Christian
Kind
a,
Radian
Popescu
b,
Erich
Müller
b,
Dagmar
Gerthsen
b and
Claus
Feldmann
*a
aInstitut für Anorganische Chemie, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), Engesserstrasse 15, D-76131, Karlsruhe, Germany. E-mail: claus.feldmann@kit.edu; Fax: +49-721-6084892; Tel: +49-721-6082855
bLaboratorium für Elektronenmikroskopie, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), Engesserstrasse 7, D-76131, Karlsruhe, Germany
First published on 6th August 2010
Nanoscale silver hollow spheres are first prepared via a microemulsion approach with 15–20 nm as the outer diameter, 3–5 nm as the wall thickness, and 10–15 nm as the diameter of the inner cavity. The presence of hollow spheres is confirmed by electron microscopy (SEM, BF-/HAADF-STEM, HRTEM) as well as by X-ray diffraction with a line-shape analysis to characterize the microcrystalline properties. In addition to the hollow spheres, massive silver nanoparticles of similar size (outer diameter of 15–20 nm) are gained via microemulsions. Based on the similarity of experimental conditions and the resulting particle size, as-prepared silver hollow spheres and massive nanoparticles are used to compare their optical properties and surface-plasmon resonance. In contrast to reducing the diameter of massive particles, “hollowing” of silver nanoparticles leads to a red-shift of the plasmon resonance. With a red shift of about 33 nm in the case of the hollow spheres, a quantum-size effect is indeed observed and in accordance with the thin sphere wall.
In comparison to quasi-zero-dimensional massive metal nanoparticles (i.e., outer diameter < 5 nm), nanoscale hollow spheres exhibit a quasi-infinite two-dimensional layer (viz. is along the sphere wall) as well as a quasi-zero-dimensional direction (viz. is perpendicular to the sphere wall). Such morphology could lead to quantum-size effects that differ from massive particles of similar size.9 Moreover, the outer and inner surfaces of hollow spheres may allow specific surfaces that are otherwise only reached by very small particles. The latter, however, are difficult to prepare and tend to rapid agglomeration. To this concern, the extended surface of hollow spheres can be advantageous from the perspective of biocidity and catalysis, too.
To date, literature addressing the synthesis of silver hollow spheres is rather limited. Although, miscellaneous synthetic approaches—mainly including emulsion techniques and hard templates—have been involved, polycrystalline and agglomerated hollow spheres have been gained most often.10–18 Moreover, hollow spheres of metallic silver have been only reported with diameters exceeding 100 nm. In this study, non-agglomerated silver hollow spheres with diameters <50 nm are firstly realised. Synthesis was performed via a microemulsion-based strategy.19 Based on very similar experimental conditions, but an essential difference regarding the addition of the starting materials, the microemulsion approach allows to prepare silver hollow spheres as well as massive silver nanoparticles of similar size. Consequently, the optical properties and eventual quantum-size effects can be validated based on both morphologies. Such a comparison of hollow spheres and massive nanoparticle—based on similar conditions of synthesis and an identical surface functionalisation—has been barely applied till now.
Fig. 1 Schematic mechanism of the formation of (a) nanoscale silver hollow spheres at the liquid-to-liquid phase-boundary of a w/o-micelle and (b) massive silver nanoparticles by coalescence of two separate micellar systems. |
To realise nanoscale hollow spheres, again, microemulsion techniques were performed, however, with the starting materials now located in different phases—one reactant inside the aqueous micelles while the second was added to the non-polar dispersant phase (Fig. 1a).28,29 As a consequence, the reaction yet proceeds at the liquid-to-liquid phase boundary. To initiate this diffusion-controlled reaction and to strictly limit the formation of the solid at the phase boundary, appropriate experimental conditions are prerequisite. This includes a suited type and concentration of the starting materials, a sufficient solubility/non-solubility of the relevant starting material in the water-/oil-phase as well as a sufficient reaction rate. In detail, the non-polar compound [Ag(PPh3)4]NO3 was added to the oil-phase; NaBH4 as a water-soluble reducing agent was added to the polar phase (Fig. 1a). To control diffusion and reaction rate, reduction of silver was started—subsequent to the addition of the silver precursor—at decreased temperature (0 °C) and over a long period of time (20 h). Subsequent to this initial formation of a first, very thin solid shell, the reaction rate was sped up by slowly increasing the temperature to 60 °C. Finally, the blackish grey product was separated by centrifugation and carefully purified to remove the ingredients of the microemulsion (i.e. surfactants, residual precursors and salts and oil-phase).
Fig. 2 Size and size distribution according to DLS analysis and STEM images: (a) as-prepared silver hollow spheres and (b) massive silver nanoparticles (DLS subsequent to redispersion in ethanol). |
Size and morphology of as-prepared silver nanoparticles were further elucidated by electron microscopy. To overview the particle shape and size, STEM images were recorded (Fig. 2). Here, spherical and nearly monodisperse particles with 15–20 nm in size are observed for both, as-prepared hollow spheres and massive silver nanoparticles. To reliably prove the presence of hollow spheres, HRTEM was involved (Fig. 3a). Here, ring-type structures are visible as a two-dimensional projection of the three-dimensional hollow spheres. Based on a statistical evaluation of 56 particles, the outer diameter is again confirmed to about 15–20 nm, while the wall thickness can be deduced to 3–5 nm.
Fig. 3 HRTEM images of silver nanoparticles: (a) images of different as-prepared silver hollow spheres with (b) lattice fringes indicating the crystallinity of the sphere wall; (c) images of a selected hollow sphere taken consecutively within a few seconds, showing the fragility of the hollow spheres when exposed to the electron beam; (d) high-resolution images of massive silver nanoparticles with lattice fringes. |
According to HRTEM images massive silver nanoparticles are crystalline and exhibit lattice fringes with a d-value of 2.4 Å (Fig. 3d). This matches well with the (111) lattice plane of elemental Ag (2.36 Å).30 Similar lattice fringes and d-values are also observed for the hollow spheres and indicate the crystallinity of the sphere wall (inset of Fig. 3b). In contrast to massive silver particles, however, the hollow spheres turned out to be extremely sensitive to the electron beam. Already after few seconds of illumination with high-energy electrons the hollow spheres show a significant loss of contrast and a complete collapse of the sphere structure. This is accompanied by a rapidly proceeding removal of the wall material (Fig. 3c). Moreover, a certain amount of massive silver particles, exhibiting diameters that are smaller than those of the hollow spheres, is observed in TEM analysis. In sum, these findings can be explained by the phenomenon of “quasi-melting”,31–34 which has been observed for hollow spheres already.27 Considering the rapid destruction of the hollow spheres under TEM conditions, the observation of residual massive particles is certainly not a surprise.35
Low-energy scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) images of as-prepared silver hollow spheres recorded at 30 keV in the bright-field (BF) and high-angle annular dark-field (HAADF) mode are shown in Fig. 4a and b. Electron-beam induced degradation of the particles is significantly reduced at 30 keV compared to TEM studies at 200 keV which allows a detailed analysis of the particle structure. The inner cavity can be clearly resolved in Fig. 4a where the BF-STEM intensity is higher compared to the darker wall regions. The contrast behaviour is reversed in the HAADF-STEM image Fig. 4b which shows another particle. BF-STEM images do not only show the projected particle size but in addition allow for quantification of the thickness of the sample along the electron beam direction if the chemical composition of the sample is known. This quantification is based on Monte-Carlo simulations which yield the transmitted electron intensity taking into account the specific detector data.36 The calculated BF intensity (transmission) of silver is shown in Fig. 4d as a function of the sample thickness (vacuum corresponds to a transmission of 1). Using the calculated transmission intensity profile in Fig. 4c—across the particle shown in Fig. 4a—the sample thickness can be quantified. Note that the background intensity of the carbon support film was subtracted from the BF intensity measured in the region of the hollow sphere which yields a transmission of 1 outside of the particle (region “1” in Fig. 4a and c). The transmitted intensity decreases to a value ∼0.4 in the wall of the hollow sphere (regions “2” in Fig. 4a and c) which corresponds to an Ag thickness of ∼17 nm. The transmission at the central cavity (region “3”) reaches 0.65 which corresponds to an Ag thickness of ∼9 nm. The measured thickness of the particle in Fig. 4a suggests an ellipsoid-type shape which is consistent with the data obtained by DLS and XRD (see below).
Fig. 4 Low-energy STEM images of silver hollow spheres recorded at 30 keV in the (a) BF-mode at 30 kV and (b) HAADF-mode. (c) Intensity profile through the hollow sphere in (a). (d) Transmission in the BF-mode calculated by Monte-Carlo simulations as a function of the Ag thickness. The cross-section of the hollow sphere along the direction of transmission is indicated by vacuum: 1, maximum wall thickness: 2 and center of the inner cavity: 3. |
X-Ray powder diffraction (XRD) pattern of both as-prepared nanomaterials are shown in Fig. 5. Both—the hollow spheres as well as massive nanoparticles—turn out to be highly crystalline. From the XRD peak positions lattice parameters of a = 407.7 ± 1 pm (massive particles) and a = 409.0 ± 3 pm (hollow spheres) were determined, which are in good agreement with a = 408.5 pm of face-centred cubic bulk-silver.30 The reflections of the hollow spheres (Fig. 5a) are significantly broadened in comparison to those of massive particles (Fig. 5b). This finding points to a smaller crystallite size and is well in agreement with the shell-like structure. Line shapes of all Bragg peaks were derived via Voigt-functions and used to determine the microcrystalline properties.37 Thus, an average crystallite size of 24 nm along the (111)- and (110)-direction, and of 17 nm along (001) was calculated for massive silver particles from the single-line integral width. In the case of the hollow spheres, values of 9 nm along (111) and (110) as well as 6 nm along (001) were gained. These data suggest a slightly elliptical shape of both types of nanoparticles, which is indeed frequently observed in STEM and TEM images (Fig. 2, 3 and 4a). Finally, microstrain of the nanoparticles as indicated by the 〈ε2〉1/2 value was verified. This results to 3.3–4.9 × 10−4 for massive nanoparticles and to 8.6–19.1 × 10−4 for the hollow spheres.37 Altogether, these data are consistent with data stemming from DLS, SEM, STEM and TEM. However, it should also be mentioned that the significance is certainly reduced based on only three Bragg peaks available at comparably low θ angles. Moreover, the scattering behaviour and form factor of hollow spheres will be slightly different from massive particles.
Fig. 5 X-Ray powder diffraction patterns of as-prepared silver hollow spheres (a) and massive silver nanoparticles (b). |
Fig. 6 FT-IR spectra of as-prepared silver hollow spheres and massive silver nanoparticles indicating a similar surface conditioning. |
Based on identical size, size distribution and surface conditioning, finally, the optical properties of as-prepared hollow spheres and massive silver nanoparticles were studied. To this respect, suspensions of both nanomaterials in ethanol were used to record UV-Vis spectra (Fig. 7). Thus, the absorption maximum of silver hollow spheres was determined at a wavelength of 432 nm. In the case of massive silver nanoparticles the absorption maximum appeared at 399 nm. The line-width of the plasmon resonance for the hollow spheres with about 130 nm (FWHM: full-width-at-half maximum) is somewhat broader than for similar-sized massive Ag or Au nanoparticles (70–120 nm),22,23 but well in accordance with data observed for gold hollow spheres (110–160 nm).40,41 The red-shift of 33 nm—as observed here for the hollow spheres—can be also compared to differently sized massive nanoparticles. To this concern, theoretical considerations and experimental data have validated a blue-shift of about 30 nm when decreasing the diameter of massive nanoparticles by about 50 nm.42 This finding and correlation are schematically illustrated in Fig. 8.
Fig. 7 Optical properties of as-prepared silver hollow spheres and massive silver nanoparticles in ethanol: Photo of suspensions as well as UV-Vis spectra with shifted surface-plasmon resonance absorption of as-prepared hollow spheres (red) and massive silver nanoparticles (black). |
Fig. 8 Scheme illustrating the energy of the plasmon resonance absorption when decreasing the outer diameter of massive nanoparticles and upon “hollowing” the particles to become hollow spheres (with d1/d2: diameter; note that the visible colour as adumbrated above is complementary to the plasmon absorption).45 |
Obviously, “hollowing” of massive silver nanoparticles leads to an opposite effect as compared to decreasing the outer diameter of massive silver nanoparticles. A similar behaviour and red-shift of the plasmon resonance has been already discussed in the case of gold hollow spheres.27,43,44 The different behaviour of hollow and massive metal nanoparticles is also well in agreement with the theoretical background of the plasmon resonance that suggests a higher polarizability of the symmetric plasmon in the case of hollow spheres (Fig. 8).45 Furthermore, the obtained results may serve as an example to confirm the so-called plasmon hybridization model as suggested by Halas et al.46
Altogether, the morphological shift of the surface-plasmon resonance between as-prepared hollow spheres and massive silver nanoparticles is reliably validated. The observed red-shift clearly indicates that “hollowing” of massive particles leads to a quantum-size effect that differs from decreasing the outer diameter of massive particles. The latter finding also evidences the smaller massive particles observed in TEM analysis indeed to stem from sphere destruction under TEM conditions. If these massive particles were originating from the microemulsion synthesis they would have caused a blue-shifted surface-plasmon resonance, which is not observed experimentally. Based on the successful preparation of nanoscale hollow spheres and massive silver nanoparticles via microemulsion techniques, additional adaptability might arise in future from the fact that fine-tuning of outer diameter and cavity size of the hollow spheres is in principle possible via this approach, too. This has been recently demonstrated in the case of La(OH)3 hollow spheres as a first example.47
Based on similar size, size distribution and surface conditioning, as-prepared hollow spheres and massive nanoparticels are well suited to study for morphological quantum-size effects. Accordingly, UV-Vis spectra exhibit a red-shift of 33 nm of the surface-plasmon resonance in the case of the hollow spheres as compared to similar-sized massive particles. “Hollowing” of silver nanoparticles obviously influences the plasmon resonance in opposite to reducing the size of massive nanoparticles. The latter show a blue-shift upon decreasing the outer diameter. In sum, a morphological quantum-size effect of the surface-plasmon resonance can be reliably validated by comparision of microemulsion-made silver hollow spheres and massive nanoparticles.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2010 |