Yahui Lia,
Qunzan Lub,
Qiumeng Chena,
Xuan Wub,
Jianliang Shen*ab and
Liangliang Shen*a
aState Key Laboratory of Ophthalmology, Optometry and Vision Science, School of Ophthalmology and Optometry, School of Biomedical Engineering, Wenzhou Medical University, Wenzhou 325027, PR China. E-mail: shenjl@wiucas.ac.cn
bEngineering Research Center of Clinical Functional Materials and Diagnosis & Treatment Devices of Zhejiang Province, Wenzhou Institute, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Xinsan Road, Longwan District, Wenzhou 325001, PR China
First published on 5th January 2021
Particle fusion is well-recognized as an important spontaneous process to produce higher-order nanostructures during morphology transition in polymerization-induced self-assembly (PISA). However, to our knowledge, the directional contact, adhesion, and fusion of adjacent nanoparticles have been rarely elucidated in PISA. Herein, a directional fusion of ellipsoidal morphologies was demonstrated during PISA of semi-fluorinated liquid-crystalline (SFLC) block copolymers. The ellipsoidal nanostructures, including micelles and vesicles, preferred to undergo a directional fusion in a head-to-head model, leading to the formation of nanorods and nanotubes, respectively. We believe the directional fusion will offer insightful guidance in PISA to the preparation of complicated functional nanostructures.
Recently, liquid-crystalline (LC) block copolymers have been broadly employed to mediate the self-assembly behaviors of BCPs. In particular, it was well-demonstrated that self-assembly of LC block copolymers facilitated the formation of cylindrical nanostructures.27,28 For example, Li and co-workers found that BCPs comprising a cholesteryl LC core-forming block preferred to form cylindrical micelles.29 Winnik et al. described that the self-assembly of BCPs comprising a polyferrocenylsilane block can readily produce rod-like micelles within a broad range of BCP composition window.30 Among various liquid-crystalline polymers, fluorinated polymers are remarkable materials because of their unique properties and wide applications in several areas.29–33 Particularly, semi-fluorinated poly(meth)acrylates bearing side groups with high numbers of fluorocarbons (≥7) exhibit excellent LC nature because F-alkyl chains are much bulkier and more rigid than alkyl chains.34,35 In recent years, the self-assembly of semi-fluorinated liquid-crystalline (SLFC) BCPs for constructing cylindrical nanostructures has been systematically developed. For example, Liu and co-workers demonstrated that triblock terpolymers bearing a fluorinated block can readily self-assemble into cylindrical micelles.36 Manners et al. reported that the self-assembly of a SLFC BCP afforded monodisperse cylindrical micelles through a fragmentation-thermal annealing process.37 Yuan and co-workers found that cylindrical micelles could be readily prepared by PISA of semi-fluorinated-containing monomer in a wide range of lengths of core-forming block.38 However, the dynamic process of morphology evolution for the formation of cylindrical micelles was not discussed. Despite significant progress, the unique advantage of BCPs with a LC block in forming cylindrical nanostructures compared with coil–coil BCPs need further elucidation.
Recently, a few researchers have reported that ellipsoidal morphologies can be readily obtained through PISA of rigid rod-coil BCPs with a LC block.39 For instance, Chen and co-workers presented an efficient approach to forming a series of anisotropic morphologies, including ellipsoidal vesicles via polymerization-induced hierarchical self-assembly of azobenzene-containing BCPs.40 Shen and co-workers reported that facile preparation of ellipsoidal micelles can be achieved in the dispersion polymerization of heptadecafluorodecyl methacrylate (HDFDMA) employing several macromolecular chain transfer agents (macro-CTAs) in a wide selection of solvents.41 In contrast, the PISA of amorphous coil–coil BCPs usually results in isotropic spheres.
Fusion is an important spontaneous process to generate higher-order structures during morphology evolution in PISA.42 For instance, spheres fuse to worms18 and vesicles fuse to form tubes, compound vesicles,43 and tetrapod polymersomes.44 Cai and co-workers have well-demonstrated that one-dimensional nanowires readily formed via the fusion of spindle-like micelles along the long axis of the micelles.45,46 We envision that it might also undergo a directional fusion of ellipsoidal morphologies during the formation of cylindrical nanostructures via PISA of BCPs containing a LC block. However, to the best of our knowledge, the directional fusion effect on the formation of cylindrical nanostructures has been rarely discussed in PISA. Although Lv et al. reported that the fusion of vesicles in one dimension can occur to form nanotubes in their PISA protocol,43 the directional contact, adhesion, and fusion of adjacent nanoparticles was not elucidated. Herein, we aim to verify the directional effect on the fusion of ellipsoidal morphologies during dispersion polymerization of HDFDMA using poly(2-(dimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate) (PDMAEMA30) as the macro-CTA.
Then, the PDMAEMA30 macro-CTA was chain-extended through RAFT dispersion polymerization of HDFDMA in ethanol at 70 °C at 20% w/v solids content. The polymerization condition and results were summarized in Table 1. 1H NMR spectra confirmed that near quantitative HDFDMA conversions were accomplished within 11–23 h. The BCPs compositions can be confirmed by 1H NMR using a mixed solution CDCl3/CF2ClCFCl2 (3:2, v/v), which allowed efficient dissociation of SFLC block aggregation and ordering. Fig. 2 demonstrated the 1H NMR spectrum of PDMAEMA30–PHDFDMA62 as a representative example. Although the targeting DP of HDFDMA was 60, the actual repeat units of HDFDMA was determined to be 62 by comparing the integral ratio of signal h′ (δ = 4.30 ppm) and h (δ = 4.14 ppm).
Feed ratioa | Solids% | Conv.b% | Dh,appc | PDIc |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Molar ratio (PDMAEMA30-CTA/HDFDMA/AIBN).b Monomer conversions determined by 1H NMR spectroscopy in CDCl3.c The average value of apparent hydrodynamic diameter (Dh,app) and the polydispersity index (PDI) of particle size confirmed by DLS characterizations with the block copolymer concentration of 0.1% (1 mg mL−1). | ||||
1/50/0.3 | 20 | 99 | 126 | 0.18 |
1/60/0.3 | 20 | 99 | 140 | 0.11 |
1/70/0.3 | 20 | 99 | 164 | 0.08 |
1/80/0.3 | 20 | 99 | 191 | 0.08 |
1/90/0.5 | 20 | 99 | 200 | 0.15 |
1/100/0.5 | 20 | 99 | 280 | 0.43 |
1/100/0.5 | 15 | 99 | 230 | 0.34 |
1/100/0.5 | 30 | 99 | 350 | 0.49 |
1/105/0.5 | 30 | 99 | 618 | 0.35 |
Fig. 2 1H NMR spectrum of PDMAEMA30–PHDFDMA62 block copolymer in CDCl3/CF2ClCFCl2 mixed solvent (3:2, v/v). The targeting DP of HDFDMA was 60. |
The morphologies of BCP nanostructures were analysed by transmission electron microscopy (TEM). The corresponding size distributions of the PDMAEMA30–PHDFDMAn nano-objects were characterized by dynamic light scattering (DLS). As shown in Fig. 3A, the dispersion polymerization targeting a DP of 50 resulted in a mixture of anisotropic ellipsoidal micelles with different sizes. The DLS results in Fig. 4 (the black line) indicated an average value of the apparent hydrodynamic diameter (Dh,app) at 126 nm with PDI = 0.18. The statistical analysis in Fig. S1† indicated that the average length of short and long axis for big ellipsoidal micelles is 91 and 212 nm, respectively. As for small ellipsoidal micelles, the average length of the short and long axis was determined to be 40 and 96 nm, respectively. As the targeting DP increased to 60, the average Dh,app of the nano-objects slightly increased to be 140 nm with PDI of 0.11 (the red line in Fig. 4). The TEM image in Fig. 3B indicated that ellipsoidal vesicles in coexistence with short rods generated. The statistical analysis in Fig. S2A and B† indicated that the average length of the short and long axis of the ellipsoidal vesicles is about 225 nm and 95 nm, respectively. The average thickness of the vesicular wall is calculated to be 36 nm (Fig. S2C†). The average width of short rods (30 nm, Fig. S2E†) is slightly lower than the short axis of small ellipsoidal micelles (40 nm on average, Fig. S1D†), indicating that short rods were generated from the fusion of small ellipsoidal micelles. As shown in Fig. S3,† the near-ellipsoidal vesicles with varied size formed when the DP of HDFDMA was targeted as 70, 80, and 90, respectively. Besides the near-ellipsoidal vesicles, ellipsoidal micelles with small size can also be observed. Their corresponding DLS results were exhibited in Fig. S4.†
Fig. 4 DLS results of PDMAEMA30–PHDFDMAn BCP nano-objects synthesized via PISA in ethanol at varied solids content. |
Interestingly, with a further increase of DP of HDFDMA to 100, nanorods with varied length formed (Fig. 3C). Besides nanorods, ellipsoidal micelles can also be clearly observed. DLS results in Fig. 4 (the blue line) also demonstrated a wide distribution of size (PDI = 0.43). The peak at 1189 nm corresponded to long rods while the peak at 177 nm corresponded to the mixture of short rods and ellipsoidal micelles. The statistical analysis in Fig. S5† demonstrated that the average width of nanorods (108 nm) is basically consistent with the short axis of the ellipsoidal micelles, suggesting that nanorods were resulted from the directional fusion of the ellipsoidal micelles along the long axis. As is well-recognized, the solids content is one of the critical factors influencing the morphology evolution process in PISA. In principle, low solid contents will retard the morphology evolution by decreasing the probability of collision and fusion of nanoparticles.47–49 To acquire more convincing evidence for a directional fusion of ellipsoidal micelles, the PISA of PDMAEMA30–PHDFDMA100 at 15% solids content was subsequently performed. As shown in Fig. 3D, a string of ellipsoidal micelles as an intermediate state into long rods is successfully captured. DLS result in Fig. 4 (the green line) exhibited two main peaks at 60 and 450 nm, respectively, which is in good agreement with the corresponding TEM image in Fig. 3D. Moreover, the adjacent ellipsoidal micelles are linked together along the long axis. This result confirms our hypothesis that the directional fusion of ellipsoidal micelles along their long axis can lead to the formation of nanorods, which is schematically illustrated in Scheme 1B. Similarly, Cai et al. elucidated that partial open ends exist in the ellipsoidal-like particles due to the uneven coverage of the particle core by the stabilizer chains, leading to particle fusion in a head-to-head model.45
As well-elucidated, the membrane curvature serves as a critical factor in dictating the morphology transition of BCPs nanoparticles.18,50 Particle fusion during PISA is mainly driven by membrane tension.42 Therefore, one of the motivations for the morphology transition is to reduce the membrane curvature and tension to the maximum extent. The fusion of the spherical micelles into worm-like micelles is isotropic since the molecular curvature for spherical micelles is isotropic. In contrast, the membrane curvature of the ellipsoidal micelles is anisotropic: the membrane curvature of the two poles is much higher than other locations. Theoretically, three kinds of fusion models of ellipsoidal nanoparticles can be presented, which can be denoted as a head-to-head model, a side-by-side model, and a random model, respectively (Scheme 2). As revealed by TEM analysis in Fig. 3D, the ellipsoidal micelles preferred to fuse in a head-to-head model, affording the lowest membrane curvature and tension. In contrast, the fusion of ellipsoidal micelles in the other two kinds of models cannot decrease the membrane curvature and tension to the maximum extent.
Scheme 2 Schematic demonstration of a directional fusion of ellipsoidal morphology along the long axis driven by the molecular curvature. |
In principle, increasing DP of core-forming block and improving total solid content are commonly used strategies for promoting morphological transitions during PISA. Thus, the PISA of PDMAEMA30–PHDFDMA100 nano-objects at 30% solids contents was conducted. As indicated in Fig. 5A, micron-long tubes were generated, of which the average width of the tubes was around 102 nm and the width of the tube wall was 35 nm, respectively (Fig. S6†). Besides micro-long tubes, ellipsoidal vesicles (Fig. 5A) and the fusing dimer with a central wall (Fig. 5B) were also observed. The DLS results shown in Fig. 5D agree well with the morphological observations in Fig. 5A: the peaks with 70, 477, and 5157 nm corresponded to small ellipsoidal vesicles, vesicle dimers, and micro-long tubes, respectively. Furthermore, the width of the tube wall was almost the same as that of a fused dimer (37 nm, Fig. 5B). Hence, combining these results, it can be rationally concluded that microtubes resulted from the directional fusion of ellipsoidal vesicles in a head-to-head model, which was schematically shown in Scheme 1C. Firstly, the two poles of the ellipsoidal vesicles preferred to contact and adhesive, resulting in a central wall within the vesicular dimer (Fig. 5B), which is in well agreement with the observation by Discher et al.8 In this way, the molecular curvature of the ellipsoidal vesicles can be reduced to the maximum extent. Then, the central wall is destabilized and retracted into the outer wall, resulting in short tubes (Fig. 5C). Subsequently, the short tubes further fused with more ellipsoidal vesicles and eventually, formed micro-long tubes. Rationally, both ellipsoidal vesicles and the short tubes can be regarded as the precursors for long micro-tubes. An increase of just 5 HDFDMA units at 30% solids led to gradual transition from micro-tubes to rods as the cavities of tubes were gradually filled (Fig. S7 and S8†).
The LC nature of the PHDFDMA block is the main reason for the formation of unusual anisotropic morphology. Herein, the mesomorphic properties of PDMAEMA30-b-PHDFDMAn nanostructures were analysed by using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and X-ray diffraction (XRD). As is shown in Fig. 6, diffraction peaks at 2.8°, 5.6°, 8.4°, and 17.9° correspond to four Bragg spacings (3.16, 1.58, 1.07, and 0.50 nm), among which the spacing of 1.58 nm can be assigned to the rod-like perfluoroalkyl chain length.51 This provides convincing evidence that HDFDMA blocks formed an ordered smectic B (SmB) phase. As Lv et al. reported, the temperature of polymerization (Tp) in PISA is crucial for morphological evolution because the mobility of core-forming block can be affected by Tp.43 They found that when Tp of PISA was appropriately lower than or close to the glass transition temperature (Tg), the mobility of the core-forming block was retarded, facilitating the one-dimension fusion of vesicles into tubes. In our work, the Tp for all PISA formulations were set to be 70 °C, a commonly used temperature for most RAFT-PISA protocols. To check if the Tp we utilized is appropriately lower than or close to the SmB-to-isotropic phase transition temperature of PHDFDMA blocks, the DSC measurements were conducted. As indicated in Fig. 7, a SmB to isotropic phase transition at 72 °C for PDMAEMA30–PHDFDMA100 was revealed, suggesting that Tp at 70 °C is appropriate in our PISA system. In order to better explain directional fusion mechanism for ellipsoidal morphologies, we performed a PISA of PDMAEMA30–PHDFDMA100 with 20% solids content at 76 °C. TEM micrograph in Fig. S9† demonstrated that only spherical particles formed and no fusion of nanoparticles was observed. Since the Tp at 76 °C is higher than the SmB-to-isotropic phase transition temperature, the ellipsoidal morphologies were not produced and no directional fusion can be observed.
Fig. 6 X-ray diffraction patterns for (A) PDMAEMA30–PHDFDMA50 and (B) PDMAEMA30–PHDFDMA100 fluoro-containing block copolymer nanoparticles. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: DLS results and TEM images. See DOI: 10.1039/d0ra09548f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |