Nobushige Kai‡
a,
Hideya Kono‡a,
Timo Stünkela,
Daiki Imotoa,
Riccardo Zanasi*b,
Guglielmo Monaco
b,
Francesco F. Summa
b,
Lawrence T. Scott
c,
Akiko Yagi*ad and
Kenichiro Itami
*de
aDepartment of Chemistry, Graduate School of Science, Nagoya University, Chikusa, Nagoya 464-8602, Japan. E-mail: yagi.akiko@itbm.nagoya-u.ac.jp
bDipartimento di Chimica e Biologia “A. Zambelli”, Università, Degli Studi di Salerno, Fisciano 84084, SA, Italy. E-mail: rzanasi@unisa.it
cDepartment of Chemistry, University of Nevada, Reno, Nevada 89557-0216, USA
dInstitute of Transformative Bio-Molecules (WPI-ITbM), Nagoya University, Nagoya 464-8602, Japan
eMolecule Creation Laboratory, RIKEN Cluster for Pioneering Research, Wako, Saitama 351-0198, Japan. E-mail: kenichiro.itami@riken.ac.jp
First published on 23rd April 2025
Nanobelts are cyclic arenes that only consist of annulated structures. Recently, various types of nanobelts have been synthesized and their unique properties have been unveiled. However, cationic nanobelts without heteroatoms have been rarely synthesized, and their properties are of significant interest from both fundamental and application perspectives. Herein, we report the synthesis of radical cationic and dicationic hydrocarbon nanobelts by chemical oxidation of methylene-bridged [6]cycloparaphenylene ([6]MCPP). These cationic species are remarkably stable in air, which made it possible to measure and uncover their structural and electronic properties. Notably, the [6]MCPP dicationic salt has sharp absorption and fluorescence bands at longer wavelengths than those of neutral [6]MCPP, close to the near-infrared region. From both experimental and theoretical investigation, the existence of a strong diatropic belt current in [6]MCPP dication was indicated. In addition, a longer lifetime was observed for the hexamethyl[6]MCPP dicationic salt than for the [6]MCPP dicationic salt in solution.
Nanobelts and aromatic belts are a class of synthetically challenging and recently emerging cyclic π-extended arenes (Fig. 1a).6,7 Since the first synthesis of (6,6)carbon nanobelts ((6,6)CNB) in 2017,6 different types of nanobelts have been synthesized, and their properties have been investigated. Despite the recent advances in nanobelts, cationic nanobelts are limited to certain dicationic/tetracationic species of nonalternant nanobelts doped with nitrogen atoms and bowl-shaped nanobelts.8 There are no reports on the synthesis of stable cationic species of nanobelts, probably because of their assumed instability; thus, their synthesis is in strong demand.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 (a) The structures of neutral aromatic hydrocarbon nanobelts. Ar = p-tBuC6H4. (b) The structures of [6]MCPP radical cation SbCl6− salt 1 and [6]MCPP dication (SbF6−)2 salt 2. |
Herein, we report the synthesis of stable cationic hydrocarbon nanobelts. Methylene-bridged [6]cycloparaphenylene ([6]MCPP) was selected as our target nanobelt for obtaining a cationic nanobelt.9 [6]MCPP is a nanobelt synthesized by our group in 2020, in which all the benzene rings of [6]CPP are bridged by methylene units. The synthesis of [6]MCPP requires only two steps from pillar[6]arene,10 which has enabled the large-scale synthesis and commercialization of [6]MCPP.11 Unique properties of [6]MCPP, such as a small energy gap (2.66 eV) and paratropic belt current, have led the progress of MCPP chemistry, as demonstrated by the syntheses of larger MCPPs ([8]MCPP and [10]MCPP),12 a naphthalene-based MCPP,13 and functionalized MCPPs.14 Owing to the high highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) energy (−4.40 eV), electron-donating methylene units, and rigid cyclic π-conjugated system of [6]MCPP, we anticipated that cationic species of [6]MCPP can be easily and stably produced under air. The [6]MCPP radical cation SbCl6− salt 1 and [6]MCPP dication (SbF6−)2 salt 2 were synthesized and found to be very stable as solutions in CH2Cl2 and even as solids in air. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) analysis, ultraviolet (UV)–visible (vis)–near-infrared region (NIR) absorption/fluorescence measurements, X-ray crystal structure analysis, and electron spin resonance (ESR) measurement of 1 and 2 revealed several unique properties of the cationic nanobelts.
Chemical oxidation of [6]MCPP with 3 equivalents of NOSbF6 in CH2Cl2 solution, at 23 °C under an argon atmosphere, changed the red color of the reaction solution, derived from [6]MCPP, to a yellow green color. From 1H NMR, 13C NMR, and electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometric analyses, as well as UV–vis–NIR absorption measurements, the full conversion of [6]MCPP was observed and 2 was obtained in 92% isolated yield (Scheme 1, bottom). When using 1 equivalent of NOSbF6, the formation of 1 was indicated by the ESR and absorption spectra of the reaction mixture. Eventually, under these conditions, 1 was isolated in 73% yield (see the Section 2.1 in ESI† for details). By treating [6]MCPP with Et3OSbCl6, a slightly weaker oxidant than NOSbF6 (Eox; 0.87 V and 0.91 V (vs. Fc/Fc+), respectively), 1 was also selectively formed as judged by ESR analysis and absorption measurements and isolated in 99% yield (Scheme 1, top). In the ESR spectrum of the CH2Cl2 solution of 1 measured under argon, the g value of 1 is 2.0037 (329.059 mT) and the hyperfine structure was observed, which are reasonable based on the results reported for [n]CPP radical cations (see Fig. S14 in ESI†). The half-life time of 1 and 2 are determined as about 143 hours and 26 hours, respectively, from the decay of the maximum absorption peak intensities in CH2Cl2 solution under air (see Fig. S1 and S2 in ESI†). The determined values of half-life time should be longer than those of CPP cations, which have been characterized as air-sensitive; however, no lifetime data have been reported.4 The comproportionation reaction by mixing 2 and neutral [6]MCPP was conducted in CH2Cl2 at room temperature. This oxidant-free method of generating the radical cation was previously reported in the case of CPP by the Yamago group.4d As a result, 1 was obtained quantitatively, also supporting high stability of 1 (see the Section 2.4 in ESI†).
A single crystal of 2 was successfully obtained by slow evaporation of a CH2Cl2 solution at −30 °C under an argon atmosphere for 6 days. X-ray single-crystal structural analysis revealed the crystal structure of 2 (Fig. 2a) and its packing structure, where the [6]MCPP2+ scaffold is aligned in columns with two sandwiched SbF6− anions and CH2Cl2 molecules (Fig. 2b).15 The diameter of the [6]MCPP2+ scaffold is estimated as 7.675 Å, which is 0.083 Å shorter than that of neutral [6]MCPP (Table 1). Considering the carbon–carbon bonds, the difference between 2 and [6]MCPP strongly indicates that the [6]MCPP2+ scaffold has a quinoidal character. The harmonic oscillator model of aromaticity (HOMA) values for the 6-membered rings are estimated using the crystal structures of [6]MCPP and 2, and density functional theory (DFT) calculations at the B3LYP/6-31G(d) level of theory (see the Section 5 in ESI† for details). The average HOMA value is 0.702 for [6]MCPP2+ scaffold in contrast to 0.955 for [6]MCPP, supporting the decreased benzenoid character of 2. This difference was also observed in the case of cationic CPPs, which explains the effective delocalization of the positive charge across the entire [6]MCPP2+ scaffold.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 X-ray crystal structure of 2. (a) Oak Ridge Thermal Ellipsoid Plot (ORTEP) drawing of 2 with 50% thermal probability. (b) Packing structure viewed along the a-axis. |
The UV–vis–NIR absorption and fluorescence spectra of 1 and 2, in CH2Cl2 solutions, are recorded and compared with those of [6]MCPP (Fig. 3a). For 1, four absorption peaks are observed at 415, 890, 1037, and 1054 nm. The absorption band in the NIR region clearly indicates the radical cationic character of 1, which undergoes transitions with a singly occupied molecular orbital (SOMO). Using DFT calculations, the frontier molecular orbitals of 1 and 2 were depicted and the features similar to those seen in most of radical cations and cations were found. The SOMO of 1 is distributed exactly the same way as the HOMO of [6]MCPP, and the other frontier molecular orbitals of 1 are shifted by one (see Fig. 3b and S10 in ESI†). Similarly, the LUMO of 2 has the same orbital distribution as that of the HOMO of [6]MCPP, whereas the other orbitals are shifted by one. As estimated by time-dependent DFT (TDDFT) calculation at the UB3LYP/6-31G(d) level of theory, the absorption bands of 1, with peaks at approximately 415 nm, 890 nm, 1037 nm and 1054 nm can be attributed to HOMO/HOMO−1 to LUMO, and SOMO → LUMO, HOMO/HOMO−1 → SOMO transitions, respectively, though the absorption at 890 nm is very weak, presumably because SOMO → LUMO transition is forbidden (f = 0). Fluorescence of the CH2Cl2 solution of 1 was measured but not observed.
The absorption bands of the CH2Cl2 solution of 2 are observed with peaks at 453 and 745 nm. The positions of the peaks correspond well with the HOMO/HOMO−1 → LUMO+1 (415 nm) and HOMO/HOMO−1 → LUMO (701 nm) transitions calculated using TDDFT. Notably, the absorption band with a peak around 745 nm is very sharp with a full width at half maximum (FWHM) of 14.5 nm. The fluorescence spectrum of 2 was observed, whereas neutral [6]MCPP exhibited negligible fluorescence due to forbidden transitions. The FWHM of the fluorescence band of 2 is also small (20 nm), comparable to that of quantum dots or dyes with heteroatoms.16 No vibronic structure was observed in the fluorescence band, probably because the structure of 2 is too rigid to see obvious vibronic structures. The fluorescence quantum yield (ΦF) of 2 is determined to be 0.23. Considering that the Stokes shift is only 5 nm and self-absorption is not negligible, the value of ΦF is significant. Compared to [6]CPP2+ (SbF6−)2 CH2Cl2 solution, 2 has over 10 times larger ΦF (0.23 vs. 0.018).4f The oscillator strengths (f) for fluorescence of 2 and [6]CPP2+ (SbF6−)2 were estimated to be 0.22 and 0.21, respectively, from TDDFT calculation based on the optimized structures of S1 states for [6]MCPP2+ and [6]CPP2+ (see the Section 5 in ESI† for details). Because ΦF is defined as kf/(kf + knr + kISC), where kf is fluorescence rate, knr is nonradiative deactivation rate, kISC is intersystem crossing rate, and kISC is negligible for [6]MCPP2+ and [6]CPP2+, the difference in ΦF may be due to knr. Nonradiative deactivation, particularly thermal deactivation, is expected to be small in the [6]MCPP2+ scaffold compared to [6]CPP2+ by virtue of the rigid structure resulting from the methylene bridges. These results clearly show that methylene-bridging modulates the spectroscopic properties of the parent [6]CPP dication structure, enabling fluorescence, which is a remarkable structural effect of methylene-bridging firstly revealed by this work.
In our previous work, the paratropic belt current of MCPP, which changes depending on the ring size, was first unveiled.12 The chemical shifts of the methylene hydrogen atoms in 1H NMR spectra indicate the existence of a paratropic belt current that decreases with increasing ring size of [n]MCPP (n = 6, 8, and 10), which is also supported by a theoretical study of the magnetically induced current density. To investigate the belt-current effect in the [6]MCPP2+ scaffold, the 1H NMR spectrum of 2 in CD2Cl2 was recorded (Fig. 4). As observed for neutral [6]MCPP, 2 also exhibited three types of signals: a singlet signal at 4.18 ppm, two doublet signals at 3.61 ppm and −0.34 ppm. This suggests a D3d symmetry for 2 in CH2Cl2 solution, indicating a delocalized positive charge on the entire [6]MCPP2+ scaffold. The observed chemical shifts of the signals were further supported by simulations using gauge-including atomic orbitals (GIAO) calculations at the B3LYP/6-311+G(2d,p) level (see Section 5 in ESI† for details). The singlet signal of 4.18 ppm is assigned to the hydrogen atoms on benzene rings (highlighted as green color in Fig. 4). The doublet signal of 3.61 ppm is assigned to the methylene hydrogen atoms facing outside of nanobelt (Hout, highlighted as red color) and the doublet signal of −0.34 ppm is from those facing inside of nanobelt (Hin, highlighted as blue color).
A paratropic/diatropic belt current refers to a delocalized electronic current induced in cyclic π-conjugated molecules, such as nanobelts, when exposed to a magnetic field aligned with their symmetry axis. This current flows in a direction that generates a paramagnetic/diamagnetic (paratropic/diatropic) response, often associated with antiaromaticity/aromaticity.12,17 As described in our previous reports concerning the neutral MCPP, 1H NMR chemical shifts of hydrogen atoms, especially ones directed to inner side of the belt, provide evidence for the existence of the paratropic belt current in neutral MCPPs, further supported by a theoretical study of the magnetically induced current density. The extraordinary upfield shift of the 1H NMR signals of 2 can only be attributed to a drastic change in the current regime induced by the magnetic field of the spectrometer. As we will show in the following, the paratropic belt current that characterizes the magnetic response of [6]MCPP disappears in the dication, giving way to an intense diatropic belt current that causes a large anisotropic effect on the 1H NMR signals. The deshielding effect is particularly pronounced for Hin, whose δ moves up-field by 4.41 ppm. The aromatic hydrogen atoms undergo a similar shift equal to 3.67 ppm, while Hout moves only 0.62 ppm for their external disposition.
Magnetically-induced electron current density and aryl–aryl bond current strength of 2 have been calculated assuming the combination B97-2/6-311+G(2d,p) of density functional and basis set, using the SYSMOIC program package as in previous studies, adopting the GSGT method for having origin-independent results.17a The wave functions for the calculation have been obtained using the G16 program package,17b including, in this case of a charged molecule, the solvent (CH2Cl2) effect by means of the CPCM method.17c
We find that the dominant contribution to the delocalized electron current density is given by the HOMO. This contribution is shown in Fig. 5, in which intensities lower than 0.04 a.u. were cut to clearly show the shape of the current and how its flow bifurcates and comes together around the six-membered rings of the nanobelts. To facilitate the comparison with [6]MCPP, we placed side by side in the bottom of Fig. 6 the current density calculated for the neutral (left) and charged (right) species adopting the same filter, this time equal to 0.015 a.u., to cut the low magnitude current. The inset on the left is therefore identical to that used for depiction of the paratropic belt current in [6]MCPP.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 The summary of belt current in neutral [6]MCPP (left) and [6]MCPP dication 2 (right). The belt current strength is calculated at B97-2/6-311+G(2d,p) level of theory adopting the CSGT method. |
In comparison with [6]MCPP studied in ref. 12, first, we observe the opposite direction of circulation of the current, i.e., diatropic instead of paratropic; second, the magnitude of the current is much larger. To obtain a quantitative estimate, bond current strengths17d have been calculated, integrating the current crossing a 5 × 5 a.u. square perpendicular to one aryl–aryl bond in its middle (shown in red in both Fig. 5 and 6) for the three instances: only HOMO, all-but-HOMO, all-MOs. Values are reported in Table 2 as a percentage of the benzene ring current strength (IBEN) calculated using the same method, i.e., I/|IBEN| × 100, with IBEN = 12 nA T−1. Customarily, the sign of the IBEN is taken as negative, so that paratropic/diatropic current strengths are identified by a positive/negative sign.17e
Molecule | HOMO | All-but-HOMO | All-MOs |
---|---|---|---|
2 | −241 | −1 | −242 |
[6]MCPP | +138 | −63 | +75 |
As it can be seen, the delocalized diatropic belt current of 2 is almost entirely due to the HOMO. Two contributions were instead found for [6]MCPP, one dominant paratropic and another less intense diatropic. All that can be very easily understood by considering the symmetries of the frontier molecular orbitals shown in Fig. 3.
According to the few electrons model by Steiner and Fowler,17f,g an occupied-to-unoccupied virtual transition gives a paratropic contribution if the product of symmetries contains a match to a rotation, and a diatropic contribution if it contains a match to a translation. For [6]MCPP the HOMO → LUMO transition (a2g × a1g = a2g) gives the already well-known paratropic belt current whose strength is 138% of |IBEN|, while the HOMO−1 → LUMO transition (eu × a1g = eu) makes a contribution that accounts almost entirely for the diatropic contribution of −63% of |IBEN|. The smaller HOMO–LUMO gap is consistent with the bigger paratropic contribution. Now, as already observed above, the HOMO of [6]MCPP becomes the LUMO of 2. Thus, two transitions originate from the HOMO of the dication (eu × a2g = eu and eu × a1g = eu) which give the large diatropic belt current shown in Fig. 5, whose strength is estimated to be −242% of |IBEN|.
The summary of the belt current of neutral [6]MCPP and 2 is shown in Fig. 6. Two-electron oxidation turns a paratropic belt current of MCPP skeleton into a diatropic belt current, which is significantly increased to reflect experimentally observed huge upfield 1H NMR chemical shift of inner methylene hydrogen atoms of 2. Owing to the large strength of the diatropic belt current in the dication, the current predicted based on the “in-plane aromaticity” concept4c appears to be qualitatively correct. The belt current has a sizable effect also on the carbon NMR signals (see Tables S5–S9 in ESI† for a brief account). In addition, nucleus-independent chemical shift (NICS) was also calculated, which also indicates the increased aromaticity of 2 (see Table S4 in ESI†).
The interesting properties of 1 and 2 described above are unveiled owing to their high stability under air as both solution and solid. In order to discuss the extraordinarily high stability of 2, the chemical oxidation of hexamethyl[6]MCPP, which is a known molecule reported in 2021,14a has been tried in a same manner as the synthesis of 2 (Scheme 2). The dicationic species of hexamethyl[6]MCPP 3 has been obtained successfully to investigate its half-life time in CH2Cl2 solution under air. As a result, it was found that 3 has a much longer half-life time than 2, which is estimated to be about 2640 hours (110 days). Although discussion for high stability was difficult because neither 13C NMR analysis nor X-ray diffraction analysis was successful, kinetic protection, electron-donating effect and hyperconjugation effect of methyl groups likely improve the stability of [6]MCPP dication.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2359239. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5sc01305d |
‡ These authors contributed equally. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |