Yingyu
Xu
,
Cong
Peng
and
Qingan
Zhang
*
School of Materials Science and Engineering, Anhui University of Technology, Maanshan 243002, China. E-mail: qazhang@ahut.edu.cn
First published on 5th July 2024
To clarify the hydrogen storage mechanism of Mg(In) solid solution, the hydrogenation and dehydrogenation characteristics of Mg0.9In0.1 alloy are systematically studied in this work. It is found that the Mg0.9In0.1 solid solution is first hydrogenated to Mg3In and MgH2 under a hydrogen atmosphere. The polymorphism of Mg3In leads to different hydrogenation features of the solid solution in various temperature ranges. Consequently, the reversible dehydrogenation reactions have somewhat distinct enthalpy changes due to the different crystal structures of Mg3In. When the hydrogenation temperature is not lower than 340 °C, Mg3In can be further hydrogenated to (Mg1−xInx)3In and MgH2. The hydrogenation reactions of both β′-Mg3In and β-Mg3In are also reversible although they have sloping hydrogenation and dehydrogenation plateaus in pressure–composition isotherms. This work provides new insights into the hydrogen storage mechanism of Mg(In) solid solution.
Not long ago, Zhu proposed an interesting and effective approach to alter the desorption enthalpy of MgH2 by the reversible formation of Mg(In) solid solution.9 It was found that the Mg0.95In0.05 solid solution alloy had a reduced hydrogen absorption enthalpy of −68.1 kJ mol−1 H2 and a reversible hydrogen capacity of 5.3 wt%.9,10 Thereafter, the Mg(In) solid solution alloys have attracted more attention as one of the most promising hydrogen storage materials.11–14 However, the previously reported results on the hydrogenation–dehydrogenation mechanism of Mg(In) solid solution alloys were ambiguous. Some researchers reported that the Mg(In) solid solution phase was hydrogenated to Mg2In, β′′-MgIn and MgH2 at 300 °C, and further to the β phase and MgH2 at 400 °C.9,10 All the hydrogenated products can be reversibly dehydrogenated to the Mg(In) solid solution phase. Another group proposed that the Mg(In) solid solution phase was hydrogenated first to β′-Mg3In and MgH2, then to Mg2In and MgH2, and finally to β′′-MgIn and MgH2.11,12 These hydrogenation reactions were also reversible during the subsequent dehydrogenation process. In a recent investigation, the authors suggested that the mechanism of the reversible hydrogenation–dehydrogenation reaction should be described as Mg(In) + H2 ↔ MgH2 + β′-Mg3In.13,14 Such differences in the hydrogenation mechanism of the Mg(In) solid solution might be related to different experimental conditions due to the complex phase relationship in the Mg-rich Mg-In system.15
According to the Mg-In phase diagram (see Fig. 1), the β phase with the disordered fcc A1-type structure can exist in a wide composition range from 23.2 to 93.5 at% In.15 During slow cooling, the β phase will transform into the ordered L12-type (Cu3Au-type) β′ phase in space group Pmm when the indium content is less than 39 at% and into the ordered L10-type (CuAu(I)-type) β′′ phase in space group P4/mmm as the indium content is about 39–59 at%.15 When the composition is around 25 at% In, the ordering transformations from the disordered β-Mg3In phase to the ordered L12-type β′-Mg3In and further to the ordered 12R-type β1-Mg3In occur by slow cooling.16 Hence, the complexity of phase transitions in the Mg-rich Mg-In system will inevitably result in various hydrogen-induced disproportionation reactions of the Mg(In) solid solution under different experimental conditions. To clarify the hydrogenation–dehydrogenation mechanism of the Mg(In) solid solution phase, the Mg0.9In0.1 alloy was selected as a research object in this work in view of the fact that the solubility limit of In in Mg is about 11 at% at room temperature.15 Given the complexity in the hydrogenation reaction of Mg(In) solid solution, the hydrogenation–dehydrogenation behaviour of the Mg3In alloy was studied first. Then the phase changes of the Mg0.9In0.1 alloy during hydrogen absorption and desorption were investigated. Finally, the hydrogen storage thermodynamics of the Mg0.9In0.1 alloy were studied systematically.
Fig. 1 Phase diagram of the Mg-rich Mg-In system redrawn from ref. 15. |
In situ XRD measurements of the annealed alloys during hydrogen absorption were performed using the HTHP-XRD-500 sample cell (Beijing Scistar Technol. Co. Ltd) with a silver holder and a beryllium window. During the in situ XRD measurements, the temperature was raised from 300 °C to 400 °C in steps of 10 °C and the hydrogen pressure was maintained at 4 MPa. In each step, the in situ XRD data of the Mg3In sample were recorded after a two-hour holding period. For the Mg0.9In0.1 sample, the holding period time in each step was set to ten hours due to its slower hydrogenation kinetics.
Fig. 2b shows the in situ XRD patterns of the annealed Mg3In alloy during the heating process under a hydrogen pressure of 4 MPa. It can be seen that the diffraction peaks of both β′-Mg3In and β1-Mg3In are present in the temperature range from 300 to 330 °C. As the temperature is raised to 340–360 °C, only the diffraction peaks of β′-Mg3In and MgH2 are observable. It is interesting that the peaks of β-Mg3In reappear together with those of MgH2 starting at 370 °C. This indicates that the hydrogenation of β-Mg3In proceeds in three stages within the temperature range from 300 to 400 °C.
To further explore the transformation mechanism of the β-Mg3In phase under a hydrogen atmosphere, isothermal hydrogenation and dehydrogenation reactions were carried out. Fig. 3a shows the Rietveld refinement of the XRD pattern for the Mg3In sample hydrogenated at 320 °C for 10 hours. It can be seen that the hydrogenated sample consists of β′-Mg3In and β1-Mg3In phases, demonstrating that the ordering transformations of Mg3In occurred during the hydrogenation process. Thus the overall reaction within the temperature range of 300–330 °C can be expressed as
β-Mg3In → β′-Mg3In + β1-Mg3In | (1) |
Fig. 3 Rietveld refinements of the observed XRD patterns for the Mg3In samples hydrogenated and dehydrogenated at (a and b) 320, (c and d) 350 and (e and f) 390 °C for 10 hours. |
Such a hydrogen-induced ordering phenomenon is similar to that observed in ErNi2 where the ordering transformation from a MgCu2-type structure to a TmNi2-type superstructure easily occurred by hydrogenation at 25 °C.18 This is because the formation and migration of vacancies and rearrangement of metal atoms can be greatly promoted by dissolved hydrogen.19,20 After dehydrogenating the hydrogenated Mg3In sample at 320 °C for 10 hours, the XRD pattern almost remains unchanged compared with that of the hydrogenated sample (see Fig. 3b). This means that reaction (1) is irreversible during the dehydrogenation process at 320 °C. This is because there is a certain amount of hydrogen atoms remaining inside the β′-Mg3In and β1-Mg3In phases after dehydrogenation, stabilizing the ordered structures.18,20
Fig. 3c shows the Rietveld refinement of the XRD pattern for the Mg3In sample hydrogenated at 350 °C for 10 h. Obviously, the hydrogenated sample is composed of β′ and MgH2 phases. In the ideal Cu3Au-type β′-Mg3In structure, Mg and In atoms occupy the 3c site (0, 1/2, 1/2) and 1a site (0, 0, 0), respectively. However, the real β′ phase exists in a composition range of 26–38.8 at% In because indium atoms can partially occupy the 3c site of Mg.15 In the present work, the occupancy factors of Mg and In atoms in the 3c site were determined to be 0.91 and 0.09, respectively, by the Rietveld refinement of the XRD pattern. Thus the β′ phase in the hydrogenated sample can be denoted as β′-(Mg0.91In0.09)3In. This means that the β-Mg3In phase first transforms into the ordered β′-Mg3In and further decomposes to β′-(Mg0.91In0.09)3In and MgH2 during the isothermal hydrogenation at 350 °C. The overall hydrogenation reaction can be written as
β-Mg3In + H2 → β′-(Mg1−xInx)3In + MgH2 | (2) |
Fig. 3d shows the XRD pattern of the Mg3In sample dehydrogenated at 350 °C for 10 hours. It can be seen that only the β′-Mg3In phase appears in the dehydrogenated sample. Thus the dehydrogenation reaction can be expressed as
β′-(Mg1−xInx)3In + MgH2 → β′-Mg3In + H2 | (3) |
Fig. 3e and f show the XRD patterns of the Mg3In samples hydrogenated and dehydrogenated at 390 °C for 10 h, which are similar to those of the samples hydrogenated and dehydrogenated at 350 °C for 10 h. The composition of the β′ phase in the hydrogenated sample can be determined to be β′-(Mg0.86In0.14)3In by Rietveld analysis. However, the in situ XRD patterns clearly indicate the existence of β and MgH2 phases as the hydrogenation products at 390 °C (see Fig. 2b). These results demonstrate that the β phase in the hydrogenated and dehydrogenated samples quickly transformed into the β′ phase in the subsequent cooling process. This is because the ordering transformation of the β phase to the β′ phase proceeds very fast due to a large number of crystal defects including vacancies and interstitial H atoms.20 Hence, the reversible reactions at 390 °C can be expressed as
β-Mg3In + H2 ↔ β-(Mg1−xInx)3In + MgH2 | (4) |
Fig. 4 (a) XRD patterns, (b) optical morphology, (c) SEM image and (d) EDX spectra for annealed Mg0.9In0.1 alloy. |
Fig. 5 shows the in situ XRD patterns of the Mg0.9In0.1 alloy during the heating process under a hydrogen pressure of 4 MPa. Because the hydrogenation reaction of Mg0.9In0.1 alloy proceeds slowly, the diffraction peaks of the Mg(In) solid solution phase are present until the temperature reaches 360 °C. Despite this, it is clear that the hydrogenation of the Mg(In) solid solution phase also has three distinguishable stages. When the temperature ranges from 300 to 330 °C, β′-Mg3In, β1-Mg3In and MgH2 are formed as the products of hydrogenation. Upon increasing the temperature to 340–360 °C, β1-Mg3In disappears but the β′ and MgH2 phases are retained. As the temperature is further raised to 370 °C, only the peaks of the β phase and MgH2 are observable.
Fig. 5 In situ XRD patterns of Mg0.9In0.1 alloy during the hydrogenation process (the Ag peak is from the sample holder). |
Fig. 6a shows the Rietveld refinement of the XRD pattern for the Mg0.9In0.1 alloy hydrogenated at 320 °C for 50 hours, indicating the coexistence of β′-Mg3In, β1-Mg3In, MgH2 and remaining Mg(In). When the hydrogenated sample was dehydrogenated at 320 °C for 50 hours, the Mg(In) solid solution phase was reversibly formed (see Fig. 6b). Thus, the hydrogenation and dehydrogenation reactions of Mg(In) in the temperature range from 300 to 330 °C can be written as
Mg(In) + H2 ↔ β′-Mg3In + β1-Mg3In + MgH2 | (5) |
When the Mg0.9In0.1 alloy was hydrogenated at 350 °C for 50 hours, the β′ and MgH2 phases were generated (see Fig. 6c). The composition of the β′ phase was determined to be (Mg0.92In0.08)3In by Rietveld refinement. Likewise, the β′-(Mg0.92In0.08)3In and MgH2 phases can be reversibly transformed into Mg(In) during subsequent dehydrogenation (see Fig. 6d). According to Fig. 5, 6c and d, the hydrogenation and dehydrogenation reactions of Mg(In) in the range of 340–360 °C can be expressed as
Mg(In) + H2 ↔ β′-Mg3In + MgH2 | (6) |
β′-Mg3In + H2 ↔ β′-(Mg1−xInx)3In + MgH2 | (7) |
The XRD patterns of Mg0.9In0.1 samples hydrogenated and dehydrogenated at 390 °C for 20 hours are shown in Fig. 6e and f, respectively. Similarly, β′ and MgH2 are detectable in the hydrogenated sample and Mg(In) is observable in the dehydrogenated sample. The composition of the β′ phase can be calculated to be (Mg0.85In0.15)3In. For the same reasons as mentioned above for Mg3In alloy, the β′-(Mg0.85In0.15)3In phase was formed from the hydrogenation product β-(Mg0.85In0.15)3In during the cooling process. Hence, the hydrogenation and dehydrogenation reactions of Mg(In) in the range from 370 to 400 °C can be written as
Mg(In) + H2 ↔ β-Mg3In + MgH2 | (8) |
β-Mg3In + H2 ↔ β-(Mg1−xInx)3In + MgH2 | (9) |
To further confirm this, the microstructures of hydrogenated and dehydrogenated Mg0.9In0.1 samples were observed by TEM (see Fig. 7). Evidently, the hydrogenated sample consists of β′ and MgH2 phases, and the dehydrogenated sample is composed of a single phase Mg(In).
Fig. 7 HRTEM images, HAADF-STEM images and the corresponding EDX elemental mappings of the Mg0.9In0.1 samples (a–e) hydrogenated and (f–j) dehydrogenated at 390 °C. |
It should be noted that neither β2-Mg2In nor β′′-MgIn was observed in the hydrogenated samples. This result might be related to the slow kinetics of hydrogen-induced decomposition. Fig. 8 shows the isothermal hydrogenation and dehydrogenation curves at different temperatures. It can be seen that the hydrogenation reaction takes 20 hours even at 390 °C. This is because the hydrogen-induced decomposition of Mg(In) requires long-range diffusion of In atoms (see Fig. 7d). In contrast, the hydrogenation kinetic rate of mechanically alloyed Mg(In) alloy becomes faster due to its nanoscale microstructure.10,12 Once the composition of the hydrogenation product enters the β′′ phase region, non-stoichiometric β′′-MgIn can be formed (see Fig. 1).
Fig. 8 (a) Hydrogenation and (b) dehydrogenation curves of the Mg0.9In0.1 alloy at different temperatures. |
Fig. 9 (a–c) P–C isotherms of hydrogen absorption and desorption at different temperatures and (d) van't Hoff plots for the flat plateaus of Mg0.9In0.1. |
The van't Hoff plots for the flat plateaus are displayed in Fig. 9d. Consequently, the dehydrogenation enthalpies for reactions (5), (6) and (8) can be calculated to be 71.84, 69.86 and 66.69 kJ mol−1 H2, respectively. Obviously, these dehydrogenation enthalpies are smaller than the value of 75 kJ mol−1 H2 for MgH2.6 This means that indium doping can improve the dehydrogenation thermodynamics, which provides a possible pathway to achieving the US-DOE's goals.23 The thermodynamic destabilization of MgH2 is related to the reaction of the hydride with Mg3In forming Mg(In) solid solution upon dehydrogenation.9,12,24 However, the present work indicates that different crystal structures of Mg3In result in various degrees of destabilization. This is because the enthalpy of formation for Mg3In is associated with the change in stacking sequence (β1 → β′) and the order–disorder phase transition (β′ → β).15,16,25
As for the sloping plateaus of reactions (7) and (9), the slopes indicate different portions of hydrogen-induced Mg3In decomposition at various pressures.26 The decomposition reaction of Mg3In might not be complete yet due to slow kinetics when the measurements of hydrogenation isotherms were terminated. Thus it is difficult to accurately calculate the enthalpy changes of reactions (7) and (9) by taking the equilibrium pressures from the midpoints of sloping plateaus. In the present case, the sample is composed of β-(Mg1−xInx)3In and MgH2 after the measurement of hydrogenation performance at 400 °C. However, further increasing the hydrogenation temperature will result in the occurrence of partial melting as the composition of β-(Mg1−xInx)3In reaches the solidus line (see Fig. 1), which makes its hydrogenation behaviour more complicated. Thus further investigations are needed to understand the de/hydrogenation feature of the β phase on the basis of enhancement of the kinetics.27,28
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |