Xuhua
Wang
ac,
Oliver
Hofmann
bc,
Rupa
Das
a,
Edward M.
Barrett
a,
Andrew J.
deMello
bc,
John C.
deMello
*bc and
Donal D. C.
Bradley
*ac
aExperimental Solid State Physics Group, Blackett Laboratory, Imperial College London, United Kingdom SW7 2AZ. E-mail: d.bradley@imperial.ac.uk
bElectronic Materials Group, Department of Chemistry, Imperial College London, United Kingdom SW7 2AZ. E-mail: j.demello@imperial.ac.uk
cMolecular Vision Ltd, Imperial BioIncubator, Imperial College London, United Kingdom SW7 2AZ
First published on 17th October 2006
We report the use of solution-processed thin-film organic photodiodes for microscale chemiluminescence. The active layer of the photodiodes comprised a 1 : 1 blend by weight of the conjugated polymer poly(3-hexylthiophene) [P3HT] and [6,6]-phenyl-C61-butyric acid-methylester [PCBM]—a soluble derivative of C60. The devices had an active area of 1 mm × 1 mm, and a broad-band response from 350 to 700 nm, with an external quantum efficiency of more than 50% between 450 and 550 nm. The photodiodes have a simple layered structure that permits facile integration with planar chip-based systems. To evaluate the suitability of the organic devices as integrated detectors for microscale chemiluminescence, a peroxyoxalate based chemiluminescence reaction (PO-CL) was monitored within a poly(dimethyl-siloxane) (PDMS) microfluidic device. Quantitation of hydrogen peroxide indicated excellent linearity and yielded a detection limit of 10 µM, comparable with previously reported results using micromachined silicon microfluidic chips with integrated silicon photodiodes. The combination of organic photodiodes with PDMS microfluidic chips offers a means of creating compact, sensitive and potentially low-cost microscale CL devices with wide-ranging applications in chemical and biological analysis and clinical diagnostics.
One of the preferred methods for analyte detection in microfluidic devices is based around chemiluminescence (CL),3,4 which offers a simple but sensitive means of monitoring low level analyte concentrations. CL reactions typically involve the formation of a metastable reaction intermediate or product in an electronically excited state, which subsequently relaxes to the ground-state with the emission of a photon.5 CL is particularly attractive for portable microfluidic assays, because the CL reaction acts as an internal light-source, thereby lowering instrumental requirements and significantly reducing power consumption and background interference compared to fluorescence assays. Specificity of CL reactions is typically afforded by up-stream enzymatic assays, which generally produce an oxidizing species such as hydrogen peroxide that initiates the CL reaction.3,4 Importantly, the use of CL assays tends to avoid the problematic background emission from interfering compounds or from the microfluidic substrate itself that is frequently encountered in fluorescence detection. CL-based systems have been successfully applied to on-chip electrophoretic separations of metal ions,6,7 immunoassays8 and enzyme assays,9 and consequently there is considerable interest in creating complete analytical devices that incorporate the CL assay and optical detector into a single integrated package.
In previous reports of CL detection in microfluidic environments, the CL signal has generally been detected and quantified using externally mounted photomultiplier tubes (PMTs) and/or microscope collection optics.10–13 Recently, however, Jorgensen et al. reported the use of integrated silicon photodiodes for monitoring luminol-based chemiluminescence reactions in micromachined silicon microfluidic chips.14 They selected hydrogen peroxide as a model compound for quantitation because it is produced by a number of enzymes in the presence of dissolved oxygen and certain analytes such as alcohol, glucose, and cholesterol.15 Using this approach they were able to attain measurable signals down to 10 µM, thus showing that high sensitivity chip-based CL detection could be implemented in a fully integrated microscale format.
The use of silicon photodiodes and micromachined silicon substrates, however, entails relatively high-cost fabrication techniques that preclude the use of such devices in disposable point-of-care applications where low cost is of primary concern. In recent work, therefore, we investigated whether integrated microscale CL could be implemented in a lower cost format using poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) instead of silicon as the substrate material and organic photodiodes in place of the Si detectors.14 PDMS has good biocompatibility and optical transparency over the visible range,16 and allows for rapid molding-based prototyping and scalable manufacturing at low cost and with high reliability. At the same time, organic devices may be fabricated at low temperature using simple layer-by-layer deposition procedures that are fully compatible with plastic substrates.17–19 The combination of PDMS microfluidic chips with organic photodiodes therefore offers an attractive route to fabricating low-cost diagnostic devices, which incorporate the fluidic channels and the detectors into a single monolithic package.
In our first proof-of-principle studies, we used organic photodiodes based on vacuum deposited bilayers of copper phthalocyanine (CuPc) and fullerene (C60) to detect the emission signal from a peroxyoxalate chemiluminescence (PO-CL) based assay.20 These measurements confirmed the feasibility of using organic devices for detection of the CL signal, but yielded relatively poor detection limits of 1 mM compared to 10 µM reported by Jorgensen et al.14 The modest detection limits were attributable in part to a significant mismatch between the area of the photodiodes (∼16 mm2) and the area of the detection zone on the microfluidic chip (∼2 mm2), which resulted in a high background signal (∼1 nA) due to the dark current.
To improve the limit of detection, it is necessary to substantially reduce the short-circuit dark current in the photodiode. In the work reported here we replaced the 16 mm2 vacuum deposited CuPc/C60 bilayer devices with 1 mm2 solution-processed polymer devices based on 1 : 1 blends by weight of poly(3-hexylthiophene) [P3HT] and [6,6]-phenyl-C61-butyric acid-methylester [PCBM]—a soluble derivative of C60. The P3HT/PCBM devices fabricated in our laboratory typically have very low short-circuit dark current densities of <10−6 mA cm−2, and are consequently a good choice for high sensitivity detection. The 1 mm × 1 mm dimensions of the P3HT:PCBM devices are well matched to the 800 µm × 1 mm detection zone of our microfluidic chips and so minimise the background signal due to the dark current. The thin-film polymer photodiodes, when integrated with PDMS microfluidic chips, provide compact, sensitive and potentially low-cost microscale CL devices with wide-ranging applications in chemical and biological analysis and clinical diagnostics.
Fig. 1 (A) Microchip layout with inlets for premixed CPPO, dye, catalyst (1) and hydrogen peroxide (2), mixing channel and outlet (3). The inlets are 400 µm-wide, 800 µm-deep and 1 cm-long, while the mixing channel is 800 µm-wide, 800 µm-deep and 5.2 cm-long. The active area of the photodiode used for CL detection is 1 mm × 1 mm. The photodiode is located at a position 1 cm downstream from the point-of-confluence of the two inlet streams. (B) The quantum efficiency action spectrum for an ITO/PEDOT:PSS/P3HT:PCBM/Al photodiode and the normalised emission spectra for the two CL dyes used in this work: 9,10-diphenylanthracene (Cyalume blue) and 9,10-bis(phenylethynyl)anthracene (Cyalume green). The emission spectra of both dyes overlap the spectral response of the photodiode. |
The photocurrent action spectrum of the polymer device was determined using a 150 W xenon lamp (Bentham Instruments Ltd, Reading, UK), a CM110 monochromator (CVI Technical Optics, Onchan, UK), and a 236 Source-Measure-Unit (SMU) (Keithley, USA). The spectrum was corrected for the intensity of incident light, using a reference spectrum from a calibrated silicon photodiode (UV-818, Newport, UK). The current–voltage characteristics at varying levels of illumination were measured using the Keithley 236 Source-Measure-Unit and the variably attenuated output of a 633 nm laser diode.
Fig. 2 (A) Current–voltage characteristics of the P3HT:PCBM photodiode shown in Fig. 1 under varying levels of 633 nm monochromatic illumination. (B) The intensity dependence of the short-circuit photocurrent for the same device. The signal varies linearly with intensity over the full range investigated. |
The chemiluminescence spectra for the blue and green luminescent dyes are shown in Fig. 1B, and are essentially identical to the corresponding photoluminescence spectra for the dyes (not shown) in accordance with the indirect nature of the PO-CL emission mechanism. The emission spectra of the two dyes match reasonably well with the response of the photodiodes and, as noted above, their quantum efficiencies are close to unity so both dyes can be favourably used with the P3HT/PCBM photodiodes. The Cyalume green dye, however, coincides more closely with the peak response of the photodiode and so was used for the measurements reported here.
To initiate the CL reaction, the dye–reagent–catalyst mixture and the H2O2 were pumped hydrodynamically into inlets 1 and 2 respectively (see Fig. 1A) and the signal was detected 1 cm downstream of the point-of-confluence. The CL signal was observed to rise monotonically from zero to a maximum steady-state value over a period of several seconds depending on flow conditions. To determine the optimal flow conditions for later experiments, we first fixed the concentration of H2O2 at 1 mM and investigated the influence of the total flow rate on the measured CL signal. The variation of the CL signal in response to changes in the flow rate is shown in Fig. 3, where the black arrows denote the points in time at which the flow rate was changed. In each case, steady-state was reached within ∼20 s of adjusting the flow rate. The data shows the progression in CL signal as the total flow rate was sequentially changed from 0 to 150 to 75 to 30 to 0 to 150 and back to 0 µl min−1. A total flow rate of 150 µl min−1 resulted in the strongest CL signal with excellent reproducibility being obtained between the second and the penultimate flow rates (both 150 µL min−1). The slight fluctuations in the steady-state CL signal are due to small gas bubbles generated in the early stages of the reaction that scatter the emitted light.
Fig. 3 Transient CL signal for the on-chip mixing of 1 mM hydrogen peroxide with CPPO, 9,10-bis(phenylethynyl)anthracene and 5 mM DMAP. The data show the progression in CL signal as the total flow rate was sequentially changed from 0 to 150 to 75 to 30 to 0 to 150 and back to 0 µL min−1. The arrows indicate the times at which the flow rate was adjusted, and the asterisks represent 0 µL min−1, i.e. stopped flow. The most stable CL signal was obtained at a total flow rate of 75 µL min−1, and this flow rate was therefore selected for subsequent measurements. |
The intensity of the measured CL signal is dependent on the mixing dynamics within the channel: at the optimal flow rate, substantial mixing of the reagents has already occurred by the time they reach the detector, leading to a strong CL signal; at higher flow rates, the reagents will not have mixed adequately by the time they reach the detection zone, leading to a reduced CL signal; and, at excessively slow flow rates, the reaction is partially over by the time the detection zone is reached, leading again to a reduced signal. For the Cyalume reagents selected, the catalysed CL reaction proceeds quickly so the strongest emission is obtained at the highest flow rate of 150 µL min−1. In principle, the CL emission strength could be enhanced by raising the flow rate further still. However, at flow rates above 100 µL min−1, the system was prone to occasional periods of excessive effervescence, resulting in an intermittently unstable signal (not shown). The effervescence is most severe in the earliest stages of the reaction and for reasons of reliability it is preferable to use lower flow rates, which allow the reaction to ‘settle down’ before the detection zone is reached, resulting in a weaker but significantly more stable signal. In practice, a flow rate of 75 µL min−1 was found to provide a good compromise between long term signal stability (over a time-scale of several minutes) and absolute intensity.
The total flow rate was fixed at 75 µL min−1 to investigate the influence of H2O2 concentration on the intensity of the CL signal. H2O2 solutions of sequentially increasing concentration were pumped into inlet 2, and the CL reagent with catalyst and dye were pumped into inlet 1. The transient response of the CL signal at each of the H2O2 concentrations is shown in Fig. 4A. In each case steady-state is reached within approximately 10 s, which is important for real-world applications that require fast sample-to-answer times. At concentrations above 100 µM there is a slight overshoot in the signal before steady-state is reached which may relate to a change in the mixing dynamics within the chip. The signal nonetheless reaches steady-state within a short period of time and the overshoot does not adversely affect analytical performance. The steady-state CL signal is plotted against hydrogen peroxide concentration in Fig. 4B, and excellent linearity is obtained in the range 10 µM to 1 mM with a correlation coefficient, R, of 0.997. (A slight deviation from linearity was observed at higher H2O2 concentrations due presumably to an insufficient amount of dye or reagent to react with hydrogen peroxide.) The detection limit for the integrated chip/detector was <10 µM, which represents a 100-fold enhancement compared to the data we reported previously.20 Significantly, the sensitivity of the integrated CL devices described here is equivalent to that of the devices reported by Jorgensen et al. using integrated silicon photodiodes.14
Fig. 4 (A) Transient CL signals for the on-chip mixing of CPPO, 9,10-bis(phenylethynyl)anthracene and 5 mM DMAP with various concentrations of hydrogen peroxide at a total applied flow rate of 75 µL min−1. (B) The steady-state CL signal as a function of H2O2 concentration extracted from the data in (A). The error bars are deduced from the fluctuating (steady-state) transient signals and correspond to three standard deviations either side of the mean value. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2007 |