Alejandro Martínez-Buenoab,
Patricia Marín San Román
ab,
Raquel Giménez
*ab and
Teresa Sierra
*ab
aInstituto de Nanociencia y Materiales de Aragón (INMA), CSIC-Universidad de Zaragoza, 50009 Zaragoza, Spain. E-mail: rgimenez@unizar.es; tsierra@unizar.es; t.sierra@csic.es
bDepartamento de Química Orgánica, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad de Zaragoza, 50009 Zaragoza, Spain
First published on 14th July 2025
This work reports on the decisive influence of the length of flexible amide spacers for obtaining soft materials out of star-shaped molecules. Either liquid crystal behaviour or gel behaviour was found for 1,3,5-triphenylbenzene connected to three triphenylamine units through flexible amide spacers with different numbers of carbon atoms. The spacer of two carbon atoms induces liquid crystal behaviour but not gel formation. Conversely, an analogous compound with a three carbon atom spacer is not liquid crystalline and forms gels in different solvents. The obtained liquid crystal phase shows a hexagonal columnar organization responsive to electric fields, allowing the material to be aligned homeotropically in ITO cells, that is, with the columns perpendicular to the electrodes and parallel to the applied electric field. Taking advantage of the photoactivity of triarylamine units bearing amide groups, the response under light irradiation in the gel state was explored.
Among molecular designs, not only discotic π-conjugated molecules but also less conventional ones such as three-arm star-shaped mesogens6 can give rise to columnar mesophases. Star-shaped molecules have attractive prospects, in part due to their synthetic versatility to introduce π-conjugated functional units at their arms,7 either conjugated8–15 or joined through a non-conjugated spacer.16–21 Thus, columnar organizations with prominent semiconducting properties10,22–26 or stimuli-responsive luminescence8,27 have been reported.
To enhance the stability of these columnar architectures, hydrogen bond groups can be introduced in the arms to reinforce intermolecular/intracolumnar interactions. In this respect, aromatic tricarboxamides, such as benzene-1,3,5-tricarboxamide (BTA) (Fig. 1), are the most used star-shaped structural motif to achieve hydrogen bonding stabilized columnar liquid crystals and/or nanoaggregates in solvents.28
The 1,3,5-benzene core has also been expanded to 1,3,5-triphenylbenzene (TPB) (Fig. 1), introducing additional levels of rotational mobility. In this respect, TPB trisamides have been studied for gels29,30 and aggregates.31 Concerning liquid crystal behaviour, several star-shaped mesogens with a TPB core have been described, albeit without amide groups,32–37 with an important interplay between molecular structures and modes of self-assembly.
In this work, a novel design for star-shaped hydrogen bonded TPBs is reported, but unlike previously described BTA derivatives, the amide group is inserted within a short but flexible spacer of two or three carbon atoms (Scheme 1). This spacer is useful to bring higher flexibility, which in combination with hydrogen bonding abilities favours the formation of stable columnar phases at room temperature and gels.17,22 Functional units derived from triphenylamine (TPA) have been introduced at the periphery to bring photoactive properties, leveraging the photooxidation behaviour of amide TPA derivatives.38 In particular, we describe here the synthesis and properties of two TPB star-shaped molecules, namely TPB-2CTPA and TPB-3CTPA, their thermal properties, the contrast between hydrogen bonding patterns by IR spectroscopy, and their gel formation abilities. Different behaviour was found depending on the number of carbon atoms of the flexible amide spacers connecting the core with the arms. In addition, the presence of amide groups allowed us to explore the response of the mesophase to electric fields and the photoactivity of TPA units in the gel state.
Compound | Thermal propertiesa (T °C, [ΔH kJ mol−1]) | T5%b | Lattice parameters |
---|---|---|---|
a Thermal data obtained from the first cooling process and the second heating process at a rate of 10 °C min−1. Temperatures are taken at the onset.b Temperature corresponding to a 5% weight loss using thermogravimetry. Colh(g): glassy hexagonal columnar phase, Colh: hexagonal columnar mesophase, I: isotropic liquid, and Cr: crystalline phase. | |||
TPB-2CTPA | I 94 [2.2] Colh 47 Colh(g), Colh(g) 64 Colh 100 [3.0] I | 363 | a = 45.5 Å |
TPB-3CTPA | I 115 [31.3] Cr, Cr 127 [27.4] I | 355 | — |
Upon cooling from the isotropic phase, POM observations of compound TPB-2CTPA revealed a birefringent fan-shaped texture (Fig. 2a), characteristic of hexagonal columnar mesophases. This texture was fluid below the clearing temperature, and could be sheared, but became rigid at room temperature. This thermal behaviour was in agreement with the DSC thermogram of the first cooling cycle, which showed an exothermic peak at 94 °C and a glass transition at 47 °C. The heating cycle was consistent with the cooling ones, showing a glass transition at 64 °C and an endothermic peak with an onset at 100 °C, corresponding to the transition to the isotropic liquid (Fig. 2b).
The texture behaviour of TPB-2CTPA was also investigated under the application of an electric field given the possibility of attaining a net dipole moment along the column due to intermolecular hydrogen-bonded amide motifs.16,40–43 For this purpose, the material was introduced in a commercial 5 μm ITO/glass cell. Upon cooling from the isotropic liquid, the columnar mesophase exhibited a birefringent fan-shaped texture (Fig. 2c), with larger domains than in the texture observed during previous POM studies. The application of a square-wave electric field (1.0 Hz, 20 Vpp) at 90 °C led to the darkening of the ITO area in 80 min, which is consistent with the evolution of the texture to a homeotropic alignment. This homeotropic texture is stable after removing the electric field and cooling at room temperature, while the ITO-free area retained the initial texture. The same effect was observed by applying a square-wave electric field (1.0 Hz, 50 Vpp) in the isotropic liquid phase, followed by cooling under the applied field at a rate of 0.5 °C min−1.
On the other hand, the analogue TPB-3CTPA with a longer spacer behaves under the POM as a crystalline solid with an undefined texture. The corresponding thermogram shows only one thermal transition upon both heating and cooling, with an enthalpy value of around 30 kJ mol−1 (Fig. S4a, ESI†). These results evidenced that this compound crystallizes directly from the isotropic liquid, without forming a mesophase, as confirmed by X-ray diffraction (XRD) experiments (Fig. S4b, ESI†).
The columnar mesomorphism of compound TPB-2CTPA was confirmed by XRD experiments performed at room temperature in samples cooled from the isotropic liquid (Fig. 2d). The diffractogram shows three reflections in the small angle region related to distances with ratios of d, d/√3 and d/√4, which correspond to the reflections (100), (110) and (200) of a hexagonal lattice with a lattice parameter a = 45.5 Å. Furthermore, a diffuse broad reflection is observed at 4.5 Å due to the molten nature of the alkyl chains, confirming the liquid crystalline behaviour. The absence of a maximum at high angles corresponding to an intermolecular distance along the column hinders the calculation of a stacking parameter (c) and, therefore, impedes the correct estimation of the number of molecules per unit cell (Z). For similar star-shaped compounds with tris(triazolyl)triazine at the core, and a hexagonal columnar phase with parameters a = 49.5 Å and c = 3.4 Å and density = 1 g cm−3, a Z = 2 value was considered.22 Taking into account the similar molecular size and the lattice parameter obtained for TPB-2CTPA, it is reasonable to propose a disordered columnar packing in which two molecules arrange on each column stratum on average (Fig. 2e). The non-regular arrangement is in accordance with the fact that intracolumnar stacking is not observed and not all amide groups are involved in intermolecular hydrogen bonding interactions (see below).
At room temperature, the compound with the shortest spacer, TPB-2CTPA, exhibits two N–H stretching bands around 3300 and 3400 cm−1 (Fig. 3a), consistent with the presence of both hydrogen bonded and free N–H groups within the columnar assemblies, respectively. Additionally, the CO stretching region appears as a broad band spanning 1650 to 1720 cm−1, indicating an overlap of hydrogen-bonded and free C
O stretching vibrations. In contrast, TPB-3CTPA shows a single N–H stretching band centred at 3295 cm−1 and a sharp C
O stretching band at 1660 cm−1 (Fig. 3b), suggesting that both the N–H and C
O groups are fully engaged in hydrogen bonds.
Upon heating TPB-2CTPA, the intensity of the associated amide N–H stretching band gradually decreased and shifted to higher wavenumbers, while the intensity of the free N–H stretching band increased. A similar trend was observed for the CO stretching band, which shifted to higher wavenumbers as expected due to the progressive weakening of hydrogen bonds with increasing temperature.
For TPB-3CTPA, no significant changes were observed in the associated N–H and CO stretching bands until the transition to the isotropic liquid takes place. At this temperature, both bands exhibited a marked intensity decrease along with an abrupt shift to higher wavenumbers. Additionally, the emergence of new bands at 3390 cm−1 and 1690 cm−1, corresponding to free N–H and C
O stretching vibrations, respectively, indicated the partial disruption of intermolecular hydrogen bonds. This abrupt change at the melting temperature is consistent with a crystalline phase.
These results revealed a clear distinction in the nature and strength of the intermolecular hydrogen bonding interactions of TPB-2CTPA and TPB-3CTPA, which correlates well with their different phase behaviour. For TPB-2CTPA, the presence of both hydrogen-bonded and free N–H and CO stretching bands suggests the formation of more dynamic, ordered but fluid, hydrogen bonded columnar aggregates. Also, this is consistent with a non-regular arrangement, as deduced from the absence of a reflection maximum at high angles in the DRX pattern related to a long-range stacking distance. In contrast, the longer and more flexible spacer in compound TPB-3CTPA facilitates hydrogen bonding interactions between amide groups, leading to enhanced stabilization of intermolecular interactions, thus favouring the formation of a crystalline phase.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 SEM images of xerogels of compound TPB-3CTPA from (a) 1-octanol, (b) dodecane and (c) toluene. |
The morphology of the aggregates formed by TPB-3CTPA in each solvent was analysed via scanning electron microscopy (SEM) of the xerogels. All three xerogels show a fibrillar morphology, regardless of the solvent employed. The 1-octanol xerogel displayed entangled fibril bundles with an average width of 150 nm (Fig. 4a). In the case of the dodecane xerogel, larger aggrupation of fibres made of smaller fibres of average width 75 nm can be distinguished (Fig. 4b). The xerogel in toluene displays fibril bundles with a width of 100 nm on average (Fig. 4c).
Some TPA derivatives containing at least one amide group36,45–50 or a carboxylic group51 have the ability to generate radical cation species under light irradiation in the presence of chlorinated solvents (Fig. 5a). In this respect, the photoresponse of TPB-3CTPA was investigated both in dilute dichloromethane solution and in the 1-octanol gel by introducing a small amount of dichloromethane (DCM). These studies were carried out using UV-vis (Fig. 5b and d) and 1H NMR spectroscopy (Fig. 5c).
The solution was initially colourless, and the UV-vis spectrum exhibited two intense absorption bands at 275 nm and 310 nm, along with two weaker bands at 405 nm and 800 nm (Fig. 5b, black line). After 2 minutes of irradiation with a Hg lamp, the solution turned light green, and the bands at 275 nm, 405 nm and 800 nm showed a marked intensity increase, except for the 310 nm band, which displayed a pronounced decrease. In addition, three new absorption bands appeared at 725 nm, 650 nm, and 465 nm (Fig. 5b, green line). These spectral changes are attributed to the formation of the triarylammonium radical cation, which was also observed to form by cyclic voltamperometry (Fig. S5, ESI†), and it is known to exhibit a strong absorption in the near-infrared region.38,52 After 16 minutes of irradiation, the solution turned orange, and the absorption bands at 800 nm, 725 nm, and 650 nm almost disappeared, while the band at 465 nm increased in intensity (Fig. 5b, orange line). The orange color is consistent with the formation of the dicationic species, which has been reported to absorb in the visible range and represents a further oxidation state of the TPA moieties.52
In the case of the 1H NMR spectra, the initial spectrum displayed well-resolved signals corresponding to the aromatic protons of the TPA moieties, the TPB core, the spacer, and the aliphatic chains (Fig. 5c). After irradiation, all signals attributable to the TPA protons vanished, while the signals corresponding to the TPB aromatic core and the aliphatic chains remained observable. This behaviour is consistent with previously reported photoinduced aggregation and radical formation processes involving TPA derivatives in chlorinated solvents, in which the disappearance of proton signals has been attributed to the formation of the triarylammonium radicals and subsequent supramolecular self-assembly into highly anisotropic aggregates.38,52,53
The modification of the gelation properties through the photooxidation process was studied for the 1-octanol gel by introducing 5 wt% of dichloromethane. As in the case of the solution, short irradiation times induced the generation of light green colour in the gel due to the presence of the triarylammonium radical cations as confirmed in the UV-vis spectrum (Fig. 5d). As observed for the solution, longer irradiation times resulted in the formation of dicationic species and the disruption of the gel. This phenomenon is attributed to the increased charge density and stronger electrostatic repulsion between the dicationic units, which interferes with the non-covalent interactions, such as π-stacking or van der Waals forces, responsible for maintaining the integrity of the supramolecular network.
Finally, the photooxidation process did not occur in a solution of the compound in acetone or in the gel in 1-octanol, that is, in the absence of chlorinated solvents.
Furthermore, the formation of aggregates in solvents is also different depending on the spacer length, and only the three-carbon spacer derivative can yield organogels in different solvents at 1 wt%. It is demonstrated that the TPA redox unit photooxidizes in the gel state under light irradiation by adding a small amount of a chlorinated solvent, which is interesting for stimuli-responsive gels and optoelectronic applications.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Synthetic route and full experimental procedures and characterization data. NMR spectra. DSC thermograms. Additional information about XRD studies and electrochemical properties. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5tc01929j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |