Rebecca L. Charltonab,
Douglas O. Escrivaniab,
Christopher Browna,
Niranjan Thotaa,
Victor S. Agostino
a,
Exequiel O. J. Porta
a,
Timur Avkiranc,
Andrew T. Merrittc,
Paul W. Denny
d,
Bartira Rossi-Bergmannb and
Patrick G. Steel
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, Durham University, Lower Mountjoy, South Rd, Durham DH1 3LE, UK. E-mail: p.g.steel@durham.ac.uk
bInstitute of Biophysics, Carlos Chagas Filho, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, 21941-902 Rio de Janeiro – RJ, Brazil
cLifeArc, Accelerator Building, Open Innovation Campus, Stevenage, SG1 2FX, UK
dDepartment of Biosciences, Durham University, Lower Mountjoy, South Rd, Durham DH1 3LE, UK
First published on 31st January 2025
Current therapeutic options for leishmaniasis are severely limited, highlighting an urgent need to develop more effective and less toxic drugs to combat a major global public health challenge. Clemastine fumarate displays good levels of antileishmanial efficacy, but further optimisation is challenged by its difficult synthesis. Here, we demonstrate that simple N-linked analogues are easier to access, can exhibit higher selectivity and show comparable efficacy in a mouse model of Leishmania amazonensis infection.
The current treatment of Leishmania infections is difficult with multiple manifestations caused by 21 of the 35 known Leishmania species reported to infect mammals. There is currently no approved vaccine against Leishmania infection,7–9 so control of the disease relies on a limited number of drug treatments that are toxic, require intensive professional health services and are not effective across all manifestations and causative species.10 For example, the antimonials (Glucantime or Pentostam) and amphotericin B which are current first-line therapies require up to 20–30 daily intramuscular or intravenous injections to complete a course of treatment. In addition, these not only produce severe adverse reactions, but the unpleasant nature of the administration leads to poor patient compliance which increases the risk of the development of resistance. Currently, the only orally viable solution is miltefosine, a failed (but repurposed) antineoplastic agent, which has significant toxicity and resistance issues.11
Reflecting this situation, the discovery and development of new therapeutic solutions is vital. Towards this goal, in recent work, we have identified clemastine fumarate (CF) 1a as a potential new anti-leishmanial agent that functions as an inhibitor of the essential leishmanial sphingolipid biosynthetic enzyme, inositol phosphorylceramide synthase (IPCS). Excitingly, this activity could be translated into in vivo mouse models of infection.12 Whilst attractive as a repurposed drug,13 CF exhibits multiple activities. Moreover, although an over-the-counter drug, assembling the CF skeleton is surprisingly challenging due to the requirement to form a chiral tertiary ether linkage. Only two stereoselective syntheses have been reported and, in these, the ether bond is achieved by the alkylation of an enantioenriched tertiary alcohol 2 with a proline derived alkyl halide (S)-3.14,15 However, this reaction is non-trivial, occurring in low yields, and was accompanied by competing ring expansion to afford the azepane 4 (Fig. 1). As such we were interested in exploring alternative linkages that could enable more rapid SAR and, in this report, summarise our efforts in this regard and describe the formation of simpler, more accessible analogues that provide equivalent inhibition of Leishmania survival in vitro and in vivo.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Structures of clemastine (1) and CF (1a) and previously reported synthesis of (S,S)-clemastine 1 by Clayden et al.14 |
Pleasingly employing enantiomerically pure homoprolinol derivatives afforded analogues 9 and 10 which exhibited comparable in vitro activity to CF 1a, vide infra (Scheme 1, Table S1†) with slightly higher activity observed for the R-stereochemistry configured pyrrolidine ring 10. Although facile, this etherification proved capricious and alternative linkers based on amide and triazole units, that enabled more efficiently SAR assessment, were explored (Scheme 2). The required precursors for each of these could be accessed commercially or synthesised in relatively few steps and the coupling reactions proved efficient enabling multiple analogues to be prepared in parallel (Table S1†).
When tested against microsomal enzyme preparations of L. majIPCS16 (Fig. 2, Table S1†) the comparisons of pyrrolidine, tetrahydrofuran and cyclopentane derivatives 19, 21–23 supported earlier observations that all active compounds retained a basic nitrogen in the head group.17 In general, whilst enzyme inhibitory activity was retained in a number of these analogues, much lower activity was observed against promastigote parasites. The most active analogue was the N-dimethylaminoethyl indazole derivative 24, which exhibited equivalent levels of inhibition of L. majIPCS activity as observed for CF. Speculating that this lower activity in promastigote parasite assays reflected a (membrane) transport issue, we then explored the corresponding ether derivative 27. Attempts to prepare this by acid catalysed ether formation failed and ultimately this was achieved through displacement of the corresponding benzylic chloride 25 (Scheme 3). Whilst this provided enhanced antiparasitic effects when compared to the corresponding amide 24, this was significantly lower than that observed with CF.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Activity of a selection of simple amide and triazole linked CF analogues against a microsomal preparation of L. majIPCS and L. major promastigote parasites, respectively. Values in parenthesis indicate relative inhibition of the enzyme preparation at 20 μM. For further details and a full list of analogues see ESI.† |
![]() | ||
Scheme 3 Synthesis of indazole analogue 27. i. MsCl, NEt3, DCM; ii. ClH·Me2NCH2CH2Cl, K2CO3, DMF, Δ (54%), iii. LiAlH4, THF (100%); iv. NaH, DMF then add 25 (14%). |
Given the enhanced activity observed with simple ether type linkages, we then attempted to optimise the synthetic route to this connection using simple alcohol precursors. A screen of Lewis acids using 4-bromobenzhydrol and 3-phenyl-1-propanol (Fig. S1†), identified AuCl as the most efficient catalyst for this transformation. However, successful etherification with homoprolinol required N-Cbz protection to prevent inhibition of the reaction by the free amine. The carbamate was then reduced to form the desired clemastine analogues in a reliable fashion (Scheme 4). Although limited to functionality stable to the reduction conditions, this synthetic route provided a simple method to explore SAR around the biaryl fragments (table, Scheme 4). Disappointingly none of these derivatives displayed better antiparasitic activity than that observed for CF.
![]() | ||
Scheme 4 Synthesis, and anti-promastigote activity, of biarylcarbinol analogues generated through AuCl catalysed etherification. |
Whilst nor methyl clemastine 10 retained good levels of activity in both assays this was not as effective as commercial samples of CF. Speculating that the stereochemistry at the diarylcarbinol might be crucial we then explored enantioselective strategies towards this component. Employing methodology described by Braga et al.,18 enantiomerically pure (R)-configured benzhydrol 5a was prepared by (R)-diphenylpyrrolidinemethanol 34 mediated arylation of 4-chlorobenzaldehyde (Scheme 5). In order to preserve the integrity of this chiral centre we returned to the SN2 methodology described by Clayden et al.14 Using the (R)-configured pyrrolidine-2-ethyl chloride (R)-3 as this had shown higher activity in earlier assays, preparation of the (R,R) analogue 35 was achieved; albeit in low yield and accompanied by the azepane by-product 36. The (S,R) analogue 37 could similarly be prepared either by arylating benzaldehyde with 4-ClC6H4B(OH)2 or using the enantiomeric chiral auxiliary (S)-34. Testing against both L. major and L. amazonensis (L. amaz) promastigotes revealed that optimal activity resided in the (R,R) diastereoisomer 35 which showed comparable activity to CF in both enzyme and parasite assays.
![]() | ||
Scheme 5 Enantioselective synthesis and anti-promastigote activity of nor methyl clemastine analogues. |
Whilst good levels of activity could be realised, the synthetic challenge remained, particularly that caused by ring expansion during alkylation with the proline-derived alkylating agents. To address this, we explored a simple positional shift in the amine component. These compounds could be generated by AuCl ether formation with a bromoalcohol followed by SN2 alkylation with a proline derived amine. As before the stereochemistry of the pyrrolidine component had minimal effect (Table 1 entries 1 & 2). Replacing the 2-methyl substituent with a longer functionalised sidechain was deleterious to activity and an unsubstituted pyrrolidine showed only modest effects (Table 1 entries 3–6). Despite the simplicity of the synthetic chemistry these initial compounds had only moderate efficacy when compared with CF. Speculating that the position of the basic nitrogen relative to the benzhydryl centre was important we then prepared examples with 2, 3 and 4 carbon linkers (Table 1, entries 1,7, 8). Consistent with this hypothesis, the 3-carbon linker analogues, which have an equivalent spacing between heteroatoms as that found in CF, afforded optimal anti-parasitic activity.
Entry | 38 | Carbinol stereochemistry | NR2 | n | Method yield (%) | L.mj EC50a (μM) | L.amaz EC50a (μM) | BMDM CC50 (μM) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a EC50 determined using promastigote parasites – see ESI† for details.b Obtained in 65% yield after reduction of 38c with LiAlH4, THF. | ||||||||
1 | a | RS | ![]() |
0 | A (54%) | 2.05 | 3.40 | — |
2 | b | RS | ![]() |
0 | A (57%) | 2.65 | 4.10 | — |
3 | c | RS | ![]() |
0 | A (26%) | 23.83 | 17.39 | — |
4 | d | RS | ![]() |
0 | Ab | 5.88 | 3.20 | — |
5 | e | RS | ![]() |
0 | A (57%) | 14.41 | 12.35 | — |
6 | f | RS | ![]() |
0 | A (47%) | — | 3.27 | 57 |
7 | g | RS | ![]() |
2 | A (40%) | 1.21 | — | — |
8 | h | RS | ![]() |
1 | A (57%) | 0.09 | — | — |
9 | i | S | ![]() |
0 | B (55%) | 7.05 | — | — |
10 | j | S | ![]() |
0 | B (57%) | 11.5 | — | — |
11 | k | R | ![]() |
0 | A (61%) | 1.7 | 3.2 | — |
12 | l | R | ![]() |
1 | B (55%) | 0.030 | 0.041 | 73 |
13 | m | R | ![]() |
1 | B (42%) | 0.031 | 0.042 | — |
14 | n | R | ![]() |
1 | B (44%) | 0.027 | 0.017 | — |
15 | o | R | ![]() |
1 | B (42%) | 0.08 | 0.10 | — |
Whilst this enabled easy assessment of SAR this came at the cost of stereochemical insights. Consequently, and in contrast to the CF head group, direct alkylation of the diaryl carbinol with a preformed N-linked alkyl halide proved viable yielding a single enantiomer ether product in good yields with no evidence for ring expanded side products. Whilst alkylations of 10b, using preformed alkoxide in toluene, were susceptible to rapid oxidation to the benzophenone, presumably caused by trace amounts of oxygen in the reaction mixture, this issue could be circumvented by switching to a more polar solvent (DMF) and in situ deprotonation and alkylation. As before the stereochemistry of the diaryl carbinol was crucial with higher activity observed in the R-configured series of compounds (Table 1, entries 9–11, 8–13). As before, the presence of a 2-substituted pyrrolidine was desirable although the stereochemistry had minimal impact with a gem dimethyl variant proving equally effective in these assays. As the simple 2-methylpyrrolidines were more accessible, we arbitrarily selected the S isomer for all further analyses.
CF was originally selected from a screen for inhibitors of the sphingolipid synthase, (L. majIPCS) and to verify that this new analogue retained this profile we applied the same assays as used before. As described previously, the dose-dependent growth inhibition of L. major wildtype (WT) and mutant Δ LCB2, in which L. majIPCS is redundant, was assessed and compared to validate the on target effects of N-linked analogue 38l (Fig. 3A). Using cycloheximide as a control these assays showed that, similar to CF 1a, analogue 38l is approximately 3 times more active against WT than the mutant Δ LCB2 promastigotes. Sensitivity was restored in both series in the add-back cell line (PX) suggesting that both CF 1a and N-linked analogue 38l are disrupting the sphingolipid pathway. To support inhibition of the IPCS, the HPTLC biochemical assay described by Mina et al.16 was employed. In this, using a microsomal preparation of the L. majIPCS, a fluorescent substrate NBD-C6-ceramide was combined with PI and the two drugs. Following the reaction, the product, NBD-C6-IPC, and residual starting material were separated via HPTLC and analysed by fluorescence spectroscopy. No product was observed in either of the compound treated reactions demonstrating that 38l was a functional analogue of CF 1a, acting as an inhibitor of IPCS, (Fig. 3B).
In order to retain comparisons with CF we then evaluated activity in an intramacrophage model of L. amazonensis. Pleasingly, comparable levels of antiparasitic activity (0.51 ± 14 μM) were retained with the enhanced benefit of a lower toxicity against the host bone-marrow derived macrophage (CC50 = 73 ± 14 μM; SI ∼140). The significantly enhanced selectivity index (SI) was encouraging. It is known that, as an early H1 antagonist, CF was not particularly selective with reported activity against other receptors notably the muscarinic receptors (M1, M2, M3 and M5).19–21 Given the lower cytotoxicity it was of interest to explore whether this simple structural modification had changed other activities. Accordingly, CF, and analogues (R,R)-35 and 38l were assessed in a simple radioligand displacement assay. CF and the simple nor-methyl analogue (R,R)-35 showed very similar binding profiles with activity against a broad representation of receptor sub-types. However, the N linked analogue 38l showed greater selectivity with effective binding (>40%) observed for only the H1, M1, and M4 receptors and lower affinity to the M5 and 5-HTB2 receptors (Fig. S2†).
Finally, with good levels of intramacrophage activity and low cellular toxicity in cell culture, efficacy in a mouse model of L. amazonensis infection was assessed. In our earlier studies we were unable to deliver CF to the mouse orally, an observation we attributed to the high rate of metabolism and low kinetic solubility of the parent drug in this model. As analysis of 38l suggested that the physicochemical parameters were unsurprisingly similar to clemastine (38l clogP 4.25, log
S −5.16; 1 clog
P 4.18, log
S −5.12)22 it was likely that these challenges remained. Consequently, we used IL dosing for this experiment. To enable direct comparison with CF, the same treatment regimen (dose of 1.2 mg kg−1 via IL injection twice a week for 4 weeks starting on DPI) was used for both compounds. Whilst CF-treated mice showed a small weight loss, all other groups; trial and positive and negative controls; showed little variation in the weight of mice (Fig. 4A). Analysis of the mice 35 days post-infection revealed that lesion growth trends were similar for the groups treated with analogue 38l and CF 1a via IL administration (Fig. 4B). Overall, both treatments showed a statistically significant reduction in parasitaemia when compared to the untreated group (Fig. 4D).
Whilst the fungal enzyme catalysing this reaction, known as AUR1p, has long been characterised as essential and a target for antifungals, studies in other kingdoms are less well established. In recent work we identified the leishmanial orthologue and used a microsomal preparation to screen a library of compounds for inhibitory activity. This led to the discovery of the histamine H1 antagonist CF as a potential antileishmanial. Although exhibiting good activity in a mouse model of infection, CF is challenging to further optimise as reported synthetic routes are non-trivial requiring the enantioselective formation of a quaternary benzhydryl carbon centre and its subsequent alkylation with a proline derived alkyl halide which is prone to isomerisation.14,24
In this report, we have described a solution to both these problems, enabling the rapid assembly of a clemastine analogue 38l that retains the antileishmanial activity of CF but with lower host cell toxicity. Intriguingly this lower toxicity is mirrored by an enhancement in the selectivity of 38l in binding to other neurotransmitter receptor subtypes. Given that CF has other activities, including a suppression of the host immune system,19,25 this relationship may be coincidental and requires further study. With good antileishmanial activity in an intramacrophage amastigote assay, analogue 38l was progressed into an in vivo infection study. Whilst CF is an oral drug, efforts to administer both CF and 38l to mice in this fashion were not successful. However, IL administration showed that 38l has comparable efficacy to CF and is, therefore, a potential therapy against CL.
Future work will now focus on the generation of analogues to further enhance activity and selectivity as well as to address the delivery challenges. These studies will be greatly simplified using the alternative structural design developed in this work. The outcomes of these efforts together with use of novel formulation technologies designed to enhance oral bioavailability are in progress and will be reported in due course.
The animal protocols for this study were approved by the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee under the number 030/17. The research was conducted in compliance with the principles stated in the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals (NIH).26
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Table S1: assay data for compounds prepared in this study; Fig. S1. Lewis acid screen for biarylcarbinol ether formation; Fig. S2: relative selectivity of clemastine fumarate 1a and analogues (R,R)-35 and 38l; methods for the synthesis of all compounds and biological procedures; copies of 1H and 13C NMR spectra for compounds assayed in this study. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4md01004c |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |