Aline Xavier*ab,
Flavia Zacconicde,
Constanza Gainzaf,
Daniel Cabreragh,
Marco Arreseg,
Sergio Uribeabi,
Carlos Sing-Longabfj and
Marcelo E. Andiaabi
aBiomedical Imaging Center, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Chile. E-mail: acarvalhodasilva@uc.cl
bMillennium Nucleus for Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance, Chile
cFaculty of Chemistry and Pharmacy, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Chile
dResearch Center for Nanotechnology and Advanced Materials CIEN-UC, Pontificia Univesidad Católica de Chile, Chile
eInstitute for Biological and Medical Engineering, Schools of Engineering, Medicine and Biological Sciences, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Chile
fInstitute for Mathematical and Computational Engineering, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Chile
gGastroenterology Department, School of Medicine, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Chile
hDepartment of Chemical and Biological Sciences, Universidad Bernardo O'Higgins, Chile
iRadiology Department, School of Medicine, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Chile
jMillennium Nucleus Center for the Discovery of Structures in Complex Data, Chile
First published on 19th December 2019
Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) is the most common liver disease in the world and it is becoming one of the most frequent cause of liver transplantation. Unfortunately, the only available method that can reliably determine the stage of this disease is liver biopsy, however, it is invasive and risky for patients. The purpose of this study is to investigate changes in the intracellular composition of the liver fatty acids during the progression of the NAFLD in a mouse model fed with Western diet, with the aim of identify non-invasive biomarkers of NAFLD progression based in 1H-MRS. Our results showed that the intracellular liver fatty acid composition changes as NAFLD progresses from simple steatosis to steatohepatitis (NASH). Using principal component analysis with a clustering method, it was possible to identify the three most relevant clinical groups: normal, steatosis and NASH by using 1H-MRS. These results showed a good agreement with the results obtained by GC-MS and histology. Our results suggest that it would be possible to detect the progression of simple steatosis to NASH using 1H-MRS, that has the potential to be used routinely in clinical application for screening high-risk patients.
Research performed in 2015 with a sample of 8515431 patients from 22 countries showed that 25% of the total population in the world suffers from NAFLD.3 According to statistics, about 30–40% of people with steatosis develop NASH. Moreover, 10–30% of them develop cirrhosis, which could progress to hepatocellular carcinoma.4
Currently, there are no specific biomarkers that can predict this “bad progression” of NAFLD. Most of the current available diagnosis methods mainly focus on estimating the total amount of fat stored in the liver using ultrasound (US), computed tomography (CT) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). However, these methods have some drawbacks: US does not work properly in obese patients, CT uses ionizing radiation and none of these methods can recognize either inflammation or early stages of fibrosis. In addition, it is necessary to detect the disease in NASH stages while the disease is reversible.5 Therefore, the only method that can reliably determine the stage of this disease is a biopsy with a histological evaluation, however, it is invasive and risky for patients.6–8
In an attempt to develop biomarkers correlated with the progression of the disease, previous studies have characterized the fatty acids (FA) stored in the intracellular lipids in the liver by using gas chromatography with mass spectrometer (GC-MS), and they have identified some changes in the FA profile when comparing healthy livers, livers with steatosis, and livers with steatohepatitis.9–12 Araya et al. (2004)12 found a decrease in polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA), while the saturated fatty acids (SFA) and the monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFA) had no significant changes between healthy patients and patients with steatosis. This study also found a decrease of the long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids between healthy patients and patients with steatosis, and between patients with steatosis and patients with steatohepatitis. Additionally, the same conclusion was found by Puri et al. (2007).11
Although the analysis of the lipid composition opens an interesting field for the diagnosis of fatty liver progression, it still requires a biopsy, so its routine use is limited. On the other hand, magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) provides a non-invasive technique that allows to determine the structure of organic substances.7 The idea of defining a classifier using MRS emerges due to the need to find a way to replace biopsy with a non-invasive method that can classify NAFLD based on the composition of different fatty acids stored in the liver.
Previous studies have shown that it is possible to associate the results of MRS with those obtained from GC-MS. Unfortunately, those studies considered only fatty acids with 14, 16 and 18 carbons and not fatty acids with long chain, which seems to have a big relevance in the NAFLD progression.13–16 Furthermore, studies that emphasize the importance of fatty acids on the liver have analyzed it in vivo with MRS but have not correlated their results with the true amount of fatty acids as no biopsy was performed.17–20
The purpose of this study is to investigate and compare the intracellular composition of the liver fatty acids using histology, GC-MS, 9.4T 1H-MRS during the progression of NAFLD in a mice model fed with Western diet, with the aim of identifying non-invasive biomarkers of NAFLD progression to NASH.
We fed a group of C57BL/6 male mice with Western diet (AIN76A, Test Diet) for 4 weeks (n = 6), 10 weeks (n = 6) and 24 weeks (n = 6). The Western diet has 4.49 kilocalories per gram, and the calories come from: fat (40%), protein (15.8%), and carbohydrate (44.2%). We also fed a group (n = 6) with a chow diet (500l*, Labdiet) with 3.36 kilocalories per gram, and the calories come from: fat (13.4%), protein (30%), and carbohydrate (57%). The Western diet is a model of “Western fast food” diet characterized by high calories, high cholesterol and high fructose content.21
At the end of the diet intervention, the mice were anesthetized with ketamine/xylosine, and the livers were harvested. A portion of the liver was used for histology analysis. The remaining liver was divided into two portions that were analyzed independently. We extracted the intracellular FA using a protocol adapted by Folch et al.,22 proceeded by an esterification process to obtain fatty acids methyl esters (FAME) since they are more stable (do not form hydrogen bridges). It's important to comment that the quantity of FA is the same as FAME. Finally, those FAME were analyzed using a 9.4 T MRS and GC-MS.
Previous studies were performed and allowed the conclusion that 300 mg of liver was required since, after the extraction in healthy mice, we obtained 5 mg of FAME and that is the minimum amount of sample required to perform a 1H MRS with enough SNR. For the GC-MS, 2 mg of FAME is enough.23
Injector temp. | Oven ramp | Sample injection | Electron impact |
---|---|---|---|
220 °C | 150 °C × 1 min 15 °C min−1 to 200 °C 200 °C × 5 min 12 °C min−1 to 260 °C | Split mode (1:20) helium at 1 ml min−1 (constant flow) | Ionization potential of 70 eV |
FAME were identified by comparing retention times to known standards and by matching them up with the mass spectra from NIST library (National Institute of Standards and Technology, USA).
The mass of each FAME (in µg) was calculated according to the integration area of corresponding peak and the relation with the integration area of the internal standard (C19:0) added to the sample (50 µg). Fatty acids composition was defined as the percentage of individual fatty acids in respect of its total.
We took a known value in mg of FAME from each sample and added 700 µl of CDCl3 that has a small proportion of tetramethylsilane (TMS) as an internal reference. This mixture was introduced into a 5 mm diameter tube. The spectra acquisition was made with Topspin V3.0 and the parameters were: spectral width 8012.820 Hz, relaxation delay 1 s, number of scans 16, acquisition time 2.045 s, flip angle 30° to avoid T1 relaxation effects and total acquisition time 48.72 s (number of scans × [time between pulses + acquisition time]). The experiment was conducted at 25 °C. The spectra were analyzed using MestreNova Version 10.0. First, the spectra were centered (TMS in 0 ppm); then we calculated the area under the curve (AUC) of all seven peaks corresponding to fatty acids and finally, we normalized the AUC by the total amount of fatty acids. The fatty acids peaks used were: methyl terminal protons (–CH3, approximately 0.9 ppm); bulk methylene protons (–CH2–, approximately 1.3 ppm); β-methylene protons (COO–CH2–CH2–, approximately 1.6 ppm); allylic protons (–CH2–CHCH-, approximately 2.0 ppm) α-methylene protons (COO–CH2–CH2–, approximately 2.2 ppm); diallylic protons (CH–CH2–CH, approximately 2.8 ppm) and olefinic internal protons (–CHCH–, approximately 5.3 ppm).
The score of steatoses vary between 0 and 3, the score of ballooning vary between 0 and 2, the score of inflammation vary between 0 and 3, and the score of fibrosis vary between 0 and 4. The NAS is the sum of steatosis, ballooning and inflammation scores. It can vary between 0 and 8. A NAS score less than 3 means no NASH, while a score higher than 4 means NASH. Scores of 3 or 4 means indeterminate.
The GC is the gold standard to characterize fatty acids. The mixture containing all the fatty acids methyl esters is introduced in a GC-MS where it is warmed, and the fatty acids start to separate from each other by their volatility and polarity.27
There are many types of FA in the liver of a human being. All of them generate just seven peaks corresponding to the chemical equivalent protons. Fig. 1 shows an example of a FAME with 18 carbons and 2 double bonds in the signal of the MR spectroscopy.
Fig. 1 MRS simulation of a FAME with 18 carbons and 2 double bonds. The proton chemically equivalent are shown in numbers. |
Therefore, MRS does not detect the quantity of the fatty acids directly, but it is possible to assume that, if we have a change in fatty acids profile, we will have a change in the metabolites detected by MRS.
PCA is a data analysis technique that is used to represent a large set of data samples with a reduced set of features that explain most of the variability in the original set. These features, called principal components, are determined by finding linear combinations of the data samples that explain the largest variability in the dataset. Therefore, the first principal component corresponds to the direction of maximum possible variance, whereas the second explains the maximum remaining variance and so on.28 By considering a small number of principal components, we can visualize the data and determine if there is a natural distribution of the measurements performed on each mouse that correlates to their disease progression.
To determine if the distribution of GC-MS and 1H-MRS data has itself some structure from which we can infer the presence or progression of the disease, an agglomerative hierarchical clustering method was applied. Agglomerative hierarchical clustering is a “bottom-up” approach; each data point is initially considered to be a cluster, and data points are grouped together at each step according to some criterion. At the end of the procedure we obtain several potential groupings of the data, with a decreasing number of clusters.28 For our analysis, the data points are grouped according to their Euclidean distance and Ward's linkage function.29 This choice promotes that at each step, among all possible choices, pairs of clusters are merged in order to minimize the variation within the resulting cluster with respect to all other possible choices.
Mice group | Mice age (weeks) | Mice weight (g) | Liver weight (g) | Weight of FAME/total liver sample, % |
---|---|---|---|---|
Chow-diet (control) | 16 | 26.63 ± 1.33 | 1.22 ± 0.07 | 3.07 ± 0.65 |
Western diet for 4 weeks | 16 | 28.27 ± 2.76 | 1.14 ± 0.08 | 5.84 ± 2.11 |
Western diet for 10 weeks | 22 | 36.23 ± 6.24 | 1.61 ± 0.56 | 12.68 ± 4.28 |
Western diet for 24 weeks | 36 | 46.23 ± 2.12 | 3.32 ± 0.48 | 23.62 ± 2.54 |
Fig. 3 shows a boxplot with individual values of the NAS score. The control group, mice fed with Western diet for 4 weeks and two mice fed with Western diet for 10 weeks have no NASH, while the mice fed with Western diet for 24 weeks and four mice fed with Western diet for 10 weeks have NASH.
All the FA can be grouped into three main categories: saturated fatty acids (SFA), monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFA) and polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA). The SFA have no double bonds (i.e., C14:0, C15:0, C16:0, C18:0), while the MUFA have one double bond (i.e., C16:1, C18:1) and the PUFA have two or more double bonds (i.e., C18:2, C18:3, C20:3, C20:4, C20:5, C22:6).
Fig. 5 shows that PUFA liver content decreased with the progression of the disease from 40.5% in control group to 4.5% at 24 weeks (PANOVA < 0.001). In contrast, MUFA liver content increased from 26.8% in control group to 67.8% at 24 weeks (PANOVA < 0.001), while SFA remain constant.
Fig. 6 Areas under the curve (AUC) calculated with MestreNova V10.0. In red, the results of a control mouse with a chow-diet and in blue, a mouse with a Western diet for 24 weeks. |
The three groups that can be visually identified show a rough correlation with the number of weeks each mouse has been fed (Fig. 8a and b). Interestingly, the group of mice fed for 10 weeks has been split in two, with some of them grouped with mice fed for 4 weeks, and the rest grouped with mice fed for 24 weeks. Those grouped with the mice fed for 4 weeks are those with no NASH whereas those grouped with the mice fed for 24 weeks are precisely those that have NASH (Fig. 3).
We used agglomerative hierarchical clustering to group both the GC-MS and 1H-MRS data (Fig. 8c and d). Interestly, the clusters obtained correspond to three stages of NAFLD: the first one with a low NAS score, normal; the second one, with an intermedium NAS score, low to medium steatosis; and the third one with high NAS score with inflammation and early stages of fibrosis.
Furthermore, the mouse whose result is at the top of the GC-MS graph (Fig. 8a) was grouped as a control mouse, even though it was fed with Western diet for 4 weeks. However, its NAS value was 0. Fig. 9 shows the mean of NAS score for each the cluster identified (control, No NASH, NASH).
Fig. 9 NAS score for each cluster found by PCA with the data from GC-MS and MRS. *p < 0.05 (significant difference between groups) and NS (no significant difference between groups). |
GC-MS analysis showed that the fat in the liver is composed of, at least, 12 different fatty acids, which have different evolution during the NAFLD progression. Besides that, the analysis identifies a pattern of fatty acids composition during NAFLD progression: although the total amount of fatty acids increased during the NAFLD progression, not all the fatty acids progressed in the same way. The PUFA decreased, while the MUFA increased and the SFA remained the same during the progression of the disease. Similar results were found by Levant et al. (2013) in mice with a high-fat diet for 8 weeks.30 The decrease in the PUFA can be explained since the arachidonic (C20:4); eicosapentaenoic acid (20:5) and docosahexaenoic acids (C22:6) are precursors for a variety of anti- and pro-inflammatory mediators.31,32
MRS analysis found all the seven peaks related to fatty acids. The diallylic peak (2.8 ppm), corresponding to FA with two or more double bonds, also decreased in good agreement with the PUFA results found by CG-MS. The olefinic (5.3 ppm), allylic (2.0 ppm) and bulk methylene (1.3 ppm) peaks are somehow related to this change in PUFA and MUFA, because they are related to double bonds.
As mentioned by Leporq et al. (2014), who used only theoretical values calculated from oil mass composition for validation, one of the limitations of their work was not to have the gas chromatography analysis as gold standard to characterize those FA.33 Opposite to this, our study overcomes this limitation with the GC-MS analysis.
Our results, as evidenced by PCA, showed that the liver fatty acid composition changes as NAFLD progresses. In addition, by using agglomerative hierarchical clustering it was possible to identify the 3 most relevant clinical groups: normal, steatosis and NASH. In essence, the NAS score of the entire population was reproduced by clustering the GC-MS data in three groups. In addition, applying the same analysis to the 1H-MRS data shows it is possible to identify the same 3 groups using ex-vivo MRS, which provide some evidence that the proposed methodology could be used in vivo and non-invasive, however further studies has to be done to prove this hypothesis.
Some limitations of our studies are related to the possibility that our results may vary if the mice were fed with different diets, although we have used the diet most like human diet.34,35 However, this limitation might explain differences in the NAFLD progression among patients, in which some of them evolve to NASH and cirrhosis, whereas others remain in the early stages of NAFLD for a long time.
Additionally, the MRS acquisition was performed only over the extracted liver fatty acids, so that it is now necessary to validate our results with in vivo whole liver MRS acquisition. The transition to an in vivo measurement has some challenges since it may account with a series of extra parameters like respiratory and cardiac motion, presence of water component, the correlation between acquisition time, NSA, voxel size and SNR to assure the comfort of the patient, but also the spectra quality.
Preliminary results showed that it would be possible to identify the same 7 peaks in human and mice livers in vivo at 7.0 T (ref. 36) and 9.4 T (ref. 37), respectively (Fig. 10). Although the 7.0 T is not available for clinical use yet, research could be made in this equipment by benefitting from its good spectral resolution to validate the method.
Fig. 10 In vivo MR spectra from a 9.4 Tesla in a mouse (red) and 7 Tesla in human (blue) showing that it is possible to identify all the seven peaks correspondent to the fat spectrum in the liver. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |