Benedikt
Fischer
*ab,
Maurice
Nuys
ac,
Oleksandr
Astakhov
a,
Stefan
Haas
ad,
Michael
Schaaf
e,
Astrid
Besmehn
f,
Peter
Jakes
g,
Rüdiger-A.
Eichel
gh and
Uwe
Rau
ab
aIEK-5 Photovoltaik, Forschungszentrum Jülich GmbH, Wilhelm-Johnen Straße, 52425 Jülich, Germany. E-mail: b.fischer@fz-juelich.de
bJülich Aachen Research Alliance (JARA-Energy), Faculty of Electrical Engineering and Information Technology, RWTH Aachen University, Schinkelstr. 2, 52062 Aachen, Germany
cDepartment of Energy Building Services Environmental Engineering, University of Applied Sciences Muenster, Stegerwaldstraße 39, 48565 Steinfurt, Germany
dDepartment of Aerospace Engineering, FH Aachen University of Applied Sciences, 52066 Aachen, Germany
eZEA-1 Engineering und Technologie, Forschungszentrum Jülich GmbH, Wilhelm-Johnen Straße, 52425 Jülich, Germany
fIEK-14 Elektrochemische Verfahrenstechnik, Forschungszentrum Jülich GmbH, Wilhelm-Johnen Straße, 52425 Jülich, Germany
gIEK-9 Grundlagen der Elektrochemie, Forschungszentrum Jülich GmbH, Wilhelm-Johnen Straße, 52425 Jülich, Germany
hInstitute of Physical Chemistry, RWTH Aachen University, 52074 Aachen, Germany
First published on 21st October 2024
Liquid silanes can be used for low-cost, fast deposition of hydrogenated amorphous silicon (a-Si:H) as an alternative to state-of-the-art deposition processes such as plasma enhanced chemical vapor deposition or electron beam evaporation. However, liquid silane deposition techniques are still in their infancy. In this paper, we present a new version of the atmospheric pressure chemical vapor deposition technique designed to improve the reproducibility of a-Si:H deposition. With this new tool, we explore ways to improve the quality of the material. The films can be prepared using pure trisilane as a precursor; frequently, however, trisilane is diluted with cyclooctane for better handling and process control. Currently, the influence of this dilution on the film quality is not well understood. In our work, we investigate and compare both precursor strategies. This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of the effects of cyclooctane dilution, deposition temperature, process duration, and precursor amount on the structure stoichiometry and electronic properties of the resulting films. The analysis was performed using a range of techniques, including Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, electronic spin resonance spectroscopy, Raman spectroscopy, ellipsometry, secondary ion mass spectrometry, and conductivity measurements. For films deposited with pure silane, we found a low oxygen (O) and carbon (C) impurity incorporation and an adjustable H content up to 10%, resulting in a photosensitivity of up to 104. Dependent on the dilution and deposition temperature, the films deposited with cyclooctane dilution showed various amounts of C incorporation, culminating in an a-Si:H/a-SiC:H structure for high temperatures and dilutions. High purity a-Si:H films as a-Si:C:H films are promising for application in solar cells and transistors either as an amorphous functional layer or as a precursor for recrystallization processes, e.g., in TOPCon solar cell technology.
A number of studies have been carried out on the deposition of a-Si:H using liquid precursors such as trisilane often diluted using the solvent cyclooctane for better handling.5,6,11 Cyclooctane was used as a suitable widely available solvent with a stable carbon ring, which is important to avoid carbon contamination of amorphous Si films. However, to the best of our knowledge, there is little to no data on the actual influence of cyclooctane on the carbon content or film structure. Therefore, in our study, we investigate the effect of cyclooctane dilution on the a-Si:H film properties by changing the dilution ratio from 0 to 99% in the deposition process. The entire deposition parameter space comprises four dimensions: cyclooctane dilution, deposition temperature, deposition time, and precursor amount. To elucidate the influence of multiple process parameters on film properties, we employ a set of characterization techniques: spectroscopic ellipsometry for thickness; electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopy for paramagnetic states and defects; secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) for atomic composition; a custom-built setup for electrical conductivity; Raman spectroscopy for structural analysis; and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy for the H content cH, the Si–H bonding configuration and the incorporation of carbon.
The study is organized and presented as follows. First, the effects of deposition temperature, deposition time, and precursor amount are examined in films prepared with pure trisilane as a precursor. A comparison to a reference intrinsic a-Si:H film deposited by PECVD allows us to explore the potential a-Si:H material quality achievable through the new deposition method. In the second part of the paper, we analyze the effects of cyclooctane dilution, with particular emphasis on the potential incorporation of carbon and the resulting impact on the quality of the deposited material. For undiluted trisilane there are regions of parameters delivering intrinsic films with high photosensitivity potentially applicable as passivation layers in solar cells and other regions yielding films with low H content suitable for blistering-free crystallization processes. For the diluted precursor, we can see incorporation of carbon, which strongly depends on substrate temperature. At temperatures below 495 °C, only minor contamination is detected, negligible for the electronic film properties, whereas at higher temperatures, the carbon content increases significantly reaching up to 1022 atoms per cm3 at 580 °C which puts the resulting films into the category of silicon carbide alloys. In this case, the technique can find its applications for atmospheric pressure preparation of SiC.
Using this setup, nine sample series have been prepared. As summarized in Table 1 the sets of samples are separated into two major groups for materials prepared with pure trisilane and diluted trisilane. In both cases, we aimed to test a wide range of deposition parameters. The primary investigated parameter in each group of samples is shown in bold. For pure trisilane the series “Temp1”, “Time1”, and “Amount1” a variation of one deposition parameter (deposition temperature, time or precursor amount respectively) is investigated. The samples were characterized mainly by FTIR spectroscopy, ellipsometry and conductivity measurements. For the ESR and SIMS measurements, two extra series called “ESR” and “SIMS” were prepared. In the sixth series “Dilution” the trisilane content diluted in cyclooctane used as the precursor was changed from 1 to 100% at three different temperatures. The last three series, “Temp2”, “Time2”, and “Amount2” again focus on the variation of deposition temperature, time or precursor amount respectively, but using 2% trisilane diluted in cyclooctane as the precursor.
Series | TS content [%] | Temperature [°C] | Time [min] | Amount [μl] |
---|---|---|---|---|
Temp1 | 100 | 410–580 | 10 | 10 |
Time1 | 100 | 440, 555 | 10, 20, 50 | 20 |
Amount1 | 100 | 440, 555 | 10 | 10, 20, 50 |
ESR | 100 | 440, 495, 555 | 10, 20 | 10, 20 |
SIMS | 100 | 440, 495, 555 | 10, 20 | 10, 20 |
Dilution | 1–100 | 440, 495, 555 | 10 | 10–1000 |
Temp2 | 2 | 410–580 | 10 | 400 |
Time2 | 2 | 470 | 1-50 | 400 |
Amount2 | 2 | 470 | 10 | 200–1000 |
The film thickness is measured by spectroscopic ellipsometry using a T-Solar/M2000 from J.A. Woollam.
The Si bonding structure is analyzed using FTIR using a Nicolet 5700 system from Thermo Electron Corporation.
To calculate the bond-density, we used the absorption strengths by Beyer and Ghazala16 for the Si–H and by Kaneko et al.17 for the Si–C stretching vibrations. We calculated the microstructure parameter R, which is often used to describe the microstructure of a-Si:H films according to the method published previously in ref. 18. R is the ratio of the integrated peak areas of Si–H vibrations contributing to peaks near 2100 cm−1 and 2000 cm−1, corresponding to H bonded in void-rich and dense materials, respectively.16,19–21 Adding carbon to a-Si:H films can increase the peak near 2100 cm−1 and therefore the R, since vibrations of Si–H bonds with a carbon back-bond on the silicon atom are also located near the 2100 cm−1 peak.22 We used this fact together with the Si–C vibration peak located at 780 cm−1 and SIMS measurements to investigate the carbon content in the a-Si:H films deposited with trisilane diluted in cyclooctane.
To investigate the chemical composition, we performed SIMS measurements using the time-to-flight setup ToF-SIMS5.ncs from IONTOF GmbH with a cesium sputtering beam and a sputtering energy of 1 keV on an area of (300 × 300) μm2. We compare the SIMS measurement of the APCVD films with an intrinsic a-Si:H reference film deposited by PECVD with the recipe for the passivating i1-layer used in SHJ solar cells.23 The dark and photoconductivity σd and σph, respectively, of our film is measured using a home-made system. The light source was a mercury lamp calibrated to an intensity of one sun.
Electron spin resonance (ESR) measurements (a.k.a. electron paramagnetic resonance – EPR) are made in conventional continuous wave (CW) mode using a commercial X-band (ν = 9.8 GHz) Bruker ELEXSYS E-500 system in an ER 4108 TMHS resonator at room temperature. Two identical pieces of the thin film on a Corning glass substrate cut in (5 × 5) mm2 pieces were fixed face-to-face with scotch tape on the tip of a 4 mm diameter quartz sample tube and positioned in the center of an opaque resonator cavity. To ensure that the substrate or holder does not contribute to the detected signal, a reference measurement was made on substrates without sample films, which showed a negligible baseline compared to the signal detected from the films under test. A calibrated sample of sputtered amorphous silicon with a spin number of 2 × 1015 and g-value of 2.00565 was used as a reference secondary standard24 for calibration of the magnetic field and signal intensity for further g-value and spin density evaluation in measured samples. The spectra were measured at a microwave power of 0.1 mW, a sweep width of 100 G, a magnetic field modulation at a frequency of 100 kHz and an amplitude of 3 G. It was confirmed that no saturation or over modulation effects occur under these conditions.
Dark and photoconductivity σd and σph, thickness d, H content and microstructure parameter R of the pure silane samples of series Temp1, Time1 and Amount1 are summarized in Fig. 2.
Fig. 2a shows the results for samples of series Temp1. The film thickness of the a-Si:H films strongly increases with increasing hot plate temperatures between 410 °C and 495 °C due to a higher growth rate, in agreement with the literature.27 At 495 °C, a plateau is reached, likely indicating the complete deposition of the injected precursor. The thickness decreases slightly for temperatures of 555 °C and 580 °C, which can be attributed to two effects. (i) The major effect is a larger area that is unintentionally heated up to temperatures allowing the deposition of a-Si:H (e.g., at the walls of the deposition chamber). A larger deposition area at the same precursor amount leads to thinner films on the substrate if the growth process is limited by the precursor amount and not by deposition time. (ii) A minor effect is that cH decreases from 4% at T = 440 °C to below 1% at T > 525 °C due to hydrogen effusion, which can also lead to a small shrinking effect of the a-Si:H films with higher temperature.28,29
The conductivity measurement results in Fig. 2a show a split of σph and σd for temperatures T ≤ 495 °C. In this range, the logarithm of σph qualitatively follows the curve of cH. For temperatures above 495 °C, σd increases to values nearly equal to those of σph. At these higher temperatures, cH drops significantly to below 1%. The conductivity continues to increase with increasing deposition temperature, surpassing 106 S cm−1. This increase may be attributed to a higher density of defects, which could enhance hopping conductivity and might lead to the formation of a conductive defect band. The ratio of σph to σd, known as photosensitivity, is often used to assess the quality of intrinsic a-Si for optoelectronic applications.30–32 The highest photosensitivity, 2.5 × 102, was observed at 470 °C in the Temp1 series shown in Fig. 2a. The microstructure parameter is below 0.1 for all films, except for the film deposited at 410 °C. The low R for films deposited at T > 410 °C can result from two different material properties. (i) It can result from the dense material with H bonded mainly within the Si-network.25,33 (ii) It can result from the void-rich material where H bonded in voids effused during the deposition process, since the deposition temperature is above the effusion peak temperature at approximately 385 °C of H in voids, but below that of H within the Si network.34 Because of the absence of the H in the voids which would contribute to the 2100 cm−1 peak, this could result in a low R despite the presence of voids in the material. The increased R for the film deposited at 410 °C might be a relic of the low film thickness of d = 9 nm. For low a-Si:H film thicknesses, the amount of H within the bulk a-Si:H can be in the same order of magnitude as the amount of the H bonded at the interface between a-Si:H and c-Si. The interface H can contribute significantly to the 2100 cm−1 peak, leading to a higher R.18
The hydrogen effusion during deposition is examined in more detail in the Time1 series, where 20 μl of trisilane was injected at 440 °C and 555 °C for durations of 10, 20, and 50 minutes. The results of this series are displayed in Fig. 2b. For Td = 440 °C, cH and R decrease with longer deposition times. Specifically, cH drops from 8% to 4%, and R decreases from 0.2 to 0.05. This suggests that hydrogen bonded in a more porous or void-rich structure (associated with the 2100 cm−1 peak) indeed effuses out of the film over time. As the deposition time increases, σd increases while σph decreases. This trend is consistent with a higher density of defects and a lower hydrogen content, both of which contribute to a lower σph and, consequently, reduced photosensitivity.35,36 For Td = 555 °C, cH falls below 2%, and R is approximately 0, as the 2100 cm−1 peak is near or below the detection limit. Both σph and σd are almost equal, and both increase with longer deposition times. These observations suggest that the effusion of hydrogen and the resulting changes in the film's microstructure and defect density significantly influence the conductivity and photosensitivity of the material.
The effect of the injected precursor amount has been investigated by preparing the sample series Amount1, whose measurement results are shown in Fig. 2c. For two deposition temperatures, T = 440 °C and T = 555 °C, we used precursor amounts of 10, 20 and 50 μl trisilane. Increasing the amount of precursor results in increased film thickness, which is accompanied by noticeable scatter in the data, presumably due to uncertainties in precursor injection.
For T = 440 °C, R and cH increase with increasing precursor volume. The conductivity measurements show for all precursor amounts a high photosensitivity up to 104. The photoconductivity of the films deposited at T = 440 °C shows a slight correlation with the H contents of the films, which could already be seen in Fig. 2a and b for temperatures below 495 °C. For the deposition at T = 555 °C, the growth rate is higher than that for the deposition with T = 440 °C. However, the high temperature probably leads to a high effusion rate, leading to a low cH and low R for all film thicknesses. Accordingly, the photosensitivity of all films deposited at T = 555 °C is ∼1.
The surface profile of the a-Si:H thin films is dependent on the growth-temperature and thickness of the films. Regarding the films from the series in Fig. 2a for T = 410 °C and T = 440 °C, a flat surface without holes is obtained, as shown representatively for T = 440 °C in Fig. 3a. No signs of blistering have been observed, maybe due to a combination of small film thickness and a low H-diffusion rate. At T = 495 °C, shown in Fig. 3b, we observed circular holes. These were found also for the depositions at T = 470 and 525 °C. We attribute the formation of these holes to blistering due to H2 cumulated in voids within the film or at the interface to the c-Si substrate.37 For T = 555 °C and 580 °C, the surface is flat again (shown in Fig. 3c). As a matter of speculation, this might result from a loose film structure with micropores in which the hydrogen can easily effuse without accumulation and subsequent blistering. Also, it is possible that at higher temperatures hydrogen is ejected from the surface before it can incorporate into the bulk of the material.
Fig. 3 Pictures made with a light microscope at five times magnification of a-Si:H films deposited at a plate temperature of (a) 440 °C, (b) 495 °C and (c) 555 °C. |
Another possible explanation for smooth H effusion without blistering is related to the growth of crystalline structures within the material. These crystalline structures are expected to reveal themselves in Raman spectra. However, the spectra shown in Fig. 4 show a clear peak at 480 cm−1 for all deposition temperatures, indicating that the material is amorphous and not crystalline.26,38,39 For a deposition temperature of 525 °C, the peak is slightly shifted to higher wavenumbers which can be attributed to a more dense material or the onset of nanocrystalline growth, which is often observed in this temperature regime for longer annealing times.40–42
Fig. 4 Raman spectra showing the typical peak of Si–Si vibrations in amorphous silicon at 480 cm−1 of a-Si:H films deposited at 440, 495 and 555 °C. |
Paramagnetic electronic states in the APCVD a-Si:H films were analyzed via ESR spectroscopy. The deposition parameters of these 3 samples are shown in Table 1 in the “ESR” row. It is widely accepted that the ESR signal detected in the undoped amorphous silicon originates from Si dangling bonds causing defect states within the band gap.35,43 The ESR spectra given in ESI Fig. S1a† show a pronounced featureless, slightly asymmetric single line at a g-value of approx. 2.0055 – typical for dangling bonds in amorphous silicon.35,43 Both the intensity of the line and, indirectly, the g-value point to a material with a high density of dangling bond defects.35 The density of dangling bonds is crucial for the electronic quality of a-Si:H. It has been shown by Astakhov et al.35 that photoconductivity is inversely dependent on the spin density in a-Si:H. At the same time, hydrogen passivation can effectively reduce the density of dangling bonds and improve the electronic quality of a-Si:H. Fig. 5 shows the conductivity, H-content and ESR spin density for the three a-Si:H samples with similar thicknesses (∼130 nm) as a function of the hot plate temperature. With increasing temperature, cH measured by FTIR decreases. This is in line with the increase in the density of dangling bonds detected as an increase in the spin-density NS measured by ESR.35,44 The high amount of dangling bonds can lead to an increase of the σd and can be responsible for the reduction of σph in agreement with the trends observed in a-Si:H prepared by the traditional methods.35,45
Fig. 6 shows SIMS depth profiles of the a-Si:H films deposited at 440, 495 and 555 °C and a reference intrinsic a-Si:H film, deposited by PECVD. The samples have similar thicknesses d between 130 and 180 nm. In comparison to the reference high quality PECVD material, the APCVD material deposited at 440 °C shows similar purity with comparable C and O contents to the reference PECVD film. However, the H content in the APCVD sample is lower and less homogeneously distributed over the film thickness. The amount of H decreases near the surface as well as near the interface of the c-Si substrate. Such kind of H distribution was reported for PECVD a-Si:H films exposed to post deposition annealing.46 Therefore, we attribute the inhomogeneous hydrogen distribution in the APCVD material to the out diffusion at 440 °C. The SIMS profiles in APCVD films prepared at higher temperatures confirm the decrease of the H content with the temperature increase detected by the FTIR measurements. Simultaneously, the increase in the deposition temperature leads to an increase in C and O content within the film. These impurities can contribute to the increase in the number of defect states.47 The O and C counts increase near the surface, especially for T = 495 °C and T = 555 °C, indicating a higher impurity incorporation with lower precursor content within the deposition chamber.
Fig. 6 Silicon, hydrogen, carbon, and oxygen SIMS profiles of (a) an intrinsic PECVD film and APCVD films deposited at (b) 440 °C, (c) 495 °C and (d) 555 °C. |
Fig. 8a shows conductivity, thickness, hydrogen content, microstructure parameter R and density of Si–C bonds as a function of trisilane concentration in dilution samples deposited at 440 °C. Both σd and σph as well as cH are mostly unaffected by cyclooctane dilution. In contrast, the microstructure parameter R increases with a decreasing trisilane concentration for trisilane concentrations below 10%. In this series, the effect on the carbon content was not detectable with FTIR. However, SIMS measurements, shown in Fig. S2,† revealed a 3–4 orders of magnitude increase in carbon content compared to films made with pure silane. The H concentration varies only slightly between 6 and 8%. The scatter of the film thickness within the Dilution series is probably due to the manual precursor injection (cf. Experimental section).
Fig. 8b shows the material properties vs. the dilution ratio for films deposited at 495 °C. The figure shows that cH and R increase with an increasing cyclooctane concentration for films made with less than 10% trisilane content. This trend might be due to the incorporated carbon, which is supported by the increasing Si–C vibrational peak located at 720–780 cm−1. The increase in cH, up to 6%, might be one reason for the increased photosensitivity observed in samples with trisilane concentrations below 10%. The difference in photosensitivity between 10% and 100% trisilane content is likely due to fluctuations in deposition conditions. A deposition temperature of 495 °C is close to the critical point where the photo-/dark conductivity splitting vanishes (as shown in Fig. 2a). Therefore, small differences in temperature or precursor amounts can have a significant impact on photosensitivity.
Fig. 8c shows the material properties vs. the dilution ratio for films deposited at 555 °C. For trisilane concentrations above 10%, no hydrogen is detected. However, at concentrations below 10%, a significant amount of hydrogen is present in the film, likely bonded to silicon with carbon back-bonds (R = 1). Despite this, the hydrogen does not seem to passivate defects, as the conductivities (σph and σd) remain similar across all films, regardless of hydrogen content.
A Si–C peak was observed for all dilution ratios. Even in pure trisilane deposition, enough carbon—likely from impurities in the glove box—was incorporated into the film, resulting in a noticeable peak in the FTIR spectrum. Reducing the trisilane concentration leads to increased carbon incorporation, reaching levels comparable to the silicon content (1022 atoms per cm3).
Fig. 9a shows the results of the Temp2 series. The thickness of the films increases with increasing deposition temperature for T < 525 °C and remains almost constant for T > 525 °C. For all films, R is higher than 0.4. The microstructure parameter R decreases with increasing temperature for T < 495 °C, probably due to a lower proportion of H at the interface (which vibrates at a wavenumber of 2100 cm−1) relative to the overall Si–H spectrum. In contrast, for T > 495 °C, R increases, tentatively due to a carbon content increase leading to more Si–H bonds with C back-bonds. This more stable bonded H might also lead to a cH of 2% for layers deposited at T > 495 °C, instead of full H effusion. Beside the film deposited at T = 580 °C, all films show a photoresponse with a maximum at 470 °C, probably because of the higher cH (σd at 440 °C probably an outlier).
In Fig. 9b the results of sample series Time2 are shown. The photosensitivity varies with the deposition time with a maximum for the 10 min deposition. Accordingly, cH strongly increases from 2% to 6% and R strongly decreases from 1 to 0.4 within the first 5 min. The film thickness data indicate that the growth rate first is approximately constant and then, for deposition times longer than 5 min, the growth rate decreases, due to depletion of the precursor. In addition, a longer deposition time leads to a higher incorporation of carbon and less inserted H into the film.
Fig. 9c shows the results of the sample series Amount2. An increased amount of precursor seems to increase the a-Si:H growth rate. This leads to a (linear) increase in the film thickness. The higher film growth is linked to an increase in photosensitivity and cH. The higher growth rate is also accompanied by a lower carbon incorporation and lower R, probably because of fewer carbon back-bonds of Si–H vibrations.
For one film deposited at T = 580 °C using the solution with 2% trisilane, an ESR measurement was made, to analyze the g-factor, which is influenced by the SiC stoichiometry.52 As shown in Fig. S1b,† the film with a thickness of 430 nm showed a g-factor of 2.004 which is closer to that of amorphous silicon carbide (a-SiC) (2.003) rather than a-Si (2.0055), in agreement with the high carbon content in the films.52 The spin density of this sample was 1.35 × 1019 cm−3, which is slightly lower than that of the sample deposited with pure trisilane at T = 555 °C, possibly because of the increased cH and related passivation of defects for films deposited using high cyclooctane concentrations.
We found a cH of less than 10% and a low R in all films, which aligns with the fact that even the lowest deposition temperature used in this work is above the H effusion temperature.34 The elevated temperatures result in a high hydrogen effusion rate during the growth process, particularly for hydrogen located in voids leading to a low R.28 This suggests that the high defect density measured by ESR may stem from insufficient passivation and structural imperfections.36
In agreement with this, a clear correlation between the hydrogen concentration and the conductivity of the films was observed, consistent with the findings of Beyer and Wagner36 and Fritzsche.44 They suggested that a decrease in cH can cause an increase in defect densities, leading to a decrease in σph.35
The a-Si:H films produced by our process are characterized by high purity, particularly in terms of low oxygen and carbon incorporation. However, the relatively low hydrogen content (cH) in the films presents a challenge for some specific applications. For example, passivating layers of a-Si:H in silicon heterojunction (SHJ) solar cells are required to have higher hydrogen content for effective passivation. To address this issue, one potential solution is post-deposition hydrogenation.
For films deposited at high temperatures T ≥ 555 °C, a small amount of H found in the a-Si:H films renders them highly suitable for various high-temperature processes, including recrystallization, as it significantly diminishes the risk of blistering. Therefore, this material shows strong potential for use as a precursor for polycrystalline silicon in TopCon solar cells.
A low cH (<2%) indicates that the deposition time of 10 min is long enough to remove not only all H at internal surfaces (2100 cm−1 peak) but also almost all H atoms within the silicon-network.
In addition, the low cH and therefore high defect density seem to create a conductive defect band, which increases the σd while also speeding up the recombination of photogenerated carriers, resulting in a photosensitivity of around 1.
The defect density increases one order of magnitude for a deposition temperature increase from T = 440 °C to 555 °C, probably as a result of less H incorporation into the film.36
With increasing deposition temperature, the O and C content increase as well, with an especially sharp increase near the surface, as shown in Fig. 6. This can tentatively be attributed to slower a-Si:H film deposition at the end of the deposition process, due to the depletion of the trisilane concentration during the growth process. This combined with the high temperature leads to a higher ratio of impurity radicals to silane radicals and therefore to a higher impurity incorporation. Therefore, for films deposited at high temperatures, in addition to a lack of H, oxygen impurities can lead to a higher amount of defects within the material as well.47,54 Kinoshita et al.54 showed a decrease in the conductivity with increasing oxygen content. However, they only found a minor reduction in the photosensitivity for very high oxygen contents up to 1021 atoms per cm3, indicating that the reduction of the photosensitivity for high temperatures as shown in Fig. 2a is mainly a result of the low H content available for passivation within the film.
The origin of the C and O atoms can be the rest of organic solvents used for other film depositions within the chamber or impurity gases within the glove box such as CO2, which is not monitored. The very steep increase in C and O counts at the surface of all samples, observed for sputter times >100 s in Fig. 6, can be attributed to impurities on the sample surfaces originating from the transportation of the samples in the ambient atmosphere.
By varying the deposition time and precursor volume, the film properties can be varied as well. A higher amount of precursor leads to a higher number of radicals that can interact with the substrate surface. The increased growth rate due to more radicals can lead to a higher incorporation of H and to a more porous or void-rich film, resulting in a higher R.43 Increasing the deposition time in fact decreases the average growth rate and can lead to annealing effects. Both, a decreased growth rate and thermal annealing, reduce cH and R for films deposited with pure trisilane.
The introduction of cyclooctane as a solvent for trisilane leads to significant carbon incorporation in the films, enhancing reproducibility by increasing the available precursor. Films grown with the 2% trisilane solution exhibit greater thickness, particularly at higher temperatures, due to more efficient precursor utilization. Specifically, 400 μl of the 2% trisilane solution (equivalent to 8 μl of trisilane) yields a thicker film compared to the 10 μl of pure trisilane.
At lower temperatures and cyclooctane concentrations, moderate carbon contamination has minimal impact on conductivity and cH but increases R due to additional Si–H bonds with carbon back-bonds. At deposition temperatures above 495 °C and cyclooctane concentrations above 95%, key differences in film properties emerge. A higher carbon incorporation is accompanied by increased hydrogen incorporation and higher R, reflecting the bonding of H primarily to silicon atoms with carbon back-bonds.17,22 Because of the effect of the added carbon on R, the R values of films with higher carbon content cannot be directly compared to those of films made with pure trisilane.
Effusion experiments of a-SiC:H show a higher temperature stability of H in a-SiC:H than in a-Si:H,28,55 in agreement with the fact that a higher carbon content of the films also leads to a higher H incorporation at high deposition temperatures.
Because of the higher H content, the carbon incorporation can improve the photosensitivity of the films deposited at temperatures between 495 °C and 555 °C. For films made of pure silane, almost no σph/σd splitting can be observed for this temperature regime.
The high Si–C peak in FTIR spectra and a g-value of 2.004 observed for a sample deposited at T = 580 °C and with 2% trisilane solved in cyclooctane as the precursor demonstrate that for films deposited at high temperature and with high cyclooctane concentrations the material configuration shifts from carbon-polluted a-Si:H to an a-Si:H/a-SiC:H mixture. The silicon-rich a-SiC:H matrix is a promising candidate as a precursor for nano-crystalline silicon embedded in an a-SiC matrix, which can be achieved through the process of annealing. This material has a wide applicability in optoelectronic applications.56–60
These results show that the use of cyclooctane as a solvent for silicon precursors can significantly influence the film properties. Nevertheless, we also showed that deposition temperatures and cyclooctane concentrations below 495 °C and 90%, as used for most liquid silane processes, are uncritical regarding C incorporation.5,6,11
The microstructure, defect density and conductivity of a-Si:H change with the process parameters of the deposition system such as deposition temperature, deposition time, and precursor amount. Using pure trisilane, the hydrogen content and microstructure parameter can be varied in the range of 0–10% and 0–0.6, respectively. We found the lowest defect density of 3 × 1018 cm−3 and a photosensitivity in the order of 104 for films deposited at T = 440 °C. It is therefore necessary to further improve the film quality with regard to hydrogen content and defect density in order to make it suitable for use in SHJ solar cells. However, for high temperatures such as T = 555 °C, the low H-content of the films presented here makes them a suitable candidate for high-temperature processes such as recrystallization, as the risk of blistering due to H accumulation is significantly reduced.
We investigated the influence of cyclooctane as solvent on the film properties and found a critical trisilane concentration of 10% diluted in cyclooctane and a critical deposition temperature of 495 °C. For lower trisilane concentrations and higher temperatures, we found a significant incorporation of carbon, leading to changes in the film properties such as an increased H content and a microstructure parameter increase up to 1. This also results in macroscopic changes such as an increase in the photoconductivity of the film, maybe allowing the fabrication of a-Si:H films with a higher heat stability. From FTIR spectra and ESR measurements, it can be concluded that for the highest dilutions and temperatures, the material can be regarded as a mixture of a-Si:H and a-SiC:H. SIMS measurements have shown that when deposition temperatures are below 495 °C and the trisilane content is 10% or higher, the carbon content in the films slightly increases. However, this carbon increase is not significant enough to affect the hydrogen content or the conductivity of the films.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4se01308e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |