Rahul Kesarwani,
Partha P. Dey and
Alika Khare*
Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati, Guwahati, India. E-mail: alika@iitg.ac.in
First published on 12th March 2019
The surface scaling behavior of nanostructured Cu thin films, grown on glass substrates by the pulsed laser deposition technique, as a function of the deposition time has been studied using height–height correlation function analysis from atomic force microscopy (AFM) images. The scaling exponents α, β, 1/z and γ of the films were determined from AFM images. The local roughness exponent, α, was found to be ∼0.86 in the early stage of growth of Cu films deposited for 10 minutes while it increased to 0.95 with a longer time of deposition of 20 minutes and beyond this, it was nearly constant. Interface width w (rms roughness) scales with depositing time (t) as ∼ tβ, with the value of the growth exponent, β, of 1.07 ± 0.11 and lateral correlation length ξ following ξ = t1/z and the value of 1/z = 0.70 ± 0.10. These exponent values convey that the growth dynamics of PLD Cu films can be best described by a combination of local and non-local models under a shadowing mechanism and under highly sticking substrate conditions. From the scaling exponents and power spectral density function, it is concluded that the films follow a mound like growth mechanism which becomes prominent at longer deposition times. All the Cu films exhibited SPR properties where the SPR peak shifts towards red with increasing correlation length (ξ) whereas bandwidth increases initially with ξ and thereafter decreases gradually with ξ.
The XRD spectra of Cu metallic thin films deposited on the glass substrate for various deposition time from 6 to 45 minutes are shown in Fig. 1. The XRD peaks observed at 43.33° and 50.29° correspond to the Cu (111) and Cu (220) planes, respectively with former being more intense.30 Fig. 1 clearly shows the increase in the intensity of both the peaks with the deposition time which is due to the increase in thickness thus facilitating the participation of larger number of diffracting planes. The crystallite size was estimated from the FWHM of the most intense peak of (111) plane by Debye–Scherrer's formula.31 The inset in Fig. 1 shows the nearly linear increase in the size of Cu crystallites from 3.2 nm to 30.3 nm with increasing deposition time from 6 to 45 min respectively.
Fig. 1 XRD spectra of PLD Cu thin films deposited on glass substrate (SiO2) for deposition time, t, from 6 to 45 min. Inset shows variation of crystallite size with t. |
The surface morphology of the films was characterized by AFM to unveil the surface microstructures and the growth dynamics of the films.29 Fig. 2(a)–(f) shows the AFM images of all the films for the deposition time of 6, 8, 10, 20, 30 and 45 min, respectively. The initial visualization of AFM micrographs indicates the uniform distribution of grains over the film surface. Initially, for the lower deposition time, the grains were observed to be of spherical in shape. With increasing deposition time or growth time, the repeated impinging of particle flux from incoming laser induced plasma towards the substrate, the nucleation sites increased followed by coalescence of smaller size grains to form bigger particles along with the formation of columnar structure. Eventually, at 30 and 45 minutes duration, relatively large sized and densely packed grains were formed as is evident from Fig. 2(e) and (f) respectively. To unveil the growth process and the dynamic scaling behaviour, the scaling exponents; root mean square (RMS) roughness or interface width (w) and local slope (m) of the islands had been calculated from AFM images. These quantities were obtained from HHCF, H(r, t). It is defined by the statistical average of the mean square of height difference between the pair of points, separated by r and is written as:29
H(r, t) = 〈|h(r + r′, t) − h(r′, t)|2〉 | (1) |
Fig. 2 AFM images of PLD Cu films for the deposition time of (a) 6 minutes, (b) 8 minutes, (c) 10 minutes, (d) 20 minutes, (e) 30 minutes and (f) 45 minutes. |
The HHCF, can also be defined by exponential correlation model, which satisfies the requirement for self-affine surface and manifests anisotropic scale invariance, given by29
(2) |
For r ≪ ξ, from eqn (2)
(3) |
(4) |
The log–log plot of H(r, t) as measured from AFM images, as a function of distance ‘r’ along with curve fitted to eqn (2) for all the films deposited for various interval of time (t) is shown in Fig. 3. The measured value fits well to eqn (2) (R2 > 0.97). The HHCF can be clearly divided into two distinct regions of r ≪ ξ and r ≫ ξ. For longer deposition time of 20–45 minutes, an oscillatory behavior was observed for r ≫ ξ indicating the formation of the mounded surface.29 It is clear from Fig. 3 that the value of H(r, t) increases as Cu film thickness increases (with increasing growth time), indicating the increase in the RMS roughness. From the best fitting of experimental HHCF curves using eqn (2), w, ξ as well as α were estimated for each film. The variation of w, ξ and α as a function of deposition time on the log–log scale is shown in Fig. 4 (a), (b) and (c) respectively. Fig. 4(a) shows the increase in the value of w from 0.65 to 7.48 nm for the films grown from 6 to 45 minutes respectively further confirming the increase in roughness of the film with the increasing growth time ‘t’.
Fig. 3 log–log plot of HHCF, H(r, t) as a function of distance r and fitted to eqn (2) for Cu thin films on glass substrate for deposition times of 6–45 minutes along with bare substrate. |
Fig. 4 Variation in (a) surface roughness w, (b) correlation length ξ, and (c) roughness exponent α with the deposition duration, t. |
The increasing nature of ξ with t, as shown in Fig. 4(b), indicates the lateral growth of the islands. The lateral growth could be attributed to the increased in crystallite size (XRD results, Fig. 1) with increasing deposition time. The parameters w and ξ showed power law dependence as w ∼ tβ and ξ ∼ t1/z respectively having values of β = 1.07 ± 0.11 and z = 1.42 ± 0.21. There is a slight decrease in value of α from 0.88 for 6 minutes deposited film to 0.86 for that of 10 minutes and beyond this it increases to 0.95 for 20 minutes and thereafter the changes are insignificant. This affirms that local roughness decreases while the RMS roughness (defined by w) increases from 0.65 to 7.48 nm with increasing film thickness from ∼35 to 280 nm. In order to quantify the dynamics of the roughness, ξ versus w for all the samples were plotted (on log–log scale) and shown in Fig. 5(a). The relation between w and ξ can be worked out as w ∼ ξγ, where the value of exponent, γ, was found to be 1.50 ± 0.54 comparable to that obtained from the values of β and 1/z. The value of γ can predict the competition between lateral and vertical growth.
The observed value of γ > 1 indicates the faster vertical growth compared to lateral growth and is also related to the roughness of the film surface. In order to identify the mode of the growth, local slope as a function of deposition time was plotted and as shown in Fig. 5(b). The dependence of m on time indicates the non-stationary growth in the present case. The upward shift of the H(r) with deposition time, Fig. 3, further signifies the non-stationary growth of the film.25,29
In the case of PLD, the particle flux from laser produced plasma impinging on the substrate is of diverging nature having non-uniform distribution of particles thus the growth process is dominated by shadowing effect. Another unique feature of this technique is the large kinetic energy of the particles striking the substrate, and so the deposition can be performed at relatively low substrate temperature with minimal re-emission.32 Thus growth model best suited for the PLD is of that of proposed by Drotar et al. in which the surface under shadowing (roughening effect) and zeroth-order sticking coefficient corresponding to minimal reemission (s0 = 1 and sn = 0 for n > 0) are considered. It is described by stochastic continuum growth equation,33
(5) |
The first term on the right-hand side (v∇2h) represents the evaporation dynamics where surface relaxation is achieved by annealing mechanism, the second term (k∇4h) accounts for smoothening by surface diffusion due to the curvature-induced chemical potential gradient, in the third term F0 contains information about the shadowing effect, as well as the nature of the incoming particle flux given by where θ is the local polar angle, Φ is the local azimuthal angle and R(θ, Φ) is the distribution of the incoming flux and is the unit vector normal to the substrate. The factor in the third term represents growth normal to the local surface and the last term in eqn (5), η (r, t), is the noise in the system. The value of β and 1/z via Monte Carlo simulations in 2 + 1 dimensions from the eqn (5) was reported to be 1 and 0.93 ± 0.1 respectively.33 These values are in close proximity to that of obtained in the present case for HHCF analysis. In the PLD process, the impinging particles from laser produced plasma plume on the substrate, arrive within the angular range of 0° to ±θ1/2(∼cos−1(1/2)p),34 where θ1/2 is the angle between normal to the target surface and the direction where flux density becomes half of maximum and p varies from 7–20 depending on laser spot size on the target, laser fluence and degree of ionization of plasma.32,34 In the present work, on Cu target the laser spot size was of ∼1 mm diameter and laser fluence ∼ 4 J cm−2, the corresponding value of p ∼ 7–8 giving θ1/2–22–23°.34 The glass substrate used has a melting point of around 550 °C and deposition temperature was kept at 400 °C, close to the softening temperature, which could have resulted in a very high sticking coefficient, s0 ∼ 1. These deposition conditions favouring large shadowing and high sticking coefficient for substrate satisfy the requirement for the surface growth model given by eqn (5).33 Under the dynamic scaling, Δ = β/α − 1/z = 0, but in the present case, Δ = 0.37 indicates the presence of anomalous scaling behavior and the surface is not self-affine. This is understandable as the growth of the film in PLD is under strong influence of shadowing and thus dynamic scaling no longer holds.35 Interestingly, the calculated exponents (α, β, 1/z) are quite close to the exponents predicted by the model of mound formation.33,36 The oscillating behavior of the HHCF in the region where r ≫ ξ, Fig. 3, also indicates the formation of mounded surface, particularly for thicker films (deposited for duration, t = 20, 30 and 45 minutes).
The power spectral density function (PSDF), given by 29 for these films is exhibited in Fig. 6. It displays P(k) versus k plot extracted from the respective AFM images of Cu films deposited on glass substrates for duration of 6, 8, 10, 20, 30 and 45 minutes. The PSDF shows a characteristics peak, km = 2π/λ (λ = wavelength) for mounded surface and is absent for self-affine surface.29 The characteristic peak was absent in the PSDF spectra of the films deposited for 6 to 10 minutes duration, Fig. 6(a)–(c), indicating self-affine film surface. The PSDF of the films deposited for duration longer than 10 minutes show characteristics peak depicting mound formation. With increasing time, the peak feature of mounded surface becomes more prominent and km (∼1/ξ) reduces indicating increase in average separation between the islands. Inset in Fig. 6 shows corresponding 2D fast Fourier transform (FFT) images. It clearly shows a bright ring like structure in k-space for films deposited for longer times, 30 and 45 minutes, further supporting the mound growth.28 From above observation it is clear that the growth of the Cu film initially, for the shorter duration of deposition is predominantly self-affine surface but as deposition progresses film surface becomes mounded with the well-defined characteristic wavelength. The formation of mounds on any surface are basically due to different growth effects such as step-edge barrier, diffusion effect, shadowing, and re-emission, and which could be local or non-local in nature. In the present case, the non-local phenomena of strong shadowing owing to the directional nature of PLD along with high sticking condition of substrate (the deposition performed at glass softening temperature) favours mound formation in Cu films.
Metal nanoparticles (NPs) having plasmonic properties possess characteristic SPR peak at which incident light is strongly absorbed or scattered. Fig. 7(a) shows the absorption spectra of Cu films grown for deposition time from 6 minutes to 45 minutes via PLD. All these spectra exhibit the characteristic SPR absorption peak with asymmetric tail toward longer wavelength and broad bandwidth. All these absorbance spectra were fitted with bi-gaussian lineshape function37 and are shown in Fig. 7(a) as solid lines for estimation of SPR peak positions and respective bandwidths (Γ). The SPR peak, λSPR, shifts to longer wavelength side and accompanied by continuous increase in intensity with increasing time of deposition. The SPR peak position as a function of ξ and w are shown in Fig. 7(b) and (c) respectively. It was observed that with increase in ξ, which gives island size, λSPR was red shifted from 780 nm to 922 nm. According to Mie theory,38 metal clusters above a critical size exhibit red-shift in λSPR, with increasing size of cluster.15 The surface roughness, w, of the film is also responsible for the shift in λSPR and it increases with w7 and similar trend was observed in the present case as shown Fig. 7(c).
The broadening of the SPR bandwidth increases abruptly initially from 428 nm to 635 nm with ξ increasing from 13 to 14.5 nm respectively and then it falls down to 470 nm with further increase in ξ to 58 nm as shown in Fig. 7(d). The broadening of SPR band as well as asymmetric nature are due to wide size distribution of nanoparticles within the film, irregularity in the shapes, and increase in surface roughness of the film.14,39,40 The bandwidth of SPR has been reported to increase with decreasing particle size exhibiting inverse size effect15 while it increases in proportion to r.m.s roughness.39,41 In the present case, SPR bandwidth increased for the films deposited from 6 minutes to 10 minutes due to increase in interface width (or r.m.s roughness) from 0.6 nm to 1.51 nm even though ξ increased from 13 to 14.5 nm. However, the film deposited for 20 min to 45 min (ξ > 20 nm) had shown an overall decrease in SPR bandwidth with an increase in ξ from 24 to 58 nm satisfying the inverse size effect. Thus w and ξ play dominant role in shaping up the SPR bandwidth of the plasmonic nanostructured Cu thin films.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |