Abdul Kalam
Azad
a,
Nedal Y.
Abu-Thabit
*a and
Mahmoud H.
Abu Elella
b
aChemical Engineering Department, Jubail Industrial College, P.O. BOX: 10099, Jubail Industrial City 31961, Saudi Arabia. E-mail: abuthabit_nidal@yahoo.com; Tel: +966 13 340 5400
bChemistry Department, Faculty of Science, Cairo University, Giza 12613, Egypt
First published on 21st April 2025
The industrial revolution and the frequent crude oil spills have caused tremendous contamination of the natural water resources with oily waste. Superwetting textiles have been proposed as advanced functional materials for selective oil separation from oily wastewater. Superwetting textiles have been fabricated by engineering smart coatings that allow for the modified textile's optimal surface roughness and chemical composition. During the past decade, polydopamine (PDA) has been proposed as a sustainable, biodegradable, and biomimetic coating for the fabrication of superwetting textiles with superhydrophobic and/or underwater superoleophobic properties. PDA coatings offer advantages including a simple coating procedure in a wide pH range, use of various organic/inorganic oxidants, high adhesion strength to various substrates, increased surface roughness of the coated substrates, and diverse post-functionalization via different ionic/covalent interactions. Thus, bioinspired, sustainable and durable superwetting textiles have been designed and fabricated by controlling the surface roughness and the surface energy of the PDA-coated textiles. This review highlights the recent advances in fabricating superwetting PDA-coated textiles for the separation of various oil/water mixtures. Two classes of superwetting textiles are discussed, including superhydrophobic (SHB) and superhydrophilic/underwater superoleophobic (SHL/UWSOB) PDA-coated textiles. In each case, the discussion focuses on the fabrication methods, coating procedures, separation performance, recyclability, and enhanced mechanical and chemical durability due to the synergistic effect of the deposited and/or functionalized PDA coating. The discussion includes the separation of emulsified mixtures, current challenges, proposed solutions, and future perspectives of PDA-coated textiles for practical and large-scale oil/water separations.
Sustainability spotlightDuring the past two decades, developing superwetting materials has emerged as an advanced technology for the efficient separation of oil/water mixtures. Among various special wettability materials, textiles and fabrics have been proposed as flexible porous membranes for the treatment of oily wastewater and crude oil spills. Superwetting textiles modified with polydopamine (PDA) coatings are regarded as a sustainable class of smart multifunctional materials for the treatment of stratified and emulsified oil/water mixtures. PDA coatings offer advantages such as low cost, versatility, biodegradability, and simple fabrication that avoids the use of harsh chemicals/conditions. The PDA coating plays a critical role in the fabrication of durable superwetting textiles by enhancing the adhesion and surface roughness and offering diverse post-functionalization with low/high surface energy materials. |
Special wettability materials have superhydrophobic or superhydrophilic superwetting surfaces for liquids on liquid/air/solid or water/oil/solid interfaces with a water contact angle (WCA) greater than 150° or less than 10°, respectively.17,18 During the past two decades, special wettability materials with superhydrophobic (SHB) or superhydrophilic and underwater superoleophobic (SHL/UWSOB) surfaces have been proposed as advanced functional materials for the separation of emulsified and stratified oil/water mixtures.19–21 Typically, the construction of superwetting surfaces can be achieved by tuning the surface roughness and surface energy.22,23 The common substrates that have been modified as superwetting materials for oil/water separation include fabrics and textiles,24–26 sponges,27–30 metal meshes,31–34 and polymeric membranes.35–38 Compared to other substrates, woven and nonwoven textiles have been proposed for efficient separation of oil/water mixtures in harsh environments due to their low cost, high porosity, high permeability, high flexibility, good mechanical durability, and corrosion resistance.39,40 Unlike superwetting sponges, which have been mainly employed as absorption materials for oil/water separation,27 superwetting textiles have been utilized as filter membranes to separate oil/water mixtures by a filtration strategy that is beneficial for continuous and large-scale separations.41–43
The surface wettability of various textiles has been modified by using different strategies such as grafting, dip-coating, spray-coating, chemical vapor deposition, solution immersion, and in situ polymerization. The fabrication of superhydrophobic textiles has been achieved by using a wide range of materials/chemicals/techniques, which aim to: (1) increase the surface roughness,44 and (2) reduce the surface free energy of the modified fabrics. The presence of strong adhesion between the deposited materials (e.g., nanoparticles) and the surface of the modified textiles plays an important role in making durable superwetting textiles with superior mechanical abrasion resistance, good recyclability, and corrosion resistance.45,46 Good adhesion can be promoted via strong inter/intramolecular ionic interactions, covalent bonds, or ionic/covalent crosslinks.47,48
Polydopamine coatings, invented by Lee and Messersmith in 2007, have been employed extensively for fabricating various durable superwetting substrates, including fabrics and textiles.49–51 In general, the PDA coating is prepared by chemical oxidative polymerization in the absence (pH = 8.5) or presence (neutral/acidic conditions) of organic/inorganic oxidants.52–54 The main requirement for chemical oxidative polymerization is the presence of an electron donor atom (e.g., O, N, or S) with a high oxidation tendency to induce the initiation of the chain growth via the formation of cation/cation radical species.55 Chemical oxidative polymerization has been employed for the fabrication of electrically conducting polymers such as polyaniline, polypyrrole and polythiophene.56–60 The oxidative polymerization of polydopamine is depicted in Fig. 1A. The versatility of the polydopamine coating is due to its ease of application as well as its ability to adhere to various surfaces (metals, plastics, ceramics, etc.) by a simple solution immersion and in situ deposition process.61–63 Depending on the modification process, materials used and the chemical composition of the textile surface, the adhesion of polydopamine to the fabric surface can be achieved via different surface interaction mechanisms including metal coordination, Michael-type additions and/or Schiff-base formations, hydrogen bonding, and π–π stacking,48,52,64–67 as shown in Fig. 1B. This review highlights the most recent literature studies related to the fabrication of superwetting textiles modified with polydopamine coatings for oil/water separation applications. The first part of the review is related to SHB textiles, the second part is devoted to the SHL/UWSOB textiles, and the final section discusses the separation of emulsions. In addition, the recent related studies have been presented and summarized in Tables 1 and 2.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Polymerization and interaction mechanisms of dopamine. (A) Polydopamine formation: the copolymer consisting of 5,6-dihydroxyindole (DHI) and dopamine. (B) Diverse interactions of dopamine and DHI.64 |
Type of fabric/textile | Modification materials | Optimum coating parameters | Highest oil permeation flux (L m−2 h−1) | Separation efficiency (%) (recyclability) | Durability features | Ref. | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Surface roughness | Surface energy | DA conc. (mg mL−1) | Buffer | Time (h) | Temp. (°C) | Other materials | |||||
a Abbreviations: T = Tris-buffer; P = phosphate buffer; R. T. = room temperature; PDA NPs = polydopamine nanoparticles; SDA = structure directing agent; SiO2 = silicon dioxide; NH4OH = ammonium hydroxide; CuSO4 = copper sulphate; AgNO3 = silver nitrate; FeCl3·6H2O = ferric chloride. | |||||||||||
PET | PDA NPs | PFDTS | 2 | T/P | 20 | 35 | — | — | — | *Resistance to abrasion and UV radiation | 68 |
Blended fabric (35% cotton, 65% polyester) | PDA NPs | ODA | 1 | T–HCl | 24 | 60 | Folic acid as SDA | — | 97.1 | *Resistance to wear and NaCl solution (3.5 wt%) | 69 |
Cotton fabric, polyester gloves | PDA microcapsules | ODA or ODT | 0.5 | T–HCl | 12 | R. T. | — | — | — | *Mechanically induced self-healing superhydrophobicity | 70 |
*Resistance to stretching, compression, friction and mechanical washing | |||||||||||
Cotton | PDA NPs | — | 10 mM | T–HCl | 24 | R. T. | CuSO4 | — | — | *Durable antibacterial and sticky superhydrophobic properties | 71 |
Cotton fabric | PDA NPs | — | 0.02 g | TEOS-HCl/HMDS | 24 | q | SiO2 | 4000 | 99.9 | *Excellent mechanical stability | 72 |
*Resistance to abrasion and UV irradiation | |||||||||||
*Resistance to high temperature boiling water and organic solvent | |||||||||||
Cotton, polyester, wool fabric | PDA NPs | HDTMS | 0.1 g/10 mL | — | 50 | 12 | — | — | — | *Self-healing ability | 73 |
*Resistance to abrasion and washing (20 cycles) | |||||||||||
*Coated fabrics achieved 80% transmittance | |||||||||||
Cotton | PDA NPs/PEI | — | 60 mg mL | T–HCl | 35 | 14 | Borax, TA | — | >98 | *Resistance to high temperature degradation | 74 |
*Resistance to abrasion and washing | |||||||||||
*Flame retardant and self-extinguishing ability | |||||||||||
Tetra-copolyester and polypropylene | PDA NPs | PFDT | 2 | T–HCl | 25 | 12 | SiO2, AgNO3 | — | >90 | *Excellent stability and recyclability | 75 |
*Employed in oil/water separation, smart oil engineering, microfluidic devices | |||||||||||
Cotton fabric | PDA NPs | ODA | 2 | Sodium perborate (PBS) | 90 | 50 | FeCl3 | — | >96 | *Resistance to harsh environments | 76 |
*Outstanding recyclable and self-cleaning performance | |||||||||||
Polylactic acid non-woven fabric | PDA NPs | (PVDF-HFP) | 2 | T–HCl | 20 | R. T. | FeCl2·4H2O, FeCl3·6H2O | — | 99.5 | *Excellent recyclability and higher absorption capacity | 77 |
*Higher surface stability and self-cleaning ability | |||||||||||
*Resistance to abrasion | |||||||||||
*Ability to separate floated oil due to its magnetic properties | |||||||||||
Blended fabric (35% cotton, 65% polyester) | PDA NPs | ODT | 8 | — | 4 | 25 | Sodium periodate | 4500 | >97 | *Resistance to UV irradiation, hot water and acetone | 78 |
*Resistance to abrasion and fouling | |||||||||||
Blended fabric (50% nylon 56 and 50% cotton) | PDA NPs | DMPA, POSS | 0.3 g | T & T–HCl | 24 | 45 | MPMDS | — | — | *Excellent mechanical and chemical stability | 79 |
*Outstanding durability and self-cleaning ability | |||||||||||
PET, cotton, PP and blended fabric of cotton (35%) and PET (65%) | PDA NPs | 1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorodecanethiol | 2.0 | T–HCl | 2 | — | AgNO3 | — | — | *Excellent oil–water separation and self-cleaning ability | 80 |
Pristine fabric | PDA NPs | PDMS | 80 mg/40 mL | Alkaline | 24 | R. T. | SiO2 | — | 95 | *Anti-fouling and self-cleaning ability | 81 |
*Resistance to corrosive solution, organic solvent, UV irradiation and washing | |||||||||||
Other materials | PDA NPs | OTEOS | 0.4 g | T–HCl | 10 | R. T. | SiO2 | — | — | *Excellent durability and mechanical stability | 82 |
*Resistance to harsh environments and UV irradiation | |||||||||||
Cotton | PDA NPs | n-DDT | 2.0 | 25% NH4OH | 24 | 60 | AgNO3, CuSo4 | 72![]() |
>99 | *High oil absorption capacity | 83 |
14![]() |
*Stable surface after 100 separation cycles | ||||||||||
Cotton | PDA NPs | DDT | 2.0 | T–HCl | 24 | R. T. | FeCl3·6H2O | — | >98 | *Improved thermal stability and excellent photocatalytic activity | 84 |
Cotton | PDA NPs | SA | 2.0 | T | 4 | 25 | CuSO4·5H2O | — | — | *Excellent UV protection and solar-induced rapid self-healing properties | 85 |
*Excellent mechanical and chemical stability | |||||||||||
Polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) | PDA NPs | HS(CH2)11CH3/HS(CH2)10COOH (Thiol) | 2.0 | T–HCl | 24 | 40 | AgNO3 | 11![]() |
99.2% (light oil/water mixture) | *Excellent durability and reusability | 86 |
96.5% (heavy oil/water mixture) | *Rapid stimulus responsibility, superior wettability switching ability, comparable permeability and high separation efficiency | ||||||||||
*Energy-saving separation of multiphase oil/water mixtures and emulsions | |||||||||||
Cotton | PDA NPs | PDMS | 100 mg/50 mL | T | 60 | 12 | CuSO4·5H2O, ZIF-8 nanomaterials | — | — | *Excellent photothermal antibacterial activity against E. coli and S. aureus under near-infrared (NIR) light irradiation | 87 |
*Durability and self-cleaning ability | |||||||||||
Cotton | PDA NPs | Hexa decyl tri methoxy silane | 2 | T–HCl | 12 hours stirring/24 freeze drying | R. T. | FeCl3·6H2O | 8561.02 | 99.5 | *Excellent mechanical and chemical durability | 88 |
*Suitable for large scale oil-water separation | |||||||||||
*Significant photocatalytic properties | |||||||||||
Woolen felt | PDA NPs | DDT | 0.01 | T–HCl | 14 | R. T. | AgNO3, TiO2 | — | — | *Low cost, bio-degradable and self-extinguishing properties | 89 |
PP fibre | PDA NPs | 3-Aminopropyltriethoxysilane (APTES) | 200 mg L−1 | T–HCl | 12 h reaction/5 h immersion | R. T. | MXene nanosheets, polypyrrole (PPy), pH responsive polymer (PDM) | — | — | *Excellent pH responsive membrane driven by sunlight | 90 |
*Excellent stability, corrosion resistance and recyclability | |||||||||||
Cotton | PDA NPs | PDMS | 2 | — | 12 | R. T. | MWCNT | 16.21 m3 m−2 h−1 | 99 | *Resistance to acid, alkali and abrasion test | 91 |
*Self-healing ability on the surface | |||||||||||
Nylon 56 | PDA NPs | Trimethylaminomethane, tetraallyl silane | 400 mg/200 mL | — | 0.5 | 60 | 3-Mercaptopropionic acid, methyl siloxane-dimethyl siloxane copolymer (mercapto) | — | >98 | *Excellent self-cleaning and anti-fouling properties | 92 |
*Strong candidate for environmental and industrial applications |
Type of fabric/textile | Surface roughness | Optimum coating parameters | Water permeation flux (L m−2 h−1) | Pressure (MPa) | Separation efficiency (%) (recyclability) | Durability features | Ref. | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
DA conc. (mg mL−1) | Buffer | Time (h) | Temp. (°C) | Other materials | |||||||
Cotton | PDA NPs | 4.0 | T–HCl | 24 | R. T. | Chitosan | 15![]() ![]() |
— | >99 | *Outstanding chemical and mechanical resistance | 93 |
Polyester fabric | PDA NPs and PEI | 2.0 | T | 7 | — | Sodium periodate (NaIO4), hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) and copper sulfate (CuSO4) | >115![]() |
Gravity | >99.2 | *Resistance to extreme environments and long term durability | 94 |
Cotton | PDA NPs and TiO2 | 120 | T–HCl | — | — | (3-Aminopropyl) triethoxysilane (KH550, 99%), copper sulfate pentahydrate (CuSO4·5H2O), polyethylene glycol (PEG) | 32![]() |
Gravity | 99.9 | *Resistance to salt solution, acids and abrasion | 95 |
Poly(arylene ether nitrile) (PEN) nanofibrous mat | PDA NPs | — | T–HCl | 4 | R. T. | Hexagonal boron nitride (h-BN), CuSO4, H2O2 | 588.1 (emulsion) | 0.04 | >99 | *Resistance to harsh environments and antifouling ability | 96 |
8400 (oil/water mixture) | |||||||||||
Thermoplastic polyurethane | PDA NPs | — | T | — | — | Multi-walled carbon nanotubes | 4195–7240 | 0.05 | 99.9 | *Enhanced mechanical properties, thermal stability and electrical conductivity | 97 |
*Excellent anti-oil adhesion properties | |||||||||||
Poly acrylonitrile fibre (PAN) | PDA nano spheres | 40 mg | T–HCl | 7 | 25 | — | 1570 L m−2 h−1 bar−1 | — | 96.1 | *Good separation efficiency and durability | 98 |
Pristine material | PDA nano spheres | 0.5 g/10 mL | — | 48 | R. T. | AgNO3 | — | — | 99.3 | *Outstanding cycle performance and antibacterial activity | 99 |
Polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) | PDA NPs | 2.0 | T–HCl | 24 | 40 | AgNO3 and thiols | 2500 | Gravity | >99 | *Superwettability and superior pH responsibility | 86 |
Micro cellulose ester membrane (MCEM) | PDA NPs | 0.2g/100 mL | T–HCl | 12 | R. T. | HAP, SiO2, Tetraethoxysilane(TEOS) | 2000–7000 | — | 90.90 | *Improved tensile strength and mechanical stability | 100 |
*Resistance to acidic/alkaline/salt solutions | |||||||||||
*Separation flux of light oil 3000 L (m2·h)−1 | |||||||||||
*Oil discharge rate of heavy oil can reach 98.95% | |||||||||||
Bacterial cellulose (BC) | PDA NPs | 0.46 g/150 mL | T | 24 | R. T. | TiO2, sodium alginate | 7428–8774 (heavy oil) | — | >99 | *Low cost, non-toxic and eco friendly | 101 |
9597–10![]() |
*Excellent anti-pollution and photo catalytic properties | ||||||||||
Cotton | PDA NPs | 5 mg mL−1 | T–HCl | 1 h sonication/4 h immersion/24 | R. T. | Carbon nanotubes | 10![]() |
Gravity | >99.8 | *Outstanding cationic dye adsorption capacity | 102 |
*Excellent stability and durability under harsh conditions | |||||||||||
Cotton | PDA NPs | 4 | T–HCl | 24 | R. T. | SiO2, TEOS | 8100–34![]() |
Gravity | >99 | *Ultra-low adhesion towards crude oil | 103 |
*Continuous separation of crude oil/water (15 times) and toluene/water (100 times) |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Schematic illustration of various wettability states: (a) an illustration of wetting models based on Young's model (b), Wenzel's model (c), and Cassie–Baxter's model (d); measuring the advancing and receding angles by (e) tilting the substrate; and (f) changing the droplet volume by gradually introducing or extracting liquid from a sessile droplet, ref. 108. |
The wetting phenomena have been described using Young, Wenzel, and Cassie–Baxter models. Thomas Young introduced the concept of the CA for the solid/liquid interface. He discussed the cohesion of superficial particles at both solid and liquid surfaces. Additionally, once the tension at the interfaces reaches equilibrium, as illustrated in Fig. 2c, the correlation can be represented by Young's equation,26 as indicated in eqn (1):
cos θY = (γSG − γSL)/γLG | (1) |
cos θW = R cos θY | (2) |
Increasing surface roughness and reducing feature size can cause a liquid droplet to be suspended above the rough surface structure, trapping small amounts of air beneath the liquid in pits or grooves. This phenomenon was explained by the Cassie–Baxter model according to the following eqn (3) and Fig. 2e:
cos![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | (3) |
Contact angle hysteresis (CAH) refers to the difference between the advancing contact angle (θa) and the receding contact angle (θr) of the droplet. θa is the angle generated as the droplet spreads on the surface, whereas θr is created when the droplet retracts from the surface. Contact angle hysteresis exists because contact lines usually do not slide freely. Real surfaces are amorphous, deformable, rough, and show different crystalline orientations, leading to the observed contact angle hysteresis.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Schematic illustration of the fabrication of a superhydrophobic fabric with a micro-nanostructure via a novel mussel-inspired approach, and a superhydrophobic cloth boat made from the fabric for self-driven oil spill cleanup (A), reproduced with permission from ref. 69. Regeneration of hydrophobicity through mechanical stimulation (B) and mechanism in the self-healing process during compression (C), reproduced with permission from ref. 70. |
Liu et al. fabricated self-healing superhydrophobic cotton fabrics, coated with PDA microcapsules, by using a one-step modification process.70 The pristine cotton fabric was dipped into an emulsion containing a low surface energy material (ODA or octadecanethiol ODT), Tris–HCl buffer, and DA (0.5 mg mL−1) for a total period of 12 hours. After plasma treatment, the modified superhydrophobic fabric lost its hydrophobicity and became hydrophilic, as shown in Fig. 3B and C. However, upon mechanical action on the fabric (compression/stretching), the self-healing property was demonstrated with a full recovery of its superhydrophobic nature. This self-healing property was attributed to the release of the low surface energy materials (ODA or ODT) embedded in the coated PDA microcapsules (Fig. 3B and C).
Guo et al. reported a simple one-pot method to fabricate a robust superhydrophobic cotton fabric by the solution immersion method.72 The surface roughness was achieved by the combined effect of PDA and silicon dioxide (SiO2) through the copolymerization process at room temperature and the lower surface energy was attained by the presence of methyl groups on the PDA/SiO2-coated superhydrophobic fabric. The modified fabric exhibited a separation efficiency of 99.9% and a permeation flux of ∼4000 L m−2 h−1 with a stable performance even after 20 separation cycles. The modified fabric showed excellent mechanical durability for various tests (abrasion, peeling, and ultrasonic treatment), as shown in Fig. 4A–D. The functionalized fabrics showed high durability in harsh chemical environments, UV irradiation, and boiling water (Fig. 4E–H).
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 (A) Photographs showing the abrasion process. (B) Contact angle and sliding angle of the superhydrophobic fabric after each abrasion cycle. The optical images of the static water droplets (5 μL) after each abrasion cycle are shown in the insets. (C) Photographs showing the tear test process and water droplets (dyed with crystal violet) on the fabric surface after the test. (D) Contact angle and sliding angle of the superhydrophobic fabric after each tear test cycle. The optical images of the static water droplets (5 μL) after each cycle are shown in the insets. (E) Photograph of the superhydrophobic PDA@SiO2 coated cotton fabric immersed in boiling water. (F) A stable, silver mirror-like phenomenon of the fabric immersed in boiling water. (G) Photograph of water (dyed with crystal violet) standing on the fabric treated in boiling water for 5 min. Optical image of the static water droplets (5 μL) after 5 min of boiling-water treatment is shown in the inset. (H) Water contact angle and sliding angle of the tested fabric after each 5 min boiling-water treatment. Optical images of the static water droplets (5 μL) after each 5 min boiling-water treatment are shown in the insets, reproduced with permission from ref. 72. |
Luo et al., reported the fabrication of a flame retardant superhydrophobic polyethylene imine (PEI) grafted cotton fabric coated with the biologically derived materials of tannic acid (TA), borax, and PDA by a dip-coating method,74 as shown in Fig. 5A. Borax was utilized to attain the flame-retardant property. However, when it comes into contact with water during washing, the borax will dissolve. Hence, TA was used to make a complexation with borax with the additional benefit of oxygen-free radical scavenging and carbonization ability during combustion. The functionalized cotton fabric displayed a WCA of 153.3° ± 1.2°, a WSA of 9° ± 0.8°, and an oil/water separation efficiency of >98% after 30 cycles. The residual content during thermal studies at 800 °C under nitrogen and oxygen atmospheres is about 48.9% and 27.9%, respectively, clearly showing the improved thermal stability of the modified fabric as depicted in Fig. 6A–D.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Schematic illustration for the preparation of superhydrophobic cotton fabrics: (A) TA/borax coating, reproduced with permission from ref. 74; CF/PDA/FeOOH/DDT (B), reproduced with permission from ref. 79; CF with aligned Cu(OH)2 nanoneedles (C), reproduced with permission from ref. 78. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Digital photographs of char residues of (A) pristine cotton and (B) TA/B@PDA cotton fabrics after CCT. (C) THR and (D) HRR of cotton samples, reproduced with permission from ref. 74; illustrations of fabric with reactive red dye powder under rinsing with water: (E) original cotton fabric and (F) Fe/PDA/ODA cotton fabric, reproduced with permission from ref. 5. |
Cheng et al. deposited β-FeOOH nanorods on the PDA-coated cotton fabric by an in situ hydrothermal process to provide roughness on the surface84 (Fig. 5B). Superhydrophobicity (WCA ∼ 151°) and lipophilicity (OCA ∼ 0°) were achieved by the addition of 1-DDT on the PDA/β-FeOOH deposited cotton fabric to reduce the surface energy. The modified fabric exhibited higher oil–water separation efficiency for all types of oils, which is greater than 98% after 50 cycles. Enhanced thermal stability and excellent photocatalytic performance after 5 cycles were observed in the modified fabric due to the development of an even layer of β-FeOOH nanorods on the PDA-coated fabric.
Belal et al. synthesized copper hydroxide nanoneedles on the PDA-coated cotton fabric by the solution immersion process83 (Fig. 5C). In situ polymerization of DA was carried out on the cotton fabric, followed by the addition of Ag nanoparticles (reduction) and Cu nanoparticles (oxidation), which endowed the surface with roughness. Thereafter, the low surface energy material of n-dodecanethiol (n-DDT) was coated on the functionalized fabric to achieve superhydrophobicity. The functionalized fabric exhibited a higher WCA of 168° together with a higher oil–water separation efficiency of above 99% after 100 cycles. The attained values of WCA > 166° after the solvent immersion (32 days) and exposure to acidic/basic conditions (48 hours) reveal water repellency and stability of the functionalized fabric.
Yan et al. reported a two-step procedure for fabricating the PDA-coated superhydrophobic cotton fabric grafted with ODA through a Schiff base reaction in the presence of FeCl3 by the solution immersion method.76 The modified fabric showed excellent stability in harsh environments of varied pH, laundering, and organic solvents, with a WCA > 150° and WSA < 14°. However, it shows poor acid resistance due to the hydrolysis of amino groups in ODA and poor resistance to carbon tetrachloride (CCl4) as the ODA will be leached out in CCl4. The functionalized fabric showed an oil/water separation efficiency of above 99% after 20 cycles. As illustrated in Fig. 6E and F, the functionalized fabric showed self-cleaning properties with good mechanical durability.
Chen and Guo fabricated the PDA-coated superhydrophobic fabric composed of a polyester (65%) and cotton (35%) blend by the solution immersion method.78 The initial step involved forming a PDA coating via oxidation with sodium periodate, resulting in a modified textile characterized by hierarchical surface roughness. In the second step, superhydrophobicity was achieved by the incorporation of low surface energy ODT molecules. The functionalized fabric showed excellent superhydrophobic and self-cleaning properties with a WCA of 154° and a WSA of 9.5°. The modified fabric showed a separation efficiency of greater than 97% and a permeation flux of 4500 L m−2 h−1 even after 20 absorption/squeezing cycles.
Wang et al. employed a solution immersion method and thiol–ene click reaction to fabricate a superhydrophobic fabric composed of a blend of 50% cotton fiber and 50% nylon-56 fiber for oil–water separation with a self-cleaning ability.79 The modified fabric was prepared by immersing the PDA-coated fabric into the mercaptopropylmethyl dimethoxy silane (MPMDS) under prescribed conditions. Thereafter, superhydrophobicity was achieved by treating the mercapto-modified fabric with a mixture of hexadecyl mercaptan, octavinyl-POSS, and 2,2-dimethoxy-2-phenylacetophenone (DMPA) to provide low surface energy along with the micro–nano rough surface. The modified fabric showed WCA and WSA of 162° and 8°, respectively, with an excellent oil–water separation capacity. The durability of the modified fabric was evaluated by exposing the sample to mechanical abrasion, UV irradiation for 16 hours, immersion in an organic solvent for 24 hours, immersion in varying pH solutions (1 to 13) for 48 hours, and a laundering test for 4.5 hours. The results from the formed tests showed that the modified fabric did not lose its hydrophobicity with the WCA > 150° and WSA < 15°, which revealed the durability of the superhydrophobic fabric.
Xu et al. fabricated different PDA-coated superhydrophobic fabrics by using oxygen-induced polymerization of DA and the solution immersion method.80 Deposition of PDA and silver nanoparticles provided the surface roughness, and further superhydrophobicity was achieved by the incorporation of 1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorodecanethiol to attain the rough hierarchical structure and low surface energy. The modified fabrics showed WCA > 150° and WSA < 10° with excellent oil–water separation and self-cleaning ability.
Dong et al. fabricated the eco-friendly, solar-induced self-healing superhydrophobic cotton fabric by the solution immersion and dip-coating methods.85 An activator (CuSO4/H2O2) was used to deposit PDA onto the cotton fabric to attain a stable and uniform rough surface. Stearic acid (SA) with a concentration of 0.1 wt% was employed to reduce the surface energy due to its long alkyl chain. The modified fabric exhibited a WCA of 162° and a WSA of 7.8° with an oil–water separation efficiency of ∼100% after 5 cycles. Durability and stability of the modified fabric were evaluated by an abrasion test for 1000 cycles, a laundering test for 5 cycles, and immersion in acidic/basic/alkaline solution for 24 hours, showing that the modified fabric did not lose its superhydrophobicity with the WCA > 150°. Furthermore, UV transmittance is <1% for the modified fabric and recovers its superhydrophobicity after 6 cycles of plasma treatment and light irradiation. The above results reveal the UV protection and self-healing properties of the modified fabric.
Zhu et al., prepared the antibacterial composite cotton fabric by the dip-coating method.87 Surface roughness was created by self-polymerized PDA NPs, and the antimicrobial effect was attained by the in situ growth of ZIF-8 nanomaterials, which act as a photo thermal agent, followed by incorporating PDMS to reduce the surface energy through the dip-coating process on cotton fabrics. The prepared composite fabric shows a WCA of 153° at 1 wt% PDMS, which shows the successful attainment of super wettable characteristics. Durability was assessed through 5 washing cycles and a friction distance of 100 cm, which exhibits the WCA > 140°. Additionally, ZIF-8 nanomaterials on the prepared fabric release positively charged Zn2+ under near-infrared light irradiation to rupture the bacterial cells, which enhances the antibacterial effectiveness.
Long et al.,88 fabricated the multifunctional super hydrophobic membrane with a significant photocatalytic effect on the cotton fabric through the impregnation and water bath heating method. They employed β-FeOOH NPs to achieve the photocatalytic characteristics and rough structure on the PDA coated cotton material. Furthermore, surface energy was reduced by the incorporation of hexadecyltrimethoxysilane at 60 °C for 5 hours to attain the hexadecyltrimethoxysilane/FeOOH/polydopamine/cotton fabric (HFPC) membrane. The as-prepared HFPC membrane guards the permeation of various liquids of muddy water, tea, urine, Coca-Cola and milk with a WCA of 153–158° and a SA of 6–7°, and rejects the various organic solvents which clearly reveals the successful attainment of superhydrophobicity and antifouling properties. As shown in Fig. 7, the outstanding chemical durability and mechanical robustness were assessed through various methods such as tape peeling (1000 times), finger wiping (60 kPa/1000 times), knife scratches (1000 times), abrasion test (1000 wears), hammering test (500 g/1000 times), water impact test (2.5 m s−1 for 5 min), kneading, hand twisting, stretching, chemical immersion (24 hours), UV aging (12 hours) and outdoor weathering test (5 months). Moreover, it has an efficient catalytic activity under visible light irradiation and a catalytic degradation ability of 99.5% under UV light irradiation through the photo-Fenton reaction. Additionally, it can separate oil–water mixtures continuously with an efficiency of up to 99.5%.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Robustness of HFPC membranes. (a) Tape peel, (b) finger wipe, (c) knife scratch, (d) sandpaper abrasion, (e) heavy hammering, and superhydrophobic photographs of the corresponding 1000 cycles. (f) The corresponding changes in CAs after 1000 cycles. (g) Effective water interception even after 5 min of running water impact. (h) Elasticity test. (i) The superhydrophobic behavior after soaking in organic solvents (1 M H2SO4, 1 M NaOH, and 1 M NaCl) and 80 °C hot water for 12 h. Changes in CAs and SAs after (j) UV irradiation for 24 h and (k) outdoor weathering for 5 months. Reproduced with permission from ref. 88. |
Zhang and Guo,91 developed the self-healing durable cotton fabric for oil–water separation by a two-step process. They incorporated ZIF-8 on the cotton fabric along with PDA, as the combination of ZIF-8/dopamine (DA) can achieve quick assembly within 30 minutes on different material surfaces at neutral pH, which can enhance the self-healing properties. Besides this, multiwalled carbon nanotubes were added along with ZIF-8/DA through a solution immersion process on the cotton to attain mechanical stability.
The as-prepared fabric shows the separation efficiency of 99% with a WCA of 158.9 ± 1.4° and a SA of 4 ± 0.5°. In addition, it exhibits excellent resistance towards acidic solution (12 h), alkaline solution (6 h), ultrasonication (14 h) and abrasion (35 cycles) as the WCA is greater than 145° after the above-mentioned test. The as-prepared fabric surface retains its superhydrophobicity until 6 healing cycles, as revealed by the oxygen-plasma test due to the deposition of PDMS on the structural pores, which migrate rapidly to the surface driven by heat. However, self-healing of the microstructure on the modified fabric was not possible, as it would be demolished after abrasion, as detected by XPS.
Xue et al. fabricated a superhydrophobic PET fabric by using a two-step fabrication process,68 as shown in Fig. 8. The surface roughness was attained via COP of DA in Tris buffer, which resulted in the deposition of PDA in the form of nanostructured papillae, while the superhydrophobicity was achieved in the subsequent step by immersing the modified textiles in 1% ethanolic solution of perfluorodecyl trichlorosilane (PFDTS). In an approach to mimic the lotus leaf nanostructured morphology, PET textiles were coated initially with DA in a phosphate buffer (pH = 8.5), followed by a second coating of DA in a Tris buffer. The former approach led to an increase in the WCA from 150° to 160° due to the hierarchical nanostructured morphology of the coated textiles caused by the production of larger PDA nanoparticles during the COP in phosphate buffer solution. The modified PET textiles exhibited properties including UV-shielding, good mechanical durability, and chemical stability in acidic and alkaline environments.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Schematic illustration for the preparation of biomimetic superhydrophobic surfaces by combining mussel-inspired adhesion and lotus-inspired coating. Reproduced with permission from ref. 68. |
Lu et al. employed the polymer fiber fabric (tetra-copolyester and polypropylene) as a substrate to fabricate hierarchical rough structures to achieve superhydrophobicity by the simple bottom-up approach,75 as shown in Fig. 9A. The fiber fabric was modified through dip coating by the incorporation of SiO2 NPs (obtained by the hydrolysis of TEOS) into the DA solution, with the successive immersion of the coated fabric into the silver ammonia solution containing 0.25 wt% of PVP (stabilizing agent). The incorporation of SiO2, Ag NPs, and 1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorodecanethiol (PFDT) endowed the fiber fabric with a micro/nano hierarchical rough structure and low surface energy. The exhibited separation efficiency of above 90% after 20 cycles shows the excellent stability and recyclability of the modified fiber fabric. However, after each cycle, there is a slight change in the WCA and WSA, which further sustains its water-repellency property. Additionally, the evaluated WCA of the modified fabric with the varied particle sizes of SiO2 (200, 300, and 400 nm) are 147.8° ± 2.5°, 154.5° ± 2.2° and 160.1° ± 2.8°, respectively. Thus, the higher value of WCA shows the superhydrophobicity of the modified fabric, and it can be increased by increasing the size of SiO2.
![]() | ||
Fig. 9 Schematic illustration for the preparation of superhydrophobic fabrics (other than cotton): (A) tetra-copolyester and polypropylene/SiO2/PD/Ag/PFDT, reproduced with permission from ref. 75; PLA/PDA/PVDF-HFP (B), reproduced with permission from ref. 77; other materials/PDA/SiO2/OTEOS (C), reproduced with permission from ref. 82. |
Zeng et al. reported the fabrication of a bio-degradable superhydrophobic and magnetic poly(lactic acid) (PLA) nonwoven fabric for oil–water separation by the solution immersion method77 (Fig. 9B). PDA was deposited on the PLA nonwoven fabric by an in situ polymerization of DA. Then the surface roughness and magnetic properties were achieved by the incorporation of ferrous chloride tetrahydrate (FeCl2·4H2O) and ferric chloride hexahydrate (FeCl3·6H2O) in the molar ratio of 1:
2 to generate Fe3O4 particles on the PDA coated PLA nonwoven fabric. Surface roughness and WCA can be increased by increasing the concentration of FeCl3·6H2O (150 mmol L−1). Furthermore, the surface energy was reduced to attain superhydrophobicity by immersing the modified fabric (Fe3O4/PDA/PLA) into the solution of poly(vinylidene fluoride-co-hexafluoropro-pylene) (PVDF-HFP) for 4 hours and drying at 50 °C for 1 hour. The modified nonwoven fabric displayed a WCA of 151.7°, which reveals the accomplishment of superhydrophobicity. Surface stability was evaluated by exposing the modified nonwoven fabric to different organic solvents, aqueous H2SO4, aqueous KOH solution, and boiling water for 96 hours. The measured WCAs are very close to the initial value, which reveals that the surface stability of the modified fabric is resistant to acid, alkali, and boiling water. Moreover, the attained WCA of 148.6° even after 20 cycles of the abrasion test further confirms the stability of the surface. The separation efficiency of the modified fabric shows more than 97% even after 20 cycles, exhibiting excellent recyclability. The absorption capacity shows that the modified nonwoven fabric can absorb organic solvent up to 16 times its weight, and it reaches 36 times in the case of higher density solvent CCl4.
Zhang et al. reported the fabrication of a PDA-coated pristine superhydrophobic fabric by the combination of DA polymerization and the sol–gel method.81 Surface roughness was achieved by the incorporation of PDA and SiO2 nanoparticles, and further superhydrophobicity was achieved by the involvement of polydimethysiloxane (PDMS) to reduce the surface energy. The functionalized fabric showed an enhancement in its thermal stability and excellent oil–water separation efficiency of about 95% after 8 cycles, along with a WCA of 155°. Additionally, the functionalized fabric retains its superhydrophobicity with the WCA ∼ 150°, after immersion in different pH solutions (1 to 13) for 24 hours, organic solvent for 24 hours, washing test for 3 hours, and exposure to UV irradiation for 1 hour.
Yu et al. employed various materials such as cotton fabric, sponge, concrete, wood, paper, glass, and aluminum sheet to fabricate superhydrophobic materials by the scalable two-step spraying method 82 as shown in Fig. 9C. PDA nanoparticles were utilized to attain the surface roughness and SiO2/octyltriethoxysilane (OTEOS) was incorporated to reduce the surface energy for the betterment of superhydrophobic properties. All the modified materials exhibited a WCA of 154.2 ± 2° and a WSA of <3°. The results attained from the durability and stability test reveal that the modified material has excellent resistance under mechanical abrasion, acidic/basic conditions for 24 hours, organic solvents immersion for 24 hours, UV irradiation for 120 hours, and prolonged outdoor exposure for 12 months without losing its superhydrophobicity (WCA > 151°).
Su et al.,86 developed the pH responsive nanofibrous polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) membrane by the electrospinning process and further modification through solution immersion and a metal thiol co-ordination reaction. Surface roughness was attained by the incorporation of silver nanoparticles and successive addition of thiols (HS(CH2)11CH3/HS(CH2)10COOH), which further modifies the membrane into a pH responsive superwettable membrane. Self-polymerized DA restricts the mobility of silver nanoparticles and thiols, which creates the microstructure with upright structural stability against harsh mechanical action. The modified membrane showed the efficiency of over 99.2% for light oil/water and 96.5% for heavy oil/water mixtures. Mechanism of the wettability switching of the pH-responsive membrane is shown in Fig. 10A, which displays a WCA of 151.5° and UWOCA of 0° for pH = 7 and a WCA of 0° and a UWOCA of 152.5° (pH = 13). In addition, it exhibited the energy saving separation efficiency of about 99% for all types of surfactant stabilized emulsions with excellent durability and reusability.
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 (A) Mechanism illustration of the wettability switching of the pH-responsive membrane at pH 7 and 13, reproduced with permission from ref. 86; (B) oil–water separation time, reproduced with permission from ref. 89; (C) schematic illustration of the photo thermal conversion in the PP-MXene/PPy-PDM membrane, reproduced with permission from ref. 90. |
Hatami et al.,89 utilized the waste woolen felt due to the benefits of fire retardant and self-extinguishing properties to prepare an oil–water separation material which is inexpensive and bio-degradable on top of that. They employed varied densities (1.165, 1.650, 1.682 and 1.747 g cm−3) of woolen felt as a base matrix, which is covered with TiO2/PDA nanoparticles followed by silver nanoparticles through a solution immersion and stirring method to attain the rough hierarchical structure on the surface. Furthermore, the surfaces were modified with DDT to reduce the surface energy of the material and prepare the superhydrophobic/superoleophilic material. Among the modified superhydrophobic materials, the woolen felt material with a density of 1.650 g cm−3 shows a WCA of 155.14° with a superior separation and passage of water at times of 4:
19
:
120 and 1
:
37
:
100 (Fig. 10B), which is attributed to the homogeneous distribution of nanoparticles on the woolen felt which prevents the clusters.
Li et al.,90 constructed the pH responsive superhydrophobic composite membrane based on PP fibre, and the wettability was enhanced through PDA deposition on the substrate through in situ polymerization, solution immersion and vacuum assisted filtration methods. They used Mxene nanosheets, which are a 2D transition metal, due to the attributes of rich active sites, photo thermal properties, ceramic-like stability and polymer-like flexibility. Furthermore, to improve the stability and utilize photo thermal properties (Fig. 10C) of Mxenes, polypyrrole (PPy) was deposited on Mxenes through an in situ polymerization process. The vacuum assisted filtration method was used to construct the composite membrane, and its outer surface was covered with the transparent pH-responsive polymer PDM through a solution immersion process. The prepared composite membrane (PP-MXene/PPy-PDM) at pH = 2 exhibits a WCA of 40° and an OCA of 130°. When the pH is elevated to 12, the WCA was 130°, and the OCA was 0°. The above results indicate that the membrane is hydrophilic in an acidic environment and becomes hydrophobic in an alkaline environment. Moreover, it shows the higher separation efficiency ranging from 2.44 to 3.87 kg m−2 h−1 for the diverse oil–water emulsion with excellent resistance to abrasion, acidic and alkaline conditions.
Wang et al.,92 designated the Nylon 56 fabric to fabricate a superhydrophobic membrane through an eco-friendly method because of its high elasticity, high temperature resistance, wear resistance and environmental protection. They coated this fabric with PDA, which can provide reactive sites for other ingredients, followed by the integration of tetraallyl silane (TETRA) and (mercapto) methyl siloxane-dimethyl siloxane copolymer (MMSDC) on the polydopamine coating by the thiol–ene click reaction under ultraviolet light. The hydrophobic reagents' TETRA to MMSDC molar ratio was optimized to 1:
3, as it shows a SCA of 166°, SA of 7.5°, which confirms the effective attainment of low surface energy groups and hydrophobicity on the fabric. Mechanical stability was assessed through sandpaper abrasion for 25 cycles, which shows that the WCA dropped from 166° to 151° without losing its superhydrophobicity. Additionally, it exhibits excellent self-cleaning and antifouling properties as it repels the various pollutants of organic dye, saltwater, coffee, milk, cola, and tea.
Wang and colleagues developed a SHL/UWSOB cotton fabric by using a combination of PDA and chitosan (CS) (PDA–CS–CF).115 They evaluated the effect of each polymer individually and in combination on the UWOCA and the stability of the hydrogel coat under harsh conditions. The separation efficiency for petroleum ether and soybean oil–water mixtures was above 99.5%, with a flux of 41000 and 28
000 L m−2 h−1 respectively. These values persisted after 100 filtration cycles and after the PDA–CS–CF samples were subjected to ultrasonic, saltwater, alkaline, and acidic solution treatments. Likewise, Li and coworkers prepared a SHL/UWSOB cotton fabric for the dual removal of heavy metal ions and oil from artificial oily wastewater using the same CS and PDA polymers, but with a slightly different deposition method.119 Polydopamine was deposited on an ultrasonically cleaned CF in an oxidative polymerization process from a solution of dopamine HCl over 24 hours to yield PDA–CF. Chitosan was subsequently deposited on the dried PDA–CF from a 1% w/v solution of chitosan in glacial acetic acid to yield PDA–CF–CS after drying. The amino groups in chitosan provided adsorption points for heavy metals and crosslinking points with the quinone structure in the polydopamine coat. Fig. 11A shows the digital images of the separation process for the copper-contaminated oil–water using CF, PDA–CF, and PDA–CF–CS. As shown in Fig. 11B, the lowest water infiltration time was 117 s for the superhydrophilic PDA–CF–CS, while the UWOCA was 139.5°, 147.3° and 156.1° for CF, PDA–CF, and PDA–CF–CS, respectively. The UWOCA of PDA–CF–CS decreased to 152.6° after 300 abrasion cycles of 40 cm/cycle under a 200 g weight.
![]() | ||
Fig. 11 Digital images showing the separation process of Cu(II)–oil–water using CF, PDA–CF, and PDA–CF–CS (A); WCA and UWOCA for CF, PDA–CF, and PDA–CF–CS (B); flux and separation efficiency (C and D); and copper adsorption capacity of PDA–CF–CS (E and F), reproduced with permission from ref. 120. |
The oil–water separation efficiency remained above 99% after 10 separation cycles while the water flux decreased from 17400 L m−2 h−1 to 15
400 L m−2 h−1 by the 10th cycle (Fig. 11C and D). The copper removal efficiency was about 89% which decreased within 2 min to 67% during continuous filtration (Fig. 11E and F). Zhong and coworkers95 utilized titanium oxide NPs (due to their antibacterial, UV shielding, and hydrophilicity), polydopamine (to improve the adhesion and hydrophilicity), and (3-aminopropyl) triethoxysilane (KH550) (to improve the stability of polydopamine in an alkaline environment and additional hydration capacity), in a one-step impregnation process to prepare the SHUSO cotton fabric. The TiO2 NPs and PEG were dispersed in Tris–HCl buffer to which copper sulphate, hydrogen peroxide, KH550, and dopamine were subsequently added. The CF, soaked in sodium hydroxide at 95 °C for 24 hours. was ultrasonically cleaned and dried, and then soaked in the impregnating solution. Synergistic crosslinking polymerization across the KH550, catechol group of the dopamine, and TiO2 NPs ensured the firm fixation of the modification on the CF. The water spreading time of the modified CF decreased from 13.45 s for the pristine CF to 0.5 s. The UWOCA for all the oils used was above 169°. The separation efficiency for an oil–water mixture remained above 99.99% after 50 filtration cycles and immersion in acidic, alkaline, and salt solutions. A maximum flux of 32
000 L m−2 h−1 was obtained that varied slightly after 3 cycles. The separation efficiency of the modified CF remained above 99.99% after being subjected to 50 abrasion cycles (20 cm per cycle) on 800-grit sandpaper under 2800 Pa pressure.
Hu et al.,102 developed the SHL/UWSOB fabric for oil–water separation and removal of dyes by a two-step process of dip-coating in poly(sodium 4-styrenesulfonate) (PSS) enveloped carbon nanotube (CNT) dispersion, followed by the subsequent in situ deposition of PDA. Surface roughness (Ra) of virgin cotton was elevated from 27.005 μm to 34.055 μm by the incorporation of PSS and PDA nanoparticles. The attained fabric shows the separation efficiency of greater than 99.8% with an UWOCA of 160°, which clearly reveals its super wetting ability. Besides that, it exhibits about a 97% removal rate for cationic dyes, especially methylene blue, due to the addition of porous CNTs, which provide excellent dye adsorption and hydrophilic capability for the modified fabric. Additionally, it displays a UWOCA of >150° after exposure to the harsh conditions, viz. sandpaper abrasion, immersion in various organic solvents, 30% NaCl for 7 days, and immersion in aqueous solutions of various pH values of 1 to 13. The above outcomes indicated that the modified fabric has excellent stability and durability, which can be ascribed to the strong interactions among PDA, CNT, PSS and cotton fabric owing to the presence of hydrogen bonding between them.
Li and his colleagues,103 developed the inexpensive and eco-friendly SHL/UWSOB fabric for oil–water separation via oxidative polymerization of DA on the cotton fabric and SiO2 was integrated through a solution immersion process. The attained PDA/SiO2/cotton fabric reveals a UWOCA of 159.7° with the separation efficiency of greater than 98% for crude oil/water and 99% for toluene/water. Additionally, UWOCAs are still greater than 150° after undergoing ultra-sonication (9 h), sandpaper abrasion (500 cycles), and immersion in strong acid, strong alkali, NaCl solutions (31 days), signifying that the developed cotton fabric has notable mechanical and chemical stability. It is noteworthy to mention that the deionized water can be used easily to remove the crude oil attached to the developed fabric surface, which clearly indicates the anti-crude oil fouling property of the SiO2/PDA/CF fabric.
As shown in Fig. 12A, EFs were first prepared using a 10% solution of PAN in DMF and subsequently decorated with PDA NPs by immersing in a Tris–HCl buffer solution of dopamine at pH 8.5 for 7 hours. The permeation flux and the separation efficiency ranged from 1496 L m−2 h−1 bar−1 and 93.2% for n-hexane/water emulsion to 1570 L m−2 h−1 bar−1 and 96.1% for hexadecane/water emulsion, respectively (Fig. 12B). The optical micrographs showing the emulsion before and after separation using the PAN@PDA EF for n-hexane (C1/C2), dodecane (D1/D2), and hexadecane (E1/E2) emulsions are shown in Fig. 12C–E. Fig. 12F and G depict the permeation rate for a drop of water on a pristine PAN fiber and a PAN@PDA fiber, respectively.
![]() | ||
Fig. 12 Preparation process (A); permeability and separation efficiency (B); optical micrographs of n-hexane/water (C1), dodecane/water (D1), hexadecane/water (E1) emulsions and their separations (C2, D2, and E2) respectively; and spreading time of water drop on pristine PAN (F) and PAN@PDA (G), reproduced with permission from ref. 121. |
Li and colleagues developed a SHL/UWSOB surface on nonwoven polyester fabric by deposition of a polydopamine–polyethyleneimine (PDA–PEI) complex,94 as shown in Fig. 13A. Ammonium persulphate was introduced as a superior oxidizing agent for the co-deposition reaction. The as-prepared fabric showed a UWOCA of 165.4 ± 1.1°; a SA of 2.5 ± 0.5°; an artificial oil–water separation efficiency above 99%; and a flux that ranged from 115000 L m−2 h−1 to 118
000 L m−2 h−1, which persisted even after 100 filtration cycles, representing capacity for continuous filtration. Furthermore, the stability of the coating to retain its separation capacity under different harsh conditions was evaluated at pH 2, 7, and 12. The UWOCA of the PDA–PEI coated textile decreased by only 1° under these harsh conditions.
![]() | ||
Fig. 13 Schematic illustration of (A) the mussel-inspired coating for design of superhydrophilic non-woven fabric membranes and its proposed reaction mechanism of fast codeposition of dopamine (DA) and PEI triggered by persulfate via Michael addition and Schiff-base reactions, reproduced with permission from ref. 94; (B) synthesis of the Ag@PDS deposited membrane, reproduced with permission from ref. 99. |
Liu and colleagues reported the fabrication of hierarchical structures composed of silver nanoclusters on polydopamine spheres coated on a nonwoven nylon textile via a chemical wet reduction method99 (Fig. 13B). The UWOCA was above 150° with a diesel–water emulsion separation efficiency above 98% that persisted after 12 filtration cycles. The modified SHL/UWSOB membrane equally exhibited antibacterial activity against E. coli and demonstrated the catalytic reduction of methylene blue in the oil/water emulsion.
Huang and colleagues prepared a strong, electrically conductive, and stretchable SHL/UWSOB from electrospun polyurethane (PU) by first coating acidified carbon nanotubes on the electrospun PU.122 Subsequently, PDA@PU/ACNTs were prepared by coating PDA onto the PU/ACNT composite, as shown in Fig. 14A. The water contact angle of PDA@PU/ACNTs rapidly decreased from 62° to 0° in less than 30 s with UWOCA above 150°. The flux ranged from 4108 L m−2 h−1 to 7240 L m−2 h−1 for heptane and cyclohexane in water emulsions, respectively. The separation efficiency remained above 99.7% even after 10 cyclic separations, though the flux decreased to 3608 L m−2 h−1.122 Zhang and colleagues exploited the synergy between an electrospun poly (arylene ether nitrile) (PEN) and polydopamine-coated hexagonal boron nitride (h-BN) nanosheets to fabricate a thermo-stable, corrosion-resistant composite SHL/UWSOB double-layered membrane.123 They found that the superhydrophilicity represented by the WCA was associated with the h-BN-PDA content and decreased from 122° to 0° as the h-BN-PDA content increased to 0.75 mg. The UWOCA for different oils evaluated was below 150° and hence below the ideal value for underwater superoleophobicity. The separation flux for hexane–water emulsion was negatively affected by the h-BN-PDA content decreasing from 1894.55 L m−2 h−1 to 1274.51 L m−2 h−1 as the content increased from 0 mg to 0.75 mg, though the separation efficiency at this point was still above 99%. Likewise, the flux of the composite membrane decreased to 588 L m−2 h−1 after 10 filtration cycles for the emulsion, but remained above 8400 L m−2 h−1 for the oil–water. Overall, the separation efficiency remained above 99% through the 10 cycles. The resistance of the composite membrane to elevated temperatures in the oven was confirmed by the unchanged flux and separation efficiency of the membrane while it showed a decrease in wettability when exposed to additional corrosive solutions at elevated temperature (65 °C).96
![]() | ||
Fig. 14 Schematic illustration for preparation of composite membranes: (A) PDA@PU/ACNTs, reproduced with permission from ref. 122. (B) HAP/SiO2/PDA, reproduced with permission from ref. 100. (C) Bacterial cellulose/PDA/TiO2, reproduced with permission from ref. 101. |
Wang et al.,100 developed the SHL/UWSOB composite membrane based on micro cellulose ester through in situ process for synthesizing nano materials and vacuum filtration for membranes (Fig. 14B). Hydrophilicity was achieved by the addition of SiO2 nano materials on hydroxyapatite (HAP) with the synergistic effect of polydopamine. The prepared composite membrane of HAP/SiO2/PDA shows the high-water permeability flux and a separation efficiency of 90.90% over a wide range of light to heavy oils. The obtained UWOCA ranges from 149.75 ± 80.42° to 155.265 ± 1.902° for all the prepared membranes, and the WCA was decreased from 27.63 ± 0.997° to 11.07 ± 0.169° due to the influence of TEOS, which exhibits the wettability attributes of the composite membranes. Mechanical durability was assessed by the scratch test through knife and finger, which exhibits a UWOCA of >150° and a separation efficiency of >98%. Furthermore, it shows a UWOCA of >140° after being immersed separately in corrosive solutions of acidic/alkaline and salt for 3 days, which reveals the endurance of underwater super-oleophobic properties.
Cui and colleagues101 fabricated the non-toxic, low cost and environmentally friendly composite membrane based on bacterial cellulose, which can decay organic pollutants under ultraviolet light. They employed PDA as an anchoring substance for TiO2 nanoparticles on the surface and cross-linked with sodium alginate by vacuum assisted filtration and freeze-drying techniques (Fig. 14C). The prepared membrane (bacterial cellulose/PDA/TiO2) shows the separation efficiency of >99% for low and heavy viscous oil–water mixtures with a WCA of 0° and a UWOCA of 156.5°. It shows the effective attainment of superhydrophilic and underwater superoleophobic properties due to the addition of TiO2 and sodium alginate. As the addition of sodium alginate assists in making the membrane with a porous structure, which increases the water flux of the membrane. However, after repeated separation of the oil–water mixture, the WCA was dropped to 125.6°, and it was regenerated to 154° with the aid of UV radiation. Additionally, antifouling and extended service life of the membrane was attained by the addition of TiO2, which serves as a catalyst in decomposing the organic pollutants under UV irradiation.
![]() | ||
Fig. 15 Schematic illustration for the separation mechanisms of emulsified oil/water mixtures: (a) size-sieving mechanism, and (b) demulsification mechanism, reproduced with permission from ref. 34. |
There are limited reports that have utilized polydopamine-coated textiles for the separation of emulsified oil/water mixtures. Li et al. developed a switchable cotton fabric for oil–water separation and water purification.136 To create a rough micro–nano scale surface with high surface energy—allowing selective wetting and repelling of immiscible media—they incorporated polydopamine and NiFe2O4 nanoparticles. Surface morphology and compositional analysis confirmed a uniform NiFe2O4 coating on the cotton fabric. The modified fabric exhibited a water contact angle (WCA) of 145° in oil and an oil contact angle (OCA) of 153° in water, demonstrating its super-amphiphilic nature in air and lyophobic properties. When mounted between two vertical glass tubes for emulsion separation, the fabric effectively separated both oil-in-water and water-in-oil emulsions. Optical microscopy confirmed the absence of internal-phase droplets in the collected filtrates, achieving a separation flux of approximately 300 L m−2 h−1 by gravity with a rejection ratio of about 99%. Similar results were observed for other surfactant-stabilized emulsions, including SDS-stabilized hexadecane-in-water, diesel-in-water, and Span 80-stabilized water-in-hexane and water-in-chloroform. Cycle performance tests using SDS-stabilized toluene-in-water and water-in-dichloromethane emulsions showed that the fabric retained stable separation efficiency even after washing with water or dichloromethane. Although oil/water flux gradually decreased over time due to cake formation on the surface, the fabric exhibited antifouling properties, ensuring sustained separation performance. Additionally, its porous structure enabled the adsorption of methylene blue, highlighting its potential for water treatment applications.
Gan et al. utilized polydopamine as a binder and reducing agent for the in situ deposition of silver (Ag) nanoparticles onto a textile surface.137 This was followed by an immersion step in PFOA-Na ethanol solution to achieve a slippery oil-repellent state, creating a superhydrophobic/superhydrophilic (SHB/SHL) Ag/polydopamine-coated textile (Ag/PDA@textile). The incorporation of Ag nanoparticles endowed the textile with photocatalytic and antibacterial properties, enabling its application for dye removal from water and the inhibition of bacterial growth. The modified textile exhibited superhydrophilic and superoleophobic characteristics in air, with an oil contact angle (OCA) greater than 150° and a sliding angle (SA) of less than 9°. When wetted with water, it displayed an OCA of 50.1°, allowing oil to flow smoothly across its water-wetted surface due to the water lubricant's fluidity. Notably, even after being submerged in oil for a day, the water-wetted textile retained its oil-repelling properties, demonstrating excellent anti-oil-fouling capabilities. Oil–water separation tests revealed a high-water permeation flux of 1502 L m−2 h−1 bar−1 and a separation efficiency exceeding 99% for toluene–hot water mixtures at 80.5 °C. Comparative microscopy images before and after emulsion separation (Tween 80-stabilized toluene-in-water) further highlighted its effectiveness in separating o/w emulsions. Additionally, Ag/PDA@textile demonstrated the ability to separate immiscible oil/oil mixtures with varying polarities, showing a strong affinity for high-polarity oils while repelling low-polarity oils.
Despite these advantages, conventional PDA coating strategies face challenges such as time consumption and poor controllability. These issues arise from the slow kinetics of DA polymerization and inevitable aggregation, which limit practical manufacturing processes and hinder precise tuning of surface characteristics.138 As shown in Tables 1 and 2, the first challenge is related to the fabrication process, which is time-consuming. Most reported studies employ in situ auto-oxidative polymerization using a Tris buffer (pH = 8.5/O2), requiring long deposition periods (≈24 hours) for a PDA coating. The second challenge is related to the development of efficient strategies for restricting DA polymerization exclusively to the material's surface, minimizing waste caused by excessive self-polymerization in the solution. The first and the second challenges can be addressed by employing a direct and rapid dip-coating strategy of the textiles/fabrics in pre-polymerized polydopamine dispersions.139 In this approach, nanoparticles can be added to the polydopamine dispersion, or the dispersion itself can be prepared in the presence of the desired nanoparticles. The dip-coating method also helps to reduce the excess PDA waste. However, this proposed technique may influence the final wetting behaviour of the modified textiles due to PDA's inherent hydrophilicity and adhesion properties. To optimize adhesion, the number of dip-coating cycles can be adjusted. Additionally, post-functionalization can still be performed to modify the surface energy properties of polydopamine-coated textiles compared to those of uncoated textiles.
Another solution that enables rapid polydopamine coatings is the use of an effective oxidizing agent and/or auxiliary oxidizing agents (i.e. redox system) that accelerate the rate of oxidative polymerization. As can be inferred from Tables 1 and 2, only a limited number of studies have utilized the rapid oxidation procedures during the fabrication process. Hence, this area is an active research area that has not yet been fully explored to accelerate the polydopamine coating and shorten the overall fabrication time. In this respect, there are numerous redox systems that have been reported for the rapid polymerization of polydopamine, including Cu2+/H2O2,140,141 Fe3+/H2O2,142 Fe2+,143 ozone (O3),144 and sodium periodate (NaIO4).145 PDA exhibits good anticorrosion resistance in neutral and acidic environments but may partially degrade under alkaline conditions (pH > 12). In practical applications, pretreating water effluent to achieve a neutral pH can help extend the lifespan of PDA-coated membranes by avoiding extreme pH conditions. Notably, even state-of-the-art biodegradable superwetting crosslinked membranes degrade easily under alkaline conditions (1 M NaOH).131 Nevertheless, applying a secondary protective coating (e.g., PDMS) can enhance the chemical durability of PDA-coated textiles, albeit at the expense of increased fabrication cost and time. Additionally, the mechanical durability and relatively high cost of PDA coatings must be carefully considered in future studies.46
From the perspective of oil/water separation, future research should focus on developing faster, cost-effective, one-step fabrication methods and scaling up the production of PDA-coated superwetting textiles. The use of polydopamine nanoparticles (e.g. synthesized in the ethanol/water mixture) is expected to improve the superwetting performance of the coated textiles due to the improved surface roughness.67 Future studies should also emphasize the separation of both stratified and emulsified oil/water mixtures, including viscous crude oils and water-in-oil (w/o) and oil-in-water (o/w) emulsions. Another direction that has emerged is the application of polydopamine-coated materials for water purification and decontamination (e.g. removal of dyes, toxic metal ions, etc.).146–151 Hence, dopamine-coated fabrics could be utilized for both oil/water separation and decontamination due to the potential adsorption of polydopamine to diverse arrays of toxic organic and inorganic contaminants through different ionic interactions. This can be achieved with/without the presence of photocatalysts immobilized on the surface of the coated textiles.152 Besides the rapid degradation of the organic contaminants, the embedded photocatalysts are expected to improve the self-cleaning and antifouling performance of the polydopamine-coated textiles.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |