Xiaoyan Caoa,
Pengming Zhanga,
Nanping Guob,
Yongfen Tong*a,
Qiuhua Xua,
Dan Zhoua and
Zhijun Fengb
aSchool of Environmental and Chemical Engineering, Nanchang Hangkong University, 696 Fenghe South Avenue, Nanchang 330063, China. E-mail: tongyongfen@nchu.edu.cn; Fax: +86 791 83953373; Tel: +86 791 83953377
bSchool of Materials Science and Engineering, Nanchang Hangkong University, 696 Fenghe South Avenue, Nanchang 330063, China
First published on 14th January 2021
Due to their low flammability, good dimensional stability and chemical stability, solid polymer electrolytes are currently attracting extensive interest for building lithium metal batteries. But severe safety issues such as cracks or breakage, resulting in short circuits will prevent their widespread application. Here, we report a new design of self-healing solid polymer electrolyte (ShSPE) based on imine bonds, fabricated from varying amounts of polyoxyethylenebis(amine) and terephthalaldehyde through a simple Schiff base reaction. Moreover, adding diglycidyl ether of bisphenol A improves the flexibility and high stretchability of the polymer electrolyte. The polymer networks exhibit good thermal stability and excellent self-healing characteristics. The ShSPE with the highest NH2–PEG–NH2 content (ShSPE-3) has an improved lithium ion transference number of 0.39, and exhibits an electrochemical stability up to 4.5 V vs. Li/Li+. ShSPE-3 shows the highest ionic conductivity of 1.67 × 10−4 S cm−1 at 60 °C. Besides, the interfacial stability of ShSPE-3 is promoted and the electrolyte membrane exhibits good cycling performance with LiFePO4, and the LiFePO4/Li cell exhibits an initial discharge capacity of 141.3 mA h g −1. These results suggest that self-healing solid polymer electrolytes are promising candidates for high safety and stable lithium metal batteries.
In nature, living kingdom utilizes self-healing ability to restore function and extend life.14 Inspired by this, a series of self-healing materials have been studied to repair the damage of fracture interface through reversible chemical bond, hydrogen bond, ligand metal bond, and host guest interaction.15–17 This idea promotes the rapid development of polymer materials with self-healing properties. Compared with traditional polymers, self-healing polymers show the ability to repair damaged areas via a physical or chemical processes.18 SPEs based on self-healing materials can extend the lithium metal batteries lifetime and improve the cycling stability after crack or deformation.19 In 2018, Zhou et al. fabricated a novel polymer electrolyte with intrinsic self-healability and high stretchability, which possesses good ionic conductivity at room temperature and excellent electrochemical and thermal stabilities.20 Peng et al. report a new family of all-solid-state and flexible aqueous lithium ion batteries by designing aligned carbon nanotube sheets loaded with LiMn2O4 and LiTi2 (PO4)3 nanoparticles on a self-healing polymer substrate as electrodes that can self-heal after breaking, and these self-healing batteries are demonstrated to be promising for wearable devices.21 Li and Yang et al. applied a self-healing hydrogel with a double dynamic network comprising imine and borate ester linkages, which showed enhanced strength and mucoadhesive abilities because of the complimentary interpenetrating dynamic networks.22 In addition, according to the self-healing mechanism, self-healing materials can be divided into extrinsic and intrinsic types.23 Intrinsic self-healing materials use chemical and physical interactions, such as reversible chemical bonds or molecular diffusion to achieve repair damage interfaces.24–26 When an external force (a change temperature, irradiation, light, PH, etc.) is received, these bonds can reversibly associate and dissociate, and some dynamic bonds at the fractured/damaged areas can be re-established.27,28 For extrinsic self-healing materials, an extra repair agent is necessary to achieve self-healing. The imine bond (–CN–) is a kind of reversible dynamic chemical bond, also known as Schiff base. The most common method to prepare imine bond compounds is reacted aldehyde or ketone with amine derivatives, generally speaking, the reaction can be divided into three equilibrium processes: imine condensation/hydrolysis, imine exchange, and imine metathesis, which show dynamic property for self-healing or recycling without catalyst. It can undergo rapid degenerative bond exchange without any significant side reactions and the advantage of solvent resistance.29–32 In 2004, Brown and White, applied the microencapsulated dicyclopentadiene healing agent and Grubbs' Ru catalyst are incorporated into an epoxy matrix to produce a polymer composite capable of self-healing.33 Zhang et al., report an ultra-thin solid-state Li-ion electrolyte membrane facilitated by a self-healing polyimines polymer network, the malleability of polyamines allow for material flow to increase the density of the composite, and instill mechanical toughness.34 In this study, we aim to prepare a serial of solid polymer electrolytes based on imine bond with self-healing properties and simultaneously possess excellent electrochemical performance.
Here, we propose the design of a flexible, self-healing and high mechanical strength solid polymer electrolyte (ShSPE) based on reversible imine bonds for all-solid-state lithium metal batteries. The ShSPE, composed of polyethylene glycol (PEG) strands and imine cross-linkers, was fabricated with diglycidyl ether of bisphenolA (DGEBA), terephthalaldehyde (TPA) separately thermal cross-linking with polyoxyethylenebis(amine) (NH2–PEG–NH2) at different molar ratios. The novel self-healing ShSPE were proposed to take advantages of the good ionic conductivity of EO unit, the fast self-healing properties of dynamic covalent imine bonds and the mechanical strength of the crosslinking of amines and epoxy groups in DGEBA. Due to the reversible of the dynamic imine bond, the as-prepared solid polymer electrolyte can self-repaire quickly after rupture or damage to ensure the inherent performance of the electrolyte. In addition, the epoxy resin structure will endow the electrolyte good adhesion properties, which will be conducive to form an effective contact between the electrolyte and the electrode, further improve the safety and stability of the battery.
As shown in Fig. 2a and b excellent flexibility, transparent and self-standing polymer electrolyte films can be prepared by fusing polyoxyethylenebis (amine), terephthalaldehyde (TPA) with diglycidyl ether of bisphenol A. The thickness of ShSPE which were used in the lithium metal batteries is approximately 30∼80 μm. Because the film is relatively thin and soft, the average value is taken through multiple parallel measurements with a spiral micrometer (Fig. 2c). The surface morphology of the electrolytes film is also shown in Fig. 2d, a smooth surface and compact structure without phase separations are found, illustrating that each polymer chain segment has good compatibility.
In order to investe the structure of polymer, Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) analysis was used to confirm the successful formation of dynamic covalent polymer.
According to the previous design, the ShSP-3 with dynamic imine bonds was obtained by the condensation of amino group in NH2–PEG–NH2 and aldehyde group in TPA. Fig. 3a shows the FT-IR spectra of DGEBA, TPA and ShSP-3. The peaks at 1695 cm−1 correspond to the stretching vibration of CO from aldehyde group. Compared with the spectrum of TPA, the absorption band of aldehyde group disappeared for ShSP-3, and a new –NCH– bond at 1650 cm−1 appeared, indicating the successful polymerization of ShSP-3.38,39 Simultaneously, the amine group can attack epoxy structure to break the epoxy groups (at 912 cm−1) in the DGEBA, and the hydroxyls are created after ring-opening reaction.40
Fig. 3 FT-IR spectra of DGEBA, TPA and ShSP-3 elastomer (a) and XRD spectra (b) for NH2–PEG–NH2, polymers without Li salts (ShSP-1, 2, 3) and ShSPE-3. |
Since the ionic conductivity of the polymer electrolyte is closely related to the morphology of the polymer, the X-ray diffraction (XRD) study of the self-healable ShSP and the ShSPE are carried out (Fig. 3b). Generally, the sharp reflections at 2θ = 19.2° and 23.4° are corresponding to the crystallinity of PEG segment. From ShSP-1 to ShSP-2 to ShSP-3, the intensity of these peaks of the PEG increases, implying that the degree of crystallization decreases as the NH2–PEG–NH2 content decreases. Further introducing the LiTFSI, the sharp peaks disappeared. This means that the lithium salt acts as a plasticizer can inhibit the crystallization of EO chain, and the solid polymer electrolytes are amorphous, which are helpful to improve the ionic conductivity of ShSPE.6 Moreover thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and the differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) further reveals the designed ShSPE possesses an amorphous structure with good thermal stability (Fig. 4a) and a lowest glass transition temperature (Fig. 4b).
Fig. 4 TGA (a) and DSC (b) curves for self-healable solid polymers without Li salts (ShSP-3) and the self-healable polymeric electrolyte at different molar ratios. |
Fig. 4b shows the DSC traces of virgin polymer after NH2–PEG–NH2 and TPA, DGEBA polymerization reaction and polymer electrolytes in the temperature range of −80 to 100 °C. An obvious peak of ShSP-3 curve at 50.4 °C are associated to the melting temperature (Tm) of PEG. The glass transition temperature (Tg) of ShSPE-3∼1 show relative lower Tg in the temperature range of −33.2 to −28.2 °C and the peak of Tm disappear, indicating that the electrolytes are amorphous, which is according with the analysis of XRD. This result portends LiTFSI added into the polymers system is not only responsible for ion transmission, but also act as plasticizer to inhibit polymer crystalline in the ShSPE system. Such low Tg indicated that the ShSPE is highly flexible and possess good segmental motion, which is benefit to the lithium ion transport and movement.41
In order to further prove the thermal stability of the electrolyte, the traditional Celgard separator membrane was compared with ShSPE-3 in combustion and dimensional stability test. The results are shown in Fig. 5a and Fig. 5b, respectively. When the Celgard separator was ignited, it will completely burn within 2 s, which is due to the presence of combustible substances such as polyethylene and polypropylene.42 However, ShSPE-3 only appears edge curl after burning on fire for 1 minute. The results show that ShSPE has better fire retardancy than traditional Celgard film. In addition, heat retardancy of ShSPE and Celgard separator were also measured for comparition. Fig. 5b records the photographic images of ShSPE-3 and Celgard from 100 °C to 180 °C. It can be clearly seen that Celgard separator membrane begin to shrink at 100 °C and gradually become transparent, while the color and size of ShSPE-3 films are hardly affected by temperature. This combustion and dimensional stability contrast test further demonstrates the high heat resistance of ShSPE-3 film, which is suitable for the development of high temperature lithium metal battery.43
Fig. 5 Photographic images (a) of the flammability test of Celgard and ShSPE-3 and heated at a different temperature (b) under normal atmospheric conditions. |
In order to study the healing efficiency of ShSPE, we further studied the healing rate at different temperatures (Fig. 6a). The samples were cut into two pieces and healed at 25 °C, 60 °C and 80 °C, as represented in Fig. 6b–d respectively. This is attribute to the dynamic reversible imine bonds which can undergo both dissociative (imine hydrolysis and re-formation) and associative (imine–amine exchange and imine condensation) reactions between amine groups in the NH2–PEG–NH2 backbone and aldehyde groups of TPA or imine-containing polymer network.36 Two separated ShSPE-3 samples were fully recovered after contacted for 30 minutes at 25 °C without any external stimuli, the two halves fused into a single entity. To further confirm the self-healing ability, the healing process of cut ShSPE-3 film was observed before and after healing by the microscope, as shown in Fig. 6e. There was no defect in the recovery membrane, which strongly shows that the electrolytes poseess excellent self-healing ability. The ShSPE-3 elastomer of the self-healing process is schematically presented in Fig. 6f. It is worth mentioning that the repaired samples with a strong enough bond still show good stretch properties without cracks on the original damage, indicating the ShSPE were healed effectively to the original entirety. This is ascribe to the existence of reversible imine bond din the polymer network. Thus, it can conclude that high concentrations of NH2–PEG–NH2 may increase the chance of meeting aldehyde groups and further promote the imine exchange reactions, thereby increasing the possibility of forming imine bonds. Simultaneously, self-healing rate has been greatly improved at elevated temperature. The cut interface became fully recovered within 10 min at 60 °C and only within 5 min at 80 °C, which could be ascribed to the higher flexibility and mobility of polymer chains at high temperature.
Fig. 7 Cross-sectional SEM images of the Li/ShSPE-3/LiFePO4 (a) and schematic illustration of Li plating of general and self-healing polymer electrolytes on Li metal (b). |
The stability and interface contact performance of the electrolyte and lithium metal can be further observed by the adhesive test for electrolyte. Here, the adhesive strength between ShSPE-3 and metal surface is measured, and the results are shown in Fig. S2b.† The membrane was coated on a metal surface with the diameter of 18 mm and the thickness of film was less than 1 mm. Then a metal ruler was covered on electrolyte surface, and two metal surface were bonded together under pressure. The experimental results show that the metal surface with ShSPE-3 can easily support the weight of 200 g. It shows that ShSPE-3 has good adhesion properties. The excellent adhesion performance ensures the interface stability and good compatibility between ShSPE and electrode, then improves the safety and stability of battery.
The lithium ion transference number (tLi+) is also an important parameter for solid polymer electrolytes. The chronoamperometry curve and the electrochemical impedance spectra before and after steady-state of Li/ShSPE-3/Li cell are shown in Fig. 8d. The calculated tLi+ was 0.39 which is in good agreement with reported value for PEO/LiTFSI system, indicating that the ShSPE provide more ion diffusion channels and promote ion transport. The comprehensive electrochemical properties of the designed ShSPE is suitable for solid-state lithium metal batteries.
Full cells were assembled for an assessment with lithium-metal as the anode and LiFePO4 as the cathode under practical conditions. The charge/discharge performance of Li|ShSPE-3|LiFePO4 battery illustrated between 2.5 V and 4.2 V at a rate of 0.1C and 60 °C were plotted in Fig. 9a. The initial discharge capacities were 141.3 mA h g−1 and the coulombic efficiency approach to 96.8%. The typical plateaus shown in the process of charge/discharge demonstrate a reversible electrochemical reaction for the battery. Fig. 9b shows the cycling performance of Li|ShSPE-3|LiFePO4 cell at 60 °C. The batteries retain good specific capacity (120.4 mA h g −1) and excellent coulombic efficiency (about 97.7%) after 50 cycles at a 0.1 C-rate. The good cycling performance can be due to the good contact between the ShSPE and the electrode. In order to study the battery performance of the self-healing electrolyte, we also provided cycle performance of the Li|ShSPE|LiFePO4 battery based on healed ShSPE-3 from the cut sample at 0.1C rate (Fig. S4†). It is worth mentioning that lithium metal battery can still charge and discharge. The initial discharge capacities was 137.7 mA h g−1 at 60 °C and the capacity of 119.34 mA h g−1 is still retained after 50 cycles, which is comparable to the discharge performance of as-prepared electrolytes. This suggests that the healed electrolyte has no effect on the performance of the battery.
Fig. 9 Charge–discharge curves of ShSPE-3 based LiFePO4/Li cell for 0.1C at 60 °C with the voltage range from 2.5 to 4.2 V (a), cycling performance of the LFP/ShSPE-3/Li cell (b). |
In order to systematically study the battery performance of the all-solid polymer electrolyte prepared, the properties of several common PEG polymer electrolytes are compared and shown in Table S1.† It can be clearly seen that the electrochemistry properties of the ShSPE prepared in this paper is similar to that reported in literature.
To further investigate the practical applications of ShSPE in electronic devices, all-solid-state cell using pristine ShSPE-3 are used to light up yellow light-emitting diode (LED) lamp under a normal condition Fig. 10a. To further underline the excellent safety issue, the cell used healed ShSPE-3 was shown in Fig. 10b. It was observed that all the cell can power the LED lamp and the brightness of the lamp has almost no effect before and after healing. This is an evidence to prove that lithium metal batteries based on ShSPE display improvements in safety and longevity.
Fig. 10 Photo image and open circuit voltage of pristine and healed ShSPE-3 based Li/LFP battery (a), the photographs of the lightened LED devices before and after self-healing (b). |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d0ra10035h |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |