Buddha Deka
Boruah
*a,
Angus
Mathieson
ab,
Bo
Wen
ab,
Sascha
Feldmann
c,
Wesley M.
Dose
ad and
Michael
De Volder
*a
aInstitute for Manufacturing, Department of Engineering, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB3 0FS, UK. E-mail: bd411@cam.ac.uk; mfld2@cam.ac.uk
bCambridge Graphene Centre, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB3 0FA, UK
cCavendish Laboratory, University of Cambridge, JJ Thomson Ave, Cambridge CB3 0HE, UK
dDepartment of Chemistry, University of Cambridge, Lensfield Road, Cambridge, CB2 1EW, UK
First published on 23rd June 2020
Batteries that can be directly recharged by light would offer a new approach to balancing the unpredictable energy surpluses and deficits associated with solar energy. Here, we present a new aqueous zinc-ion battery (photo-ZIB) that can directly harvest sunlight to recharge without the need for external solar cells. The light charging process is driven by photo-active cathodes consisting of a mixture of vanadium oxide (V2O5) nanofibers, poly(3-hexylthiophene-2,5-diyl) and reduced graphene oxide, which provide the desired charge separation and storage mechanism. This process is studied using photodetectors, transient absorption spectroscopy and electrochemical analysis in dark and light conditions. The V2O5 cathodes have gravimetric capacities of ∼190 mA h g−1 and ∼370 mA h g−1 in dark and illuminated conditions respectively and photo-conversion efficiencies of ∼1.2%. Finally, we demonstrate a fully functional photo-ZIB with a ∼64 cm2 optical window in pouch cell format.
Broader contextThe development of reliable off-grid power supplies is essential to fight energy poverty in developing rural communities. Solar systems have been identified by the World Bank as a key technology for universal electricity access, yet solar energy is intermittent, and therefore solar cells usually have to be connected to rechargeable batteries or electrochemical capacitors. This increases the cost and complexity of these solutions. To address this issue, we propose a new cathode material for zinc-ion battery that can be recharged directly by light without the need for external solar cells. Instead, the light charging process in these batteries relies on a novel cathode formulation consisting of a mixture of vanadium pentoxide nanofibers mixed with poly(3-hexylthiophene-2,5-diyl) and reduced graphene oxide. These materials offer a good separation of charges as well as ion storage, which allows for direct light charging of the battery. In addition, the proposed zinc-ion batteries are using an aqueous electrolyte resulting in a cost effective and safe solution. This makes these systems suited for the intended deployment in rural communities. Finally, the fabrication of these electrodes is relatively straight forward, which we have demonstrated by fabricating a 100 cm2 pouch cell. |
In this paper, we present the first photo-rechargeable zinc-ion battery (photo-ZIB) with a much improved efficiency relative to previously reported systems (∼1.2% in this work compared to 0.06% for LiFePO4–Ru dye LIB photo-cathode system,15 and 0.034% for 2D perovskite LIB system14). This system is using an aqueous electrolyte and Zn metal electrodes, which are cost effective as compared to other battery technologies.16–18 In addition, Zn metal has a high theoretical capacity (∼820 mA h g−1 or ∼5855 mA h cm−3)19,20 and has a redox potential making it a suitable anode for aqueous electrolyte (Zn2+/Zn −0.76 V vs. standard hydrogen electrode).21,22 The cathode is the photoactive part of our design, which consists of vanadium pentoxide (V2O5) nanofibers mixed with poly(3-hexylthiophene-2,5-diyl) (P3HT) and reduced graphene oxide (rGO) which allows for both solar energy harvesting and charge storage in the same electrode as depicted in the energy band diagram of Fig. 1a (the photo-charging mechanism is discussed further on). V2O5 is selected here because of its high reversible capacity (∼375 mA h g−1)23 and suitable bandgap energy for light harvesting in the visible light spectrum (∼2.2 eV).24 Further, V2O5 nanofibers allow charge conduction along the nanofiber length,25 resulting in lower recombination probabilities of photo-excited carriers before extraction.
Fig. 1b shows an SEM image of the V2O5 nanofibers used in this work, which have a typical diameters of 50 to 100 nm (see synthesis process in methods section) and the TEM inset shows an interplanar spacing of ∼0.204 nm, which corresponds to (202) planes. The absorption spectrum of the V2O5 nanofibers in Fig. 1c shows an optical energy band edge of ∼2.2 eV and XRD data in Fig. 1d confirms the expected orthorhombic crystal structure (space group: Pmmn (59); JCPDS card no: 03-065-0131). Finally, the specific surface area of the V2O5 nanofibers is ∼44.8 m2 g−1 with the BET N2 adsorption/desorption isotherms shown in Fig. S1 (ESI†).
As depicted in Fig. 1a, the energy levels of P3HT and rGO can support the transport of photo-excited electrons from V2O5 nanofibers to the current collector. On the other hand, unpaired photo-induced holes are blocked by P3HT and accumulate in the photo-cathode. To confirm this photo-charge generation and separation process, we measure the photo-current of a photodetector with a layer-by-layer fluorine doped tin oxide coated glass substrate (FTO)/rGO/P3HT/V2O5/Ag structure. An increase in the response current of the photodetector under illumination (λ ∼ 455 nm, intensity ∼2 mW cm−2) in absence of an external bias voltage is observed (see Fig. 2a, ΔI = Ilight − Idark; where Idark and Ilight represent currents in dark and illuminated conditions). This confirms that processes internally drive the separation of photo-excited electrons from V2O5 into FTO through P3HT and rGO. At the same time, P3HT blocks the photo-excited holes to prevent recombination. We verified this by photo-current measurement of a layer-by-layer FTO/P3HT/V2O5/rGO/Ag photodetector (Fig. 2b), where no distinct increase in response current is detected under illumination of light (λ ∼ 455 nm, intensity ∼2 mW cm−2) at 0 V bias voltage. This indicates that permutation of the order of the layers, such that the energies do not align as shown in Fig. 1a, results in no photo-current. Blocking photo-excited holes is important for photo-rechargeable ZIBs as we anticipate they help drive the de-intercalation of Zn2+ ions from the cathode (see further).
Fig. 2 Cyclic response current plots of (a) FTO/rGO/P3HT/V2O5/Ag and (b) FTO/P3HT/V2O5/rGO/Ag (layer-by-layer structure) photodetectors at 0 V bias voltage under periodic illumination (λ ∼ 455 nm, intensity ∼2 mW cm−2). (c) Absolute response current plot of the photo-ZIB (photo-electrode//Zn) under dark and light illuminated (λ ∼ 455 nm, intensity ∼12 mW cm−2) conditions at 0 V applied voltage. (d) TA map of a pristine V2O5 film, excited with a 400 nm pump pulse. (e) Normalised TA kinetics of the main ground state bleach region compared to different combinations of pristine V2O5, V2O5 + rGO (V2O5 and rGO in a 98:2 ratio), V2O5 + P3HT (V2O5 and P3HT in a 98:2 ratio) and V2O5 + rGO + P3HT (V2O5, rGO and P3HT in a 98:1:1 ratio), indicating an enhanced charge carrier lifetime in the photo-electrode composition containing rGO. (f) Ultrafast normalised kinetics integrated spectrally over the same region, taken at the same fluence as in Fig. 2d and Fig S4b, c (ESI†). |
Practical photo-battery electrodes are prepared by mixing V2O5, P3HT, rGO and polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) binder in a 93:1:1:5 ratio, followed by drop-casting on a carbon felt (CF) current collector (Fig. S2 shows SEM image, ESI†) rather than using the above layer-by-layer process (see methods). The form factor of photo-batteries inherently needs to be different from thick classic battery electrodes and instead require large surface area to collect light, akin to solar cells, and therefore have a low areal loading, which is 0.8–1.2 mg cm−2 in this work. The device configuration is depicted in Fig. S3 (ESI†). As shown in Fig. 2c, chronoamperometry measurements of these mixed electrodes against a Zn metal anode in dark and light conditions show the response current increases consistently from 0 μA to ∼9 μA when illuminated (λ ∼ 455 nm). This demonstrates that the desired charge transport properties are maintained in the mixed electrodes. Note that the higher response current in the electrochemical cell test (Fig. 2c) as compared to that of electrical measurement test (Fig. 2a and b) is due to a difference in illuminated light intensity (2 mW cm−2vs. 12 mW cm−2) and the difference in conductivity of the current collector (CF vs. FTO).
Photoluminesence (PL) emissions and transient absorption (TA) spectroscopy measurements of the photo-cathodes are used to understand photo-charge carrier dynamics. The steady state PL emission spectra of pure V2O5 as well as different mixtures with P3HT and rGO are shown in Fig. S4a (ESI†). The spectra show emission at ∼720 nm from the oxygen deficiency state, which may originate from charge channeling, i.e. photo-excited charges generated across the bandgap of V2O5 at ∼520 nm relaxing to lower energy state at ∼720 nm where they recombine radiatively resulting in a PL enhancement at that energy.26 A small enhancement of the lower energy emission is observed upon the addition of P3HT – this is due to P3HT's inherent PL at this wavelength bolstering the aggregate signal. TA spectroscopy was used to probe the charge carrier dynamics of the various electrode compositions to investigate the transport properties between the various components. Fig. 2d shows the TA map of a pristine V2O5 film, with the prominent ground-state bleach around 500 nm present. The absorption spectra are shown in more detail at various pump–probe time delays in Fig. S4b (ESI†) which also displays a small bleach feature at ∼720 nm corresponding to oxygen deficiency states.26 The extraction of the relative charge carrier dynamics and absorption strength is demonstrated for the two states in Fig. S4c (ESI†). Similar data sets are obtained for thin films comprising the V2O5 with rGO and P3HT both individually and combined. The corresponding charge carrier dynamics are shown in Fig. 2e for the various compositions over micro-second timescales. Fig. 2f shows the same TA at ultrafast timescales over the first 20 ps after the pump pulse (in all cases 400 nm). On both the ultrafast and micro-second timescales the addition of rGO results in an increase in the observed charge carrier lifetime due to efficient photo-excited charge carrier transport from the V2O5 to the rGO, as depicted in Fig. 1a. This confirms the effectiveness of rGO as a conductive additive in the final electrode composition in transporting photo-excited electrons throughout the electrode and to the current collector. In contrast, the addition of P3HT alone has the opposite effect. The slight reduction of the TA lifetime in the V2O5 with P3HT sample indicates poor charge transfer between the V2O5 and the P3HT and helps to confirm its role as an effective hole-blocking layer between the V2O5 and the current collector. The full electrode composition (photo-cathode), comprising V2O5, rGO and P3HT exhibits similar TA lifetimes to the V2O5 with P3HT sample, implying that the P3HT effectively coats the V2O5 and/or rGO – preventing effective hole transfer between the two materials. Similar results are demonstrated at ultrafast timescales, shown in Fig. 2f, except that the TA lifetime for the photo-cathode is observed to be slightly longer than the pure V2O5 or V2O5 with P3HT samples at these timescales – indicating that the electron transfer from the V2O5 to the rGO is present at these timescales but is obscured by other processes at longer timescales. Note that in addition to an effective hole-blocking layer, P3HT it is also capable of contributing to additional photo-excited charges. Photons of insufficient energy to excite charges in the V2O5 may still be absorbed by the P3HT (bandgap of ∼2.0 eV) and transfer to the rGO (electrons) and V2O5 (holes), increasing the overall device performance.
Next, the electrochemical responses of the photo-ZIBs are analyzed using cyclic voltammetry (CV) and galvanostatic charge discharge (GCD) techniques in dark and illuminated conditions. As shown in Fig. 3a, the CV curves at different scan rates (0.1 mV s−1 to 1.0 mV s−1) over the potential window of 0.2–1.6 V show two pairs of reduction/oxidation peaks at 0.52/0.72 V (weak peaks) and 0.85/1.1 V (strong peaks), which are caused by the Zn2+ intercalation/de-intercalation reactions.23,27,28 Fig. S5a (ESI†) shows CV curves of the initial five cycles at scan of 0.5 mV s−1 in dark. CV tests of the photo-ZIB in dark and light show an increase in current in illuminated conditions as well as a slight reduction in over potentials (Fig. S5b, ESI,† shows CVs at 0.5 mV s−1 in dark and illuminated). The CV profiles (Fig. 3b) at scan rate of 1.0 mV s−1 show an increase of ∼54% in the swept CV area when illuminating the cell (λ ∼ 455 nm, intensity ∼12 mW cm−2). From the current peak position at different scan rates, we calculate that light increases the diffusion constant of this system by ∼43% and ∼32% for intercalation and de-intercalation respectively (see calculations in ESI†).29 This increase in the diffusion constant under illumination is in agreement with rate enhancements observed in LIBs under illumination.30 CV curves taken at different light intensities (λ ∼ 455 nm, 5 mW cm−2 and 12 mW cm−2) show that current increases with light intensity (Fig. S5c, ESI†) because of the increasing numbers of photo-charge charge carriers available to contribute to the photo-charging mechanism and CV curves as well as electrical photo-responses measured at different wavelengths (420 nm, 455 nm, 470 nm, 528 nm and white light) confirm the photo-response over a large wavelength range (Fig. S5d and S6, ESI†). Finally, CV responses of V2O5–rGO (V2O5, rGO and PVDF in a 93:2:5 ratio) photo-cathodes without P3HT in dark and illuminated conditions show a lesser increase in CV swept area of ∼12% (Fig. S7, ESI†) and hence, the low photo-charge response also confirm the benefits of P3HT as a hole blocking layer in the proposed photo-charging mechanism.
The GCD curves Fig. 3c and d show that the capacity of photo-ZIBs almost doubles from ∼190 mA h g−1 to ∼370 mA h g−1 when exposed to light (λ ∼ 455 nm, intensity ∼12 mW cm−2) at a discharge specific current of 50 mA g−1 and increases from ∼103 mA h g−1 to ∼137 mA h g−1 at faster discharge rates of 1000 mA h g−1, which leave less time for photo harvesting. For completeness, Fig. S8a–c (ESI†) shows the GCDs at 100 mA g−1, 200 mA g−1 and 500 mA g−1 in dark and light. Fig. 3e shows the rate capacities of the photo-ZIB in dark and light, demonstrating that even at very high specific currents of 2000 mA g−1, illumination still results in a ∼60% of capacity increase. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS 10 mHz to 100 kHz at voltage amplitude of 10 mV) was carried out after the second galvanostatic discharge cycle to 1.0 V with 1 h rest, and in dark and light (λ ∼ 455 nm, intensity ∼12 mW cm−2). As shown in Fig. 3f the charge transfer resistance (Rct) decreases from ∼446 Ω cm2 to ∼123 Ω cm2 when illuminated, whereas the high frequency series resistance decreases only from 67 Ω cm2 to ∼65.5 Ω cm2. Further, ex situ XRD (Fig. S9b, ESI†) and Raman (Fig. S9c, ESI†) at different states of discharge and charge confirm the charge storage reversibility of the photo-electrode during cycling. Moreover, Fig. 4a shows the long-term cycling measurement at a specific current of 500 mA g−1. The increase in the capacity at initial few cycles could be due to the activation of photo-cathode material, where similar characteristics are also observed in previous reports of V2O5 based ZIBs.27,31 Moreover, the subsequent capacity fading after 30 cycles could be due to direct drop casting of the photo-cathode material on the CF current collector without used of standard battery electrode conductive additive (e.g. SuperP). Moreover, the lower coulombic efficiencies at initial few cycles (∼98% in the first cycle) could be attributed from severe dendrite growth and self-corrosion of the Zn anode in aqueous electrolyte.32,33
Finally, in addition to the above CV and GCD measurements, we charge the photo-ZIBs by light only (i.e. without applied current) and discharge with fixed specific currents. Fig. 4b shows the photo-charging process (λ ∼455 nm, intensity ∼12 mW cm−2) as well as the discharge at a specific current of 100 mA m−2. Moreover, we can increase the capacity by illuminating the device with light while discharging (Fig. 4b). As shown in Fig. 4b, the voltage of the photo-charged photo-ZIB very slowly drops from 0.95 V to 0.715 V when discharged under light. This is due to the simultaneous actions of photo-charging and potentiostatic discharging. A nearly constant voltage response can be achieved when the photo-charge and discharge current rates are in equilibrium under illumination. Once the light is turned off, the voltage reduces to 0.2 V, following the discharge curve expected from the dark measurements. Fig. S10 (ESI†) shows the discharge curves at different specific currents in dark condition. The photo-conversion efficiency of the photo-ZIB is 1.2% using η = EAA1/PintA2 (where, EA is the areal energy density, Pin the light intensity, t is photo-charging time, A1 is the surface area of the photo-ZIB and A2 is the illuminated surface area).34 This value is higher than the previously reported efficiencies of 0.03–0.06% for photo-rechargeable LIBs.14,15 In addition, Fig. 4c shows that photo-ZIBs charged only by light can power a commercial sensor and its display (here a 1.5 V Digital Thermo-Hygrometer TFA, MPN: 30.5005). Finally, we demonstrate a larger scale implementation of photo-ZIBs in a ∼100 cm2 pouch cell with a ∼64 cm2 optical window (see Fig. 4d and photo-charging and discharge profiles in Fig. 4e).
This report demonstrates a high-performance photo-rechargeable aqueous photo-ZIB, which can be charged by light and whose capacity can almost be doubled under illumination. The photo-active cathodes of these photo-ZIBs consist of V2O5 nanofibers mixed with P3HT and rGO. These cathodes have a good absorption in the visible spectrum and allow for the separation and storage of charges needed for direct light charging without the use of solar cells. This mechanism is studied by testing photo-detectors, TA measurements, as well as GCD and CV measurements in dark and light conditions. The proposed photo-ZIBs achieve light conversion efficiencies of 1.2%, which is the highest reported for photo batteries to our knowledge, and we demonstrate that they can be implemented in both small coin cells and large pouch cells.
3 g of the V2O5 powder (Sigma-Aldrich) is mixed with a 2 M aqueous NaCl solution (100 ml) while stirring (300 rpm) at room temperature for 72 h. In this process, dissolution and recrystallization of V2O5 take place to form nanofibers.23 The resulting brownish suspension was washed with deionized water and ethanol followed by centrifugation and finally dried at ∼80 °C for 12 h in a vacuum oven.
The rGO was obtained by direct reduction of graphene oxide (Graphenea) at ∼350 °C (∼3 h) in hydrogen gas (∼100 sccm) and helium gas (∼100 sccm) environment using tubular atmospheric pressure CVD furnace.
Morphologies and crystal structures of the materials are characterized by SEM (FEI Magellan 400L with an acceleration voltage of 5 kV) and XRD (Bruker D8 Advance, Cu Kα radiation). Further, Raman spectroscopy and Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) surface area characterizations are employed using Renishaw InVia and Micromeritics 3Flex (under nitrogen environment). The optical absorbance of the materials are studied using PerkinElmer UV/VIS/NIR Spectrometer (Lambda 750).
The electrical photoresponses of V2O5 nanofibers are studied by drop casting the V2O5 nanofibers on Gold (Au)/Chromium (Cr) (40/10 nm) Inter Digitated Electrodes (IDEs) patterned on a Si3N4/Si wafer by standard UV lithographic technique. The current–voltage measurements are recorded in the voltage range −2 V to +2 V both in dark and illuminated conditions. Further, current–time photo-responses are measured by applying a 2 V bias voltage under periodic illumination of different light wavelengths of 455 nm, 528 nm, and white light.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d0ee01392g |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |