Xiang
He‡
a,
Canze
Zheng‡
a,
Xin
Deng
a,
Yingjuan
Hong
a,
Miao
Meng
a,
Chunxuan
Qi
b,
Hai-Tao
Feng
b,
Ming
Chen
*a and
Ben Zhong
Tang
c
aCollege of Chemistry and Materials Science, Jinan University, Guangzhou 510632, China. E-mail: chenming@jnu.edu.cn
bAIE Research Center, Shaanxi Key Laboratory of Photochemistry, College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Baoji University of Arts and Sciences, Baoji 721013, China
cSchool of Science and Engineering, Shenzhen Institute of Aggregate Science and Technology, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shenzhen (CUHK-SZ), Guangdong, China
First published on 30th May 2024
The search for deep-blue dyes with high luminescence efficiency in the aggregate state and high brightness is particularly important in optoelectronic application. Herein, based on a typical aggregation-induced emission (AIE) unit of tetraphenylpyrazine (TPP), four dyes were prepared by connecting it with chiral binaphthyl units via an acetylenic bond. The use of the TPP unit is critical to aggregation-enhanced emission (AEE) and deep-blue emission, whereas the merging of the binaphthyl unit is beneficial for molecular conjugation to remarkably improve absorption, photoluminescence (PL) quantum efficiency and brightness. Besides, the binaphthyl unit can serve as an axially chiral source to endow the deep-blue dyes with chirality. It was revealed that attaching a longer alkoxy chain to the dyes facilitates the formation of helical self-assemblies determined by chiral transfer but leads to an aggregation-caused emission (ACQ) effect. Moreover, using these deep-blue dyes as energy donors for energy delivery, other emissions and pure white light emission can be generated effectively via an energy transfer process based on a rational mixture of donors and acceptors in PMMA films. The device fabricated by coating this film onto a blue LED also emitted distinct and stable white light. This work provides a flexible way to design high-performance blue materials for potential applications.
Furthermore, despite their potential to exhibit AIE or AEE effects based on their structural design, many fluorescent dyes eventually show a quenched fluorescence emission behaviour in the aggregate state.8 For example, Tang reported two diphenyldibenzofulvene-based dyes, which exhibited strong emissions in the crystal state but almost quenched emissions due to unformed aggregation.9 This indicates that the aggregation-state structure has a profound effect on emission behaviour. However, it is still a challenge to artificially control the aggregate-state behaviour to deeply understand this relationship. Recently, some studies have revealed that for designing high-efficiency photothermal conversion agents, attaching long alkyl chains to the dyes can space the molecules in the aggregate state while vigorous intramolecular motions can take place after excitation due to less steric restriction to boost the non-radiative energy dissipation.10 Thus, it is particularly interesting to use such a strategy to investigate the effect of side chain length on the aggregate-state behaviour of dyes as well as their emission properties, which is instructive to design the luminescent materials with desirable functions and applications.
The search for high-performance blue materials is always important in the optoelectronic field, as they can not only realize one of the three primary colours but also act as hosts to excite other emissions.11 However, the drawbacks of low luminescence efficiency and bad light purity still hamper their applications. Tetraphenylpyrazine (TPP) belongs to a class of heterocycle-based AIE cores, which shows the merits of facile synthesis, good stability, tunable electronic property, rich nitrogen site, etc.12 Many works have demonstrated the superiority of TPP in designing functional materials. For example, the AIE molecules with large two-photon absorption cross sections can be realized by using TPP as an acceptor to induce intramolecular charge transfer.13 A metal–organic framework with TPP as the ligand can fluorescently recognize arginine due to the specific hydrogen bond interaction between the guanidine group in arginine and the nitrogen atom in TPP.14 It is also reported that TPP is favourable to boost the intersystem crossing to enhance the photosensitization by supressing the internal conversion caused by the intramolecular motions in a photosensitizer design.15 The use of TPP in developing blue materials is also promising. By decorating TPP with phenanthroimidazole-based group, an AIE emitter with sky blue emission can be generated with its fabricated light-emitting device showing a high external quantum yield of 4.85%.16 Moreover, TPP can be used to fabricate a blue-emissive amphiphilic organic cage to capture diketopyrrolopyrrole via a host–guest interaction, while their combined roles can contribute to a white light emission.17 Much recently, we fabricated microfibers with a TPP-based AIE dye, which show a high PL quantum efficiency, narrow deep-blue emissions and good photo-stability. The fibers show a good waveguide effect with a low optical loss coefficient and can light up the other emissions in the microscale.18 Although much efforts have been devoted to design blue materials based on such a building block, achieving blue AIE or AEE dyes with high brightness is still desirable.
In this work, based on a typical AIE unit of TPP, we prepared four dyes (two pairs of chiral enantiomers) named TPP-C2(R), TPP-C2(S), TPP-C6(R) and TPP-C6(S) by connecting chiral binaphthyl units with an acetylenic linker (Chart 1). The utilization of the TPP unit is crucial to the AEE effect and deep-blue emission due to its intrinsic property. The merging of binaphthyl units can obviously increase the molecular conjugation to determine a high light absorption ability >8 × 104 cm−1 L mol−1, a PL quantum efficiency of ∼72% and brightness >5.5 × 104 cm−1 L mol−1, which was particularly desirable in the practical applications. Moreover, derived from the binaphthyl units, the molecular chirality was successfully achieved via chiral transfer, as observed from the CD spectra. The molecular chirality can transfer to their self-assembled aggregates. In particular, in TPP-C6(R) and TPP-C6(S) with a longer alkoxy chain, the self-assembled fibers with an opposite helix can be formed, which can be observed using a scanning electron microscope (SEM) and a fluorescence microscope. However, we found that increasing the length of side groups can transform the AEE effect to the ACQ effect, suggesting that the emission behaviour is closely related to the aggregate-state structure affected by this factor. These dyes were further used as energy donors to excite the other emissions. We demonstrate that based on a rational mixture of these deep-blue dyes with other fluorescent dyes (Dye-G, Dye-O and Dye-R) in PMMA, the distinct green, orange and red emissions can be obtained, respectively, with an energy transfer efficiency close to 100%. The PL quantum efficiencies of these emissions were much better than their unity without a donor, indicating a superiority of utilizing them for energy delivery and magnifying emission. Moreover, by using these dyes as donors, the pure white light with a Commission International de L’Eclairage (CIE) coordinate of (0.33, 0.33) and a PL quantum efficiency approaching 100% can generate through a controlled energy transfer effect. After coating the film onto the blue LED, the resulting device can give distinct and stable white light emissions. Thus, this work provides a strategy to design chiral dyes with deep-blue emissions and high brightness for potential optoelectronic applications.
The UV-Vis spectra indicated that these dyes almost possessed an identical absorption profile in THF (Fig. 1A). The long-wavelength absorption at 383 nm was ascribed to the extended conjugation by the molecular design, while the short-wavelength absorption at 344 nm was determined by the local excitation such as the TPP unit in the molecules. Moreover, their molar absorptivity (ε) has increased to more than 8 × 104 cm−1 L mol−1 when compared to TPP (2.4 × 104 cm−1 L mol−1) (Table S1, ESI†).12a This suggested that the combination of TPP with the binaphthyl unit has remarkably improved the light-harvesting ability. Moreover, in comparison to the solutions, a red-shift effect by ∼12 and ∼18 nm was found in the powders and doped PMMA films, respectively, which was probably due to the increased intermolecular interaction caused by the aggregation or changed molecular conformations affected by the external environment (Fig. S14, ESI†). The PL spectra showed that they all have an emission maximum at 438 nm in the solutions, while a slight red-shift effect by ∼12 nm can be found in their powders (Fig. 1B and S15, ESI†). This is in accordance with the UV-Vis spectral results that the intermolecular interaction increased to some extent due to the aggregate effect. However, the emission of PMMA films was a bit bluer than that of the solutions. This is because their structural relaxation after excitation has been remarkably reduced by the rigid media, which affected the molecular levels.19 These dyes possessed short-lived fluorescence emissions as recorded by the transient PL spectra (Fig. 1C and S16, ESI†). Moreover, their PL quantum yield (ΦF) in the solutions, powders and films was evaluated by an integrating sphere. The results indicated that the ΦF values of TPP-C2(R) and TPP-C2(S) in the solutions were 18.3% and 18.7%, respectively, which were much smaller than that in the powders (31.3% and 28.0%) (Fig. 1D and Table S1, ESI†). Thus, the AEE effect was realized in TPP-C2(R) and TPP-C2(S), which was attributed to the introduction of the TPP unit. Because TPP is AIE-active, it may endow the resulting molecules with a high conformational freedom, which will provide structural relaxation in the excited state in the solution to weaken the emission, while such relaxation can be restricted in the aggregate state to enhance the emission.12a However, the emission of the dyes can be tuned by the aggregate-state behaviour affected by the appended alkoxy chains. For example, TPP-C6(R) and TPP-C6(S) possessed similar ΦF values to TPP-C2(R) and TPP-C2(S) in the solutions. However, their ΦF values dropped to 10.0% and 14.6%, respectively in the powders. Thus, increasing the length of side groups makes them suffer from the ACQ effect. This was because the much longer alkoxy chains in TPP-C6(R) and TPP-C6(S) may provide much flexible surroundings while the excited-state intramolecular motions were still easy to take place to boost the non-radiative transition. The ΦF values of all dyes were recorded as high as ∼72% in the films. This confirmed that a rigid environment can be formed by PMMA to prohibit the intramolecular motions to further boost the emissions.19 Normally, the brightness (εΦF) is an important parameter to evaluate the luminescent materials by a combinative consideration of their absorption and emission properties. Here, the brightness of these dyes in these films was calculated to be more than 5.5 × 104 cm−1 L mol−1, which were superior to the most reported conventional dyes and AIE dyes (Fig. 1E and Table S1, ESI†).20 Moreover, the Commission International de L’Eclairage (CIE) coordinates of these films were (0.15, 0.05) (Fig. 1F and Table S1, ESI†). All these suggested that these dyes are deep-blue materials with excellent brightness, which were particularly desirable in the practical applications.
Moreover, to provide more insights into the photophysical properties of these dyes, their excited-state decay rates were evaluated using the formula of kr = ΦF/τ and knr = (1 − ΦF)/τ, where kr, knr and τ are the radiative and non-radiative decay rates, and excited-state lifetime, respectively. Their calculated kr values in the solutions were ∼0.36 × 109 S−1, which were much larger than that in the powder (0.12–0.28 × 109 S−1) (Table S2, ESI†). It was corresponding to the possible formation of excimers caused by the binaphthyl unit in the aggregate state, which impaired the radiative transition process. Moreover, the knr values of these dyes in the solutions were 1.15–1.67 × 109 S−1. However, in the powders, the knr values of TPP-C2(R) and TPP-C2(S) reduced remarkably as the excited-state intramolecular motions were prohibited by the aggregation. The much obvious reduction in knr than kr from the aggregate to solution state can lead to the AEE effect. By comparison, the knr values of TPP-C6(R) and TPP-C6(S) were nearly as twice as that of TPP-C2(R) and TPP-C2(S) and close to that of their solutions. This suggested that the introduction of long alkoxy chains into the molecules can facilitate the intramolecular motions to quench the emission even when they were in the aggregate state. Besides, a much larger kr value of ∼0.61 × 109 S−1 can be found in their films in comparison to the solutions and powders. This may be due to two factors: (1) in PMMA films, the molecular conjugation may increase due to the conformational change and (2) the molecules were diluted by the films, while the formation of excimers may be effectively prohibited. Furthermore, the PMMA matrix also played a positive role in supressing the non-radiative transition as reflected by their much reduced knr value of ∼0.25 × 109 S−1, suggesting that this rigid matrix was pretty evident to restrict the intramolecular motions in the excited state.
In this work, we employed the binaphthyl unit not only because of the role in strengthening the molecular conjugation but also in consideration of a chiral source to bestow the dyes with chirality. To check this, their circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopies in the solutions were investigated. As shown in Fig. 2A, the CD spectra of TPP-C2(R) and TPP-C2(S) in the solutions showed distinct Cotton effects and a mirror-image relationship at a wavelength in the range from 230 to 450 nm. The CD signals at ∼260 nm were attributed to the binaphthyl moiety, whereas the CD bands centered at ∼390 nm and 350 nm were mainly decided by the whole molecule and TPP unit, respectively, which were corresponding to the absorption peaks in the UV-Vis spectra. This indicated that the chirality of the binaphthyl unit has successfully transferred from the part to the whole, and two chiral enantiomers with deep-blue emissions and AEE property were obtained. Besides, a very similar phenomenon was observed in the CD spectra of TPP-C6(R) and TPP-C6(S) though they experienced an ACQ effect (Fig. 2B).
Many studies indicated that the molecular chirality may aid in the self-assembly to definite morphologies such as vesicles, spheres and fibers.21 Would such self-assembly behaviour be achieved by our dyes? To answer this question, we prepared the samples with TPP-C2(R) and TPP-C2(S) dissolved in a CHCl3/CH3CN (v/v = 1:1) mixture. Because CHCl3 and CH3CN separately served as good and poor solvents, this moderate mixture may induce the formation of self-assemblies with the time. However, there was nothing detectable in the solutions by naked eyes during a continuous 5-day observation. On day 5, the sample was extracted and casted onto the silica plate, followed by studying using a scanning electron microscope (SEM). The results indicated that there were almost no definite self-assemblies, which can be observed in the image, suggestive of a worse self-assembly behaviour (Fig. S17, ESI†). In sharp contrast, a much clear structure can be formed when TPP-C6(R) and TPP-C6(S) were dissolved in the same mixture. For TPP-C6(R), the explicit fibers with a diameter of ∼15 µm can be found by SEM, which were uniformly right-handed (Fig. 2C). A similar phenomenon can be observed using a fluorescence microscope under UV light excitation, while the deep-blue fibers with a specific helix can be discerned (Fig. 2D and E). Moreover, although the fibers of similar sizes can be generated by TPP-C6(S) under the same condition, they were almost left-handed, which were confirmed by both SEM and fluorescence microscopy (Fig. 2F–H). This suggested that the molecular chirality has transferred to their self-assembled aggregates through a hierarchical approach, which ensured an efficient outcome for the generation of highly functional self-assembled structures.22 In other words, the length of alkoxy chains appended to the chiral molecules played a vital role in this transfer behaviour.
The S0 geometries of these dyes were optimized by B3LYP/6-31G(d,p), Grimme's DFT-D3.23 The results indicated that these conformations were highly twisted, particularly in the TPP and binaphthyl moieties (Fig. S18, ESI†). Thus, the incorporation of the TPP unit may weaken the π–π stacking effect while restricting the intramolecular motions in the aggregate state to facilitate the emission. The twist between two naphthyl rings in the binaphthyl unit in the enantiomers was opposite with a dihedral angle larger than 70°. The remarkable conformational difference may ensure the chiral property of dyes due to the mirror symmetry. The electronic structure analysis suggested that the highest occupied molecular orbitals (HOMOs) of these dyes were mainly distributed on the central binaphthyl units, part of the peripheral TPP unit and the connected acetylenic bonds (Fig. 3). In contrast, more electronic clouds were found in the pyrazine rings of TPP besides the above-mentioned regions in their lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals (LUMOs). The successive electronic cloud distribution on the whole molecules suggested that a good conjugation effect has been realized due to a good planarity between the naphthyl rings and the phenyl rings connected by the acetylenic bonds. Moreover, good electronic cloud overlapping between the HOMOs and LUMOs manifested that local state excitation is dominant in the excitation behaviour. Both factors can contribute to a high molar absorptivity and luminescence efficiency of the dyes. Moreover, we found that the molecular conformation as well as the electronic structure were less affected by the length of alkoxy chains, suggesting that such role exerted a negligible effect on their photo-physical properties at a molecular level.
Fig. 3 Orbital distribution on S0 conformations of (A) TPP-C2(R) and TPP-C2(S), and (B) TPP-C6(R) and TPP-C6(S) optimized by B3LYP/6-31G(d,p), Grimme's DFT-D3 and their energy levels. |
With the high-brightness deep-blue dyes in the hand, we expected to utilize them as an energy host to excite the other emissions. In this work, three fluorescent dyes named Dye-G, Dye-O and Dye-R were adopted, with their structures shown in Fig. 4A. Most of these dyes have been proved to show the AIE effect with green, orange and red emissions, respectively, and possess a high luminescence efficiency.24 We thus synthesized them according to the procedure reported in the literature with their structures well characterized by NMR spectroscopy (see ESI†). The PL study indicated that they showed emission maximums at 488, 578 and 614 nm in the films, while their absorption maximums were located at 401, 460 and 494 nm in THF, respectively (Fig. 4B and S19, ESI†). Note that the absorptions of these dyes have good overlapping with the emission of deep-blue dyes, indicating a theoretical possibility for the energy transfer from the donors to the acceptors. Indeed, when they are doped into deep-blue dyes with PMMA as a matrix, their emissions can originate remarkably with the increase in doping concentration accompanied by the decrease in blue light intensities. Moreover, the energy transfer efficiency was calculated using the formula of η = 1 − (IDA/ID), where ID is the emission intensity of donor initially, and IDA is the emission intensity of donor after doping with the acceptor.25 Our studies revealed that with a suitable mixing ratio, almost all the energies can be transferred from the donors to the acceptors after excitation (Fig. 4C and Fig. S20, ESI†). For example, when the ratio of TPP-C2(R) between Dye-G, Dye-O and Dye-R reached 2 wt%:1 wt%, 7.3 wt%:0.9 wt%, and 16.5 wt%:0.8 wt%, very high η of 93.5%, 99.9% and 97.9% can be realized, respectively (Table S3, ESI†). Because TPP-C2(S), TPP-C6(R) and TPP-C6(S) behaved similarly in the PMMA films, they all possessed a similar energy transfer process with these dopants. Moreover, the average PL quantum efficiencies of these acceptors were recorded as high as 67.1%, 99.1% and 54.8%, respectively, which were much better than their pure state, suggesting that it was attractive to magnify the emissions of other dyes through an energy transfer approach with our deep-blue dyes as energy donors (Table S3, ESI†).26
White light plays an essential role in the illumination in our daily life.27 The white light is always realized by a partial energy transfer from the blue host to the other guest, while a mixed blue emission and other emissions can generate a consecutive spectrum similar to the visible light region in the sunlight.28 In this regard, TPP-C2(R) or TPP-C2(S) was taken as a host to excite Dye-O. While the ratio of TPP-C2(R)/TPP-C2(S):Dye-O were all 1 wt%:0.3 wt%, the distinct white light emissions comprising the blue light from the donor and the orange light from the acceptor can emerge with their PL quantum efficiencies approaching 100% (Fig. 4D and E and Table S3, ESI†). The white emission can also be obtained by a controllable mixture of TPP-C2(R) or TPP-C2(S) with Dye-G and Dye-R in PMMA if the emission from the individual was balanced (Fig. 4G and H). However, their luminescence efficiencies have discounted to some extent based on this approach (Table S3, ESI†). Moreover, the CIE coordinates of these films were recorded as (0.33, 0.33), which matched well with the standard of pure white light proposed by the International Commission on illumination (Fig. 4F and I). TPP-C6(R) and TPP-C6(S) also played a similar role in generating white light (Fig. S21, ESI†). All these indicated that the high-quality white light emission can be realized readily with our dyes as hosts. Finally, to demonstrate the potential applications, the white light PMMA film containing TPP-C2(R) and Dye-O was coated on a blue LED (Fig. 5A–C). It was clear that the strong white light can be generated with the LED as an excitation source (Fig. 5D–F). Moreover, as reflected by the fluorescence spectra, less changes in colour and emission intensities can be found during 5 days, indicating a good stability in the use (Fig. S22, ESI†). Thus, it was promising to fabricate it as a device for potential illuminations.
Fig. 5 (A)–(C) Fabrication of while light-emitting device based on blue LEDs by coating a TPP-C2(R)/Dye-O film. (D)–(F) Exhibition of white light emission by the device in 5 days. |
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4tc01374c |
‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |