Kun
Ho (Kenny) Park
,
Rui
Chen
and
David Y.-K.
Chen
*
Department of Chemistry, Seoul National University, Gwanak-1 Gwanak-ro, Gwanak-gu, Seoul 151-742, South Korea. E-mail: davidchen@snu.ac.kr
First published on 30th August 2017
Herein we report a rationally designed, serial point-to-axial and axial-to-point stereoinduction and its integration into multi-step and target-oriented organic synthesis. In this proof-of-concept study, the configurational stability of several carefully designed atropisomeric intermediates and the fidelity of their unconventional stereoinductions were systematically investigated. The highly functionalized prepared synthetic intermediate was further applied in a novel chemical method to access the morphinans and it is potentially applicable to other structurally related alkaloids.
In preparation for the proposed studies, it is important to recognize that while a “point” stereochemical element can be readily generated and/or identified, an “axial” stereochemical element is only observable if the system can attain a sufficiently high rotational energy barrier. In line with this requirement, we began our proof-of-concept studies by leveraging the well-established biaryl system as the source of the “axial” stereochemical element (Scheme 1b). Furthermore, the proposed biaryl system harbors additional functional group (FG) handles which allow for the subsequent programmed-stereoinduction events.
Before pressing onto our next objective, namely the “axial-to-point” stereochemical induction, two crucial criteria had to be considered. First, the substrate must exhibit sufficient atropisomeric configurational stability during the axial-to-point stereoinduction event. Second, any preparatory transformations leading to the axial-to-point stereoinduction event must preserve the atropisomeric property within the substrate. In order to assess the configurational stability of the organometallic addition products (5a/5a′–5d/5d′), chromatographically separated and atropisomerically pure biaryl benzylic alcohols were subjected to thermal conditions and their atropisomerization was monitored by 1H NMR analysis (Table 1). Our qualitative analysis revealed that all of the substrates exhibited good configurational stability from low to moderately elevated temperatures (up to 70 °C), with the t-butyl substrates 5c and 5c′ demonstrating extended stability up to 100 °C (for details, see the ESI†).
Compd. | Temp. °C | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
40 | 70 | 90 | 100 | 110 | 120 | |
(1H NMR analysis after 1 h at each temperature up to 110 °C) | ||||||
a Ratio determined by 1H NMR integration. For details, see the ESI.† | ||||||
5a | 1:0 | 1:0.10 | 1:0.43 | 1:0.88 | 0.79:1 | 0.69:1 |
5a′ | 0:1 | 0.07:1 | 0.16:1 | 0.39:1 | 0.60:1 | 0.70:1 |
5b | 1:0 | 1:0.13 | 1:0.43 | 1:0.98 | 0.68:1 | 0.63:1 |
5b′ | 0:1 | 0.06:1 | 0.23:1 | 0.44:1 | 0.58:1 | 0.65:1 |
5c | 1:0 | 1:0 | 1:0 | 1:0.09 | 1:0.35 | 0.53:1 |
5c′ | 0:1 | 0:1 | 0:1 | 0.06:1 | 0.18:1 | 0.52:1 |
5d | 1:0 | 1:0 | 1:0.36 | 0.93:1 | 0.71:1 | 0.71:1 |
5d′ | 0:1 | 0:1 | 0.53:1 | 0.70:1 | 0.70:1 | 0.70:1 |
Next, we envisaged that the proposed axial-to-point stereoinduction would take place via a dearomatization process, in which the dearomatized product or its chemically transformed derivative would possess new “point” stereochemical element(s).9 After contemplating a variety of well-documented dearomatization protocols, hypervalent iodine mediated oxidative dearomatization appeared the most appealing owing to its operational ease, substrate scope and product versatility.10 Accordingly, benzylic alcohols 5a/5a′–5d/5d′ (except 5c/5c′, which remained as benzylic alcohols) were protected as their corresponding TBS ethers to prevent any unwanted side reactions and to enhance their atropisomeric stabilities, followed by treatment with PIFA in the presence of methanol (5d/5d′ in Scheme 3a, for 5a/5a′–5d/5d′ see the ESI†). Much to our surprise, each of the isomerically pure phenols 6d and 6d′ underwent oxidative dearomatization to afford an identical mixture of two dienone products 7d and 7d′ (7d:7d′ ∼ 1:1). The fact that 7d and 7d′ were observed as two distinct diastereoisomers based on our 1H NMR analysis suggested that the epimerization of the biaryl axis must take place during the course of the reaction. However, a postulated transition state (6-PIFA-TS, Scheme 4a), formed through an associative mechanism by invoking a coordinated phenol–aryliodide complex, should increase the rotational energy barrier and thus render higher configurational stability. While seeking a more concrete explanation, we also became aware of a recent report from the Pappo laboratory describing that several optically pure BINOL substrates underwent metal-catalyzed racemization under single-electron-transfer (SET) conditions (Scheme 4b), although the precise mechanistic origin behind this racemization process remained unclear.11 Very recently, NMR and DFT studies reported by the Koltunov group also suggested an acid-mediated atropisomerization of optically pure BINOL via several enone intermediates (e.g.BINOL-H+) that structurally closely resemble those generated during the hypervalent iodine and metal–salt mediated phenol oxidations (Scheme 4c).12
Continuing our studies, several related phenolic biaryl substrates were conceived in order to understand and to preserve the atropisomeric information (Scheme 3b and c). In this context, the phenolic substrates 6e and 6e′ with the phenol and methoxy positions switched compared to those in 6d and 6d′ demonstrated much improved thermal stability, however, when separately treated with PIDA in the presence of methanol, also afforded an identical mixture of dienones 7e and 7e′ (∼1:1). Gratifyingly, phenols 6f and 6f′ with an additional methyl substituent were found to retain their atropisomeric purity upon PIDA-mediated oxidative dearomatization, and the atropisomerically pure dienones 7f and 7f′ faithfully underwent intramolecular Diels–Alder reactions to afford tetracycles 8f and 8f′ in 70% and 61% yield, respectively, with their stereochemical relationship confirmed upon oxidation with PCC. An analogous intramolecular Diels–Alder reaction could also be realized with a 1:1 mixture of dienones 7d and 7d′ to afford a near 1:1 mixture of tetracycles 8 and 8′ (Scheme 3a). Considering that dienones 7d and 7d′ are likely to be configurationally labile at elevated temperatures (see Table 1), this latter result implied that the benzylic OTBS stereocenter offered essentially no stereoinduction during the intramolecular Diels–Alder process. Furthermore, the selective formation of the Diels–Alder product 8f from 7f (and 8f′ from 7f′) strongly suggested that the stereoinduction arose exclusively from the atropisomeric property of 7f (and 7f′) (Scheme 5). In retrospect, the benzylic “point” stereochemical directing element was positioned in proximity to the biaryl-axis for the first “point-to-axial” stereoinduction, while it was distant from the second “axial-to-point” stereoinduction event to suppress its stereo-directing ability. From a design perspective, a single stereo-directing element at each stereochemistry inducing step is synthetically more attractive to avoid any complicated synergistic stereo-directing phenomena.
Scheme 5 Atropisomerism dictated stereoinduction leading to the stereocontrolled formation of Diels–Alder products 8f and 8f′. |
To conclude our studies in remote stereoinductions, we found that substrates 6g and 6h (racemic or optically active) with their OH/OTBS stereocenter relocated in proximity to the intramolecular Diels–Alder transition-state could render a significantly higher level of point-to-point stereoinduction than 6d/6d′ (Scheme 6), an observation that was consistent with our previous synthetic studies towards platencin.13
Scheme 6 Oxidative dearomatization and intramolecular Diels–Alder reaction of biaryl phenols 6g and 6h. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 1526432. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/c7sc03189k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |