Borja
Cirera
a,
Alexander
Riss
b,
Pingo
Mutombo
c,
José I.
Urgel
ad,
José
Santos
ae,
Marco
Di Giovannantonio
df,
Roland
Widmer
d,
Samuel
Stolz
dg,
Qiang
Sun
d,
Max
Bommert
d,
Roman
Fasel
dh,
Pavel
Jelínek
*c,
Willi
Auwärter
*b,
Nazario
Martín
*ae and
David
Écija
*a
aIMDEA Nanoscience, C/Faraday 9, Campus de Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain. E-mail: david.ecija@imdea.org
bPhysics Department E20, Technical University of Munich, D-85748 Garching, Germany. E-mail: wau@tum.de
cInstitute of Physics of the Czech Academy of Science, 16253 Praha, Czech Republic. E-mail: jelinekp@fzu.cz
dEmpa, Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology, 8600 Dübendorf, Switzerland
eDepartamento de Química Orgánica, Facultad de Ciencias Químicas, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, 28040 Madrid, Spain. E-mail: nazmar@quim.ucm.es
fIstituto di Struttura della Materia – CNR (ISM-CNR), via Fosso del Cavaliere 100, 00133 Roma, Italy
gInstitute of Physics, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, CH-1015 Lausanne, Switzerland
hDepartment of Chemistry, Biochemistry and Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of Bern, 3012 Bern, Switzerland
First published on 30th August 2021
The design of organometallic complexes is at the heart of modern organic chemistry and catalysis. Recently, on-surface synthesis has emerged as a disruptive paradigm to design previously precluded compounds and nanomaterials. Despite these advances, the field of organometallic chemistry on surfaces is still at its infancy. Here, we introduce a protocol to activate the inner diacetylene moieties of a molecular precursor by copper surface adatoms affording the formation of unprecedented organocopper metallacycles on Cu(111). The chemical structure of the resulting complexes is characterized by scanning probe microscopy and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, being complemented by density functional theory calculations and scanning probe microscopy simulations. Our results pave avenues to the engineering of organometallic compounds and steer the development of polyyne chemistry on surfaces.
Recently, on-surface synthesis has emerged as a discipline that allows the design of chemical products, while providing access to surface science techniques to explore materials with utmost spatial resolution.2–6
By taking advantage of this novel synthetic paradigm, organocopper complexes have been designed by exploiting halogen-substituted compounds, typically as intermediates of the Ullmann coupling reaction. Most of the focus has been centered on halogenated sp2 carbons, with scarce examples reporting the formation of organometallic polyyne nanostructures via the chemical reactions of brominated or hydrogenated sp carbons.7–12
In parallel, terminal acetylene on-surface chemistry has shown promising results towards the fabrication of well-defined low-dimensional nanomaterials,2,6 illustrating distinct reactions such as Glaser coupling,13–15 head to head addition,16,17 alkyne cyclotrimerization,18,19 Bergmann reaction,20,21 azide–alkyne cycloaddition,22,23 Sonogashira coupling24,25 and dehalogenative homocoupling.26
Inspired by this previous knowledge, here we introduce a new pathway to activate inner polyyne moieties affording the formation of unprecedented organocopper metallacycles. To this aim we deposit the precursor 1,4-di(naphthalen-2-yl)butadi-1,3-yne (1), termed DNBD, on Cu(111) held at room temperature. Such species incorporate an inner 1,3-butadiyne moiety that is connected at both termini to rotatable naphthalene moieties. Our scanning probe microscopy (SPM) study complemented by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), density functional theory (DFT) and scanning probe microscopy calculations reveals that the two exterior carbon atoms of the diacetylene skeleton of DNBD are attacked by copper adatoms resulting in the synthesis of organocopper metallacycles, through the transformation of the diacetylene moiety of the precursors into a cumulene-like structure. Our results pave avenues for the activation of carbons on metal surfaces, giving rise to the design of unique organometallic complexes of potential relevance for modern organic synthesis and catalysis.
First, the deposition of DNBD on Au(111) held at room temperature results in the formation of chain-like nanostructures that evolve towards a closely packed assembly upon high coverage, stabilized through van der Waals interactions (cf. the left panel of Fig. 1b and S2a–d†). Importantly, high resolution images allow us to discern the intact species featuring s-cis or s-trans isomers, whereas the s-trans is in the majority (>90%). Consecutive annealing steps up to 650 K give rise to the formation of irregularly polymerized species, signaling uncontrolled reaction pathways (cf. Fig. S2e and f†).
The above mentioned scenario changes dramatically when DNBD is deposited on the more reactive Cu(111) held at room temperature. As illustrated in Fig. 2, a submonolayer coverage results in the expression of cross-like entities (cf. right panel of Fig. 1b, 2a and b) which are visualized in constant-current STM as two central lobes surrounded by four elongated protrusions, which can have distinct relative orientations. Such entities are rationalized as cumulene-based organocopper metallacycles (2), the formation of which is tentatively explained thanks to a mechanism by which the inner triple bonds of the diacetylene bridges react with copper adatoms. The organometallic complexes can adopt six different conformations (cf.Fig. 2c–h), with associated chiral ones with respect to the substrate. As depicted in the histogram in Fig. 2i, three conformers occur much more frequently. Notably, the longitudinal axis of symmetry of the macrocycle is aligned with the close-packed directions of Cu(111). The robustness of the organocopper metallacycles is confirmed by performing lateral manipulation, revealing that the complexes can be displaced and rotated along the surface over long distances (cf.Fig. 2j and k). In addition, a scanning probe microscopy image acquired at 77 K shows that they diffuse as a whole along the close-packed directions of the surface (cf.Fig. 2l). Such findings corroborate the formation of two relatively strong C–Cu–C bonds per organometallic complex.
Fig. 2 Formation and robustness of organocopper metallacycles. (a) Large-scale STM image of DNBD species deposited on Cu(111) held at room temperature. Numerous four-lobed species of dissimilar conformations can be observed (scale bar = 5 nm, It = 100 pA, Vb = −1.0 V). (b) Zoom-in region showing distinct conformers of the organocopper metallacycles (scale bar = 5 Å, It = 500 pA, Vb = −1.5 V). (c–e) The three major conformers of 2 (scale bar = 5 Å, It = 200 pA, Vb = −0.1 V). (f–h) The three minor conformers of 2 (scale bar = 5 Å; (f): It = 200 pA, Vb = −0.7 V; (g): It = 200 pA, Vb = 0.5 V; (h): It = 500 pA, Vb = −1.5 V). (i) Statistical distribution based on experimental results, showing a stark contrast between the amounts of 1, 2, 3 conformers compared to those of 4, 5, 6 ones. (j and k) In situ lateral manipulation of complex 2 as a single unit, where the tip pathway is depicted with a blue arrow (scale bar = 1 nm, It = 175 pA, Vb = −1.0 V; manipulation parameters: It = 25 nA, Vb = −100 mV). (l) STM image at 77 K showing the diffusion of the organocopper metallacycles along the high-symmetry directions of the underlying Cu(111) (scale bar = 2.5 nm, It = 10 pA, Vb = −0.5 V). (m) High-resolution XPS spectrum of the C 1s core level acquired using synchrotron radiation with a photon energy of 425 eV after deposition of 0.4 ML coverage of DNBD on Cu(111) held at RT. Colored dots in the scheme highlight carbon atoms in different chemical environments, and their colors correspond to those of the fitting components. Fitting parameters are reported in Table S1.† |
In order to get more information about the chemical structure of the organocopper metallacycle, we performed high-resolution X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (HR-XPS) using synchrotron radiation as the photon source. The C 1s core level of a sample with a coverage of 0.4 ML is shown in Fig. 2m. The carbon atoms contained in complex 2 appear in different chemical environments: 4 are bound to Cu adatoms, 4 constitute the cumulene bridges (with sp hybridization), 12 are connected to other carbon atoms only, with sp2 hybridization, and 28 are linked to hydrogens. Deconvolution of the C 1s signal has been performed by fixing these relative ratios, which produces the fit reported in Fig. 2m that is in very good agreement with the experimental data. The components related to C–H and C–C in the sp2 hybridized moieties (blue and green filled curves in Fig. 2m) appear at 284.1 eV and 284.6 eV, respectively,27 while the carbon atoms in the sp cumulene moieties (orange filled curve in Fig. 2m) display a spectroscopic signal at higher binding energy (285.1 eV). It must be noted that a fit without a separate component arising from the sp cumulene moieties did not satisfactorily reproduce the experimental data (see Fig. S3†). Interestingly, the component at lower binding energy (283.5 eV, purple filled curve in Fig. 2m) confirms the presence of metal-bound carbon atoms, as previously reported.27,28
Next, to shed light on the nature of the organocopper metallacycles, we investigated them simultaneously with scanning tunneling and non-contact atomic force microscopies (nc-AFM). First, we deposited DNBD on submonolayer patches of NaCl on Cu(111) held at 30 K in order to ensure its adsorption on ultra-thin films. Fig. 3a and b illustrate that on NaCl, where no copper adatoms are available, individual species are found. The naphthalene moieties are clearly distinguished, while the inner bridge shows two bright protrusions in nc-AFM, which is a fingerprint of the triple bond character, thus confirming the preservation of the diacetylene bridge.8,29 Second, we inspected complex 2 formed by depositing the precursors on Cu(111) held at room temperature. The naphthalene moieties are clearly visible (cf.Fig. 3c and d), whereas the macrocycle of the complex does not show any fingerprint of the previous triple bonds, signaling the change of the carbon hybridization. Instead, two bent lines can be observed, which are associated with a distortion of the cumulene bridge due to interaction with the substrate (cf.Fig. 3e and S4†). The C–Cu–C is seen as a straight line, in agreement with recently reported organometallic systems on Cu(111).9,11 Our experimental interpretation of complex 2 is qualitatively well corroborated by STM and nc-AFM simulations of a DFT relaxed organocopper metallacycle on the surface (cf.Fig. 4). The STM simulated images display the characteristic double protrusion of the macrocycle visualized with STM at biases of distinct polarity. In addition, the match between the experimental nc-AFM image (cf.Fig. 3d and e) and the simulation (cf.Fig. 4d) is good, being able to reproduce the bend of the cumulene-like bridge for close enough tip-sample distance (cf. inset of Fig. 4d). All conformers inspected with the nc-AFM exhibited this behavior (cf. Fig. S4†).
Fig. 4 Theoretical modelling of the organocopper metallacycle. (a and b) Top- and side-view of complex 2 displaying the DFT-relaxed geometry in a stick-and-ball representation. Within the metallacycle, the Cu adatoms are located 2.00 Å over the surface, whereas the C atoms comprising the cumulene-like bridge are positioned between 2.00 and 2.07 Å over Cu(111). White, grey, and orange balls represent hydrogen, carbon and copper atoms, respectively. Yellow balls display copper adatoms. (c) STM simulated image of complex 2 for negative and positive bias. Scale bar = 5 Å. (d) Non-contact AFM simulated image of the organocopper metallacycle depicted in (a). Scale bar = 5 Å. The white arrows are a guide to the eye to relate the relaxed geometry and the SPM simulated images with the experimental findings in Fig. 3. Inset: non-contact AFM simulated image of the organocopper metallacycle at a lower tip–sample distance, reproducing the bend of the cumulene-like bridge. Scale bar = 2 Å. |
Notably, according to our rationalization, due to the formation of the organocopper metallacycles, there is an unprecedented transformation from sp to sp2 hybridization of the butadiyne precursors, giving rise to cumulene-like bridges. A possible transformation route could be initiated by the attack of a copper adatom to the carbon belonging to the triple C–C bond of a single DNBD species, where the electron density is augmented, as illustrated in Fig. S5.†
Importantly, the Bader analysis of the charges of complex 2 reveals that each copper adatom loses 0.18e−, and thus they could be considered as Cu(0), which is remarkable since most of the organometallic copper compounds are in the Cu1+ oxidation state.1
On the weakly interacting Au(111) and NaCl/Cu(111) substrates, the molecular species remain pristine. On Au(111) further annealing of the sample does not promote any discernible reaction product.
In sharp contrast, on the more reactive Cu(111) substrate, DNBD species undergo a chemical attack by the copper adatoms yielding the formation of robust organocopper metallacycles based on cumulene-like bridges featuring a rare Cu(0) oxidation state. Thus, our results illustrate an unprecedented chemical reaction on a metallic surface and provide pathways to engineer robust organocopper complexes and to develop the on-surface chemistry of copper and cumulene compounds.
The Cu(111) surface was modeled using a 10 × 10 supercell made of three layers. Different starting configurations of the molecule on the surface were investigated. The structural optimization was performed until the total energy and the remaining atomic forces were below 10−5 eV and 10−2 eV Å−1, respectively. All the atoms of the supercell were thoroughly relaxed, except the bottom Cu layer. A single gamma point was used for the integration of the Brillouin zone. The calculated Hartree potential and the total charge density were used to determine the electronic properties of the molecule on the surface.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d1sc03703j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |