Csaba Fodor‡
*a,
Gergely Kali§
a,
Ralf Thomannb,
Yi Thomannb,
Béla Iván*a and
Rolf Mülhauptb
aPolymer Chemistry Research Group, Institute of Materials and Environmental Chemistry, Research Centre for Natural Sciences, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Magyar tudósok körútja 2, H-1117 Budapest, Hungary. E-mail: c.fodor@rug.nl; ivan.bela@ttk.mta.hu
bFreiburg Materials Research Center and Institute for Macromolecular Chemistry, University of Freiburg, Stefan-Meier-Straße 21, D-79104 Freiburg, Germany
First published on 20th January 2017
Macroscopically homogeneous poly(N-vinylimidazole)-linked by-poly(tetrahydrofuran) (PVIm-l-PTHF) amphiphilic conetworks (APCNs) were investigated to reveal the effect of conetwork composition in a broad composition range between 25–91 wt% PTHF content and the molecular weight of the components on phase separation and the formation of different morphological features. No macroscopic phase separation was found in these conetworks with semicrystalline PTHF phase, but the segregation of the various covalently connected phases occurs in the nanoscale. The nanophase separated APCNs possess compositionally asymmetric morphology with spherical and elongated domains together with a bicontinuous (cocontinuous) domain structure having ∼7–19 nm average domain sizes. The molecular weight of the PTHFDMA cross-linker, varying between 2170 and 10030 g mol−1, also influences the size and distance between the phases. Moreover, morphology dependent interactions with polar and non-polar solvents, as well as amphiphilic swelling behavior were found. These nanostructured materials, due to their unique nanophasic morphology and swelling properties possess significant importance and have numerous potential applications in various fields from medicine to material science and engineering.
Amphiphilic conetworks (APCNs) are nanophase separated soft materials, composed of covalently bonded, otherwise immiscible hydrophilic and hydrophobic (or even fluorophilic5–9) polymer chains.10–12 In addition the chemically bonded APCNs, supramolecular amphiphilic gels consisting of trivalent polyisobutylene and bivalent poly(ethylene oxide)13 and physically cross-linked gels via stereocomplex formation of two polylactide enantiomers14,15 are also reported. These novel polymeric systems belong to a rapidly emerging class of materials and have sparked enormous interest in the last few decades in both pure and applied sciences.7,8,16–31 APCNs possess several unique characteristics, such as the amphiphilic swelling properties and the improved mechanical characteristics compared to homopolymer hydrogels. Moreover, a special property of these materials is their phase behaviour. Indeed, in comparison with the different nanostructures and architectures of binary block copolymers, the nanophasic APCNs possess compositionally asymmetrical morphology with a cocontinous (bicontinuous) nanophase-separated structure over a broad composition range. The incompatibility of the different hydrophilic and hydrophobic polymer phases not only subserves the formation of co-(bi)continuous structures, but beyond the asymmetrical morphology development, spherical and coalesced elongated domains also appear. These domains have various proportions over the composition range and the phase separation in the APCNs leads to average domain sizes in the nanometer scale. Diversity of techniques involving differential scanning calorimetry (DSC),22,30 small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS),20,24,27 small angle neutron scattering (SANS),25,27 transmission electron microscopy (TEM),17,19,27,30 atomic force microscopy (AFM)17,19,30,32 and solid-state NMR20,21 were used to confirm the formation of separated nanodomains in these materials. The systematic study of the compositionally asymmetrical morphology of APCNs is of major importance, when a stable, bicontinuous nanophase-separated structure is formed over a broad composition window of both constituent phases with large inner surface between the distinct phases. This kind of morphology is favourable in a variety of fields such as ion conduction,33 oxygen permeation,34,35 tissue engineering36 as well as support for enhanced enzyme catalysis18,19,37 or nanotemplates of nanohybrid materials.27
In our previous publications, the synthesis and some fundamental structure–property correlations of poly(N-vinylimidazole) (PVIm) based conetworks were investigated.22,38–41 The widely used hydrophilic PVIm was cross-linked by the biocompatible, hydrophobic, rubbery methacrylate-telechelic polytetrahydrofuran (PTHFDMA) macromonomer with well-defined molecular weights. It was recently demonstrated that the poly(N-vinylimidazole)-linked by-poly(tetrahydrofuran) (PVIm-l-PTHF) amphiphilic conetworks with various PTHF lengths and different PVIm/PTHF ratios have some unprecedented structure–property relations. These parameters influence the scissor effect of the macromolecular cross-linker on the glass transition temperature, which supports the correlations between the fundamental structural parameters and the glass transition temperatures of the components.22 In this study, we aimed at to gain insight into the effect of composition and cross-linker on the nanophase separated morphology of the PVIm-l-PTHF conetworks. Through this dependence, the other goal of this work is to reveal the relationship between the swelling behaviour and the structural parameters. Based on our systematic investigations, the findings and interpretations reported here provide valuable insights into several aspects of revealing and understanding the structure–property relationships and nanostructure formation in these novel, rapidly emerging soft materials.
Synthesis of the higher molecular weight PTHFDMA macro-cross-linkers proceeds as follows: freshly distilled Tf2O initiator (2.48 mmol) was added to distilled THF (2.48 mol) under permanent stirring. In situ termination and functional group modification was performed by adding chloroform suspension of NaMA (24.8 mmol) to the reaction mixture after predetermined time. After 48 hour reaction time the solvent was evaporated, and the polymer was precipitated into water/methanol (1/1). The crude product was redissolved in THF filtered through aluminum oxide and silica gel column and concentrated. The molecular weights and the end-group modification efficiency were confirmed by 1H NMR and GPC (Mn(NMR) = 6850 g mol−1, Fn = 1.99, Mn(GPC) = 8650 g mol−1, Đ = 1.19 for PTHF6.8kDMA and Mn(NMR) = 10030 g mol−1, Fn = 1.97, Mn(GPC) = 11550 g mol−1, Đ = 1.21 for PTHF10kDMA); 1H NMR (400 MHz, chloroform-d): δ 1.61 (4H, s), 1.93 (6H, s), 3.40 (4H, s), 4.15 (4H, t, J = 6.4 Hz), 5.53 (2H, s), 6.08 (2H, s).
Based on our previous work on these materials, phase separation is expected in the transparent PVIm-l-PTHF conetworks between the incompatible, but covalently connected polymer chains. This phenomenon was proved by DSC22 and solid-state NMR investigations,38 by which two separate glass transitions were found in the conetworks (Fig. 2), indicating immiscibility of the components. It was also demonstrated that the glass transition temperatures changed with the composition of the conetworks and the molecular weight of PTHF cross-linkers.22 Since these immiscible components are covalently connected to each other, the macroscopic demixing is prohibited. Separation of the two phases can occur only in the nanoscale, confirmed by the optical transparency of the conetworks. For surface and bulk morphology examination, phase imaging by AFM or scanning probe microscopy is a convenient method, which provides valuable structural information.
Bulk morphology of the flat cryo-sectioned, annealed PVIm-l-PTHF conetworks was investigated. Phase mode AFM was performed at ambient condition that is above the melting point and glass transition temperature of PTHF, to determine the morphology and the dimensions of the phases. Representative AFM phase mode images of nanophase separated conetworks with various PTHF contents are shown in Fig. 3 (details of the AFM phase images for the whole conetwork series are presented in the ESI, see Fig. S1–S3†). For the correct interpretation of the phase mode AFM images, it is crucial to remark that cantilever with a tip curvature between 2–5 nm was used to get the necessary lateral resolution and identify the structure size as small as a few nanometers. The contrast, namely the diffuse tone difference between the phases in the phase mode AFM images can be used to map the variations of the distinct material properties, such as surface elasticity, and the direct visualization of the morphology. In the AFM phase images the two distinct polymer nanophases in the conetworks, specifically the glassy, hydrophilic PVIm and the elastic, soft PTHF phase appear with different colors, light and dark brown, respectively.
The cross-section analysis allows obtaining characteristic information about the bulk morphology of the conetworks. The AFM images indicate in all cases nanophase separation of the two polymers with different philicities, but the domains do not organize in a regular lattice over the whole composition range due to the randomly cross-linked structure of the conetworks.20,27 At low cross-linker content, (P2.2k-25 and P6.8k-52) the hydrophobic PTHF domains are dispersed in the continuous hydrophilic PVIm matrix as spheres. At increased hydrophobic ratio (P2.2k-38 and P10k-46) the distortion of the spherical domains is noticeable and elongated structures arise. From 47 wt%, 61 wt% and 66 wt% PTHF cross-linker content, depending on the molecular weight of the macromonomer (2.2k, 6.8k or 10k, respectively) the elongated PTHF phases interconnect to form continuous, more precisely cocontinuous (bicontinuous) phase next to the extended PVIm. The AFM micrographs of the PVIm-l-PTHF conetworks clearly indicate that in the conetworks the two incompatible hydrophilic and hydrophobic polymers exist in continuous phases next to each other. This bicontinuous phase morphology appears in a broad composition range, from 47 to 86 wt% PTHF content, with varying PTHF cross-linker molecular weights. At relatively high PTHF content the PVIm phases are interconnected with a certain extent and appear as nerve like system in the disordered continuous hydrophobic PTHF matrix.
It should be noted that the surface morphology may differ from the bulk morphology of the conetworks, due to the enrichment of one component on the surface during the synthesis of the conetwork.42 In other words, in PVIm-l-PTHF conetworks the hydrophobic polymer segments will move toward the surface, whereas the polymer segments with opposite philicity will become buried in the bulk, to minimize the surface energy. The selective separation of one component on surfaces was investigated and verified by Bruns et al. by applying surfaces with different chemical nature (poly(propylene), glass, Teflon, and argon) on 2-hydroxyethyl acrylate based conetworks.43
In binary block copolymers, the blocks are chemically bonded to each other, resulting in some degree of incompatibility and separating into microphases. In order to minimize the evolving incompatibility of the blocks, the copolymers self-assemble into various phase structures, as shown in Fig. 4. According to the theoretical phase diagram of block copolymers, the corresponding morphologies for binary block copolymers are indicated as follows: spheres, cylinders, gyroid and lamellar with increasing volume fraction of one of the polymer blocks. The bicomponent conetworks, compared to the binary block copolymers, have compositionally asymmetrical morphology with analogous phase structures from spherical to stable bicontinuous phase morphology. This phase behavior appears in a broad composition range and at high polymer B content reversed elongated/spherical domains are formed (Fig. 4).
The good quality and contrast of the AFM images (Fig. 3 and S2–S4†) allow qualitative evaluation of the PTHF domain sizes, i.e. the diameter of the hydrophobic domains and the inter-domain distances between the PTHF phases (details are presented in the ESI, see Fig. S5–S10†). The results reveal that the distribution of the domain sizes and inter-domain distances in the investigated PVIm-l-PTHF conetwork samples are unexpectedly narrow. The determined PTHF domain sizes of the APCNs vary between 7 nm and 19 nm while the PTHF inter-domain distances are in the range of 15 nm to 28 nm as shown in Fig. 5. It can be clearly seen in this figure that with higher molecular weight PTHF cross-linker the formed phases in the conetworks, as well as the distances, become larger than in the case of the short macromonomers (P2.2k). The hydrophilic phase sizes are in the range from 3 nm to 10 nm, which is in a good correlation with the average molecular weights of the hydrophilic PVIm segments between two cross-linking points (Mc) which vary between 134 and 5870 g mol−1.22
To study the correlation between different morphological features and the swelling behaviour of PVIm-l-PTHF conetworks, swelling measurements were performed. In particular, swelling studies on the conetworks with various composition, cross-linker length, therefore with different morphology, were carried out in water and THF. The data in Fig. 6 show the equilibrium swelling ratios (Q) as a function of composition (wt% PTHF content), and the compositionally asymmetrical morphology of the conetworks are also depicted in this figure. The Q values for both solvents change with the composition, i.e. the higher the PVIm/PTHF ratio in the conetworks, the higher the swelling in aqueous solutions. The swelling in the nonpolar THF follows opposite tendency, confirming that the increased hydrophobic ratio subserves the nonpolar swelling. In other words, the PVIm-l-PTHF conetworks behave as hydrogels in polar and as hydrophobic gels in nonpolar solvents, meaning that the conetworks possess amphiphilic character. At low PTHF content, mostly isolated spherical PTHF domains are present in the continuous PVIm phase, and the swelling of the conetwork in nonpolar solvents is restricted by the non-swollen, rigid hydrophilic matrix. With higher PTHF content the hydrophobic swelling becomes more pronounced, due to the diminished integrity of the glassy phase by the coalesced PTHF domains, shown in Fig. S1.† In this case, the expansion capacity of the PTHF domains is grater in the coherent non-swollen PVIm phase, thus the swelling in THF is more feasible. In a relatively broad composition range, where the bicontinuous phase morphology emerges, both nonpolar and polar swelling occurs with nearly the same ratio. The coexistence of the separately coherent phases allows the interaction with solvents with different polarity, and the swelling is limited only by the PVIm/PTHF ratio in the conetworks. During the swelling, the appropriately swollen phase can change the conformation or even stretch the surrounding non-swollen phase. This forced non-equilibrium state of the solvent non-compatible phase in the cocontinuous APCN is preserved during the swelling, due to the cross-linked structure.24,27,38 With increasing hydrophobic content the swelling tendency reverses. The predominant hydrophobic phase facilitates the swelling in nonpolar solvents, while the smaller and isolated PVIm phases in the coherent PTHF matrix are not able to force the whole conetwork to swell. The arrangement of the PVIm phase in the structure is similar to a nerve system with thin walls among the continuous polymer matrix. For the samples with high cross-linker content and distinct elongated/spherical PVIm domains, the aqueous swelling is negligible, while the hydrophobic swelling reaches enormous ratios (up to ∼1500%) with PTHF content around 91 wt%.
The swelling is not only affected by the morphology that is related to composition, but it seems that molecular weight of the cross-linker influences also the nonpolar swelling of the APCNs. In the case of higher molecular weight cross-linker sample, within the same composition range, the nonpolar swelling is slightly higher. The difference in the swelling is most likely due to the structural differences in the conetwork samples, such as the cross-link density or the spatial gel inhomogeneities (caused e.g. by permanent entanglements, loops, or even dangling/unreacted chain ends). In the case of the low molecular weight cross-linkers, the samples possess higher cross-link density compared to the conetworks formed from longer PTHF cross-linkers, which might restrict the polymer segment mobility.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Supporting table and figures. See DOI: 10.1039/c6ra25356c |
‡ Macromolecular Chemistry and New Polymeric Materials, Zernike Institute for Advanced Materials, University of Groningen, Nijenborgh 4, 9747 AG Groningen, The Netherlands. |
§ Organic Macromolecular Chemistry, Saarland University, Campus C 4.2, 66123 Saarbrücken, Germany. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |