Daniele Di Iorio,
Almudena Marti,
Sander Koeman and
Jurriaan Huskens*
Molecular NanoFabrication Group, MESA+ Institute for Nanotechnology, University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands. E-mail: j.huskens@utwente.nl
First published on 4th November 2019
Biomolecules are immobilized onto surfaces employing the fast and stable adsorption of poly-L-lysine (PLL) polymers and the versatile copper-free click chemistry reactions. This method provides the combined advantages of versatile surface adsorption with density control using polyelectrolytes and of the covalent and orthogonal immobilization of biomolecules with higher reaction rates and improved yields of click chemistry. Using DNA attachment as a proof of concept, control over the DNA probe density and applicability in electrochemical detection are presented.
Important routes for the ligation of molecules onto surfaces have been exploited by using click chemistry. The strain-promoted alkyne–azide cycloaddition (SPAAC) reactions between ring-strained cyclooalkynes and azides have been used for the catalyst-free modification of surfaces.7–10 More recently, the inverse electron-demand Diels–Alder (iEDDA) reaction of tetrazine with strained alkenes reported by Fox et al. introduced a broader range of compounds with even faster kinetics into the area of click chemistry.11 Tetrazine can react with trans-cyclooctyne (TCO) or norbornene groups at room temperature, atmospheric pressure and micromolar concentrations with faster kinetics and allowing up to 100% conversion, while avoiding byproducts.12–14
Alternative to the covalent modification of substrates, the physisorption of modified polyelectrolytes on surfaces for the immobilization of biomolecules has presented several advantages.15 In particular, poly-L-lysine (PLL) has been reported to present excellent properties such as biocompatibility and hydrophilicity. At physiological pH, the amino groups of the lysine sidechains are positively charged, allowing a fast adsorption of the PLL on a broad variety of negatively charged substrates through multiple electrostatic interactions.16,17 The modification of the polymer with additional functional groups and non-ionic, anti-fouling side-chains, such as oligo(ethylene glycol) (OEG), enables the engineering of surfaces with selective receptors as well as antifouling properties. A variety of different functional groups has been explored, such as biotin (for conjugation with streptavidin),18 RGD peptide (to promote cell binding),19 and maleimide (to bind thiol-PNA with control over the density at the surface).20 However, the modification of PLL with ‘clickable’ units to achieve bioconjugation at surfaces, has so far not been reported.
Here we report a surface functionalization method for fast and selective immobilization of molecules onto substrates by using PLL modified with click chemistry moieties. The employment of these polymers provides the combined advantages of providing fast and versatile surface adsorption with density control using polyelectrolytes and of the covalent and orthogonal immobilization of biomolecules with higher reaction rates and improved yields of click chemistry.
Modified PLLs were synthesized by adapting a previously reported procedure.22 PLL (MW 15–30 kDa) was functionalized in a one-step reaction, by mixing different molar ratios of NHS-(OEG)4-methyl (without a functional group) and either NHS-(OEG)4-Tz or NHS-(OEG)4-DBCO. The grafting of the polymer with short OEG ensures a better control over the PLL modification and improves the antifouling properties of PLL, thus preventing non-specific adsorption of molecules onto the PLL monolayer. By varying the molar ratios of the components in the mixture it is possible to tune the degree of functionalization of the PLL. Therefore the abbreviation PLL–OEG(x)–X(y) is used for a PLLs modified with x% of OEG and y% of functional group X (here: Tz or DBCO) grafted to the PLL. 1H-NMR was used to quantify the total degree of functionalization (x + y) of the polymer. Specifically, three different types of polymers have been synthesized: one displaying only OEG as functionalization (PLL–OEG), one presenting both OEG and DBCO (PLL–OEG–DBCO) and one with OEG and Tz (PLL–OEG–Tz). Table S1 (see ESI†) shows the PLLs synthesized and the degrees of functionalization calculated by NMR.
After the synthesis, the adsorption of PLL polymers was tested on both silicon dioxide and gold substrates. The modification of substrates with modified PLL was monitored in situ and in real time by quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D). Fig. 2 shows a typical QCM measurement where SiO2 surfaces were modified with PLL–OEG–Tz and PLL–OEG–DBCO to test the immobilization of TCO-DNA or azido-DNA respectively, and the subsequent recognition of cDNA. After the activation of the substrates by UV/ozone, the surfaces were flushed with a solution of PLL–OEG–Tz or PLL–OEG–DBCO (0.1 mg mL−1, in PBS at pH 7.4). Right after injection of the PLL solution, a clear and rapid frequency change (Δf5) was observed, confirming a fast self-assembly of the modified polymer onto the surface. An only moderate desorption of the PLL after rinsing with buffer indicated the stability of the remaining polymer, and the small dissipation signals confirmed the formation of a thin and rather rigid PLL film. No relevant differences between the two substrate materials were observed (Fig. S1†).
After surface functionalization with PLL–OEG–Tz and PLL–OEG–DBCO, TCO or azide-modified DNA (15 nts) was added for the catalyst-free coupling with Tz and DBCO, respectively. X′-DNA (1 μM) was flushed over the PLL-modified substrates. A clear frequency shift, observed upon DNA addition, demonstrated a fast attachment of the DNA probes at the surface, thus confirming the successful Tz–TCO and DBCO-azide coupling. Interestingly, the observed reaction time differed for the two types of reactions. As expected, the reaction rate of the coupling of DBCO with azido-DNA appeared to be somewhat slower than the rate observed for the reaction between Tz and TCO-DNA.7 The half-time of the reaction of DBCO with azido-DNA measured by QCM resulted to be approx. 5 min, while, under the same conditions the Tz–TCO coupling showed a half-time of approx. 1 min.
Subsequently, the correct formation of a DNA probe layer onto the surface and the possibility of forming DNA duplexes was tested by the addition of fully complementary DNA (cDNA) sequences (36 nts, see ESI†). The clear frequency change, and concomitant dissipation change, upon binding of cDNA and the stability of the signal upon rinsing with buffer demonstrate the effective hybridization of the cDNA strands. The formation of DNA duplexes at the interface, stretching out from the surface, caused a change of the viscoelastic properties of the layers which is represented by an increase of the dissipation signal.23 In contrast, the absence of both frequency and dissipation changes upon addition of ncDNA confirmed that DNA binds exclusively in the presence of the complementary sequence (Fig. S1†).
After proving the fast DNA coupling, the effect of the reactive Tz content in the PLL backbone on the adsorption of DNA was assessed by QCM. Different amounts of Tz anchored to the PLL are expected to lead to varying surface densities of DNA probes and therefore different responses for the cDNA adsorption. Hereto, PLLs containing different degrees of functionalization with Tz groups (0%, 0.5%, 4.9% and 14.6%) were tested, and the adsorption steps were plotted as a function of the percentage of Tz in the PLL backbone, for both gold and SiO2 surfaces. Fig. S2† shows the full QCM time traces obtained upon adsorption of PLL, TCO-DNA and cDNA for different PLLs on both types of surfaces. In the case of PLL–OEG (Tz = 0%), the absence of Tz groups on the surface prevented the binding of TCO-DNA, thus confirming the specificity of the Tz-TCO conjugation on the surface (Fig. S2†). The low adsorption of cDNA (≤2 Hz) confirmed also the antifouling properties of the designed PLL. For low Tz contents (i.e., 0.5 and 4.9), the data shows a clear correlation between the Tz density at the interface and TCO-DNA adsorption (Fig. 3). At higher Tz contents, instead, no further increase of the amount of TCO-DNA on the surface was observed. These results indicate that a saturation of the surface with TCO-DNA probes is obtained at approx. 5% of Tz in the PLL backbone. This is attributed to electrostatic repulsion and steric hindrance between the DNA probes. Very similar trends were observed for the adsorption steps of cDNA, indicating that the hybridization efficiency was not affected by variations of the degree of Tz functionalization.
The apparent hybridization efficiency, defined as the ratio of the frequency shifts induced by cDNA and TCO-DNA, was higher for gold surfaces compared to silicon dioxide. By taking into account the different lengths of the TCO-DNA (15 nts) and cDNA (36 nts), hybridization efficiencies (uncorrected for possible differences and changes in hydration) of 130% and 65% were obtained for gold and silicon dioxide surfaces, respectively (see also ESI, Fig. S3†). Different DNA lengths as well as the formation of a DNA duplex can cause a change in the degree of hydration, which is detected by QCM.23,24
Control over the probe density is important for an optimal interaction of the immobilized probes with the target molecule.25 For example, when considering the design of sensors for DNA detection, steric hindrance and electrostatic repulsion can cause a loss of hybridization efficiency. When deriving probe densities from QCM measurements, the hydration of the molecules needs to be taken into account. Here, we assume that the 80% of the mass adsorbed in both the DNA step is due to water.23 This leads, in case of TCO-DNA, to a calculated DNA probe at the SiO2 substrates ranging from 0.43 to 4.8 × 1012 molecules per cm2, whereas for gold substrates a density between 0.44 and 3.3 × 1012 molecules per cm2 was obtained. The hybridization step leads to values ranging respectively between 0.47 and 2.8 × 1012 molecules per cm2, and between 0.73 and 4.3 × 1012 molecules per cm2 for silicon dioxide and gold surfaces, respectively. A density of 3.5 × 1012 molecules per cm2 was obtained instead for the N3-DNA, and 3.0 × 1012 molecules per cm2 for the cDNA. Notably, the density obtained from the measurements appear to be below the reported limit for electrostatic repulsion, where values of above 5 × 1012 molecules per cm2 are known to affect the hybridization efficiency.25
Recently, our group demonstrated that using PLL functionalized with maleimide (Mal), the density of PNA probes on the surface can be controlled in the preceding synthetic step of the customized PLL.20 Based on the empirical prediction of PNA probes on the surface by using PLL–OEG–(Mal), in which each percent of grafted Mal in the PLL corresponds to 1.24 ± 0.02 × 1012 probes per cm2, it was possible to predict the density of DNA also with the current system. By adopting the same relationship for PLL–OEG–Tz and PLL–OEG–DBCO, we calculated probe densities ranging between 0.66 and 6.1 × 1012 DNA probes per cm2 for the former, and 8.3 × 1012 molecules per cm2 for the latter. These values are in good agreement with the quantification of the DNA probes obtained from the QCM measurements described above. The differences observed between the predicted and the calculated values can be attributed to a different water content that cannot be precisely estimated by QCM. Another reason may be found in differences between the Mal and tetrazine or DBCO moieties which may induce a different adsorption behavior due to differences in size and hydrophobicity. At the same time, the predicted values do not take into account the steric hindrance and the electrostatic repulsion that might occur at such DNA probe densities.
As an additional method to study the probe density and to show the applicability of the click chemistry/PLL method for electrochemical biosensing schemes, we employed chronocoulometry (CC) as a convenient electrochemical method for the detection of the adsorbed analytes on an electrode surface.26,27 In this method, the surface-bound DNA probe moieties are exposed to a cationic redox probe in solution, such as ruthenium(II/III)hexamine (RuHex), which electrostatically interacts with the phosphate groups of the DNA probe. The CC signal is proportional to the density of phosphate groups of the nucleic acids present at the surface, and a follow-up hybridization step can therefore be observed by an increase of the adsorbed RuHex probe molecules.27 Accordingly, we used here the interaction of RuHex to DNA to obtain information about the coupling of DNA probes at the surface, and to detect the surface coverage before and after the hybridization step. PLL–OEG–Tz bearing 0.5 and 4.9% of Tz were used in these measurements. The gold electrodes were modified with PLL–OEG–Tz (0.25 mg mL−1) in PBS solution. After rinsing the surface, a solution of TCO-DNA (1 μM in PBS) was added onto the electrode for 1 h, and subsequently cDNA (1 μM in PBS) was adsorbed during an additional 1 h. Typical CC curves for the gold electrodes were obtained in the presence of 50 μM RuHex in 20 mM Tris buffer (Fig. 4), while the type and density of PLL were varied. The surface densities for TCO-DNA, resulting from the CC measurements (see ESI, Fig. S4†), were 1.1 × 1012 molecules per cm2 and 2.3 × 1012 molecules per cm2 for PLL–OEG–Tz(y) with y = 0.5 and 4.9% respectively. The densities of cDNA were found to be 2.0 and 3.4 × 1012 molecules per cm,2 respectively. These values are in reasonable agreement with the previously reported results in which densities between 1 and 10 × 1012 molecules per cm2 were measured.28 Most importantly, both in the case of the DNA probe and the cDNA, these values are very comparable to the ones calculated from the QCM measurements. The relatively small observed differences can be, once more, attributed to the error in estimating the water content in the QCM measurements. At the same time, the hybridization efficiency calculated for this system appears to be higher than 100%. Interestingly, a different behavior was observed, instead, in case of N3-DNA. As shown in Fig. 4, the measured DNA probe density appeared to be lower than the measured cDNA, thus resulting in a lower hybridization efficiency. At the same time, no clear difference was observed between values of cDNA densities obtained with PLL–OEG(26.0)–Tz(4.9) and PLL–OEG(31.2)–DBCO(6.7). This observation can find an explanation in the different degrees of functionalization of the PLL. In particular, a higher amount of DBCO can lead to the (observed) surface functionalization with DNA probes. However, due to steric hindrance and electrostatic repulsion, not all the probes can hybridize with cDNA, resulting in a lower hybridization efficiency. Therefore, these results support the previous observations, where at a PLL functionalization above 5%, no further increase of cDNA was observed.
1H NMR of PLL–OEG–Tz (400 MHz D2O) δ [ppm] = 1.26–1.56 (lysine γ-CH2), 1.61–1.82 (lysine β, δ-CH2), 2.49 (ethylene glycol CH2 from both OEG and Tz coupled, –CH2–C(=O)–NH), 2.99 (free lysine, H2N–CH2), 3.16 (ethylene glycol CH2 of coupled lysine from both OEG and Tz, C(=O)–NH–CH2–), 3.35 (OEG methoxy, –O–CH3), 3.58–3.79 (ethylene glycol from both OEG and Tz, CH2–O–), 4.29 (lysine backbone, NH–CH–C(O)–), 8.4 and 7.2 (tetrazine from coupled Tz, HCAr = CArH).
1H NMR of PLL–OEG–Tz (400 MHz D2O) δ [ppm] = 1.26–1.56 (lysine γ-CH2), 1.61–1.82 (lysine β, δ-CH2), 2.49 (ethylene glycol CH2 from both OEG and DBCO coupled, –CH2–C(=O)–NH), 2.99 (free lysine, H2N–CH2), 3.16 (ethylene glycol CH2 of coupled lysine from both OEG and DBCO, C(=O)–NH–CH2–), 3.35 (OEG methoxy, –O–CH3), 3.58–3.79 (ethylene glycol from both OEG and DBCO, CH2–O–), 4.29 (lysine backbone, NH–CH–C(O)–), 7.42 (DBCO from coupled DBCO, CArH).
Gold surfaces were cleaned using basic Piranha solution (Milli-Q water: H2O2 (30%): NH4OH (25%), in ratio 5:1:1) for 5 min, then rinsed with Milli-Q water, dried in a N2 stream and treated with UV-ozone for 10 min. Silicon dioxide surfaces were submerged in 2% SDS in water and sonicated for 10 min. Afterwards, the surfaces were rinsed with Milli-Q water and activated for 20 min in UV-ozone.
The relationship between the measured frequency shift (Δf) and the adsorbed mass per unit area (Δm) was established using the Sauerbrey equation (eqn (1)):
Δf = −CΔm | (1) |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental details, synthetic procedures, QCM-D sensograms. See DOI: 10.1039/c9ra08714a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |