Lin-Ping
Shi
a,
Wen-Liang
Li
a,
Pu-Yue
Wang
a,
Xiao-Ming
Wu
*b,
Zhao-Quan
Yao
*a,
Jiong-Peng
Zhao
*a and
Fu-Chen
Liu
*a
aTKL of Organic Solar Cells and Photochemical Conversion, School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Tianjin University of Technology, Tianjin 300384, China. E-mail: yaozq@email.tjut.edu.cn; zhaojp@tjut.edu.cn; fcliu@tjut.edu.cn
bKey Laboratory of Display Materials and Photoelectric Devices, Ministry of Education, Tianjin Key Laboratory of Photoelectric Materials and Devices, National Demonstration Center for Experimental Function Materials Education, School of Materials Science and Engineering, Tianjin University of Technology, Tianjin 300384, China. E-mail: wxm@tjut.edu.cn
First published on 19th April 2024
Although great efforts have been made to explore the exquisite rare-earth (RE) clusters, the design and construction of planar RE clusters with disk-like geometrical features are still scarce. Herein, a novel disk-like RE-cluster Y12 (abbreviated as 1), formulated as [Y12(L)10(CO3)4(NO3)2(μ3-OH)6] (H2L = 7,7′-(2-methylmethylene)bis(8-quinolonol)) was synthesized successfully under solvothermal conditions. Owing to the template effect and fruitful coordination modes of NO3−, a novel Y2⊂Y10 type structure with dual-core in the center position of the cluster, which distinguishes it from the traditional brucite-type disk-like RE-cluster was achieved. Based on the ESI-MS analysis, the possible assembly mechanism of Y5 → Y8 → Y12 is proposed. The luminescence investigation illustrates that this cluster not only shows green emission in solid-state and common organic solvents but also has obvious electroluminescent performance, which can be used as the emitting layer in organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs).
Up to now, most of the reported polynuclear RE-clusters exhibit stereo geometrical features such as cage-shaped,12,13 ball-shaped,6,14 windmill-shaped,9 barrel-shaped,16 drum-shaped,17 and tubular-shaped,19 which can be attributed to the diverse coordination modes and the poor directionality of the high-valent RE3+ ions. While, regulating the growth of RE3+ ions in a certain plane to form the exquisite disk-like cluster with a planar geometrical feature is hard to achieve. Heretofore, only a few cases of RE-clusters with planar structures have been reported.24–27 The coordination modes in these disk-like RE-clusters are all similar to brucite in which the RE3+ ions are arranged in the hexagonal close-packing mode.25–27 During the growth process, each RE3+ nuclear combines with six adjacent RE3+ ions via μ3-OH−/O2− bridging, thus, the nuclear number of this type of RE-cluster needs to satisfy the relation “1 + Σn6n” (n stands for the ring number in the Brucite structure), which will hinder the discovery of the novel planar RE-cluster with the other nuclear numbers. Therefore, breaking the constraints of the brucite-type structure and discovering new coordination modes is highly desired in fabricating the new disk-like RE-clusters.
Besides, in order to control the growth of RE3+ ions toward the disk-like structure in a certain plane, the design and selection of the auxiliary ligands are also significant. Distinguishing with the commercial ligands, the in situ ligand formation strategy is one of the effective methods for rationally fabricating RE clusters in a certain direction.13,27,28 Firstly, the in situ ligands formed by the oligomerization, decomposition, or rearrangement of raw ligands and solvents are always difficult or even impossible to synthesize by conventional organic synthesis methods could bring some specific coordination modes that could not only promote the RE3+ ions assembly in a specific direction but also induce polynuclear RE-clusters with intriguing architectures.27 Secondly, the ligand formation process is relatively slow, which can remarkably avoid the formation of the precipitate caused by the fast reaction between metal ions and organic ligands, providing sufficient reaction time to form sophisticated coordination modes.19 Last but not least, some anionic templates could be formed during in situ reactions, which has beneficial effects on the construction of polynuclear RE-clusters.13 In addition, the mixed anions template strategy also proves great effect on the assembly of the polynuclear RE-cluster owing to not only their template effect to induce the formation of the clusters with specific geometrical features but also their negative charges, which can balance the positive charges of RE3+ ions to stabilize the cluster.12,15
Based on the combined strategy of the in situ reaction and the mixed anions template method, an unprecedented disk-like exquisite RE-cluster (1) with the formula of [Y12(L)10(CO3)4(NO3)2(μ3-OH)6] (H2L = 7,7′-(2-methylmethylene)bis(8-quinolonol)) was designed and synthesized successfully. Structural analysis demonstrated that this disk-like Y12 can be split into the di-nuclear Y2 subunit, which is located in the center of Y12 and the charming decanuclear ring-shaped Y10 subunit, which encapsulates the Y2 core tightly. The whole Y12 cluster was surrounded by ten L2− ligands, which were formed by the in situ reaction.29,30 The linear geometrical feature and multi-coordination sites of these in situ ligands could regulate the cluster assembly in a specific direction. Moreover, instead of μ3-OH−/O2− in the reported RE-clusters with the brucite structure, the triangular NO3− ions were introduced and anchored in this cluster to act as linkers and templates. Owing to the fruitful coordination sites and the negative charge, which could balance the superfluous positive charge, the rule of “1 + Σn6n” in the brucite-type structure will be broken. Based on the combined effect between in situ ligands and anions template strategy, the unprecedented Y2⊂Y10 disk cluster Ln-structure was achieved. The possible assembly mechanism was also confirmed by ESI-MS. Furthermore, owing to the obvious green luminescence and the good solubility of 1, these exquisite RE-clusters were used as an emission layer to fabricate the OLED. The results provide a proof-of-concept and are of relevance to developing RE-clusters as emitting layers for OLEDs, providing a novel guideline for the application of RE-clusters.
The light-yellow quadrilateral single crystal of disk-like Y12-cluster was obtained by the solvothermal reaction of Y(NO3)3·6H2O, 8-hydroxyquinoline and sodium carbonate in the mixed solution of EtOH and H2O at 140 °C for 3d. Single crystal X-ray diffraction data indicates that this disk-like Y12-cluster 1 crystallizes in the P space group of the triclinic system (Table S1†). The length and width of the Y12-cluster can reach 21.4 and 22.6 Å, respectively, which demonstrates that the structure of this cluster is approximately perfect disk-shape. As shown in Fig. 1, the whole Y12-nanocluster consists of 12 Y3+ ions, ten in situ ligands (L2−), six μ3-OH− groups, four CO32− and two NO3−. In this structure, all the Y3+ ions exhibit octa-coordination modes and are tightly bridged by μ3-OH− or NO3−. Owing to the triangular coordination mode of μ3-OH− or NO3−, the twelve Y3+ ions are distributed in the equatorial plane to form the unprecedented disk-like Y/O core. The periphery of the Y/O core is surrounded by ten L2− which is generated via the in situ reaction between 8-quinolonol and EtOH (Scheme S1†), and these ligands are located above and below the cluster plane, forming the unique double-layered five-leaf windmill structure to protect the stability of Y12-cluster (Fig. 1a–c). Besides, four CO32− ions are inserted in the center Y2 subunit to balance the superfluous positive charges and stabilize the Y12 cluster.
In order to facilitate the analysis and investigation of the structural skeleton of 1, this disk-like Y12-cluster can be split into two types of cluster units: the center di-nuclear Y2 subunit (type I) and the ring-shaped Y10 subunit (type II). In type I, the coordination environments of these two Y3+ ions are identical. Each Y3+ ion exhibits an octa-coordination mode defined by three O atoms from μ3-OH− ion, three O atoms from two CO32− ions, and two O atoms from two NO3− ions and the coordination configuration is square antiprism (Fig. S1†). While in the type II subunit, the ten Y3+ ions in this ring-like structure have similar O6N2 octa-coordination modes. According to the different coordination environments, these Y3+ ions can be divided into three types, which are represented as Y1, Y2 and Y3. Atom Y1 is stabilized by two N atoms from two L2− ligands, four O atoms from four independent L2− ligands and two O atoms from one NO3− ion. Atom Y2 is attached to two N atoms from two L2− ligands, four O atoms from four L2− ligands, one O atom from NO3− ion and one O atom from μ3-OH− ion. While atom Y3 is connected by two N atoms from two L2− ligands, four O atoms from four L2− ligands and two O atoms from μ3-OH− ions (Fig. S1d†). According to the shape calculation, the coordination configuration of all these ten Y3+ ions are snub disphenoid (Fig. S1e†). Bridged by two μ3-NO3− μ3-NO3− and six μ3-OH−, the Y2 subunit is tightly anchored in the center position of the ring-like Y10 to form the unique Y2⊂Y10 disk-like clusters, which are packaged by ten L2− ligands in the same coordination pattern: μ3–η1:η2:η2:η1 (Fig. S1†). As shown in the crystal data of 1, the bond length distances of Y–O are in the range from 2.274 to 2.444 Å, and those of Y–N are within 2.405–2.730 Å (Tables S2 and S3†), which are similar to the reported Y cluster previously. Due to the structural similarity between CO32− and NO3−, it is difficult to confirm the co-existence of these two anions in the Y12-cluster using a single X-ray crystal diffraction technique, thus, FT-IR spectral measurements were performed. As shown in Fig. S2,† the main peaks of 1 are located at 3425 cm−1, 1630 cm−1, 1570 cm−1, 1463 cm−1, 1375 cm−1, and 590 cm−1. Among them, the peak at 3425 cm−1 corresponds to the stretching vibrations of the O–H bonds in μ3-OH− groups; those at 1630 cm−1 and 1570 cm−1 can be assigned to the stretching vibrations of CN and C
C bonds in L2− ligands; the peaks at 1463 cm−1 and 1375 cm−1 can be attributed to the stretching vibration of CO32− and NO3− ions, respectively, which indicated the co-existence of the CO32− and NO3− ions in the Y12-cluster (Fig. S2b†). Interestingly, compared to the traditional μ3-OH− bridging ligands, NO3− ions have similar triangular geometrical features and more fruitful coordination modes. Using NO3− instead of the μ3-OH−/O2− ions as the bridging ligands, the restriction of the “1 + Σn6n” rule in traditional brucite-type RE-cluster is broken, with the formation of the Y2 core, the outer shell is gradually assembled by Y10 to form the unprecedented core–shell Y2⊂Y10 disk-like structure. After that, the adjacent Y12 clusters are connected via two different C–H⋯π interactions (C49–H49⋯π, d1 = 2.767 Å; C34–H34⋯π, d2 = 2.985 Å) (Table S4†) to generate the 2-dimensional supermolecule structure (Fig. 2) and further packed to form the extended 3D crystalline structure via the van der Waals’ force. The 3D stacking diagram of the Y12 cluster (1) is shown in Fig. 2 and S1c.† To confirm the phase purity of the crystal sample of 1, PXRD measurements were performed. As shown in Fig. S2a,† the main characteristic diffraction peaks in the PXRD pattern of 1 can match well with the simulation, which indicates the high purity of the synthesized sample. The difference in the intensities between the experimental result and the simulation pattern can be attributed to the preferential selection of the crystal sample. The thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) suggested that before 370 °C, there was not any obvious weight loss in the Y12 cluster (Fig. S3†).
In order to further investigate the solution stability and the possible assembly mechanism of this unique disk-like Y12 cluster, the electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) of Y12 cluster by dissolving the crystals in DMF and methanol and the crystal reaction solution in the range of m/z = 300–6000 have been collected, respectively (Fig. S4†). As shown in Table S1,† the formula weight of 1 is 4676.34, however, in ESI-MS spectra of 1 dissolved in DMF and MeOH, the molecular ion peak of the Y12 cluster was not observed. The spectrum of 1 dissolved in DMF exhibits two prominent singly-charged ion peaks at m/z = 4469.601, and 4371.716 (Fig. S4†), which can be assigned to [Y12(L)9(CO3)4(NO3)2(μ3-OH)7(H2O)5]+ (cal. m/z 4469.080) and [Y12(L)9(CO3)3(NO3)2(μ3-OH)9(H2O)]+ (cal. m/z 4371.025), respectively. Compared with the molecular formula of 1, these two cations have the same Y12 cluster but contain more μ3-OH− and water and fewer L2− ions, which indicates that the core Y12 cluster is stable in DMF and MeOH. Furthermore, the stability of the core Y12 cluster under the condition of ESI-MS measurement also paves the way for exploring the possible self-assembly mechanism. Comparing the ESI-MS spectrum of the Y12 cluster reaction solution to that in organic solvents, there are two obvious peaks that stand for two different fragment species with charge states of +3 and +2 can be observed at m/z = 709.169 and 1523.145, respectively. In detail, the peak at m/z = 709.169 can be assigned to [Y5(L)3(HL)2(NO3)(μ3-OH)3]3+ ions (cal. m/z = 709.83). While the peak, which is located at m/z = 1523.145 can be attributed to [Y8(L)6(CO3)2(NO3)2(μ3-OH)4(CH3CH2OH)3]2+ ions (cal. m/z = 1523.765) (Table S5†). It is worth noting that compared to the high intensity of the peaks at m/z = 4469.601, and 4371.716 in the spectrum of Y12 dissolved in DMF, the similar peaks in the spectrum of the reaction solution can be negligible, instead, the intensities of the peaks at m/z = 709.169 and 1523.145 are much higher in the reaction solution, which means that during the self-assembly process, the Y3+ ions and the ligands were first constructed into Y5 or Y8 fragments, and then further assembled to form the Y12 clusters. Therefore, the possible assembly mechanism can be summarized as Y5 → Y8 → Y12. As shown in Fig. S5,† firstly, the Y3+ ions occupy the periphery position and are bridged via the L2− ligands, NO3− and μ3-OH− ions react to form the arc-shaped cluster (Y5) which is similar to the crescent, then, the Y5 cluster combine with other two Y3+ ions at the periphery position and one Y3+ ion, which is located in the core position, to produce the semicircle-shaped Y8 cluster. Finally, Y8 connects the other four Y3+ ions via the bridging effect of NO3− and μ3-OH− ions to form the disk-like Y12 cluster. As far as we know, this is the first time to explore the possible assembly mechanism of the non-brucite type disk-like RE-cluster, which contains two RE3+ in the center position of the cluster.
One of the charming properties of the exquisite RE-clusters (especially Ln-cluster) is their unique photoluminescence emission derived from the f–f electronic transition, which has many distinctive optical attributes, i.e. large Stokes shifts, narrow line emission, and long lifetimes.31,32 However, owing to the Laporte-forbidden of the 4f–4f transition, the Ln-clusters always need auxiliary organic ligands to act as “antenna” to achieve strong emission.33 Distinguish with the normal exquisite Ln-cluster, in this work, the disk-like Y12 cluster (1) exhibits illustrious green light broad band emission, which can be attributed to the emission of the organic ligands (L2−). In Fig. S6a,† the UV-vis absorption spectrum exhibits a wide range of absorption peaks in the range from 250 nm to 500 nm, which can be attributed to the π–π* electronic transition in organic ligands. According to the calculation results of the Kubelka–Munk function, the band gap of 1 is 2.25 eV indicating its semiconductor characteristic of 1 (Fig. S6b†). As shown in Fig. 3, the normalized excitation and emission spectra of 1 in different states have been measured at room temperature. In the excitation spectra of 1, the peak profiles are quite different, and the maximum values are 440 nm (solid-state), 343 nm (in MeOH) and 424 nm (in DMF). While the emission spectra of this Y12 cluster (1) in the solid state and dissolved in MeOH or DMF exhibit a similar broad band single peak profile. Among them, the emission maximum value of 1 in the solid state is 533 nm, which is red-shifted by 50 nm relative to that of the pure L2− ligands, this is very common for organic luminescence ligand-based coordination complexes, which can be attributed to the reduced nonplanar distance between the two quinoline groups in L2−, due to the special coordination modes in this cluster.34 As 1 is dissolved in MeOH or DMF, an obvious blueshift of the emission peak can be observed and the emission maximum value reached 510 nm (in MeOH) and 522 nm (in DMF), owing to the solvation effect. Besides, at room temperature, the photoluminescence quantum yield (ΦF) of 1 is 4.95% with a nanosecond lifetime (Fig. S6c and d†). The short lifetime further demonstrates that the luminescence of 1 should be attributed to the ligand emission rather than the LMCT (ligand-to-metal charge transfer). On account of the good solubility and solvent stability in common organic solvents (DMF and MeOH) and the moderate luminescence emission property, this disk-like Y12 cluster can be the luminescent layer for assembling the light-emitting device.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Normalized excitation and emission spectra of 1 in the solid state and dissolved in methanol and DMF. |
In order to obtain a homogeneous film with a controlled distribution of the emission layers, the spin-coating method was used due to not only its economical properties but also this method has tiny influence on the photophysical properties of the luminescence materials.35 In this work, DMF was chosen to disperse and dissolve the crystal sample of 1 to prepare the liquid precursor, then the complex film was prepared by the spin-coating method and the phase purity of this film was examined by PXRD (Fig. S7†). According to the SEM images of the thin film (Fig. S8a†), the nano-crystal particles of the Y12 clusters can be distributed on the ITO with uniform morphology. Furthermore, the EDX mapping images reflect the uniform distribution of Y, C, N, and O in this thin film sample (Fig. S8b–f†). The UV-vis absorption and photoluminescence spectra of film sample 1 are shown in Fig. S9.† Similar to the solid sample, the absorption spectrum of the film sample also exhibits a wide-range absorption peak in the range from 250 to 500 nm. Under the 350 nm excitation, the film sample displays an obvious green emission color and the emission spectrum of 1 in the film sample exhibits a broad band centered at 515 nm, which is very similar to those recorded in the solid state and dissolved in DMF. Based on the luminescence property, the film sample of 1 can be a good candidate as the luminescent layer in an OLED device. As shown in Fig. 4a and b, the entire OLED device was assembled by the indium-tin-oxide (ITO) coated glass substrate as the anode, the poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene): polystyrene sulfonate (PEDOT:PSS, 40 nm) as the hole transport layer, Y12-cluster film as a luminescent layer (110 nm), the 1,3,5-tris(1-phenyl-1H-benzimidazol-2-yl)benzene (TPBi, 40 nm) as the electron transport layer, the LiF layer (1 nm) as the electron injection layer. Finally, 120 nm aluminum film was evaporated on top of the device as the cathode. The electroluminescence (EL) spectrum indicates that this OLED device with 40 nm PEDOT:PSS and 40 nm TPBi could exhibit a wide range of emission peaks in the range from 450 to 650 nm, the maximum is located at 532 nm (Fig. 4c). The CIE chromaticity coordinates were calculated to be (0.332, 0.514), which are located in the green light area (Fig. 4e). The photograph of the emission color further demonstrates the green light emission of the OLED. According to the voltage–current density–luminance (J–V–L) curves (Fig. 4d), the turn-on voltage is as low as 4 V with a luminance of 3 cd m−2. Besides, the luminance of this OLED shows a positive correlation depending on the voltage, and the maximum luminance of 84 cd m−2 can be obtained under 9 V before the degradation of the device. Although the performance of this Y12-cluster-based OLED device is not comparable to the commercial devices or other reported metal–organic complexes (Table S6†),36,37 this is the first systematic investigation on the EL performance of the larger RE-cluster (REnn > 10) as the emitter.
In summary, based on the combined effect of the in situ ligands, formation strategy and the anions template strategy, the rule of the “1 + Σn6n” in the traditional brucite-type RE-cluster was broken. An unprecedented disk-like Y12 cluster with Y2⊂Y10 type structure was synthesized. The structural analysis demonstrated that the two Y3+ ions form the Y2 core, which was located in the center position, while the other ten Y3+ ions were bridged by the in situ ligands to form the ring-like subunit and encapsulate the Y2 core tightly. The ESI-MS of 1 not only revealed that the metal skeleton of the Y12 cluster has good solubility and stability in some common organic solvents (DMF and MeOH) but also indicated the possible assembly mechanism could be Y5 → Y8 → Y12. Furthermore, owing to the noticeable green light emission property, we successfully fabricated the green OLED based on the Y12 cluster as a luminescence layer, and the device presents obvious electroluminescent characteristics with a luminance of 84 cd m−2 at 9 V. This work not only proposes a novel strategy for design and synthesis the disk-like RE-clusters but also provides a proof-of-concept for the application of the exquisite RE-clusters in the field of OLEDs.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Additional crystallographic data. CCDC 2335670. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4qi00635f |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2024 |