Zifeng
Yang
ab,
Xue
Li
a,
Fei
Xu
*ac,
Weiwei
Wang
a,
Yongqing
Shi
a,
Zhencai
Zhang
a,
Wenjuan
Fang
a,
Lei
Liu
a and
Suojiang
Zhang
*ab
aBeijing Key Laboratory of Ionic Liquids Clean Process, Key Laboratory of Green Process and Engineering, State Key Laboratory of Multiphase Complex Systems, Institute of Process Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, P.R. China. E-mail: sjzhang@ipe.ac.cn
bSchool of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, P.R. China
cZhongke Langfang Institute of Process Engineering, CAS, 065000, P.R. China
First published on 19th November 2020
The synthesis of green products using renewable bio-monomers has become a research trend with the requirement of sustainable development. In this work, we reported a green pathway to synthesize poly(isosorbide carbonate) (PIC) via one-step melt polycondensation of biomass-derived isosorbide (ISB) and CO2-derived dimethyl carbonate (DMC) catalyzed by eco-friendly dual site-functionalized ionic liquids; a series of these catalysts were synthesized for the first time to the best of our knowledge and their effects on the molecular weight and terminal groups of PIC were systematically investigated. The results showed that the steric structure of cations and anions of catalysts could significantly influence their catalytic performance in polymer synthesis reactions. Meanwhile, it was found that the ability of catalysts to activate the reaction substrate gradually increased with decreasing steric hindrance of cations and anions. Among our exploited ionic liquid catalysts, the selectivity of carboxymethylated products was increased significantly by using bis-tetraethylammonium hydroquinone ([N2222]2 [HQ]), and a PIC with a weight average molecular weight (Mw) of 53600 along with an ISB conversion up to 99.0% was obtained. As far as we know, the catalyst of [N2222]2 [HQ] was the most efficient catalyst for PIC one-step synthesis compared with the existing traditional ionic liquid catalysts. Besides, according to the detected intermediates of the reaction process and the results of various analytical means, a possible mechanism for the synergetic catalysis of cations–anions promoting the chain growth was proposed.
In the past few years, bio-derived PC has attracted widespread attention as a green sustainable material.7–12 Notably, poly(isosorbide carbonate) (PIC) as a kind of bio-derived PC material compared with BPA-based PC is not only green and renewable, but also has superior thermal and optical properties, which has become a hot topic.11–14 As a raw material of PIC, isosorbide (ISB) derived from biomass is a renewable resource (Scheme 1), and has a comparable structural rigidity to BPA.15–18 Therefore, ISB has been gradually considered as an ideal choice to replace traditional BPA to synthesize PC.19–21
At present, there are two main synthetic routes to PIC by using ISB as shown in Scheme 2. Most of the reported works have focused on the traditional route using ISB and diphenyl carbonate (DPC), while few research works to date have concentrated on the synthesis of PIC using ISB and dimethyl carbonate (DMC) via a one-step pathway (Scheme 2). However, CO2-derived DMC, the cornerstone of the green chemical industry in the 21st century, is an essential intermediate for the synthesis of DPC.22–25 Additionally, the low-boiling methanol, a byproduct of DMC during melt polycondensation, is more easy to remove than phenol, a byproduct of DPC.26–28 Therefore, the synthesis of PIC using ISB with DMC by a one-step pathway is the most green and cost-effective.29–31
Although the one-step pathway for synthesizing PIC is simplified and eco-friendly, to synthesize PIC with a high molecular weight via this method is still a daunting challenge due to the weak reactivity of the intramolecular hydroxyl (endo-OH) groups of ISB32,33 and the methylation reaction of DMC.34,35 In our and other previous studies, it has been found that the formation of intramolecular hydrogen bonds would decrease the reactivity of ISB and retard the chain growth (Scheme 1).27–30 On the other hand, DMC would undergo a methylation reaction compared with DPC,26,35 and the methylation products can inhibit chain growth as shown in Scheme 3. Therefore, it is necessary to develop a kind of high-efficiency catalyst and to further regulate and control the reaction for synthesis of high molecular weight PIC.
Dual site-functionalized ionic liquids have demonstrated vast superiority over conventional ionic liquids in academia during the past few years, especially in the aspect of catalysis. Moreover, the catalytic effect and economic efficiency can be improved by designing dual functionalized catalytic active sites.36–40 In this study, a series of eco-friendly dual site-functionalized ionic liquid catalysts were developed for the first time to improve the reactivity of endo-OH of ISB and the selectivity of carboxymethylation reaction of DMC for high molecular weight PIC. Under the optimal reaction conditions, bis-tetraethylammonium hydroquinone ([N2222]2 [HQ]) showed the highest catalytic reactivity compared with the existing traditional ionic liquid catalyst. It turned out that a PIC with the highest molecular weight of 53600 and an ISB conversion up to 99.0% was obtained.41 In addition, the effects of the steric structure of cations and anions on the terminal group of PIC and catalytic synthesis mechanism in the process were in-depth investigated by density functional theory (DFT) calculations and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. Moreover, the intermediates of the transesterification and polycondensation steps were captured and detected using mass spectrometry (MS) technology, and a possible synergetic mechanism of cations–anions was further proposed. The process reported here offered a direction to develop catalysts for synthesizing higher molecular weights PIC, and provided a cost-effective and green industrial synthetic route to PIC.
Entry | Catalyst | Transesterification stage | Polycondensation stage | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ISB Con.c (%) | Molecular weightd | Molecular weightd | ||||||
M n | M w | PDI | M n | M w | PDI | |||
a (1) Transesterification: 101 kPa, (160 °C, 60 min)–(180 °C, 60 min). (2) Polycondensation: 5 Pa, 230 °C, 60 min, n(DMC):n(ISB) = 7:1, and catalyst amount of 8 × 10−3 mol based on ISB. b Catalyst amount of 16 × 10−3 mol based on ISB. c Determined by GC. d Determined by DMF-GPC using polystyrene standards (RI detector). The average of data was obtained by three measurements to ensure the accuracy of the results. | ||||||||
1 | [N1111]2 [PY] | 91 | 2700 | 4100 | 1.52 | 10400 | 17000 | 1.63 |
2 | [N1111]2 [RE] | 93 | 2600 | 3900 | 1.50 | 12200 | 20200 | 1.66 |
3 | [N1111]2 [HQ] | 98 | 3100 | 4800 | 1.55 | 13300 | 21700 | 1.63 |
4 | [N2222]2 [HQ] | 98 | 3400 | 5000 | 1.47 | 14300 | 23300 | 1.64 |
5 | [N3333]2 [HQ] | 91 | 2800 | 4400 | 1.57 | 10600 | 17600 | 1.66 |
6 | [N4444]2 [HQ] | 86 | 2700 | 4200 | 1.56 | 9100 | 14500 | 1.59 |
7 | [N1111] [PH] | 78 | 2200 | 3800 | 1.73 | 7400 | 13600 | 1.84 |
8b | [N1111] [PH] | 91 | 2800 | 4500 | 1.61 | 9600 | 16800 | 1.75 |
In addition, the results of DFT calculations in Table 3 further illustrated the interactions between ISB and different anions, the same as other studies,11,28 the OH of ISB was activated and new hydrogen bonds formed between the OH of ISB and O− of different anions. The order of the hydrogen bond lengths was PY > RE > HQ, which showed that the ability to activate the ISB increased with decreasing the steric hindrance of anions. The interaction between HQ and OH of ISB was strongest, which was strikingly consistent with catalytic experiments. Therefore, the small steric hindrance of anions was advantageous for ionic liquid catalysis in polymer synthesis reactions.28
Secondly, we selected the HQ as the optimal anion, and changed the cations of ionic liquid catalysts by gradually increasing the alkyl chain length to further investigate the effect of the steric structure of cations on the catalytic performance. It was found that the activity of catalysts was gradually decreased from 98% to 86% when the chain length of cations increased from [N1111] to [N4444] (Table 1, entries 3–6). According to previous studies,27–29 DMC could be activated by electrophilic cations, so we also employed the DFT calculation to investigate the interaction between DMC and cations of catalysts. The results showed that the interaction energy decreased regularly with increasing the alkyl chain length of cations (Table 4), which illustrated that the ability to activate the DMC gradually increased with decreasing the steric hindrance of cations; the DFT results were consistent with the experimental results. Finally, we also synthesized [N1111] [PH] with only a single active site for comparison; the result showed that the activity of the catalyst was significantly reduced when the single-site catalyst dosage was the same as the dual-site IL catalyst (Table 1, entry 7 vs. 3). Moreover, the results showed that the catalytic activity did not depend on the simple superposition of the number of active sites, which further verified the advantage of dual active site-functionalized ionic liquid catalysts (Table 1, entry 8 vs. 3).
Entry | Catalyst | Oligomer terminal groupsb | PIC terminal groupsb | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Methylation | endo-CH3/exo-CH3 | –OH | endo-OH/exo-OH | Methylation | endo-CH3/exo-CH3 | –OH | endo-OH/exo-OH | ||
a (1) Transesterification: 101 kPa, (160 °C, 60 min)–(180 °C, 60 min). (2) Polycondensation: 5 Pa, 230 °C, 60 min, n(DMC):n(ISB) = 7:1, and catalyst amount of 8 × 10−3 mol based on ISB. b The peak integration of the proton from ISB in the repeating unit (peak 3 at δ 4.88 ppm in Fig. 1) was normalized to be 1, and the contents of other terminal groups were calculated on this basis. | |||||||||
1 | [N1111]2 [PY] | 0.332 | 0.96 | 0.119 | 1.29 | 0.267 | 1.21 | 0.035 | 1.33 |
2 | [N1111]2 [RE] | 0.256 | 0.90 | 0.073 | 1.28 | 0.249 | 1.11 | 0.026 | 1.17 |
3 | [N1111]2 [HQ] | 0.197 | 0.96 | 0.060 | 1.22 | 0.235 | 1.53 | 0.077 | 1.41 |
4 | [N2222]2 [HQ] | 0.057 | 0.84 | 0.186 | 1.33 | 0.018 | 1.57 | 0.071 | 1.29 |
5 | [N3333]2 [HQ] | 0.129 | 0.71 | 0.207 | 1.39 | 0.047 | 1.47 | 0.050 | 1.38 |
6 | [N4444]2 [HQ] | 0.154 | 0.75 | 0.242 | 1.35 | 0.078 | 1.84 | 0.077 | 1.41 |
In view of the excellent catalytic performance of [N2222]2 [HQ], we employed in situ NMR spectroscopy for full-scale and in-depth investigation of the process of melt polycondensation of ISB and DMC (Table 6). The results showed that the methylation product was synthesized in the transesterification stage, and the content of methylation products gradually decreased and tended to be stable when the reaction continued to the polycondensation stage, which may be the reason that some of the small molecular methylation products were extracted in the vacuum during the polycondensation reaction.
Entry | Catalyst | Stage | Time (h) | Terminal groupsb | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Methylation | endo-CH3/exo-CH3 | –OH | endo-OH/exo-OH | ||||
a (1) Transesterification: 101 kPa, 160–180 °C. (2) Polycondensation: 5 Pa, 230 °C, n(DMC):n(ISB) = 7:1, and catalyst amount of 8 × 10−3 mol based on ISB. b The peak integration of the proton from isosorbide in the repeating unit (peak 3 at δ 4.88 ppm in Fig. 1) was normalized to be 1, and the contents of other terminal groups were calculated on this basis. | |||||||
1 | Transesterification | 1 | 0.080 | 0.51 | 0.659 | 1.12 | |
2 | 2 | 0.057 | 0.84 | 0.186 | 1.33 | ||
3 | Polycondensation | 1 | 0.018 | 1.57 | 0.071 | 1.29 | |
4 | 2 | 0.015 | 1.50 | 0.045 | 1.65 | ||
5 | 3 | 0.016 | 1.60 | 0.035 | 1.50 |
The effect of the temperature on the transesterification reaction stage is depicted in Fig. 2(a); the results showed that the temperature had an outstanding influence on the reaction. The ISB conversion was improved from 41% to nearly 99% when the temperature increased from 100 to 180 °C. When the reaction temperature was increased to 160 °C, the conversion curve of ISB tended to be stable, possibly because trace amounts of ISB were challenging to convert; thus, the optimal transesterification reaction temperature should be 160 °C.
As illustrated in Fig. 2(b), the dependence of the ISB conversion on the reaction time of the transesterification reaction stage was explored. The results showed that the reaction time had a pronounced positive effect; the ISB conversion rate was fast in the initial stage, and remained almost invariant after 120 min. Thereby, the optimum reaction time was 120 min in the transesterification reaction stage.
As shown in Fig. 2(c), the reaction temperature of the polycondensation stage was also evaluated, and the results showed that the Mw of the PIC reached up to 26300 when the polycondensation temperature was up to 250 °C; this could be explained that higher temperature facilitated the removal of small molecules and reduced the viscosity of the polymer, which would accelerate the polymerization reaction.41 However, the Mw of PIC declined a little when the reaction temperature continued to increase up to 270 °C; the reason should be that high temperature accelerated the thermal degradation of PIC.29,41 Therefore, the optimum reaction temperature of the polycondensation stage was 250 °C for PIC synthesis.
Finally, the effect of reaction time on the polymerization stage was investigated, as shown in Fig. 2(d). The polymerization reaction time showed a positive impact on the Mw values of PIC, which increased quickly with the polymerization time increasing from 1 to 3 h; the maximum Mw value of 53600 could be achieved when the time was 3 h. However, when the time was further increased from 3 to 5 h, the Mw value of PIC slightly decreased, which may be owing to that high melt viscosity hindered the polymer chain growth and the ongoing competing reaction of the thermal degradation of PIC.10,22 Therefore, the reaction time of 3 h was the optimum time in the polycondensation stage.
The interaction between the DMC and the [N2222]2 [HQ] catalyst was captured by 1H NMR as shown in Fig. 3; the proton signals of [HQ] and DMC distinctly shifted when increasing the molar ratio of DMC to [N2222]2 [HQ] from 1:0 to 3:1, indicating that the cation of the catalyst could activate DMC. As similarly mentioned in other literature studies,26–28 the cation of [N2222] could activate the carbonyl group of DMC and form a weaker interaction with the CO group of DMC (step 1). Moreover, the results of DFT calculation illustrated that DMC could be activated by different cations of the catalyst, and the interaction energy changed regularly with the increase of the alkyl chain length of cations (Table 4). In addition, the O atom of the [HQ] anion was suggested to activate the OH of ISB through an intermolecular hydrogen bond (step 1);29,41 the results of DFT calculation in Table 3 have illustrated hydrogen bond formation between the OH of ISB and anion, and the 1H NMR chemical shift of the ISB and catalyst mixture further verified the inference (Fig. 4).
The ISB and DMC were activated by the anion and cation of the catalyst respectively (step 1); thereafter, along with the transfer of electrons, the transesterification took place, and formed an unstable complex intermediate state (steps 2 and, 3). Consequently, the mono-carboxymethyl ISB intermediates and methanol were synthesized by the reaction of ISB with DMC (step 4), similarly to that reported in other literature studies.28–30,41 As shown in Fig. 5, the key intermediates in the transesterification stage were detected by using ESI-MS, and the results could further verify the above conjecture and pointed out the direction for the next reaction. Meanwhile, the content of the structures e and f was less than that of a, b, c, d and g; the trend might manifest that the ISB methylation reaction was suppressed and the remaining hydroxyl groups of ISB were more prone to carboxymethylation; therefore, this suggested that the next steps of steps 5 and 6 and steps 8 and 9 were supposed to preferentially repeat the steps 2 and 3;28,41 especially, the structures b (step 7), d (step 10) and g were detected to further verify this deduction.
The small molecules including methylation and methanol products were continuously removed in the polycondensation vacuum stage, and as the reaction repeated, a high molecular weight PIC was obtained. In order to further obtain the detailed information of the polymer terminal groups, some intermediate oligomer structure was detected by MALDI-TOF-Ms in this work. As shown in Fig. S17,† the results showed that the content of carboxymethylation product a and intermediate c was much more than that of methylation product b. This may be the reason that the methylation reaction inhibited the chain growth, which was consistent with the experimental results that the content of carboxymethylation products was much larger than that of methylation products.
The synthetic method for bis-tetramethylammonium pyrocatechol ([N1111]2 [PY]), bis-tetramethylammonium resorcinol ([N1111]2 [RE]), bis-tetramethylammonium hydroquinone ([N1111]2 [HQ]), bis-tetrapropylammonium hydroquinone ([N3333]2 [HQ]), bis-tetrabutylammonium hydroquinone ([N4444]2 [HQ]), and tetramethylammonium phenol ([N1111] [PH]) was the same as that of [N2222]2 [HQ]. The characterization results of all the ionic liquids are shown in Fig. S1–S14,† and the TGA curves of ionic liquids are shown in Fig. S15.† All of them exhibited good thermal stability.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: The structures properties of oligomer and PIC; detailed characterizations; the 1H and 13C NMR spectrum of different catalysts; TGA curves of ionic liquids, etc. See DOI: 10.1039/d0gc03247f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |