Hssen Fares*,
Tarcio Castro,
Juliane Resges Orives,
Douglas Faza Franco and
Marcelo Nalin
Institute of Chemistry, São Paulo State University, UNESP, P. O. Box 355, Araraquara, SP 14800-060, Brazil. E-mail: fares.hssen@gmail.com
First published on 15th September 2017
The emission properties of Ag nanoclusters (Ag NCs) dispersed in a transparent fluorophosphate glass host have been studied. The as-prepared glass shows that the Ag NCs emit a broad white emission band almost covering the entire visible region. By changing the excitation wavelength it is possible to tune the emission from blue to yellow. The spectral width of the white light is most likely due to the presence of a variety of Ag NCs with different sizes, particularly emitting in the blue, green and red regions. The possible interaction mechanism between the different Ag species was also elucidated. The observed results provide a new platform to acquire a broad band tunable light source.
Recently, special attention is paid to oxide glassy materials doped with luminescent Ag NCs owing their superior mechanical, structural and optical properties which may give more benefits for photonic applications.15,16 In fact, oxide glass host materials are exceptionally attractive due to their high metal solubility,17 which allows tuning the material optical properties based on the dopants concentration. Most recently, a great progress has been achieved by Tikhomirov et al. that demonstrated that the introduction of CdF2/PbF2 into silicate glass network favors the dispersion of Ag NCs across the whole bulk glass.18–20 It was also demonstrated that the emission of Ag NCs depends to the size and can be tuned from UV, throughout VIS, to near-IR by selection of the proper excitation wavelength. However, the luminescent properties of the Ag NCs depend not only on their size but also on the choice of the host material.15 Since the average size distribution decreases in the medium with high viscosity due to slow diffusion of silver atoms towards nuclei,21 oxyfluoride glasses based on silica, which present a very low viscosity, diminished their potential in photonic applications based in the size distribution of small NCs. Particular properties of fluorophosphate glass such as high viscosity, low glass transition temperature, low melting point, and low optical dispersion, allow this host matrix to be an advantageous over oxyfluoride glass based silica.22,23
In this direction, Ag doped fluorophosphate glasses were prepared by simple single-step melt-quenching route. To the best of our knowledge, rare earth free white light was generated from Ag NCs dispersed in fluorophosphates glass.
Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) investigations were carried out using a Philips CM200 equipment operating at 200 kV and equipped with X-ray energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) Bruker model XFlash 6TI30. Samples were put in an agate mortar and grinded thoroughly. Then, ∼0.1 mg of powder and 10 mL of isopropyl alcohol were placed in a glass vial that was placed in an ultrasonic bath for 15 min to disperse the nanopowder. Some drops of this suspension were applied on a copper grid coated with carbon film. Afterward, the deposited sample on the copper grid was dried in air before TEM analysis.
UV-vis absorption spectra as well as transmission spectra were recorded using a Varian Cary 500 double beam spectrophotometer on the polished samples of 2 mm thickness. Excitation and emission spectra were obtained using Fluorolog (Horiba Jobin Yvon) equipment. Both measurements were obtained from glass pieces. For excitation measurements the emission wavelength was set at 550 nm. Slits were adjusted to lead a resolution of 1 nm for both excitation and emission. All measurements were performed at room temperature and corrected by the instrument response.
Fig. 1 Daylight pictures (a), luminescence images excited by a UV lamp at 254 nm (b) and 365 nm (c) for all prepared glasses. |
The transmission spectra from ultraviolet to near-infrared range of the prepared glasses are presented in Fig. 2(a). As observed, the transparency of Agx glass samples is altered with increasing of Ag doping level. Firstly, the ultraviolet cut-off wavelength is red-shifted from 280 to 345 nm and it is also accompanied by a curvature of the top of transmission edge. Secondly, the maximum transmission in near-infrared range slightly decreases from 87% to 82% with increasing of AgNO3 concentration. The evolution of transmission under different doping condition can also be evident from the pictures in Fig. 2(a). Both effects can be explained by the presence of scattering centers within the glass network, whose concentration, dimensions and/or shape evolve with increasing AgNO3 concentration. This observation is strongly proved from the absorption spectra of the corresponding glasses presented in Fig. 2(b). In fact, a weak absorption peak located at about 415 nm is detected in the Ag7 glass sample with a full width at half maximum of ∼50 nm, which is typically attributes to the presence of SPR of Ag NCs.24,25 In addition, the plasmon absorption band becomes more intense with increasing of AgNO3 concentration. These effects are related to an increase of size of the Ag NCs and/or in the amount of Ag NPs within the glass network. For samples with low (3 mol%) and intermediate (5 mol%) AgNO3 doping, it can be clearly seen that the absorbance spectra do not show any absorption bands in the violet/UV part of the spectra. Similar absorption features were observed in other previous works, where the authors assigned this behavior to the reduced particle size, which is too small (1–2 nm) to generate a SPR absorption band.26–28
The nanostructure properties of the prepared fluorophosphate glasses were analyzed by means of transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and selected area electron diffraction pattern (SAED). TEM, SAED analysis and diameter distribution of prepared samples were carried out for two different concentrations of AgNO3 (5 and 10 mol%). The size distributions of the silver NCs of the samples were obtained by the analysis of ∼250 particles. Fig. 3 shows the TEM micrographs of Ag5 (Fig. 3(a) and (c)) and Ag10 (Fig. 3(b) and (d)) glass samples. The micrographs for Ag doped fluorophosphate glasses shows that spherical particles, visible as dark contrast spots, are evenly dispersed in the glassy matrix with average diameter (AD) of 2.58 and 3.29 nm for Ag5 and Ag10 glass samples, respectively (see histogram in Fig. 3(e and f)). One can see that the Ag particles remain amorphous in the prepared glass samples. In fact, the amorphous character of Ag clusters is evidenced by SAED pattern (Fig. 3(g and h)), which contains only diffuse diffraction rings typical for an amorphous phase.
It should be noted that these tiny particles are spontaneously formed and without any heat treatment. In this sense, a reduction mechanism must be considered which is responsible for the particle formation of the tiny Ag particles during melting. Perhaps the silver reduction could occur due to the electrons extracted directly from defects that are intrinsic to the glass, namely F− vacancies residing within fluorophosphate glasses. In fact, the mechanisms for the formation of Ag NCs within oxyfluoride glass host have been suggested recently. According to Tikhomirov et al.3 the F−centers residing in glass network, where an electron substitutes onto the place of an F−, favors the formation, stabilization and homogeneous dispersion of Ag NCs. In such condition, the electrons released diffuse to occupy the vacant sites such as Ag+ ions. The reduction mechanism resulting in the formation of Ag NCs is described through the following reactions of eqn (1) where a neutral Ag NCs and Ag+ ions intrinsically condense and resulting the formation of other Ag NCs, consisting of a few Ag atoms defined as Agmx+ clusters, such as Ag dimers (Ag2+), Ag trimers (Ag32+) and tetramers (Ag42+).29
(1) |
It should be noted here that the average diameter of the large particles appears to be around 5 (±1) nm. Note that a heat treatment was carried out at 320 °C, which is below the glass transition temperature (385 °C), to remove any residual internal stress induced by the rapid cooling of the glass melt. Thus, the larger particles observed in TEM micrographs (>5 nm) are most likely generated during the sample preparation. In fact, the Ag particles within fluoride network present very high mobility already at 300 °C.3 Thus, the large Ag particles observed are formed during the annealing process due to the high mobility of the Ag particles in the fluorophosphate matrix.
Obviously, a difference in the relative intensity of the two bands is observed (centered at 270 and 360 nm) with the increases of AgNO3 concentration. The band at higher wavelength (360 nm) being more prominent in Ag10 glass samples and shifts to longer wavelength with increases of the AgNO3 concentration. These unique concentration-dependent PLE properties could not be related to glass defect centers, but are strongly pointed to the multiplicity of size/site distribution of Ag NCs as a consequence of the perturbation induced by the rearrangement of the Ag species.32
The normalized emission spectra of the Agx glass samples upon excitation of 360 nm are shown in Fig. 6(a). It is seen in Fig. 6(a) that the Ag NCs emit a broad luminescence band almost covering the visible light region (from 400 to 800 nm). Note that the un-doped glass sample (Ag0) did not show any appreciable emission. Therefore, the luminescence in the prepared glasses is due to Ag particles. A perfect concentration dependent luminescent performance is observed. In fact, increasing the Ag doping level, the emission spectra are shifted to the red at the same excitation wavelength indicating that the average Ag NCs size does increases with the Ag doping. The histograms of the prepared glasses support this point of view (Fig. 3(e and f)). Additionally, the CIE chromaticity diagram for the prepared glasses reported in Fig. 6(b) indicates a different color rendering of the emission from blue (Ag3) to yellow (Ag7 and Ag 10 glass samples) while Ag5 glass sample indicates a white emission as shown in the corresponding photograph in Fig. 1. These results point out an unhomogeneous broadening due to a number of factors, including number of Ag atoms comprising the NCs, different surroundings in the fluorophosphate network, shape and size/site distribution.
Fig. 6 Normalized emission spectra (a) and the CIE chromaticity diagram (b) of prepared samples upon 360 nm excitation. (c) The de-convoluted emission spectra of Ag NCs doped fluorophosphate glasses. |
On closer inspection, the spectra with superimposed broad bands were de-convoluted using a Gaussian distribution as shown in Fig. 6(c). All the emission spectra were fitted to three Gaussians bands peaked at about 420, 535 and 620 nm. These bands can be ascribed to the presence of different types of luminescence centers which will be called further, for simplicity and as proposed in previous work,33 as the blue, green and red Ag NCs. In fact, these luminescent Ag NCs have been argued to be mostly the Agmx+ species with different sizes. A similar result reported that the broad luminescence band is commonly ascribed to small Ag NCs.29
An analysis of these spectra highlights on the mechanism governing the emission of Ag NCs within prepared fluorophosphate glasses. One can see that the green and the red bands become more prominent with increasing Ag concentration at the expense of the blue band which decreases with the increases of Ag doping level, this effect being stronger in Ag10 glass sample. Two mechanisms can explain this effect: variations size/site distribution of Ag NCs and/or an energy transfer occurs between Ag NCs close to each other.
It was previously demonstrated that the radiative transitions originated from outer d-orbitals which means that the luminescence is sensitive to local crystal fields.15 As the silver concentration increases, the number of silver atoms in NCs rises up and then increasing the size of the NCs. Consequently, the crystal field environment of Ag NCs is affected which leads to the change in the intensity as well as the shape of the emission band. According to Tikhomirov et al.3 the short wavelength part of the Ag emission spectra corresponds to the emission by smaller size Ag NCs (called “blue” NCs), while the long wavelength part corresponds to emission by larger size NCs (called “green” and “red” Ag NCs). Hence, the decreases in the blue emission as the silver concentration increases can be explained by the decrease of the amount of smaller size Ag NCs. On the other hand, the increases of green and red emissions are related mostly to the evolution of the amount of larger NCs called here “red” and “green” Ag NCs. As described before, the evolution of the different silver species with the increase in the AgNO3 concentration can be described by a two-step mechanism. The first step consists in the formation of color centers (Ag0 and Ag2+).29 Then, when the concentration of silver is high enough, the amount of color centers is sufficient to allow their clustering in Agmx+ species. As the concentration of silver increases, the reduction rate also increases and results in the enlargement of size and concentration of Ag NCs. This is maybe explaining the increases of “green”/“red” NCs at the expense of the “blue” NCs. Our TEM images support this point of view since the volume fraction of large NCs (>3 nm) increases while the volume fraction of small NCs (<2 nm) decreases with the increases of Ag doping level.
Additionally, Fig. 7(a and b) depicts the normalized excitation and emission spectra respectively of the fluorophosphate glass doped with 7 mol% AgNO3 monitored/excited at different wavelengths. As we can see, a shift of the detection and excitation wavelength from blue to the red results in red shift of the respective excitation and emission spectra in addition to the evolution in the relative intensity of the broad band related to Ag NCs spanning the range from 270 to 400 nm. A similar behavior has been detected in previous work and as explained by M. V. Shestakov et al.34 this unique wavelength-dependent emission and excitation properties is related to the dispersion of Ag NCs with varying surroundings, i.e. with varying an Ag NCs site, and also to the presence of a variety of Ag NCs with different sizes.
Fig. 7 Normalized (a) excitation and (b) emission spectra of the fluorophosphate glass doped with 7 mol% AgNO3 monitored/excited at different wavelengths respectively. |
The second possible factor responsible for this effect is the energy transfer between neighboring Ag NCs. Recently, a model has been achieved by A. S. Kuznetsov et al. in which they demonstrate that energy transfer occurs from the smaller Ag NCs emitting in the blue to either more larger Ag NCs emitting in the green and further in the red, or directly to Ag NCs emitting in the red.19
Combining the TEM results and emission spectra of prepared fluorophosphate glasses, we can conclude that, when the size of “blue” Ag NCs reaches a critical value, they apparently cease to emit and/or they transfer energy to “green” and “red” NCs. Hence, the luminescence properties of Ag NCs are mostly defined by size as well as by the number of Ag NCs within glass network. The relationship between an Ag NCs size and its fluorescence proprieties will be discussed more in the next section.
The normalized emission spectra of the Ag5 sample upon excitation of different wavelengths according to the absorption band in the range of 270–360 nm are shown in Fig. 8(a). As we can see, the position and shape of the emission depend strongly on the excitation wavelength. When the excitation wavelength is shorter than 310 nm, the emission spectra merely exhibits a single band with the maximum shifting from the violet to the blue region, i.e., from 420 to 470 nm. On the other hand, dual mode emission bands in the range of 400–620 nm covering blue and green region gradually emerge with excitation wavelength in the range of 310–330 nm. Excitation at longer wavelength (<340 nm) resulting in a broad luminescence band almost covering the visible light region (from 400 to 800 nm). In fact, there is a strong relationship between an Ag NCs size and its fluorescence excitation wavelengths35 As we can see, the emission maximum was found to shift to longer wavelengths with increasing excitation wavelengths from 270 nm to 360 nm, which confirms a distribution of Ag NCs with different size and this match well with the earlier reported respective spectra of Ag NCs doped oxyfluoride glasses.24,29 A similar shifting with excitation wavelength has been detected in semiconductor quantum dots, and it has been related to the size-selective excitation of the quantum dots,15,36 in other words, the emission properties depend on the Ag NCs size. Thus, this unique wavelength-dependent emission and excitation properties are strongly related to Ag NCs comprising different numbers of Ag atoms, otherwise, related to the presence of a variety of Ag NCs with different sizes and geometry, particularly emitting in the blue, green and red region.3,33
As described before on previous works3 the blue part of the Ag emission spectrum corresponds to the emission by smaller size Ag NCs (called in ref. 33 as “blue” NCs), while the green and red parts correspond to emission by larger size NCs (called in ref. 33 as “green” and “red” NCs). The chromaticity diagram presented in Fig. 8(b) resumes the color rendering tuning obtained from the glass samples for different excitation wavelengths. As it is seen from Fig. 8(c), white color emission with varying tint can be generated under UV excitation (>330 nm). The obtained emission results suggest that sample Ag5 is useful for white light generation in fluorescent lamps and UV LEDs.
To obtain a deeper insight about the mechanism governing the emission of Ag NCs, the microsecond decay curves of Ag5 glass sample at different wavelengths upon 360 nm excitation were recorded. The emission was detected at 420, 550 and 620 nm; the results are presented in Fig. 9. The decay curves are fitted by a double exponential function given by:31
(2) |
Emission at: | τfast (μs) | τslow (μs) |
---|---|---|
420 nm | 11 | 68 |
550 nm | 24 | 114 |
620 nm | 39 | 131 |
As we can see, the slow PL lifetimes of the multi-exponential decay are shorter at blue emission (68 μs) wavelengths than for green and red emissions (114 and 131 μs, respectively). Analogous lifetime dependence was observed for the luminescence decay of Ag NCs doped Y-zeolites37 interpreted using a model involving four-level system: two singlet states and two close thermalized metastable triplet levels. The short lifetime (68 μs) is due to the allowed singlet–singlet transition while the longer lifetimes (114 and 131 μs) are due to the forbidden triplet–singlet transition, as it was explain in previous works.38 Moreover, Hang Lin et al.31 explain the observed distinct lifetimes to the multiplicity of size/site distribution of Ag NCs.
It is far beyond the scope of this contribution to perform a computational methods of quantum chemistry for a more comprehensive mechanism governing the luminescence of Ag NCs, as well as, the reduction mechanism of Ag NCs within the new glass system, however, the results reported herein are still interesting and some general considerations can be drawn from the experimental results, particularly TEM microscopy, luminescence decay curves and the obtained excitation and emission spectra of prepared glasses. Combining all, we can conclude that, emission of blue NCs occurs by fast singlet–singlet transition while the green and red NCs occur by slow triplet–singlet.
The simplified energy level diagram suggested in Fig. 10 illustrates the excitation and emission mechanism in Agmx+ NCs resulting the white light. We follow here the notations proposed by J. J. Velázquez et al.19 According to the authors, only the lowest electronic states contribute on the process of luminescence related to Ag NCs. Here, S0 represent the ground state, S1 is the excited singlet state, while T1 and T2 are the excited triplet states, respectively.19
Fig. 10 Schematic configuration coordinate diagram of Agmx+ NCs is referenced to the paper by Velázquez et al.19 |
When an excitation occurs with UV light, an electron undergoes a transition from the ground state S0 to the excited singlet state S1. As we can see from model involving the four-level, five possible emission transitions can occur around the blue, green, red, infrared and far infrared range of the spectrum originated from S1 → S0, T2 → S0, T1 → S0, S1 → T1 and T2 → T1 transitions, respectively. First, the excitation at shorter-wavelength (between 270 and 330 nm) will transfer the electron to S1 state giving rise to a blue.19 On the other hand, an excitation wavelength near to 360 nm will excite the electron in a low-lying single state of S1, which will rapidly relaxes to triplets excited states via slow triplet–singlet transitions T2 → S0 (green-yellow emission) and T1 → S0 (red emission),19 in addition to the shorter singlet–singlet transition S1 → S0 and then giving rise to a broad emission band almost covering the visible light region (from 400 to 800 nm). The last two transitions S1 → T1 and T2 → T1 are quenched non-radiatively by cross-relaxation energy transfer due to their relatively small energy/quantum resulting in increasing of yellow-red emission band T1 → S0.19
In summary, three basic groups of Ag NCs are responsible for the blue, green and red luminescence. The blue emitting NCs have the smallest size, and the size of NCs increases from the blue to the green and further to the red with the increases of AgNO3 concentration. This follows from the dependence of emission wavelength versus Ag doping level and also from direct structural measurements by transmission electron microscopy. The results of emission spectra dependence on Ag NCs concentrations indicates that the green and the red emissions bands becomes more prominent at the expense of the blue emission band which decrease with the increases of Ag doping level. Therefore, we conclude that when the “blue” Ag NCs reach a critical size, they apparently cease to emit and/or they transfer energy to “green” and “red” NCs.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |