Parikshit
Guragain
*a,
Mitchell
Powers
b,
John
Portman
b,
Brett
Ellman
b and
Robert J.
Twieg
a
aDepartment of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Kent State University, Kent, Ohio 44242, USA. E-mail: pguragai@kent.edu
bDepartment of Physics, Kent State University, Kent, Ohio 44242, USA
First published on 21st July 2023
Discotic liquid crystals (DLCs) are disc shaped molecules, typically with a flat rigid aromatic core functionalized with long flexible tails about the periphery. Here two series of novel triphenylene based discotic liquid crystals are synthesized using strategies including the photocyclodehydrofluorination (PCDHF) reaction, the SNAr reaction and the Suzuki reaction. Some of these new partially fluorinated triphenylene compounds have significantly shorter tails than are usually found in DLCs. The first series comprises tetrafluorinated tetraalkoxy triphenylene compounds while the second series comprises difluorinated hexaalkoxy triphenylene compounds, with tail lengths also ranging from methoxy to hexyloxy for both series. This latter difluorinated hexaalkoxy series is directly comparable to the well-known HAT series. The tetrafluorinated compounds are of particular interest as they have retained their mesomorphic properties despite having significantly shorter tails than are typically found in DLCs, including methoxy and ethoxy tails.
Of the various DLC cores suited for these purposes, triphenylenes are one of the most widely studied owing to their ease of synthesis and generally favourable temperature range. Hexaalkoxytriphenylenes (HAT)11–13 and hexaalkylthiotriphenylenes (HATT)14 are well known examples of discotic molecules which epitomize the triphenylene based DLCs. Numerous variations on these molecules have been made in order to study structure–function relationships and develop materials with more favourable properties.15–19 This includes compounds made with asymmetrically distributed tails20 as well as with additional substitutions either to the molecular core21 or to the tails themselves.22 These substitutions often include electronegative groups, including small substituents like fluorine and larger cyano or nitro groups which have been shown to dramatically affect the phase behaviour of the compounds.23–25 Fluorine in particular because of its small size, high polarity and high C–F bond strength ensures subtle but very significant modifications to the liquid crystal materials.26
Perhaps the best known DLCs are the HAT compounds, which are liquid crystalline when there are six –OC5H11 tails (n = 5) or longer tails at sites 2, 3, 6, 7, 10, 1111,25,27 (with plastic crystals being reported for n = 3 and 4). Asymmetrically substituted triphenylenes, such as the 2,3,6,7-tetraalkoxytriphenylenes, have not been as thoroughly studied, and those that have been synthesized are often non-mesogenic.24,28–30 This has led to the common belief amongst researchers that multiple long tails are a necessary to form a liquid crystal mesophase instead of a three dimensionally ordered crystal.31,32 This belief persists despite theoretical treatments33–35 and the existence of genuine tail free DLCs such as the halogenated indenes discovered by Barbera and coworkers;36 various mesogens that feature short trifluoromethyl groups instead of conventional tails37 and self-assembly of helical pores dendritic dipeptides by Percec.38 In this contribution we report a group of fluorinated alkoxytriphenylenes with tails varying from hexaalkoxy to mere methoxy groups. These compounds defy the conventional wisdom about the nature of the DLCs by retaining their mesophase even in the short-tailed limit.
These compounds were discovered in the course of development of the photocyclodehydrofluorination (PCDHF) reaction, a variant of the Mallory type photocyclization reaction39 which was reported by our group a few years back.40 This technique has proven to be especially useful for synthesizing selectively fluorinated triphenylene molecules.41,42 In some cases, the fluorine atoms are also latent reaction sites, as in the case of SNAr reactions which have been exploited here to add additional tails.
The PCDHF reaction was used in the synthesis of both series to obtain the targeted fluorinated triphenylenes. The overall synthetic route of the compounds found in Series I is found in Scheme 1. Starting with the simple substrate 1-bromo-2-iodo-4,5-dimethoxybenzene 13, a copper mediated decarboxylative coupling reaction44 was performed with the potassium salt of pentafluorobenzoic acid. This coupling reaction occurs with high specificity at the iodine atom. The resultant biphenyl 14 was subjected to a Suzuki coupling reaction with 3,4-dimethoxyphenylboronic acid to give the o-terphenyl 15 which on photoirradiation affords the 1,2,3,4-tetrafluoro-6,7,10,11-tetramethoxytriphenylene 1 which is the shortest tail entry amongst the target materials examined here.
In order to obtain the entries with longer tail lengths, all the methoxy groups of TF-TAT1 (1) were deprotected by heating in molten pyridine hydrochloride to obtain 1,2,3,4-tetrafluoro-6,7,10,11-tetrahydroxytriphenylene45 which was then subjected to realkylation reactions with different tail length alkyl iodides to produce the remaining entries in the set of target TF-TATn molecules. After full chemical characterization, phase studies were carried out with DSC and POM and, remarkably, all the compounds 1–6 were found to be mesogenic. This phase behaviour was subsequently confirmed using small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). There is some reporting of 6,7,10,11-tetraalkoxytriphenylenes and variants with additional substituents and interestingly none of the reports shows those alkoxy triphenylenes in the shorter tail limits (even if there are a few they are non-mesogenic) however there are materials with five carbon tailed and higher which are mesogenic.24,28,30 The phase behaviour of this series of compounds is collected in Table 1 and representative phase textures and DSC scans of the Series I compounds are shown in Fig. 2.
Compound | –OR | Phase behaviour (°C [kJ mol−1]) |
---|---|---|
a Enthalpies reported together. | ||
1 | –OCH3 | K 198 [19.5] Colh 310 [18.4] I 307 [7.7] Colh 182 [9.5] K |
2 | –OC2H5 | K 148 [22.4] Colh 242 [9.0] I 239 [7.7] Colh 128 [19.5] K |
3 | –OC3H7 | K 38.1 [−8.9] K′ 126 [30.2] Colh 230 [6.8] I 227 [6.6] Colh 46 K′ 38 [24.0]a K |
4 | –OC4H9 | K 109 [41.6] Colh 212 [5.4] I 209 [6.0] Colh 51 [21.0] K |
5 | –OC5H11 | K 110 [48.4] Colh 201 [4.7] I 198 [4.3] Colh 74 [45.8] K |
6 | –OC6H13 | K 98 [51.1] Colh 183 [4.9] I 180 [4.9] Colh 58 [48.7] K |
Fig. 2 (Left) DSC curves for Series I compounds. (Right) Compound 2 at 229 °C while cooling from isotropic liquid viewed through crossed polarizers. |
Motivated by these results, we undertook further modifications of Series I compounds 1–6. Each of these materials was subjected to SNAr reactions with the appropriate aliphatic alcohol to provide the Series II 1,4-difluoro hexa(n-alkoxy) compounds (Scheme 2). The SNAr reactions are highly selective for the replacement of only the fluorine atoms at positions 2 and 3, with the initial substitution taking place faster than the second substitution.41 This process produced the target Series II materials in both useful yield and purity.
Scheme 2 Synthesis of Series II (DF-HATn) 1,4-difluoro-2,3,6,7,10,11-hexaalkoxytriphenylenes by SNAr reaction. |
An examination of the phase transitions of the Series II compounds revealed mesomorphic behaviour for only compounds with propyloxy or longer tails (Table 2). This is similar to the well-known HAT compounds and is in contrast to the tetrafluoro Series I compounds (Table 1).
Compound | –OR | Phase behaviour (°C [kJ mol−1]) |
---|---|---|
7 | –OCH3 | K 210 [21.9] I 207 [24.6] K |
8 | –OC2H5 | K 150 [31.4] I 131 [30.7] K |
9 | –OC3H7 | K 41 [2.6] K′ 141 [3.0] Colh 173 [11.7] I 170 [12.6] Colh 139 [3.1] K′ 37 [3.0] K |
10 | –OC4H9 | K 108 [2.3] Colh 165 [15.2] I 163 [17.4] Colh105 [2.3] K |
11 | –OC5H11 | K −12.5 [6.2] Colh 142 [10.1] I 139 [12.8] Colh −40 [4.3] K |
12 | –OC6H13 | Colh 116 [8.4] I 113 [10.2] Colh |
Interestingly, polarized microscopy on cooling shows compound 7 has a structure that is qualitatively similar to the other columnar mesogens. However, the material does not shear when subjected to mechanical perturbation. Its structure was examined using SAXS, which revealed a hexagonal structure with high order reflections including (hkl) 300 and 210, as well as 101 reflections. The 101 reflections indicate three-dimensional order stemming from correlations between molecules from adjacent columns. Together, these features indicate the presence of long-range three-dimensional order (Fig. 3), confirming that it is non-liquid crystalline.
The TF-TATn compounds provide an interesting opportunity to analyze the role played by the tails in the mesophase as, to our knowledge, they are the only DLCs with alkoxy tails (or similar) that are mesogenic over a wide range of n starting with n = 1. We carried out SAXS studies of each of these compounds in order to see the evolution of the mesophase structure as the tails are shortened. Diffraction patterns for compounds 1–6 are collected in Fig. 4 (the structures of 5 and 6 have been reported elsewhere).41 As the tails shorten the intercolumn spacing (100 peak) decreases, as does the peak width (i.e., the correlation length increases), while the intracolumn spacing (001) is practically unchanged. Instead, the higher order reflections (110 and 200) become sharper as the hexagonal lattice becomes more ordered as tail length decreases. Unlike DF-HAT1, there is no 101 peak present in any of these compounds, so even as the two-dimensional order increases the columns retain the disorder characteristic of a discotic liquid crystal.
We can see further evidence of the increased two-dimensional ordering by examining the transition enthalpy of the TF-TATn compounds (Fig. 5). For all tail lengths, the enthalpy change at the isotropic transition is strictly smaller than at the crystal to liquid crystal transition. The liquid crystal transition is marked by the melting of the tails,46 and the conformational entropy of the tails can be substantial, resulting in a large enthalpy change. At the isotropic transition, the columns themselves melt, so the enthalpy change will be based on the cohesive interactions within and between columns being overcome and the columnar order being destroyed. The enthalpy of the isotropic transition is seen to be larger for short tails than for longer ones. This is another sign of the increased order that was apparent in the SAXS patterns. It is instructive to compare the Series I & II compounds against their nonfluorinated HAT counterparts (Fig. 6). In comparing these compounds, we can see consistent influence of increased tail lengths as well as trends that result from increased fluorination. With few exceptions (i.e., DF-HAT2), increasing the tail length reduces both the isotropic and crystalline transition temperatures. It is likely that the tails influence the transition temperatures through the combination of increased intercolumn distance and increased conformational entropy.
Fig. 6 Phase transition temperatures for the HATn, DF-HATn and TF-TATn compounds (H, D and T respectively). HATn values shown here are from the literature11,25 and include a plastic crystal phase for HAT3 and HAT4. |
The effect of fluorination appears to be more complicated. In discussing this effect, it is useful to differentiate between two types of intermolecular interactions that are ubiquitous in the columnar mesophase: cofacial interactions between neighbouring molecules within a column, and edge-on interactions between molecules from neighbouring columns. The inter-columnar interactions are greatly influenced by the tail lengths. Columnar systems typically feature nanosegregation of the tails, and while this continues in the short-tailed limit,38 as the separation between molecules decreases the edge-edge interactions become increasingly sensitive to the specific electrostatic potential at the periphery of the molecular cores. Selective fluorination can significantly affect the character of these interactions, especially for short-tailed compounds. Conversely, the intra-columnar interactions are typically limited to the co-facial interactions between molecular cores and are unaffected by changing tail lengths.
It is perhaps not surprising, therefore, that the short-tailed (methoxy and ethoxy) compounds appear to behave differently than those compounds with longer alkoxy substituents. This is presumably due to the edge-on interactions between molecular cores, which is of increased significance for the short-tailed compounds. These materials feature high isotropic transition temperatures which is suppressed in the difluoro compounds, 7 and 8, relative to the analogous hydrocarbon and the tetrafluoro systems. The partial fluorination of the difluoro compounds reduces the isotropic transition temperature near to the mesophase transition temperature of the tetrafluoro compounds, so while the difluoro compounds melt, the tetrafluoro compounds develop a mesophase that persists to high temperatures. This stabilization of the mesophase following increased fluorination is reminiscent of the effect of other electronegative groups attached to triphenylene cores (e.g., HATn compounds with NO2 or another electronegative substitution at the 1-position) which have shown a similar tendency to extend the lower limit of the columnar mesophase.23 This suggests a mesophase which only becomes stable (and energetically favourable) relative to the isotropic phase after substantial electronegative substituents are added.
The compounds with longer tails, C3H7 and longer, behave more consistently, with a greater degree of fluorination increasing both isotropic and columnar transition temperatures for both the DF-HATn and TF-TATn compounds. Here, the cofacial core–core interactions, and the entropic contributions of the long, flexible tails, are presumed to dominate, with the edge-on interactions between molecules across columns playing a much more reduced role. The cofacial interactions are influenced by fluorination, while the entropic contributions from the tails greater for the DF-HATn compounds than for the TF-TATn compounds. The difluorinated DLC's show a particularly interesting feature, namely suppression of the crystal-columnar phase transition to very low temperatures (Table 2) for the C5H11 and C6H13 tails (well below the crystal-columnar transition temperatures of both the hydrocarbon and the tetrafluorinated systems). Again, this is reminiscent of nitro-substituted triphenylene compounds.23 A theoretical comparison of the interactions of singly nitro-substituted and di-fluorinated compounds on the one hand with tetra-fluorinated triphenylenes (which do not show this behaviour) would be interesting to better understand the core–core interactions and the role of tails in these systems.
The fact that all of the TF-TATn compounds support a columnar phase offers an unusual opportunity to study the effect of tails on the properties of the columnar mesophase over a broad length range of tail lengths. One exciting example, which we are pursuing, concerns charge transport in these materials.
The Rayonet photochemical reactor (16 × 254 nm lamps) was used for all the photochemical reactions. Solutions were irradiated in a quartz tube (approximately 40 cm × 2.5 cm with 24/40 ST joint).
A Bruker 400 NMR (400 MHz for 1H-NMR; 376 MHz for 19F-NMR and 101 MHz for 13C-NMR) and Agilent 500 NMR (500 MHz for 1H-NMR; 470 MHz for 19F-NMR and 126 MHz for 13C-NMR) was used for NMR data acquisition and plots were generated by MestreNova software.
GCMS was performed in the positive ionization mode with a scan range of 50–700 m/z, a mass resolving power setting of 140000, and an automatic gain control (AGC) target value of 1 × 106 ions. The Xcalibur software (ver. 3.0, Thermo Scientific, San Jose, CA, USA) was used to collect and process mass spectral data.
Differential scanning Calorimetry (DSC) was run on a DSC 2920 from TA instruments (TA instruments Inc., Newcastle, DE, USA) and data were analyzed by using Thermal Advantage Software (version 1.1A, TA Instruments Inc., Newcastle, DE, USA).
Polarizing Optical Microscope (POM) Nikon Eclipse E600 POL was employed to examine phase identity and transitions temperatures. Temperatures were controlled using a Mettler Toledo FP82HT Hot Stage and Mettler Toledo FP90 Central Processor temperature controller (Mettler Toledo, USA-Hightstown, NJ).
SAXS measurements were taken using a Rigaku Screen Machine with a Cu Kα source on samples contained in thin-walled quartz capillaries. Samples were heated into the isotropic with data collected on cooling, except for TF-TAT1, where the data was collected from a polycrystalline state on heating due to the high clearing temperature of the compound.
The remaining 1,2,3,4-tetrafluoro-6,7,10,11-tetraalkoxytriphenylenes 3–6 were synthesized using the same general procedure (specific details in the ESI†).
The remaining 1,4-difluoro-2,3,6,7,10,11-hexaalkoxyoxytriphenylenes 8–12 were synthesized using the similar general procedure (specific details in the ESI†).
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3ma00281k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |