional cycling stability (60000 cycles). Notably, the superior performance metrics of the OSs electrode enabled state-of-the-art AOBs with a record capacity (213 mA h g−1) and an unprecedented lifespan (100
000 cycles). This work provides new insights into the structural engineering of multi-active, low-coordination-barrier OSs for advanced aqueous batteries.
Broader contextAqueous ammonium-ion batteries offer a highly safe, cost-effective, and environmentally friendly solution for next-generation energy storage. Non-metallic NH4+ charge carriers, with their small tetrahedral structures and light weights, demonstrate resource abundance, high migration rates, and strong H-bonding orientation, making them an ideal choice for overcoming the slow interfacial reactions of metal ions. A crucial task for NH4+ storage is the design of compatible electrode materials to fully unlock its potential. Electroactive organic materials stand out due to their molecular-level structural tunability and fast surface redox behavior, providing promising avenues for the development of all-organic ammonium-ion batteries (AOBs). However, the limited accessibility of NH4+ to redox-active motifs and the high coordination barriers in organic materials present significant challenges for advancing AOBs. Herein, we designed multi-H-bonded donor–acceptor self-assembled ultralow-coordination-barrier organic superstructures (OSs) by integrating melem modules (H-bond donors) and cyanuric acid units (H-bond acceptors) via hydrogen bonding and π–π interactions. The low-energy-bandgap conjugated plane and long-range π-electron delocalization of OSs electrode ensured full utilization of carbonyl/imine motifs via a high-kinetics and ultrastable two-step, 15 e−-NH4+ storage mechanism, enabling state-of-the-art symmetric AOBs with ultrahigh capacity and ultralong stability. Our work presents a promising approach for advancing the domain of multi-redox, low-energy-barrier superstructural organics for advanced energy storage. |
A crucial task for NH4+ storage is the design of compatible electrode materials to fully unlock its potential.11 To date, several inorganic materials, such as Prussian blue and Mn/V/Mo-based metal oxides, have been proposed for NH4+ storage, but they generally suffer from sluggish kinetics and poor cycling stability.12–15 An alternative approach has recently focused on π-conjugated organic materials due to their molecular-level structural tunability and rapid surface redox behavior, which enable high electrochemical activity and improved reaction kinetics for NH4+ storage.16 To date, various organic compounds, such as quinones,17 imines,18 azines,19 nitriles,20 and nitroaromatics,21 have been reported for fast NH4+ storage. However, they typically exhibit unsatisfactory capacities (<350 mA h g−1) due to a high proportion of redox-inactive motifs and substantial energy barriers for NH4+ diffusion within the active frameworks.22
Energy storage in organic electrode materials typically relies on coordination reactions between their redox-active groups and charge carriers.23 The lower the coordination barrier that redox-active groups must overcome to coordinate with NH4+ charge carriers, the more readily the coordination reaction can proceed, ultimately enhancing reaction kinetics and overall battery performance.24 Organic superstructures (OSs), derived from the epitaxial growth or self-assembly of low-dimensional building units via H-bonding interactions, exhibit ingenious hierarchical architectures and desirable functional properties.25 Generally, OSs can maximize the exposure of high-density redox-active sites inherited from their basic building units, and attain well-arranged consecutive geometries to afford fast NH4+-transfer paths, positioning them as promising candidates for large-scale energy systems.26 The structural and functional originality of OSs inspired us to consider whether multi-site-active H-bonding organic acceptors and donators as repeating units could be integrated to construct donator–acceptor-interlocking OSs with ultralow coordination barriers, thereby allowing for multielectron-redox NH4+ storage for revolutionizing battery metrics.27
Herein, we report multi-H-bonded donor–acceptor self-assembled OSs as highly redox-active, low-redox-barrier, and ultrastable electrode materials for activating superior NH4+ storage. Three-electron cyanuric acid (CA, H-bond acceptor) and six-electron 1,3,4,6,7,9,9b-heptaazaphenalen-2,5,8-triamine (HT, H-bond donor) were coupled to form an insoluble supramolecular organic superstructure through multiple H-bonds and π–π interactions. Featuring a low-energy-bandgap conjugated planar H-bonding configuration and long-range π-electron localization paths, the OSs achieved complete utilization of the built-in redox-active carbonyl/imine motifs with low-redox-energy barriers. Systematic studies revealed the reversible two-step 15 e− NH4+ coordination with carbonyl/imine sites of the OSs, which could facilitate achieving an ultrahigh capacity, rate performance, and long-term life for the constructed Zn||OSs battery. Besides, OS electrodes could be further extended to design superior symmetrical all-organic ammonium-ion batteries (AOBs), making such materials a competitive candidate for propelling advanced ammonium-ion batteries.
The supramolecular self-assembly process took 60 min to get stable well-defined organic superstructures with multi-layered geometries (Fig. 1d), rich pore channels (Fig. S4, ESI†), high thermal stability (Fig. S5, ESI†) and a uniform C/N/O element distribution (Fig. 1e). In contrast with irregular CA and HT (Fig. S6, ESI†), the scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images revealed the OSs comprised fibre-shaped superstructures built from sheet modules (Fig. S7, ESI†). The electronic conductivity of the OS cathode (obtained by mixing 60 wt% OSs, 30 wt% graphite and 10 wt% polytetrafluoroethylene) was determined as 50.46 S cm−1 using a four-probe method compared, which was higher than for the CA/HT cathodes (12.44/15.39 S cm−1), and which is favorable for highly efficient electron transfer for propelling the redox reactions (Fig. 1f). As is well-established, the optical energy gap (Eg) reflects the electron injection and conduction capabilities of organic materials, whereby a lower Eg helps to improve the electron-transfer efficiency to achieve fast charge-storage kinetics with low energy barriers.2,19 Thanks to their favourable multi-H-bonded donor–acceptor long-range superstructures, the OSs achieved a very low optical energy gap (Eg) of 2.16 eV, which was superior to that of CA (2.99 eV) and HT (2.65 eV), ensuring low-energy-barrier charge-storage kinetics (Fig. 1g). Owing to the longitudinal self-assembly of the π-conjugated aromatic planar sheets via rich H-bonds and π–π interactions (Fig. 1a–c and Fig. S2, S3, ESI†), the OSs possessed well-arranged fibre-shaped superstructure geometries (Fig. 1d and e), which provide long-range continuous charge migration paths with high conductivity (Fig. 1f) and a low energy gap (Fig. 1g), thereby contributing to efficient π-electron delocalization with low energy barriers. Overall, the OSs fused high-density redox-active sites, long-range low-barrier π-electron localization paths, and ultrastable superstructure skeletons, which could be expected to be highly competitive features for superior charge-storage metrics.
The electrochemical performances of the OSs as cathodes were studied in a Zn||OSs battery using Zn metal foil as the anode and 3 M NH4OTF/H2O solution as the electrolyte (OTF− = CF3SO3−, Fig. S8, ESI†). As depicted by the galvanostatic discharge/charge (GCD) curves (Fig. 2a), the OS cathode (derived from the reaction time of 60 min) delivered an ultrahigh capacity of 393 mA h g−1 at 0.2 A g−1, exceeding the performances of both Zn||CA (112 mA h g−1) and Zn||HT (165 mA h g−1) batteries (Fig. S9, ESI†). Upon increasing the current density to 50 A g−1 (i.e. 250-fold), the OSs still maintained a capacity of 157 mA h g−1 (Fig. 2b), highlighting their superior high-rate performance. Benefiting from their remarkable capacity together with an average discharge voltage of 0.8 V, the as-assembled battery was able to obtain a high energy output of 313 W h kg−1 at 170 W kg−1 (according to the mass loading of OSs in the cathode, i.e. ∼3 mg cm−2, Fig. S10 and Table S1, ESI†), which was higher than that with the 3 M Zn(OTF)2/H2O electrolyte (Fig. S11, ESI†), making it a strong contender compared to other recently reported organic cathode materials (Fig. 2c).30–44 Besides, the energy density of the Zn||OSs battery was calculated to be 271 W h kg−1 considering the mass loading of the OS cathode and the consumed NH4+ electrolyte.
Impressively, the Zn||OSs battery in 3 M NH4OTF/H2O electrolyte demonstrated a capacity retention of 85.8% and a Coulombic efficiency of 100% when the serve term was extended to 60000 cycles at 10 A g−1 (Fig. 2d and Table S1, ESI†), exceeding most other reported organic materials (Fig. 2e).30–33,38,39,41,43–49 Characterization of the OS cathode after prolonged cycling, including via SEM, and FT-IR and ultraviolet-visible (UV/vis) spectroscopies, indicated the outstanding stability of its structure, and regular functions, alongside its strong anti-dissolution ability (see the inset of Fig. 2d and Fig. S12, ESI†). Furthermore, the evolution of the Zn anodes through long-term cycling was examined by SEM images and XRD patterns. These revealed that during repeated Zn-plating/stripping processes, the pristine smooth Zn anode transformed into a rough and disordered surface structure without obvious dendrite formation (Fig. S13a–c, ESI†) or electrolyte penetration corrosion (Fig. S13d, ESI†). Considering the superior structural robustness of the OSs, the performance decline of the Zn||OSs cell could be attributed to structural degradation of the Zn electrode during the persistent operation (Fig. S14, ESI†).
The reaction kinetics of the Zn||OSs battery was evaluated using cyclic voltammetry (CV) measurements. The CV profiles of the OSs at different sweep rates displayed two pairs of stable redox signals (denoted as PR1, PR2, PO1, and PO2, Fig. 2f), indicating a two-step redox reaction. As the scan rate gradually increased, the peak shapes became almost the same, suggesting a high reversibility and low-ion-diffusion obstacles. Using the equation i = kvb (where i represents the current density, v is the scan rate, and k and b are constants), the b values calculated for four peaks (0.94–0.98) were found to approach to 1, revealing the rapid surface-controlled redox kinetics (Fig. 2g). In brief, the ultrafast and robust charge storage could be ascribed to the low-energy-bandgap sophisticated superstructures built with a conjugated planar configuration and long-range π-electron localization paths, which fully exposed the redox-active sites and maximized ion accessibility with ultralow coordination barriers, thereby promoting excellent electrochemical activity and durability.
To uncover the energy-storage mechanism of the OS cathode, various characterizations were employed to track its structural variation during charging/discharging. Two pairs of obvious platforms could be observed in the GCD curve (Fig. 3a), indicative of the two-step redox electrochemistry. The FT-IR spectra (Fig. 3b) displayed vibration signals belonging to CO (1697/1778 cm−1) that sharply decreased to eventually disappear during discharging (state A → B), but were almost unchanged after further discharging (state B → C), alongside the appearance of C–O species (1163 cm−1). This result indicated the highly redox-active characteristics of the C
O motifs in the OSs. Meanwhile, the generated peak at 2854 cm−1, belonging to the H-bond stretching mode (N–H⋯O),10 showed a strong uptrend during discharging and gradually lessened during charging, validating the H-bond generation/disappearance of the NH4+-coordinated carbonyl species. Moreover, a new signal (2923 cm−1) appeared that was assigned to N–H species of the NH4+ ions during discharging, proving NH4+ uptake. These results confirmed the coordination between the carbonyl motifs of the OS cathode and the NH4+ ions. Besides, the vibration intensity of C
N at 1608 cm−1 showed a reversible weakening/strengthening trend (state B → C; state C → D) during discharging/charging, while the opposite variation was observed for the C–N bands at 1097 cm−1. Significantly, a new signal at 2956 cm−1 appeared upon discharging, confirming the redox coordination between the C
N sites and NH4+ ions. Overall, the C
O and C
N motifs of the OS cathode initiated reversible electrochemical redox reactions with the NH4+ charge carriers.
Next, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) was performed to explore the H-bonding reaction mechanism between the NH4+ ions and CO/C
N groups. In ex situ high-resolution O 1s XPS spectra of the OSs cathode (Fig. 3c), C
O groups at 531.5 eV gradually weaken (state A → B) and are constant (state B → C) during discharging, along with the formation of C–O⋯H–N species at 533.0 eV, suggesting the redox interaction between NH4+ ions and carbonyl motifs. About ex situ high-resolution N 1s XPS spectra of the OSs cathode (Fig. 3d), the ratio of C
N motifs at 399.0 eV remains almost unchanged (state A → B) and declines (state B → C). Meanwhile, a newly emerged signal (400.3 eV), resulting from the generation of C–N⋯H–N, could be observed. After charging, the signals of all the species reversibly returned to their initial levels through the decoordination of NH4+ from the redox-active sites. Besides, the ex situ XRD patterns and Raman spectra provided additional proof of a two-step NH4+ coordination with the C
O and C
N groups of the OS cathode (Fig. S15, ESI†). In conclusion, two findings were evident: (i) C
O and C
N can be recognized as redox-active sites for the cathodic electrochemical reactions; (ii) the OS electrode undergoes a two-step-continuous NH4+ storage process, with C
O coordinating first and C
N second.
UV/vis spectroscopy was next employed to study the dissolution behaviour of the OS cathode at five different voltage states in NH4OTF/H2O electrolyte. Here, no obvious absorption peaks were observed in the UV/vis spectra and the colourless nature of the NH4OTF/H2O electrolyte suggested the excellent anti-dissolution of the OSs (Fig. 3e). Furthermore, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) was performed for the OS cathode at different temperatures (T) (Fig. S16, ESI†) to obtain the interfacial charge transfer resistance (Rct) for fitting the activation energy (Ea) according to the Arrhenius equation,50 where Ea reflects the interfacial coordination reaction process between the redox-active groups of organic electrodes and ionic carriers of electrolytes.23 Generally, a lower Ea indicates a lower reaction energy barrier, making it easier for ions to coordinate with the redox-active groups of organics, which helps to achieve high-kinetics redox reactions and efficient charge storage.24 NH4+ coordination had a Ea of 0.16 eV (Fig. 3f), which was lower than for the Zn2+ reaction (0.34 eV). This result implies that high-kinetics NH4+ uptake takes precedence over Zn2+ at the redox-sites of the OS cathode.
Considering the slight acidity of the NH4OTF/H2O electrolyte (pH 4.85), it was essential to probe H+ reactions during NH4+ electrochemistry. When replacing NH4OTF with HOTF/H2O electrolyte with the same pH, the capacity of the Zn||OSs battery was 6.5 mA h g−1 (Fig. S17, ESI†). This demonstrates the marginal role of H+ in the energy-storage process of the OS cathode, as also confirmed by the absence of Zn salts on the cathode surface (Fig. S18, ESI†). In addition, the element mapping images and XPS spectrum of the OS electrode at full discharge (Fig. S19, ESI†) revealed the absence of Zn signals, indicating that Zn2+ ions did not participate in NH4+ storage. Therefore, NH4+ serves as the exclusive effective shuttling carrier in NH4OTF/H2O electrolyte, which dominates the entire electrochemical redox reaction of the OS cathode. Besides, the experimental capacity of the OSs, excluding 3.3 mA h g−1 for the graphite conductive agent (Fig. S20, ESI†) and 6.5 mA h g−1 for H+ storage, was 383.2 mA h g−1, corresponding to a high utilization (99.3%) of CO/C
N motifs and a 15 e− redox reaction. In general, OSs initiate a high-kinetics and stable two-step 15 e− NH4+ charge-storage process, involving six C
O coordinating with 6 NH4+ ions and then nine C
N couplings with 9 NH4+ ions (Fig. 3g).
Next, density functional theory (DFT) simulations were carried out to unravel the energy levels and redox activity of the OSs. Molecular electrostatic potential (MEP) simulation of an optimized OS skeleton (Fig. S21, ESI†) implied that the electronegative six carbonyl and nine triazine units were dual redox-active sites (red region) for NH4+ coordination (Fig. 4a). The OSs showed a highly π-conjugated superstructure, as revealed by the π-electron localization function (ELF-π), which can facilitate efficient electron delocalization through the aromatic backbone (Fig. 4b). Theoretically, a higher π-conjugation degree makes for a lower energy gap (ΔE) between the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) and the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO). The ΔE value of the OSs was 2.51 eV, exhibiting the favourable electronic configuration of the OSs to facilitate excellent electron-transfer efficiency with a low energy barrier (Fig. 4c). The anisotropy of the induced current density (ACID) calculation44 revealed that the clockwise diamagnetic continuous current flowed across the whole organic skeleton (Fig. 4d), reflecting the global π-aromaticity of the OSs.
The structural evolution of the OS cathode upon two-step NH4+ (de)coordination was further clarified. During the first discharge stage (step 1), six NH4+ ions coordinate with six carbonyl sites by delivering a negative Gibbs free energy (ΔG) of −6.76 eV (Fig. 4e). In the subsequent discharging process (step 2), nine NH4+ charge carriers couple with nine imine motifs of triazine units by a more negative ΔG value (−13.71 eV). Step 1 has a lower ΔG value compared to step 2, suggesting that step 1 and 2 can proceed sequentially. In accordance with the minimal energy theory, a robust two-step 15 e− redox process was triggered in the OS cathode, corresponding to two pairs of discharge platforms of the Zn||OSs cell (Fig. 2a and f). The differential charge isosurfaces were employed to investigate the binding nature of the NH4+-coordinated OSs (Fig. 4f). Based on the Bader charge analysis,51 the charge accumulation and depletion among NH4+ ions and CO/C
N groups suggested their strong coordination to form robust ligand configurations involving notable charge shifts (2.67 e of state I; 6.21 e of state II). The rapid kinetics of NH4+ ions was capable of maximizing the utilization of the carbonyl/imine motifs in the ultralow-coordination-barrier OSs, thereby enhancing the electrochemical activity and durability.
As discussed above, the OSs could achieve full utilization of the high-density redox-sites, long-range low-barrier electron delocalization, and electrochemical ultrastability, and underwent two-step NH4+ storage in NH4OTF/H2O electrolyte (Fig. 3g), resulting in two redox couples at 0.69 V (6 e− transfer in the first step) and 1.01 V (9 e− transfer in the second step). Such structural and functional features make OSs promising to serve as both the cathode and anode for building advanced all-organic NH4+-ion batteries (AOBs, Fig. 5a), while avoiding excessive use and adverse structural degeneration of the Zn anodes. As a proof of concept, new-type symmetric AOBs were constructed using the original OSs as the cathode, the reduced product of OSs (OSs-R) as the anode, and 3 M NH4OTF/H2O solution as the electrolyte. The charge-storage process of the AOBs belonged to a rocking chair mechanism, which operated in the form of a NH4+ shuttle between the OS cathode and OSs-R anode. During the discharge process, the OSs cathode accepted NH4+ ions through the reduction of its CO groups, resulting in the formation of C–O bonds. Simultaneously, the OSs-R anode released NH4+ ions through the oxidation reaction, which could convert into C
N bonds. The reverse redox reactions occurred during the charge process with the opposite structural evolution.
Next, electrochemical measurements were conducted to evaluate the performances of the AOBs. The GCD curves of the OSs||OSs-R battery displayed a discharge capacity of 213 mA h g−1 at 0.2 A g−1 (Fig. 5b, based on the mass loading of OSs in the cathode). A high energy density of 80.9 W h kg−1 was obtained for the OSs||OSs-R battery by determination of the integral area of the GCD curve at 0.2 A g−1 (Fig. 5b, based on the mass loading of OSs in the cathode). With a 250-fold current density increase to 50 A g−1, the capacity still retained 96 mA h g−1, with high electrochemical reversibility within 90 cycles (Fig. 5c). The high capacity of the OSs||OSs-R cell is a key advantage over previously reported organic full batteries,4,9,52–59 making it a formidable choice for next-generation organic electrodes. Significantly, the OSs||OSs-R battery achieved an extraordinary cycling lifespan of 100000 cycles with 90.3% capacity retention at 5 A g−1 (Fig. 5d), which is the highest value among the NH4+-hosting full batteries reported to date (Fig. 5e).11,12,60–65 The comprehensive electrochemical performances of the OSs||OSs-R full cell, including its superior capacity, excellent rate performance and ultralong life, are far superior to those of the currently reported all-organic batteries (Table S2, ESI†).
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5ee00823a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |