Na
Lin
ab,
Yun-Xia
Li
a,
Yu
Liu
a,
Kai-Qi
Sun
a,
Hong-Yan
Zhang
a,
Xiao-Wu
Lei
*a and
Zhi-Wei
Chen
*a
aResearch institute of Optoelectronic Functional Materials, School of Chemistry, Chemical Engineering and Materials, Jining University, Qufu, Shandong 273155, P. R. China. E-mail: xwlei_jnu@163.com; zw_chen@jnxy.edu.cn
bSchool of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Qufu Normal University, Qufu, Shandong 273165, P. R. China
First published on 18th September 2024
Low-dimensional organic–inorganic hybrid lead halide perovskites have attracted much interest in solid-state lighting and displays, but the toxicity and instability of lead halide are obstacles to their industrial applications, which must be overcome. As an alternative, Cu(I)-based hybrid metal halides have emerged as a new type of luminescent material owing to their diversified structure, adjustable luminescence, low toxicity and low cost. Herein, we report three one-dimensional (1D) hybrid Cu(I)-based halides with the general formula ACu2Br4 (A = [(Me)4-Pipz]2+ and [BuDA]2+ and [TMEDA]2+). These 1D hybrid Cu(I) halides display stable broadband blue emission with maximum emission peaks in the range of 445–474 nm and the highest photoluminescence quantum yield of 37.8%. Furthermore, in-depth experimental and theoretical investigations revealed that the broadband blue emissions originate from the radiative recombination of self-trapped excitons. Most importantly, there is no structural degradation and attenuation of emission intensity even after continuously soaking these halides in water for at least two months, demonstrating their ultra-high anti-water stability. Hirshfeld surface analysis shows that a large number of weak hydrogen bonds can protect the inorganic skeleton from degradation due to water. This work provides a new strategy for the design of water-stable Cu(I)-based halides with efficient blue emission and wide potential applications in humid environments.
Recently, low-dimensional organic–inorganic metal halides (OIMHs), which were derived from 3D bulk perovskites APbX3 using large organic cations to replace the A-site, have captured tremendous attention from researchers because of their adjustable structures and multifunctional optical/electronic applications such as the fabrication of light-emitting diodes (LEDs), X-ray scintillators, luminescence sensors and lasers.5–8 Remarkably, versatile large organic cations and abundant lead-free metal ions allow OIMHs to deliver two-dimensional (2D), one-dimensional (1D) and zero-dimensional (0D) structures based on the spatial arrangement of anionic inorganic and cationic organic species, resulting in variform crystal structures and tunable photophysical properties.9–11 Among these low-dimensional OIMHs, 1D hybrid metal halides feature richer structures constructed by connecting metal polyhedra through corner-, edge-, and face-sharing compared with 3D perovskites. In 1D hybrid metal halides, organic cations and inorganic metal–halogen anions are spatially independent with strong intrinsic quantum confinement, which endow 1D halides with an ultrahigh PLQY and optical stability in single crystals. Compared with the narrow light emission of 3D perovskites, the soft crystal lattice of 1D halides is prone to structural deformation in the excited state, which easily results in self-trapped excitons.12 Therefore, 1D OIMHs tend to display STE-associated broadband light emissions with potential applications in solid-state white lighting and display diodes.
To date, numerous low-dimensional OIMHs have been reported in multifunctional applications with broadband emissions based on In3+, Sb3+, Sn2+, Zn2+ and Cu+ ions. However, most In3+ and Sb3+-based halides display lower-energy broadband yellow, orange or red-light emissions, while Sn2+ in the tin halides is easily oxidized to Sn4+. In addition, the reported Zn2+-based halides exhibit blue light emission, generally with low luminescence efficiency.13–16 Relatively speaking, the Cu(I)-based OIMHs possess multiple advantages of low cost and toxicity, various coordination modes, diversified PL properties and high luminescence efficiency.17,18 In general, the copper(I) ion features three kinds of coordination environments from linear two-coordinated [CuX2]− unit, three-coordinated [CuX3]2− triangle and four-coordinated [CuX4]3− tetrahedron. Under the structural directing action and charge balance effect of versatile organic cations, these basic units act as secondary building blocks to assemble various anionic cuprous halogen moieties, such as [CuX2]−, [CuX3]2−, [CuX4]3−, [Cu2X3]−, [Cu2X4]2−, [Cu2X5]3−, [Cu3X6]3−, [Cu4X6]2−, [Cu6X9]3−, [Cu6X10]4− and [Cu8X10]2−.19 The fertile coordination structures endow hybrid cuprous halides with adjustable luminescence covering the whole visible spectral range, high PLQY and multiple optoelectronic applications. Accordingly, numerous Cu(I)-based halides have been reported to display diversified coordination modes and highly efficient broadband light emissions, which are widely applied in WLED, sensors and X-ray scintillators. However, it is challenging to realize blue light emission for low-dimensional metal halides due to the large Stokes shift of STE emission. Hence, though numerous Cu(I) halides exhibit red, green, yellow light emissions with high PLQYs, as shown in the previous work, rare blue-emissive Cu(I)-based low-dimensional hybrid halide have been achieved. For example, Xia et al. reported that 0D (C8H20N)2Cu2Br4 single crystals show blue emission centred at 468 nm with a near-unity PLQY of 99.7%, a large Stokes shift of 148 nm, and a good environmental stability along with strong X-ray absorption capability, which can lead to the preparation of a large-sized scintillator screen in nondestructive X-ray imaging.20 However, Cu-based low-dimensional hybrid halides still suffer from serious instability due to the facile oxidation of Cu(I) in the presence of moisture and oxygen.21 Thus, stability is still one of the problems that need to be addressed for Cu(I)-based OIMHs.
To date, some Cu(I) hybrid halides have been reported with high stabilities by virtue of the strong π–π interaction of the neighboring cations to protect the anionic units from water, oxygen and polar organic solvents.22 For instance, Xie et al. reported a stable 0D (C20H20OP)CuCl2 (C20H20OP+ = (methoxymethyl)triphenylphosphonium) single crystal with excellent water resistance stability for at least 24 h using the protection effect of the large organic cation.23 Although limited water-stable cuprous halides have been prepared to realize water stability, this successful achievement proves the feasibility of structural design engineering to enhance the intrinsic stability of low-dimensional cuprous halides.
To further expand this crystal structural engineering, we present a series of isostructural 1D hybrid Cu(I) halides that emit highly-efficient broadband blue emissions with the highest PLQY of 37.8% from the intrinsic STEs. Significantly, these cuprous halides exhibit excellent water-resistance stability benefiting from the surrounding protection effect of organic cations through abundant hydrogen bonding. Our work provides a new structural engineering strategy for the construction of highly water-stable 1D hybrid cuprous halides and application in underwater lighting.
As shown in the inset photographs of Fig. 2a–c, the synthesized single crystals of the three Cu(I) halides are colorless and transparent under sunlight, indicating almost no absorption in the visible light range. The UV-vis absorption spectra contain large absorption bands in the range of 200–350 nm, and the corresponding bandgaps are calculated to be 4.0 eV, 3.9 eV and 3.8 eV for [(Me)4-Pipz]Cu2Br4, [BuDA]Cu2Br4 and [TMEDA]Cu2Br4, respectively, based on the Tauc's function, which are comparable to that of the most reported low-dimensional copper halides (Fig. S2–S4†). Under 254 nm UV light irradiation, all three halides exhibit bright blue light emission, and the photophysical properties of the three halides were subsequently studied at room temperature. As shown in Fig. 2a–c, the strongest photoluminescence excitation (PLE) peaks of the three halides is located at 286 nm, 295 nm and 301 nm for [(Me)4-Pipz]Cu2Br4, [BuDA]Cu2Br4 and [TMEDA]Cu2Br4, respectively. At the strongest excitation wavelength, the three halides show broadband emissions centered at 445 nm, 457 nm and 474 nm with full-width at half-maximum (FWHM) of 54 nm, 73 nm and 80 nm and Stokes shifts of 159 nm, 162 nm and 173 nm, respectively. The calculated CIE chromaticity coordinates were (0.15, 0.11), (0.15, 0.16) and (0.15, 0.23) for [(Me)4-Pipz]Cu2Br4, [BuDA]Cu2Br4 and [TMEDA]Cu2Br4, respectively, according to the PL emission spectra, which is located in the blue light region (Fig. 2d–f). The excitation wavelength-dependent PL spectra and emission wavelength-dependent PLE spectra were recorded to investigate the emission nature. As shown in Fig. S5–S7,† the three halides feature identical PL spectra under varied excitation wavelength and the PLE spectra also remain unchanged, indicating that the blue light emissions stem from the recombination of the same excited states, which were further confirmed by only one emitting center in the 3D consecutive PLE/PL maps (Fig. S8†). Additionally, the finely ground microscale powders of the three halides also have sufficient emission intensity compared with the single crystals, ruling out the possibility of surface defect-induced emission (Fig. S9–S11†). The PL decay curves of the three halides were fitted by the biexponential function, which give an average PL lifetime of 7.1 μs, 12.2 μs and 15.6 μs for [(Me)4-Pipz]Cu2Br4, [BuDA]Cu2Br4 and [TMEDA]Cu2Br4, respectively, demonstrating the phosphorescence characteristics, resembling many reported low-dimensional Cu(I) halides (Fig. 2g–i).25–27 The photoluminescence quantum yield (PLQY) of the three halides were measured using the PL measurement system with the integrating sphere, which was calculate to be 37.8%, 13.6% and 10.3% for [(Me)4-Pipz]Cu2Br4, [BuDA]Cu2Br4 and [TMEDA]Cu2Br4, respectively (Fig. S12–S14†). These values are lower than those of some previously reported blue-emissive low-dimensional Cu(I)-based halides, such as (TPA)CuBr2,28 (C8H20N)2Cu2Br4,20 and (TEA)2Cu2Br4,29 but higher than those of the 3D bulk materials Cs2AgInCl6,30 [(Me)2-DABCO]Cu6I831 and [(NH4)2]CuPbBr5.32 Considering the large Stokes shift, wide FWHM and microsecond scale lifetime, these broadband blue light emissions can be ascribed to the radiative recombination of STEs resulting from the strong electro-phonon coupling, which is similar to those of various reported low-dimensional hybrid metal halides.33,34
The temperature-dependent PL spectra of [(Me)4-Pipz]Cu2Br4 were recorded from 80 K to 300 K to further investigate the mechanism of broadband blue light emission considering the highest PLQY. As shown in Fig. 3a and b, neither peak splitting nor the visible wavelength shift of the PL spectra was observed, indicating the single emission mechanism, which is consistent with the result from the wavelength-dependent PL and PLE measurement. In addition, the PL intensity increases monotonically along with decreasing temperature, which results from the weakened thermal vibration-induced nonradiative recombination. The thermal activation energy (Ea) can be calculated according to the Arrhenius formula to evaluate the excitation recombination degree as follows.
The band structure and density of states (DOS) based on DFT were calculated to in-depth understand the electronic property of [(Me)4-Pipz]Cu2Br4. As shown in Fig. 4a, the band structure shows a direct band gap of 3.2 eV. This value is slightly lower than the result of 4.0 eV obtained from the experiment due to the underestimated bandgap for the semiconductor in the DFT study.38–40 In addition, the relatively flat valence band maximum (VBM) and conduction band minimum (CBM) indicate the weak electronic interactions between the adjacent cuprous bromide chains, further verifying the intensive quantum confinement effect and highly localized electrons in [(Me)4-Pipz]Cu2Br4. The total and partial density of states (DOS) are shown in Fig. 4b, the VBM is mainly contributed by the Cu 3d and Br 4p states, whereas the CBM is mainly composed of the Br 4s orbital. The negligible contribution of organic cations to both the CBM and VBM verifies the highly localized excitons on the cuprous bromide chains, which further confirm that the emission should come from the STEs on the [Cu2Br4]2− chains. Further, the charge density in the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) and lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) is overwhelmingly located on the [Cu2Br4]2− chains, validating the highly localized excitons (Fig. 4c). Based on the above experimental and theoretical investigations, we ascribe the broadband blue light emission to the STEs, which is similar to that of many reported 1D hybrid halides. The schematic diagram of the proposed photophysics process is depicted in Fig. 4d.41–43 Upon UV light excitation, the electrons at the ground states are excited promptly to the excited states and then interact with phonon vibration to form self-trapped excitons due to the strong structural deformation at the excited state of the soft 1D crystal lattice. Subsequently, the excited electrons undergo intersystem crossing (ISC) from the singlet state to the triplet state as triplet STEs. Finally, the recombination from the STEs to the ground states gives rise to broadband light emission with a large Stokes shift.
Fig. 4 (a) Calculated band structure and (b) DOS; (c) Charge density of HOMO and LUMO; (d) Configuration diagram of the emission process of [(Me)4-Pipz]Cu2Br4. |
Despite recent advances in the synthesis and application of optoelectronic devices, the inherent instability of metal halides on exposure to heat and moisture still restricts their practical applications, which must be overcome fundamentally. The encapsulating strategy has been developed to achieve the high stability of OIMHs, but it still suffers from the complicated synthetic process. Hence, designing and synthesizing metal halides with intrinsic stability at the molecular level is of great significance for their practical applications.44,45 A series of contrast experiments show that these 1D halides feature high thermal and chemical stabilities. As shown in Fig. S16,† the TGA curves indicate that the three halides can be stable up to about at least 250 °C with high thermal decomposition temperature. In addition, these halides exhibit high chemical stabilities in various organic solvents. As shown in Fig. S17–S19,† the PXRD patterns and PL emission spectra after soaking in various organic solvents remained unchanged compared to that of the as-synthesized sample, indicating the high tolerance for these polar organic solvents. After exposure to humid air for one month, the PXRD pattern remained consistent with that of the as-synthesized sample and the PL emission intensity only reduced by 9.4%, demonstrating high stability in the atmospheric environment (Fig. S9†).
More interestingly, [(Me)4-Pipz]Cu2Br4 exhibits extraordinary anti-water stability besides the chemical and thermal stabilities. As shown in Fig. 5a, [(Me)4-Pipz]Cu2Br4 can still maintain the original shape and bright blue light emission even after continuous immersion in water for over two months. To further verify the structural stability, the PXRD pattern of the sample after soaking in water for two months was recorded. As shown in Fig. 5b, the PXRD pattern after soaking in water is in accordance with that of the initial sample, indicating no structural degradation and ultra-high stability in water. Fig. 5c shows the PL spectra before and after immersing the sample in water for different times, which exhibits the same spectral profile. We performed inductively-coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) for the residual solution after removing the sample, and the result indicates that negligible Cu+ dissolves in water with a low mass concentration of 21 ppm, showing almost no Cu+ leaching in the experimental process. Besides, the PL intensity reduces only 4.5% after two months compared to that of the pristine sample. Meanwhile, the PLQY of 34.8% is still close to that of the as-synthesized sample, further demonstrating the high anti-water stability (Fig. 5d). The anti-water stability of these 1D halides are comparable with those of previously reported Zn2+, Cu+ and Sn3+-based halides, such as (C4H9)4NCuCl2,46 (C20H20OP)CuCl2,23 (1,3-dppH2)2Cu4I8·H2O47 and (TBP)2SnCl6,48 further confirming the potential applications under extreme conditions. To deeply understand the nature of the ultra-high anti-water stability of [(Me)4-Pipz]Cu2Br4, Hirshfeld surface calculation was performed to analyze the intermolecular force between the [CuBr4]2− and [Me4-Pipz]2+ components using the CrystalExplorer software. As shown in Fig. 5e and f, abundant hydrogen bonds of C–H⋯Br between [CuBr4]2− and [Me4-Pipz]2+ were found with the proportion of 67.6% in all the weak intermolecular force of [(Me)4-Pipz]Cu2Br4, strengthening the interactions between the [CuBr4]2− anions and [Me4-Pipz]2+ cations, which is favourable for the high structural stability. In the crystal structure, the closely arranged [Me4-Pipz]2+ cations form a dense “shell” to tightly wrap the inorganic skeleton. Thus, the large amount of hydrogen bonds and separating effect from the organic component can protect the inorganic skeleton, further enhancing the anti-water stability as well as the thermal and chemical stabilities.49,50
Powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) data were obtained using a Bruker D8 ADVANCE powder X-ray diffractometer (Cu Kα, λ = 1.5418 Å) in the 2θ range of 5–50°. UV-vis absorption was measured directly on ground single crystals with BaSO4 as the substrate in the wavelength range of 200–1000 nm on a PE Lambda 900 UV/vis spectrophotometer. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was done on a Mettler TGA/SDTA 851 thermal analyzer under a N2 atmosphere with a heating rate of 10 °C min−1 from 25 °C to 800 °C.
The PLQY was determined on an FLS980 fluorescence spectrometer with an integrating sphere in the solid state, utilizing a 450 W xenon lamp with an excitation power of 600 μW cm−2 as the light source.
Calculation of PLQY. ηQE = IS/(ER − ES) was employed to calculate the value of PLQY, where IS is the sample's luminescence emission spectrum, ES is the wavelength of the integrating sphere's excitation light spectrum (without the sample), and ER is the sample's excitation spectrum.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2367415, 2367417 and 2367419. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4dt02072c |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |