Adrian
Moreno
*,
Javier
Delgado-Lijarcio
,
Juan C.
Ronda
,
Marina
Galià
and
Gerard
Lligadas
*
Universitat Rovira i Virgili, Departament de Química Analítica i Química Orgànica, Laboratory of Sustainable Polymers, Tarragona 43007, Spain. E-mail: adrian.moreno@urv.cat; gerard.lligadas@urv.cat
First published on 16th January 2025
Amine-infused hydrogels (AIHs) represent a promising platform for developing solid absorbents with improved CO2 absorption capacity. However, most of them rely on petroleum-based and toxic monomers. Lignin nanoparticles (LNPs) are becoming prominent players at the interface between sustainable nanomaterials technology and chemical science due to their high surface-area-to-mass ratio, which allows them to interact with multiple active compounds. Capitalizing on this spherical morphology and high surface area, the present work presents a strategy to prepare hybrid and particulate lignin-based hydrogels that can act as amine carriers for CO2 capture. The entire process is based on the internal stabilization of LNPs via intraparticle cross-linking process and subsequent base-catalyzed ring-opening reaction between LNPs and poly(ethylene glycol) diglycidyl ether in aqueous media. Upon swelling the hydrogel with an amine solution, hybrid and particulate lignin-based AIHs rapidly capture CO2 with a higher overall uptake compared to commonly used aqueous amine solutions under similar experimental conditions, while also stand and in some cases surpass the performance of other AIHs reported in the literature. Additionally, these new materials can be easily regenerated multiple times with minimal decrease in CO2 absorption capacity, demonstrating their potential application in decarbonization capture technologies.
Green foundation1. In this work, lignin nanoparticles (LNPs) are used as covalent cross-linking agents to prepare lignin-based particulate hydrogels with enhanced mechanical properties. These new hydrogels are capable of swelling in amine aqueous solutions and shown a rapidly and quantitatively absorption of CO2. Typically, hydrogels used for CO2 capture are composed of monomers derived from fossil resources and toxic cross-linking agents. Thus, our approach represents a promising alternative by utilizing lignin, a natural and abundant biopolymer with no food competition, and typically discarded by the pulp and paper industry.2. We have developed a particulate hydrogel with up to 60% biobased content and demonstrated that stand or, in some cases, surpasses the performance of petroleum-derived hydrogels in CO2 capture experiments. 3. Future experiments should address issues such as the effect of particle size and uniformity on the mechanical properties and performance of the material. Additionally, exploring the possibility of increasing the biobased content should also be considered to minimize or eliminate the use of petroleum-sourced resources completely. |
To address this challenge, the use of hydrogels as an amine carrier for CO2 absorption has garnered interest in recent years. Pioneering works reported by Wood et al. demonstrated that hydrogels swelled in aqueous amine solutions, can act as macro-recipients where CO2 and amines can interact easily.11–14 This fact is due to the effective absorption of amines within the cross-linked polymeric matrix –owing to the swelling ability of hydrogels–, and the increase in surface area that facilitates CO2 diffusion and its reaction with the amine solution in situ. These relatively new CO2 absorbents were coined amine-infused hydrogels (AIHs), given the fact that their preparation simply involves the swelling “infusion” of the hydrogel with the corresponding amine solution. These systems have demonstrated quantitative and short absorption times (<1 hour),11 and the versatility to carrier greener materials for CO2 capture such as amino acid salts in contrast to conventional amines such as monoethanolamine (MEA).14 However, when it comes to the hydrogel part, the systems reported so far are based in cross-linked polymers derived from fossils resources such as poly(acrylamide)/poly(sodium acrylate) that are synthetized from toxic monomers (acrylamide) and employing also toxic cross-linking agents such as N,N′-methylenebis(acrylamide) (MBA).12,13 Here, it is worth mentioning that the use of inorganic capsules or organic hydrogel beads is also emerging as a notably approach.15–17 These materials tend to have a more remarkable porous structure and large surface area, which, upon swelling with the corresponding amine aqueous solution, shown high efficiency towards CO2 capture.
Therefore, it can be deduced that the next logical steps to upgrade this strategy should involve the utilization of hydrogels derived from biomass (i.e., bio-based hydrogels) and combine them with nanoparticles to maximize the efficiency of CO2 capture. In this sense, particulate hydrogels, where polymeric nanoparticles act as the cross-linking sites, have demonstrated improved mechanical properties and a large surface area in contrast to monolithic hydrogels.18 Thus, one can envision that particulate hydrogels could have great potential when applied to CO2 capture after swelling with amine aqueous or organic solutions, owing to the inherent porosity of hydrogels and the high surface area of nanoparticles that would facilitate the interaction with the amine and promote the reaction with CO2.
Among possible raw materials, lignin is one of the most promising components for the development of bio-based hydrogels, as it is often discarded in pulp and paper processes and has an inherently partially cross-linked structure rich in aliphatic, phenolic, and carboxylic acid groups, making it an excellent cross-linking agent.19–21 The formation of lignin-based hydrogels has been explored previously, showing their potential to develop functional materials for diverse applications, such as filtration membranes,22–24 drug delivery systems,25–27 or thermoelectric materials,28–30 among others.31–33 However, so far, lignin nanoparticles (LNPs) have not been applied in the preparation of particulate hydrogels, despite having a well-defined spherical shape, a large surface area-to-mass ratio and remarkable colloidal stability.34–37 In addition, LNPs can circumvent issues such as heterogeneous structure and broad molecular weight distribution, which are known hurdles in developing lignin-based materials.
In this work, we present a robust and straightforward preparation method to develop hybrid and particulate lignin-based hydrogels composed primarily of internally stabilized LNPs. In these new particulate hydrogels, LNPs act as physical cross-linking points, increasing the surface area of the hydrogels. This represents a promising strategy to enhance the interaction of active molecules within the hydrogel matrix (Fig. 1). We show that these bio-based particulate hydrogels can swell in the presence of aqueous or organic amine solutions and perform an efficient CO2 absorption, surpassing in some cases the performance of commercially available hydrogels. We also demonstrate that the incorporation of LNPs is a key factor not only in increasing the kinetics of the CO2 absorption process but also in improving the mechanical properties of the final material, which is critical for further applications.
With the colloidal stable hy-LNPs available, our next step was to explore the thermal-induced intraparticle cross-linking process and investigate their stability in alkaline pH. To achieve this, hy-LNPs were subjected to hydrothermal curing at 100 °C for 48 hours to produce cross-linked hy-LNPs (c-hy-LNPs) (Fig. 1, step 3). The intraparticle cross-linking process takes place between the phenolic OH of SKL and the oxirane groups of TECy, as reported previously when epoxides are used as cross-linkers.39 The success of the cross-linking process was evaluated via FTIR analysis before and after the curing process from isolated freeze-dried hy-LNPs and c-hy-LNPs. Among the FTIR bands, the most characteristic is the band corresponding to the oxirane group around 910 cm−1. As can be seen from Fig. 2b, after the curing process, this band vanishes completely, thus confirming the effective ring-opening of TECy and the cross-linking reaction. In addition, DSC thermogram recorded from hy-LNPs also revealed the presence of an exothermic peak associated with the ring-opening processes between 60–90 °C confirming the curing process in this range of temperature (Fig. S17†). DLS analysis of the colloidal c-hy-LNPs dispersions revealed negligible variation in particle size, thus confirming that the curing step was limited to an intraparticle, and not interparticle, cross-linking processes (Fig. 2a). The structural stability of c-Hy-LNPs after being exposed to a strong alkaline environment (pH = 13) for 24 hours was initially evaluated by DLS. DLS analysis indicates that c-hy-LNPs remain colloidal, as evidenced by only a slight increase in particle size that can be attributed to the swelling of the particles (Fig. 2a). In addition, TEM imaging of c-hy-LNPs before and after exposure to alkaline conditions did not reveal any significant change in the shape and size of the particles, thus confirming their colloidal stability and resistance against marked basic pH (Fig. 2d and Fig. S18 and S19†). It is worth mentioning that colloidal stability against basic pH was achieved by employing only 5 wt% of cross-linker, thus leading to the obtention of stabilized LNPs with a lignin content as high as 95%. Previous reports required a minimum of 20 wt% of cross-linker to achieve internal stabilization of LNPs.39,43 This difference can be attributed to the increased reactivity of triepoxides compared to diepoxides, which could lead to a reduction in the production cost of stabilized LNPs while maintaining a higher biobased content.
With the internally stabilized c-hy-LNPs in our hands, we directed our efforts to the preparation of lignin-based particulate hydrogels (c-hy-LNPs@gel) via a base-catalyzed ring-opening reaction between c-hy-LNPs and poly(ethylene glycol) diglycidyl ether (PEGDGE) (Fig. 1, step 4). Accordingly, c-hy-LNPs@gel was prepared by simple homogenization of previously basified c-hy-LNPs dispersions with PEGDGE at room temperature, followed by hydrothermal curing at 40 °C for 16 hours to trigger the base-catalyzed epoxy ring-opening reaction. After gelation, the resulting mechanically stable gels were peeled off from the containers in the form of discs (d = 1 cm, h = 0.5 cm), soaked, and rinsed in pure water prior to further testing (Fig. 3b). Here it is important to mention that in order to obtain mechanically robust and flexible hydrogels, it is essential to add the optimal amount of cross-linker (PEGDGE). Considering that the total amount of phenolic hydroxyl groups in pristine SKL is 4.04 mmol g−1 lignin, as quantified by 31P NMR spectroscopy (Table S1 and Fig. S20†), and assuming that some of them have been consumed during the internal stabilization of hy-LNPs and not all are exposed on the surface of the particles, the optimal amount of PEGDGE to obtain self-standing hydrogels was found to be 2 mmol g−1 lignin. The cross-linking process was confirmed by FTIR, which, as discussed above for the stabilization of hy-LNPs, shows a complete disappearance of the oxirane bands at 910 cm−1 and 758 cm−1 after the hydrothermal curing, thus confirming the success of the cross-linking process (Fig. 3a). To study the morphology of c-hy-LNPs@gel scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM) analysis was employed. The SEM images of the surface and cross sections of c-hy-LNPs@gel revealed microscopic pore structures were c-hy-LNPs are homogeneously dispersed within the hydrogel matrix without any micrometer sized agglomerates (Fig. 3c and Fig. S21†). Similarly, AFM micrograph also prove the particulate nature of the synthetized hydrogel (Fig. 3d). One possible explanation for this well-defined particle dispersion could be attributed to an increase viscosity of the system during the curing process due to the evaporation of water, which likely restricted particle diffusion and, consequently, reduced their tendency to agglomerate due to the density difference compared to the hydrogel matrix. For comparative purposes, monolithic lignin-based hydrogels without LNPs (SKL@gel) and lignin-based hybrid hydrogels (hybrid@gel) using a mixture of c-hy-LNPs and SKL (1:
1 wt%) were also prepared. SEM imaging of both control hydrogels revealed a microscopic porous structure, with an obvious reduction of c-hy-LNPs content in the case of the hybrid hydrogel and a complete absence in the case of the monolithic hydrogel (Fig. S22†). In addition, regardless of the hydrogel composition (monolithic, hybrid, or particulate), a gel content exceeding 95% was determined through extraction with an organic solvent (tetrahydrofuran) (Fig. S23†), indicating extensive cross-linking network formation during the synthetic step.
Mechanical properties are crucial and largely define the range of applications for hydrogels. In this sense, and intrigued by the impact that c-hy-LNPs could have in this aspect, uniaxial tensile testing was carried out to investigate the mechanical properties of the synthetized hydrogels. The c-hy-LNPs@gel exhibited a marked improvement in both tensile strength and elongation at break compared to the monolithic hydrogel without LNPs and the hybrid hydrogel (Fig. 3e). Notably, direct comparison with the monolithic (SKL@gel) and hybrid (hybrid@gel) hydrogels evidenced an increase in elongation at break by a factor of 4 and 2, respectively. This was accompanied by a more moderate increase in tensile strength (50% for the monolithic and 25% for the hybrid), demonstrating that particulate hydrogels are tougher and more resistant materials.
These significant differences in mechanical properties can be attributed to the well-defined spherical shape and high surface area-to-mass ratio of c-hy-LNPs, which would act as physical cross-linking points and establish effective interactions within the hydrogel matrix via non-covalent bond formation. These non-covalent interactions, mainly hydrogen bonding between the hydroxyl groups of both c-hy-LNPs and PEGDGE, would play a crucial role as sacrificial bonds that form new interactions during the deformation process, ultimately explaining the positive reinforcing effect in the hybrid and particulate hydrogels in contrast to monolithic hydrogel. While many previous works have reported the positive effects of incorporating LNPs into polymeric matrixes,46–48 none have explored their use in the preparation of covalent cross-linked particulate hydrogels. In this context, it is important to highlight that our approach represents a simple methodology to access lignin-based particulate hydrogels with improved mechanical properties, thus expanding their potential application to fields where marked mechanical properties are needed, such as membrane filtration preparation.24 Aligned with this, the water absorbency capacity (i.e., swelling) of the hydrogels was also evaluated. The monolithic (SKL@gel) hydrogel swelled and absorbed water quickly, reaching a water content of over 230% after 2 hours. When immersing the hybrid (hybrid@gel) and the particulate (c-hy-LNPs@gel) hydrogels, a systematic decrease in the water absorbency capacity was observed as the wt% of c-hy-LNPs in the system increased (200% for the hybrid and 170% for the particulate). This decrease could be attributed to a denser packing and higher cross-linked density in the hydrogels containing c-hy-LNPs, as the particles act as physical cross-linking points, thereby limiting the pore size around them.
As discussed in the introduction, amine-infused hydrogels (AIHs) allow fast and efficient CO2 uptake due to their enlarged surface area, which promotes effective diffusion of CO2.11 Intrigued by the effect that the incorporation of LNPs with a favorable and large surface-area-to-mass ratio could have on these systems, we decided to investigate lignin-based particulate hydrogels as AIHs for CO2 uptake. Regardless of whether the hydrogel employed was monolithic, hybrid, or particulate, AIHs were prepared by simply grounding and swelling of the hydrogel with an amine aqueous solution for 1 hour, highlighting the operational simplicity of preparing these CO2 capture absorbents (Fig. 4a). Diethanolamine (DEA) was selected as the amine due to its water solubility and high boiling point (271 °C). It is important to note that a minimum amount of hydrogel (15 wt% based on the liquid amine solution) is essential to ensure a high adsorption of the amine (91% based on titration experiments) within the hydrogel matrix in order to prevent the undesired squeezing of the amine solution.
Attempts to reduce the hydrogel content in an effort to optimize the process result in the squeezing out of the amine solution over time, which could negatively impact the CO2 absorption capacity of the system (Fig. S24†).
The initial CO2 capture experiments using AIHs were conducted using a DEA aqueous solution at a fixed concentration of 30 wt%. The experimental conditions and corresponding results are summarized in Table 1 (entries 1–4), while the absorption kinetics as a function of time are shown in Fig. 4b.
Entry | DEA (g) | Water (g) | DML (g) | Hydrogela | Theoretical absorptionb (g) | Determined absorption (g) | 50% absorption timec (min) | CO2 loading (mol of CO2 mol−1 of DEA) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a 0.3 g of hydrogel were used in each experiment.
b Assuming the reaction mole ratio of DEA to CO2 is 2![]() ![]() |
||||||||
1 | 0.6 | 1.4 | — | — | 0.124 | 0.070 | 6 | 0.28 |
2 | 0.6 | 1.4 | — | SKL@gel | 0.124 | 0.115 | 10 | 0.46 |
3 | 0.6 | 1.4 | — | hybrid@gel | 0.124 | 0.120 | 7 | 0.48 |
4 | 0.6 | 1.4 | — | c-hy-LNPs@gel | 0.124 | 0.131 | 4 | 0.53 |
5 | 0.6 | — | 1.4 | SKL@gel | 0.124 | 0.101 | 35 | 0.38 |
6 | 0.6 | — | 1.4 | hybrid@gel | 0.124 | 0.124 | 24 | 0.50 |
7 | 0.6 | — | 1.4 | c-hy-LNPs@gel | 0.124 | 0.124 | 17 | 0.50 |
For comparative purposes, a DEA aqueous solution was also studied, and as can be observed, it showed the lowest absorption capacity (56% CO2 uptake) (Table 1, entry 1 and Fig. 4b). This is mainly associated with the formation of viscous carbamate salts, which hampers the mass transfer inside the DEA solution and therefore slows the interaction of CO2 with DEA, as reported previously.49,50 When it comes to using AIHs, it is clear that regardless of the lignin-based hydrogel employed, higher CO2 uptake compared to the DEA solution was observed (Table 1, entries 2–4 and Fig. 4b). For instance, the monolithic hydrogel (SKL@gel) showed a 90% CO2 uptake in around 1 hour, while in the case of the hybrid hydrogel (hybrid@gel) and particulate hydrogel (c-hy-LNPs@gel), quantitative CO2 uptake was observed in 35 minutes and 25 minutes, respectively (Fig. 4b). These significant differences are associated with the increased surface area, which enables a complete and maximum interaction of CO2 with DEA. Here it is worth mentioning that the theoretical molar ratio of secondary amines to CO2 is 2:
1, as reported previously,11 thus the maximum loading for DEA was 0.5 mol CO2 per mol of DEA. As can be observed in Table 1 (entries 2–4), the CO2 uptake of lignin-based AIHs was in the range of 0.5 mol of CO2 per mol of DEA, which proves the excellent absorption efficiency of lignin-based hydrogels. In contrast, the DEA solution showed a CO2 uptake of 0.28 mol per mol of DEA, which is significantly lower than that of AIHs. The effect of the introduction of LNPs in the hydrogel formulation was also evident, as increasing the amount of c-hy-LNPs systematically showed faster CO2 uptake kinetics. For instance, the particulate hydrogel reached 50% CO2 uptake in 4 minutes and complete uptake in 25 minutes, while the hybrid hydrogel showed 50% CO2 uptake in 7 minutes and complete uptake in 35 minutes (Table 1, entries 3 and 4 and Fig. 4b). These results can be rationalized by the fact that c-hy-LNPs have a favorable large surface area enriched with hydroxyl and phenolic groups. These functional groups would allow an efficient immobilization of the amine via non-covalent interactions (e.g., hydrogen bonding) at the particle surface, improving their accessibility to interact with CO2, thus accelerating the in situ reaction between CO2 and DEA. It is important to highlight that the results (e.g., CO2 uptake values and kinetic absorption) obtained with the particulate hydrogels (c-hy-LNPs@gel) not only stand the comparison but also, in some cases, surpass those of hydrogels derived from petroleum resources, thus highlighting the potential of lignin-based particulate hydrogels for decarbonization technologies (Fig. 4c). To confirm the interaction between the CO2 gas and DEA in lignin-based AIHs, FTIR analysis before and after CO2 absorption was conducted. After CO2 absorption, the characteristic bands of carbamate formation, which are the symmetric and asymmetric COO− stretching vibrations at 1540 cm−1 and 1255 cm−1, respectively, together with the band assigned to the NR3+ deformation at 1307 cm−1, were observed, thus validating the CO2 absorption in lignin-based AIHs (Fig. S25†).51
In order to develop a competitive CO2 capture technology, the captured CO2 must be easily removed from the sorbents so they can be recycled and used again as circular materials. AIHs swollen with amine aqueous solutions suffer from water evaporation during thermal-induced CO2 desorption, which leads to a poor sorbent cycling process. To avoid that, high-boiling point non-aqueous solvents such as ethylene glycol have been reported to show notable performance in the recycling process.13 Here, we selected Agnique AMD 3L (N,N-dimethylactamide, DML), a green bio-solvent derived from the lactic acid platform and commercialized by BASF, as a high-boiling point (200 °C) solvent to explore the recyclability of lignin-based AIHs. Thus, the hydrogels were swollen under the same conditions used in the previous experiments, simply replacing the amine aqueous solution with an amine DML solution. Kinetic absorption experiments and experimental details are shown and summarized in Fig. 4d and Table 1 (entries 5–7), respectively. Kinetic experiments revealed an identical trend to that observed previously when amine aqueous solutions were used. For instance, the particulate hydrogel (c-hy-LNPs@gel) exhibited the fastest CO2 uptake with a 50% absorption time of 17 minutes, in contrast to 25 minutes and 35 minutes for hybrid (hybrid@gel) and monolithic (SKL@gel) hydrogels, respectively (Fig. 4d and Table 1, entries 5–7). Additionally, it was noted that the presence of c-hy-LNPs is crucial to reach quantitative CO2 absorption, as hybrid and particulate hydrogels achieved levels of 0.5 mol of CO2 per mol of DEA, in contrast to the monolithic hydrogel that exhibited lower values (0.38 mol of CO2 per mol of DEA), as can be observed in Table 1, entries 5–7. Here it is worth mentioning that when non-aqueous solvents are used, lignin-based AIHs clearly surpass the performance of commercial hydrogels. For instance, poly(acrylamide)-based hydrogels exhibited a 50% absorption time of 150 minutes compared to a 50% absorption time of 17 minutes for particulate lignin-based hydrogels.13 This confirms the exceptional performance of lignin-based hydrogels for CO2 capture and highlights their potential for industrial carbon neutralization processes.52
To further confirm the occurrence of CO2 absorption in lignin-based AIHs when non-aqueous solvents are employed, and also assess the temperature conditions for desorption of CO2 and evaporation of the DEA/DML mixture, thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was performed. Thus, particulate lignin-based AIHs (c-hy-LNPs@gel) were presaturated with CO2 to assess the desorption conditions. Fig. 4e displays the mass change and derivative mass, which indicates the rate of mass loss for the CO2-loaded particulate lignin-based AIHs during the heating process. Two peaks are clearly distinguishable in the plot of derivative weight (Fig. 4e, green and gray shadows). The one at a lower temperature around 100–130 °C corresponds to the characteristic CO2 desorption as reported previously for similar systems,11,12 while the second starting around 170 °C corresponds to the evaporation process of both DEA and DML. These results confirm the absorption of CO2, but more importantly, they also show the possibility to remove CO2 from the sorbent without significant loss of amine and solvent, which is crucial for assessing the recyclability of lignin-based AIHs. The recyclability of particulate lignin-based AIHs was investigated by exposing the particulate hydrogel to CO2 for 2 hours before being placed in an oven at 120 °C for 1 hour to remove the CO2. After that, and without adding additional DEA and DML, it was used for the next absorption cycle (Fig. 4f, absorption cycle 1). A minor decrease in CO2 uptake (less than 10%) was observed over 6 cycles associated to minor evaporation process of solvent and amine, indicating a notable capability of lignin-based AIHs to be reused and demonstrating their potential application in the circular capture of CO2 (Fig. 4f).
Gel content (%) = (M1 − M2)/M1 × 100% |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4gc05489j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |