Satoshi
Yoda
*a,
Keisuke
Sato
b and
Hideko T.
Oyama
b
aNanosystem Research Institute, National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST), 1-1-1 Higashi, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8565, Japan. E-mail: s-yoda@aist.go.jp; Fax: +81 29 861 4567; Tel: +81 29 861 9425
bDepartment of Chemistry, Rikkyo University, 3-34-1 Nishiikebukuro, Toshima-ku, Tokyo, 171-8501, Japan. E-mail: hideko-oyama@rikkyo.ac.jp; Fax: +81 3 3985 2363; Tel: +81 3 3985 2363
First published on 22nd July 2011
Paclitaxel (PT) is a mitotic inhibitor used in cancer chemotherapy. Impregnation of PT into amorphous poly(DL-lactic acid) (PDLLA) in mixtures of high-pressure ethanol (EtOH) and carbon dioxide (CO2) at various compositions was investigated at 313 K and 20 MPa. It was demonstrated that the high pressure EtOH–CO2 mixture is a promising solvent for fabrication of polymer-based drug delivery systems (DDS) materials, which enables the avoidance of drug deterioration due to processing at elevated temperatures. A mixture with 25 mol% EtOH allowed impregnation of the largest amount of PT in the PDLLA matrix. The amount of impregnated PT in the EtOH–CO2 mixtures was 10 times and 28 times larger than those in supercritical CO2 and liquid EtOH, respectively. The composition of the EtOH–CO2 mixture affected the amount of PT that could be impregnated. The increase in the amount of impregnated PT in the mixture is probably attributed to plasticization of PDLLA and increased solubility of PT into the EtOH–CO2 mixture. The degree of swelling observed in the PDLLA caused by plasticization depended on the composition of the EtOH–CO2 mixture, with the volume increasing to 1.7 times the initial size for a mixture containing 40 mol% EtOH at 313 K and 20 MPa. Physical aging was induced after the swollen PDLLA in supercritical CO2 was vitrified by pressure drop from 20 MPa to atmospheric pressure at 313 K, whereas vitrification hardly occurred in the EtOH–CO2 mixture under the same conditions.
An alternative route using supercritical carbon dioxide (scCO2) as a medium in fabrication of materials for drug delivery has been developed.2scCO2 is an environmentally friendly, non-flammable, and non-toxic solvent and is easily removed from the polymer matrix after fabrication. Since scCO2 plasticizes a variety of polymers including PLA and enables processing at lower temperature than that in the atmosphere, it can prevent thermal deterioration of drugs. Thus the scCO2 route is quite beneficial for preparation of DDS materials. Polymer microspheres containing drugs and scaffolds (polymer sponges) incorporating drugs are two major applications. Preparation of microspheres has been attempted using a variety of precipitation techniques such as rapid expansion of scCO2 (RESS), and anti-solvent techniques for precipitation.2,3 In recent studies, polymer particles and drug systems such as poly(L-lactic acid (PLLA) and retinyl palmitate,4PLLA and azacytidine,5poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) and 2-acetyloxy-4-(trifluoromethyl) benzoic acid (trifulsal),6 were prepared and characterized. Biodegradable polymer scaffolds prepared by polymer saturation with CO2 (with decreasing glass transition temperature) followed by depressurization induce the formation of the polymer. The scCO2 process is free from residues of organic solvent, which may damage cells or tissues.6 Recently polymer scaffolds incorporating drugs or bioactive agents like PMMA–PLA and ibuprofen systems have been reported.7
In the preparation of these polymeric medical materials, the solubility of drugs into scCO2, the swelling behavior of the polymers in scCO2, the affinity of polymer and drug molecules, are important factors for a successful impregnation process. Solubility of drugs into scCO2 is a first hurdle in many cases. Solubility of drugs into scCO2, which generally have a large molecular weight and/or molecular polarity, is unfortunately quite low.8 For this reason a variety of precipitation techniques using CO2 as an anti-solvent have been employed for the preparation of drug-containing particles.
Addition of polar solvents to scCO2 such as ethanol (EtOH) is known to be effective to increase the solubility of many polar substances. Additionally, polar solvents are also effective for plasticization, swelling and possibly dissolution of polymers. Recently Kiran applied a high pressure acetone–CO2 mixture to the formation process of PLLA.9 He reported that the PLLA was solubilized in the high pressure mixtures at optimized conditions, and that the higher incorporation with the mixture affected the properties. High pressure mixtures of CO2 and organic solvent for drug incorporation into polymers should be used efficiently. However, mainly due to difficulty in measurements, there are limited data on drug solubility and polymer plasticization in mixtures of scCO2 and organic solvents. Lack of solubility and plasicization data is a technical barrier for effective use of the mixture.
In the present paper we report on a novel fabrication of PLA-based DDS material using a high-pressure EtOH and CO2 mixture. EtOH is believed to be the only organic solvent acceptable for the preparation of medical materials. Conveniently, high-pressure EtOH and CO2 mixtures form the homogeneous phase over a wide range of compositions.10 The homogeneous mixture is expected to increase the solubility of drugs and plasticization of PLA. Therefore, the homogeneous mixture is expected to be very useful for preparation of DDS materials.
Here we demonstrated impregnation of an anticancer drug, paclitaxel (PT) (Fig. 1) into amorphous poly(D,L-lactic acid) (PDLLA) in a high pressure EtOH–CO2 mixture at 313 K and 20 MPa. PT is a bioactive natural product of alkaloid and is widely employed in chemotherapy for lung, ovarian, and breast cancers. Solubility of PT into scCO2 has been already reported,11–14 which ranges from 10−7 to 10−6 in molar fraction. The solubility of PT in the EtOH–CO2 (10 mol% EtOH) mixture was also mentioned previously11 and described as about 10 times larger than that in scCO2. Detailed solubility measurements of PT in an EtOH–CO2 mixture are under investigation in our group and similar results were obtained. Therefore the EtOH–CO2 system is expected to be more beneficial for impregnation of PT compared to scCO2. The effects of scCO2 on PLA swelling caused by plasticization have been studied,15–17 but there is little literature available on high pressure EtOH–CO2 mixtures. We conducted an evaluation of PDLLA swelling in EtOH–CO2 mixtures using a high pressure view cell, and measured the PT amount impregnated into the PDLLA under different compositions of high pressure EtOH–CO2 mixtures. The relationship between swelling and PT impregnation, and the efficacy of the EtOH addition to CO2, are discussed in detail.
Fig. 1 Chemical structure of paclitaxel (PT). |
Fig. 2 (a) Schematic diagram of apparatus for swelling observation of PDLLA in EtOH–CO2 mixtures. (b) Close-up of the view cell. |
The PDLLA disk (20) was evacuated in the cell (9) at 313 K, at least 24 h before starting measurement. CO2 was liquefied through the cooling unit (2) at 273 K. The liquefied CO2 and EtOH were sent by high pressure pumps (1) and (3) (Shodex DS-4) and then mixed with each other at the accumulator (4) (10 cm3 high pressure column filled with 1 mm glass beads). The molar ratio of EtOH/CO2 was controlled by changing the flow rates of the pumps. The mixture then passed through the buffer tank (5) in a thermostatic zone (15) at an experimental temperature which was controlled to ±0.1 K. After reaching equilibrium, the mixture was introduced into the cell (9) by switching the 6-port valve (8), and left for 24 h under these conditions. The images of PDLLA in the view cell were recorded every 5 min at the same magnitude by a CCD camera (11) and PC (12). Since the PDLLA is fixed between the windows with a constant gap (0.5 mm), vertical swelling could be neglected. Under these conditions, the degree of swelling (ΔS) is defined as follows:
(1) |
Fig. 3 (a) Schematic diagram of apparatus for impregnation of PT in PDLLA. (b) Close-up of the high pressure vessel. |
The amount of impregnated PT in the PDLLA disk was determined using gel permeation chromatography (GPC). The sample was first dissolved in chloroform. The GPC analysis was conducted using TSK-GEL (300 mm (L) × 7.8 mm (ID), Tosoh Corp.) and chloroform as eluent at (313 K). Details of GPC measurements are described elsewhere.20 The amount of PT was estimated by both UV-VIS and fluorescence detectors. The UV-VIS absorbance of PT was measured at 250 nm by the former detector and the fluorescence intensity of PT was monitored at 310 nm with the excitation wavelength of 250 nm by the latter detector.
Fig. 4 (a) Profiles of PDLLA swelling degree (ΔS) in EtOH–CO2 mixtures at 313 K, 6–20 MPa. (b) Typical appearance of PDLLA before and after swelling with 50 mol% of EtOH at 12 MPa. |
This type of EtOH–CO2 mixture effect on polymer swelling has not been previously reported. Matsuyama et al. reported a higher solubility of poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG, molecular weight average = 4000) than pure scCO2 and than pure EtOH (insoluble) was observed.22 They found the maximum solubility of PEG in a 50 wt% EtOH mixture. In the report they performed similar measurements with other polymers including PLA (molecular weight = 5000), but no particular effect was found for PLA in their report. This might be due to the number of measurement points and to the polymer type. As mentioned their report, the polarity and the van der Waals force of the mixed solvent were highly important factors. The solubility and swelling of polymers in EtOH–CO2 mixtures were fundamentally related to the interactions between polymer, EtOH, and CO2. For polymers having some polarity (such as PLA and PEG), interactions between the polymer and pure CO2 were too small, whereas pure EtOH was too polar and their molecules tend to be self-associated.
Pöhler et al. investigated the density of high pressure EtOH–CO2 mixtures at 2–23 MPa and 0–50 mol% EtOH and reported that the maximum density of the mixture was at 30 mol% EtOH, 15–23 MPa.23 This indicates that self-association of both CO2 and EtOH molecules was diluted and the association of these molecules was optimized in this composition. For the polymer–EtOH–CO2 system, there would be good conditions where interactions among those molecules are balanced, so that solvent molecules are more available to the polymer network. It was presumed that swelling of PDLLA in our work is related the amount of solvent included in the polymer network.
Fig. 5 Typical DSC curves (around Tg) of PDLLA treated in EtOH–CO2 mixtures at 313 K, 20MPa. (a) The first heating (Cycle 1) and (b) the second heating (Cycle 2). The dotted line shown in (a) indicates the Tg obtained from Cycle 2. |
The glass transition temperature (Tg) of untreated PDLLA film was determined at 329.5 K for the first heating (Cycle 1). In contrast, a sample treated in scCO2 showed a sharp endothermic peak at 334.0 K increasing the Tg by 4.5 K. The result indicates that the treatment in scCO2 induces physical aging of PDLLA, in which Tg shifted to higher temperatures and more heat was required for the rearrangement of polymer chains for glass transition. Physical aging is a phenomenon that occurs when a polymer is cooled from above to below its Tg, a reduction in the specific volume or enthalpy, and an apparent shift to the creep response to longer times occurs.24 Here, the materials with non-equilibrium glassy states tend to slowly rearrange their molecules to reach the equilibrium state, since a rapid cooling through Tg slows down the molecular mobility and creates thermodynamically unstable glass. Here in the present study, a treatment at high pressure gas increases the free volume of PDLLA, thereby causing plasticization and swelling. Furthermore, the depressurization of CO2 from 20 MPa to atmospheric pressure at 313 K transforms PDLLA from the rubbery state to the glassy state. Along with this change, physical aging is induced in PDLLA to rearrange the polymer chains to reach a thermodynamically more stable state. Such stabilized polymeric materials need more energy for the glass transition, thereby increasing Tg and the area of the endothermic peak as shown in Fig. 5. Since the first heating eliminates the structure formed by physical aging and thermal history, in the second heating (Cycle 2) of DSC measurements the Tg of all specimens showed almost the same value of 330.1 K. In Fig. 5(a) the Tg obtained by the second heating is shown by the dotted line. A similar physical aging phenomenon of PLLA and PDLLA is also observed during annealing at 313 K at atmospheric pressure, in which the temperature at the endothermic peak and enthalpy loss during annealing increased linearly with the logarithm of aging time.25 However, there are only few reports on physical aging induced by a high gas pressure treatment involving supercritical CO2.
In samples treated in EtOH–CO2 mixtures and EtOH, an endothermic peak around 334.0 K became broader and weaker in intensity, and shifted to a lower temperature with increased EtOH content. Physical aging was obviously prevented in EtOH–CO2 mixtures. In these samples, another large endothermic peak was detected around 373 K. The peaks on the sample treated in 75% EtOH and 100% EtOH are multimodal and noisy. After investigating some possible reasons, we confirmed that a similar peak was observed for the PDLLA immersed in liquid EtOH at atmospheric pressure and incompletely dried. Even with thorough evacuation (without heating), a small amount of EtOH might be tightly trapped in these high-pressure treated samples. Probably due to a variety of EtOH molecular states in inhomogeneously swelled PDLLA, split peaks were observed in samples treated in 75% and 100% EtOH. The EtOH molecules probably play a role in plasticization and thereby prevent physical aging.
Fig. 6 The relationship between the EtOH content of EtOH–CO2 mixtures and the amount of impregnated PT in PDLLA at 20 MPa, 313 K. ΔS values under the same conditions are shown for comparison. |
The result verified that a larger solubility is not necessary for a larger amount of impregnation. As mentioned above, the solubility of PT increases significantly and monotonically with enhancement of the EtOH content. Solubility of PT in EtOH (molar fraction) was much higher than that in EtOH–CO2 mixtures (at least larger than 10−3).18In EtOH-rich solvents, a distribution equilibrium of PT should be considered. It is possible that the affinity of PT for PDLLA becomes lower than that for the EtOH–CO2 mixture. As a result of these competitive influences, i.e. solubility of PT, swelling of PDLLA and distribution equilibrium of PT, the amount of impregnated PT peaks at 25% of EtOH mixture and then decreases with further increasing EtOH content.
Footnote |
† Electronic Supplementary Information (ESI) available: Supplement table 1. See DOI:10.1039/c1ra00070e/ |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2011 |