Ewa
Radzikowska
a and
Janina
Baraniak
*ab
aDepartment of Bioorganic Chemistry, Center of Molecular and Macromolecular Studies, Polish Academy of Sciences, Sienkiewicza 112, 90-363 Łódź, Poland
bInstitute of Chemistry, Environmental Protection and Biotechnology, Jan Długosz University, Armii Krajowej 13/15, 42-201 Częstochowa, Poland. E-mail: baraniak@cbmm.lodz.pl
First published on 14th October 2014
Chimeric oligonucleotides containing phosphodiester and phosphorothioate linkages have been obtained using the solid phase synthesis. The oligonucleotide parts possessing natural internucleotide phosphate bonds were assembled using commercially available nucleoside 3′-O-(2-cyanoethyl-N,N-diisopropylamino)phosphoramidites 7 whereas the phosphorothioate segment was built using nucleoside 3′-O-(2-thio-1,3,2-oxathiaphospholanes) 3. The oxidation steps, crucial for the conversion of phosphite linkages into the phosphate moieties, were conducted using tert-butylperoxy-trimethylsilane, and this reagent was not harmful to the diester phosphorothioate linkages. When P-diastereopure nucleoside 3′-O-(2-thio-1,3,2-oxathiaphospholane) monomers were employed the resulting chimeric backbone retained the P-stereoregularity of the phosphorothioate units.
PS-ODNs display several attractive features like nuclease resistance, activation of RNase H, and good pharmacokinetic properties.5 Their limitations include sequence-nonspecific binding to cellular proteins and concentration dependent competitive inhibition of many nucleases and polymerases.6 Because the uniform modification of oligonucleotides with phosphorothioate linkages is not required to confer enhanced stability,7 several efforts have been made to synthesize “chimeric” oligonucleotides possessing natural phosphate and phosphorothioate internucleotide linkages in the same molecule (PS/PO-ODNs).8 Two main types of such constructs have been reported. The first one consists of oligomers possessing the PS-linkages in alternate positions,9 while in the second the oligomer is composed of oligophosphate and oligophosphorothioate clusters.8a,b,c In the latter type it was assumed that the unmodified segments would preserve good hybridization properties of natural oligonucleotides, while the phosphorothioate segments would enhance the in vivo stability towards exo- and endonucleases compared to the unmodified PO-Oligos. Thus, the chimeric PS/PO-Oligos were expected to be advantageous over PS-Oligos8 with increased affinity towards the target oligonucleotides and reduced the non-specific interactions with proteins.
The actual biological activity of the oligonucleotide phosphorothioates (e.g., interactions with proteins or nucleic acids) may depend on stereochemical factors because the phosphorus atoms in the PS-linkages are stereogenic.10 One has to keep in mind that the phosphoramidite11 and H-phosphonate12 methodologies (commonly used to prepare PS-Oligos) are nonstereospecific and give a mixture of 2n diastereomers, where n is the number of internucleotide phosphorothioate functions. Thus, various methods have been elaborated to synthesize these P-chiral oligonucleotide analogs in a stereocontrolled manner,13 among them the oxathiaphospholane method developed by Stec et al.,14 the method utilizing nucleoside 3′-O-(3-N-acyl)oxazaphospholidine derivatives as monomer units,15 and the method based on a stereoselective synthesis of nucleoside 3′-O-oxazaphospholidine monomers16 are the most significant.
All these three methodologies can be used to synthesize PO/PS chimeric oligonucleotides although only the oxathiaphospholane method requires an additional set of 2-oxo-1,3,2-oxathiaphospholane monomers for the incorporation of PO-linkages.14b Taking into account the commercial availability of phosphoramidite nucleotides, it was tempting to combine the oxathiaphospholane method with the phosphoramidite one in order to obtain oligonucleotides having a stereoregular phosphate/phosphorothioate chimeric backbone. Unfortunately, the oxathiaphospholane method is incompatible with the phosphoramidite method of DNA synthesis, because the internucleotide phosphorothioate linkages (assembled using the oxathiaphospholane monomers) are diester moieties and they easily get oxidized during the treatment with an iodine–base–water solution,17 which is a typical way for the conversion of unstable phosphite (PIII) linkages into the stable phosphate (PV) moieties. To solve this problem one had to find an effective and strictly chemoselective reagent to oxidize the trivalent phosphorus atoms leaving untouched the labile phosphorothioate diesters present in the growing oligomer molecule. Here we present our results on making the oxathiaphospholane and phosphoramidite protocols compatible with the selection of tert-butylperoxy-trimethylsilane as an oxidizing reagent.
In order to decrease the reactivity of TBHP, it was transformed into tert-butylperoxy-trimethylsilane (tert-BuOOSiMe3, 6). This reagent has been successfully applied by Salamończyk for selective oxidation of phosphite groups in dendrimers already possessing diester P = S and P = Se branching units within the same molecule.20 The trimethylsilane modification made 6 to be much less reactive than 1, thus 50 equiv. of the oxidant and 30 minutes time were needed for the quantitative oxidation of the model dithymidyl phosphite. It was demonstrated by 31P NMR spectroscopy that under these conditions no desulfurization of 2 occurred and that the phosphorothioate function in 2 was not temporarily protected (silylated) with the trimethylsilyl group delivered by 6 (see ESI†).
Having defined the conditions suitable for the reaction in solution, the analogous reaction was executed in solid-phase experiments on a 1 μmol scale. The reaction pathway leading to the desired PS/PO-ODNs is shown in Scheme 2. Commercially available nucleoside 3′-O-(2-cyanoethyl-N,N-diisopropylamino)phosphoramidites 7 were used for the introduction of natural phosphate nucleotide units. In turn, phosphorothioate nucleotide parts were introduced using nucleoside oxathiaphospholane monomers 3 (Table 1), which were obtained in the modified manner compared to the published procedure.14b In preliminary experiments the monomers 3 were used as mixtures of P-diastereomers.
Compound | Chromatographic mobility vs. configuration at P atom | 31P NMR (CDCl3) δ (ppm) | Yield (%) |
---|---|---|---|
3a (Ade) | “Fast” (SP) | 103.57 | 42 |
“Slow” (RP) | 103.65 | 33 | |
3b (Cyt) | “Fast” (SP) | 104.09 | 45 |
“Slow” (RP) | 104.34 | 30 | |
3c (Gua) | “Fast” (SP) | 103.78 | 20 |
“Slow” (RP) | 103.88 | 26 | |
3d (Thy) | “Fast” (RP) | 106.70 | 49 |
“Slow” (SP) | 106.73 | 44 |
Using the procedure presented in Scheme 2, a series of protected chimeric PS/PO-oligonucleotides 13 was synthesized (Table 2). Starting from the 5′-end, the oligomers contained triester phosphate internucleotide linkages (1–5 units), followed by 1–3 diester phosphorothioate internucleotide linkages (Table 2). The starting nucleoside 8 was anchored to the controlled pore glass support using a DBU-resistant sarcosinyl-succinoyl linker.21 To build the phosphorothioate segments, the oxathiaphospholane derivatives 3 were condensed with the 5′-hydroxyl group of the growing oligomers. Then, the PO-segments were assembled via the phosphoramidite method using a 20-fold molar excess of the phosphoramidites 7 for each coupling, and at each of those cycles the phosphite moieties in oligonucleotide derivatives 11 were oxidized using a 50-fold molar excess (concentration: 0.33 μmol ml−1) of tert-BuOOSiMe3 (6) over 30 minutes to form the corresponding phosphates 12. Similarly, a 15-mer DMTTPSTPSTPS(TPO)8TPSTPSTPST was obtained containing an octameric phosphate segment at the middle of the chain and trimeric phosphorothioate segments at, both, 3′- and 5′-ends. Finally, the oligomers 12 were deprotected with concentrated NH4OH to form DMT-tagged chimeric PS/PO oligonucleotides 13, which without any further purification were subjected to MALDI-TOF MS analysis to assess the content of the oxidized products. For these compounds the molecular ions were accompanied by ions at m/z = M-304, attributed to the oligomers being partially detritylated due to the acidity of the matrices used.
Entry | Comp | Sequence | Theoretical mass (Da) | Observed mass MALDI-MS m/z (M − 1) | Peak (M − 16) contenta (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
a The intensities of the (M − 1) peaks were taken as 100%. b HPA (3-hydroxypicolinic acid) matrix. c THA (2′,4′,6′-trihydroxyacetophenone) matrix. d Voyager-Elite MALDI-TOF mass spectrometer. e SHIMADZU Axima Performance MALDI-TOF mass spectrometer. f Below the detection limit. | |||||
1 | 13a | DMTTPOTPSTPST | 1488 | 1488.4 | 0b,d,f |
2 | 13b | DMTTPOTPOdCPST | 1457 | 1456.8 | 3.7c,d |
3 | 13c | DMTTPOTPOdGPST | 1497 | 1496.8 | 5.6c,d |
4 | 13d | DMTTPOTPOTPSTPST | 1792 | 1791.7 | 3.9b,d |
5 | 13e | DMTTPOTPOTPOAPSAPST | 2114 | 2113.1 | 4.8c,d |
6 | 13f | OHTPOTPOTPOAPSAPST | 1812 | 1811.3 | 7.0c,d |
7 | 13g | DMTTPOTPOTPOd(CPSCPS)T | 2066 | 2064.9 | 4.3b,d; 6.0c,d |
8 | 13h | OHTPOTPOTPOd(CPSCPS)T | 1764 | 1762.7 | 6.3b,d; 11.0c,d |
9 | 13i | DMTd(GPOGPOAPOAPOAPSA) | 2167 | 2167.0 | 10.6b,d |
10 | 13j | DMTd(GPOGPOAPOAPSAPSA) | 2183 | 2183.0 | 8.0c,d |
11 | 13k | DMTTPOTPOTPOd(APSAPSAPSA) | 2454 | 2454.1 | 1.3b,d |
12 | 13l | DMTTPOTPOTPOTPOd(APSAPSAPSA) | 3062 | 3061.5 | 0b,d,f |
13 | 13m | DMTTPOTPOTPOTPOTPOd(CPSCPSCPSC) | 2964 | 2963.5 | 25.9b,d |
14 | 13n | DMTTPSTPSTPS(TPO)8TPSTPSTPST | 4896 | 4895.1 | 0b,d,f |
15 | 13o | [all-Sp]-TPOTPOTPOTPOTPOd(APSAPSAPS)T | 2749 | 2751.1 | 20.0b,d; 16.0b,e |
16 | 13p | [all-Sp]-TPOTPOTPOTPOTPOd(CPSCPSCPS)T | 2677 | 2674.9 | 15.0b,d |
17 | 13r | [all-Rp]-TPOTPOTPOTPOTPOd(CPSCPSCPS)T | 2677 | 2674.3 | 5.6b,d; 3.0b,e |
18 | 13s | [all-Sp]-TPOTPOTPOTPOTPOd(GPSGPSGPS)T | 2797 | 2797.4 | 18.0b,d |
19 | 13t | [all-Rp]-TPOTPOTPOTPOTPOTPSTPSTPST | 2722 | 2721.5 | 6.0b,d |
Starting from pure P-diastereomers of 3, chimeric PS/PO-Oligos possessing stereodefined phosphorothioate linkages (of either RP or SP configuration)14b were synthesized (entries 15–19) and the MS data (Table 2) are given for the detritylated oligomers. During each synthesis of PS/PO-Oligo, the dimethoxytrityl cation absorbance was monitored and the crude product was characterized by means of RP HPLC (see ESI†). The repetitive yields calculated on the DMT+ cation absorbance decay were in the range of 94–96%.
One might consider that the yield of the synthesis of 13n should be lower than those for the other assembled oligomers. This is because, in this case, the attachment of the last PS segment by the oxathiaphospholane method inevitably leads to the elimination of the 2-cyanoethyl groups from the PO units and such generated phosphodiester linkages may be susceptible to side reactions. However, this can be avoided, because exactly the same situation had taken place during the synthesis of chimeric PS/PO-Oligos based only on the oxathiaphospholane method14b where the by-products related to transformations of the phosphodiester linkages were not observed.
An exemplary 31P NMR spectrum (recorded for crude 13r) indicates the presence of two groups of signals at the expected intensity ratio 3:5, corresponding to the phosphorothioate and phosphate moieties (δ 55.50 ppm and −0.97 ppm, respectively, Fig. 1).
Analysis of the MALDI-TOF MS data revealed that in the majority of spectra the signal corresponding to the molecular ion (taken as 100%) was accompanied by a signal at m/z (M-16) of low intensity (typically <10%), which we attributed to the molecules with one of the sulfur atoms being randomly replaced with an oxygen atom. However, if the PS→PO exchange was caused by tert-BuOOSiMe3, the phosphorothioate diester linkages should be exposed to a cumulative treatment over up to eight synthetic cycles. Thus, one should observe a correlation between the number of phosphoramidite condensation/oxidation steps and the extent of the PS→PO exchange. But none of the recorded spectra contained signals attributable to the oxidation of two (m/z = M-32) or three (m/z = M-48) P-S linkages in a single molecule. Moreover, the MS analysis of 13k (entry 11) showed the presence of the M-16 signal, whereas in the MS spectra recorded for 13l (which contains one more thymidine phosphate residue) and for 13n (eight consecutive oxidation steps) the relevant M-16 signals were not detected at all. On the other hand, it has been noticed that the extent of desulfurization for a given oligomer varied depending on the spectrometer and on the matrix used for MS analysis (entry 15 or 17). When THA was employed, a more intense signal (M-16) was observed compared to that detected for the HPA matrix (entry 7 or 8).
It is worth noting that when oligo 13o-mix was synthesized using only commercially available deoxyribonucleoside phosphoramidites 7 (B1 = Thy, AdeBz) and either 3H-1,2-benzodithiol-3-one1,1-dioxide or iodine–water to oxidize the trivalent phosphorus atoms, MALDI-TOF MS analysis of deprotected oligo revealed desulfurization of phosphorothioate diesters to the extent of 22%.
Therefore, these studies have shown that to a certain extent the desulfurization occurred under the MALDI-TOF MS operating conditions. To the best of our knowledge it is the first example demonstrating that unexpected desulfurization can take place even under common negative MALDI-TOF MS operating conditions. On the other hand desulfurization of phosphorothioate oligonucleotides occurring during negative electrospray ionization (ESI-MS) has been described in the literature.22 Thus, a comparative analysis of the desulfurization of oligo 13k (entry 11) based on spectra recorded by means of ESI and MALDI techniques (see ESI†) revealed the greater amount of its desulfurization product in the ESI-MS spectrum (ca. 8% vs. 1.3%).
To identify the other factors which might be responsible for desulfurization we focused our attention on the paper published by Beaucage et al. concerning the desulfurization of PS-Oligos synthesized by the phosphoramidite method.23 Their studies based on 31P NMR revealed that under solid-phase synthesis conditions the loss of the 2-cyanoethyl protecting group from the triester thiophosphate linkage (occurring to the extent of ∼5–13%) depended on the capping reagents being used.24 Generated in this way phosphorothioate diesters underwent desulfurization by phosgene detected in, both, fresh and aged solutions of the detritylating reagent (3% TCA in CH2Cl2). Since the internucleotide phosphorothioate linkages assembled by the oxathiaphospholane method were unprotected we have taken into consideration the influence of the detritylating reagent on the desulfurization of the PS/PO-Oligos. Hence, oligos 13-e and 13-g were synthesized on the solid support (entries 5 and 7) and MS analysis showed that the observed desulfurization increased for oligos which were released from the support after removal of the DMT group (entries 6 and 8).
These examples have shown that the process of detritylation plays a role in the desulfurization process. This phenomenon should not be neglected, because the DMT group is repeatedly removed during PS/PO-oligonucleotide chain assembly. As a remedy to avoid the negative effect of phosgene on the quality of the PS/PO-Oligos a freshly prepared 3% TCA in toluene may be used.
Deoxyribonucleosides were purchased from Pharma Waldhof (Germany). Tetrazole solution, 1,4-diazabicyclo[5.4.0]undec-7-ene (DBU), 2-cyanoethanol, succinic anhydride, bis(trimethylsilyl)acetamide, acetic anhydride, dimethyl-aminopyridine and piperidine were purchased from Aldrich (USA). Fmoc-sarcosine was purchased from Bachem (Switzerland). Long chain alkylamine controlled pore glass (500 Å, mesh 80–120) was supplied by Sigma (USA). Phosphorus trichloride, ethyl acetate, butyl acetate, chloroform, dichloromethane, benzene and triethylamine were purchased from POCH (Poland). Elemental sulfur was dried under high vacuum for 12 h. Acetonitrile was used as a solvent for DBU and oxathiaphospholane monomers was dried over P2O5 (5 g L−1) and distilled through a 20 cm Vigreux column under an atmosphere of dry argon and stored over 4 Å molecular sieves. At least one-third of the initial volume must be left in the flask. Acetonitrile dried in this way must be transferred using gastight syringes under an atmosphere of dry argon, or by vacuum line. Phosphoramidites of 5′-O-DMT-nucleosides were purchased from Glen Research and tert-butyl hydroperoxide [a solution in decane (ca. 5.5 M over molecular sieves 4 Å)] was obtained from Fluka. 2-Chloro-1,3,2-oxathiaphospholane (14)26 and 2-chloro-4,4-dimethyl-1,3,2-oxathiaphospholane (15)14b were prepared according to the procedures described previously.
In the column 5′-O-DMT-nucleoside 8 (1 μmol) anchored to the LCA CPG support using a DBU-resistant sarcosinyl-succinoyl linker21 was detritylated with 3% solution of TCA (trichloroacetic acid) in methylene chloride and washed with 4 mL of dry acetonitrile and then with 4 mL of dry methylene chloride and dried under high vacuum.
For the coupling step, in the case of introduction of phosphorothioate internucleotide linkage (PS), a solution of an appropriate oxathiaphospholane monomer 3 (20 μmol) and DBU (50 μmol) in dry acetonitrile (150 μL) was prepared and instantly introduced into the column. After 15 minutes of intensive swirling the column was washed with dry acetonitrile (4 mL) and dry methylene chloride (4 mL) and dried under argon. Unreacted 5′-hydroxyl groups were capped using the standard DMAP–Ac2O–lutidine solution in THF.
During the introduction of phosphate linkages for the coupling step a solution of appropriate phosphoramidite monomer 7 (20 μmol) and 1-H-tetrazole (20 μmol) in dry acetonitrile (150 μL) was prepared and instantly introduced into the column. After 15 minutes of intensive swirling the column was washed with dry acetonitrile (4 mL) and dry methylene chloride (4 mL) and dried under argon. Unreacted 5′-hydroxyl groups were capped using the standard DMAP–Ac2O–lutidine solution in THF. For oxidation of newly formed phosphite to phosphate groups t-BuOOSiMe3 (50 μmol) was used as solution in acetonitrile (150 μL).
When the synthesis was complete, the oligomer was cleaved from the support under standard conditions (25% NH4OH, 2 h) and the protecting groups from nucleobases were removed at 55 °C over 12 h. The sample was concentrated under reduced pressure in a Speed-Vac concentrator.
A single cycle of chain elongation was as follows:
1) detritylation, 3% TCA in methylene chloride (2 × 5 ml),
2) wash, acetonitrile (4 ml), methylene chloride (4 ml), drying under high vacuum,
3) coupling (monomers 3 or 7),
4) wash, acetonitrile (4 ml), methylene chloride (4 ml),
5) capping, acetic anhydride/DMAP/2,6-lutidine/THF (0.15 ml; 2 min),
6)* oxidation, t-BuOOSiMe3 (6) (50 μmol) in acetonitrile (150 μL) (30 min),
7) wash, acetonitrile (4 ml), methylene chloride (4 ml),
8) removing of β-cyanoethyl groups, 10% piperidine in acetonitrile (v/v) (1 hour),
9) wash, acetonitrile (4 ml), methylene chloride (4 ml), drying under high vacuum.
* Only when phosphoramidite monomers 7 were used.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ob01837k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |