Fan Songad,
Cuiqing Wuad,
Hailong Chen*b,
Qi Liuac,
Jingyuan Liuac,
Rongrong Chencd,
Rumin Liad and
Jun Wangad
aCollege of Material Science and Chemical Engineering, Harbin Engineering University, Harbin 150001, People's Republic of China
bCollege of Shipbuilding Engineering, Harbin Engineering University, Harbin 150001, Heilongjiang, P. R. China. E-mail: Chenhailong2017@163.com
cKey Laboratory of Superlight Material and Surface Technology, Ministry of Education, Harbin Engineering University, Harbin 150001, People's Republic of China
dInstitute of Advanced Marine Materials, Harbin Engineering University, Harbin 150001, People's Republic of China
First published on 14th September 2017
Inspired by lotus leaves and pitcher plants, superhydrophobic surfaces and super slippery surfaces have been fabricated to improve the characteristics of AZ31 magnesium alloy surfaces. Here, a superhydrophobic surface with a hierarchical structure was constructed on a magnesium alloy surface via a one-step, environmentally friendly method, and a slippery liquid-infused porous surface (SLIPS) was obtained by immersing the superhydrophobic surface in perfluoropolyether. Compared with an untreated magnesium alloy and the prepared superhydrophobic coating, the SLIPS coating showed good corrosion resistance in 3.5 wt% NaCl solution according to electrochemical tests. The present study provides more possibilities to extend the application of special wettable surfaces.
However, Mg alloys have some properties that hinder their extensive application: high chemical activity, easy oxidization, poor abrasion performance and poor corrosion resistance.6 It is crucial to confer Mg alloys with high corrosion resistance, and two main approaches have been applied to enhance the corrosion resistance of Mg alloys: using high purity alloys that retain heavy metal impurities below a threshold value; post-processing and surface modification processing.7–9 Surface modification of Mg alloys can be done using chemical conversion films,10 micro-arc oxidation,11 polymer films,12 layer-by-layer self-assembly,13 and layered double hydroxide (LDH) coating.14
Inspired by the unique properties of living beings, researchers have tried to simulate natural materials, especially special wetting interface materials that are superhydrophobic, superhydrophilic, superaerophobic or superaerophilic.15 Due to its liquid-repellent properties, superhydrophobic surfaces have prominent corrosion resistance as well as anti-fouling, anti-icing, friction-reduction, and oil/water-separation properties.16–20 Like the lotus leaf, the superhydrophobic surface has special wettability as the static contact angle for water is >150°.21–23 Studies have shown that water droplets on a solid surface can be classified into two states: Wenzel and Cassie–Baxter.24,25 Because of the roughness of the superhydrophobic surface, the Cassie–Baxter state is a better fit for the superhydrophobic surface.
The “air cushion” principle can protect a metal alloy from corrosion in a corrosive medium. Wang et al.26 proposed a novel one-step potentiostatic electrolysis method to fabricate superhydrophobic films on a copper surface. The superhydrophobic film presented excellent inhibition to copper corrosion and stability in water containing Cl−. Mo et al.27 fabricated a TiO2/fluoromethylhydro-silicone oil composite coating which possessed excellent anti-corrosion performance and exhibited superhydrophobicity. Xiao et al.28 fabricated a superhydrophobic surface via two steps. First, the copper surface was anodized in KOH solution to generate Cu(OH)2 nanoneedle arrays. Second, the surface was grafted with FAS to achieve superhydrophobicity. The superhydrophobicity was found to be stable at pH 1–13 but decreased substantially in 3.5 wt% NaCl solution due to the loss of the hierarchical microstructures in nanoneedle arrays. Although the superhydrophobic surface possesses a corrosion-resistant function, it cannot retain this function under a liquid environment for a long time.
Based on the above-reported faults, increasing numbers of researchers have proposed new types of repellent surfaces: slippery liquid-infused porous surfaces (SLIPS).29,30 Aizenberg and colleagues were the first to study SLIPS, which were inspired by a pitcher plant.31 The entrapped lubricant is immiscible to the water phase and other liquids, so it is not destroyed and the lubricant is stored for a long time.32 In this way, the SLIPS can overcome corrosion resistance under a poor environment for a long time.33 However, most reports had ignored the oil retention of SLIPS and whether the structure of the surface can influence the properties of the super slippery surface. The differences in the results between superhydrophobic surfaces and SLIPS have rarely been studied.
In the present study, we fabricated a superhydrophobic surface on an AZ31 Mg alloy via a single one-step hydrothermal method.34 Then, SLIPS were created by infusing perfluoropolyether (PFPE) onto the superhydrophobic surfaces. A bare Mg alloy was also infused with PFPE to compare it with the SLIPS in terms of corrosion resistance. In addition, the corrosion behaviour of the superhydrophobic surface and SLIPS were studied after different immersion times. The proposed superhydrophobic surfaces may have a considerable effect on the corrosion resistance of metals.
Scheme 1 Preparation of the superhydrophobic film and super slippery surface on the AZ31 magnesium alloy (schematic). |
Fig. 1 Scanning electron micrographs of the surface of the as-prepared superhydrophobic AZ31 at different magnifications (a–c) and the super slippery surface (d). |
Fig. 1d shows that the super slippery surface microstructure was different to the structure of the superhydrophobic surface. SEM shows that the super slippery surface became thickened, the original micro/nano-hierarchical structure was covered with lubricating oil, part of the gap was partially filled, and that injection of lubricating oil did not affect the flower-like composite structure of the whole surface.
The hierarchical micro/nano-scaled structure provided more space to capture the air to achieve superhydrophobicity and store lubricating oil to maintain this lubricating property.
The chemical composition of the as-prepared superhydrophobic surface was measured by FTIR spectroscopy in the frequency range 3500–500 cm−1. Fig. 2 depicts the FTIR spectrum of the treated sample. The peaks at 2920 and 2857 cm−1 corresponded to the asymmetric and symmetric stretching vibrations of –CH2– groups, respectively, in the high-frequency region.37 In the low-frequency region, peaks at 1576 cm−1 and 1467 cm−1 appeared, which was not noted in the original stearic acid, and the carboxyl group (–COO) peak at ≈1701 cm−1 does not appear in Fig. 2. This observation suggested that carboxylate (CH3(CH2)16COO−) was formed on the substrate.
To confirm the infusion of lubricating oil onto the surface, electron-dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) was carried out. Fig. 3 shows the EDS spectra of the superhydrophobic surface (a) and SLIPS (b). The elements C, O, Mg, Mn and S were clearly detected on both sample surfaces. Compared with the superhydrophobic surface, a new element (F) and more C were observed in the SLIPS spectrum. The main component of the lubricating oil PFPE allowed effective irrigation into voids within the superhydrophobic surface.
Fig. 3 EDS of (a) the surface of the as-prepared superhydrophobic AZ31 and (b) super slippery surface. |
cosθ = flscosθ0 − flv |
Fig. 5 Static contact angle of superhydrophobic surfaces (a–c), super slippery surfaces (d–f) and dynamic wettability of the SLIPS after different times (g–i). |
To further investigate the long-term stability of the SLIPS, we tested the dynamic wettability. The video screenshots in Fig. 5g–i show the advancing (θA) CA and receding (θR) CA to be different. The θA and θR CAs were 106° and 103°, 110° and 106° and 110 ± 1° and 106° after air exposure for 1, 3 and 5 days, respectively. Using these results, the CAH was calculated to be 3°, 4°and 4°, respectively. It has been reported that CAH is due to a barrier at the front of the droplet.38 The smaller the CAH, the easier it is for the droplets to roll from the solid surface. We noted that the CAH changed only slightly, a result that was consistent with a static contact angle. From a long-term viewpoint, the super slippery surface could achieve self-repair by repeated infiltration of a lubricating oil surface for the purpose of sustainable recycling.
Fig. 6 Change in contact angle of water droplets with pH values from 1 to 14 on a (a) superhydrophobic surface and (b) super slippery surface. |
The existence of the air layer can be explained by the photographs of the treated surfaces immersed in water (Fig. 7). The submerged region of the superhydrophobic sample looked like a silver mirror when viewed from an oblique angle, which indicated that the air cushion had been trapped on the micro/nanostructure based on the total reflection theory.39 The SLIPS Mg alloy showed no change on the surface irrespective of whether the area was immersed in water or exposed to air. These results further confirmed the notion that air pockets were replaced by lubricating oil (PFPE), which was in good agreement with the SEM image (Fig. 1d).
Fig. 7 (a) Superhydrophobic film sample and (b) super slippery surface specimen immersed in deionized water at a certain slant angle. |
Overall, the superhydrophobic surface and super slippery surface had long-term stability and chemical stability, which can meet the requirements of applications. Indeed, the SLIPS applications are more extensive than those for compounds with a superhydrophobic coating.
Fig. 8 Polarization curves of untreated AZ31, superhydrophobic AZ31 and SLIPS AZ31 in 3.5 wt% NaCl aqueous solution. |
Sample | Time (h) | Ecorr (V/(Ag/AgCl)) | icorr (μA cm−2) |
---|---|---|---|
Bare Mg | 3 | −1.195 | 15.8 |
Superhydrophobic Mg | 3 | −1.176 | 0.219 |
To investigate the corrosion resistance of the samples further, the corrosion behavior of different types of surfaces was studied by EIS in 3.5 wt% NaCl aqueous solution.
Fig. 9 displays the Nyquist diagrams of the bare AZ31 Mg alloy, slippery liquid-infused Mg alloy, the superhydrophobic surface, and the SLIPS immersed in 3.5 wt% NaCl aqueous solution for 6 h, respectively. The diameter of the Nyquist plots of the SLIPS was the largest and had only a capacitive loop in the high-frequency region (Fig. 9a). Many studies have shown that the larger the diameter of Nyquist plots, the lower is the corrosion rate and the better is the corrosion resistance, and that the capacitive loop is related to the charge transfer.40 In addition, there was no diffusion process, which indicated the electrochemical reaction on the SLIPS was only controlled by charge transfer. Thus, among these four types of surfaces, the SLIPS could decrease the corrosion rate the most. Fig. 9b shows that there were two capacitive loops in the high- and low-frequency ranges in the Nyquist plots for the superhydrophobic surface. The diameter of the capacitive loop in the Nyquist plots of the superhydrophobic Mg alloys was larger than that of the bare Mg alloy, suggesting that the superhydrophobic surface could decrease the corrosion rate. The enlarged Nyquist plots of the bare Mg alloy and slippery liquid-infused Mg alloy are shown in Fig. 9c; the diameters of these two surfaces were similar, which consisted of a medium-frequency capacitive loop and a low-frequency inductive loop. The latter demonstrated that the electrolyte was immersed in the surface, and that pitting corrosion occurred on the Mg alloy surface and the corrosive products deposited on the surface.41 In this way, we showed that the Mg alloy could not be protected from corrosion by infusing oil without a rough structure being present.
Fig. 9 Nyquist plots for four types of surfaces immersed in 3.5 wt% NaCl aqueous solution for 6 h (a–c). |
The Bode diagrams were also measured. The low-frequency impedance modulus |Z| value represents the corrosion resistance of the surface. Fig. 10a shows that the impedance values of the bare AZ31 and slippery liquid-infused Mg alloy were similar and much lower than that of the as-prepared superhydrophobic surface and SLIPS. This observation indicates that the corrosion resistance of the bare AZ31 Mg alloy was improved by surface treatment of the superhydrophobic surface and SLIPS. The value of |Z|0.01 Hz decreased from ≈200 Ω cm2 for the untreated AZ31 Mg alloy to 105 Ω cm2 for the superhydrophobic coating after immersion for 6 h. Thus, the |Z| increased by three orders of magnitude. The value of |Z|0.01 Hz of SLIPS was 107 Ω cm2, which was increased by two orders in comparison with the superhydrophobic surface. Similar to other reports,42–44 the values of |Z| in the high-frequency range were evidently different between these four samples. The high-frequency limit of the Bode plots is supposed to represent the electrolyte resistance; the variation at 105 Hz was due to the air layer between the superhydrophobic interface and the solution, which made the electrolyte resistance for the superhydrophobic-coated Mg alloy larger than that for the untreated alloy. Moreover, the variation at 105 Hz was due to the oil layer between the super slippery interface and the solution, which made the electrolyte resistance for the SLIPS larger than for the other alloy samples. Fig. 10b (Bode plots of phase angle vs. frequency) shows one time constant at ≈0.1 Hz and another time constant at ≈100 Hz for the untreated AZ31 Mg alloy. The medium-frequency and low-frequency time constants could be ascribed to the electrolyte solution of the immersed bare Mg alloy surface and charge transfer-controlled process, respectively. The Bode plot of the superhydrophobic-treated sample and super slippery surface-treated sample showed two time constants at ≈10 Hz and ≈1000 Hz, respectively, which was ascribed to the self-capacitance and controlled charge transfer that occurred at the interface between the surfaces and substrates. In addition, the phase angle for the SLIPS and superhydrophobic surface at high and low frequency was higher than that of the bare and slippery liquid-infused Mg alloy, and the shape was distinct. The results stated above were in good agreement with the features of Nyquist plots observed in Fig. 10a.
Fig. 10 Bode plots for four types of surfaces immersed in 3.5 wt% NaCl aqueous solution for 6 h (a) |z| versus frequency, (b) phase angle versus frequency. |
To understand the long-time stability of the superhydrophobic film and SLIPS, EIS tests were conducted after immersion in 3.5 wt% NaCl aqueous solution for different times at room temperature. The results of the superhydrophobic surface and super slippery surface were observed from Nyquist plots and Bode plots in Fig. 11 and 12. The diameters of the capacitive loops of the Nyquist plots and values of |Z|0.01 Hz decreased gradually with increasing immersion time (Fig. 11) due to the decreased thickness of the air layer between the superhydrophobic surface and NaCl solution. The Nyquist plots for superhydrophobic samples immersed for >5 days contained a high-frequency capacitive loop, a medium-frequency capacitive loop, and a low-frequency inductive loop (Fig. 11b). Bode plots of phase angle vs. frequency (Fig. 11 days) showed that there were two time constants for the superhydrophobic surface immersed for <72 h and three time constants for the surface immersed for 5 days to 12 days. The phase angles of the superhydrophobic sample immersed for 5 days to 12 days were <0° in the low-frequency range, indicating pitting corrosion on the surface. However, the charge transfer of the treated surface after immersion in NaCl solution for 12 days remained higher than that of the untreated sample, and the low-frequency modulus remained high. This effect was attributed to the water-repellence that prevented contact between the corrosion liquid and the substrate surface that resulted in corrosion resistance. These results indicated that the superhydrophobic surface could improve the corrosion resistance of the Mg alloy based on a robust micro/nanostructure trapping more air between the corrosion liquid and substrate.
Fig. 12 shows the impedance plots of the SLIPS immersed in 3.5 wt% NaCl aqueous solution at different times. Although the diameters of the Nyquist diagrams and values of |Z|0.01 Hz decreased with increasing immersion time, the speed of decrease was relatively slow and steady. The value of |Z|0.01 Hz of the SLIPS immersed for 30 days remained >105 Ω cm2. The enlarged Nyquist plot (Fig. 12b) showed no inductive loop in the low-frequency range, which meant no pitting corrosion on the SLIPS Mg alloy after immersion for 30 days and the modulus value |Z| remained higher than that of the uncoated and superhydrophobic surface substrates after immersion for 30 days. These results further demonstrated that the liquid lubricants completely covered the surface and prevented surface electron transfer. Based on the results of the characterizations, we showed that the SLIPS possessed good long-term performance and corrosion resistance.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |