Shichuan
Zhong‡
a,
Lifeng
Hang‡
b,
Lulu
Wen
a,
Tao
Zhang
ac,
An
Cao
a,
Pan
Zeng
a,
Hanlin
Zhang
a,
Dilong
Liu
a,
Weiping
Cai
a and
Yue
Li
*a
aKey Lab of Materials Physics, Anhui Key Lab of Nanomaterials and Nanotechnology, Institute of Solid State Physics, Hefei Institutes of Physical Science, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Hefei 230031, Anhui, P. R. China. E-mail: yueli@issp.ac.cn
bThe Department of Medical Imaging, Guangdong Second Provincial General Hospital, Guangzhou 518037, P. R. China
cSchool of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, Nanyang Technological University, 21 Nanyang Link, Singapore 637371, Singapore
First published on 15th February 2023
We develop a tunable, ultrafast (5 seconds), and mass-producible seed-mediated synthesis method to prepare branched Au superparticles consisting of multiple small Au island-like nanoparticles by a wet chemical route. We reveal and confirm the toggling formation mechanism of Au superparticles between the Frank–van der Merwe (FM) growth mode and the Volmer–Weber (VW) growth mode. The key factor of this special structure is the frequent toggling between the FM (layer by layer) growth mode and the VW (island) growth mode induced by 3-aminophenol, which is continuously absorbed on the surface of newborn Au nanoparticles, leading to a relatively high surface energy during the overall synthesis process, thus achieving an island on island growth. Such Au superparticles demonstrate broadband absorption from visible to near-infrared regions due to their multiple plasmonic coupling and hence they have important applications in sensors, photothermal conversion and therapy, etc. We also exhibit the excellent properties of Au superparticles with different morphologies, such as NIR-II photothermal conversion and therapy and SERS detection. The photothermal conversion efficiency under 1064 nm laser irradiation was calculated to be as high as 62.6% and they exhibit robust photothermal therapy efficiency. This work provides insight into the growth mechanism of plasmonic superparticles and develops a broadband absorption material for highly efficient optical applications.
In contrast, Au superparticles (superparticles: size- and shape-controlled Au nanoparticle assemblies) with 3D structures are independent of light polarization and possess a high NIR optical utilization due to their multiple couplings in the 3D orientation.7,8 However, most of the Au superparticles were obtained by self-assembly and their stability was not good. As a result, their practical applications were seriously restricted.9–12 In contrast, the stability of superparticles fabricated by wet chemical methods proved to be relatively high,13 but their direct synthesis still remains a challenge. Recently, Yin et al. reported a seed-mediated growth method to directly synthesize Au superparticles with broadband absorption in the NIR region by the reduction of chloroauric acid using dopamine under nitrogen flow in 6 hours and these emerging NIR plasmonic materials possessed an ultra-high photothermal conversion efficiency both experimentally and theoretically.14
However, for Au superparticles as a kind of new material, it is not enough to rely only on their high NIR optical utilization to replace the positions of Au NRs in some sensing regions. Crucially, the tunable optical properties of Au NRs for a variety of applications are their main competitive factors.1 Since the optical properties of Au nanoparticles depend on their morphology and scale, therefore, it is important to gain an in-depth understanding of the growth mechanism of branched Au superparticles for accurate morphological regulation of this emerging material. However, it is difficult to directly elucidate the growth mechanism of this branched structure in previous studies because of multiple surfactants and complicated fabrication processes. Therefore, a facile, rapid, and mass-producible synthetic method is not only a requirement of practical applications, but also a shortcut to comprehend the growth mechanism. More importantly, unadjustable Au nanoparticle assemblies hardly accord with the concept of superparticles; intuitively understanding the growth mechanism of this structure has long-term significance for the development and application of plasmonic superparticle materials. Therefore, there is an urgent need to develop a facile, rapid synthetic method for branched Au superparticles and to regulate their optical properties by understanding the growth mechanism.
Herein, we report a facile, ultra-fast, and mass-producible fabrication method for the synthesis of branched Au superparticles by seed-mediated growth, yielding uniform and well-dispersed core–shell Au superparticles in 5 seconds at room temperature. The role of surfactants in the synthetic process is investigated through designed experiments, and the key factor of branched structure formation is the frequent toggling between layer by layer growth mode and island growth mode induced by 3-aminophenol, leading to the island-on-island growth of the Au nanoparticles. In addition, the special growth mode is due to the continuous relatively high surface energy, which is related to the synergistic effect between the amino group and the hydroxyl groups of 3-aminophenol, and the hydroxyl group provides the continuous adsorption capacity toward the growth interface. Based on the proposed mechanism, the optical properties of branched Au superparticles could be regulated by changing the core scale, branch width, and the scale of Au island-like nanoparticles. Additionally, we briefly demonstrate the excellent properties of branched Au superparticles with different morphologies, such as photothermal conversion and therapy and NIR SERS. The photothermal conversion efficiency under 1064 nm irradiation was calculated to be as high as 62.6%. This work gives insight into the growth mechanism of branched Au superparticles and provides a potential multifunctional plasmonic material for efficient NIR sensing fields.
Typically, there are many factors that affect the surface energy during seed-mediated growth, such as lattice mismatch, and surfactant.13,14 However, in our work, the main influencing factor of surface energy is only the surfactant because there is no lattice mismatch and the existence of multiphase. Therefore, we will focus on the effect of surfactants on the growth mode in our case.
We systematically investigated the role of surfactants in the synthetic process through controllable experimental conditions. The TEM images of branched Au superparticles fabricated using different amounts of poly(diallyldimethylammonium)chloride (PDDA) are shown in Fig. S1.† According to Fig. S1a† (PDDA content is zero), it can be found that extensively branched self-nucleation superparticles appeared in the solution, and there are few thin branches on each seed nanoparticle. Obviously, the branched morphology still exists when PDDA is absent, indicating the negligible relationship between PDDA and relatively high surface energy. As the content of PDDA increased to more than 5 μL in the synthetic system, the phenomenon of self-nucleation obviously disappeared, and the morphology of branched Au superparticles became more uniform, which is illustrated by TEM images in Fig. S1b–d.† Furthermore, the extinction spectra of branched Au superparticles with different PDDA contents are shown in Fig. S2.† In the spectrum of superparticles without PDDA, there are two extinction peaks that are located at 560 nm (the plasmonic band of pristine seed nanoparticles located at 540 nm) and 770 nm, which are assigned to the seed nanoparticles and the self-nucleation branched superparticles, respectively. Then, as the contents of PDDA increased, the morphology of branched Au superparticles became more uniform; therefore, the two optical extinction peaks merged into one peak and gradually blue-shifted. Based on the TEM images and optical extinction spectra, PDDA is a surfactant that dynamically tunes the uniformity and stability of branched superparticles, but it is independent of the relatively high surface energy.
The TEM images of branched Au superparticles fabricated using different contents of 3-aminophenol are shown in Fig. S3;† the branched structure is very messy when the content of 3-aminophenol was 35 μL in this synthetic system, but it gradually became uniform as the content of 3-aminophenol increased. Note that the amount of 3-aminophenol cannot be zero since it is the reducing agent for this synthetic process. Moreover, their optical extinction spectra are shown in Fig. S4,† and there is an extended plasmonic band in the spectrum of Au superparticles synthesized using 35 μL of 3-aminophenol, implying the irregular structure of superparticles, which is consistent with the TEM image. As the amounts of 3-aminophenol increased, the plasmonic peaks gradually narrowed and blue-shifted, indicating that the structure became more homogeneous. Furthermore, we also employed some other reducers instead of 3-aminophenol for fabricating Au superparticles, such as ascorbic acid, dopamine, and sodium borohydride. However, none of them could achieve this branched structure (Fig. S5†), implying the close relationship between this distinctive structure and 3-aminophenol. Based on these results, it is easy to know that 3-aminophenol is not only a reducing agent but also a morphology controlling agent.
Furthermore, we changed the hydroxyl group to the amino group based on the first set of parallel experiments, namely, o-phenylenediamine, m-phenylenediamine, and p-phenylenediamine were employed to synthesize Au nanoparticles, and their TEM images are shown in Fig. 2d–f, respectively. Interestingly, the multi-island structure still appeared in the experiments when o-phenylenediamine and p-phenylenediamine were present, indicating that the amino group might be the origin of the relatively high surface energy. The diameter of Au island-like nanoparticles is larger than that of the first set of experiments; meanwhile, the clearer dot matrix patterns in the SAED pattern demonstrate the trend from poly-crystal to single-crystal (insets). Unexpectedly, abundant small self-nucleation Au nanoparticles appeared in the reaction involving m-phenylenediamine, and there is nothing on the Au seeds, despite it is just a difference of a hydroxyl group compared with 3-aminophenol (Fig. 2b). In addition, the partial self-nucleation phenomenon also appeared in the experiment of p-phenylenediamine, but the morphology of self-nucleation nanoparticles is still a multi-island morphology compared with the spherical morphology in an m-phenylenediamine experiment, which is illustrated in Fig. S6† and the inset in Fig. 2e. In contrast, there is no self-nucleation in the experiment of o-phenylenediamine. Generally, the binding capability of o-phenylenediamine with Au nanoparticles is stronger than that of other isomers according to the literature.22 Therefore, this self-nucleation phenomenon might be caused by insufficient binding capability, and the position of groups can affect the binding capability of a molecule. Furthermore, the hydroxyl group might offer robust binding capability for surfactant molecules to Au nanoparticles, and the amino group may be the main cause of the relatively high surface energy.
Moreover, we changed the amino group to the hydroxyl group based on the second set of parallel experiments; scilicet, catechol, resorcinol, and hydroquinone were employed to synthesize Au nanoparticles, and their TEM images are shown in Fig. 2g–i. Expectedly, none of them can reproduce this branched structure that is composed of abundant small Au island-like nanoparticles, but there is no self-nucleation phenomenon in them, which is in good agreement with previous speculation. Moreover, the obvious dot matrix pattern in the insets demonstrates the formation of single-crystal during the synthesis. Therefore, the hydroxyl group is not the main cause of the relatively high surface energy, but it provides strong binding capability for surfactants with Au nanoparticles.
Moreover, the extinction spectra of Au nanoparticles of the three sets of experiments are shown in Fig. S7.† The spectra of each set are significantly different, which is in good agreement with the TEM images.
According to the above analysis, we can expatiate the growth mechanism of branched Au superparticles in detail. First, the newborn Au atoms are deposited on the surface of Au seeds through layer-by-layer mode (FM mode) when the reductive reaction begins; yet this process is transient because abundant 3-aminophenol rapidly binds to the surface of Au atoms leading to relatively high surface energy, and FM mode transforms into the VW mode. Then, multiple heterogeneous nucleation sites appear on the surface of the seeds, on which newborn Au atoms are selectively deposited. The surface energy decreases as the deposition of Au atoms, the VM mode is transformed into the FM mode again, and these nucleation sites gradually grow into islands via a layer-by-layer mode. When the diameter of Au island-like nanoparticles increases to several nanometers, the surface energy exceeds the threshold via the cumulative adsorption of 3-aminophenol; therefore, the FM mode transforms into VW mode once again, and multiple heterogeneous nucleation sites appear in the Au island-like nanoparticles. Immediately, the growth continues to repeat the above process. Finally, the island-on-island branched structure is obtained by the multiple above-mentioned looping processes.
Additionally, cetyltrimethylammonium chloride (CTAC) is also a general surfactant to adjust the reaction rate of seed-mediated growth, and they could combine with Au ions to form complexes that indirectly reduce the reaction rate.26,27 Therefore, as an extra surfactant, different concentrations of CTAC were introduced to synthesize branched Au superparticles, and their TEM images are shown in Fig. 3a–e. Expectedly, the diameter of Au island-like nanoparticles of branched Au superparticles gradually increased as the amount of CTAC increased from 0 to 400 μL in the synthetic system, and the diameters of islands and widths of branches are counted in Fig. 3f. The diameters of islands are 4.83 ± 1.03 nm, 7.43 ± 1.68 nm, 7.66 ± 1.28 nm, 9.2 ± 2.37 nm, and 10.9 ± 1.69 nm, respectively; the widths of branches are 39.3 ± 11.8 nm, 28.9 ± 3.6 nm, 22.8 ± 6.4 nm, 22.3 ± 4.2 nm, and 19.8 ± 3.2 nm, respectively.
Moreover, their plasmonic peak locations also gradually red-shifted as the amount of CTAC increased, and the extinction spectra are shown in Fig. S10.† Nevertheless, the uniformity of branched Au superparticles is disturbed, which is caused by the competitive adsorption between CTAC and 3-aminophenol, although it is also a method to regulate the surface energy of synthesis.
Furthermore, we successfully regulated the width of the branch of Au superparticles by controlling the amount of chloroauric acid, and their TEM images and extinction spectra are shown in Fig. S11 and S12.† Briefly, the width of the branch is proportional to the content of chloroauric acid, and the plasmonic band broadened gradually with increasing chloroauric acid contents.
Therefore, we can well regulate the morphology of branched Au superparticles by tuning the scale of Au island-like nanoparticles, the width of the branch, and the scale of Au seeds. Furthermore, the synthetic method could easily magnify ten times to fabricate the branched Au superparticles, which is illustrated by the video in ESI.†
Additionally, we compare the synthetic results of Au superparticles with the data from the literature,14,28–31 which is shown in Table S1.† It can be found that our method is not only facile and efficient but also more uniform in the morphology of superparticles. More importantly, our work provides a complete explanation of the morphological evolution of Au nanoparticles from heterogeneous core–shell particles to superparticles and reveals the key factors of the growth process of Au superparticles, providing important insight for the synthesis of noble metal superparticles.
Additionally, surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy is also a general application for plasmonic nanoparticles, which is based on the surface-enhanced Raman scattering effect of them, and NIR SERS has attracted much attention currently due to its good signal anti-interference capability and tissue penetration capability.20,34 Obviously, SERS is related to the scattering in their extinction and thereby the larger nanoparticles are suited to the SERS because of the more scattering proportion in extinction.32 In addition, the matching between extinction peaks and the wavelength of the laser is also an important factor for the SERS test. Therefore, these two kinds of branched Au superparticles (with a core diameter of 60 nm) were also subjected to the SERS measurements (Fig. 4g). Typically, 10−6 M 4-aminothiophenol (4-ATP) was used as a model molecule for the SERS test; the wavelength of the laser was 785 nm. In contrast, the pristine superparticles without CTAC exhibit poor SERS signal intensity while the intensity of superparticles fabricated with 400 μL CTAC is much stronger than the former. Several repeated measurements are shown in Fig. 4h and i. It can be found that the signal intensity gap between the two kinds of superparticles is still large despite a certain intensity fluctuation, indicating that the larger scale of Au island-like nanoparticles is more suitable for SERS application.
Moreover, the pristine Au superparticles (without CTAC) were also employed for the measurement of in vitro NIR-II photothermal therapy (PTT); the PTT process is shown in Fig. 5a. According to the cell uptake results in Fig. 5b, the cell uptake ratio slightly decreased as the concentrations of superparticles increased; the still approximately 80% cell uptake ratio under 50 ppm superparticles indicates that the cells possess good uptake of superparticles. Moreover, the cytotoxicity of superparticles was measured, as shown in Fig. 5c. The excess 90% cell viability in the dark at different concentrations of superparticles indicates the high biocompatibility of these branched Au superparticles. Compared with almost 100% cell viability in PBS solution, the superparticle solution exhibits a high cell death ratio under 1064 nm laser irradiation (1 W cm−2, 5 min); the cell death ratio in the 50 ppm superparticle solution is approximately 80%, which is stronger than that of Au nanorods and equivalent to the current excellent photothermal agents.35–38 Moreover, the apoptosis induced by PTT treatment was measured by flow cytometry using a cell apoptosis kit; the results are shown in Fig. 5d. About 18% (13% is necrotic cells, refers to the Q1 value) cell death occurred in the cells treated with superparticles in a dark environment, which agrees with the cell viability results. As the laser was turned on, the cell death ratio increased to 50.6%, most of which were early apoptosis and late-stage apoptosis (Q2 and Q4), indicating the good PTT efficiency of superparticles. Moreover, we compare the PCE value of Au superparticles with the data of Au nanoparticles from the literature (Table S2†).3,39–43 To the best of our knowledge, the best NIR-II PCE value of pure-gold nanomaterials is no more than 70% currently, combined with the good PTT effect in vitro as above; therefore, our branched Au superparticles are excellent PTT materials.
Overall, the above measurements exhibit the performance advantages and potential applications of branched Au superparticles with different morphologies.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3na00008g |
‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |