Anupam
Prasoon
,
Barun
Dhara
,
Debashree
Roy
,
Shammi
Rana
,
Sujit
Bhand
and
Nirmalya
Ballav
*
Department of Chemistry, Indian Institute of Science Education and Research (IISER), Dr Homi Bhabha Road, Pashan, Pune 411008, India. E-mail: nballav@iiserpune.ac.in
First published on 5th September 2019
Downsizing coordination polymers (CPs) to thin film configurations is a prerequisite for device applications. However, fabrication of thin films of CPs including metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) with reasonable electrical conductivity is challenging. Herein, thin film fabrication of a Cu(II)-CP employing a layer-by-layer method is demonstrated whereby a self-assembled monolayer on Au was used as the functionalized substrate. Growth of the Cu(II)-CP at the solid–liquid interface generated open-metal Cu(II) sites in the thin film which were susceptible to activation by molecular dopant molecules. A significant enhancement in in-plane electrical conductivity and an unheralded cross-plane current rectification ratio (exceeding 105 both at room-temperature and at an elevated temperature) were achieved. Such a remarkable rectification ratio was realized, similar to those of commercial Si rectifier diodes. This phenomenon is attributed to the formation of an electronic heterostructure in the molecularly doped thin film. Molecular doping additionally transformed the interfacial properties of thin films from hydrophilic to highly hydrophobic.
Of the aforementioned strategies, the introduction of guest molecules remains convenient for imparting conductivity to an otherwise non-conducting MOF as the pores themselves act as the sites for modulating the electrical transport properties.7–17 Although some molecules have successfully been used as dopants to provide conductivity to MOFs, the 7,7,8,8-tetracyanoquinodimethane (TCNQ) molecule has paved the way to rationally design and enhance the conductivity of such systems by several orders of magnitude.8 A continuous conductivity path between TCNQ and the open-metal sites of binuclear Cu(II) paddle wheels was attributed to the conductivity enhancement by 106 times.8,9 Such thin films of MOFs can be fabricated by various techniques; however, the layer-by-layer (LbL) approach is considered to be the most robust as it not only results in the growth of oriented films of MOFs but is also known for being easily performed and cost-effective.18,19
Herein, we describe for the first time the fabrication of thin films of Cu–BTEC, a Cu(II)-coordination polymer (CP) with the 1,2,4,5-benzenetetracarboxylic acid (BTEC) ligand,20 on a self-assembled monolayer (SAM) template via the LbL technique (Fig. 1). Interestingly, TCNQ molecules could be directly doped into the Cu–BTEC thin film – without the need for activation of the open-metal sites. Doping with TCNQ molecules also leads to a dramatic change in the wetting properties of the Cu–BTEC thin film. A significant enhancement of the in-plane electrical conductivity (six orders of magnitude) of the molecularly doped thin film was detected when the current–voltage (I–V) measurements were performed at 300 K. Remarkably, a current rectification ratio (RR, defined as the absolute value of the quotient between the current recorded for one voltage polarity and the current recorded for the same voltage at the opposite polarity) exceeding 105 was observed when I–V measurements were performed cross-plane which closely matched with the RR values of the commercial diodes 1N4007 and 1N4733A (≥105).
Commercial diodes (Schottky21 or p–n junctions22) primarily made of inorganic materials, for example Si, have typical RR values in the range of 105–108. However, the best performing molecular diodes23–25 with RR values of 102 to 103 were considered to be inferior to commercial diodes until realization of the ‘supramolecular diode’ at metal/SAM/metal oxide junctions with an RR value beyond 105, driven by electrostatic interactions.26 Also, earlier studies on thin films of MOFs did reveal electrical rectification, specifically at indium tin oxide (ITO)/Cd(II)–MOF/aluminium (Al) junctions;27–30 however, RR values were consistently observed to be <102. Thus, to the best of our knowledge, the present work reports the highest value of RR to date in the domain of organic–inorganic hybrid materials like CPs including MOFs. Furthermore, cross-plane I–V characteristics of our doped thin film at 300 K remained almost unaltered at an elevated temperature of 450 K along with retention of the RR value.
The surface morphologies of pristine and doped Cu–BTEC thin films, as displayed in field-emission scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM) images, consistently revealed uniform coverage on the Au substrate (Fig. 2a). The insets of FE-SEM images exhibiting the corresponding contact angles (CA) of water clearly showed the conversion from a hydrophilic surface in the pristine film (CA = 15 ± 5°) to a highly hydrophobic surface in the doped film (CA = 135 ± 5°) (Fig. 2a). Apart from the distinctive chemical identity, a notable difference between the surface morphological features of pristine and doped Cu-BTEC thin films is the presence of a reasonably higher number of air-pockets in the latter compared to the former system that could generate highly hydrophobic surfaces32 – as was observed in respective zoomed-in FE-SEM images (Fig. S1†). The thickness of the pristine Cu–BTEC thin film from the cross-sectional FE-SEM image was estimated to be 700 ± 25 nm and this value did not change in the case of the doped Cu–BTEC thin film (Fig. 2a).
Out-of-plane X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of the thin films showed that the crystalline nature of Cu–BTEC20 was retained even after doping with TCNQ molecules (Fig. 2b). The most noticeable change was the appearance of a new peak at 2θ ∼ 5.8° in the case of the doped thin film which can be assigned to the incorporation of TCNQ molecules with an ordering into the Cu–BTEC thin film similar to previous reports on the incorporation of guest molecules into MOFs including thin films.8,11 Note that this new diffraction peak is not characteristic of bulk TCNQ and thus excludes the possibility of TCNQ molecular layers on top of the doped thin film (Fig. S2†). To ensure that our careful washing procedure (after doping) could get rid of additional surface adsorbed TCNQ moieties, we have performed electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy measurements, and indeed, no characteristic EPR signal of bulk TCNQ at 325 mT (g = 2.00) was observed in the doped thin film (Fig. S3†).8,33
The infiltration of TCNQ into the pores of Cu–BTEC was further demonstrated by Raman measurements wherein a peak at ∼240 cm−1 characteristic of paddle wheel open-metal Cu(II) sites34–36 in the pristine thin film vanished after doping with TCNQ molecules (Fig. 2c). Complete vanishing of the Raman band in the doped thin film could be due to activation of the open-metal sites by TCNQ (top layers) as well as solvent molecules (bottom layers).34 The presence of inherent open-metal sites in the Cu–BTEC thin film helped not only in coordinating the TCNQ molecules to such sites but also in ordering the redox-active guest molecules into the pores of Cu–BTEC. As additional evidence from Raman spectra, we attribute the huge suppression of the C–H out-of-plane bending vibration at 845 cm−1 in the doped film in comparison to the pristine film to the ordering phenomenon (Fig. S4†).37 The solid–liquid interfacial growth of thin films having innate open-metal sites or open-coordination sites is exciting not only in terms of coordinating the incoming guest molecules to the metal centers but also because it eliminates the need for any activation process8,17 which could potentially damage the structural integrity of the framework materials.34,38
The oxidation states of Cu before and after the doping process were probed with the help of high-resolution X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The pristine Cu–BTEC thin film exhibited Cu 2p3/2 signals at ∼934 eV (major) and at ∼932 eV (minor) with strong satellite features indicating the dominant presence of Cu(II) over Cu(I) (Fig. 2d) – consistent with earlier reports on Cu–MOFs obtained from Cu(II) salt and aromatic carboxylic acids.36 However, the doped thin film showed Cu 2p3/2 major signal at ∼932 eV and minor signal at ∼934 eV with an almost complete disappearance of the satellite features thereby confirming that Cu(I) is the dominant species over Cu(II) which were generated upon doping with TCNQ molecules (Fig. 2d).16,39
The bonding motif of TCNQ was investigated by Raman spectroscopy, and upon comparing the Raman spectra of the pristine and doped thin film, a significant red-shift from ∼1455 cm−1 to ∼1374 cm−1 (Δν ∼ 80 cm−1) for the CC wing stretching mode was observed which suggested charge transfer between the Cu–BTEC framework and TCNQ amounting to ∼1.3e charge for the TCNQ moiety (Fig. S5†).40 The nitrile CN stretching frequency at ∼2208 cm−1 could be fitted with two peaks, one at ∼2202 cm−1 and the other at ∼2217 cm−1, which is an indication that the bonding environment of TCNQ is non-equivalent – two of the CN moieties are bound to the open-metal center while the remaining two CN moieties are unbound (Fig. 3a).8 These findings were substantiated by the infrared reflection-absorption spectroscopy (IRRAS) data which revealed that the CN stretching frequency of the doped film shifted from ∼2223 cm−1 to ∼2202 cm−1 with respect to neutral TCNQ (Fig. S6†) and such a red-shift (Δν ∼ 20 cm−1) can be assigned to partial charge transfer between TCNQ and the Cu–BTEC framework.41 The emergence of characteristic vibrational modes overall provides a strong indication that TCNQ molecules do interact with the open-metal sites available in the Cu–BTEC framework. Furthermore, N 1s XPS data clearly showed two distinct chemical environments, one at a binding energy of ∼398.5 eV and the other at a binding energy of ∼399.5 eV, which can be assigned to bonded and free nitrogens of TCNQ, respectively (Fig. 3b).42,43 Referring to an earlier observation,8 a bonding motif of TCNQ to the Cu–BTEC system is proposed and can be visualized from the schematic in Fig. 3b (an enlarged view is presented in Fig. S7†).
The solid-state UV-vis absorption spectra of pristine and doped thin films were markedly different (Fig. 4a) – prominent absorption peaks in the visible region suggested the presence of gap-states in the case of the doped thin film. Such gap-states might reduce the electronic band gap and facilitate electron transport in the thin film.44,45 To investigate the effect of molecular doping on the electrical conductivity, I–V measurements on our thin films were carried out in both in-plane and cross-plane modes. An impressive enhancement (7.8 × 106 times) was observed for the in-plane electrical conductance value of the doped thin film in comparison to that of the pristine thin film (Fig. 4b) resembling electronic coupling between the HKUST-1 MOF (comprising Cu(II) ions and 1,3,5-benzenetricarboxylic acid (BTC) also known as Cu–BTC) and dopant TCNQ generating a conducting path via Cu⋯TCNQ links.8 Poor conductivity of Cu–BTEC could be due to the considerably higher energy level of the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) in comparison to the work function values of standard metallic electrodes; on the other hand, the LUMO level of TCNQ is substantially closer to the Fermi energy of electrodes. In an electronically interacting system of Cu–BTEC and TCNQ, the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO)/LUMO levels of Cu–BTEC and TCNQ are expected to be primarily localized in the eg orbitals of Cu centres in the paddle wheel unit and π orbitals, respectively.12 Therefore, an increase in the conductivity value of TCNQ doped Cu–BTEC is expected due to efficient orbital overlap (dx2−y2 → π* and π → dx2−y2) reducing the injection barrier.9
When I–V measurements were carried out in cross-plane mode, the electrical conductance value of the pristine thin film was observed to be similar to the in-plane conductance value (3.6 × 10−11 and 6.8 × 10−11 S, respectively) (Fig. 4c); interestingly however, a remarkable rectification feature was observed for the doped thin film (Fig. 4d). The RR value was estimated to be more than 105 – a record value in the realm of organic–inorganic hybrid materials as well as coordination polymers. This is a huge achievement considering the fact that coordination polymers including MOFs (either in bulk form or in thin film form) so far have not been able to cross the 102 mark in RR values.27–30 Motivated by such an unusual observation, we wanted to directly compare the I–V characteristics of our system with those of commercial Si diodes (1N4007 and 1N4733A), and RR values were estimated to be on par (Fig. S8†)!
Now the question is, why the unusual rectification of electrical conductivity across molecularly doped thin films? It can be reasoned that formation of an electronic heterostructure occurs under the adopted experimental conditions; for a thin film with a thickness of ∼700 ± 25 nm, only the top layers were doped with the guest molecules while the bottom layers closer to the Au substrate remained pristine due to saturation in the uptake of TCNQ (or a concentration gradient across the thin film).46 In the cross-sectional energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDXS) data elemental nitrogen (N) acting as a marker for TCNQ was mainly present in the top layers of the film but was conspicuous by its absence in the bottom layers (Fig. S9†). Thus, while carrying out I–V measurements in-plane, only enhancement of the electrical conductivity was observed; however for I–V measurements performed cross-plane, rectification was observed because the flow of current was restricted due to the electronic heterostructure resembling a typical p–n junction.47,48 So, roughly half of the thin film was conductive while the other half was insulating in nature, giving rise to the rectification. Conventionally, in a p–n junction diode, the positive terminal of the source is connected to the p-type material and the negative terminal of the source is connected to n-type material in forward bias and vice versa in reverse bias.49 In the case of our doped thin film, when we connected the negative terminal of the source to the upper side of the thin film and the positive terminal of the source to the lower side of the thin film, forward bias I–V characteristics (and vice versa in reverse bias) were observed. Knowing the p–n junction identity of commercial Si diodes (1N4007) and complementarity in the I–V characteristics, we can assume that the top and bottom layers of our doped thin film behave like n-type and p-type materials, respectively (Fig. S10†). To further support our claim, we have recorded capacitance–voltage (C–V) characteristics on pristine and doped Cu–BTEC thin films and plotted 1/C2 values vs. V – so called Mott–Schottky analysis (Fig. S11†).50,51 A negative slope for the pristine thin film indicates a p-type material while a positive slope for the doped thin film is typical of an n-type semiconductor.
Schottky barriers at the metal–semiconductor interfaces are well known to cause current rectification and all the previous MOF Schottky diodes were demonstrated to primarily originate from specific semiconducting MOF–metal interfaces.27–30 To check such a possibility in our system, we have measured in-plane and cross-plane I–V characteristics on the doped thin film using various types of contacts, namely EGaIn, conductive C paste, direct Au tips, and direct Pt tips, having different work function values. However, similar I–V patterns as well as RR values were consistently observed (Fig. S12†) which suggested that the CP–metal Schottky contact is not the dominating factor at the origin of such an electrical rectification. Further, we deliberately spin-coated TCNQ on top of a pristine Cu–BTEC thin film and carried out I–V measurements. An enhancement in the in-plane electrical conductance value of the spin-coated thin film in comparison to that of the pristine thin film was observed; interestingly however, no cross-plane electrical rectification was observed (Fig. S13†) thereby clearly demonstrating the fact that even if additional TCNQ moieties are present on the surface of the doped thin film, the TCNQ–CP interface does not cause the electrical rectification. Overall, in the present system of the TCNQ doped Cu–BTEC thin film, the Schottky barrier was apparently a minor factor; rather, formation of a p–n junction type electronic heterostructure was the dominating factor in the current rectification process.
Looking closely at the resistance values obtained in cross-plane mode, it can be seen that the values pertaining to the negative potential correspond very well to those observed for the pristine thin film (∼109) while the values pertaining to the positive potential resemble those of the doped thin film (∼104). This finding also corroborates the presence of an electronic heterostructure in the film. To further verify that the rectification behaviour was due to our chemically engineered thin film and not an instrumental artefact, the directionality of current flow was reversed to source measure unit (SMU)-2 from source measure unit (SMU)-1 (and vice versa), and indeed, a reverse pattern was observed (Fig. S10†). Note also that our I–V data on pristine as well as doped thin films, in both in-plane and cross-plane modes, were successfully reproduced across different batches of samples (Fig. S14†). Also, substrate scope for fabrication of such CP thin films appears flexible.52 The uptake of TCNQ in the thin film as a function of time and the corresponding electrical response could perhaps provide better insight into the microscopic origin of the electronic heterostructure vis-à-vis current rectification.
An activation energy (Ea) of 0.16 eV from the Arrhenius plot was estimated11 from the temperature dependency of the in-plane I–V characteristics for the doped thin film (Fig. S15†). Temperature-dependent I–V measurements in cross-plane mode on the doped thin film showed no appreciable change in the rectification features, and the RR values remained constant at 3.1 × 105 when the temperature was increased to 450 K and again cooled down to 300 K which implies that our thin film as well as the electronic heterostructure is very stable and can sustain temperatures as high as 450 K (Fig. 5a) in agreement with the temperature-dependent PXRD patterns (Fig. 5b) – also a notable achievement in the field of CPs.
A recent report clearly showed the conversion of Cu–BTC to Cu–TCNQ on exposure to a methanolic (protic solvent) TCNQ solution;17 however, no such transformation was observed in the present work. Our various complementary measurements ruling out the possibility of formation of a Cu–TCNQ/Cu–BTEC lattice heterostructure are as follows: (1) the crystalline structure of Cu–BTEC was well-preserved in the doped thin film and the characteristic diffraction peak at 2θ = 5.8° was absent in the pristine Cu–TCNQ thin film (Fig. S16†).32,53 The Raman band of pristine Cu–TCNQ at 520 cm−1 (perhaps due to the Cu⋯Cu interaction mode) was absent in our doped thin film (Fig. S17†). (3) In our EDXS analysis, a uniform presence of elemental oxygen (O) on the surface as well as the cross-section in both pristine and doped thin films was observed (Fig. S18†). (4) In the case of pristine Cu–TCNQ, one main peak in the N 1s XPS signal is expected;54 however, the N 1s XPS spectrum of our doped thin film clearly exhibited two distinctive peaks. (5) The solid-state UV-vis spectra of the pristine Cu–TCNQ thin film and our doped thin film were markedly different (Fig. S19†). (6) Finally, the in-plane I–V characteristics of our doped thin film, both at room-temperature and at high-temperature, were observed to be distinct from those of the pristine Cu–TCNQ thin film (Fig. S20†).32,53
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c9sc03733k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |