Pengtao
Jing‡
a,
Dong
Han‡
a,
Di
Li
a,
Ding
Zhou
a,
Dezhen
Shen
a,
Guanjun
Xiao
*b,
Bo
Zou
b and
Songnan
Qu
*a
aState Key Laboratory of Luminescence and Applications, Changchun Institute of Optics, Fine Mechanics and Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, 3888 Eastern South Lake Road, Changchun 130033, China. E-mail: qusn@ciomp.ac.cn
bState Key Laboratory of Superhard Materials, College of Physics, Jilin University, Changchun 130012, China. E-mail: xguanjun@jlu.edu.cn
First published on 20th September 2018
There has been a long standing debate on the luminescence origination from carbon nanodots (CDs). Herein, we report the solvent dependent piezochromism of CDs by diamond anvil cells experiment. Red- and blue-shift piezochromism were observed in CDs with N,N-dimethylformamide and water as pressure transmitting medium (PTM) with increasing pressure from atmospheric pressure to 25 GPa, which were related to increased π–π stacking and protic-solvent-induced surface chemical structural changes, respectively. Based on theoretical modeling and structural analysis of hydrothermally treated CDs (h-CDs), the reversible and irreversible piezochromism from green emission to blue emission with water as PTM was attributed to pressure induced enhanced intermolecular hydrogen bonding and addition reaction between water molecules and surface electron withdrawing groups on the CDs, respectively. The decreased electron withdrawing ability of the surface chemical structures of CDs further affects their intrinsic luminescence. This work provides a new understanding of the piezochromic luminescence origination from CDs, which is related to the surface related intrinsic luminescence.
Conceptual insightsThe in situ optical characterization under high pressure is a straightforward and efficient method to study the structural and electronic properties of luminescent materials. Generally, solvent acts as pressure transmitting medium (PTM) in diamond anvil cells (DAC) experiment. Previous literatures have reported that solvents modulate PL properties of carbon dots (CDs) under atmospheric pressure. It is still a challenge to produce the high pressure and solvent induced surface structural changes of CDs to understand their luminescence origination. We reported solvent dependent piezochromism of CDs using DAC experiment. We observed red- and blue-shift piezochromism in CDs with aprotic and protic solvents as PTM with increasing pressure from atmospheric pressure to 25 GPa, respectively. The irreversible blue-shift piezochromism in protic solvent (water or ethanol) was attributed to the high pressure induced addition reaction between solvent molecules and surface electron withdrawing groups on the CDs. In contrast, the reversible red-shift piezochromism in aprotic solvent (N,N-dimethylformamide) provided evidence of enhanced π–π stacking in the inner core of CDs. We anticipate that this work will benefit the fundamental understanding of the luminescence origination from CDs and tuning their intrinsic luminescence to promote their applications in bio-imaging, lasing materials, and light emitting diodes. |
The application of high pressure can be a straightforward and efficient way to study the structural and electronic properties of CDs. The transition from sp2 bonded graphite to sp3 bonded diamond under high-pressure and high-temperature conditions has been studied for over 50 years.24,25 Very recently, piezochromic luminescence was reported in two literatures. At high pressure of 22.84 GPa, blue-shift piezochromism of PL emission from yellow to green was observed in a CDs ethanol solution.26 The authors proposed that the color change in the luminescence of the yellow emissive CDs is attributed to the structure transition from sp2 domains to sp3 hybridized domains under high pressure. In another study, pressure-triggered blue- and red-shifted PL were observed in a type of CDs, which were attributed to the decrease of surface carbonyl groups and enhanced π–π stacking, respectively.27 The tunable piezochromic luminescence indicated that the PL from CDs was not only related to the sp2 structure domain but also affected by the surface chemical environments.28–31 Surface groups of CDs, such as pyridinic N and carbonyl O, have been demonstrated to play an important role in the PL from CDs.29,31 Previous literatures have shown that solvents modulated PL properties of CDs under atmospheric pressure.28,29,32 Therefore, optical properties of CDs under high pressure in different solvents could shine light on understanding the relation of surface chemical structures and optical properties of CDs. To the best of our knowledge, solvent dependent piezochromism has not been investigated in CDs. It is still a challenge to produce the high pressure and solvent induced surface structural changes of CDs to understand their related optical changes.
Herein, in situ optical properties of microwave synthesized CDs under high pressure with water and N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) as pressure transmitting medium (PTM) were investigated by the diamond anvil cells (DAC) experiment. Red-shift piezochromism was observed in CDs with water or DMF as PTM with increasing pressure from 0 GPa to 1.8 GPa. Blue-shift piezochromism from green emission to blue emission was only observed in CDs with water as PTM with increasing pressure from 1.8 GPa to 25 GPa, which can be partially recovered with pressure relaxation to 0 GPa. In contrast, recoverable and red-shift piezochromism was observed in CDs with DMF as PTM with increasing pressure from 1.8 GPa to 25 GPa. Furthermore, similar unrecoverable blue emission after high pressure relaxation in water as PTM was obtained from the CDs by hydrothermal treatment (h-CDs). Based on theoretical modeling and structural analysis of h-CDs, the high pressure induced reversible and irreversible blue-shift piezochromism from green emission to blue emission with water as PTM was attributed to pressure induced enhanced intermolecular hydrogen bonding and addition reaction between water molecules and surface electron withdrawing groups on the CDs, respectively. This decreased the electron withdrawing ability of the surface chemical structures of CDs, and further affected their intrinsic luminescence.
Considering the solvents dependent PL properties, a DAC experiment was used to investigate the optical properties of the CDs under high pressure with water or DMF as PTM. The experimental setup is shown in Fig. S3 in ESI.† The piezochromism from green to blue was clearly observed in images of CDs in water from 0 GPa to 25 GPa, while green emission was observed in DMF even in 25 GPa (Fig. 1a and b). The PL spectra evolution of CDs in water under different pressures is shown in Fig. 1c. The PL peak of CDs in water firstly red-shifted from 540 nm to 550 nm with increasing pressure from atmospheric pressure to 1.8 GPa, and then blue-shifted to 470 nm upon further compression to 25 GPa (Fig. 1e). The red-shifted PL from atmospheric pressure to 1.8 GPa can be attributed to the increasing π–π stacking.25,34,35 The PL peak instantaneously changes from 555 nm to 535 nm at 1.8 GPa. To exclude the influence of phase transition from liquid to solid,36 PL spectra of CDs in water (room temperature) and ice (0 °C) were measured and it showed similar PL peak (Fig. S4, ESI†). Thus, the blue-shift piezochromism of CDs at 1.8 GPa is not related to phase transition of H2O, but the PL intensity quenching of CDs at 1.8 GPa may be related to the decreased transparency of solid H2O under high pressure with small bubbles like that in ice. In previous literature, the origin of blue-shift piezochromism of CDs from yellow emission to blue–green emission with increasing pressure from atmospheric pressure to 23 GPa was attributed to the structural transitions from sp2 domains to sp3 hybridized domains.24 However, the PL peak of CDs in DMF continuously red-shifted from 530 nm to 545 nm with increasing pressure from atmospheric pressure to 25 GPa (Fig. 1d and e), indicating pressure induced structural transitions from sp2 domains to sp3 hybridized domains did not take place in this case. The continuous red-shift piezochromism of CDs in DMF should be due to enhanced π–π stacking of the inner core under high pressure.27,37,38 Thus, it can be inferred that the blue-shift piezochromism of CDs in water is not due to the structural transition from sp2 C to sp3 C, but may be related to the solvent dependent pressure induced surface chemical changes, which further affect their intrinsic luminescence. The normalized emission intensity of CDs in water and DMF with increasing pressure is shown in Fig. 1f. The PL intensity of CDs in water shows two quenching steps, from 100% to 8% and from 8% to 2% for pressure increasing from 0 GPa to 1.8 GPa and further to 25 GPa, respectively. In contrast, the PL intensity of CDs in DMF continuously decreases to 10% with pressure increasing from atmospheric pressure to 25 GPa. Pressure dependent PL spectra of CDs in ethanol as PTM were also measured in the DAC experiment. It showed PL emission blue-shift from 530 nm to 440 nm with increasing pressure from atmospheric pressure to 24 GPa (Fig. S5, ESI†). It is noted that the blue-shift piezochromism is related to protic solvents, such as water and ethanol.
The pressure dependent absorption spectra measurements of CDs were also carried out to investigate their optical transitions in different PTM solvents (Fig. 2a and b). The main absorption peak of CDs in water experienced red-shift from 410 nm to 420 nm with increasing pressure from atmospheric pressure to 1.8 GPa (Fig. 2c), which agrees with increased π–π stacking under high pressure.27,37,38 However, this main absorption peak is instantly decreased and changed from 420 nm to 440 nm. On further increasing the pressure to 25 GPa, this absorption peak continually decreased and red-shifted to 450 nm, while the absorption peak at 320 nm was significantly increased (Fig. 2d), which was related to the optical transition of blue-shifted emission centers. In contrast, the main absorption peak of CDs in DMF continuously red-shifted from 419 nm to 435 nm with increasing pressure from atmospheric pressure to 25 GPa without immediate change of the absorption band (Fig. 2c). The intensity of the absorption peak of CDs in DMF at 320 nm was slightly increased with increasing pressure to 25 GPa (Fig. 2d), which was because of the small blue emission component under high pressure. Considering the π–π stacking related pressure induced optical changes, it can be inferred that the green emission should be from the π-conjugated domains in the inner cores, which can be the intrinsic state of the CDs. After high pressure relaxation, the PL of CDs in water was partially recovered (Fig. 3a). The residual blue emissive band, about 11% of the total PL band (Fig. S6a, ESI†), indicated chemical reaction happened between some CDs and water molecules under high pressure. In contrast, the PL profile of CDs in DMF was totally recovered after high pressure relaxation (Fig. 3b), indicating that the similar chemical reaction cannot happen between CDs and DMF molecules under 25 GPa. Considering water is a protic solvent and DMF is an aprotic solvent, it can be inferred that the reaction sites should be on the electron withdrawing groups on the surface of CDs, which can bond with hydroxyl group in water molecules or chemically react with water molecules. Thermally treated DAC experiment was used to investigate the acceleration of high temperature on the chemical reactions between CDs and water molecules. Pressure dependent PL spectra of CDs with high temperature (80 °C, 353 K) treatment are shown in Fig. 3c. PL spectra after high pressure relaxation under high temperature shows unrecovered PL spectrum and more residual blue emissive band (77%) (Fig. 3d and Fig. S6b, ESI†). The PL intensity of CDs in water with thermally treated DAC experiment shows a two step quenching process, which is similar to that in water under room temperature. The PL peak of CDs shows obvious blue-shift from 530 nm to 420 nm with increasing pressure from atmospheric pressure to 6 GPa, resulting from the chemical reaction between CDs and water molecules. Then, the PL peak of CDs red-shifted from 420 nm to 440 nm with increasing pressure from 6 GPa to 22 GPa, related to the increased π–π stacking of blue emitted products (Fig. S7, ESI†). These results indicate that the high temperature treatment in DAC experiment accelerates the chemical reaction between CDs and water molecules.
To well understand the chemical reactions between water and CDs under high pressure, the CDs were further processed by hydrothermal treating at 160 °C (433 K) to promote the chemical reaction. The hydrothermally treated CDs were named as h-CDs. In the absorption spectrum of h-CDs in water, the absorption band at 420 nm significantly decreased, while the absorption band at 320 nm significantly increased (Fig. 4a), which is similar to the absorption spectrum of the CDs in water at 25 GPa in DAC experiment. Fig. 4c and d show the 3D fluorescence excitation–emission maps of CDs and h-CDs aqueous solutions. It can be seen that the PL peak changed from green (530 nm) in CDs to blue (450 nm) in h-CDs, which is also consistent with the PL changes of the CDs in water from 0 GPa to 25 GPa. The PL decay curves of CDs and h-CDs are shown in Fig. 4b. The average PL lifetimes of CDs and h-CDs in water are 6.5 ns and 7.8 ns, respectively (Table S1, ESI†). These irreversible optical changes of CDs after high pressure and hydrothermal treatment in water imply that the intrinsic green emission of CDs can be affected by the surface chemical changes.
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) was performed to identify the surface chemical structures of CDs and h-CDs. XPS spectra of CDs and h-CD show three peaks at 284.0, 400.0, and 530.6 eV in Fig. 4e which are attributed to C 1s, N 1s, and O 1s, respectively.13,16 The ratios of N atoms and C atoms in CDs and h-CDs from XPS results are similar (about 1:5), but the ratio of O atoms and C atoms in h-CDs is much higher than that in CDs. In high-resolution C 1s spectra of CDs and h-CDs four peaks at 284.5, 285.8, 286.7, and 288.5 eV were observed in Fig. 4f, which are attributed to sp2 C, C–N, C–O, and CN/CO, respectively. The relative content of sp2 C was decreased after hydrothermal treatment probably because the water molecules reacted with surface carbon–carbon double bonds. The high-resolution N 1s spectra of CDs and h-CDs showed three peaks at 399.8, 400.3, and 401.9 eV (Fig. 4g), which are attributed to pyridine-like N (C–N–C), quaternary graphite-like N (N–(C)3) and N–H bands, respectively. It can be seen that the content of N–H in h-CDs is higher than that in CDs, whereas the content of pyridine N in h-CD is lower, indicating that some portion of pyridine N in CDs transferred to N–H after hydrothermal treatment. The high-resolution O 1s spectra of CDs and h-CDs show two peaks at 533.0 and 531.5 eV (Fig. 4h), which are attributed to C–OH/C–O–C and CO groups, respectively. It can be seen that the content of C–OH/C–O–C in h-CDs is higher than that in CDs. Based on the XPS results, it can be concluded that h-CDs consist of less sp2 C and more hydroxyl- and N–H groups than CDs, indicating that water molecules react with some carbon–carbon double bonds, carbonyl O and pyridine N on the surfaces of CDs through addition reaction in the hydrothermal process, which could be the reason for the portion of the unrecoverable blue emission of the CDs after high pressure relaxation (25 GPa). Considering the electron withdrawing property of carbonyl and pyridine groups, which can be hydrogen bond acceptor sites, it can be inferred that enhanced hydrogen bonding could take place between water molecules and carbonyl/pyridine groups on the surface of CDs under high static pressure conditions (25 GPa). This hydrogen bonding can be weakened after high pressure relaxation. We propose that the high pressure induced enhanced hydrogen bonding between the electron withdrawing groups and water molecules might account for the recovered blue emission for the CDs under high pressure.
To demonstrate our hypothesis, first-principles calculations based on the density functional theory (DFT) were carried out. For XPS analysis, the proposed simplified model is a monolayer graphene plate consisting of 19 aromatic rings with two (–N–(CO)–N–) fragments at the edge of the graphene plate. In Fig. 5a, two water molecules were put close to the carbonyl groups of the model to simulate the optical band-gap of the CDs for enhanced hydrogen bonding with water molecules under high pressure (Status 1). After structure relaxation, the distance between the water molecules and graphene plate is increased, simulating the optical band-gap of the CDs in water under atmospheric pressure (Status 2). The lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) levels of the model in Status 1 and 2 are similar, indicating that the delocalized π* orbital of graphene-like structure is insensitive to the surface chemical environment. The highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) of the model in Status 1 also delocalize in whole graphene-like domain, while the HOMO of the model in Status 2 is distributed around carbonyl groups. It can be inferred that enhanced hydrogen bonding in Status 1 can weaken the electron withdrawing property of the carbonyl groups on the edge of the model. Under high pressure or hydrothermal treatment, some CO groups react with water molecules and change to C–OH groups, inducing the unrecoverable change of PL spectra. In Fig. 5b, the band-gap of the model increases from 1.27 eV (Status 2) to 1.39 eV (Status 1). The band-gap of the model with one water molecule was also calculated and showed the same trend before and after structural relaxation (Fig. S8, ESI†). The simulated increased band-gap can be used to explain the blue-shift piezochromism of CDs in water under high pressure from 1.8 GPa to 25 GPa. Thus, it can be inferred that the surface chemical structural changes can affect the intrinsic emission of CDs.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c8nh00258d |
‡ P. Jing, and D. Han contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |