Chuangchuang
Xu
and
Jiaxi
Xu
*
State Key Laboratory of Chemical Resource Engineering, Department of Organic Chemistry, College of Chemistry, Beijing University of Chemical Technology, Beijing 100029, People's Republic of China. E-mail: jxxu@mail.buct.edu.cn
First published on 26th November 2019
Tandem Meinwald rearrangement and nucleophilic substitution of oxiranenitriles was realized. Arylacetic acid derivatives were readily synthesized from 3-aryloxirane-2-carbonitriles with amines, alcohols, or water in the presence of boron trifluoride under microwave irradiation, and the designed synthetic strategy includes introducing a cyano leaving group into arylepoxides and capturing the in situ generated toxic cyanide with boron trifluoride, making the reaction efficient, safe, and environmentally benign. The reaction occurs through an acid-promoted Meinwald rearrangement, producing arylacetyl cyanides, followed by an addition–elimination process with nitrogen or oxygen-containing nucleophilic amines, alcohols or water. The current method provides a new application of the tandem Meinwald rearrangement.
Meinwald rearrangement, a rearrangement reaction of epoxides into aldehydes or ketones by ring-opening and 1,2-shift of hydride or alkyl groups, is a classical monofunctional group conversion reaction that has been widely used in organic and drug syntheses, and even in total syntheses of natural products (Scheme 1a).3 The rearrangement reaction generally occurs in the presence of protonic acids,4 Lewis acids,5 or nucleophiles,6 in which the rearrangement products such as aldehydes or ketones are identified by the formation of the most stable carbenium intermediates, and the migratory aptitude of the substituents attached to the epoxide moiety, Lewis acids or nucleophiles, and solvents. Since the reaction was first reported by Meinwald in 1963,7 it has been studied in-depth and a series of modified Meinwald rearrangement reactions have been developed.4–6 Additionally, the Meinwald rearrangement in tandem processes has also attracted considerable attention for its new application in synthetic organic chemistry.8–18
On the basis of the Meinwald rearrangement mechanism (Scheme 1a), we envisioned that if a leaving group is introduced into epoxides, they undergo a Meinwald rearrangement (1,2-hydride shift) to produce highly reactive acyl derivatives with a leaving group. The acyl derivatives further react with nucleophiles to give more stable carboxylic acid derivatives (Scheme 1b). In addition, compared to other epoxides possessing a leaving group, oxirane-2-carbonitriles (cyanoepoxides) can be easily prepared from aldehydes and chloroacetonitrile by the Darzens reaction19 and cyanide is a good leaving group.20 Thus, oxirane-2-carbonitriles were eventually selected to explore above idea. A microwave-assisted BF3·OEt2-promoted method to synthesize arylacetic acid derivatives from 3-aryloxirane-2-carbonitriles with nitrogen and oxygen nucleophiles via a tandem Meinwald rearrangement and nucleophilic substitution was developed. Inexpensive and readily available boron trifluoride etherate first acts as a Lewis acid to promote the Meinwald rearrangement and then functions as a scavenger to capture the in situ generated toxic cyanide,21 making the reaction safe and environmentally benign. The reaction features the advantages of microwave irradiation acceleration, short reaction time, metal-free synthesis, readily accessible starting materials, and a wide substrate scope. Such a strategy would not only provide a new application of the Meinwald rearrangement, but also be of importance in the synthesis of arylacetic acids, arylacetates, arylacetamides, and a series of arylacetic acid derivatives that widely exist in nature and drugs.22
Entry | 2a/equiv. | Acid/equiv. | Conditions | Time | Yield/% |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Reactions were conducted on a 0.5 mmol scale of cis-1a in 5 mL of anhydrous 1,4-dioxane. All yields are yields of the isolated products. b Commercial solvent was used. c A high boiling-point solvent of dipropyleneglycol dimethyl ether was used. d A mixture solvent of dipropyleneglycol dimethyl ether and 1,4-dioxane (2:3, v:v) was used. e Anhydrous cyclopentyl methyl ether was used as the solvent. f Indole derivative was obtained in 30% yield as the byproduct. g B(C6F5)3 was used as a Lewis acid instead of BF3·OEt2. | |||||
1b | 1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | Refluxed | 9 h | 42 |
2b | 1 | AlCl3/1.3 | Refluxed | 9 h | Trace |
3b | 1 | ZnCl2/1.3 | Refluxed | 9 h | Trace |
4b | 1 | FeCl3/1.3 | Refluxed | 9 h | 34 |
5b | 1 | FeCl2/1.3 | Refluxed | 9 h | Trace |
6b | 1 | TsOH·H2O/1.3 | Refluxed | 9 h | 15 |
7 | 1.1 | BF 3 ·OEt 2 /1.3 | Refluxed | 9 h | 57 |
8b | 1.2 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | Refluxed | 9 h | 43 |
9b | 1.5 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | Refluxed | 9 h | 39 |
10b | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/0.5 | Refluxed | 9 h | 23 |
11b | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/0.8 | Refluxed | 9 h | 31 |
12b | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.0 | Refluxed | 9 h | 36 |
13b | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.1 | Refluxed | 9 h | 48 |
14b | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.2 | Refluxed | 9 h | 46 |
15b | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.4 | Refluxed | 9 h | 41 |
16b | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/2.0 | Refluxed | 9 h | 34 |
17b | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/110 °C | 1 h | 50 |
18 | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/110 °C | 1 h | 59 |
19 | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/120 °C | 1 h | 62 |
20 | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/140 °C | 1 h | 64 |
21 | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/160 °C | 1 h | 66 |
22 | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/180 °C | 60 min | 72 |
23 | 1.1 | BF 3 ·OEt 2 /1.3 | MW/180 °C | 30 min | 72 |
24 | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/180 °C | 10 min | 69 |
25 | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/180 °C | 20 min | 70 |
26 | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/180 °C | 40 min | 68 |
27 | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/180 °C | 80 min | 69 |
28 | 1.1 | BF 3 ·OEt 2 /1.3 | MW/190 °C | 30 min | 77 |
29 | 1.0 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/190 °C | 30 min | 71 |
30 | 1.2 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/190 °C | 30 min | 68 |
31 | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.2 | MW/110 °C | 30 min | 70 |
32 | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.4 | MW/110 °C | 30 min | 62 |
33c | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/190 °C | 30 min | 48 |
34d | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/190 °C | 30 min | 42 |
35e | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/190 °C | 30 min | 24f |
36g | 1.1 | BF3·OEt2/1.3 | MW/190 °C | 30 min | 45 |
To test the influence of different diastereomers of cyanoepoxide 1a, trans-1a was subjected to the optimal conditions, affording product 3a in 52% yield, lower than that of its cis-diastereomer cis-1a (Scheme 2).
With the optimal conditions in hand, cis-cyanoepoxides cis-1 were applied. The scope and generality of the reaction with different nitrogen-containing nucleophiles 2 were investigated and the results are summarized in Table 2. For different anilines 2, both electron-withdrawing and electron-donating substituted anilines were well suited for the reaction and gave the corresponding products in acceptable to good yields (3b–3j). p,m,o-Toluidines gave the corresponding products 3b, 3c, and 3d in 78%, 57%, and 64% yields, respectively. The lower yields of o,m-toluidines can be attributed to the slight steric hindrance (o-isomer) and the electron-withdrawing property (m-isomer), respectively. 4-Methoxyaniline gave 3e in 81% yield, but 4-hydroxyaniline generated 3f in 61% yield, which may be due to the stronger interaction between the hydroxyl group and BF3, making the oxonium in the BF3-coordinated hydroxyl group an electron-withdrawing group. Additionally, 4-fluoro, 4-chloro, 4-bromo, and 4-cyano substituted anilines gave 3g–3j in 66%, 65%, 76%, and 45% yields, respectively. For aliphatic amines, phenylmethanamine and propan-1-amine were also evaluated to give the corresponding products 3k and 3l in 53% and 43% yields, respectively. The lower yields compared to anilines are possibly attributed to the stronger basicity of aliphatic amines, making them slightly strong interaction with Lewis acid BF3, decreasing their nucleophilicity. Furthermore, functionalized aniline ethyl 4-aminobenzoate gave the desired product 3m in 46% yield. Besides, N-methylaniline was used to generate 3n in 63% yield. Finally, the reactions of different 3-aryloxirane-2-carbonitriles with anilines were conducted. cis-3-Phenyloxirane-2-carbonitrile (cis-1b) gave 3o in 66% yield. cis-3-Aryloxirane-2-carbonitrile with an electron-donating group on the phenyl ring, such as cis-3-(4-methyl)oxirane-2-carbonitrile (cis-1c), yielded product 3p in 55% yield. cis-3-(4-Fluorophenyl)oxirane-2-carbonitrile (cis-1d) produced 3q in 55% yield. The electron-withdrawing substrate cis-3-(4-chlorophenyl)oxirane-2-carbonitrile (cis-1e) gave product 3r in 66% yield. Besides, cis-3-(2-bromophenyl)- and cis-3-(3-bromophenyl)oxirane-2-carbonitriles (cis-1f and cis-1g) gave products 3s and 3t in 48% and 46% yields, respectively.
a Reaction conditions: cis-1 (0.5 mmol), 2 (0.55 mmol), and BF3·OEt2 (0.65 mmol) in 5 mL of anhydrous 1,4-dioxane were stirred at 190 °C for 30 min under microwave irradiation in a sealed vessel. Yields of the isolated products are indicated. |
---|
To further study the influence of different diastereomers of cyanoepoxides on the yield of the tandem reaction, trans-3-(4-fluorophenyl)oxirane-2-carbonitrile (trans-1d) was also examined under the optimal conditions, giving product 3q in 54% yield, almost the same yield as that of its cis-diastereomer cis-1e (Table 2). The results indicate that both cis- and trans-cyanoepoxides 1 can undergo the Meinwald rearrangement and subsequent displacement under our reaction conditions.
In addition to nitrogen-containing nucleophiles, oxygen-containing nucleophiles are also suitable for this reaction to generate the corresponding arylacetic acids and their esters after optimization of the reaction conditions. The optimized reaction conditions for alcohols are that cis-cyanoepoxide cis-1 (0.5 mmol), alcohol 4 (0.9 mmol), and BF3·OEt2 (0.5 mmol) in 5 mL of anhydrous 1,4-dioxane were stirred at 175 °C for 30 min under microwave irradiation in a sealed vessel (for details, see Table S2 in the ESI†). The best reaction conditions to prepare arylacetic acids are just changing the nucleophile to H2O and loading amount of BF3·OEt2 to 1.2 equivalents (for details, see Table S3 in the ESI†).
With the optimal reaction conditions, the generality of the reaction with different oxygen-containing nucleophiles 4 was evaluated (Table 3). The reactions of cis-3-(4-bromophenyl)oxirane-2-carbonitrile (cis-1a) with several alcohols were first investigated. Anhydrous ethanol and methanol gave 5a (53% yield) and 5b (43% yield), respectively. Besides, long-chain anhydrous alcohols n-hexanol and 4-methylpentanol produced 5c and 5d in 55% and 54% yields, respectively. Additionally, (+)-endo-norborneol also gave product 5e in 48% yield. Furthermore, different 3-aryloxirane-2-carbonitriles were reacted with anhydrous ethanol. cis-3-(4-Methylphenyl)- and 3-(4-chlorophenyl)oxirane-2-carbonitriles (cis-1b and cis-1c) gave products 5f and 5g in 42%, and 44% yields, respectively.
a Reaction conditions: cis-1 (0.5 mmol), 4 (0.9 mmol), and BF3·OEt2 (0.5 mmol) in 5 mL of anhydrous 1,4-dioxane were stirred at 175 °C for 30 min under microwave irradiation in a sealed vessel. Yields of the isolated products are indicated. b cis-1 (0.5 mmol), 4 (0.6 mmol), and BF3·OEt2 (0.6 mmol) were used. |
---|
Finally, the reactions of different cis-3-aryloxirane-2-carbonitriles with water were investigated. cis-3-Aryloxirane-2-carbonitriles with both electron-withdrawing and electron-donating groups on the aryl ring were well suited for the reaction, giving the corresponding arylacetic acids 5h–5m in moderate to good yields ranging from 52% to 78%. For further application, cis-3-(naphthalene-2-yl) and 3-(naphthalene-1-yl)oxirane-2-carbonitriles (cis-1h and cis-1i) were used and gave products 5n and 5o in 49% and 40% yields, respectively. 2-(Naphthalen-1-yl)acetic acid (5o) is a synthetic plant hormone in the auxin family and is an ingredient in many commercial plant rooting horticultural products. It can be used for the vegetative propagation of plants by stem and leaf cutting. It is also used for plant tissue culture.23
Overall, the designed reaction possesses a wide substrate scope and produces arylacetic acids, arylacetates, arylacetamides, and a series of arylacetic acid derivatives.
Yields of most products are in a moderate range. In the case of nitrogen nucleophiles, side reactions for the formation of indole derivatives occur sometimes.19 Additionally, in the cases of oxygen nucleophiles, relatively low yields were obtained probably because of the stronger interaction between BF3 and the oxygen atom, further forming [B(OR)2F2]− or [B(OH)2F2]− and resulting in lower concentration of oxygen nucleophiles in the reaction mixture.
To gain insight into the reaction mechanism, control experiments were conducted and are summarized in Scheme 3. The reaction of cis-1a under the standard conditions without any nucleophiles was investigated and 2-(4-bromophenyl)acetyl cyanide (6a) was observed in both HRMS and 1H NMR spectra, indicating that cyanoepoxide cis-1a truly underwent the Meinwald rearrangement, producing the corresponding arylacetyl cyanide 6a under our reaction conditions. However, a mixture of 5h and 6a was isolated after work-up (Scheme 3a and c). Besides, when the reaction mixture was quenched with water before purification, only 24% of 5h was isolated and no product 6a was detected, revealing that 2-(4-bromophenyl)acetyl cyanide (6a) is unstable and a water sensitive compound. Previously, Mohan and coworkers reported that 3-phenyloxirane-2-carbonitrile (1b) could not generate the Meinwald rearrangement product when it was refluxed in DCM under the catalysis of 0.1 mol% of Bi(OTf)3.24 Here, cis-3-phenyloxirane-2-carbonitrile (cis-1b) was examined under the catalysis of 0.1 mol% of Bi(OTf)3 in anhydrous 1,4-dioxane at 190 °C for 30 min under microwave irradiation in a sealed vessel. The corresponding 2-phenylacetyl cyanide (6b) was detected by GC-MS. Product 6b shows a different retention time and mass spectral fragmentation from cyanoepoxide 1b. Moreover, cis-3-phenyloxirane-2-carbonitrile (cis-1b) was reacted with 1.1 equivalents of water under the catalysis of 0.1 mol% of Bi(OTf)3 in anhydrous 1,4-dioxane at 190 °C for 30 min under microwave irradiation in a sealed vessel, eventually giving 5i in 43% yield. The results further prove that cyanoepoxides can undergo the Meinwald rearrangement, producing the corresponding acyl cyanides at a higher temperature (Scheme 3d and e).
Based on the reported mechanism of the Meinwald rearrangement4–6 and our experimental results, the following plausible mechanism is proposed (Scheme 4). The reactions with nitrogen- and oxygen-nucleophiles exhibit different mechanisms. For the reaction with nitrogen nucleophiles 2, BF3·OEt2 first coordinates with epoxides 1 to afford intermediates I, followed by ring-opening of the epoxide ring to give benzylic carbocation intermediates II. The predominant formation of the benzylic carbocations makes the ring-opening regiospecific.25 The intermediates II undergo a 1,2-hydride shift to generate arylacetyl cyanides III. They possess high reactivity and easily undergo an addition–elimination process with nitrogen nucleophiles 2 to give substitution products arylacetic amide derivatives 3 through tetrahedral intermediates IV, which eliminate a cyanotrifluoroborate anion because the coordination between BF3 and cyanide is stronger than that between BF3 and Et2O.
In the case of oxygen nucleophiles 4, oxygen nucleophiles 4 (alcohols and water) first react with BF3 to generate super acids H[B(OR)F3],26 which can dissociate into protons and [B(OR)F3]− ([B(OH)F3]− when water is used as an oxygen nucleophile). Protons can catalyze epoxides to undergo a Meinwald rearrangement to form protonated arylacetyl cyanides VII through intermediates V and VI. When alcohols are used as oxygen nucleophiles, they nucleophilically attack intermediates VII to generate tetrahedral intermediates VIII, which eliminate cyanide. Cyanide and [B(OR)F3]− generate [B(CN)F3]− and alcohols ROH after proton transfer from protonated products 5 to the RO group in [B(OR)F3]−. However, when water is used as an oxygen nucleophile, because equal amounts of BF3 and water are added, no free water exists in the reaction system. It should be noted that [B(OH)F3]− nucleophilically attacks intermediates VII to form tetrahedral intermediates IX, which eliminates H[B(CN)F3] to afford arylacetic acids 5h–o. Although the amount of alcohols is more than that of BF3 when alcohols are used as nucleophiles, a similar process of [B(OR)F3]− instead of [B(OH)F3]− as an oxygen nucleophile nucleophilically attacking intermediates VII is not exclusive in the synthesis of arylacetates 5a–g.
Cyanotrifluoroborate [−B(CN)F3], even dicyanodifluoroborate [−B(CN)2F2], tricyanofluoroborate [−B(CN)3F], and tetracyanoborate [−B(CN)4] were prepared previously from the reaction of boron trifluoride etherate or potassium tetrafluoroborate and potassium cyanide in acetonitrile21a or trimethylsilyl cyanide and potassium tetrafluoridoborate,21b respectively. This is the reason why more than one equivalent of BF3 is required in our reaction. In all reactions, the amount of BF3 is no less than that of cyanoepoxides to capture the in situ generated toxic cyanide, keeping no free cyanide in the reaction mixture. [−B(CN)4] is stable in water.21b revealing that cyanotrifluoroborate cannot release CN− when treated with aqueous solution during workup, making the procedure safe and environmentally benign.
In our previous work, 3-aryloxirane-2-carbonitriles 1 reacted with anilines 2 catalyzed by a catalytic amount of BF3·OEt2 or AlCl3 in the presence of trifluoroethanol, producing indoles.19 However, in this work, 3-aryloxirane-2-carbonitriles 1 reacted with anilines 2 catalyzed by a stoichiometric amount of BF3·OEt2 in 1,4-dioxane under higher temperature conditions, giving the Meinwald rearrangement products followed by nucleophilic addition and elimination, affording arylacetic derivatives. By comparing the differences of these two reaction conditions, we think that 1,4-dioxane as the solvent and a higher reaction temperature make it easier for cyanoepoxides to undergo the Meinwald rearrangement process, producing arylacetyl cyanides as key intermediates followed by the substitution of nucleophilic amines, alcohols, and water to afford the final products arylacetic acids and their derivatives. But refluxing in alcohols under lower temperature conditions makes the ring-opening process easy, followed by intramolecular aromatic electrophilic substitution, generating the indole products. This is the reason why in a previous report cyanoepoxides could not generate the corresponding products acyl cyanides.24
Commercial-grade reagents and solvents were used as received without further purification unless otherwise noted, and anhydrous solvents were purified using the standard processes. The reaction pressure was about 200 psi when reactions were conducted in 1,4-dioxane at 190 °C under microwave irradiation in a sealed vessel. All 3-aryloxirane-2-carbonitriles 1 used in this work were synthesized in our previous work.19,27
Caution: After workup, the waste silica gel and water should be treated with aqueous sodium hypochloride solution for decomposition of the possibly present cyanide residue.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Tables S1, S2, and S3 on the optimization of the reaction conditions; full spectroscopic data for all isolated compounds 1, 3, 5 and 6a; HRMS of 6a; and GC-Mass of 1a, 1b and 6b. See DOI: 10.1039/c9ob02428j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |