Jaime Faria,
Coro Echeverria*,
João P. Borges*,
Maria H. Godinho and
Paula I. P. Soares*
i3N/CENIMAT, Departamento de Ciência dos Materiais, Faculdade de Ciências e Tecnologia, FCT/UNL, 2829-516 Caparica, Portugal. E-mail: coro@fct.unl.pt; jpb@fct.unl.pt; pi.soares@fct.unl.pt
First published on 17th October 2017
The incorporation of thermosensitive microgels that can act as active sites into polymeric fibers through colloidal electrospinning originates multifunctional, highly porous, and biocompatible membranes suitable for biomedical applications. The use of polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP), a biocompatible, water-soluble polymer as a fiber template, not only allows the use of a simple set-up to produce composite membranes, but also avoids the use of organic solvents to prepare such systems. Further crosslinking with ultraviolet (UV) radiation avoids membrane dissolution in physiological conditions. Highly porous, UV crosslinked composite membranes with monodisperse mean fiber diameters around 530 nm were successfully produced. These composite membranes showed a Young Modulus of 22 MPa, and an ultimate tensile strength of 3 MPa, accessed in the mechanical tests. Furthermore, the same composite membranes were able to swell about 30 times their weight after 1 hour in aqueous medium. In this work composite multifunctional membranes were designed and extensively studied. PVP, a biocompatible water-soluble polymer, was used as a fiber template to incorporate thermoresponsive poly-(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAAm)-based microgels into the composite membrane using colloidal electrospinning. The design of multifunctional membranes can be further tailored to several biomedical applications such as temperature-controlled drug delivery systems.
Colloidal or emulsion electrospinning is similar to the traditional electrospinning but uses a colloidal system of two or more immiscible phases as fibre precursor instead of an homogeneous solution.7 Since this technique allows the production of multicomponent nanofibers with controlled morphology using a simple nozzle, colloidal electrospinning comes as a good replacement for co-axial electrospinning, which uses coaxial nozzles for the same purpose.8 Furthermore, this approach is environmentally friendly since it enables the minimization of the amount of organic solvents used during the production process.9
The main advantages that colloidal electrospinning possesses is the different fibre morphologies that can be obtained, regarding dispersed phase placement inside the fibre. Taking this in consideration, there are two main types of morphologies that appear in colloidal electrospinning fibres: ‘bead-on-a-string’10 and ‘core–shell’.11
The incorporation of stimuli-sensitive microgels, which can act as active sites, into polymeric fibres by means of colloidal electrospinning can originate multifunctional fibres with fast thermosensitive behaviour and tuneable surfaces. Díaz et al.12 produced composite fibres of poly-(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAAm)-based microgels using polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) as fibre template, obtaining fibres with a mean diameter of 0.9 μm and a water uptake of 17 times their dry weight. Poly-(ethylene oxide) (PEO) fibres confining PNIPAAm–chitosan (PNIPAAm–Cs) microgels with a mean diameter of 63 nm and bead-on-a-string morphology were also reported.13
PVP is a neutral hydrophilic water-soluble polymer with low toxicity and high biocompatibility with living tissues, capable of binding reversibly to various molecules (dyes, metals and some polymers) in solution.14,15 PVP can easily be crosslinked using ultraviolet (UV) radiation, a cheap and high-energy radiation, thus allowing its application in biological systems without polymer dissolution.15–19
We have previously reported the use of colloidal electrospinning to produce multifunctional membranes with thermosensitive microgels as active sites using PEO, also a water-soluble polymer, as a fibre template.13 Therefore we could not apply such multifunctional membranes in physiological systems because of the risk of polymer/membrane dissolution. In the current work we will use PVP as a fibre template to perform colloidal electrospinning, followed by UV crosslinking to prevent polymer dissolution. During UV irradiation, the pyrrolidone substituents and cyclic amides on the PVP chains generate macroradicals – produced by UV direct photolysis of PVP – whose recombination could lead to intermolecular crosslinking PVP.20 The results of PVP's UV direct photolysis are depicted in Fig. S1.† To achieve such purpose we report the optimization of PVP as a fibre template for the production of composite non-woven mats (or membranes) by confining thermosensitive PNIPAAm microgels in PVP fibres using colloidal electrospinning. UV irradiation was used to crosslink the PVP matrix, thus avoiding its dissolution in physiological conditions, but still maintaining its swelling capability. Both mechanical and swelling properties of the membranes were studied and their behaviour with different UV crosslinking times analysed. The novelty of this work is the development of a production technique that allows tailoring a multifunctional composite system simply by changing the composition/cargo of the confined microgels. The simple and easy-to-use technique here used (colloidal electrospinning) is versatile enough to produce a system on demand for the desired application.
All reagents were used as received without any further purification.
Reagents | wt% monomer | Mass (g) | Volume (mL) |
---|---|---|---|
a Since acrylic acid comes in liquid form and its density is 1.05 g cm−3, upon synthesis of PNIPAAm–AAc microgels the volume of AAc corresponding to 6 and 10 wt% (regarding PVP mass) is 57.1 and 95.2 μL, respectively. | |||
NIPAAm | 100 | 1 | 20 |
MBA | 5 | 0.05 | 20 |
APS | 10 | 0.1 | 20 |
SBS | 5 | 0.05 | 20 |
80 + 20 mL H2O |
Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images were obtained using a Hitachi H-8100 II with thermo-ionic emission LaB6. TEM analysis was performed in a small piece of a membrane placed in a Kevlar 25 mesh grid.
Tensile tests were performed with a tensile testing machine from Rheometric Scientific (Minimat Firmware Version 3.1). PVP and composite membranes were cut into 10 × 5 mm rectangles and mounted onto a pair of clamps and stretched at a speed of 0.1 mm min−1.
Swelling properties of the membranes were performed using 6 rectangular samples (10 × 5 mm) of each sample immersed in water for 0.5, 1, 2, 3 and 5 h. Between each immersion time the water was changed in order to minimize any possible single polymer chains resulting from the dissolution to reattach to the PVP molecule.
Fig. 1 (A) Representative SEM images of electrospinning optimization study; (B) SEM (left) and TEM (right) images of composite membrane produced with the optimized parameters. |
Since the flow rate determines how much solution is available at the tip of the needle for fibre formation, for a given voltage there is a lower limit of flow rate for the Taylor cone to be stabilized.22 If the flow rate is increased above this limit the fibre diameter increases because there is a greater volume of solution at the tip than the one that can be ejected; therefore, MFD increases with the increasing flow rate (Fig. 1A).
When high voltages are applied, the polymer jet suffers a greater stretching due to the greater columbic forces and stronger electric field, which leads to thinner fibres. However, applying lower voltages results in the reduction of the polymer jet's acceleration, which increases its time of flight and consequently its stretching ability.23 In this study the applied voltage did not affect the fibres MFD, in the tested range (Fig. 1A).
A small increase in MFD was observed with the increase of TCD (Fig. 1A). The non-woven mat produced with 12 cm TCD appears to be denser than the 18 cm TCD one. Moreover, TCD of 18 cm originates a wider dispersion of diameters, from 400 nm to 1400 nm. Therefore, the TCD of 12 cm is more appropriate for the desired optimization.
Using the optimized electrospinning parameters, composite membranes were electrospun from a 14 wt% PVP/EtOH solution with 10 wt% of microgels, using a flow rate of 0.7 mL h−1, 15 kV and a TCD of 12 cm. Although 0.7 mL h−1 was not an obtained parameter on the electrospinning optimization study, it is well known that a decrease in flow rate leads to fibres with smaller diameters.24 The decrease in process flow rate from 1 to 0.7 mL h−1 was made in order to bring the fibres' diameter closer to the microgels one.
Using the optimized parameters a composite membrane with MFD of 497 nm was obtained, versus a PVP membrane with 817 nm (Fig. 1B). Several factors could be influencing this decrease: the used flow rate was lower (0.7 mL h−1) which gives the solvent more time to evaporate, resulting in fibres with lower diameter,2 the solution's viscosity could also influence the MDF. To better understand the influence of this parameter, rheological studies were made to the solutions used in the electrospinning and colloidal electrospinning experiments. Both solutions had a fairly similar value of viscosity (3778.7 Pa s for the 14 wt% PVP/EtOH solution and 3023.3 Pa s for the 14 wt% PVP/EtOH with 10 wt% microgels solution), which means that the viscosity is not an influencing parameter in the composite fibres' MFD. Moreover, in the TEM image (Fig. 1B) it is possible to identify a microgel incorporated inside a PVP fibre. The size of the microgel is found to be close to 150 nm. However, as suggested by the dynamic light scattering (DLS) plot (Fig. 1B), the microgel's hydrodynamic diameter (Dh) at 25 °C (temperature used when electrospinning) corresponds to 450 nm. This value of diameter decreases with temperature due to the microgels' collapse. The diameter of the microgels in the collapsed state corresponds to 150 nm which fits with the diameter measured for the microgels observed by TEM. The difference in microgel size observed by TEM compared to DLS could be related to the solvent evaporation process that the membrane suffers: during this process, the solvent evaporates from both membrane and microgel, leading to a possible collapse by the microgel.
Regarding PVP membranes (Fig. 2), there are no great changes in the MFD with the increase of irradiation time, since all membranes have a MFD of approximately 830 nm (Table 2). However, with 60 minutes of UV there are some visible cracks on the fibres' surface, possibly indicating excessive irradiation time, which could be related to an increase of crosslinking degree. The same effect was observed in composite membranes, where no significant differences were found in the MFD, although some cracks were also observed after 60 minutes of UV (Fig. 2 and Table 2).
UV irradiation (min) | PVP MFD (nm) | Composite MFD (nm) |
---|---|---|
5 | 823 ± 50 | 554 ± 64 |
10 | 856 ± 111 | 511 ± 65 |
15 | 833 ± 69 | 579 ± 109 |
20 | 665 ± 49 | 543 ± 69 |
30 | 741 ± 82 | 532 ± 45 |
40 | 871 ± 64 | 509 ± 60 |
60 | 817 ± 46 | 497 ± 78 |
As for PVP membranes (Fig. 3), an equilibrium for the Young's Modulus and UTS is reached after 20 minutes of UV, which means that irradiating the mats for more than 20 minutes does not bring a visible advantage to the system's mechanical properties. Although the mechanical properties do not change, the morphology is in fact affected with the increase of irradiation time (appearance of cracks for 60 minutes of UV). The same mechanical behaviour was observed for composite membranes. As for the influence of the confined microgels, it seems that it is not too evident through the mechanical properties: composite membranes have a ‘maximum’ Young's Modulus of approximately 22 MPa, while PVP membranes round 25 MPa; the same happens for the UTS values (Fig. 3). Once again, this lack of influence may be due to the reduced size of the microgels or to the small load confined inside the PVP fibres.
Fig. 3 Mechanical properties of PVP vs. composite membranes: (A) Young's modulus (E), and (B) ultimate tensile strength (UTS). |
Fig. 4 Swelling behaviour of UV crosslinked PVP vs. composite membranes, and their respective variation of mesh size and crosslinking degree with increasing UV irradiation time. |
From the analysis of the swelling properties it is possible to calculate the network mesh size, which is directly related to the crosslinking degree of the polymer network after UV crosslinking process by the application of the Equilibrium Swelling theory25 by assuming that UV crosslinking gives rise to the formation of a hydrogel. When studying a hydrogel's behaviour in a liquid medium there are three important parameters for the characterization of the network structure: (i) polymer volume fraction in the swollen state (υ2,s), (ii) molecular weight of the polymer chain between two neighbouring crosslinking nodes and (iii) mesh size (ξ). Both and mesh size can only be average values due to the fact that the crosslinking process is completely random.26
These three parameters can be determined using the Equilibrium Swelling theory that states that a crosslinked polymer gel, when immersed in a fluid and allowed to reach equilibrium with its surroundings, is subject only to two opposing forces: the thermodynamic force of mixing and the retractile force of the polymer chains. However, this theory cannot be applied to hydrogels prepared in the presence of water. Peppas and Merrill modified the original Flory–Rehner theory to consider the volume fraction of the chains in the relaxed state (υ2,r), i.e. immediately after crosslinking (eqn (1)):26
(1) |
(2) |
(3) |
Interestingly the composite membranes present a smaller swelling ratio at equilibrium, than the PVP ones (approximately 10 vs. 30, at 30 minutes of UV). This could be explained by the presence of microgels. Theoretically, when a fluid penetrates a network it chooses the path of least resistance cross the network, i.e. a straight line. In composite membranes the addition of microgels creates obstacles (the microgels themselves) that interfere with the normal diffusion of water, forcing it to work around the obstacles. This means that the actual (average) path traversed by the species while diffusing in the interstitial fluid (in our case, water) in a porous medium (composite membranes) is longer than the path traversed in a solid medium (PVP membranes).
The ratio of the actual distance travelled by the species (Δl) per unit length of the medium (Δx) is commonly denominated as tortuosity (τ),29 which is a parameter that strongly influences the diffusion coefficient of a fluid through a membrane. The relation between tortuosity and diffusion coefficient is presented in eqn (4).
(4) |
Another possible explanation for the composite membranes' reduced swelling can be the insufficient crosslinking of the microgels. After the microgels' synthesis, if the percentage of crosslinking agent is insufficient, some unbonded polymer chains remain on the surface of the microgel. When submitting the final composite membrane to UV treatment, those free polymer chains may bond to the PVP during the irradiation process, turning the microgels into anchoring points that hinder the swelling of the composite system.
Although the confinement of microgels did not show a noticeable change in the mechanical properties of the membranes, changes in the swelling properties were evident. To further investigate the influence of the microgels, a higher load should be confined into the fibres, since with a 10 wt% load the microgels are not homogeneously distributed throughout the entire membrane, which could be affecting the properties of the overall membrane.
This work gives a step forward towards the design and development of new and improved smart systems that can be tailored for the desired application, whether it is biomedical or industrial. For instance, one possibility is loading different stimuli-responsive microgels with distinct types of drugs, thus creating a multiresponsive membrane able to prevent different symptoms; another approach would be loading the microgels with anti-corrosion agents to produce a self-healing membrane. The versatility of the used technique, as well as the different components of the proposed composite are what make this system a very interesting and promising topic of research.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c7ra07166c |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |