Yuxi Chenab,
Wenqian Zhangab,
Changkun Shea,
Guishun Liab,
Lihua Zhangab,
Shaohua Liua,
Ya Chengc,
Chengbin Jing*ab and
Junhao Chuab
aEngineering Research Center for Nanophotonics and Advanced Instrument, Ministry of Education, Department of Materials, School of Physics and Electronic Science, East China Normal University, 500 Dongchuan Road, Shanghai 200241, China. E-mail: cbjing@ee.ecnu.edu.cn
bKey Laboratory of Polar Materials and Devices, Ministry of Education, Department of Materials, School of Physics and Electronic Science, East China Normal University, 500 Dongchuan Road, Shanghai 200241, China
cThe Extreme Optoelectromechanics Laboratory, Department of Materials, School of Physics and Electronic Science, East China Normal University, 500 Dongchuan Road, Shanghai 200241, China
First published on 8th November 2019
A sodium citrate (SC) doped polypyrrole (PPy)/PS capillary sensor was prepared for ultra-small volume HCl gas detection. A PS film was formed in advance on the inner wall of a silica glass capillary tube, which enabled us to prepare a high-qualified PPy sensitive film inside the tube. The crystallinity, morphology, microstructure and carrier transport properties of the PPy film were characterized by XRD, SEM, FTIR and Hall effect system, respectively. The results indicated that the as-prepared tube sensor sample was able to detect 0.2 mL 30 ppm HCl gas while the plane-shaped PPy/PS sensor failed to probe. The improvement of sensing properties was attributed to the trend of crystallinity, pore (or gap) morphology and the long-narrow gas cell. The tube-like gas cell and the featured PPy/PS film of the tube sample contribute to sensing the small volume of HCl gas, which may be applied in breath analysis for potential nonintrusive disease diagnosis.
Since the PPy sensitive material has electrochemical redox properties and proton acid doping behaviours, the electrical properties of PPy membrane may cause changes upon contacting with several acidity or chemical gases.11–13 Therefore, it can be fabricated into gas sensors for the detection of inorganic and organic gases in environment.14 When the PPy membrane adsorbs specific gases, the polymer chain will swell or undergo some kind of chemical reaction, which will affect the electron density of PPy molecular chain and change the conductivity.15,16
Based on the above unique mechanism, recently, Jing-Shan Do et al. proposed a conductimetric acetone gas sensor based on PPy with the high sensitivity and short response time.17 In addition, Jeon et al. fabricated the ultra-thin PPy nanosheets for detecting HCl and NH3.18 In their case, the hydrated C10SO3Na crystals were used as a template to grow PPy nanosheets with layer thickness of ∼21 nm for detecting HCl and NH3 gases ranging from 20 to 100 ppm.
It is well-known that HCl as a typically toxic gas will cause serious harm and even endanger personal safety once leaked in chemical industry production processes. Furthermore, HCl is also the main component of human gastric juice, and the changes of chemical properties will be closely related to human health.19,20 At present, there has been remarkable growth in the improvement of detecting gaseous HCl with different sensing materials, including lanthanide complexes,21 metal oxides22 and conducting polymers.23 Currently, Lee and co-authors designed the stimuli-responsive colorimetric and fluorometric sensors based on polydiacetylenes for detecting the 0.8 μL of HCl in a 100 mL chamber by observing the color change.
Although great progresses have been made in sensing HCl gas,24 there are still several shortcomings. For instance, the volume of most sensing cavity cells is large and it is difficult to detect ultra-small volume gas. For narrowing the cavity cell, hollow optical fiber gas sensors with a long path cell were developed based on the principle that the differences in light absorption by different gases.25 However, the devices of these optical sensors may be complicated which equipped with expensive laser sources and detector. For the sensing of ultra-small volume gas, the shapes of previous sensing materials were powders or flat films, probably failing to detect a small amount of gas. Generally, ultra-small volume gas sensing is critical to the application in detecting gases related in human bodies. As far as we know, almost 3500 chemicals are reported in exhaled human breath,26 gaseous HCl may be one of them as it is the main component of human gastric juice. Once the person suffers from stomach disease, the nature of the exhaled HCl gas by the human body may change. In some emergency situations, only a small volume of breathing gas may be collected for detecting. Therefore, the detection of such small volume gas is an urgent need and still a great challenge.
In this work, a PPy doped sodium citrate (SC) film based on PS/silica capillary tube sensor was proposed and fabricated. It can be expected that the SC serves as a dopant to increase conductivity by releasing protons. For improving the microstructure and conductivity of PPy film, we explored the preparation parameters including the volume ratio of reaction monomer and initiator, reaction time and extraction time. SEM, FTIR, XRD and Hall Effect system were taken to measure the morphology, microstructure and transport properties of samples. To verify the sensing properties of tube sample, we investigated the sensitivity, response time and recover time depending on the tube lengths and concentrations for detecting ultra-small volume HCl gas (0.2 mL). In addition, the continuous dynamic response–recovery performance was also measured with the gas volume of 0.2 mL and concentration of 100 ppm. The results indicated that this simple and cost-effective tube sensor present the excellent properties in detecting the small volume gaseous HCl.
PPy was synthesized in tube by chemical polymerization method at room temperature under atmospheric. FeCl3·6H2O (7.817 g) as the initiator was resolved into 100 mL deionized water. The dopant SC (0.0369 g) was added into 10 mL FeCl3 solution and stirred until dissolved completely. Then, 100 μL Py monomer was reacted with the above initiator solution. After 2 min aging time, the pre-mixed reaction solution was pumped into the above PS coated capillary tube until filled absolutely at the speed of 0.027 mL min−1. The static process sustained 1 h to promote the growth of PPy film. After then, deionized water was pumped to clean the large particles of film surface on the inner wall, followed by dried for 6 h. The schematic diagram of prepared PPy-SC/PS tube sensor is shown in Fig. 1(a).
Fig. 1 Schematic diagram of the proposed sensors (a) PPy-SC/PS compound tube and (b) plane sensor. (c) Experimental setup for the HCl gas detection of PPy-SC/PS tube. |
For comparison, the PPy was grown on both PS and glass plane in the shape of 2 × 5 cm2, respectively. They were fabricated in the same preparation method, except that the substrates were soaked into the reaction solution instead of using peristaltic pump. The schematic diagram of prepared PPy-SC/PS plane sensor is shown in Fig. 1(b).
The experimental setup for the HCl gas detection of PPy-SC/PS tube was shown in Fig. 1(c). HCl gas was collected from the vapor of hydrochloric acid solution. Then we used pure N2 gas to dilute above gas to obtain different concentrations of HCl gas. HCl gas was collected from the vapor of hydrochloric acid solution. Then we used pure N2 gas to dilute above gas to obtain different concentrations of HCl gas. The concentration based on the formula , where Vx is actual volume of gas injection, V is gas chamber volume, C (ppm) is initial gas concentration, Tr is room temperature, Tb is the temperature in gas chamber and the final concentration is also measured by commercial detector (ADKS-1, Aidekesi Company). The 0.2 mL mixed N2/HCl gases were injected into the tube controlled by syringe. Both ends of the PPy-SC/PS tube were coated with silver glue and wound with copper wires as electrodes. The changed electrical signals depending on HCl gas were recorded by electrical instrument. All experiments were operated at room temperature (25.0 °C) and the relative humidity (60% RH).
We conducted many experiments to explore the optimum film formation parameters. It can be found that the aging time of precursor solution has a great influence on the film growth morphology because the formation rate of PPy particles is relatively fast, resulting in a cotton-like coarse film. Take that into account, an incompletely reacted precursor solution was pumped into the tube for improving the quality of PPy film onto the inner wall of the tube. Also, the influence of growing time was explored systemically which may affect the thickness and initial resistance of PPy film. The results indicated that the PPy has the minimum resistance with the aging time of 2 min and the growing time of 1 h.
Fig. 2 shows the X-ray diffraction patterns of as-prepared PPy-SC/PS in the tube and on the plane, respectively. There are obvious wide peaks at about 2θ = 24.3° in both tube and plane samples indicating the amorphous structure of PPy, which almost match to the distance of the interplanar aromatic rings.27 However, the tube sample holds stronger peak intensity and narrower full width at half maximum revealing that the PPy chains of tube sample may be located in a more ordered state with better trend of crystallinity.28
Fig. 3(a)–(c) shows SEM images of PPy-SC on different substrates (a) glass plane, (b) PS plane, (c) PS tube, respectively. It can be seen from Fig. 3(a) that only a few PPy particles grow on the glass substrate, indicating that PPy is difficult to form a film on the smooth glass due to weak interaction force at the interface. The results are consistent with the above experimental phenomena. In comparison, continuous and stacked PPy can be found when growing on the PS substrate as shown in Fig. 3(b) and (c). There are a larger number of PPy particles with a diameter of about 200 nm and the pore size of about 2 μm. These pores may result from not fully dense agglomeration in PPy growing process. It should be noted that the pore structure possesses the large the surface-area-to-volume ratio which may contribute to the gas sensing. Moreover, the higher degree of dense agglomeration can be observed in PPy grown on PS tube substrate (Fig. 3(c)) compared with the PS plane sample (Fig. 3(b)).
Fig. 3 SEM images of PPy-SC on different substrates (a) glass plane, (b) PS plane, (c) PS tube, (d) the cross-section of PS tube sample. Note: the inset is an amplification of circled place. |
It is still difficult for us to know if there are certain mechanisms of PPy growth on the inner wall of tube. We conclude that PPy particles will adhere to the inner wall of the glass tube to form a thin film at the beginning of growth.29 It is worth noting that the glass tube has a small radius of curvature, and the growth direction of PPy anywhere is directed to the tube centre. Herein, this growth orientation may promote the agglomeration of PPy during the growth process. Further studies are underway. The part cross-sectional morphology of PPy-SC/PS compound tube sample is displayed in Fig. 2(d). The clear structure of 4 layers can be seen, in which the thicknesses of the PS and PPy layer are about 1 μm and 700 nm, respectively.
The FTIR spectrum of PPy-SC on different substrates are shown in Fig. 4. It can be found that five-membered ring-stretching and conjugated C–N stretching vibration peaks in PPy at 1612 cm−1 and 1469 cm−1, respectively.30 The peaks at 779 cm−1 and 1191 cm−1 are associated with the wagging and in-plane vibration. In addition, the bands at both 2920 cm−1 and 2850 cm−1 corresponded to five membered ring C–H stretching. These main peaks are overlap perfectly in three curves, indicating that the PPy has been synthesized successfully.
Fig. 4 The FTIR spectrum of PPy-SC on different substrates (tube, glass tube and PS plane, respectively). |
In order to investigate the electrical properties of PPy-SC, we measure the specific resistance, electronic mobility ratio and carrier concentration by Hall effect system as depicted in Table 1. It is found that the PS plane sample has lower specific resistance, electronic mobility ratio and higher carrier concentration. The carrier concentration value of PS sample is 3 times that of glass sample. Herein, PPy-SC/PS sample possesses more excellent electronic conductivity which may be beneficial for gas sensing.
Sample | Type | Specific resistance (ohm m) | Mobility ratio (m2 (V s)−1) | Carrier concentration (m−3) |
---|---|---|---|---|
PPy-SC/glass | p | 1.99455 × 10−3 | 1.18033 × 10−4 | 2.65120 × 1025 |
PPy-SC/PS | p | 7.87441 × 10−4 | 1.04687 × 10−4 | 7.57147 × 1025 |
In order to investigate the electrical properties of PPy-SC, we measure the specific resistance, electronic mobility ratio and carrier concentration by Hall effect system as depicted in Table 1. A Hall instrument was used to measure the carrier concentration n and mobility μ of the sample. The n and μ values can be estimated based on formulas 1/(nq) = VHt/(IB) and μ = VHt/(IB), respectively, where q is electron charge, VH is the Hall voltage, t is the sample thickness, I is the current, B is the magnetic field, σ is electrical conductivity. It is found that the PS plane sample has lower specific resistance, electronic mobility ratio and higher carrier concentration. The carrier concentration value of PS sample is 3 times that of glass sample. Herein, PPy-SC/PS sample possesses more excellent electronic conductivity which may be beneficial for gas sensing.
The sensitivity S is defined as S = (R − R0)/R0 × 100%, where R is the measured real-time resistance and R0 is the initial resistance.31 The response time is defined as the time corresponding that resistance value reaches to 90% of its change in presence of the test gas. The recovery time is defined as the time back to 90% of resistance change. In order to prove the effectiveness of the proposed capillary sensor for the detection of ultra-small volume gases, sensing performances of three PPy-SC samples (PS tube, glass plane and PS plane) were compared and discussed in this work.
The influences of different substrates on the sensing performances such as response time, recovery time and sensitivity are investigated with 0.2 mL volume HCl gas (200 ppm) at the flow rate of 27 mL min−1, as shown in Fig. 5. We calculated the sensitivities, response times and recovery times of PPy-SC samples with the substrate of PS tube (12.9%, 18 s, 77 s), PS plane (3.2%, 10 s, 10 s) and glass plane (0.2%, 6 s, 8 s), respectively. The tube sensor with PS film holds higher sensitivity in spite of longer response time and recovery time. It is reasonable that there are more sensitive particles, namely larger surface area-to-volume ratio and pore structure in PPy-SC/PS tube sample comparing with plane samples. Furthermore, tube sensor has a long-narrow gas cell, which brings more HCl gas to sufficiently react with PPy in tube. It is revealed that the tube sensor has a significant advantage in detecting small volumes of HCl gas, such as 0.2 mL ultra-small volume gas.
Fig. 6 presents the transient responses of PPy-SC/PS tube sensor with the length of 3 and 5 cm (0.2 mL, 300 ppm and 27 mL min−1). The sensitivity of 5 cm tube sensor is 26.3% higher than that of 3 cm tube sensor (21.8%). The response time and recovery time of tube sensor are also calculated with the length of 5 cm tube (81 s, 670 s) and 3 cm tube (20 s, 96 s). On one hand, after removing HCl, a small amount of HCl molecules are still adsorbed by the surface molecules of PPy, so the full recovery may occur after sufficient time. On the other hand, it is reported that many types of polymer tubes possess strong gas adsorption capacity.32 We noticed that our tube sensor connects with silicone tube to make up a closed loop system. The desorbed HCl molecules from PPy may be captured by the inner wall of silicone tube. It may also impose influence on the recovery of the sensor. Future research is needed to improve this. Although, the shorter PPy-SC/PS tube sample holds shorter response time and recovery time, the longer sample shows higher sensitivity. The long-narrow gas cell can bring dynamically molecular collisions in HCl molecule and PPy polymer as gas flows in it, which contributes to the enhancement of effective contact area between them. It is understandable that a longer tube sample has higher sensitivity and longer recovery time. For the reason that, short length of PPy-SC/PS tube sensor is a good choice for fast response and recovery time while long length sample is effective for high sensitivity. Thus, 5 cm tube sensor is better choice for ultra-small volume sensing.
The transient responses of PPy-SC/PS capillary tube sensor to various gas concentrations (5 cm length, 0.2 mL HCl), as shown in Fig. 7. As the HCl gas concentration increasing from 30 to 2000 ppm, all of sensitivity response time and recovery time appear the increasing trends from 30 ppm (1.9%, 18 s, 23 s) to 2000 ppm (38503%, 356 s, 199 s). It is worth noting that for the plane sensors, there is no obvious resistance change when detecting 30 ppm HCl gas. This further illustrates that the tube sensor is reliable for detecting low concentration with small volume HCl gas. Generally, a large gas chamber with a volume of about 20 L has been used for measurement of the sensing performances of a traditional plane sensor sample. It is inconvenient in some cases where a small volume of gas sample is available, such as medical respiratory gas detection. In this sense, the capillary tube-like sensor is advantageous since it needs only a small volume of gas sample. Besides the 100 ppm HCl gas, we also measured the sensing property of the tube sensor for 30 ppm HCl gas sample. The response reaches 1.9% and the response time is 18 s (see Fig. 7). We noticed that there are few reports on ultra-low concentration HCl gas detection, although PPy has been used to detect a 20 ppm HCl gas sample (response is 30%).15 Future work is needed to further improve the sensing performance of the tube-like sensor.
To investigate the response and the recovery properties, Fig. 8(a) presents the four reproducibility tests of the 5 cm-length PPy-SC/PS tube sensor exposed to 0.2 mL, 100 ppm HCl gas. As shown in the inset of Fig. 8(a), initially, the resistance value decreases rapidly upon pumping HCl gas, subsequently, the resistance recovers slowly after the removal of HCl gas and pumping air gas. The results show that PPy-SC/PS tube sensor possesses outstanding reproducibility performance although it may take very long time to recover absolutely. The long-term stability was investigated by monitoring the sensing response per 12 h exposed to 100 ppm of HCl gas (see Fig. 8(b)). It can be seen that the sensing performance of this sensor remains almost unchanged.
The sensing mechanism can be explained as follows.15,33 The sensing process is connected with the oxidation level of the PPy material. Generally, PPy is a p-type semiconductor in conducting state. Upon the HCl molecules introduced into PPy, the doping of PPy is achieved by means of the protonation of the amine group by HCl. On the basis of electric neutral balance principle, the PPy backbone would become positively charged by this protonation. In this process, the polarons in the PPy chain promote two localized electronic levels in the band gap including the bonding and anti-bonding cation levels. Moreover, at higher oxidation levels, the polarons associate with each other thereby producing the doubly charged spinless bipolarons. In this case, the oxidation level of PPy is easily affected by the external environment, such as chemical signals and electromagnetic waves, which may cause changes in the conductivity of PPy. The conductivity of PPy changes by the formation of radical cations that travel along the polymer backbone. In other words, the negatively charged Cl− ions are incorporated into the PPy layer, resulting to the increase of electrical conductivity of PPy. So, a drop in resistance can be observed.
The selectivity is an important factor of gas sensors for detecting a specific gas. In order to measure the gas selectivity, we tested the response to several other gases with same concentration (300 ppm), such as NH3, chlorobenzene, NO2, cyclohexane and acetone (see Fig. 9). The results indicate the PPy sensor is rarely sensitive to these gases, and the best response reaches 8.1% (NH3) which is lower than HCl (26.3%). Therefore, this sensor is much more sensitive to HCl gas.
Fig. 9 Selectivity histogram for sensing response of PPy tube sensor with different gases. (Note: concentration of each gas is 300 ppm.) |
In fact, the sensing response of the PPy sensor is not very high, especially when compared it to other fluorescent HCl sensors.34,35 However, the designed capillary tube-like PPy sensor is based on the detection of electricity signals instead of fluorescent intensity. It has the advantages of convenient operation, low-cost, device miniaturization, and can be applied to small volume gas detection. This will be able to pave a way for practical applications.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |