Xuzhao Yangab and
Yun Fang*a
aThe Key Laboratory of Synthetic and Biological Colloids, Ministry of Education, School of Chemical and Material Engineering, Jiangnan University, Wuxi 214122, China. E-mail: yunfang@126.com; yangxz@zzuli.edu.cn
bHenan Provincial Key Laboratory of Surface and Interface Science, School of Material and Chemical Engineering, Zhengzhou University of Light Industry, Zhengzhou 450002, China
First published on 23rd July 2018
Ammonium-based room-temperature asymmetrical gemini ionic liquids, 1-trimethylammonium-3-(pyridinium)propane bisdicyanamide ([N111C3Py][DCA]2) and 1-trimethylammonium-3-(1-methylpiperidinium)propane bisdicyanamide ([N111C3MPi][DCA]2) were respectively synthesized and structurally characterized by 1H NMR and 13C NMR. Thermal stability of the gemini ionic liquids was determined by thermogravimetric analysis under a pure nitrogen atmosphere. Densities and viscosities of pure GILs and their binary mixtures with acetonitrile (MeCN) were investigated over the entire range of mole fractions at various temperatures, from 288.15 to 333.15 K, under atmospheric pressure. Moreover, the excess molar volumes (VEm) and the viscosity deviations (Δη) of the binary mixtures were evaluated and well fitted to the Redlich–Kister polynomial expression. The negative values of VEm and Δη result from strong self-association and interaction between the gemini ionic liquid molecules and MeCN. Results are discussed in terms of molecular interactions and structures.
Ionic liquids (ILs) consisting of only anionic and cationic species have been tailored as replacements for organics commonly used in reactions or separations in the academic and industrial fields due to their negligible volatility, non-flammability, thermal stability, wide electrochemical window, wide liquidus range, recyclability, and so on.1–5 Their unique and tunable physicochemical properties such as melting point, density, viscosity, solubility, heat capacity and surface tension mainly depend on the possible cation and anion combinations. Each cation or anion is associated with an equivalent anion or cation that is either hydrophobic or hydrophilic, providing almost infinite opportunities to design desired ILs with functionalities to fit possible chemical processes and physical applications in materials science and technology.6–9 To date, most investigated ILs are still traditional monocationic ILs. Most IL studies focus on synthesis, properties, the relationships between structure and properties, molecular dynamics, and applications.
Recently, other than the monocationic types, a novel category of ILs, namely gemini ILs (GILs), consisting two cationic head groups linked by a rigid or flexible spacer and two anionic moieties, have gained increasing attention due to their superior properties in terms of thermal stability, tunability and volatility.10 The physicochemical properties such as melting point, density, viscosity, solubility, heat capacity, surface tension and solubility behaviors can thus be altered and engineered to a greater extent than the traditional ILs because of the larger number of possible combinations of numerous cationic moieties, anions, and linkages. Therefore, GILs have been proposed to serve as gas chromatography stationary phases,11,12 solvents for high-temperature reactions,13 and novel high-temperature lubricants14 where conventional ILs fail. Some investigations in GILs have explored their specific and/or desired applications in the field of science and technology.
In the past few years, relatively little attention has been paid to GILs because of the much fewer reports compared with monocationic ILs, and the understanding on GILs is thus lacking. Part of the reason may be that GILs still possess some inconveniences and disadvantages. In some instances, GILs display higher melting points and viscosities in comparison with common monocationic analogues with the same anion. Sometimes, they present as solids even beyond 100 °C (ref. 15) and show higher viscosities even at high temperatures, which may result in decreasing rates of mass transfer and increasing pumping costs, thus limiting their real potential applications to the processes requiring higher temperatures. Some experimental and theoretical efforts to design and synthesize novel GILs with lower melting points and viscosities have been made while our work was in progress.16,17 The most common methodology for lowering the melting point of GILs is to change the counteranions, which thus can alter the solvation properties. According to the literature on this subject, incorporating larger bulky or asymmetrical cationic moieties into the structure of GILs can reduce the cohesive forces and depress ion pairing. Meanwhile, GILs with longer alkane linkage tend to have comparatively lower melting points. As for GILs, it has been proven that employing the longer alkyl chains, introducing specified functional groups, or matching the relatively low symmetry, high flexibility, and weakly coordinating anions can decrease the viscosity. The combination of dicyanamide (DCA), bis(trifluoromethane)sulfonamide (NTf2), or trifluoromethanesulfonate (TfO) anion with cations may form lower-viscosity GILs. Meanwhile, GILs possess the same desirable solvation properties and can dissolve various biomass materials. Therefore, another easy approach to decrease the dynamic viscosity at low temperatures and reduce the costs is to mix GILs with less viscous conventional organic co-solvents or other molecular liquids. The viscosities of pure GILs and their mixtures with other less viscous solvents are essential data, and the knowledge is primordial for industrial and academic processes.
When GILs are applied in academic and industrial fields, it is important to determine and understand their physicochemical properties, namely density, viscosity, thermal behavior, and the relationships between these properties and ionic species and structures. A systematic and precise evaluation of physicochemical properties may be equally important in academic research because it is the required beginning of a comprehensive study of GILs and can help us find optimum GILs for real applications. The accumulation of these data and relationships between the properties and structures may be also an essential step to designing and synthesizing desired GILs. Until now, the systematic and accurate knowledge of physical and chemical properties of GILs and their mixtures with molecular co-solvents are still very lacking compared with conventional monocationic ILs.
To our knowledge, GILs containing DCA anion possess lower melting points and dynamic viscosities due to the coordinating ability of this anion.18–20 In the present work, novel unsymmetrical ammonium-based room-temperature GILs, 1-trimethylammonium-3-(pyridinium)propane bisdicyanamide ([N111C3Py][DCA]2) and 1-trimethylammonium-3-(1-methylpiperidinium)propane bisdicyanamide ([N111C3MPi][DCA]2) were synthesized and characterized by 1H NMR and 13C NMR. The thermal stability of these pure dicationic organics, and the density and dynamic viscosity data of pure GILs together with the binary mixture with acetonitrile, were respectively measured over the entire concentration range in the temperature range from 283.15 to 333.15 K, with 5 K intervals, at atmospheric pressure. In addition, the onset decomposition temperature (Tonset) and the temperature at the maximum rate of weight loss (Tmax) were obtained. Meanwhile, thermal expansion coefficients (α) of the binary mixtures were calculated, and the temperature dependence of the viscosity of pure GILs was correlated using various empirical equations. The excess molar volume (VEm) and dynamic viscosity deviations (Δη) of the binary mixtures were respectively obtained and fitted to the Redlich–Kister (R–K) type polynomials to determine the temperature dependence of VEm and Δη. Results are discussed in terms of molecular interactions and structures to give a better understanding of these interactions between GILs and MeCN.
Chemical name | CAS no. | M.W. | Mass fraction purity | Source |
---|---|---|---|---|
Pyridine | 110-86-1 | 79.10 | >99.9% | Aladdin Industrial Inc., China |
1-Methylpiperidine | 626-67-5 | 99.17 | 97.0% | Aladdin Industrial Inc., China |
(3-Bromopropyl)trimethylammonium bromide | 3779-42-8 | 261.00 | >99.0% | Aladdin Industrial Inc., China |
Methanol | 67-56-1 | 32.04 | >99.9% | Aladdin Industrial Inc., China |
Ethanol | 64-17-5 | 46.07 | >99.5% | Aladdin Industrial Inc., China |
Sodium dicyanamide | 1934-75-4 | 89.03 | >96.0% | Aladdin Industrial Inc., China |
Silver nitrate | 7761-88-8 | 169.87 | >99.0% | Aladdin Industrial Inc., China |
Ethyl acetate | 141-78-6 | 88.11 | >99.5% | Aladdin Industrial Inc., China |
The structures were identified using 1H NMR and 13C NMR (Bruker AVANCE III 600 MHz Digital NMR Spectrometer). The NMR analysis is presented below.
Solutions containing GIL ([N111C3Py][DCA]2, [N111C3MPi][DCA]2) were prepared gravimetrically using an analytical balance with a precision of ±0.1 mg (type AR224CN, Ohaus) in mass fraction by magnetic stirring. The mixtures were degassed using an ultrasonic bath to remove ubiquitous oxygen. No decomposition was observed at the experimental conditions.
Fig. 1 TG-DTG curves of the synthesized GILs: solid line, [N111C3Py][DCA]2; dashed line, [N111C3MPi][DCA]2. |
GIL | Tonset/K | Tmax/K |
---|---|---|
[N111C3Py][DCA]2 | 523.12 | 537.89 |
[N111C3MPi][DCA]2 | 514.91 | 525.58 |
x1 | ρ/(g cm−3) | VEm/(cm3 mol−1) | η/(mPa s) | Δη/(mPa s) |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Uncertainties are u(T) = 0.01 K, u(p) = 200 Pa, u(x) = 0.00001, u(ρ) = 1 × 10−5 g cm−3, u(η) = 1 × 10−4 mPa s, u(VEm) = 1 × 10−5 cm3 mol−1, u(Δη) = 1 × 10−4 mPa s. | ||||
283.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.79283 | 0.00000 | 0.4012 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.94085 | −0.97370 | 4.1446 | −751.1908 |
0.1999 | 1.02068 | −1.71560 | 14.1880 | −1496.8373 |
0.2998 | 1.07022 | −2.34740 | 52.8431 | −2213.1164 |
0.3997 | 1.09874 | −2.28366 | 131.4302 | −2889.4636 |
0.4999 | 1.11754 | −1.94751 | 245.2401 | −3532.8549 |
0.6002 | 1.13081 | −1.46086 | 473.5503 | −4062.5019 |
0.7001 | 1.14132 | −1.00940 | 856.9804 | −4434.0060 |
0.7998 | 1.15001 | −0.61026 | 1384.9022 | −4659.5089 |
0.8997 | 1.15759 | −0.30151 | 2374.5011 | −4424.8430 |
1.0000 | 1.16399 | 0.00000 | 7557.3000 | 0.0000 |
288.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.78748 | 0.00000 | 0.3819 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.93710 | −1.06971 | 3.7453 | −384.1405 |
0.1999 | 1.01708 | −1.80523 | 12.2943 | −763.4836 |
0.2998 | 1.06687 | −2.44250 | 42.1502 | −1121.1315 |
0.3997 | 1.09560 | −2.38204 | 97.8751 | −1452.9104 |
0.4999 | 1.11432 | −2.01322 | 174.6311 | −1764.8230 |
0.6002 | 1.12773 | −1.52525 | 321.0604 | −2007.4485 |
0.7001 | 1.13827 | −1.05804 | 553.7802 | −2162.2324 |
0.7998 | 1.14706 | −0.65821 | 848.1505 | −2254.5906 |
0.8997 | 1.15467 | −0.33773 | 1335.8011 | −2154.4445 |
1.0000 | 1.16099 | 0.00000 | 3879.3002 | 0.0000 |
293.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.78210 | 0.00000 | 0.3641 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.93325 | −1.16161 | 3.4486 | −215.7600 |
0.1999 | 1.01350 | −1.89961 | 10.7510 | −427.5212 |
0.2998 | 1.06356 | −2.54413 | 34.4992 | −622.6177 |
0.3997 | 1.09248 | −2.48435 | 75.8173 | −800.1442 |
0.4999 | 1.11123 | −2.09777 | 129.0504 | −966.4130 |
0.6002 | 1.12467 | −1.59225 | 226.4001 | −1088.7837 |
0.7001 | 1.13523 | −1.10687 | 371.2505 | −1162.7783 |
0.7998 | 1.14414 | −0.70962 | 561.9012 | −1190.5347 |
0.8997 | 1.15171 | −0.36192 | 850.2906 | −1120.9892 |
1.0000 | 1.15801 | 0.00000 | 2191.0021 | 0.0000 |
298.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.77670 | 0.00000 | 0.3479 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.92940 | −1.25684 | 3.2052 | −127.5774 |
0.1999 | 1.00993 | −1.99789 | 9.5451 | −251.8027 |
0.2998 | 1.06026 | −2.64942 | 28.7061 | −363.0764 |
0.3997 | 1.08939 | −2.59250 | 59.8222 | −462.3951 |
0.4999 | 1.10809 | −2.17645 | 98.1055 | −554.9384 |
0.6002 | 1.12162 | −1.66146 | 165.5803 | −618.4203 |
0.7001 | 1.13217 | −1.15193 | 263.8207 | −650.6149 |
0.7998 | 1.14119 | −0.75440 | 381.8602 | −662.7485 |
0.8997 | 1.14879 | −0.39323 | 561.3303 | −613.7131 |
1.0000 | 1.15504 | 0.00000 | 1306.0011 | 0.0000 |
303.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.77127 | 0.00000 | 0.3332 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.92546 | −1.34827 | 3.0028 | −80.2941 |
0.1999 | 1.00637 | −2.09932 | 8.5509 | −157.7926 |
0.2998 | 1.05698 | −2.75793 | 24.3252 | −224.9822 |
0.3997 | 1.08623 | −2.69155 | 48.2821 | −283.9888 |
0.4999 | 1.10500 | −2.26048 | 76.3252 | −339.1586 |
0.6002 | 1.11858 | −1.72897 | 125.0205 | −373.7594 |
0.7001 | 1.12918 | −1.20477 | 192.4303 | −389.3130 |
0.7998 | 1.13819 | −0.78296 | 271.0104 | −393.5306 |
0.8997 | 1.14587 | −0.41680 | 392.0407 | −355.4642 |
1.0000 | 1.15211 | 0.00000 | 830.8034 | 0.0000 |
308.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.76581 | 0.00000 | 0.3196 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.92152 | −1.44331 | 2.8266 | −53.1763 |
0.1999 | 1.00283 | −2.20547 | 7.7113 | −104.0307 |
0.2998 | 1.05372 | −2.87052 | 20.9521 | −146.4733 |
0.3997 | 1.08309 | −2.79382 | 39.6003 | −183.5086 |
0.4999 | 1.10198 | −2.35408 | 61.2755 | −217.6841 |
0.6002 | 1.11555 | −1.79623 | 96.7161 | −238.1493 |
0.7001 | 1.12619 | −1.25443 | 145.6202 | −244.9286 |
0.7998 | 1.13521 | −0.81098 | 200.1906 | −245.9304 |
0.8997 | 1.14295 | −0.43465 | 286.2104 | −215.5937 |
1.0000 | 1.14921 | 0.00000 | 557.7103 | 0.0000 |
313.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.76032 | 0.00000 | 0.3071 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.91759 | −1.54292 | 2.6723 | −36.1615 |
0.1999 | 0.99930 | −2.31554 | 7.0336 | −70.3655 |
0.2998 | 1.05048 | −2.98730 | 18.1521 | −97.7738 |
0.3997 | 1.07997 | −2.89941 | 33.2670 | −121.1856 |
0.4999 | 1.09893 | −2.44284 | 50.0027 | −143.0950 |
0.6002 | 1.11256 | −1.86821 | 76.5772 | −155.1990 |
0.7001 | 1.12321 | −1.30274 | 108.6508 | −161.6527 |
0.7998 | 1.13227 | −0.84251 | 145.4805 | −163.2723 |
0.8997 | 1.14008 | −0.45767 | 212.6704 | −134.6090 |
1.0000 | 1.14634 | 0.00000 | 385.9631 | 0.0000 |
318.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.75479 | 0.00000 | 0.2956 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.91375 | −1.65443 | 2.5404 | −25.7686 |
0.1999 | 0.99579 | −2.43121 | 6.4291 | −49.9213 |
0.2998 | 1.04725 | −3.10782 | 16.0410 | −68.3228 |
0.3997 | 1.07673 | −2.99083 | 28.2121 | −84.1652 |
0.4999 | 1.09596 | −2.54328 | 43.4605 | −97.0147 |
0.6002 | 1.10959 | −1.94200 | 63.8640 | −104.7363 |
0.7001 | 1.12025 | −1.35176 | 89.6683 | −106.9457 |
0.7998 | 1.12934 | −0.87169 | 117.5001 | −107.0710 |
0.8997 | 1.13719 | −0.47058 | 161.4022 | −91.1844 |
1.0000 | 1.14350 | 0.00000 | 280.7116 | 0.0000 |
323.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.74922 | 0.00000 | 0.2849 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.90992 | −1.77188 | 2.4252 | −18.8302 |
0.1999 | 0.99229 | −2.55219 | 5.9133 | −36.3336 |
0.2998 | 1.04405 | −3.23519 | 14.1380 | −49.0794 |
0.3997 | 1.07349 | −3.08442 | 24.1920 | −59.9960 |
0.4999 | 1.09306 | −2.65537 | 36.7422 | −68.4794 |
0.6002 | 1.10664 | −2.01914 | 51.7495 | −74.5269 |
0.7001 | 1.11738 | −1.41618 | 70.9492 | −76.2975 |
0.7998 | 1.12642 | −0.90043 | 91.6491 | −76.5260 |
0.8997 | 1.13441 | −0.50423 | 122.6207 | −66.5255 |
1.0000 | 1.14068 | 0.00000 | 210.2033 | 0.0000 |
328.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.74362 | 0.00000 | 0.2750 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.90539 | −1.83606 | 2.3240 | −14.0743 |
0.1999 | 0.98889 | −2.68735 | 5.4676 | −27.0702 |
0.2998 | 1.04085 | −3.36644 | 12.5480 | −36.1132 |
0.3997 | 1.07043 | −3.20431 | 20.9750 | −43.8096 |
0.4999 | 1.09015 | −2.76831 | 30.6054 | −50.3513 |
0.6002 | 1.10372 | −2.10255 | 43.2911 | −53.8533 |
0.7001 | 1.11448 | −1.47543 | 57.6375 | −55.6306 |
0.7998 | 1.12358 | −0.94486 | 73.2282 | −56.1307 |
0.8997 | 1.13161 | −0.53208 | 95.5920 | −49.8901 |
1.0000 | 1.13787 | 0.00000 | 161.6706 | 0.0000 |
333.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.73797 | 0.00000 | 0.2658 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.90166 | −1.97249 | 2.2332 | −10.6614 |
0.1999 | 0.98531 | −2.81029 | 5.0838 | −20.4522 |
0.2998 | 1.03768 | −3.50545 | 11.2140 | −26.9508 |
0.3997 | 1.06739 | −3.32996 | 18.3542 | −32.4395 |
0.4999 | 1.08721 | −2.87872 | 27.6141 | −35.8462 |
0.6002 | 1.10082 | −2.18985 | 37.5872 | −38.5526 |
0.7001 | 1.11166 | −1.54878 | 48.5280 | −40.2404 |
0.7998 | 1.12080 | −0.99949 | 60.3110 | −41.0609 |
0.8997 | 1.12887 | −0.56992 | 75.3011 | −38.6997 |
1.0000 | 1.13508 | 0.00000 | 126.6806 | 0.0000 |
x1 | ρ/(g cm−3) | VEm/(cm3 mol−1) | η/(mPa s) | Δη/(mPa s) |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Uncertainties are u(T) = 0.01 K, u(p) = 200 Pa, u(x) = 0.00001, u(ρ) = 1 × 10−5 g cm−3, u(η) = 1 × 10−4 mPa s, u(VEm) = 1 × 10−5 cm3 mol−1, u(Δη) = 1 × 10−4 mPa s. | ||||
283.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.79283 | 0.00000 | ||
0.0999 | 0.93640 | −1.36085 | ||
0.2001 | 1.00377 | −1.88498 | ||
0.3001 | 1.04175 | −2.05646 | ||
0.3998 | 1.06511 | −1.94636 | ||
0.5002 | 1.08154 | −1.77557 | ||
0.6000 | 1.09299 | −1.46325 | ||
0.7001 | 1.10148 | −1.06328 | ||
0.7996 | 1.10806 | −0.62985 | ||
0.8998 | 1.11386 | −0.28797 | ||
1.0000 | 1.11889 | 0.00000 | ||
288.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.78748 | 0.00000 | 0.3819 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.93241 | −1.43318 | 3.9949 | −750.8835 |
0.2001 | 1.00031 | −1.97687 | 17.4160 | −1494.2247 |
0.3001 | 1.03856 | −2.15309 | 56.9202 | −2209.9725 |
0.3998 | 1.06199 | −2.02840 | 145.5904 | −2874.2886 |
0.5002 | 1.07843 | −1.83548 | 334.0607 | −3444.0914 |
0.6000 | 1.09009 | −1.53694 | 678.7513 | −3853.1427 |
0.7001 | 1.09859 | −1.11845 | 1177.0028 | −4110.8998 |
0.7996 | 1.10511 | −0.65109 | 2304.7011 | −3734.6754 |
0.8998 | 1.11098 | −0.30499 | 3991.5051 | −2804.6377 |
1.0000 | 1.11602 | 0.00000 | 7552.9043 | 0.0000 |
293.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.78210 | 0.00000 | 0.3641 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.92841 | −1.50767 | 3.6867 | −446.4707 |
0.2001 | 0.99685 | −2.07101 | 15.1392 | −886.1625 |
0.3001 | 1.03541 | −2.25572 | 45.9441 | −1305.6011 |
0.3998 | 1.05881 | −2.10191 | 111.5906 | −1688.8479 |
0.5002 | 1.07538 | −1.90356 | 243.4312 | −2009.0525 |
0.6000 | 1.08720 | −1.60992 | 465.9624 | −2235.8656 |
0.7001 | 1.09568 | −1.16562 | 729.2211 | −2423.2995 |
0.7996 | 1.10223 | −0.68268 | 1390.0052 | −2210.5118 |
0.8998 | 1.10812 | −0.32027 | 2477.2033 | −1574.4559 |
1.0000 | 1.11318 | 0.00000 | 4502.8071 | 0.0000 |
298.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.77670 | 0.00000 | 0.3479 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.92442 | −1.58546 | 3.4196 | −278.5217 |
0.2001 | 0.99341 | −2.16899 | 13.1605 | −551.2202 |
0.3001 | 1.03221 | −2.35320 | 37.6911 | −808.5644 |
0.3998 | 1.05574 | −2.19039 | 87.2882 | −1039.9970 |
0.5002 | 1.07235 | −1.97315 | 181.4506 | −1228.8377 |
0.6000 | 1.08428 | −1.67459 | 322.0602 | −1369.5392 |
0.7001 | 1.09278 | −1.21064 | 508.0509 | −1465.7063 |
0.7996 | 1.09939 | −0.71785 | 895.2501 | −1358.9721 |
0.8998 | 1.10527 | −0.33124 | 1609.8034 | −926.8610 |
1.0000 | 1.11037 | 0.00000 | 2819.1027 | 0.0000 |
303.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.77127 | 0.00000 | 0.3332 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.92044 | −1.66754 | 3.1755 | −180.6008 |
0.2001 | 0.98998 | −2.27102 | 11.6030 | −356.1672 |
0.3001 | 1.02904 | −2.45647 | 31.3811 | −520.0159 |
0.3998 | 1.05280 | −2.29851 | 69.5380 | −664.9347 |
0.5002 | 1.06938 | −2.05255 | 139.0803 | −779.7539 |
0.6000 | 1.08142 | −1.74937 | 245.8206 | −856.2733 |
0.7001 | 1.08992 | −1.26180 | 370.0421 | −915.8636 |
0.7996 | 1.09651 | −0.74075 | 623.1633 | −845.4521 |
0.8998 | 1.10246 | −0.34783 | 1084.9006 | −567.7061 |
1.0000 | 1.10758 | 0.00000 | 1836.6025 | 0.0000 |
308.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.76581 | 0.00000 | 0.3196 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.91646 | −1.75299 | 2.9790 | −119.5863 |
0.2001 | 0.98657 | −2.37770 | 10.3162 | −234.8621 |
0.3001 | 1.02588 | −2.56245 | 26.5041 | −341.0421 |
0.3998 | 1.04978 | −2.39555 | 56.5374 | −433.0100 |
0.5002 | 1.06643 | −2.13406 | 109.3102 | −503.0946 |
0.6000 | 1.07851 | −1.81241 | 185.3313 | −549.1979 |
0.7001 | 1.08708 | −1.31317 | 274.3805 | −582.6383 |
0.7996 | 1.09376 | −0.78797 | 449.3407 | −529.4345 |
0.8998 | 1.09966 | −0.36017 | 759.8422 | −341.5472 |
1.0000 | 1.10482 | 0.00000 | 1224.0039 | 0.0000 |
313.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.76032 | 0.00000 | 0.3071 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.91247 | −1.84135 | 2.8089 | −82.9919 |
0.2001 | 0.98316 | −2.48769 | 9.2371 | −162.3142 |
0.3001 | 1.02274 | −2.67330 | 22.7451 | −234.3855 |
0.3998 | 1.04678 | −2.49684 | 46.5810 | −295.8721 |
0.5002 | 1.06356 | −2.22902 | 86.9782 | −341.3967 |
0.6000 | 1.07563 | −1.88014 | 145.1305 | −368.6528 |
0.7001 | 1.08427 | −1.36878 | 210.1421 | −389.3077 |
0.7996 | 1.09097 | −0.82296 | 328.5107 | −356.0891 |
0.8998 | 1.09690 | −0.37822 | 544.5711 | −225.7796 |
1.0000 | 1.10208 | 0.00000 | 856.1032 | 0.0000 |
318.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.75479 | 0.00000 | 0.2956 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.90850 | −1.93568 | 2.6754 | −59.3758 |
0.2001 | 0.97977 | −2.60323 | 8.2623 | −115.7300 |
0.3001 | 1.01962 | −2.78885 | 19.6420 | −166.1677 |
0.3998 | 1.04379 | −2.60040 | 39.2504 | −208.1917 |
0.5002 | 1.06058 | −2.30515 | 70.3852 | −239.1214 |
0.6000 | 1.07287 | −1.96819 | 113.8913 | −257.3102 |
0.7001 | 1.08149 | −1.42703 | 163.4606 | −269.6195 |
0.7996 | 1.08823 | −0.86432 | 246.2922 | −248.2978 |
0.8998 | 1.09416 | −0.39463 | 399.5903 | −156.9389 |
1.0000 | 1.09937 | 0.00000 | 618.4704 | 0.0000 |
323.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.74922 | 0.00000 | 0.2849 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.90452 | −2.03419 | 2.5387 | −43.6837 |
0.2001 | 0.97640 | −2.72562 | 7.4884 | −84.8095 |
0.3001 | 1.01646 | −2.90347 | 17.3140 | −120.9674 |
0.3998 | 1.04088 | −2.71874 | 33.3481 | −150.7790 |
0.5002 | 1.05761 | −2.38500 | 58.1723 | −172.1224 |
0.6000 | 1.07003 | −2.04255 | 91.7744 | −184.4120 |
0.7001 | 1.07871 | −1.48556 | 129.8503 | −192.3654 |
0.7996 | 1.08553 | −0.91428 | 192.9417 | −175.0290 |
0.8998 | 1.09146 | −0.41944 | 302.8822 | −111.1645 |
1.0000 | 1.09667 | 0.00000 | 460.1203 | 0.0000 |
328.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.74362 | 0.00000 | 0.2750 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.90054 | −2.13668 | 2.4270 | −32.8145 |
0.2001 | 0.97303 | −2.85127 | 6.8167 | −63.4963 |
0.3001 | 1.01333 | −3.02380 | 15.3720 | −89.9425 |
0.3998 | 1.03789 | −2.82613 | 28.6281 | −111.5830 |
0.5002 | 1.05465 | −2.46556 | 48.6852 | −126.6675 |
0.6000 | 1.06705 | −2.08804 | 74.3203 | −135.9640 |
0.7001 | 1.07595 | −1.54452 | 104.9515 | −140.3705 |
0.7996 | 1.08290 | −0.97541 | 151.8803 | −128.2670 |
0.8998 | 1.08877 | −0.44005 | 233.0924 | −82.1285 |
1.0000 | 1.09400 | 0.00000 | 350.2906 | 0.0000 |
333.15 K | ||||
0.0000 | 0.73797 | 0.00000 | 0.2658 | 0.0000 |
0.0999 | 0.89656 | −2.24440 | 2.3198 | −24.8435 |
0.2001 | 0.96968 | −2.98310 | 6.1635 | −47.9780 |
0.3001 | 1.01025 | −3.15277 | 13.6690 | −67.3970 |
0.3998 | 1.03496 | −2.94283 | 24.7680 | −83.1416 |
0.5002 | 1.05162 | −2.53274 | 41.5710 | −93.3707 |
0.6000 | 1.06408 | −2.13177 | 62.2790 | −99.5333 |
0.7001 | 1.07321 | −1.60246 | 85.5210 | −103.2427 |
0.7996 | 1.08030 | −1.03658 | 122.0300 | −93.5235 |
0.8998 | 1.08610 | −0.45662 | 182.9900 | −59.5417 |
1.0000 | 1.09137 | 0.00000 | 269.5100 | 0.0000 |
For pure GILs, the order of the experimental density is [N111C3Py][DCA]2 > [N111C3MPi][DCA]2. [N111C3Py][DCA]2 has higher density value, while [N111C3MPi][DCA]2 possesses lower density over the experimental temperature range. The higher value for [N111C3Py][DCA]2, which contains the [Py]+ cation, is due to the smaller molecular size of the cation compared with the [MPi]+ cation. The densities of GILs increase with the decrease of cation molecular weight and are higher than those of the monocationic analogues reported in the literatures.28,29 The density for [C3Py][DCA] at 298.15 K is 1.08980 g cm−3, lower than that of [N111C3Py][DCA]2 (1.15504 g cm−3), which may be due to the stronger inter-ionic interactions of the GILs than those of the traditional monocationic ILs.9 With the increasing temperature, densities of pure GILs were observed to linearly decrease (see Fig. S1 in ESI†) due to the decrease in the van der Waals forces, which consequently increases the mobility of the ions.30 Molecules are farther apart from each other at higher temperatures, causing the decrease in density.
The density values of binary mixtures containing MeCN as a function of the mole fraction of GIL (x1) at various temperatures (283.15 to 333.15) K are listed in Tables 3 and 4. As expected, the densities of binary mixtures linearly decrease with increasing temperature, while they increase with decreasing MeCN content. A linear model was consequently employed to correlate the experimental densities and temperature.31 Volume expansion properties of GILs and their mixtures may be a prerequisite for understanding their stability in applications, especially those under higher temperature. In the present study, density changes linearly with the temperature change; the value of thermal expansion coefficient (α), a measure of how the volume changes with temperature, can be further quantified from the density data by the following expression:32,33
(1) |
To attain a deeper understanding of the interaction between GIL and the organic solvent, the excess molar volume (VEm), expressing the extent of deviation of mixtures from ideal behavior, of the binary systems ([N111C3Py][DCA]2 + MeCN and [N111C3MPi][DCA]2 + MeCN) were respectively calculated from the experimental density data of the mixtures based on the following expression:34,35
(2) |
The experimental excess molar volumes can be mathematically represented by the Redlich–Kister polynomial equation:36,37
(3) |
(4) |
Fig. 2 and 3 show that the variation VEm, as a function of mole fraction of the GIL (x1), is negative over the entire range of composition, suggesting negative deviations from ideal solution behavior. It is more interesting that the VEm in every GIL + MeCN system has minimum values at around x1 ≈ 0.3 for all temperatures investigated, which indicates the strongest interaction. The values of VEm for the system consisting of GILs and relatively polar solvents may mainly depend on the following factors: (1) the dipole–dipole, ion–dipole, and ion–ion interactions between components of the binary mixtures;21 (2) contraction or molecular packing as a consequence of differences in size and shape of molecules (free volume difference of unlike molecules);21 (3) expansion due to the disruption of self-association in the GIL or solvent; (4) contraction owing to specific interaction between the GIL and MeCN; and (5) variation in intermolecular forces between the GIL and solvent molecules that are in contact. This behavior, negative VEm, can be interpreted in several opposing ways. Interactions between like molecules give rise to positive VEm values, while interactions between unlike molecules such as dipole–dipole interaction, dispersion force, or hydrogen bonding lead to negative contributions to VEm.23 As seen in Fig. 2 and 3, the negative values of VEm for the mixtures over the entire investigated range of GIL mole composition and in all analyzed temperatures indicate stronger interactions between GIL and MeCN molecules than those between the pure components. The interactions between unlike molecules, [N111C3Py][DCA]2, MeCN and [N111C3MPi][DCA]2, MeCN, are stronger than those between MeCN molecules, and negative VEm values are observed with the following sequence: [N111C3MPi][DCA]2 > [N111C3Py][DCA]2. GILs can be solvated by MeCN molecules because of a strong ion–dipole interaction, resulting in weakening ion–ion interactions between anions ([DCA]−) and cations in the GILs.18,38 The packing efficiency of MeCN accommodation in the interstice of GIL networks, the difference in the interaction, and hydrogen bonding may be dominant in these binary systems. Meanwhile, the interstitial accommodation and the effect of the condensation of GIL and MeCN make further negative contributions to VEm. In fact, unsymmetrical curves of VEm may be more likely to occur while the components of the binary mixture have large molecular weight and size differences. It is observed that the curves of VEm are asymmetric, indicating a large molar volume difference between the two components (GIL and MeCN) of the binary mixtures.
It can be observed that values of excess molar volume for binary systems of [N111C3Py][DCA]2 + MeCN and [N111C3MPi][DCA]2 + MeCN decrease and become more negative with increased temperature, indicating volume expansion. The variation in VEm with temperature is attributed to the competition of packing efficiency and the hydrogen bonding interaction in the binary mixture. In general, as the temperature increases, the packing efficiency strengthens, leading to decrease of VEm value.39 In the present binary mixtures of [N111C3Py][DCA]2 + MeCN and [N111C3MPi][DCA]2 + MeCN, the variation of VEm with temperature indicates that packing efficiency may play a dominant functional role in the change in value of VEm.
The sequence for the experimental viscosities of the two pure GILs is [N111C3MPi][DCA]2 > [N111C3Py][DCA]2. Among the obtained GILs, the viscosity of [N111C3MPi][DCA]2 is remarkably larger than [N111C3Py][DCA]2. The viscosity may be affected by the cation's aromaticity; the aromatic compounds possess lower viscosity values than the non-aromatic ones: [Py]+ < [MPi]+. The viscosity will be greatly affected by the cation's inherent interactions related to the GIL structure and bulk distribution. The π–π interactions in pyridinium GIL were expected to provide higher resistance to shear stress due to a more rigid IL structure and bulk distribution; the results, however, showed the opposite, with lower viscosity for the pyridinium GIL, since the π–π interactions will also lend a more rigid ring structure and induce a more organized bulk distribution compared with the more flexible piperidinium ring, resulting in a relatively flexible structure and a greater entanglement of the rings in the liquid phase.40 The viscosities of GILs are higher than those of the monocationic analogues reported in the literature.18,41 The viscosity of the pure GILs decreases sharply at low temperature when the temperature is increased, while it decreases smoothly at high temperature (see Fig. S2 in ESI†), making the temperature-dependent viscosity of GILs challenging.
The temperature dependence of the viscosity of pure GIL ([N111C3Py][DCA]2 or [N111C3MPi] [DCA]2) can be expressed in the following equations. A common method is by employing the three-parameter Vogel–Tammann–Fulcher (VTF) equation and modified VTF (mVTF) equation:42
(5) |
(6) |
Meanwhile, other expressions, the inverse cubic equation (Litovitz equation)43 and simple linear equation (Ghatee equation)44 can also be used to correlate the viscosity of pure GILs with the temperature:
(7) |
(8) |
The equation parameters, together with correlation coefficients (R2), can be evaluated (see Table S5 in ESI†). The results indicate that both VTF and mVTF equations can quite accurately correlate the viscosity of pure GILs with temperature. The higher accuracy of the VTF and mVTF equations may be due to the larger number of parameters in the equations.
From Tables 3 and 4, it can be observed that the values of dynamic viscosity of the binary systems decreased with the addition of MeCN, as expected. The addition of common organics with higher relative permittivity (e.g. MeCN) may increase the ion solvation (weakening ion–ion interactions) and result in significantly reduced viscosity of the mixture. Deviation of the viscosity, Δη, can be calculated from the viscosity data of the mixtures and pure components based on the following equation:23
Δη = η − (x1η1 + x2η2), | (9) |
The viscosity of a mixture strongly relies on the liquid's structure. Thus, Δη depends on molecular interactions as well as the size and shape of the molecules. Accordingly, the viscosity deviation of a mixture containing a molecular solvent and an ionic species is the competition of molecular size and molecular interaction (H-bonds, van der Waals interactions).46 The viscosity deviations are negative, provided that the mixture is dominated by intermolecular forces between the solute and the solvent (the van der Waals interactions). On the contrary, the viscosity deviations are positive when the mixture is dominated by strong specific interactions (H-bonds).47 Furthermore, the negative values of Δη for the binary mixtures may also imply that the viscosities of associations formed between unlike molecules are relatively greater than those of the like ones. Negative values of Δη may also occur for the binary mixtures in which dispersion forces are dominant, particularly for the mixtures containing different molecular sizes.48,49 In the present investigation, the negative values of Δη showed that the interaction between cation and anion became weak owing to the solvation interaction between ions (cation and anion) and MeCN molecules. Based on the viscosity deviations shown in Fig. 4 and 5, the negative deviations can be attributed to strong van der Waals interactions and dispersion forces, and weak hydrogen bonding interaction between the molecules of GIL ([N111C3Py][DCA]2, [N111C3MPi][DCA]2) and MeCN.
Viscosity deviation can also be fitted to the Redlich–Kister equation:48
(10) |
(11) |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c8ra04127j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2018 |