Kefan Shi‡
a,
Marliyana Aizudin‡
b,
Meilan Pan
*a and
Edison Huixiang Ang
*b
aCollege of Environment, Zhejiang University of Technology, Hangzhou, Zhejiang 310014, China. E-mail: mlpan@zjut.edu.cn
bNatural Sciences and Science Education, National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore 637616, Singapore. E-mail: edison.ang@nie.edu.sg
First published on 13th January 2025
Bionic evaporators inspired by natural plants like bamboo and mushrooms have emerged as efficient generators through water capillary evaporation. However, primitive natural evaporators cannot currently meet growing demand, and their performance limitations remain largely unexplored, presenting a substantial challenge. Through extensive experimentation and detailed simulation analysis, this study presents a precisely engineered H-type bamboo steam generator. This innovative design incorporates a unique node structure embedded with graphite flakes and an internode characterized by micro- and nanoporous channels, all achieved through streamlined carbonization. The results are striking: a water evaporation rate of 2.28 kg m−2 h−1 and a photothermal conversion efficiency of 90.2% under one-sun irradiation, outperforming comparable alternatives. This study also marks the first comprehensive simulation in COMSOL modeling water capillary evaporation, driven by the synergistic effects of photothermal graphitic layers, broad-spectrum solar absorption, and capillary microstructures. The chimney-assisted, enclosed cavity structure further enhances water capillary evaporation and thermal localization. This breakthrough not only enables efficient use of waste biomass but also advances the field of sustainable materials, opening new avenues in solar-driven steam generation.
New conceptsA new concept is proposed with the development of a precisely engineered H-type bamboo steam generator, inspired by natural plant structures such as bamboo. This innovative design incorporates a unique node structure embedded with graphite flakes and an internode featuring micro- and nanoporous channels, achieved through streamlined carbonization. Unlike traditional bionic evaporators, which struggle to meet growing demand and have limited performance insights, this design significantly enhances water evaporation rates and photothermal conversion efficiency. With a water evaporation rate of 2.28 kg m−2 h−1 and a photothermal conversion efficiency of 90.2% under one-sun irradiation, it outperforms existing alternatives. Furthermore, this study introduces the first comprehensive simulation of water capillary evaporation using COMSOL, demonstrating the synergistic effects of photothermal graphitic layers, broad-spectrum solar absorption, and capillary microstructures. The chimney-assisted, enclosed cavity structure optimizes water capillary evaporation and thermal localization. This work advances sustainable materials science by not only enabling efficient waste biomass utilization but also offering a novel approach to solar-driven steam generation, paving the way for more efficient, scalable evaporator designs. |
Prior research has delved into utilizing bamboo as sustainable photothermal material in various configurations to achieve higher photothermal conversion efficiency (PTCE) and water evaporation rates.18–20 Most of the research focuses on how to load other functional materials into bamboo colums or directly onto the surface of bamboo charcoal powder.21 For example, CS/BFs/CPPs sponge evaporator by combining chitosan (CS), bamboo fibers (BF), and carbonized pomelo peel particles (CPP) through freeze-drying yielded a water evaporation rate of 2.32 kg m−2 h−1 and a photothermal conversion efficiency (PTCE) of 89.23% under standard one-sun irradiation conditions.19 However, some studies have revealed that using the special structure of bamboo itself to make evaporators can also reach or even exceed functional materials.22,23 Zhang et al. engineered a three-dimensional (3D) carbonized bamboo (CB) at high temperature of 700 °C,24 achieving an impressive water evaporation rate of 2.03 kg m−2 h−1 with a PTCE of 90% under comparable circumstances. Despite the recent surge in studies exploring bamboo's role in steam generation, the effective utilization of its inherent characteristics—particularly its node and internode structure—to design an efficient steam generator remains an area requiring deeper investigation.
A significant challenge in achieving highly efficient and consistent solar steam evaporation lies in attaining simultaneous thermal localization and a continuous evaporation process.25 Traditional solar steam generator setups employ planar-structured solar absorbers to facilitate water evaporation and photothermal conversion but encounter challenges such as heat loss and irregular evaporation rates due to inconsistent airflow from natural air circulation.26,27 These shortcomings hinder the development of straightforward evaporators that combine effective thermal localization with spontaneous air circulation, primarily due to insufficient understanding of airflow dynamics, water vapor transport, and heat dissipation during solar evaporation.28,29 Ming et al. demonstrated that chimney-assisted convection effectively reduces vapor condensation around the evaporator, maintaining low local humidity and enhancing evaporation performance.30 Additionally, cavity structures confine heat within an enclosed space, creating a stable thermal gradient that maximizes energy efficiency.31 These insights highlight the critical roles of fluid dynamics and thermal management, particularly through chimney and cavity effects, in improving evaporation efficiency. Consequently, designing efficient steam generators that leverage these mechanisms has become an increasingly important focus in solar evaporation research.
This investigation introduces a carefully engineered bamboo steam generator developed through extensive experimentation and thorough simulation analyses. This innovative H-type generator incorporates a unique node enriched with graphite flakes and an internode characterized by inherent micro/nanoporous channels. The design, achieved through a refined carbonization process, demonstrates exceptional performance: boasting a water evaporation rate of 2.28 kg m−2 h−1 and a photothermal conversion efficiency of 90.2% under one sun irradiation, surpassing comparable alternatives. This achievement is credited to the combined effects of photothermal graphitic layers, broad solar absorption, and a structured porous framework. Notably, the chimney-assisted and enclosed cavity structures within our carbonized bamboo steam generator play pivotal roles, significantly reducing heat loss and expediting water evaporation processes.
The NGF solar absorber achieved nearly 100% light absorption across the 200–2500 nm range, indicating its superior capacity for solar steam generation (Fig. 1C). Conversely, the INPC absorbed significantly in the UV range but only 40% in visible and near-infrared spectra. NGF exhibited higher surface temperatures than INPC, reflecting its superior photothermal performance, as seen in the temperature profile graph under 1 sun irradiation (Fig. 1D). Both absorbers showed a rapid initial temperature rise with NGF outperforming INPC over time. NGF attained a maximum surface temperature (Tmax) of 330 K, compared to 312 K for INPC. Tmax for both dropped quickly to around room temperature (∼295.15 K), highlighting their light-dependent characteristics. A linear relationship was observed between absorber temperatures and irradiation intensity (1–4 sun) (Fig. 1E). NGF reached steady state faster than INPC at all intensities. Thermal infrared (IR) images (Fig. 1F) showed NGF and INPC at 4 suns both warmer from above, with INPC cooler from the side, suggesting potential for water transport. The combination of NGF and INPC showed improved thermaldistribution and a low heat loss rate of 9.9% (radiation: 5.4%, convection: 4.5%), indicating efficient thermal management (Note S1, ESI†). Therefore, the high degree of graphitization and excellent light absorption properties of NGF ensure efficient conversion of solar energy into heat, directly boosting water evaporation rates. The high thermal conductivity of NGF facilitates localized heating at the evaporator surface, minimizing heat dissipation to the surrounding environment. NGF reinforce the node's structure, providing mechanical stability during repeated use and contributing to the evaporator's long-term durability. The combination of NGF in the node and the porous channels in the internode synergistically enhances water transport and evaporation by ensuring consistent water supply to the photothermal layer. These characterizations and insights into the role of NGF their critical contribution to the high performance of evaporators.
Fig. 2 and Fig. S5 (ESI†) show three types of bamboo-inspired steam generators: H-type, T-type, and —-type. These homemade generators were tested in solar steam generation experiments (Fig. S6, ESI†), evaluating performance based on water evaporation rate, enhancement factor (EF), and photothermal conversion efficiency (PTCE) using eqn (S1–S3, ESI†). A control experiment with hollow PE foam on DI water without a solar absorber served as the baseline. Comparisons were made between the H-type generator and the T-type and —-type controls. Water mass changes were measured with an analytical balance under 1 sun irradiation for 30 minutes (Fig. 2B). The optimized H-type generator achieved a water evaporation rate of 2.28 kg m2 h−1, surpassing the control (0.74 kg m2 h−1), T-type (1.82 kg m2 h−1), and —-type (0.78 kg m2 h−1) by 3.08, 1.25, and 2.92 times, respectively. Dark-condition evaporation rate was 0.35 kg m2 h−1, which was subtracted from solar measurements to isolate sunlight effects. EF values for H-type, T-type, and —-type generators against the control were 3.39, 2.71, 1.87, and 1.10, respectively (Fig. 2C). Fig. 2D shows evaporation rates under varying solar conditions (1–4 suns), with the H-type generator showing significant increases from 2.55 kg m2 h−1 to 4.92 kg m2 h−1 at 2, 3, and 4 suns, respectively (Fig. S7, ESI†). The H-type generator achieved a high evaporation rate of 2.28 kg m2 h−1 and a PTCE of 90.2%, which is much higher than reported bamboo-based generators, including —-type and T-type steam generators (Fig. 2E and Table S1, ESI†). Moreover, it also surpassed the other functional materials in —-type and T-type steam generators (Fig. 2F and Table S2, ESI†), indicating the superior performance. Its durability was confirmed with minimal mass loss after 25 reuse cycles (Fig. S8, ESI†).
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (A) Schematic illustration of H-type, T-type and —-type steam generators according to the natural structure of bamboo. (B) Cumulative mass change of DI water against time under different conditions: water in dark (dark), water under sunlight irradiation (blank), water with PE foam (control), and different steam generators under 1 sun irradiation. (C) Enhancement factor graph and (D) water evaporation rate performances under different simulated solar irradiation (sun) using H-type, T-type and —-type steam generators. (E) Comparison of evaporation rate capabilities in different modification strategies for bamboo-graphite as steam generators. (F) Comparison of evaporation rate capabilities of this work steam generator against other previously documented steam generators under 1 sun irradiation (Table S1, ESI†). |
Solar water evaporation was tested on simulated seawater with NaCl concentrations of 1.5, 2.5, and 3.5 wt% (Fig. S9, ESI†). Higher salt concentrations led to reduced mass change and evaporation rates due to salt accumulation. The H-type steam generator demonstrated self-cleaning with salt crystallizing during the day and dissolving at night (Fig. S10, ESI†).34,35 Long-term stability was assessed by exposing the generator to 8 h of solar irradiation and 16 h of darkness, showing effective salt dissolution due to the 3D hierarchical structure of the bamboo. Desalination efficiency was tested with the H-type prototype on 3.5 wt% seawater, with significant reductions in metal ion concentrations, meeting WHO standards (Fig. S11, ESI†).36 The H-type, T-type, and —-type generators showed PTCEs of 90.2%, 84.4%, and 90.4%, respectively, with the H-type outperforming the control by fivefold (Note S2, ESI†). Moreover, the evaporation efficiency of the H-type bamboo steam generator was tested under actual sunlight over three days to evaluate its performance under realistic conditions (Fig. S12, ESI†). Eight modular H-type bamboo evaporators were tested under actual sunlight over three days, achieving a combined evaporation efficiency of 10.63 kg m−2 d−1 at a solar intensity of 0.75 suns, demonstrating its adaptability to fluctuating sunlight conditions and ability to sustain high evaporation rates. Additionally, the potential challenge of selective absorption in the H-type evaporator design was examined under non-vertical solar irradiation. Even at a 30° angle of incidence, the evaporator retained approximately 80% of its performance, highlighting its resilience to varying solar angles (Fig. S13, ESI†).
The optimization of H-type solar generators involved adjusting the chimney and cavity heights (Fig. 3A), where T and B denote the top and bottom heights of chimney relative to cavity, with L being node thickness (∼0.2 cm). Mass changes were measured with an electronic balance, and temperatures were monitored with sensors (T0–T4). Evaporation rates increased linearly with chimney height but decreased due to reduced heat exchange at excessive heights. Optimal performance was achieved with a top height (T) of 4 cm, yielding a maximum evaporation rate of 1.77 kg m−2 h−1 (Fig. 3B). Similarly, adjusting the bottom height (B) while keeping the top height fixed at 1 cm showed that the best rate of 2.12 kg m−2 h−1 was at a bottom height of 3 cm (Fig. 3C). The NGF and INPC segments enhance the H-type solar steam generator through light-to-heat conversion and water transport, driven by the chimney and cavity structure.
To delve deeper into the phenomena of chimney and cavity effect in an H-type steam generator, we employed a finite-element method (FEM)-based 3D model, COMSOL 6.1 Multiphysics, to analyze the flow field in conjunction with temperature data (Note S3 and Fig. S14, 15, ESI†).37,38 The chimney's higher temperature relative to ambient air creates a pressure differential (Δp), generating upward airflow that accelerates evaporation by removing moisture from the surface (Fig. S16, 17 and Movie S2, ESI†). Dalton's law supports that increased pressure variance speeds up evaporation. Modeling showed that a 4 cm chimney height optimized temperature difference, pressure, and airflow, boosting evaporation rates (Fig. 3D).39 However, higher chimneys reduced heat exchange velocity, diminishing evaporation rates. An optimal cavity bottom height of 3 cm improved heat retention by minimizing heat loss (Fig. 3E, Fig. S18, 19 and Movie S3, ESI†).40 This retention was observed through smaller temperature differences between cavity sensors T2 and T3 compared to larger differences between chimney sensors T1 and T0, highlighting the cavity's role in enhancing PTCE.
The study involved simulations of light-to-heat and water transport within an H-type steam generator, specifically within an oval-shaped microstructure channel and cavity (Fig. 4A), which confirmed a laminar flow structure. The simulation approach was guided by a backstep geometry tutorial using the Navier-Stokes equations for incompressible fluid flow (eqn S5 and S6, ESI†).41 The software was utilized to conduct a laminar flow simulation of the steam generator, computing temperature, pressure, and velocity during the flow (eqn S7 and S8, ESI†). In the simulation (Fig. 4B), temperature sensors (T1 and T2) were strategically placed on the NGF surface: T1 at the upper end and T2 at the lower end, with the center of the NGF surface defined as 0 cm and a radius of 0.7 cm. Upon exposure to simulated sunlight, we monitored the computed surface temperature distribution, including temperature profiles relative to longitudinal height and lateral radius length. A notable temperature increase was observed at the center of the NGF compared to the INPC counterpart. This difference is attributed to factors such as the higher density of layered graphite flakes on the NGF surface and a broader solar absorption bandwidth, both of which enhance the photothermal capability of the NGF. Furthermore, heat loss along the axial direction of the NGF surface was observed (Fig. 4C). The temperature at the upper NGF surface (T1) was computed to be 330.2 K, while the lower surface temperature (T2) was 326.2 K, indicating a 4.0 K temperature decrease. Over time, a linear relationship between temperature distribution on the NGF surface and its lateral diameter of 1.4 cm was evident. Additionally, computational modeling of NGF channels (Fig. 4D) revealed steady-state evaporation occurring at various channel sites (e.g., interlayer, adjacent, and surface) of the NGF, as shown in Fig. 4E. The difference in atmospheric pressure between the upper and lower sections of the NGF facilitated the upward movement of water molecules, thereby increasing the rate of evaporation through the NGF channels (Fig. 4F). XPS data (Table S2, ESI†) reveal that the NGF sample has a high content of oxygenated functional groups, enhancing its hydrophilicity.
Raman measurements (Table S3, ESI†) show a low ID/IG ratio in NGF, indicating fewer defects and a more ordered structure, which contributes to higher water evaporation rate. INPC's oval-shaped microstructures, simulated under sunlight, were analyzed for flow fields and evaporation rates. The upper INPC sections exhibited photothermal effects, while the lower sections showed efficient water transport due to capillary action. Highest evaporation rates were noted at the inlet and outlet of the oval micropore channels. Contact angle analysis (Fig. S20, ESI†) confirmed NGF and INPC's superior wetting and evaporation rates. Computational analysis (Fig. 4G) showed a clear correlation between temperature, INPC length, and relative humidity (RH), with higher temperatures and shorter lengths leading to increased evaporation rates due to decreased RH.
Combined with the results of experiments and simulations, The enhanced performance of the H-type structure can be attributed to the synergistic effects of its chimney-assisted and cavity-enclosed design. These features improve spontaneous airflow, minimize heat dissipation, and enhance thermal localization, thereby accelerating water evaporation. The —-type structure, characterized by its planar configuration, demonstrated the lowest evaporation rate due to its high susceptibility to heat loss and limited airflow facilitation. The T-type structure, which introduces a vertical alignment to the evaporator but lacks the enclosed cavity design of the H-type, performed better than the —-type but still fell short in achieving optimal thermal management and water transport efficiency. By contrast, the H-type structure integrates the advantages of both chimney and cavity effects, ensuring efficient heat retention, reduced heat loss, and consistent evaporation rates. The optimized airflow dynamics within the chimney further boost evaporation by facilitating the removal of water vapor from the surface. Additionally, the hierarchical node and internode structures of the H-type bamboo contribute to enhanced water transport and light absorption, further improving its photothermal performance.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4mh01667j |
‡ Kefan Shi and Marliyana Aizudin contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |