Junxia
Wang
a,
Ziyi
Lu
ab,
Ruisi
Cai
a,
Hanqi
Zheng
a,
Jicheng
Yu
abcd,
Yuqi
Zhang
*ae and
Zhen
Gu
*abcdf
aZhejiang Provincial Key Laboratory for Advanced Drug Delivery Systems, College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, 310058, China. E-mail: yqzhang21@zju.edu.cn; guzhen@zju.edu.cn
bDepartment of General Surgery, Sir Run Run Shaw Hospital, School of Medicine, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, 310016, China
cJinhua Institute of Zhejiang University, Jinhua, 321299, China
dLiangzhu Laboratory, Zhejiang University Medical Center, Hangzhou, 311121, China
eDepartment of Burns and Wound Center, Second Affiliated Hospital, School of Medicine, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, 310009, China
fMOE Key Laboratory of Macromolecular Synthesis and Functionalization, Department of Polymer Science and Engineering, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, 310027, China
First published on 11th January 2023
Microneedles have been expected for the construction of next-generation biosensors towards personalization, digitization, and intellectualization due to their metrics of minimal invasiveness, high integration, and favorable biocompatibility. Herein, an overview of state-of-the-art microneedle-based detection and sensing systems is presented. First, the designs of microneedle devices based on extraction mechanisms are concluded, corresponding to different geometries and materials of microneedles. Second, the targets of equipment-assisted microneedle detections are summarized, as well as the objective significance, revealing the current performance and potential scenarios of these microneedles. Third, the trend towards highly integrated sensors is elaborated by emphasizing the sensing principles (colorimetric, fluorometric and electronic manner). Finally, the key challenges to be tackled and the perspectives on future development are discussed.
Microneedles, a type of needle mostly shorter than 2 mm, have become an attractive minimally invasive transdermal approach. The original concept of microneedles was described in the 1970s. Along with the development of etching techniques, the first microneedle-structured array was reported by Hashmi et al. in 1995,3 and subsequently, Henry et al. firstly applied them in the transdermal delivery of calcein AM.4 The first microneedle-based sensing method, employing silicon microneedles in combination with a microcuvette for glucose level determination in blood, emerged in 2000.5 In the 2010s, Gu and coworkers integrated a glucose-sensitive component and a drug release component into a microneedle array patch for closed-loop insulin delivery.6,7 Since then, applications of microneedles have been investigated for more than two decades, involving biofluid sampling, instrument-coupled detecting, integrated sensing, and drug delivery.
As an attractive platform, microneedles offer the following advantages in sampling, detection, and sensing areas. Fine designed shapes of microneedles enable minimalized invasive insertion with high patient compliance. Diverse choices of materials and easy manufacturing allow high integration and flexible modification, providing opening scopes for biological sensing. The fabrication of microneedles could be cost-effective and mass-productive, offering vast possibilities for productization, marketization, and terminalization. To date, microneedle-based assays not only facilitate fitness adjustments, daily health management, and disease progression tracking, but also provide new insights into agricultural virus prevention, drug abuse control and food safety inspection.8–12
The majority of detection or sensing-aimed microneedles are still in the clinical trial stage. Only the TAP device,13–15 a microneedle-based minimal blood collection device (∼100 μL), has been approved by the FDA for use in hospitals, clinics, pharmacies, laboratories, and other settings. Taking diabetes monitoring as an example, TAP could be used to perform glycated hemoglobin testing, which is an indicator typically associated with blood glucose levels in diabetic people. In fact, microneedles are currently mostly commercialized in the field of cosmetics. Moreover, there are also several microneedles approved for transdermal injection and delivery of vaccines, insulin, or anesthetics, including Soluvia® (Becton-Dickinson Technologies),16 Intanza® (Sanofi Pasteur),17 MicronJet® (NanoPass Technologies),18etc.
In this review, we focus on state-of-the-art microneedle-based sampling, detection and sensing devices. First, the microanatomy of the skin and biofluids is introduced, and extraction mechanisms are concluded to guide the shape design and material optimization of microneedles. Second, the targets and significances of equipment-assisted microneedle detections are surveyed to reveal the current performance and potential scenarios of these microneedles, including physiological indicators, ions, small molecules, nucleic acids, proteins, cells and bacteria, as well as multiplex assays. Third, the trend towards highly integrated sensors is elaborated by emphasizing the inside sensing principles (colorimetric, fluorometric and electronic manner). Finally, the current challenges to be tackled and the perspectives on future development are also discussed to fulfil the great potential of this technology.
Blood tests have long been the gold standard for clinical diagnosis. The blood in the skin is mainly delivered by the capillaries in the dermis, which consists of two intercommunicating plexuses: the superficial plexus (300–600 μm depth) located at the junction of the papillary layer and reticular layer, and the deeper plexus (1300–1500 μm depth) situated at the dermal–subcutaneous junction.24 Generated by blood transcapillary filtration, ISF is contained in all layers of the skin underneath the stratum corneum and accounts for 45% of the skin volume (blood only 5%).25 There are three dominant pathways for the analyte exchange of ISF: transcellular for analytes around a few hundred Daltons or less and uncharged analytes like glucose; paracellular and transcytosis for larger and charged analytes like proteins.26 Therefore, the ISF concentrations of electrolyte ions (e.g., Na+, K+), small molecules (e.g., glucose), and some diets (e.g., caffeine, alcohol) are comparable to the plasma concentrations.27–31 However, some hormones like cortisol or antibiotics like penicillin and vancomycin are protein bound. Their concentrations in ISF are only equal to the free state concentrations in plasma, excluding the protein-bound ones.32–34 Reported concentrations of common biological analytes in blood and ISF have been surveyed and are presented in Table 1. To make full contact with the capillary plexus, microneedles for blood extraction are generally longer than 1500 μm.19,35,36 However, microneedles for ISF extraction could be as short as 100 μm,37 and the needle length is usually less than 1500 μm to avoid blood drawing.
Analytes | Molecular weight (Da) | Blood/plasma | ISF | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|
Na+ | 23.0 | ∼136 mM | Similar | 27 |
K+ | 39.1 | ∼3.97 mM | Similar | 27 |
Glucose | 180.2 | 1.6–28.4 mM | Similar | 28 |
Lactate | 90.1 | 6.9–24.9 mg dL−1 | 20.6–56.6 mg dL−1 | 29 |
Caffeine | 194.2 | Can reach several tens of μM | Similar | 31 |
Alcohol | 46.1 | Can reach several tens of mM | Similar to a breathalyzer outcome (a direct estimation of blood alcohol content) | 30 |
Cortisol | 362.5 | Hundreds of nanomolars (∼90% protein bound) | Similar to unbound in plasma | 32 |
Penicillin G | 334.4 | ∼60% protein bound | Similar to unbound in plasma | 33 |
Vancomycin | 1449.3 | ∼55% protein bound | Similar to unbound in plasma | 34 |
Fig. 2 Schematic illustrations of different extraction mechanisms of (A) swelling-based extraction. Reproduced with permission.51 Copyright 2017, Wiley-VCH Verlag. (B) Antibody-based extraction. Reproduced with permission.56 Copyright 2021, Springer Nature Publishing. |
Targets | Microneedle compositions | Detection ranges | Time consumptions/continuous sensing | Related equipment | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Subcellular mechanical force | PDMS-MNs coated with fibronectin or collagen IV | >12 nN | — | Confocal microscopy | 58 |
Two-degrees of freedom (DOF) force | Stainless steel-MNs with silica epoxy resin optical fibers, and a nitinol tube | 0.25–15 mN | — | Fiber Bragg grating (FBG) interrogator | 59 |
Three-degrees of freedom (DOF) force | Stainless steel-MNs with silica epoxy resin optical fibers, and a nitinol tube | >0.124 mN for the X/Y direction, >0.74 mN for the Z direction | — | Fiber Bragg grating (FBG) interrogator | 60 |
K+ | Eshell 300-MNs with PMMA microfluidic channels | 10−5–10−2 M | 20 s for stabilization | Potentiostat | 67 |
K+, Na+ | A 26-gauge hypodermic needle assembled with a PDMS substrate, and electrodes | 5–200 mM for NaCl, and 1–15 mM for KCl | <100 s | Potentiostat | 69 |
pH | Epoxy siloxane-MNs with a PDMS substrate | pH = 3–7 | Continuously sensing for 5 h | Electrochemical analyzer | 71 |
pH | Stainless-steel acupuncture needles | pH = 4–8 | 5 min for a single response, continuously sensing for >40 min | Micro Raman spectrometer | 74 |
pH | (NOA) 65-MNs | pH = 5–9 | — | Microscopy with extra-long working distance (ELWD) objectives | 73 |
Lactate | PC–MNs with Au electrodes and nanocarbons | 10–200 μM | — | Potentiostat | 77 |
Lactate | Pt–MNs with functional electrodes | 0.375–12 mM | — | Potentiostat | 78 |
β-Hydroxybutyrate, glucose | Carbon paste-filled hollow MNs with electrodes | 0.05–12 mM for β-hydroxybutyrate, 1–10 mM for glucose | Continuously sensing for 4 h | Potentiostat | 99 |
Alcohol | Stainless steel-MNs with a Pt wire multilayer transducer | 5–80 mM | Continuously sensing for 100 min with 10 min intervals | Potentiostat | 93 |
H2O2 | Steel-MNs coated with GO/H2PtCl6 | 0.4–20 mM | 5 min | Electrochemical workstation | 95 |
Urea | c-GelMA-MNs | — | — | Commercial urea kit | 97 |
Vancomycin | Au-coated Ni–MNs with optofluidics | 0.1–72.6 μM | 10 min | — | 87 |
Morphine and fentanyl | Hollow MNs with working electrodes and carbon paste transducers | 20–140 μM for morphine, 10–200 μM for fentanyl | 1 min for a single time of response, continuously sensing for 3 h | Potentiostat | 11 |
Fentanyl | Pt–MNs with electrodes modified by graphene ink | 27.8–160 μM | — | Potentiostat | 89 |
Apomorphine | Resin-MNs with electrodes | 20–100 μM | Continuous sensing for 2 h with 10-min intervals | Potentiostat | 90 |
Levodopa | Resin-MNs with electrodes | 5–300 μM | Continuous sensing for 2 h with 10 min intervals | Potentiostat | 91 |
DNA of Phytophthora infestans | PVA-MNs | 1.2 pg μL−1 to 12 ng μL−1 | 1 h | Thermal cycler | 10 |
DNA of Epstein–Barr virus | PMVE/MA-MNs | 1.5 × 104–5.0 × 106 copies per μL | 15 min | Microfluidic biosensors with a potentiostat | 102 |
DNA of Epstein–Barr virus | PMVE/MA-MNs with printed nanotubes | 5.0–1.0 × 104 copies per μL | 10 min | Potentiostat and electrochemical microfluidic biosensor | 103 |
DNA of Epstein–Barr virus, sepsis-associated cfDNA, and kidney transplantation-associated cfDNA | PMVE/MA-MNs with printed nanotubes | 3 × 10−14–3 × 10−11 M | Continuous sensing for 8 days | Electrochemical workstation | 104 |
DNA of the allergized domain in milk and shrimps | PVA-MNs | 0.00003 ppm for milk DNA, and 0.00005 ppm for shrimp DNA | <1 h | Thermal cycler | 105 |
miRNA | PLLA-MNs coated with alginate and peptide nucleic acid | 6–500 nM | <0.5 h | Fluorescence scanner | 49 |
miRNA | GO-GelMA-MNs | 500 pM–500 nM | 1 h | Confocal microscope | 116 |
Myoglobin and troponin | Au–MNs with electrodes | 100–1000 ppb | — | Potentiostat | 108 |
Epidermal growth factor receptor 2 | Si–MNs with Au electrodes | 50–250 ng mL−1 | <1 h | Potentiostat | 9 |
IL-8 | Au–MNs embedded with microwells | 62 pg mL−1 to 538.6 ng mL−1 | <20 min | Potentiostat | 112 |
Cocaine antibody, interleukin 6, and periostin | PS-MNs with Fe3O4 nanoparticles in the substrate | 0.33 pg mL−1 −2.5 ng mL−1 for cocaine antibody, n.s. for interleukin 6 and periostin | 5 h | Fluorescence imager | 56 |
E. coli | TMA/CAA/HEMA-MNs with Au-nanopopcorns | 1.43 × 102 −2.4 × 106 cfu g−f | <10 min | Raman spectrometer | 113 |
Tissue-resident memory T cells | PLLA-MNs coated with alginate and sucrose | — | 24 h | Flow cytometry | 114 |
TNF-α, IL-1β, and IL-6 | PEGDA/PEG/ HMPP-MNs coated with photonic crystals | 10–500 ng mL−1 for TNF-α, IL-1β, and IL-6 | <3 h | Spectrometer and luminoscope | 115 |
Mechanical forces are essential in the interaction of cells with their surrounding extracellular matrix (ECM). To evaluate interactions inside cells, Tan et al. proposed a PDMS-based elastomeric microneedle array. Cells could attach to multiple posts, resulting in deflection in needles, and the degree of deflection observed by confocal microscopy could directly indicate the traction of the subcellular force distributions (Fig. 3A).58 Besides, miniaturized force sensors could offer the surgeon imperceptible force information, improving the accuracy and safety of retinal microsurgery. To assist retinal vein cannulation practice, Gonenc et al. attached two fiber Bragg grating (FBG) sensors on one hollow stainless-steel microneedle. Tests on fertilized eggs showed a 100% success in cannulation, demonstrating the feedback sensing of the microneedle sensors.59 Similarly, while previous studies focused on 2D mechanical monitoring, Zhang et al. took it further into 3D force sensing, by increasing the number of optical fibers into three. Benefiting from this novel FBG configuration, the detection sensitivity was also improved.60
Fig. 3 Schematic illustrations of microneedles for detection of different targets. (A) Representative SEM images of cells attached to a microneedle array for single-cell force sensing. Reproduced with permission.58 Copyright 2003, National Academy of Sciences. (B) Plasmonic microneedles coated with gold nanorods functionalized with pH-sensing molecules. Reproduced with permission.73 Copyright 2019, American Chemical Society. (C) Electrochemical sensing platform for quantitative detection of lactate which was correlated with tumor progression. Reproduced with permission.78 Copyright 2021, Elsevier. (D) Rapid extraction of plant DNA using swelling microneedles. Reproduced with permission.10 Copyright 2019, American Chemical Society. (E) Minimally invasive detection of cocaine-specific antibodies in an immunized mouse model after microneedle extraction. Reproduced with permission.56 Copyright 2021, Springer Nature Publishing. Copyright 2020, American Chemical Society. |
Biosignals like EMGs, ECGs, and EEGs are all tightly related to physiological status. Particularly, at-home surveillance devices to measure these biosignals are expected to be wearable, miniaturized, highly biocompatible, and stable to meet the needs of long duration monitoring. For the sake of improving biocompatibility, the main body of these MNs is commonly made of titanium, polyimide, and silicon.61
EMGs provide the opportunity to evaluate and record the electrical activity generated by skeletal muscles. Kim et al. proposed a curved microneedle array integrated with a band. The EMG signals before and after 20 min of stair climbing exercise were recorded and compared with those of commercial electrodes, with the microneedles exhibiting improved sweating-tolerance.62 Guvanasen et al. designed stretchable PDMS microneedles to cover and monitor the lateral gastrocnemius muscle in felines. The microneedles could bear repeated stretching of up to 40% tensile strain.63
ECGs can be sensed with microneedle electrodes by measuring minor electrical changes in the skin, which come from the depolarization and repolarization of the heart muscle during heartbeats. Wang et al. fabricated a PDMS microneedle array and coated it with a layer of Ti and a layer of Au, achieving a smaller impedance and higher signal quality during ECG monitoring.64 Long-term monitoring as long as 48 h has been achieved, as well as human volunteer testings.65
EEGs reflect voltage fluctuations caused by ionic currents in neurons, and are commonly used to diagnose epilepsy, sleep disorders, coma, encephalopathy, and even brain death. Microneedles enable the direct collection of an EEG, without the need of hair cutting or gel smearing, providing a user-friendly approach for patients needing long-term monitoring. Wang et al. fabricated a MEMS-based pyramid microneedle array for long-time EEG measurement. The impedance of the microneedle electrode was found to be much more stable than that of a standard electrode within a 5 h monitoring.66
Acid/base disorders are closely associated with renal failure, ischemia, multiple sclerosis and psychiatric disorders. Therefore, monitoring the dynamics of pH in the body is also of great significance for health monitoring and disease progression indication.70 To realize pH sensing, Lee et al. fabricated a conformable microneedle array with epoxy siloxane and polydimethylsiloxane. Polyaniline, whose conductivity is strongly influenced by pH, was coated on microneedles, realizing sensitive and persistent skin pH monitoring in a peripheral artery disease (PAD) mouse model.71 Mani et al. proposed an electrode-based microneedle to achieve label-free and real-time pH sensing. The in vivo performance of this microneedle was demonstrated in mouse cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and bladders, indicating a wide range of potential clinical applications.72 Moreover, specific molecules binding with H+ or responding to various pH levels would improve the specificity of microneedle analysis. Park et al. reported an in situ sensing plasmonic microneedle array that could work in the human skin, functionalized with pH-responsive 4-mercaptobenzoic acid-coated nanorods (Fig. 3B).73 Besides conventional structures, acupuncture-derived microneedles have also been applied in pH sensing. Pan et al. etched two groves on one acupuncture needle, loaded with redox-responsive and pH-responsive SERS probes, respectively. In muscles, the redox and pH could be detected by this acupuncture-derived microneedle within 5 min.74 Besides healthcare, applications of microneedles have been extended to food safety control. Li et al. utilized the above acupuncture-derived microneedle to detect the redox and acid states of peels, bananas, and strawberries, to avoid food exposed to the air.75
Besides sports medicine, lactate is also a tumor biomarker. Cancer cells increase glucose consumption through glycolysis, while continuously pumping out lactate. This process promotes angiogenesis and immune escape. Thereby, the level of lactate is also an indicator of tumor stage, metastasis, and survival. Li et al. produced a lactate-sensing microneedle array and successfully recorded the lactate levels in tumor-bearing mice. The signal intensity was found to be associated with tumor burden and progression (Fig. 3C).78
According to the International Diabetes Federation, about 537 million adults and 1.2 million children and adolescents suffer from diabetes.82 Hypoglycemia could lead to convulsions or coma, while chronic hyperglycemia causes eye and kidney injury. Long term monitoring of blood glucose levels is of substantial significance for diabetes management. For instance, for each additional day of sensor application per week, the glycated hemoglobin levels could be cut by an average of 0.15%.83 However, the invasive and painful application of these devices limits patient compliance. More recently, glucose sensing devices are heading towards integration, digitalization, and wearability. Tehhrani et al. proposed a fully-integrated wearable microneedle sensor with a wireless transportation function for dual biomarker detection (lactate and glucose, or alcohol and glucose). This wearable device has been verified in volunteers performing common daily activities with robust analytical performances.84 Moreover, Li et al. developed a wearable system to realize closed-loop treatment through sequential glucose sensing, signal transportation, and intelligent drug release. With incorporation with reversible iontophoresis (RI) microneedles and a flexible printed circuit board (PCB) controller, this device exhibited accurate tracking of glucose fluctuations and responsive release of enclosed insulin, successfully regulating the blood glucose levels in a diabetic rat model.53 Besides, to overcome the low-throughput limitation of RI-based sensors, Cheng et al. constructed a fully-integrated touch-actuated glucose microneedle sensor, achieving a 160% enhancement in extraction throughputs.85 In addition, the combination of microneedles and stretchable soft electronic sensors could further improve a diabetic patient's compliance. Lee et al. applied a graphene–Au hybrid sensor with improved electrochemical activities in the construction of a wearable microneedle patch, which could monitor glucose levels in ISF and offer feedback therapeutics accordingly. The sweat-based sensing of glucose and pH was demonstrated in diabetic mouse models and two human volunteers.86
Vancomycin (VAN), a specific antibiotic against Gram-positive bacteria, is the last choice for the treatment of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus infection.87 However, excess VAN in circulating biofluids would lead to nephrotoxicity (renal failure) and ototoxicity (irreversible deafness). To monitor the VAN levels, Ranamukhaarachchi et al. developed an optofluidics-integrated hollow microneedle and analysed VAN levels through a competitive binding assay. Only sub-nanolitre volumes (∼1 nL) of ISF were required to reach a wide working range.87 Furthermore, Rawson et al. have reported the first in-human study of real-time electric monitoring of phenoxymethylpenicillin using microneedles. This evaluation has shown that the pharmacokinetics obtained by microneedle analysis and microdialysis were highly similar, and the area under the concentration (AUC)–time curve of the drug in ISF is similar to that in serum.88
For abuse management of addictive drugs such as opioids (OPs), a cost-effective and rapidly responsive sensing platform could be availed for drug control. Mishra et al. provided a wearable electronic microneedle device for the simultaneous and continuous monitoring of fentanyl and OP nerve agents. In a skin-mimicking gel model, screening for morphine and fentanyl has been demonstrated.11 Moreover, Joshi et al. proposed an interference-free fentanyl detecting assay using microneedles, the sensing performance of which was verified in diluted serum.89 Similarly, in situ monitoring of apomorphine90 and levodopa91 has also been validated in microneedles, providing attractive tools for drug abuse control.
Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), a by-product of reactive oxygen metabolism and a hub for the interconversion of reactive oxygen species, is the most common reactive oxygen molecule in living organisms. H2O2 is closely related to apoptosis and cell proliferation, and the related signalling pathways are associated with asthma, inflammatory arthritis, atherosclerosis, neurodegenerative diseases, etc.94 Jin et al. proposed a microneedle-based electrochemical biosensor, and achieved in situ and real-time sensing on pig skin and living mice. This work demonstrated a promising platform for highly sensitive H2O2 sensing, in a minimally invasive manner.95
Urea and uric acid are metabolites of proteins, and are excreted almost exclusively by the kidneys. The urea or uric acid level is clinically significant in assessing kidney function and monitoring kidney diseases.96 To determine urea and indicate renal complaints, Fonseca et al. described a swelling microneedle platform for ex vivo extraction of urea. The subsequent urea detection was conducted with a commercial kit.97 Moreover, He et al. reported a microneedle-based colorimetric tattoo sensor, whose colors changed with pH, glucose, uric acid, and temperature levels in four separated detection areas, realizing the simultaneous detection of the four targets ex vivo.98
Similarly, ketone body monitoring was also realized using microneedles. Since ketone body accumulation leads to hyperglycaemia and metabolic acidosis, complications of diabetic ketoacidosis often happen to diabetic patients, with potentially fatal consequences. Therefore, monitoring both blood glucose and ketone bodies is greatly needed for diabetic patients. Teymourian et al. proposed a real-time monitoring microneedle patch for the continuous detection of ketone bodies and glucose, by measuring β-hydroxybutyrate (a common ketoacidosis biomarker) through β-hydroxybutyrate dehydrogenase.99
Plant diseases could bring a severe impact on agricultural productivity, while pathogen-induced poor harvest is a widespread issue. In terms of the in-field diagnosis of plant diseases, Paul et al. fabricated a swelling microneedle patch that could extract pathogen DNA (Phytophthora infestans) from field-infected tomato leaves. After extraction, conventional PCR was carried out to quantify the specific DNA fragment (Fig. 3D).10 In order to expand application scenarios, they have also improved this device with an isothermal nucleic acid amplification approach and integrated it with a cellphone-based fluorescence analyzer.100
The Epstein–Barr virus (EBV), a DNA virus of the herpesvirus family, is the pathogen of infectious mononucleosis. EBV is closely associated with the development of nasopharyngeal carcinoma and childhood lymphoma, and has been classified as one of the potentially cancer-causing viruses.101 Rapid sensing of EBV could facilitate the management of individual antiviral therapy. Yang et al. designed microneedles coated with specific oligonucleotides that could respond to EBV genome fragments, which were then sensed with an electrochemical microfluidic platform.102 Furthermore, they combined this device with a reverse iontophoresis approach to realize a wearable EBV-sensing microneedle patch with improved DNA capture. This device could detect EBV DNA from tumor-bearing immunodeficient mice, and the limit of detection was lowered into several copies per μL in vitro, showing great progress for a wearable electronic healthcare device.103 Recently, clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) technology has also been integrated into microneedle devices for analysis of nucleic acids. Yang et al. demonstrated a CRISPR-activated wearable system consisting of a flexible PDMS substrate, a pair of printed carbon nanotubes, and a three-electrode microneedle prototype functionalized with Cas9/sgRNA.104 The wearable system achieved real-time monitoring of viruses, sepsis, and cell-free DNA with 60% fetal bovine serum interference. The in vivo studies proved its satisfying stability of over 10 days.104
On account of a large number of allergy sufferers, a rapid screening platform for allergens is indispensable for individualized daily healthcare. Li et al. reported a swelling microneedle array to screen the DNA of specific allergy sources (milk, shrimp) in foods, providing a promising daily health control candidate for allergic people.105
MicroRNA, a class of short noncoding RNAs (commonly 19–25 nucleotides), also holds wide potential to become an individual biomarker or in combinations. Sulaiman et al. proposed a hydrogel microneedle patch functionalized with peptide nucleic acid (PNA). The specific miRNA could bind with the conjugated PNA through base pairing, and was subsequently stained by DNA dye, enabling in vivo fluorescence detection of specific miRNAs in a psoriatic mouse model.49
Myoglobin and troponin are the mostly used biomarkers of myocardial damage, which fall off from myocardial fibers during cell injury and then enter the biofluid circulation.107 Miller et al. described a hollow microneedle array containing electrodes for myoglobin and troponin detection. Although not fully integrated, this manuscript offered a proof-of-concept demonstration of on-needle detection of protein biomarkers.108 Cystatin C, a protein marker reflecting the glomerular filtration rate, is an important indicator for the diagnosis of chronic kidney disease, and the prognosis of cardiovascular diseases.109 Puttaswamy et al. provided a lab-on-a-microneedle device for localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) of cystatin C in buffer and blood samples.44 Similarly, Dervisevic et al. proposed an electrochemistry microneedle sensor, enabling the quantitation of a breast cancer biomarker (epidermal growth factor receptor 2) in skin mimicking gels.9 Chen et al. proposed a semi-localization microneedle system for detection of the carcinoma embryonic antigen in mice models and human volunteers bearing breast tumor.110
Cytokines, mostly secreted by immune cells, are a type of special small proteins with humoral regulating activities. Along with the expanded clinical immunotherapy, a cytokine-monitoring device could bring insight into subtle changes in the immune system, therefore guiding adaptive clinical treatments.111 Song et al. proposed a microneedle and microwell-based impedance sensor against human interleukin 8 (IL-8). This microneedle in real-time monitored the IL-8 levels in a mouse model that endogenously expressed IL-8, and the results were comparable to those measured by the ELISA gold standard approach.112
Endogenous antibody detection is of particular interest for indication of vaccination efficacies and disease prognosis, and, in some cases, the epidemiological investigation of infectious diseases. Wang et al. proposed an immune sandwich-based microneedle array for ultrasensitive in situ detection of antibodies and cytokines. For the proof-of-concept demonstration, IL-6, periostin and cocaine antibody detection was realized in mice models with high biocompatibility, low detection limitation, and good reproducibility (Fig. 3E).56
Unlike those of bacteria, extraction and detection of cells using microneedles face practical issues. Most of cells that could be reached by microneedles are keratinocytes, whereas the cells involved in conventional blood tests cannot cross the capillary clusters, and therefore are not available for microneedles. However, there are certain immune cells that prefer to remain in peripheral tissues like skin, rather than circulate in the bloodstream, such as tissue-resident macrophages, natural killer (NK) cells, NK T cells, B cells, and memory T cells. Mandal et al. presented a strategy to monitor the tissue-resident memory T cells (TRM cells) in skin using microneedles. The TRM cells were traced for months in the inoculated mouse, and the sampling from human skin explants was also demonstrated.114
Fig. 4 Schematic illustrations of microneedles for multiplex analysis based on different decoding principles. (A) Color-encoded microneedles loaded with photonic crystals. Reproduced with permission.115 Copyright 2019, Wiley-VCH Verlag. (B) Tattoo-patterned microneedles for dermal biosensor delivery. Reproduced with permission.98 Copyright 2021, Wiley-VCH Verlag. |
Comprehensive omics information could also be obtained with the aid of microneedles. Tran et al. developed a microneedle array to extract ISF for liquid chromatography mass spectrometry analysis in proteomics. They found that the protein species in ISF were highly similar to those in plasma and serum of the same donors, further supporting the development of ISF biomarkers in the field of in vitro diagnosis.117
Principles | Readouts | Targets | Sensing | Microneedle compositions | Detection ranges | Time consumptions/continuous sensing | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Colorimetric manner | Naked-eye visible | Glucose | GOx-based TMB-HRP colorimetric systems | PVA-MNs with a PVA colorimetric layer | 50–400 mg dL−1 | ∼10 min | 120 |
Naked-eye visible | Glucose, cholesterol | Oxidase-based MADB/TOPS colorimetric systems | Stainless steel-MNs with a PDMS layer, and two NC membranes | 0–270 mg dL−1 for glucose, 0–320 mg dL−1 for cholesterol | ∼3 min | 125 | |
Naked-eye visible | E. coli, pH | Polydiacetylene liposomal bio-ink binding with antibodies | Silk-MNs | — | <4 h | 12 | |
Naked-eye visible | pH, glucose, uric acid, and temperature | pH indicators, GOx/uricase-based TMB-HRP colorimetric systems, and temperature responsive solutions | HA-MNs | 6.0–8.0 for pH; 1–10 mM for glucose, 0.2–1.6 mM for uric acid, 36–39 °C for temperature | 10 min | 98 | |
Naked-eye visible | Glucose, lactate, cholesterol, and pH | Oxidases/HRP/three chromogenic dye systems, and the pH indicator bromocresol green | HA-MeHA-MNs with a NC membrane | 0–16 mM for glucose, 0–3.2 mM for lactate, 0–12 mM for cholesterol, 5–8 for pH | 10 min | 135 | |
Cellphone-assisted | Glucose | Glucose-responsive colloidal crystal colorimetric systems | Resin-MNs with colloidal crystals | 100–400 mg/dL | ∼5 min | 121 | |
Cellphone-assisted | Uric acid | Uricase/polypyrrole nanoparticles/TMB colorimetric systems | PVA-MNs with a PVA colorimetric layer | 200–1000 μM | ∼40 min | 131 | |
Fluorometric manner | Cellphone-assisted with a handheld LED light | DNA | LAMP amplification with nucleic acid dye | PVA-MNs | 10–100 ng | 30 min | 100 |
Portable fluorescence reader-assisted | ROS | Redox reaction of PEGylated Cy5 | HA-MNs | 50–250 μM | 20 min | 126 | |
Electronic manner | Cellphone-assisted | Glucose | Amperometry | Stainless steel-MNs with PCB electrodes | 3–13 mM | Continuous sensing for 21 h | 119 |
Cellphone- assisted | Glucose, lactate, and alcohol | Chronoamperometry | PMMA-MNs with microelectrodes, an electronic control system, and a Bluetooth package | 0.32–40 mM for glucose, 0.15–28 mM for lactate, and 0.50–100 mM for alcohol | <5 min for a single response, and continuous sensing for 12 h | 84 | |
Cellphone- assisted | Tyrosinase | Amperometry, CV | Stainless steel-MNs with a bandage sensor (printing stress-enduring inks) | 0.1–0.5 mg mL−1 | <2 min | 145 | |
Cellphone- assisted | Glucose | CV | Cyclic olefin copolymer-MNs | 0.05–20 mM | Continuous sensing for 72 h | 122 |
In terms of redox-responsive agents, the analytes of interest could be firstly oxidized with a specific oxidase to generate H2O2, which could subsequently react with a H2O2-responsive chromogenic agent. Paper is a major constituent of these colorimetric assays, owing to its merits of hydrophilicity, portability, and cost effectiveness.136 For example, Li et al.125 designed a paper-mediated colorimetric microneedle system to realize dual identification of glucose and cholesterol levels in rabbit models. Glucose and cholesterol were collected via a single microneedle, oxidized via glucose oxidase (GOx) and cholesterol oxidase, and finally reacted with N-ethyl-N-sulfopropyl-m-toluidine (TOPS) and N,N-bis(4-sulfobutyl)-3,5-dimethylaniline disodium salt (MADB) to form purple and green colors, respectively.125 Similarly, Zeng et al. designed paper sensor-integrated microneedles for multi-metabolite analysis in ISF.134 Moreover, direct addition of chromogenic agents into microneedles enables fully integrated sensor fabrication.120,121,131,132 Wang et al. applied GOx, horseradish peroxidase (HRP), and 3,3′,5,5′-tetramethylbenzidine (TMB) into PVA layers to realize the in situ colorimetric detection of glucose in a type 1 diabetic mouse model. The patch could turn blue on the back side once exposed to a high level of glucose. The color intensity of microneedles could be obtained via a miniaturized scanner.120 Moreover, cellphones have been integrated with colorimetry-based microneedle devices for higher accuracy and sensitivity. Zhang et al. described an in situ smartphone-assisted microneedle detection of uric acid. Polypyrrole nanoparticles with HRP-like nanoenzyme activities, urease, and TMB were introduced into microneedles, thus producing a blue color in the absence of uric acid. The color intensity was recorded with a cellphone camera, and finally analysed with the MATLAB software.131
Introduction of colorimetric nanoparticles is an alternative approach for construction of colorimetric microneedles, such as the widely-used Au nanoparticles (AuNPs). The aggregation of AuNPs could induce color changes from red to blue under the principles of local surface plasmon resonance (LSPR). When the distance between nanoparticles was narrowed, one particle could resonate with neighbours to form new vibrational modes, leading to changes of the absorption spectrum.135 For example, Puttaswamy et al. proposed a combined method of extracting ISF using microneedles, and monitoring cysteine C (Cys C) by a lateral flow immunochromatography assay (LFIA). The sample flow in LFIA was driven by capillary force, and the flowing Cys C and antibody-coated AuNPs were immobilized at a specific position. The Cys C levels were quantified under an immune-sandwich principle, when the AuNPs were aggregated into a naked-eye visible band.44 Colloidal crystals, a 2D or 3D oriented arrangement of monodisperse particles (e.g., SiO2 NPs), are featured with photonic band gaps that shift along the array arrangement, thus resulting in macroscopic color changes. Zeng et al. modified SiO2 NP colloidal crystals with glucose-binding fluorophenylboronic acid (FPBA), which was subsequently coated on shells of microneedles. Once in contact, glucose could enter and alter the alignment of FPBA-SiO2 NPs, resulting in a redshift of the microneedle colors from blue to green (Fig. 5A).121
Fig. 5 Schematic diagrams of microneedle-integrated sensing platforms. (A) Colloidal crystal-loaded microneedles for colorimetric detection of glucose. Reproduced with permission.121 Copyright 2020, Elsevier. (B) Multiplexed microneedle sensor with systematic electronic integration. Reproduced with permission.84 Copyright 2022, Springer Nature Publishing. (C) Aptamer-based microneedles for electrochemical signal detection. Reproduced with permission.146 Copyright 2022, American Chemical Society. |
Besides direct target recognition, trace analytes like nucleic acids often require signal amplification, such as catalytic hairpin assembly (CHA),116,128 post-collection polymerase chain reaction (PCR),8 and loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP).100 Paul et al. designed a microneedle device integrated with a smartphone-based florescence reader and a handheld excited LED light, for detection of pathogen DNA. The microneedles firstly extracted DNA samples by swelling upon insertion into skin, which were then transferred to a reaction chamber to be amplified by LAMP.100
Fluorescent tattooing is an emerging sensing technique with higher integration. Microneedles could serve as a medium to deliver the tattoo sensor to the dermis, enabling the construction of a painless in situ tattoo sensor. Babity et al. loaded hydrocyanines into a dissolvable microneedle array to form a transient ratiometric tattoo, which was non-fluorescent at reduced states, but highly fluorescent in oxidized forms, thus enabling responsive sensing of reactive oxygen species (ROS).126
Besides detection sensitivity, selectivity is essential for electrochemical monitoring devices, especially for blood or ISF samples with complex molecular compositions. To address the issues of endogenous interference, which is caused by direct oxidation on electrodes, the microneedles are generally coated or functionalized with enzymes,148 nano-enzymes,123 antibodies,9 polymer layers,127,129 or permselective membranes.50 For example, Li et al. modified polydopamine nanospheres (PDNS) with AuNPs on Pt microneedles for voltammetric signal detection of lactate. The PDNS served as intermediates between AuNPs and microneedles, enhancing the density of AuNP decoration, and improving the stability of the device.123 Zheng et al. coated a sodium-selective membrane on microneedles for real-time selective monitoring of Na+. The membrane-functionalized microneedles not only penetrated the skin for sampling, but also accommodated selective electrodes and extended gates, greatly facilitating the construction and integration of a flexible electronic biosensor.50
Integration of a sensing component, which can convert extracted biomarkers into transmitted signals, is of vital significance for expansion of terminal applications. Typically, the sensing component is usually attached to the back of the microneedle array.53,125,149,150 Once inserted, the extracted biofluid firstly flows out of the back and subsequently enters the detection or sensing zone, and finally, the corresponding outputs are transmitted to mobile phones via a wireless transmitter.50,53 For example, Cheng et al. developed a microneedle-based wearable system for long-term glucose monitoring. The sensing component was an electrode coated with GOx hydrogels, which could produce H2O2 and induce electron transfer for detection. By combining a touch activator, a wireless electronic detector and a user-friendly app, a miniaturized and user-friendly electrochemical detection platform was constructed (Fig. 6A).85 Meanwhile, microbial contamination during long-term wearing poses biosafety challenges for practical applications of the wearable devices. Cost-effective polymeric microneedles provide a disposable choice to balance the biosafety and cost challenges of electronic devices. For example, Lee et al. designed a microneedle-based strip-type disposable system to realize glucose monitoring and multistage drug delivery. The polymeric microneedles were assembled with a thermal actuator to allow periodic replacement.151 Similarly, Tehrani et al. developed a highly-integrated wearable microneedle sensor for multiple biomarker monitoring, including glucose, lactate, and alcohol.30 Nine distinct subcomponents, including a discardable microneedle array, and reusable electronics, were assembled, enabling convenient replacement of the sampling component.
Fig. 6 Schematic illustration of different functional components assembled on microneedles. (A) The assembly of a wireless-transited pattern-integrated glucose sensor. Reproduced with permission.85 Copyright 2022, Elsevier. (B) Microneedle-based TAP device with inside microfluidic channels for flow control. Reproduced with permission.15 Copyright 2018, Springer Nature Publishing. (C) A self-powering electronic microneedle array with an enzyme battery. Reproduced with permission.52 Copyright 2021, Springer Nature Publishing. |
With the addition of a control component, microneedles are endowed with multiple functions, such as sample handling, and fluidic manipulations. PDMS is widely used to manufacture control components for microneedles, due to the benefits of easy fabrication and flexibility. For example, Li et al. constructed a blood-extraction system consisting of a PDMS-fabricated self-recovery actuator and a long hollow microneedle. By integrating an elastic chamber with several valves, the device achieved blood extraction activated by finger pressing.36 Moreover, the control component could be fabricated by injection-moulding of plastics or rubbers such as acrylonitrile butadiene styrene and thermoplastic elastomers. Blicharz et al. assembled a microneedle-based tap-actuated device (named TAP) for painless collection of blood. A solid microneedle array was integrated into the device to withdraw 100 μL blood by a vacuum after skin puncture. The inner microfluidic channel could generate thorough mixing of blood and lithium heparin anticoagulant to achieve blood preservation (Fig. 6B).15
Power supply determines the level of integration of certain microneedle systems, especially those combined with electro-osmosis extracting components or electronic sensors. Generally, power is supplied with lithium-ion polymer or coin cell batteries.30,53 For example, Cheng et al. connected a 3.7 V rechargeable lithium coin cell battery to the back of a PCB for power supply.85 Besides, enzymatic biobatteries can be an alternative for integrating a fully organic disposable transdermal patch. For example, Kusama et al. integrated series-connected enzymatic biobatteries (fructose/O2 battery) for both ISF extraction and drug delivery.52 Cotton cloth was used as both the reservoir of fructose and the ion conductor in the circuit to drive the transdermal EOF, which demonstrated the feasibility of an entirely organically composited microneedle patch (Fig. 6C).
Passive and active extraction of biofluids using microneedles has been established, and the surge in microneedle technology has advanced the field of biofluid sampling. However, the latency for sub-millilitre ISF draining calls for minutes, whereas a routine phlebotomy could obtain dozens of millilitres. The sampling using microneedle devices needs to be accelerated. Moreover, small analytes in ISF have been partially investigated (Table 1), while the detailed relationship between ISF and blood in abnormal physiological states (in illness or under treatment) still needs to be systematically explored with extensive clinical validations.
Colorimetric, fluorometric, and electronic signal sensing has been integrated to facilitate the construction of microneedle terminal sensors, especially wearable electronic sensors. Recently, several groups have reported the fabrication of electro-microneedles that could work in vivo for long periods without interference.30,53,85 However, the long-term in vivo implementation is still an issue in the field concerning calibration and biocompability.142 Pipelines including biocompatible testings,152 samplings,153 and threshold settings154 still require careful explorations.
The rising theranostic microneedles, combined with both monitoring and treatment functions, initiated an alternative direction for individual healthcare management.155–157 Yu et al. reported a glucose-sensing insulin patch loaded with nanoscale hypoxia-responsive vesicles (Fig. 7A). The encapsulated GOx could sense the glucose levels, rapidly consume the oxygen under hyperglycemia conditions, and generate a hypoxic environment through enzymatic oxidations, leading to the breaking of vesicles and the release of inside insulin.6 Moreover, the sensing of glucose by phenylboronic acid and the subsequent responsive release of insulin have also been demonstrated on microneedles.7 In addition to microneedles cascaded with sensing and releasing functions, theranostic microneedles capable of outputting signals have also been proposed. Shan et al. constructed a wound microenvironment-responsive colorimetric microneedle array for indication of wound conditions as well as the required treatment. The color would change at bacteria-infected sites, while the inside nanozymes could generate ˙OH for bacteria killing (Fig. 7B).158 Moreover, a closed-loop wearable microneedle array has been proposed to sense glucose levels and accordingly treat diabetic mice with insulin (Fig. 7C). The glucose levels could be determined, and wirelessly transited to cellphones. The pre-loaded insulin could be released, triggered by an integrated flexible PCB, revealing impressive capabilities of a smart carry-on personal health care terminal.53
Fig. 7 Schematic illustration of intelligent microneedles integrated with diagnosis and treatment functions. (A) A smart glucose-sensing microneedle patch with hypoxia-responsive vesicles for diabetes treatment. Reproduced with permission.6 Copyright 2015, National Academy of Sciences. (B) Wound-healing intelligent colorimetric-sensing microneedles. Reproduced with permission.158 Copyright 2022, Elsevier. (C) Diabetes-treatment electronic-sensing microneedles. Reproduced with permission.53 Copyright 2021, Wiley-VCH Verlag. |
In short, as a promising platform, microneedles have been integrated with various detection techniques to realize sampling, sensing, and monitoring capacities. More and more technique crossovers are emerging in conjunction with microneedles to facilitate precise and personalized daily health profiles, such as wireless transitions,50,84,85,122,145 and digital recording.65,159 Further advances in microneedle-based devices could be expected with novel biomarker discovery in ISF, in vivo biocompatibility and stability improvements, and theranostic health management.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |