Yi-Shou Wang*,
Xin-Yu Li,
Rui-Rui Li,
Xiao-Nan Yuan,
Zhu-Qing Zhao and
Xing-Xing Gou
Shaanxi Key Laboratory of Comprehensive Utilization of Tailings Resources, Shaanxi Engineering Research Center for Mineral Resources Clean & Efficient Conversion and New Materials, College of Chemical Engineering and Modern Materials, Shangluo University, Shangluo 726000, China. E-mail: 202138@slxy.edu.cn
First published on 21st May 2025
Water pollution has become a global concern, especially from toxic metal-derived oxo-anions like CrO42−, Cr2O72−, and TcO4−. Adsorption, particularly ion-exchange-driven adsorption, is a promising remediation approach. In this study, a novel imidazolium-based cationic organic network material, ImCON1, was designed and synthesised. Multiple characterisation techniques were used to analyse its structure and properties, including FTIR, solid-state 13C CP-MAS NMR, SEM, TGA, XRD, and XPS. ImCON1 has a cross-linked, irregular spherical morphology, remarkable stability, and an amorphous nature. It shows high-efficiency removal of various toxic oxo-anions, CrO42−, Cr2O72−, and MnO4− (as a surrogate for TcO4−) from water. The uptake capacities are 259 mg g−1 for CrO42−, 1118 mg g−1 for Cr2O72−, and 694.5 mg g−1 for MnO4−, comparable to or higher than those of previously reported materials. The sorption kinetics follow the pseudo-second-order model, indicating rapid capture. ImCON1 is resistant to a wide pH range and effectively captures oxo-anions even in the presence of competing anions. An ImCON1-packed chromatographic column can efficiently remove oxo-anions from water through an anion exchange mechanism and can be reused for at least ten cycles. This novel cationic organic network material holds great promise for wastewater treatment applications and paves the way for developing high-performance adsorption materials at the molecular scale.
Sustainability spotlightThe synthesis of ImCON1, a novel cationic organic network, represents a significant sustainable advance. It enables ultra-fast and high-capacity removal of toxic oxo-anions from water. This aligns with the UN's Sustainable Development Goal 6 (Clean Water and Sanitation) by offering an efficient solution for wastewater treatment. With excellent pH resistance, good performance in the presence of competing anions, and reusability, it provides an environmentally friendly approach to purifying water and protecting aquatic ecosystems. |
Porous organic polymers (POPs)32,33 and covalent organic frameworks (COFs)34–37 are fabricated through strong covalent bonds, yielding high physicochemical stability. This remarkable stability has propelled them to the forefront of the domain of porous materials.38–41 In real-time applications, it has been observed that stability is often prioritised over direct structure–property correlations. These compounds have attracted significant attention in various fields, such as gas adsorption, catalysis, and drug delivery.42–45 However, their application in capturing hazardous oxo-anions from water is extremely scarce.46 The fundamental prerequisite is a cationic network equipped with exchangeable anions to achieve anion capture via ion exchange. Cationic organic networks (CONs) represent a novel class of porous organic materials with significant potential for scavenging water contaminants. The organic skeletons within CONs enable facile structural design and modification. Meanwhile, the strong covalent bonds endow them with high-level stability even under harsh conditions.47–55 More notably, the charged frameworks of CONs and abundant counterions can enhance adsorption performance. Various CONs have been developed and utilised to remove specific contaminants selectively.56–62 However, research on CONs remains in its infancy, and the design of a single material with the capacity to adsorb a diverse range of water pollutants remains highly desirable. The charged active sites are unquestionably the most critical textural factor influencing the adsorption performance of a CON material. In light of this, we have endeavoured to optimise the efficiency of CONs by augmenting the density of charged sites. To this end, a novel imidazolium-based cationic organic network material, ImCON1 (Fig. 1a), was meticulously designed and synthesised. Subsequently, ImCON1 was employed to uptake diverse toxic oxo-anions present in water, and it exhibited a notably high adsorption capacity along with rapid kinetic behaviour.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 (a) Structure of ImCON1, (b) solid-state 13C CP-MAS NMR spectrum of ImCON1 (the peak marked with * is the spinning sideband), (c) FTIR spectrum of ImCON1 compared with monomers. |
High-resolution scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images disclose the cross-linked, irregular spherical morphology of ImCON1 (Fig. 2a). The particle diameters of this material are approximately within the range of 1–1.5 μm. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) data suggested that ImCON1 possessed remarkable thermal stability (Fig. 2b). At temperatures exceeding 259 °C, a significant weight loss was observed, possibly due to the elimination of solvent molecules from the pores of ImCON1. The thermal degradation temperature of ImCON1 was approximately 417 °C. The X-ray diffraction patterns unequivocally confirm the amorphous nature of ImCON1, indicating the existence of a complex and disordered arrangement reminiscent of an ionic liquid-derived structure (Fig. S1†). The absence of long-range order implies that the framework comprises randomly packed particles instead of crystalline domains. However, the broad diffraction peaks at 7.5° and 23.5° indicate that ImCON1 still preserves an organisation typical of ionic networks.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a) SEM image, (b) TGA curve, and XPS spectra of ImCON1 (c) survey, (d) C 1s, (e) N 1s and (f) Br 3d. |
The chemical compositions of the ImCON1 materials were rigorously analysed via X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). In the full survey spectra presented in Fig. 2c, five distinct peaks, located at 533.6 eV, 402 eV, 285.5 eV, 183 eV, and 68 eV, can be readily identified. These peaks correspond to O 1s, N 1s, C 1s, Br 3p, and Br 3d, respectively. The detection of oxygen (O) at 533.6 eV is attributed to water absorption, a finding that is consistent with the results from FTIR and TGA. This congruence among the different analytical techniques validates the reliability of the characterisation of the ImCON1 materials. Turning to the C 1s spectrum, as depicted in Fig. 2d, ImCON1 exhibits three well-defined peaks at binding energies (BE) of 284.8 eV, 286.4 eV, and 288.9 eV. These peaks signify the carbon species from aromatic rings, alkyl linkers, and the CN+ bonds within the imidazolium rings. The N 1s spectrum, shown in Fig. 2e, clearly elucidates the nitrogen composition. The dominant peak, with a relatively high BE value of 401.7 eV, represents the highly delocalised imidazolium cations (C
N+). Conversely, the smaller peak, with a lower BE value of 399.1 eV, can be attributed to non-ionic nitrogen atoms within the imidazolium ring.56 Regarding the Br 3d spectra, as presented in Fig. 2f, two prominent peaks centered at 67.2 eV (3d5/2) and 68.2 eV (3d3/2) are observed. These peaks confirm the successful incorporation of the targeted bromide anions paired with the imidazolium cations. Overall, the XPS data provide a comprehensive and in-depth understanding of the chemical constitution and bonding within the ImCON1 structure, thereby contributing to a more profound knowledge of the material's properties at the atomic and molecular levels.
To evaluate the performance of ImCON1 as an ion-exchange-based adsorbent, it was essential to understand its physical properties, including porosity, surface morphology, and the surface charge of the polymer. These parameters are crucial in determining the anion uptake performance of such materials in an aqueous medium. Low-temperature N2 gas adsorption experiments (Fig. S2a†) were conducted to assess the porous properties. Before the gas uptake experiments, the ImCON1 sample was activated by heating it at 120 °C for several hours, followed by N2 gas adsorption and desorption at 77 K. A notably low nitrogen uptake was recorded in the low relative pressure range (P/P0 = 0–0.6). However, a gradual increase in N2 uptake in the relatively high P/P0 region indicated the presence of mesopores. Employing the BET isotherm model, the surface area of ImCON1 was determined to be 1.80 m2 g−1. The pore size distribution calculated using nonlinear density functional theory (NL-DFT) demonstrated the microporous nature of ImCON1 (Fig. S2b†). The relatively low surface area resulted from substantial blockage of the internal voids/pores by the bromide counteranions associated with the cationic backbone of the as-synthesised ImCON1. Field emission scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM) micrographs revealed an agglomerated morphology with evenly distributed elements (C, N, and Br), as demonstrated by energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) mapping (Fig. S3†). The EDX data further verified the presence of bromide counteranions within the void spaces of ImCON1, which consequently led to a reduced specific surface area of the ionic ImCON1.
A similar approach was adopted to study the capture of dichromate anion (Cr2O72−) from water. After exposing ImCON1 to an aqueous Cr2O72− solution, the supernatant liquid transitioned from yellow to colourless. The characteristic peak of Cr2O72− emerged at λmax = 350 nm, and its absorbance was monitored for time-dependent studies (Fig. 3b). Within a 3 minute interval, approximately 96% of the Cr2O72− was removed from the water. Simultaneously, the white ImCON1 gradually turned yellow. A novel characteristic absorption band manifested at 940 cm−1. This can be ascribed to the presence of Cr2O72−. This indicates that Cr2O72− had replaced bromide anions within the channels of ImCON1, as presented in Fig. S5.† Subsequently, the kinetic data were subjected to fitting using the pseudo-second-order equation. The kinetic constant k2 was determined to be 0.009 g mg−1 min−1, with a correlation coefficient R2 > 0.999 (Fig. S8†). To the best of our knowledge, this kinetic constant is significantly higher than those of most reported adsorbents, which indicates the rapid adsorption property of ImCON1 towards Cr2O72−. Furthermore, the capacity of ImCON1 for Cr2O72− ions was calculated (1118 mg g−1) from the UV-vis study. Notably, this value surpasses the capture capacities of most of the adsorbent materials reported in the existing literature (Table S2†), suggesting that ImCON1 can function as an efficient adsorbent. The adsorption isotherm was acquired to evaluate the adsorption capacity of ImCON1 for Cr2O72−. As presented in Fig. S11,† the equilibrium adsorption capacities of Cr2O72− at different concentrations were obtained. The isotherm was then fitted to the Langmuir model.
In addition to Cr2O72− and CrO42−, TcO4− ions are hazardous water pollutants because of the radioactivity of 99Tc. Since handling radioactive species is inconvenient in a typical laboratory, we chose MnO4− as a non-radioactive surrogate for TcO4−. Mn and Tc are in the same periodic group, making MnO4− a close chemical analogue of TcO4−. Following the methodology for Cr2O72− and CrO42− capture, we conducted detailed studies on removing MnO4− from water. The capture of MnO4− was monitored at λmax = 525 nm. A rapid decline in the absorption spectrum was observed, and the purple solution was decolorised within 1 minute (Fig. 3c). Concurrently, the white solid adsorbent, ImCON1, turned dark brown. These dual observations strongly suggested an interaction between ImCON1 and permanganate ions (MnO4−). FT-IR analysis confirmed the presence of MnO4− in MnO4−@ImCON1, with the characteristic absorbance at 904 cm−1 (Fig. S6†). ImCON1 demonstrated highly promising results in the MnO4− sequestration from aqueous solutions. The uptake capacity reached 694.5 mg g−1, significantly higher than those of previously reported compounds (Table S3†). To delve into the sorption rate of ImCON1 towards MnO4−, corresponding kinetic experiments were carried out. As illustrated in Fig. S9,† when the treatment duration was extended to 3 minutes, ImCON1 reduced the MnO4− concentration to below 54.5%. Further prolonging the treatment time beyond 2 minutes did not result in a significant decrease, indicating that the sorption process had reached equilibrium. The sorption kinetics of ImCON1 were further analysed by fitting the experimental data to a pseudo-second-order model (Fig. S12†). The high correlation coefficient obtained from the fitting suggests that the sorption process is likely governed by chemical adsorption. The ultrafast exchange kinetics can be primarily attributed to the small particle size, high porosity, and elevated positive charge density of ImCON1.
Given the harsh conditions of wastewater, the influence of pH on the sorption efficiency of oxo-anions was investigated. As illustrated in Fig. 3d, the impact of acid–base conditions on the sorption of CrO42− was negligible. The removal efficiencies reached 100% within the pH range of 4 to 10. When ImCON1 was placed in a more acidic environment, specifically at pH 2, the removal percentage of CrO42− decreased to 84%. In a strongly basic solution with a pH of 12, ImCON1 still demonstrated a high removal rate of 87% for CrO42−. When contrasted with the results obtained for the removal of CrO42−, the removal efficiency of Cr2O72− was found to be relatively more significantly influenced by the basic environment at pH 12, as depicted in Fig. 3e. At pH 12, ImCON1 could achieve a removal rate of up to 84% for Cr2O72−. This phenomenon is likely attributed to different Cr(VI) ionic forms in aqueous solutions at various pH values. Furthermore, as presented in Fig. 3f, it was evident that the removal of MnO4− ions remained unaltered by the pH value. The demonstrated acid–base resistance of ImCON1 strongly suggests that the polymeric network featuring covalent linkers plays a crucial role in maintaining structural stability and enhancing the sorption capacity under harsh environmental conditions. To determine the chemical stability of ImCON1 in acidic and basic environments, samples of ImCON1 were suspended in 0.1 M HCl and 0.1 M NaOH solutions, respectively, for 24 hours. Fourier-Transform Infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy was utilised to analyse the samples. Under acidic conditions, as illustrated in Fig. S13,† the FTIR spectra of ImCON1 treated with HCl (blue curve) exhibit no significant shifts or disappearances of the characteristic peaks associated with the structure of pristine ImCON1 (pink curve). This observation indicates that the chemical bonds within ImCON1 remained largely intact under acidic conditions. Under basic conditions, the FTIR spectra of ImCON1 treated with NaOH (green curve) in Fig. S13† reveal certain alterations. Specifically, the frameworks of ImCON1 undergo a gradual loss of positive charges, which can be attributed to the deprotonation of C2–H from the imidazolium rings in basic solutions. Nevertheless, despite these modifications, the overall structure of ImCON1 retains a degree of stability, as the key characteristic peaks related to its primary framework can still be identified.
Wastewater contains competing anions (e.g., F−, Cl−, Br−, I−, NO3−, SO42−) and the target oxo-anions. Therefore, we conducted binary mixture studies for all oxo-anions with a 10-fold excess of moles of various competing anions. Notably, significant capture of the oxo-anions was still observed in the presence of competing anions. In the case of CrO42− ions, efficient removal was achieved in the presence of F−, Cl−, Br−, I−, and NO3− ions, as shown in Fig. 3g. However, the removal efficiency for the SO42−/CrO42− ion mixture was relatively lower, reaching approximately 75%. Similar phenomena were also detected in the adsorption experiment of ImCON1 on the mixed solution containing Cr2O72− (Fig. 3h). ImCON1 was able to capture over 84% of Cr2O72− from the mixtures. This might be attributed to the high charge density of SO42− ions and their strong interaction with the polymer network. Moreover, the removal of MnO4− ions remained unperturbed by other anions, as depicted in Fig. 3i. These binary mixture studies demonstrated the efficacy of ImCON1 in capturing oxo-anions, even when competing anions were present in the solution.
To study the effect of temperature on adsorption, we have investigated the capacities of ImCON1 for oxo-anions at different temperatures. As depicted in Fig. S14,† we systematically investigated the adsorption capacities of ImCON1 for CrO42− ions across a range of temperatures. The results demonstrate that the adsorption capacity of ImCON1 for CrO42− ions is temperature-dependent. Starting at 20 °C with an adsorption capacity of approximately 277 mg g−1, the capacity steadily increased until it reached a peak value of 316.7 mg g−1 at 40 °C. Within this temperature interval, the enhancement in adsorption capacity upon increasing temperature is likely due to heightened molecular motion. This increased mobility promotes more effective interactions between ImCON1 and CrO42− ions, facilitating adsorption. Conversely, as the temperature ascended beyond 40 °C (at 50 °C, 60 °C, and 70 °C), a decline in adsorption capacity was observed. This phenomenon can be ascribed to the elevated thermal energy at higher temperatures, which may induce the desorption of pre-adsorbed CrO42− ions or disrupt the favourable binding interactions between the adsorbent (ImCON1) and the adsorbate (CrO42− ions). Our research on the temperature-modulated adsorption of CrO42− ions by ImCON1 reveals that an optimal temperature, around 40 °C in this context, can significantly enhance the adsorption capacity. In contrast, extremely low and high temperatures are detrimental to adsorption. These findings offer crucial insights for the practical application of ImCON1 in removing oxo-anions under diverse thermal conditions.
Furthermore, an ImCON1-packed chromatographic column was fabricated and employed to remove oxo-anions from water. A 0.5 mM stock solution of each oxo-anion was passed through the column. A noticeable colour change in the eluent occurred for Cr2O72−, CrO42−, and MnO4− ions, indicating their capture by ImCON1. UV-vis studies further confirmed the absence of Cr2O72−, CrO42−, and MnO4− ions in the eluted water, demonstrating the utility of the ImCON1-based column for removing toxic oxo-anions (Fig. 4a, c and e). To determine whether the removal process within the column was anion exchange or surface adsorption, water was passed through the column loaded with oxo-anion@ImCON1. The colourless eluent verified the anion exchange mechanism, ruling out surface adsorption. Subsequently, the reusability of ImCON1 was investigated with a NaBr solution. When 0.5 M NaBr was passed through the column for Cr2O72− and CrO42−, a yellow solution emerged, indicating the presence of Cr(VI) oxo-anions. ImCON1 maintained its efficiency with no significant fluctuations over ten consecutive cycles (Fig. 4b, d and f). This study confirmed that ImCON1 remained stable after adsorbing the target oxo-anions and being regenerated with 0.5 M NaBr, enabling repeated capture of these anions across multiple cycles.
The validation of ImCON1's practical applicability holds substantial significance. Industrial wastewater samples laden with dichromate anions were procured from Dongzheng Chemical Co., Ltd in Shangnan County, Shaanxi Province, China. Before the adsorption experiment, a comprehensive compositional analysis of the wastewater was meticulously executed. The analysis revealed the presence of a diverse array of anions, including Cl−, SO42−, and NO3−, cations such as Na+, Ca2+, and Fe3+, as well as organic substances. The wastewater exhibited a complex chemical makeup with a pH of approximately 6.5. Subsequently, adsorption experiments were conducted using ImCON1 in this industrial wastewater. The outcomes were remarkable. ImCON1 sustained a high adsorption rate for dichromate anions in this intricate wastewater milieu. The characteristic peak of Cr2O72− in the wastewater solution at λmax = 362 nm diminished rapidly. In a mere 30 seconds, approximately 82% of the chromate anions were removed, a performance comparable to that in pure synthetic solutions (Fig. S15†). The adsorption rate was scarcely influenced by the complex components present in the industrial wastewater. Regarding the saturated adsorption capacity, ImCON1 continued to showcase high-capacity adsorption performance. The saturated adsorption capacity for dichromate anions reached 331 mg g−1. These findings unequivocally demonstrate that ImCON1 can efficiently sequester dichromate anions in industrial wastewater, thereby highlighting its outstanding adaptability and tangible practical value in real-world applications.
Zeta potential provides crucial information about the surface charge of the material, which is closely related to its adsorption mechanism and stability in solution. We conducted zeta potential measurements on ImCON1 before and after the adsorption of Cr2O72− (Fig. S16†). Before adsorption, the zeta potential of ImCON1 in an aqueous suspension was measured to be +25.4 mV at a pH of 7. This positive zeta potential is consistent with the cationic nature of ImCON1, as it contains positively charged imidazolium groups on its surface. The positive charge on the surface of ImCON1 is responsible for attracting the negatively charged toxic oxo-anions through electrostatic interactions, facilitating the adsorption process. After the adsorption of Cr2O72−, the zeta potential of ImCON1 decreased to +16.4 mV. This significant decrease in the zeta potential indicates that the negatively charged Cr2O72− anions have been adsorbed onto the surface of ImCON1, neutralising a portion of the positive charge. The change in zeta potential also provides evidence for the anion-exchange mechanism, as the adsorbed anions alter the surface charge characteristics of the material. The change in zeta potential values of ImCON1 before and after adsorption of toxic oxo-anions indicates that the surface charge of ImCON1 is significantly affected by the adsorption process, and this change is directly related to the anion-exchange mechanism and the overall adsorption performance.
We employed Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations to elucidate the adsorption mechanism of oxo-anions on ImCON1 comprehensively. The optimised structures depicted in Fig. S17† vividly illustrate the spatial configurations of ImCON1 before and after the adsorption of CrO42−, Cr2O72−, and MnO4−. The specified distances, namely 2.116 Å for CrO42−, 2.447 Å for Cr2O72−, and 3.133 Å for MnO4−, between the oxo-anions and the ImCON1 framework, precisely quantify the proximity and potentially signify the interaction intensity. Simultaneously, Table S4† furnishes the sorbates' average isosteric heat and adsorption distances. The relatively elevated average isosteric heats, with values of 611.961 kcal mol−1 for CrO42−, 609.029 kcal mol−1 for Cr2O72−, and 612.196 kcal mol−1 for MnO4−, strongly indicate an exothermic adsorption process. These DFT-generated structural and thermodynamic data synergistically complement our experimental findings, thereby establishing a robust theoretical framework for a profound understanding of the adsorption behaviour, including the high adsorption capacities and selectivities exhibited by ImCON1 towards oxo-anions.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5su00122f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |