Zhihui
Xiong
a,
Haotian
Tian
*b,
Zhixi
Li
a,
Guowei
Deng
*a,
Fang
Ding
a,
Qian
Wu
b and
Mingjun
Xia
*b
aSchool of Innovation and Entrepreneurship, Chengdu Normal University, Chengdu 611130, China. E-mail: guoweideng86@163.com
bBeijing Center for Crystal Research and Development, Key Laboratory of Functional Crystals and Laser Technology, Technical Institute of Physics and Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China. E-mail: tianhaotian@mail.ipc.ac.cn; xiamingjun@mail.ipc.ac.cn
First published on 9th April 2025
The development of birefringent materials, especially infrared (IR) birefringent crystals, has been limited by conflicting microstructural requirements, such as broad transmission range, wide band gap, and large birefringence. In this work, we propose a “low-dimensional motif intercalation” strategy for designing high-performance birefringent materials. Utilizing the layered selenophosphorus Ba3P2Se8 as a prototype compound, a novel IR birefringent crystal Ba4HgP2Se10 with enhanced birefringence was successfully synthesized by the intercalation of the linear [HgSe2]2− moieties, while the outstanding optical properties such as wide band gap and long IR cutoff were maintained. Notably, the Ba4HgP2Se10 crystal exhibits the largest band gap among known selenophosphorus compounds, accompanied by a wide IR transmittance range and substantial birefringence. Theoretical calculations reveal that the outstanding optical properties of Ba4HgP2Se10 arise from the synergistic interaction between Ba2+ cations, [HgSe2]2− anions, and the layered selenophosphorus framework.
Traditional birefringent crystals are primarily composed of halides and oxides. Among them, oxide crystals have long been the focus of research due to their excellent birefringence and large band gaps. Many outstanding oxide birefringent crystals, such as YVO4,11 LiNbO3,12 CaCO3,13 TiO2,14 and α-BaB2O4,15 have been developed over the years. However, the absorption vibrations of metal–oxygen bonds in these oxide crystals severely limit their IR transmission range, not suitable for IR wavelength range applications. In contrast, the halide crystal MgF2 not only has a large band gap but also exhibits high transparency from the UV to IR region. Unfortunately, its practical application is significantly restricted by its weak birefringence (0.012@1064 nm).16 Therefore, there is a pressing need to develop birefringent crystals for IR applications. Sulfides, phosphides, and selenides have long been studied as classical candidates for IR optoelectronic materials. Among these, selenides typically exhibit a wider IR transmission range than phosphides and sulphides, as the heavier atomic mass of selenium can effectively reduce lattice vibrational phonon energy.17 In recent years, several excellent selenide IR crystals have been developed, such as BaGa4Se7,18 PbGa4Se7,19 BaGa2GeSe6,20 NaAsSe2,21 BaHgGeSe4,22 and PbGa2GeSe6.23 However, due to the selenium's relatively weak electronegativity, the most reported selenide crystals have a smaller band gap with a low laser damage threshold, making them susceptible to photorefractive damage. Therefore, the exploration of an effective strategy to balance the three key properties—wide transmission range, high birefringence, and large band gap—is critical for the design of high-performance IR birefringent crystals.
According to the functional motif theory, the macroscopic optical properties of crystals are closely related to the microscopic optical properties of the constituted functional motifs and their arrangements.24 In general, low-dimensional functional motifs, such as two-dimensional (2D) planar groups and one-dimensional (1D) linear units, typically exhibit high polarizability anisotropy, which promotes the formation of large birefringence.25 Additionally, heavy elements can effectively lower the phonon energy of lattice vibrations, thereby extending the IR transmission range. Functional motifs with a strong covalent character typically exhibit a large HOMO–LUMO gap, which contributes to broadening the band gap.26–31 A crystal that incorporates all these characteristics can achieve a balance between IR transmission, birefringence, and band gap. In principle, these features can be simultaneously realized by integrating functional motifs into a suitable and easily modifiable structural framework.
In this work, we propose a “low-dimensional motif intercalation” strategy, which involves constructing a multifunctional 2D layered framework suitable for the IR region and introducing low-dimensional functional motifs between its layers. This is mainly based on the following three considerations: (i) the balance between the band gap and the IR cutoff can be achieved by selecting appropriate building blocks for the layered framework; (ii) the weaker binding energy between adjacent layers provides significant flexibility for introducing additional functional units with high polarizability anisotropy, offering a unique opportunity to enhance birefringence; and (iii) the layered framework itself exhibits relatively high anisotropy, which also contributes to the birefringence. To implement this strategy, we focused on selenophosphorus for the selection of the layered framework construction templates. On the one hand, the heavier atomic mass of selenium contributes to a broader IR transmission range in crystals. On the other hand, the similarity in electronegativity between phosphorus and selenium enables the formation of relatively strong covalent bonds, contributing to the expansion of the band gap. Furthermore, considering that the introduction of alkaline earth metal elements can effectively reduce the dispersion of the compounds, the Ba2+ ion was selected as a counter ion to further increase the atomic mass. Based on these considerations, a selenophosphorus compound Ba3P2Se8 with a layered structure was screened as a prototype compound, as expected, which can achieve a balance between a large band gap and a long IR cutoff (Fig. S1†). To further enhance its birefringence (theoretical calculations show that its birefringence is 0.095@1064 nm), guided by the above design strategy, the linear [HgSe2]2− unit was further introduced into the interlayer, while hoping that its heavier mass can further extend the IR transmission range. Accordingly, a novel birefringent crystal Ba4HgP2Se10 was successfully synthesized. Notably, the synergy between the selenophosphorus layered framework and [HgSe2]2− units resulted in a broad IR transmission range, a large birefringence (0.152@1064 nm), and a wide band gap (2.45 eV), achieving an optimal balance among the three key performance parameters. In particular, the band gap of Ba4HgP2Se10 was the widest observed among selenophosphides to date. Herein, we report its synthesis, crystal structure, optical properties, and theoretical calculations.
Ba3P2Se8 crystallizes in the centrosymmetric space group P21/a of the monoclinic crystal system. The structure features two distinct environments for P atoms (P1 and P2) and two environments for Ba ions (Ba1 and Ba2). Both P1 and P2 atoms coordinate with four Se atoms to form [PSe4] tetrahedra, with P–Se bond lengths ranging from 2.208 to 2.220 Å. Two [PSe4] tetrahedra extend along the a- and b-axes through the connection of Ba1 ions, forming two nearly opposite polar layers (Fig. 1a and b). These polar layers are interconnected via Ba1 ions to create a double-layer framework (Fig. 1a). This framework is further stabilized along the c-axis by Ba2 cations, ultimately resulting in the three-dimensional (3D) crystal structure of Ba3P2Se8 (Fig. 1b).
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 (a) The double-layer of Ba3P2Se8. (b) 3D crystal structure of Ba3P2Se8 in the bc plane. (c) The three-layer of Ba4HgP2Se10. (d) 3D crystal structure of Ba4HgP2Se10 in the bc plane. |
Ba4HgP2Se10 crystallizes in the centrosymmetric space group P of the triclinic crystal system. In the structure, there are nine crystallographically independent atoms with one Hg atom, two Ba atoms (Ba1 and Ba2), five Se atoms, and one P atom. Each P atom is coordinated to four Se atoms, forming a [PSe4] tetrahedron with P–Se bond lengths ranging from 2.208 to 2.220 Å. Each Hg atom, in turn, is bonded to two Se atoms, forming a linear [HgSe2] unit with an Hg–Se bond length of 2.440 Å. Due to the symmetry restrictions of the space group P
, the [PSe4] tetrahedra adopt two opposite orientations within the structure (Fig. 1c and d). Similarly to its parent compound Ba3P2Se8, the two [PSe4] tetrahedra in Ba4HgP2Se10 extend along the a- and b-axes through the connection of Ba1 ions, thereby forming two oppositely oriented polar layers (Fig. 1c and d). The introduction of the [HgSe2] units leads to the isolation of the two oppositely oriented [PSe4] units, effectively inserting a non-polar layer composed of [HgSe2] units and Ba1 ions between the two polar layers of Ba3P2Se8. These three layers are interconnected via Ba1 ions, forming a non-polar three-layer structural framework (Fig. 1c and d). This framework is further extended along the c-axis by Ba2 ions, resulting in the formation of the 3D crystal structure of Ba4HgP2Se10 (Fig. 1d).
As shown in Fig. 2a, the diffuse reflectance spectrum reveals a band gap of 2.45 eV for Ba4HgP2Se10, corresponding to a cutoff wavelength of 506 nm. To the best of our knowledge, this is the widest band gap observed among selenophosphorus compounds, significantly greater than those of others including K2P2Se6 (2.08 eV),36 Rb2P2Se6 (2.32 eV),36 KZrPSe6 (2.2 eV),37 RbZrPSe6 (2.2 eV),37 CsZrPSe6 (2.3 eV),37 KPSe6 (2.16 eV),38,39 RbPSe6 (2.18 eV),38,39 K0.6Cs0.4PSe6 (2.1 eV),40 β-CsPSe6 (1.9 eV),40 KNb2PSe10 (1.19 eV),41 RbNb2PSe10 (1.16 eV),41 CsNb2PSe10 (1.07 eV),41 Cs5BiP4Se12 (1.85 eV),42 Cs5P5Se12 (2.17 eV),43 K4GeP4Se12 (2.0 eV),44 Rb4GeP4Se12 (2.0 eV),44 and Cs4GeP4Se12 (2.0 eV).44 To further understand the origin of this wide band gap, we calculated the band gap and PDOS curves of Ba4HgP2Se10 and compared them with those of its parent compound, Ba3P2Se8. As shown in Fig. S5,† Ba4HgP2Se10 exhibits a higher calculated band gap compared to Ba3P2Se8. Interestingly, the PDOS analysis shows that the top of the valence band and the bottom of the conduction band in both compounds are mainly composed of Se-p, P-s, P-p and Ba-d states, indicating that the band gap in both compounds is governed by the [PSe4] unit and the ionic interactions between [PSe4] units and Ba2+ ions (Fig. S6†). To further elucidate the microscopic mechanism underlying this band gap difference, we analyzed the electron density maps of the two compounds. As shown in Fig. S7,† the introduction of [HgSe2] units in Ba4HgP2Se10 effectively isolates the adjacent [PSe4] tetrahedra, resulting in no overlap of the electron clouds between neighboring layers. It is likely that this structural difference inhibits electronic interactions between the adjacent [PSe4] units, thus contributing to the widening of the band gap.
To characterize the transmission range of Ba4HgP2Se10, IR spectra were measured. As shown in Fig. 2b, the IR cut-off edge of Ba4HgP2Se10 is approximately 21.5 μm. Notably, this IR cut-off edge exceeds those of many well-known birefringent crystals, such as MgF2 (7.04 μm),16 CaCO3 (2.3 μm),13 YVO4 (5 μm),11 TiO2 (4.5 μm),14 LiNbO3 (5 μm),12 and α-BaB2O4 (3.5 μm).15 It also outperforms several previously reported phosphide and sulfide crystals, including CdSiP2 (9 μm),45 ZnGeP2 (12.5 μm),46 MgSiP2 (10.3 μm),47,48 AgGaS2 (13 μm),49 and AgGaSe2 (16 μm).49 More importantly, such a long IR cut-off combined with a large band gap allows Ba4HgP2Se10 to exhibit a wide transmission range superior to those of all commercial birefringent crystals to date (Fig. 4). Since the IR transmission range of materials is closely related to the phonon energy of lattice vibrations, we speculate that the exceptional IR transmission range of Ba4HgP2Se10 is due to the relatively high atomic masses of Ba, Hg, P, and Se. These heavier atoms likely lower the phonon energy of lattice vibrations, thereby broadening the IR transmission range.
To characterize the birefringence of Ba4HgP2Se10, refractive index dispersion curves were calculated. As shown in Fig. 3a, the refractive indices of Ba4HgP2Se10 are n[100] = 2.68, n[010] = 2.77, and n[001] = 2.62 at a wavelength of 1064 nm, respectively, indicating that the birefringence of Ba4HgP2Se10 at 1064 nm is 0.152 (Fig. 3b), significantly higher than that of its parent compound Ba3P2Se8 (0.093 at 1064 nm). Notably, the experimental refractive indices of Ba4HgP2Se10 will be obtained using the devices by cutting from the bulk crystal in the future. To elucidate the mechanism behind the enhancement of birefringence, the electron density maps of both compounds were calculated. As shown in Fig. S7,† although the electron density around the [PSe4] unit is nearly isotropic, the laminar framework of Ba3P2Se8 leads to significant interlayer voids that reduce the electron density along the c-axis. This results in a marked difference in the electron density between the c-direction and the in-plane direction, which may be the primary origin of birefringence in Ba3P2Se8. In contrast, the interlayer gap in Ba4HgP2Se10 is further expanded due to the incorporation of the [HgSe2] unit, which further decreases the electron density in the c-direction. This further enhances the electron density contrast between the c-direction and within the layer, contributing to an enhanced birefringence mechanism. Additionally, apart from the contribution from the layered framework, the electron cloud around the [HgSe2] unit in Ba4HgP2Se10 exhibits significant anisotropy. Gaussian calculations indicate that its polarizability anisotropy is as high as 117.5, which is substantially greater than the anisotropy value of 9.0 of the [PSe4] unit, suggesting that the [HgSe2] unit also plays a significant role in enhancing birefringence. Furthermore, since all the [HgSe2] units in the structure are arranged in parallel and their projection along the b-axis is significantly larger than those in other directions (Fig. 3c), the electron density along the b-axis is substantially higher compared to the a- and c-axes (Fig. 3d and e). This may lead to a significantly stronger response in the b direction than those in the a and c directions when interacting with the incident light, causing the wave velocity in the b direction to decrease more significantly than those in the a and c directions, and thus the refractive index along the b direction is significantly higher than those along the a and c directions, which could be another main reason for the large birefringence of Ba4HgP2Se10 and is consistent with the calculated refractive index dispersion curves (nb > na > nc) (Fig. S8†). That is, the co-operation of the laminar framework and the linear [HgSe2] unit creates the large birefringence of Ba4HgP2Se10. Notably, the birefringence of Ba4HgP2Se10 exceeds those of many commercially available birefringent crystals, such as α-BBO (Δn = 0.116 at 1064 nm),15 LiNbO3 (Δn = 0.089 at 1064 nm),12 and MgF2 (Δn = 0.012 at 1064 nm)16 (Fig. 4). Moreover, it also possesses a large band gap and a wide IR transmission range. These results indicate that Ba4HgP2Se10 should be a promising IR birefringent crystal.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Crystallographic data and structural data (Tables S1–S4), figures presenting the calculation results of Ba3P2Se8 (Fig. S1), and figures presenting the measurement results and details of Ba4HgP2Se10 (Fig. S2–S8). CCDC 2413877 for Ba4HgP2Se10. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5dt00186b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |