Maomao
He‡
a,
Jie
Li‡
a,
Hesong
Han
a,
Clarissa Araujo
Borges
b,
Gabriel
Neiman
a,
Joachim Justad
Røise
ac,
Piotr
Hadaczek
d,
Rima
Mendonsa
e,
Victoria R.
Holm
e,
Ross C.
Wilson
e,
Krystof
Bankiewicz
d,
Yumiao
Zhang
af,
Corinne M.
Sadlowski
a,
Kevin
Healy
a,
Lee W.
Riley
b and
Niren
Murthy
*ae
aDepartment of Bioengineering, University of California Berkeley, University Avenue, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA. E-mail: nmurthy@berkeley.edu
bDepartment of Public Health, University of California Berkeley, University Avenue, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA
cDepartment of Chemistry, University of California Berkeley, University Avenue, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA
dDepartment of Neurological Surgery, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210, USA
eInnovative Genomics Institute, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94704, USA
fSchool of Chemical Engineering and Technology, Tianjin University, 300350, China
First published on 12th August 2020
Reduction sensitive linkers (RSLs) have the potential to transform the field of drug delivery due to their ease of use and selective cleavage in intracellular environments. However, despite their compelling attributes, developing reduction sensitive self-immolative linkers for aliphatic amines has been challenging due to their poor leaving group ability and high pKa values. Here a traceless self-immolative linker composed of a dithiol-ethyl carbonate connected to a benzyl carbamate (DEC) is presented, which can modify aliphatic amines and release them rapidly and quantitatively after disulfide reduction. DEC was able to reversibly modify the lysine residues on CRISPR–Cas9 with either PEG, the cell penetrating peptide Arg10, or donor DNA, and generated Cas9 conjugates with significantly improved biological properties. In particular, Cas9–DEC–PEG was able to diffuse through brain tissue significantly better than unmodified Cas9, making it a more suitable candidate for genome editing in animals. Furthermore, conjugation of Arg10 to Cas9 with DEC was able to generate a self-delivering Cas9 RNP that could edit cells without transfection reagents. Finally, conjugation of donor DNA to Cas9 with DEC increased the homology directed DNA repair (HDR) rate of the Cas9 RNP by 50% in HEK 293T cell line. We anticipate that DEC will have numerous applications in biotechnology, given the ubiquitous presence of aliphatic amines on small molecule and protein therapeutics.
An important application of RSLs is for the reversible modification of lysine residues on proteins. For example, a wide number of compounds have been developed that can improve the therapeutic efficacy of proteins, such as PEG or cell penetrating peptides.10–12 These adjuvants need to be conjugated to proteins in order to enhance protein delivery. Lysine residues are ubiquitously present on proteins and can be easily modified under mild aqueous conditions because of their high nucleophilicity, and are therefore an attractive target for conjugating adjuvants to proteins. However, lysine residues are also frequently essential for protein activity and extensive modification usually compromises protein activity. Therefore, RSLs that can reversibly modify lysine residues have the potential to overcome this limitation and thus service as a promising strategy for protein delivery.13
Two major classes of RSLs have been developed to modify aliphatic amines, which are disulfide carbamates (DCBs)14,15 and dithiobenzyl carbamates (DTBs).16–18 Even though DCBs and DTBs (Fig. S1†) have demonstrated the great potential of RSLs in prodrug design, they have not found widespread applications for protein delivery due to their slow self-immolation rates or incomplete release. There is consequently great interest in developing new amine-modifying RSLs that can modify the lysine residues of proteins in a traceless manner.13,19
In this report, we present a traceless self-immolative linker, which is composed of a dithiol-ethyl carbonate linker combined with a benzyl carbamate linker, termed DEC (Fig. 1a). DEC is composed of two rapidly hydrolyzing self-immolative linkers connected in series, and this unique design allows it to overcome the challenges associated with making RSLs for aliphatic amines. The two linkers embedded in DEC are a thiol-ethyl carbonate linker and a 1,6-elimination linker.20 These two linkers were selected for incorporation in DEC because they individually release alcohols instantaneously and amines after activation. Specifically, the thiol-ethyl carbonate linker rapidly releases a cyclic thiol ether after disulfide reduction, and the 1,6-elimination linker rapidly releases aliphatic amines. Our hypothesis is that by combining the thiol-ethyl carbonate linker with the 1,6-elimination linker, we would generate a novel RSL which rapidly releases amines through a two-step release mechanism after reduction (Fig. 1a). In step 1, the thiol-ethyl carbonate linker of DEC is reduced, generating a free thiol which spontaneously cyclizes into a cyclic ether, causing the hydrolysis of the carbonate in DEC and the release of a phenol. In step 2 the phenol intermediate triggers the 1,6-elimination process to release the aliphatic amine. In this paper, DEC was used to develop new prodrugs and also modify the genome editing enzyme CRISPR–Cas9 (ref. 21) with PEG, CPPs and donor DNA (Fig. 1b). We anticipate that DEC has numerous potential applications in biotechnology given the ubiquitous presence of aliphatic amines on small molecules and protein therapeutics.22
We performed additional experiments to investigate if the ciprofloxacin released from PEG–DEC–Cipro was biologically active, given that modification of the amine of ciprofloxacin causes its inactivation. The minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of PEG–DEC–Cipro was measured in the presence of GSH (10 mM) on E. coli SF207, a clinical strain resistant to a variety of antibiotics, isolated from a patient with bloodstream infection (see ESI page S11† for detail). Table S1† shows that the MIC of PEG–DEC–Cipro was 0.25 μg mL−1 (at an equivalent dose of ciprofloxacin) in the presence of GSH (10 mM), which is the same as free ciprofloxacin, while the MIC is much higher without GSH (>1 μg mL−1).
An important application of amine reactive self-immolative linkers is for the reversible modification of lysine residues on proteins. For example, a wide number of compounds have been developed that can improve the therapeutic efficacy of proteins, such as PEG or cell penetrating peptides.10–12 These adjuvants need to be conjugated to proteins in order to enhance protein delivery. However, this remains challenging due to the lack of efficient linkers that can reversibly modify aliphatic amines. We therefore investigated if DEC could reversibly modify the lysine residues of proteins, and if it exhibited the same benefits over the DTB and DCB linkers, when attached to proteins.
CRISPR–Cas9 was selected as a model protein for investigation and was PEGylated with DEC. Cas9 is an excellent testbed for investigating the self-immolative nature of DEC because it has multiple lysine residues in its active site, and widespread modification of the lysine residues will result in its inactivation.25 In addition, there is currently great interest in PEGylating Cas9, which has the potential to address several of the challenges associated with Cas9 delivery, in particular, its immunogenicity, slow diffusion through tissue and proteolysis in serum.26
mCherryCas9 (a Cas9 variant that is fused to mCherry) was PEGylated using the DEC, DTB or DCB linkers (Fig. 3a and S8†), and the release of PEG and the regeneration of Cas9 nuclease activity was determined after GSH reduction. Fig. S9† and 3b demonstrate that mCherryCas9 was efficiently PEGylated by all three linkers, but only the DEC linker efficiently released PEG after reduction for 1 hour (98% vs. 34% and 29%). Fig. 3c demonstrates that the nuclease activity of mCherryCas9 was significantly inhibited by PEGylation, regardless of the linker used. However, the nuclease activity of Cas9 PEGylated with DEC was significantly increased after reduction with GSH. In contrast, GSH reduction caused minor increases in nuclease activity in mCherryCas9 samples PEGylated with the DTB or DCB linkers, presumably due to incomplete amine release (80% vs. 23% and 19%).
We evaluated the stability of mCherryCas9–DEC–PEG in plasma, to determine if it had the extracellular stability needed for in vivo applications. Fig. S11† demonstrates that mCherryCas9–DEC–PEG was stable in plasma and had a t1/2 > 20 hours, but was rapidly reduced in the presence of intracellular levels of GSH (t1/2 < 4 hours). PEGylated Cas9 has numerous potential advantages over wild type Cas9, such as lower immunogenicity and improved diffusion through tissue, which is essential for genome editing in a clinical setting. We performed experiments to investigate if Cas9–DEC–PEG could efficiently diffuse through the striatum after an intracranial injection and compared its tissue distribution with unmodified Cas9. We selected the brain as a testbed for Cas9–DEC–PEG because the poor diffusion of Cas9 through brain tissue is a key challenge that needs to be overcome before the clinical potential of Cas9 can be fully realized.27–29 A fluorescently labeled Cas9 (Alexa488Cas9) and Alexa488Cas9–DEC–PEG5k were injected and infused bilaterally into the left and right striatum of mice at a concentration of 1 μg μL−1. The distribution of the injected Alexa488Cas9 or Alexa488Cas9–DEC–PEG5k was then determined based on fluorescent imaging and immunohistological staining (IHC) for Cas9 (Fig. 3d and S13†). Fig. 3d indicates that Alexa488Cas9–DEC–PEG5k diffused through the striatum significantly better than its unmodified counterpart (Alexa488Cas9), and had a volume of distribution (Vd) that was 3.7-fold higher than native Alexa488Cas9 (Table S2†). Collectively these results demonstrate that the DEC linker can reversibly modify the lysine residues of proteins (Cas9) and has the stability in biological fluids needed for in vivo applications.
Next, we investigated if cell penetrating peptides (CPPs) could be conjugated to Cas9 using a DEC linker. CPPs have great potential for enhancing the delivery of Cas9 into cells, and have been extensively explored for Cas9 delivery.30–32 However, linkers that can reversibly conjugate CPPs to Cas9 have not been studied. CPP–DEC was synthesized, which is composed of a fluorescent cell penetrating peptide FITC–Arg10Lys1 connected to the DEC linker, and was then conjugated to Cas9 (Fig. 4a, S14 and S15†).33 Cas9/CPP–DEC conjugation reactions were performed at various molar ratios, ranging from a 10 to 500-fold molar excess of CPP–DEC to Cas9 (Fig. 4b).
An in vitro cleavage assay was performed to test the activity of Cas9–CPP with or without GSH (Fig. 4c and S16†). Fig. 4c shows that Cas9 conjugated with CPP–DEC can regain its nuclease activity after reduction with GSH in a ratio-dependent manner. For example, the nuclease activity of Cas9 was significantly reduced after conjugation with a 50–250 fold excess of CPP–DEC, but was recovered after GSH reduction. However, bioconjugation reactions done at a 500 molar excess of CPP–DEC resulted in only partial activation of the Cas9 RNP under the same conditions, presumably due to denaturation of the protein, incomplete reduction of DEC, or electrostatistic interactions between the conjugated CPPs and the gRNA. Cas9–CPP conjugates made at a 100/1 molar ratio were selected for further investigation. This preparation was analyzed by the BCA assay and fluorescence spectroscopy, and had an average of 40 CPPs per Cas9 protein. The Cas9–CPP conjugate was analyzed by gel electrophoresis to verify that the CPPs could be cleaved from the Cas9 protein after reduction. Fig. S15† demonstrates that CPP–DEC was covalently conjugated to Cas9 or mCherryCas9 and was also released in the presence of cellular concentrations of GSH (10 mM). The release kinetics of the CPPs from Cas9–CPP was determined using gel electrophoresis. Cas9–CPP was mixed with GSH (10 mM) for different durations and release of the CPPs was determined by quantification of the FITC fluorescence on the Cas9–CPP. Fig. 4d demonstrates that the CPPs are released rapidly from Cas9 under intracellular GSH concentrations, with a release half-life of 5 minutes.
The ability of Cas9–CPP to edit cells was investigated. Cas9–CPP (33 μg mL−1) containing a gRNA that cleaves the eGFP gene was incubated with HEK293T eGFP cells. After 72 hours, the genomic DNA was extracted and the eGFP gene was amplified by PCR, and analyzed by Sanger sequencing (Fig. 5a). The HEK293T eGFP cells were also analyzed by flow cytometry (Fig. S17†). As a control, Cas9 RNP was transfected with lipofectamine 2000.34Fig. 5a shows that Cas9–CPP delivered functional Cas9 RNP into cells and edited 5.1% of the eGFP gene in HEK cells, which was comparable to lipofectamine delivered Cas9 RNP (4.1%), as determined by TIDE analysis. Cas9 RNP by itself had nearly no editing activity in cells without transfection reagents.
Further experiments were performed to study if CPP–DEC could enhance the internalization of Cas9 into cells. mCherryCas9 was conjugated with CPP–DEC with a 100 molar excess ratio. mCherryCas9–CPP was incubated with HeLa cells and the internalization was analyzed by flow cytometry and fluorescent microscopy (Fig. 5b and S18†). As a control, cellular internalization of unmodified mCherryCas9 was investigated. Our results demonstrate that mCherryCas9–CPP was internalized more efficiently than wild-type mCherryCas9 (7 folds higher in HeLa cells). To further determine the tropism of mCherryCas9–CPP, the uptake of mCherryCas9 vs. mCherryCas9–CPP was determined in human cardiomyocytes derived from induced pluripotent stem cells. Fig. S19† demonstrates that mCherryCas9–CPP was also robustly internalized by human cardiomyocytes, suggesting that protein conjugation with CPP–DEC is a broadly applicable strategy for enhancing the internalization of proteins into cells.
Finally, we investigated if DEC can enhance the efficiency of homology-directed repair (HDR) by reversibly conjugating Cas9 RNP to template donor DNA. Generating HDR in cells with Cas9 reagents is a central challenge in genome editing, and is currently one of the key bottlenecks preventing the translation of Cas9 based therapeutics.35 A crucial challenge in promoting efficient HDR is to deliver sufficient quantities of the Cas9 RNP and donor DNA into cells. Recently, chemically tethered Cas9 RNP–donor DNA has been demonstrated to result in significant increases in HDR, due to the simultaneous localization of Cas9 RNP and donor DNA within the same region of the genome.36,37 However, current methods for tethering the Cas9 RNP to donor DNA require making Cas9 fusion proteins, which have been challenging to express and purify.37,38
We therefore investigated if DEC could be used to directly conjugate donor DNA to the Cas9 RNP, in a mix-and-go manner, to generate a reagent that did not require extensive manipulation, and could be easily adopted by the biomedical community. Our synthetic strategy for making Cas9–RNP donor DNA conjugates is shown in Fig. 6a. Cas9 RNP–DEC–azide was first prepared by conjugating Cas9 RNP with DEC–PEG–azide (Fig. S20 and S21†), the resulting conjugate was then reacted with DBCO–DNA (donor DNA with a DBCO tag at 5′) through the strain-promoted click reaction (Fig. S22 and S23†), and directly added to cells.
To test if Cas9 RNP–DEC–DNA conjugates could increase the HDR rate of the Cas9 RNP, a BFP expressing HEK 293T cell line was used as a reporter system. The BFP gene differs from the GFP gene by a single amino acid, and BFP expressing cells can be transformed into GFP expressing cells by Cas9 mediated cutting of the BFP gene and repair of the double stranded break via HDR from a donor DNA. BFP HEK cells were transfected by electroporation with Cas9 RNP–DEC–DNA, using a 127 nucleotide donor DNA that was designed to convert the BFP gene into the GFP gene. As a control, Cas9 RNP was physically mixed with donor DNA at the same ratio (Cas9 RNP/DNA) and electroporated into cells. The HDR rate was then quantified by determining the percentage of GFP expressing cells via flow cytometry. Fig. 6b and Fig. S24† demonstrate that cells treated with Cas9 RNP–DEC–DNA had a 50% increase in HDR over cells treated with a physical mixture of Cas9 RNP and donor DNA.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d0sc00929f |
‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |