Xuan
Zhao
,
Na
Na
and
Jin
Ouyang
*
Key Laboratory of Theoretical and Computational Photochemistry, College of Chemistry, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China. E-mail: jinoyang@bnu.edu.cn
First published on 10th September 2022
The biological state at the subcellular level is highly relevant to many diseases, and the monitoring of organelles such as mitochondria is crucial based on this. However, most DNA and protein based nanoprobes used for the detection of mitochondrial RNAs (mitomiRs) lack spatial selectivity, which leads to inefficiencies in probe delivery and signal turn-on. Herein, we constructed a novel DNA nanoprobe named protein delivery nano-corona (PDNC) to improve the delivery efficiency of Cas protein, for spatially selective imaging of mitomiRs in living cells switched on by a CRISPR/Cas system. Combined with a single-molecule counting method, this strategy enables highly sensitive detection of low-abundance mitomiR. Therefore, the strategy in this work opens up new opportunities for cell identification, early clinical diagnosis, and research in biological behaviour at the subcellular level.
However, the traditional fluorescence methods always face the problem of “always on”, because the fluorescence signal is turned on during the transportation process, which reduces the accuracy and sensitivity of detection.12–15 Fluorescence imaging sensing strategies require the design of a switch to regulate signal turn-on, which has been developing in the field of fluorescence imaging in recent years. In some strategies, enzymes can act as signal switches due to their catalytic function.16,17 Or light has been utilized as a powerful tool to artificially control the signals to turn on. The discovery of UCNPs enables such a strategy to flourish.18–20 Nevertheless, a strategy to automatically turn on the signal when reaching the target position, without additional factors such as lighting control, still needs to be developed.
Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats (CRISPRs) and CRISPR-associated (Cas) systems made a great contribution to establish platforms in enhancing assay sensitivity, specificity, multiplexity, and clinical applications.21–23 CRISPR/Cas system's precise cutting of nucleic acids makes it important molecular scissors in the process of identifying and manipulating nucleic acids.24,25 And, in some reports, the CRISPR/Cas system can respond in a short period of time due to excellent precision and clever controllable strategies.26–28 These properties make it become a candidate for fluorescent signal switches.29–31 But remarkably, when proteins and nucleic acids are the major components of cellular uptake, there are two-sided effects. While biomacromolecules on nanomaterials improve biocompatibility, losses during uptake reduce the delivery efficiency. Therefore, the delivery of the CRISPR/Cas system is a problem worth considering.
Delivery strategies of the CRISPR/Cas system have been organized into two broad categories: viral and non-viral vectors.32,33 Viral vectors may lead to carcinogenesis and immunogenicity. The residual virus and integrated genes will lead to the emergence of new mutations, which limits its clinical application.33 Gold nanoparticles are often used as carriers for in vivo detection probes or therapeutic drugs due to their excellent biocompatibility, which deserves further use.34–36 However, in the process of protein loading on gold nanoparticles, the contact of protein with gold may lead to protein denaturation, which limits the transport efficiency of Cas protein.37–39 Prof. X. Chris Le et al. reported on the construction of a new type of protein corona, termed binding-mediated protein corona.40 The binding-mediated protein corona overcomes both limitations of the traditional protein corona for the delivery of biologically active proteins: irreversible binding and protein leakage.
In this work, we reported a DNA nanoprobe technology for spatially selective imaging of mitochondria in living cells switched on by a CRISPR/Cas system. The DNA probes and mitochondrial targeting units triphenylphosphonium (TPP) are attached to silicon-coated gold nanoparticles (AuNPs). AuNPs, as a carrier, loaded with DNA probes, guide RNAs and Cas protein into cells. This sort of multi-layered coronal structure, named protein delivery nano-corona (PDNC), improved the delivery efficiency of Cas protein. Target mitomiRs competed against DNA probes, prompting them to form stable double chains. The CRISPR/Cas system, as DNA scissors, plays the role of a switch to turn on the fluorescent signal in this strategy. Due to the presence of CRISPR/Cas, the fluorescent signal only turned on when the DNA probe reacted with target mitomiRs, which avoids waste during probe transmission and a high background signal, improving the sensitivity of imaging. “Gene scissors” can make the probe generate a signal response in a short period of time, so this kind of rapid imaging detection is beneficial to early clinical diagnosis.41–45 What's more, the lower background signal allows the method to be combined with a single-molecule counting technique46–48 to detect the distribution and behavior of mitochondria, which are important indicators of cancer cells. The sensitive DNA nanoprobe hold promise for ideas to diagnostic imaging of cancer cells.
Fig. 1 (A) TEM image and (B) and (C) DLS data of AuNPs and AuNPs@SiO2. (D) TEM mapping of AuNPs@SiO2. |
Scheme 1A shows the process of PDNC construction. Firstly, the inner crown, which mainly consists of the DNA probe and guide RNA of Cas9 protein, was attached to the Au/Si substrate. Since the main component of the silicon shell is APTMS, the amino group on it provided site groups for the subsequent connection of the DNA inner crown. The EDC/NHS cross-linking method was used to link the substrate material with DNA chains. As shown in Fig. S1A,† differences in FT-IR spectra mean the success of group modification. The remarkably increased characteristic peaks at 2978 cm−1 correspond to the saturated C–H stretching vibration. The peaks at 1645 cm−1 indicated the presence of amide and CO stretching vibrations. Triphenylphosphonium (TPP), as a mitochondria-targeting ligand, was modified on the substrate material, so that precise guidance for mitochondrial fluorescence imaging was enabled. The peaks at 1450 cm−1 in Fig. S1A† represented the ring breathing vibrations generated by the aromatic rings in TPP, which are exhibited when conjugated with phosphorus. In addition, UV/Vis absorption spectra showed that the modified nanoparticles had a tiny redshift in optical absorption compared to that of AuNPs due to changes in the size and local refractive index. These consistent results indicate a successful modification process.
After that, due to the presence of a guide RNA, the Cas9 protein was bound to the nanostructure, forming the outer corona (Scheme 1A). The multi-layered coronal structure keeps the protein out of touch with the substrate metal material, avoiding protein inactivation. Meanwhile, we observed that the outer layer coronal structure of proteins may affect the uptake of nanomaterials in cells. The quantification of cell uptake was performed by measuring intracellular AuNPs using ICP-MS. MCF-7 cells were incubated for 4 h with PDNCs, which had different Cas to AuNP ratios. As shown in Fig. S2A,† the cell uptake gradually increased with increasing ratio of Cas protein to AuNPs. By optimizing this factor, we chose a 10:1 ratio as the optimal condition to improve the cellular uptake. Under this condition, the cell uptake can be improved while avoiding the waste of excessive Cas protein shedding due to the steric hindrance effect. Besides, compared with the PDNC, the cellular uptake of nanoparticles without the addition of the Cas protein outer corona was at a lower level (Fig. S2B†). Furthermore, the introduction of serum had basically no effect on it. Proteins in FBS are nonspecific and have little effect on the stability of the PDNC outer corona. These results demonstrate the excellent properties of PDNCs for cellular uptake, which could be caused by increased PDNC outer corona density which is more favorable for cellular uptake. This provides a new idea for improving the transmission efficiency of the CRISPR/Cas system.
Based on the successful construction of the PDNC, we designed a strategy for the CRISPR/Cas system to detect mitochondrial miRNAs (mitomiRs). After the PDNC entered into the cell, the mitochondria-specific recognition unit TPP, which is modified on the surface, came into play, resulting in targeting of mitochondria. As shown in Scheme 1B, due to the hairpin structure, the fluorescent dye TAMRA and quenching group BHQ1 on the DNA fluorescent probe are so close that the fluorescence signal would be quenched. In the meantime, the Cas protein captured by the guide RNA was fixed on the DNA single-stranded S2, which cannot initiate the cleavage of the active site by the CRISPR/Cas system. However, when two kinds of target mitomiRs appeared, everything changed. Due to the complementary base pairing mechanism and the principle of strand displacement, the existence of miRNA-21 caused the H2 chain of the hairpin structure to be replaced, when miRNA-10b would make S2 chain to be substituted. At this point, the AuNPs were separated from DNA probes, completing their mission as carriers. The long distance prevents the energy transfer between AuNPs and fluorophores, which allows no change in the fluorescence signal to occur at this time. Ingeniously, H2 and S2 have extensive complementary base pairing, forming stable double strands, on which an active site PAM sequence would be recognized and cut by CRISPR. The breakage of the H2 chain separated TAMRA from BHQ1, preventing the quenching. The fluorescent dye TAMRA was shed and the fluorescent signal turned on in mitochondria.
To prove the feasibility of this strategy, we validated this process in vitro. As shown in Fig. 2A and B, we explored the effect of the presence or absence of Cas protein and the target miRNA. The presence of target mitomiR miRNA-21 and miRNA-10b alone cannot turn the signal on. The Cas protein, as the key to enabling the response, was also indispensable. Only in the presence of all three, there would be an obvious fluorescent signal response. This can be understood as a simple logic gate (Fig. S3†). A high FL signal was observed (output = 1) when both mitomiR and Cas protein were introduced into the tube (input = 1/1). In addition, the dual-target strategy enables a PDNC with excellent selectivity. As shown by heat map analysis in Fig. 2C, multiple common miRNAs had little effect on the fluorescence signal.
Although fluorescent signal response only occurred when both target miRNAs were present, we sought to explore the sensitivity of this strategy for the detection of a single target miRNA. We fixed the concentration of miRNA-10b at 100 nM to detect different concentrations of miRNA-21. A satisfactory linear relationship was obtained (Fig. 2F), whose linear equation is Y = 1665.19logA + 2608.92 (Y is the fluorescence intensity (a.u), A is the concentration of miRNA-21 (pM), and R2 = 0.9923, ranging from 0.1 pM to 50 nM). Similarly, the linear equation for the detection of miRNA-10b is Y = 355.88logB + 195.75 (B is the concentration of miRNA-10b (pM), and R2 = 0.9952, ranging from 1 pM to 50 nM). The limits of detection (LOD) are 0.04 pM and 0.3 pM, respectively. The limits of detection (LOD) were calculated by the 3σ/S method (σ is the standard deviation of blank sample measurement and S is the slope of the calibration plot). The expected linear relationship is necessary for high sensitivity detection, which demonstrates the excellent potential of this strategy for highly sensitive imaging at the subcellular level.
What's more, a variety of strategies based on the CRISPR/Cas system have been developed recently.49,50 Of note, many of these methods suffer from a longer signal response time due to the lack of spatiotemporal selectivity, as Cas proteins need to seek targets in the environment to initiate cleavage.51 We tested the signal response time of this work as shown in Fig. S4.† The co-incubated Cas protein and gRNA were added to a double-stranded DNA solution composed of the H2 chain and S2 chain, and the change of fluorescence intensity with time was observed. Compared with no Cas protein added (black line in Fig. S4A†), the fluorescence signal increases rapidly within seconds and remains stable for 5 minutes to half an hour (red line). We can infer the cleavage efficiency of the CRISPR/Cas system from this. As shown in Fig. S4B,† the increase in the fluorescence signal means the success of cleavage. Similarly, we modeled the response speed of this strategy to target mitomiR in vitro. With the addition of the target, the signal increased and reached a steady state after 15 minutes (Fig. S4C†), which makes the method have the application prospect of rapid detection.
Before this, cell viability experiments have been performed to demonstrate the biocompatibility and low toxicity of PDNCs. As shown in Fig. S5,† the cell survival rate had been maintained above 80% when the concentration of PDNCs and incubation time increased, suggesting a satisfactory biocompatibility of the probe. In addition, to rule out the possibility that autofluorescence had an effect on imaging, we discussed the function of Cas protein as a lock to turn on the signal. When PDNCs without Cas-loaded entered cells, the connection between the fluorescent dye and the quenching group could not be cut off, and the fluorescent signal remained in a quenched state. However, when the CRISPR/Cas system was intact on PDNCs, the cleavage of Cas acted as a switch, allowing red fluorescence to be observed (Fig. S6†). The combined effect of targeting and response switches allows this strategy to turn on the signal at specific subcellular sites, which is beneficial for highly sensitive imaging or detection.
Differences in mitomiR expression between similar cancer cells are also worth investigating, which is a test for the accuracy and sensitivity of imaging at the subcellular level. We selected HeLa cells and MCF-7 cells as a comparison pair to observe the fluorescence signal difference between them. As shown in Fig. 4A, a red fluorescent signal was observed in both kinds of cells, indicating the abundant distribution of mitomiR in the mitochondria of cancer cells. However, the fluorescence intensity was different due to the difference in the mitomiR content. From a statistical point of view, there was a significant difference between the two (Fig. 4C, n = 3, and **P < 0.01). What's more, since some mitomiRs also exist in the cytoplasm, the strategy of using dual-target mitomiR simultaneous detection to improve selectivity in this work needs to be validated. As shown in Fig. 4B, PDNCs showed specificity in both HeLa and MCF-7 cells, whose colocalization coefficients between TAMRA and Mitolite Green channels were both above 0.8. The excellent targeting ability of this strategy towards mitochondria was more precisely demonstrated, which provided a platform for more sensitive imaging at the subcellular level.
Primarily, the properties of an individual fluorescent dot deserve to be analysed. We digested PDNC-incubated MCF-7 cells in a 6-well plate and prepared a cell lysate from hypotonic solution and sonication. The highly sensitive TIRF technique was utilized to image the diluted cell lysate (Fig. 5B). We determined whether individual fluorescent spots were single molecules by analysing their photobleaching properties. Single-step bleaching behaviour is often regarded as important evidence that the fluorescent dot is a single molecule. In contrast, if the analysed fluorescent spot is a “multi-step” drop, it means that the analysed fluorescent spot is a polymer of multiple fluorescent dye molecules. As shown in Fig. 5A, the single fluorescent spot circled in the inset has a one-step bleaching behaviour, which proves that it is a single fluorescent molecule.
In addition, 100 individual fluorescent spots were investigated by statistical methods, and their fluorescence intensity distributions were measured as shown in Fig. 5C. The intensity of most fluorescent spots is from 110 to 140 a.u., basically conforming to normal distribution, which ensures that single fluorescent spots can be observed. A high signal-to-noise ratio is essential for highly sensitive detection. The point-spread functions (PSFs) in Fig. 5D exhibit a high signal of an individual fluorescent spot and low background noise. The resulting high signal-to-noise ratio lays the foundation for the subsequent single-molecule counting methods.
Subsequently, we attempted to explore the possibility of detecting lower concentrations of mitomiR using the single-molecule counting method. In the same environment, we prepared different concentrations of mitomiR samples, in which a single sample had the same concentration of miRNA-21 and miRNA-10b. As the concentration of mitomiR increased, the number of fluorescent spots gradually increased (Fig. 6A), which was consistent with the increase in fluorescence intensity macroscopically. A good linear relationship was established as shown in Fig. 6B. The linear regression equation is Y = 44.08logC + 780.11 (Y is the counts of fluorescence spots, C is the concentration of mitomiR (M), and R2 = 0.9904, ranging from 1 aM to 10 nM). The limit of detection was found to be 31.2 × 10−20 M, which is lower than previously reported values using other methods.
Due to the important role of mitomiR in mitochondria and its correlation with various diseases, the detection of low-abundance mitomiR can help us to analyse the mitochondrial content in different cancer cells and disease diagnosis. We attempted to establish the relationship between the mitomiR and mitochondrial content or cell type. We selected MCF-7, HeLa and 293T cells for comparison, and detected their mitomiR content with the strategy of this paper. There are two main reasons for us to choose 293T cells as a normal comparison: one is the low expression of mitomiR in 293T cells and the other is that it is easy to transfect, often used as a host cell. We wondered if it was possible to distinguish different cell types by observing differences in the mitomiR content. We prepared 10 cell lysate samples from each of the three types of cells incubated with PDNCs, and detected the corresponding mitomiR content by the single-molecule counting method. As shown in Fig. S7A,† for MCF-7 cells, an average of 600.7 fluorescent spots could be captured, significantly different from 326.5 for HeLa cells and 51.8 for 293T cells, which is consistent with the trend difference in the content of mitomiR in the three kinds of cells.
Although the mean values are quite different, there are still some different cells that get similar detection results when discriminating cells based on these results. In order to verify the reliability of this strategy for discriminating cells, we introduced receiver operator characteristic (ROC) curve analysis. The area under the curve (AUC) is the integral area of a group of data, which can illustrate the identification effect of a certain method. In clinical diagnosis, the closer the AUC value is to 1, the higher the sensitivity and specificity the method has, and the better the diagnostic effect we get. As shown in Fig. S7B–D,† the AUC of ROC analysis in all MCF-7 vs. HeLa, MCF-7 vs. 293T and HeLa vs. 293T is above 0.85, which demonstrates the good sensitivity and accuracy of this strategy in discriminating cells and then shows the application prospect of clinical early diagnosis.
Fluorescence spectra were collected on a FR-6000 fluorescence spectrophotometer (Shimadzu, Japan). DLS data were obtained by using a Nano-ZS Zetasizer ZEN3600 (Malvern Instruments Ltd, UK). TEM images were acquired with a FEI Talos F200S microscope (Thermo Fisher Scientific, USA) operating at 200 kV. Fluorescence imaging experiments were carried out with a Nikon N-SIM super-resolution microscope (Nikon, Japan) and acquired the images in TIRF observation mode. ICP-MS data were collected on a NexION 300X; iCAP6300 (PerkinElmer, USA). FT-IR experiments were obtained via an IR Affinity-1 (Shimadzu, Japan). All aqueous solutions were prepared using ultrapure water which was purified with a Milli-Q water purification system (Millipore, Milford, MA, USA).
The outer coronal structure is composed of Cas 9 proteins, which require a guide RNA for connections. Before the hybridization, the guide RNA, composed of crRNA and tracrRNA, should be heated to 95 °C for 5 min and cooled to room temperature in 1 h naturally. 30 pmol Cas 9 protein and 50 pmol guide RNA were mixed in 100 μL buffer, and incubated at 37 °C for 30 min. The mixture was added into previous DNA probe capped AuNP@SiO2 (10 μL), and co-incubated at 37 °C for 15 min. The protein delivery nano-corona (PDNC) was obtained.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See https://doi.org/10.1039/d2sc03329a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |