Nicole R.
Raniszewski
,
Jenna N.
Beyer
,
Myles I.
Noel
and
George M.
Burslem
*
Department of Biochemistry and Biophysics, Department of Cancer Biology and Epigenetics Institute, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, PA 19104, USA. E-mail: George.Burslem@Pennmedicine.upenn.edu
First published on 7th February 2024
Ubiquitination is a key post-translational modification on protein lysine sidechains known to impact protein stability, signal transduction cascades, protein–protein interactions, and beyond. Great strides have been made towards developing new methods to generate discrete chains of polyubiquitin and conjugate them onto proteins site-specifically, with methods ranging from chemical synthetic approaches, to enzymatic approaches and many in between. Previous work has demonstrated the utility of engineered variants of the bacterial transpeptidase enzyme sortase (SrtA) for conjugation of ubiquitin site-specifically onto target proteins. In this manuscript, we’ve combined the classical E1/E2-mediated polyubiquitin chain extension approach with sortase-mediated ligation and click chemistry to enable the generation of mono, di, and triubiquitinated proteins sfGFP and PCNA. We demonstrate the utility of this strategy to generate both K48-linked and K63-linked polyubiquitins and attach them both N-terminally and site-specifically to the proteins of interest. Further, we highlight differential activity between two commonly employed sortase variants, SrtA 5M and 7M, and demonstrate that while SrtA 7M can be used to conjugate these ubiquitins to substrates, SrtA 5M can be employed to release the ubiquitin from the substrates as well as to cleave C-terminal tags from the ubiquitin variants used. Overall, we envision that this approach is broadly applicable to readily generate discrete polyubiquitin chains of any linkage type that is accessible via E1/E2 systems and conjugate site-specifically onto proteins of interest, thus granting access to bespoke ubiquitinated proteins that are not currently possible.
In addition to the challenges that exist for the robust generation of custom polyubiquitin chains, there are limitations to the current strategies for the site-specific attachment of polyubiquitin chains onto proteins of interest. Commonly employed approaches utilize chemistry-driven methods such as native chemical ligation (NCL)8,11,12 and thiol-alkene conjugation13,14 and endopeptidase strategies.15 Recently, the Lang group demonstrated a methodology to site-specifically ubiquitinate proteins utilizing the bacterial transpeptidase enzyme sortase A (SrtA) from Staphylococcus aureus.16 Sortase was first discovered as a key enzyme involved in bacterial cell wall assembly and has been posited to be a potential target for antimicrobial therapies,17,18 but has since also been employed in countless bioconjugation applications including self-cleaving peptides and proteins,19,20 antibody–drug conjugate assembly,21 and many more.22 Broadly, sortase utilizes its own catalytic cysteine residue to catalyze the transfer of a peptide bearing an LPXTG motif onto an N-terminal glycine-bearing peptide substrate (Scheme 1). Sortase A from Staphylococcus aureus in particular has been a prominent target for bioengineering efforts, with labs designing mutants that catalyze the transpeptidation in the absence of calcium,23 improving the catalytic activities,24 and engineering mutants with different substrate specificities.25,26
Scheme 1 Engineered sortase bacterial transpeptidase can be used in combination with ubiquitin mutants bearing C-terminal sortase motif and His-tag (UbKXSrt-His). |
The approach outlined by Fottner et. al. enables expedient preparation of ubiquitinated substrates utilizing two point mutations in the C-terminal tail of ubiquitin which also renders it resistant to DUB protease activity (Scheme 1). We theorized that we could we employ this sortase system coupled with a classic E1/E2 chain extension approach to readily generate polyubiquitin chains of varying length in vitro, then subsequently select for sortase compatible chains by enrichment of a C-terminal His-tag on ubiquitin. Through this work, we successfully purified several unique polyubiquitin chains in a facile manner and conjugated them to both the N-terminal glycine and a specified internal position of substrate protein sfGFP. Further, we demonstrated the utility of this approach to remove ubiquitin from these same substrates in a sortase-dependent manner, demonstrating the modularity of this system while highlighting differential activities between SrtA 5M and SrtA 7M, two commonly employed sortase variants. Finally, to demonstrate the generality of this work, we attached K63 and K48-linked polyubiquitin to DNA replication protein proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) at position 164, a heavily modified position required for DNA translesion synthesis.27
To generate polyubiquitin chains, we generated a UbK48Srt-His construct that is proximally blocked and can only be chain extended outward from lysine 48. We reacted wild type ubiquitin (Ub WT) and UbK48Srt-His in a 3:1 ratio with UbK48Srt-His as the proximal ubiquitin to drive chain extension. For tri ubiquitin and higher order polyubiquitin chains, we found that using purified polyubiquitin chains of Ub(n-1) in lieu of monomeric Ub WT (Fig. S4, ESI†) yielded more favourable results during chain extension. As anticipated, we observed two species for each multimer of ubiquitin (Fig. 1A) corresponding to WT and Srt-compatible isoforms. Upon IMAC enrichment we were able to completely separate the His-tagged polyubiquitin species from the non-His-tagged species (Fig. 1A), thus providing facile access to substrates for sortase mediated conjugations. Previous work reports that polyubiquitin chains of different lengths can be easily purified from one another based on size and charge by cation exchange chromatography,6,28 though when we applied this to our workflow, we found that presence of the C-terminal His-tag altered the elution profiles of the chains and ultimately hindered the cation exchange purification. To combat this challenge, we explored the use of SrtA to exchange the C-terminal His-tag for a shorter motif. Pleasingly, by using SrtA 5M29 in the presence of an excess of a diglycine peptide, we were able to drive trans-amidation from the –GGHHHHHHH to –GG, restoring the original sortase recognition motif (–LLPLTGG), rather than hydrolysis (which would result in the production of sortase-incompatible UbK0-LLPLT). Indeed, upon treatment with SrtA 5M at 37 °C, we observed near complete cleavage of the His-tag from UbK48Srt-His to give UbK48Srt species in as little as 30 minutes (Fig. 1B and Fig. S1, ESI†). Interestingly, we also tested the hydrolysis and trans-amidation via the calcium-independent mutant sortase SrtA 7M23 but did not see any significant hydrolysis, even after 16 hours (Fig. S2, ESI†).
Thus following enzymatic synthesis, IMAC and C-terminal editing, different chains could be readily separated from one another by length via cation exchange chromatography (Fig. 1C, D and Fig. S5, ESI†) with purified chains yielding 1–4% on average, which is consistent with literature reports.28 To demonstrate the generalizability of this system, we also generated K63-linked ubiquitin oligomers via the same approach (Fig. 1C, D and Fig. S5, ESI†) by using different E1/E2 enzymes.
Following the generation of UbK0Srt-sfGFP, we were curious about the reversibility of this reaction. After reaction of SrtA 5M with UbK0Srt-sfGFP, we observed slower hydrolysis of UbK0Srt-sfGFP than the hydrolysis of the His-tag from UbK48Srt-His (Fig. 1B), with gradual hydrolysis leading to near-complete cleavage of UbK0Srt-sfGFP after 16 hours (Fig. 2C and D). When the cleavage assays were conducted in the presence of 1 mM GG and GGG peptides, we observed a faster rate of cleavage (estimated half-life ∼2 h) by SrtA 5M for both sets of GG/GGG peptides (Fig. S3, ESI†), while we observed no cleavage of the UbK0Srt-sfGFP species after 16 h when using SrtA 7M (Fig. S2, ESI†). Further, when cleaving with SrtA 5M in the presence of GG peptide, we observed near-quantitative production of the original UbK0Srt species by LC/MS (Fig. S1, ESI†). This provided useful insight into the use of the two sortase variants for control of our experimental system.
To generate site-specifically (poly)ubiquitinated PCNA, we first performed GCE to incorporate the pAzF click handle into the protein (Fig. 4A and B, left). We selected K164 as the point of conjugation given its significance in DNA translesion synthesis. To do so, we mutated the K164 position to an Amber stop codon (TAG) for GCE and added a C-terminal His-tag for purification. pAzF incorporation was robust at this site, with the final PCNA product showing high fidelity incorporation of the pAzF (Fig. 4B, left and Fig. S5, ESI†). Following purification, the PCNA-164pAzF was subjected to SPAAC with GGG-DBCO to install the oligoglycine handle for sortylation (Fig. 4B). Following SPAAC, we utilized SrtA 7M to conjugate purified mono (Fig. 4C), di, and triubiquitin linked by either K48 or K63 to the PCNA trimers at site 164. Both K48-linked and K63-linked polyubiquitin were successfully conjugated onto this position and were visible by SDS-PAGE stained with Coomassie Blue (Fig. 4D) as well as Western blotting against ubiquitin, K48-linked polyubiquitin, or K63-linked polyubiquitin (Fig. 4E and Fig. S7, ESI†) thus demonstrating our approach.
Fig. 4 Generating site-specifically polyubiquitinated PCNA. (A) Schematic showing general workflow of generation of PCNA-164Ubn. [PDB ID: 6FCM]35 (B) Schematic and deconvoluted intact-protein mass spec showing pAzF incorporation and GGG-DBCO click chemistry. (C) SDS-PAGE gel stained with Coomassie showing click-dependent monoubiquitination of PCNA164pAzF. (approx. 60% conversion based on densitometry). (D) SDS-PAGE gel stained with Coomassie showing mono, di, and triubiquitination of PCNA with K48-linked and K63-linked polyubiquitin. (E) Western blots showing successful conjugation of polyubiquitins to PCNA164pAzF-DBCO-GGG. Immunoblot against ubiquitin (top), K48-linked polyubiquitin (bottom left), and K63-linked polyubiquitin (bottom right). |
Given pre-existing work in the field (outlined in ref. 16 and 19), we wanted to highlight some key features of our technology compared to what is currently published. The Lang group has previously developed and reported a system for GCE which incorporates a novel unnatural amino acid, azido-glycylglycyl lysine (AzGGK), which enables the use of sortase mediated ligation directly onto lysine residues at the position of interest on a protein. This generates an isopeptide linkage that is more akin to a native ubiquitination, which may be desirable in instances where a near-native linkage is critical to the experimental system it is being applied to. The incorporation of pAzF in our hands is very robust and while the click chemistry results in a less native linkage between the ubiquitin and protein of interest, the use of commercially available pAzF and GGG-DBCO abrogate the need for chemical synthesis of the AzGGK, making this strategy more accessible to biochemistry labs and to those who may want to avoid chemical synthesis of reagents. The Lang group has also used a derivation of this technology to generate polyubiquitin chains by generating ubiquitin dimers via and E1/E2 system and using the AzGGK/sortase approach to make longer ubiquitin chains by incorporating the AzGGK into the ubiquitin monomers themselves. While this system presents a robust approach to generate polyubiquitin chains, our strategy which utilizes wild-type ubiquitin leaves opportunity for GCE to be used in alternative ways (e.g. incorporating click or photoaffinity handles, post-translational modifications such as phosphorylation) throughout the ubiquitin chains without the complication of introducing multiple GCE sites into the ubiquitin monomers. Finally, through our blended approach using SrtA 7M for forward conjugation and SrtA 5M in the presence of diglycine for cleavage, we can recover unspent ubiquitin from the reactions by purification since the system disfavors hydrolysis of the sortase recognition motif in unconjugated ubiquitin monomers.
Taken together, the work presented here expands on the current knowledge, use, and applications of sortase technology, as well as providing valuable methods for generating ubiquitinated protein substrates via sortase-mediated ligation. This suite of reagents and methodologies provides access to ubiquitinated proteins with greater control and homogeneity than previous approaches, which will enable new avenues for the exploration of the ubiquitin code and enable us, and others, to explore the ubiquitin code more extensively.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Detailed methods, supplemental figures, and construct sequences. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3cb00229b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |