David
Šorm
*a,
Jan
Blahut
*b,
Bogdana
Bashta
a,
Ivana
Císařová
c,
Eva
Vrbková
d,
Eliška
Vyskočilová
d and
Jan
Sedláček
a
aDepartment of Physical and Macromolecular Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Charles University, Hlavova 2030, Prague 2, 128 43, Czech Republic. E-mail: david.sorm@natur.cuni.cz
bInstitute of Organic Chemistry and Biochemistry of the Czech Academy of Sciences, Flemingovo náměstí 542/2, Prague 6, 160 00, Czech Republic. E-mail: blahutj89@gmail.com
cDepartment of Inorganic Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Charles University, Hlavova 2030, Prague 2, 128 43, Czech Republic
dDepartment of Organic Technology, University of Chemistry and Technology Prague, Technická 5, Prague 6, 166 28, Czech Republic
First published on 25th June 2024
Although organometallic porous polymer networks are recognized as promising heterogeneous catalysts, the relationship between ligand/monomer geometry and network parameters is usually not well understood due to the lack of atom-resolved characterization methods for the amorphous network matrix. In this work, a series of copper(II) salen-type metal complexes was synthesized, using trans- and cis-1,2-diaminocyclohexane segments, and thoroughly characterized by single-crystal X-ray diffraction and solution- and solid-state NMR spectroscopy. Terminal ethynyl groups of the complexes were then transformed into polyacetylene chains by coordination chain-growth homopolymerization, resulting in highly porous (458–655 m2 g−1) organometallic polymer networks with a copper(II) ion content of about 12 wt%. The presence of paramagnetic copper(II) moieties in these complexes and respective polymer networks required the application of tailored NMR techniques, which together with X-ray crystallography and DFT calculations of the paramagnetic NMR shifts made it possible to investigate the differences in the complex geometry in liquid, powder and crystalline form and compare it with the complex geometry in polymer networks. All prepared organometallic polymer networks were also tested as heterogeneous catalysts for styrene oxidation with uncommonly high substrate conversions and compared with their low-molecular-weight analogues. The high reusability of such heterogeneous polymer-based catalysts was also proven.
Anchoring metal salen complexes to diverse, mostly porous supporting materials leads to the “heterogenization” of these catalysts resulting in their good separability from the reaction mixture, reusability, and sometimes enhanced selectivity or stability.28,29 In numerous instances, metal salen complexes were immobilized on porous supports like nanocomposites,30,31 polymer resins,32 heterostructured clays,33 graphene oxides34 or widely used mesoporous silica-based supports.35–39 Other complexes directly participated in the formation of porous solids while maintaining their catalytic activity. In these cases, metal salen complexes were integral components of porous materials such as covalent organic frameworks.40 The special category is represented by metal salen complexes incorporated as building blocks of porous organic polymers (POPs).41 POPs are a class of amorphous polymers characterized by a three-dimensional network structure possessing large specific surface areas given by permanent micro/mesoporosity. These characteristics arise from the rigidity of the network segments coupled with extensive cross-linking.42–46 An essential study in this field was published by Xie et al. in 2013: a metallosalen-containing POP was prepared by Sonogashira–Hagihara cross-coupling of a dibrominated cobalt(III) salen-based complex with a 1,3,5-triethynylbenzene cross-linker and subsequently used as a CO2 sorbent and at the same time as a heterogeneous catalyst for the transformation of CO2 into a cyclic carbonate.47 Subsequently, Xie et al. continued with a follow-up study using a POP based on a zinc(II) salen-type complex.48 Other authors inspired by these works prepared zinc(II) or cobalt(III) salen-based POPs with ionic imidazolium groups tested as heterogeneous catalysts for CO2 conversions.49,50 Another catalytic utilization of metallosalen-containing POPs was in halogenation,51 the Henry reaction52 or epoxide hydration.53
The characteristics and the catalytic activity of salen-type complexes can be influenced by the type of complexed metal ion, the substituents on the salicylidene segments of the ligand, and the character of the central diamine part of the ligand. The diamine part of the ligand can significantly affect the geometry of the complex. The most common diamines used for the synthesis of salen-type metal complexes are 1,2-ethylenediamine, 1,2-phenylenediamine, and 1,2-diaminocyclohexane.7,16–18,21,26,27 The last one can exist in two stereoisomers, cis and trans. Moreover, the trans stereoisomer is a chiral compound having two enantiomers with 1S,2S and 1R,2R configuration (Fig. 1). The enantiomerically pure trans-1,2-cyclohexanediamine can be used for the preparation of chiral salen-type metal complexes applied in enantioselective catalysis.16–18 Many authors referring to heterogenized salen-type metal complexes containing 1,2-diaminocyclohexane used mostly the enantiomerically pure trans variant or a racemic mixture.29 However, the effect of 1,2-diaminocyclohexane isomerism on the structure, texture, morphology, and catalytic properties of resulting materials was not studied. For these purposes, various NMR techniques represent powerful tools for the characterization of organometallic complexes in both solution and the solid state. Special NMR methods have proven to be effective even in the characterization of paramagnetic organometallic complexes. However, due to fast paramagnetically induced relaxations, a wide range of paramagnetically induced shifts, and their anisotropy, conventionally used pulse sequences typically fail. Thus, multiple experiments tailored to application on paramagnetic materials have been recently proposed.54 In particular, under fast magic-angle-spinning (MAS) conditions where 1H nuclei can be directly detected, the HSQC experiment with TEDOR recoupling provides excellent resolution and sensitivity.55 Additionally, a 1H–1H correlation experiment can be conducted on paramagnetic samples, under MAS conditions, correlating either single-quantum coherence with another single-quantum coherence (SQ–SQ) or with double-quantum coherence (SQ–DQ).56,57 The second approach is recommended for paramagnetic samples with broad resonances58 because of their diagonal-free properties. This means that the signal on the SQ–DQ diagonal appears only when multiple chemically equivalent atoms experience mutual dipolar couplings (e.g. the signal on the diagonal appears for a CH3 group but not for isolated CH). Back-to-back mixing using four phase-shifted 90° pulses in a rotor period (BaBa) is typically used for the SQ–DQ correlation in paramagnetic systems due to its extensive bandwidth.59
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Three isomers of 1,2-diaminocyclohexane: (a) (1S,2S)-1,2-diaminocyclohexane, (b) (1R,2R)-1,2-diaminocyclohexane (both trans) and (c) (1S,2R)-1,2-diaminocyclohexane (cis). |
The vast majority of salen-based metal complexes containing POPs were prepared by step-growth copolymerization of the metal complexes with cross-linking comonomers.60 This approach introduces into the structure of the POP catalytically inactive chemical blocks (derived from cross-linking molecules) the only task of which is to form a network structure and help achieve a porous texture. Herein, we propose the concept of POP-type organometallic networks prepared by direct chain-growth insertion coordination homopolymerization of copper(II) salen-type complexes without using any supportive cross-linkers. Complexes used for this homopolymerization were prepared using isomerically well-defined 1,2-diaminocyclohexane building blocks, namely (i) enantiomerically pure trans-(1S,2S)-1,2-diaminocyclohexane, (ii) racemic trans-1,2-diaminocyclohexane and (iii) cis-1,2-diaminocyclohexane. The influence of isomerism of 1,2-diaminocyclohexane building blocks on the structure and properties of both paramagnetic copper(II) salen-type organometallic complexes and final POPs prepared from these complexes was investigated particularly by the abovementioned advanced NMR spectroscopy based on HSQC-TEDOR and BaBa SQ-DQ correlation combined with the quantum chemical prediction of paramagnetically induced shifts.55,61 In addition other characterization methods were used, namely, single-crystal X-ray diffraction, FTIR spectroscopy, circular dichroism, and N2 adsorption/desorption isotherms. The combination of a facile polymerization technique with a dexterous organometallic system led to the emergence of new, thoroughly characterized heterogeneous catalysts that are highly active in the oxidation of styrene.
The SALDAC ligands have a unique combination of functional groups suitable for the complexation of divalent metal ions (two imine groups and two hydroxy groups per molecule) and for polymerization into organometallic polymer networks (two terminal ethynyl groups per molecule). All three SALDAC ligands, L1, L2, and L3, were prepared in yields ranging from 73 to 92% and their proposed structures were confirmed by 1H and 13C{1H} NMR spectroscopy (Fig. S4–S9†), FTIR spectroscopy (Fig. 2) and HR-MS (see the ESI†).
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 FTIR spectra of series (A) L1, Cu-L1 and P-Cu-L1, (B) L2, Cu-L2 and P-Cu-L2 and (C) L3, Cu-L3 and P-Cu-L3. |
FTIR spectroscopy confirmed the successful metalation of all three ligands: bands of –HCN– stretching were shifted from ∼1633 cm−1 (in the FTIR spectra of ligands L1, L2, and L3) to ∼1628 cm−1 (in the FTIR spectra of complexes Cu-L1, Cu-L2 and Cu-L3) (Fig. 2). This shift is frequently discussed and reported upon the introduction of metal ions into Schiff base-type complexes.12,68 On the other hand, two bands proving the presence of ethynyl groups visible in the spectra of all three ligands (2100 cm−1 due to –C
C– stretching and 3300 cm−1 due to
C–H stretching) also remained in the spectra of all three complexes. This confirmed that ethynyl groups of L1, L2, and L3 persist unaffected (after metalation) in Cu-L1, Cu-L2, and Cu-L3 complexes. Interestingly, the FTIR band at 3300 cm−1 was split in some spectra. In FTIR spectra of ligands L1 and L2, the bands of
C–H stretching were split by 18 cm−1. This may reflect the conformational changes of L1 and L2 and the existence of two conformers of these trans-1,2-diaminocyclohexane-based ligands. The central cyclohexane segments of these conformers have both azomethine-linked substituents in either axial or equatorial positions. The conformational changes are, however, blocked once L1 and L2 are transformed into organometallic complexes Cu-L1 and Cu-L2. In the respective organometallic complexes, both substituents on the cyclohexane ring are locked in equatorial positions (confirmed by X-ray crystallography, Fig. S12†). This is consistent with the fact that the splitting of the
C–H stretching band was not observed in FTIR spectra of Cu-L1 and Cu-L2 complexes. A different situation was observed in FTIR spectra of ligand L3 and complex Cu-L3. The cis isomer of the 1,2-disubstituted cyclohexane segment has one substituent in the equatorial and one in the axial position and its conformational change leads to an identical molecule. This is why in the spectrum of the L3 ligand only a single band of
C–H stretching from ethynyl groups was visible. The splitting of the band of the
C–H group in the spectrum of the Cu-L3 complex was most probably due to the fact that two ethynylsalicylidene segments present in the Cu-L3 complex were not identical as confirmed by the 1H-detected HSQC-TEDOR spectrum (vide infra, Fig. 4).
The UV/Vis spectra of ligands L1, L2, and L3 showed the absorption band of the n → π*/π → π* transition belonging to the –HCN– group at λ = 333 nm. This band was red-shifted in UV/Vis spectra of complexes Cu-L1, Cu-L2, and Cu-L3 to λ = 377 nm (measured in dichloromethane, Fig. S10†). Similar spectroscopic behaviour was reported in our previous work.12 The circular dichroism (CD) spectra revealed the chiral character of the L1 ligand and the Cu-L1 complex, while no CD signals were observed for trans racemates L2 and Cu-L2 and cis isomers L3 and Cu-L3. The CD spectra in Fig. S11† showed signals at λ = 354 nm (spectrum of L1) and λ = 417 nm (spectrum of Cu-L1) relating to the chirality associated with the cyclohexane ring. Moreover, the CD spectrum of Cu-L1 displayed a positive Cotton effect (with a positive-to-negative CD couplet) in the range of λ = 430–680 nm, which can be ascribed to the presence of torsional helicity of the chiral organometallic complex.69 Along with that, a significant increase of specific rotation [α]D was observed when comparing L1 and Cu-L1 (from 19° to 632°, respectively, measured at 20 °C in dichloromethane, 1 mg ml−1).
Crystals for single-crystal X-ray diffraction were grown by slow evaporation from concentrated (∼4 mg ml−1) dimethylformamide solutions. Crystals of enantiomerically pure transCu-L1 (Fig. S12†) and cisCu-L3 (Fig. S13†) complexes (see more details in the ESI†) were obtained and measured. The racemic transCu-L2 complex did not crystallize. Measured single-crystal X-ray diffraction confirmed the proposed structures (Scheme 1) of organometallic complexes. For the Cu-L1 complex, two symmetrically independent molecules were observed (space group P21). This is a typical phenomenon for enantiomerically pure substances.70,71 Crystals of Cu-L3 were also formed by two molecules. Conformational changes of the cis-L3 ligand (from configuration 1S,2R to configuration 1R,2S and vice versa) were locked once the ligand was transformed into organometallic complex Cu-L3. This led to a racemic mixture of two centrosymmetric cis complexes (space group P21/n). The complexes differed in configuration on chiral centres (1S,2R vs. 1R,2S). Similar conformational locking of (non-metalated) cis-1,2-diaminocyclohexane-based compounds was described by van Beek and Samoshin.72 The structures of complexes Cu-L1 and Cu-L3 obtained from X-ray diffraction showed in both cases good steric accessibility of terminal ethynyl groups, promising for their efficient polymerization, together with good steric accessibility of coordinated copper(II) ions for substrate molecules, promising for catalytic application. The coplanarity of the cyclohexane ring within the Cu-L1 complex with the phenyl rings resulted in a reduced spatial occupancy of the entire complex in comparison with the Cu-L3 complex, in which the cyclohexane ring exhibited an out-of-plane orientation relative to the phenyl rings.
NMR spectroscopy provides a sensitive tool for comparison of organometallic complexes in the liquid state, in the solid form, as well as, within the polymer network. For the purpose of this advanced NMR analysis, only enantiomerically pure trans isomer Cu-L1 and cis isomer Cu-L3 were studied. The solution-state 1H spectrum of Cu-L1 (Fig. 3B) exhibited typical features of the paramagnetic compounds: we observed four distinct signals between 25 and −6.6 ppm with linewidths ranging from 22 Hz to 7.5 kHz and extremely short T1 relaxation times of ∼2 ms (global T1(1H) at 70 kHz MAS). Surprisingly, the 1H spectrum of solid Cu-L1 measured under fast MAS conditions (70 kHz, Fig. 3A) presents a similar resolution to the spectrum in solution with similar NMR shifts of all four observed signals. The structure of Cu-L1 therefore remained similar upon dissolution in aprotic solvents. Under the conditions of fast MAS, an irregular line-shape of resonance at 25 ppm was observed indicating the overlap of several lines (in contrast to the spectra at slower MAS; see Fig. S14†). Additionally, two bands between 10 and 0 ppm were composed of several overlapping signals. Similarly, the comparison between the solid-state 1H spectrum of Cu-L3 with its solution-state spectra indicates a similar structure in both phases (Fig. S15†). However, extensive signal overlap of multiple signals occurred in this case in the region between 15 and −10 ppm.
Fortunately, signal overlaps were efficiently resolved using 1H-detected 2D 1H–13C correlation experiments (HSQC-TEDOR).55 This 2D experiment can be readily measured (typically after approximately 4 h of experimental time) in the 13C natural abundance even for paramagnetic compounds (Fig. 4). This excellent sensitivity is mainly caused by a short T1 relaxation allowing short repetition time (here 55 ms due to limited hardware duty cycle) as well as strong 1H–13C dipolar interaction, which allows extremely short dephasing and rephasing times for the coherence transfer (2 × rotor period = 32 μs each). Extensive improvement of resolution is, for example, demonstrated in the signal at 25 ppm in the 1H spectrum of Cu-L1, which was clearly separated into the correlation of two CH pairs with very distinct 13C shifts (225 and 25 ppm).
Additionally, these correlation experiments can be readily compared with DFT calculations providing unambiguous spectral assignment. Signals of all inequivalent CH pairs were detected for Cu-L1, apart from signals of the CH pair number 5, 9, and 10, which were too close to the copper(II) ion and were not detected due to fast T2 relaxation and extreme 1H and/or 13C NMR shifts predicted by calculation (Fig. S16 and S17;† see numbering of atoms in Scheme 1). Interestingly, the signals of equatorial and axial H12 appear at very distinct NMR shifts of 25 ppm and 3 ppm, respectively, which indicate the stronger contact shift for H12eq located in-plane with the paramagnetic copper(II) ion. The resolution was also extensively enhanced for the Cu-L3 sample using a 2D HSQC-TEDOR experiment (Fig. 4B).
Due to crystal packing, molecule Cu-L1 is not perfectly C2-symmetric in the solid state. This is most pronounced on different C11 and C11′ shifts but also other CH correlations are slightly split into pairs of overlapping signals. Compared to Cu-L1 with trans conformation, the cis conformation of the cyclohexane ring in Cu-L3 results in a much stronger deviation from the C2 symmetry of the complex, which was particularly emphasized by a distinct 13C NMR shift of C11 and C11′ (50 and 250 ppm). The difference in the 13C shift was also observable for C12 and C12′ as well as for C4 and C4′. In all cases, the calculated differences between NMR shifts of the primed and non-primed C–H pairs corresponded well to the experimental one.
Here, we recommend critical precautions during the analysis of the calculated NMR shift. The hyperfine coupling constant (which is the most critical parameter for paramagnetic-shift calculations in a system with a dominant Fermi-contact shift mechanism, as in this case, see Tables S1 and S2†) changes significantly with the variation of the exact Hartree–Fock exchange (HFX) admixture to the used density functional.55,73 On the one hand, for 10% HFX, the difference in the NMR shift of the C8 and C8′ was predicted to be almost 12 ppm while for 40% HFX the predicted difference was only about 3 ppm. The absence of splitting of the C8 signal in the experimental 2D spectra indicates that the admixture with higher HFX content provided a more realistic prediction for this nucleus. Also, the absolute value of the NMR shift was in better agreement with the admixture having the higher HFX content. On the other hand, the 1H shift of the equatorial H12 was best predicted with HFX about 25%. Therefore, several calculations in a range of HFX concentrations are recommended for appropriate sampling of this inaccuracy as indicated by our “rainbow plots” shown in Fig. 4.
The excellent resolution of the 1H spectra and completed assignment allowed us to fully understand the homonuclear 1H–1H SQ–DQ correlation spectra as well (Fig. 5 and Fig. S20†). The efficiency of double-quantum build-up and subsequent intensity of the observed signals of the SQ–DQ correlation depends on the strength of a dipolar coupling between correlated nuclei. The dipolar coupling decreases with the 3rd power of interatomic distance and therefore, for a given mixing time, the intensity of the SQ–DQ correlation signal steeply decreases with distance (inset of Fig. 5). Using a short mixing time (128 μs) the intensity of the SQ–DQ correlation signal for atoms separated by more than 5 Å decreases to below 10% of its maximal value making them effectively undetectable. However, experimental data show multiple correlations between 1H atoms separated by a distance longer than 5 Å within the Cu-L1 molecule – in an extreme case 17.9 Å for H1–H1′ correlation (intramolecular distances indicated as black values in Fig. 5). Observed correlations, therefore, indicate dense crystal packing of Cu-L1 and subsequent intermolecular contacts. This is in excellent agreement with the crystal structure detected by X-ray diffraction: close intermolecular proximities of involved 1H nuclei smaller than 5 Å were detected in the crystal structure for all observed SQ–DQ correlations (minimal distances indicated as red values in Fig. 5).
The 1H–1H SQ–DQ correlation spectrum was also acquired for Cu-L3 (Fig. S20†) where, however, stronger signal overlaps hid most of the potential fine detail. The only two well-resolved correlations that indicated crystal packing via intermolecular proximities were between H4–H11ax′ and H4–H11eq′, which corresponded to distances of 2.4 and 3.5 Å in the single-crystal X-ray structure.
Altogether, we may conclude that 1H-detected solid-state NMR uniquely matches the structures in the single-crystal, in the powder sample, and in solution showing that the structure of these studied copper(II) complexes remained unchanged. This was also in line with calculation. The predicted NMR shifts of the structure fully optimized in the PCM solvent model match well with the predicted NMR shifts for the single-crystal structure (with reoptimized 1H positions), apart from subtle effects caused by the decrease of local symmetry due to crystal packing. This is true for both Cu-L1 and Cu-L3 (Fig. S16 and S18†).
All three networks contained almost the same amount of copper(II) ions, ranging from 12.0 to 12.2 wt% (Table 1). The FTIR spectra in Fig. 2 showed that roughly all terminal ethynyl groups of Cu-L1, Cu-L2, and Cu-L3 complexes were transformed upon polymerization into polymer networks P-Cu-L1, P-Cu-L2 and P-Cu-L3 (the bands at 3300 cm−1 and 2100 cm−1 were no more visible in their spectra). The band of –HCN– stretching at ∼1628 cm−1 from spectra of complexes remained at the same position in the spectra of all three polymer networks proving that the organometallic cores persist unaffected during polymerization. The polymer networks P-Cu-L1 and P-Cu-L3 were also studied by solid-state NMR. On comparing the 1H–13C correlation spectra of the polymer networks and related monomeric organometallic complexes (Fig. 6), the broadening of signals typical of the transformation of microcrystalline monomers into polymers can be seen. Additionally, the narrow signal of the acetylenic CH1 disappeared and was replaced by a broad resonance at 125 and 6.5 ppm in 13C and 1H spectra, respectively, which correspond to the vinylene groups in the polymer chains. The position of the most shifted CH4 resonance was the same in the spectra of complexes and final networks. This was another confirmation that the structure of the copper coordination environment remained unaltered upon polymerization.
Network | SALDAC isomer | Copper content [wt%] | S BET [m2 g−1] | V mi [cm3 g−1] | V tot [cm3 g−1] | V mi/Vtot |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
P-Cu-L1 | trans enantiomer | 12.2 | 522 | 0.22 | 0.39 | 0.56 |
P-Cu-L2 | trans racemate | 12.1 | 458 | 0.19 | 0.34 | 0.57 |
P-Cu-L3 | cis | 12.0 | 655 | 0.26 | 0.71 | 0.36 |
The results of FTIR and solid-state NMR spectroscopies agreed with the proposed structures (Scheme 2) of organometallic polymer networks P-Cu-L1, P-Cu-L2, and P-Cu-L3. All networks were composed exclusively of respective N,N′-bis(5-ethynylsalicylidene)-1,2-diaminocyclohexane ligands coordinating copper(II) ions (one ligand coordinated one metal ion) and polyacetylene chains.
Despite the fact that P-Cu-L1, P-Cu-L2, and P-Cu-L3 were cross-linked exclusively by metalated SALDAC segments (and no other cross-linker was used for the preparation), all these networks exhibited a micro/mesoporous texture and quite high BET areas (458–655 m2 g−1, Table 1). It is thus evident that organometallic segments not only introduced functionality into the networks but also served as rigid building blocks contributing to the formation of porous textures. The rigidity of the metalated copper(II) complex was essential to achieve porous textures with large BET areas. To prove this fact, we homopolymerized the non-metalated ligands, L1, L2, and L3, in the same way. Homopolymerization provided networks in quantitative yields, which were, however, non-porous.
Remarkably, the textural properties differed depending on the used SALDAC isomer. Networks P-Cu-L1 and P-Cu-L2 built from enantiomerically pure Cu-L1 and racemic Cu-L2 segments (both with trans configurations) showed BET areas of 522 and 458 m2 g−1, respectively. The N2 adsorption/desorption isotherms of both networks shown in Fig. 7 were similar with a pronounced N2 adsorption at low relative pressures (p/p0 < 0.1, filling of micropores), followed by only a small increase in the adsorbed amount of N2 as the relative pressure reached p/p0 ∼ 1. This shape of the N2 adsorption/desorption isotherms is characteristic for prevailingly microporous materials with a low content of mesopores. The characteristics of N2-DFT pore size distribution curves shown in Fig. 7 confirmed this finding, pointing to a high content of micropores (pore width < 2 nm) and a low contribution of mesopores (pore width > 2 nm) to the total porosity. In contrast, network P-Cu-L3 built from a segment with cis configuration showed a larger BET area (655 m2 g−1). The N2 adsorption/desorption isotherms on P-Cu-L3 (Fig. 7) again showed a pronounced N2 adsorption in the p/p0 < 0.1 region, which was followed by a continuous N2 trapping up to a relative pressure of p/p0 ∼ 1. Isotherms of this type are typical for micro/mesoporous materials with a significant contribution of mesopores. This was in good accordance with the N2-DFT pore size distribution shown in Fig. 7, indicating an increased contribution of mesopores to the total porosity. The differences in textural properties between networks with trans configuration, P-Cu-L1 and P-Cu-L2, and the network with cis configuration, P-Cu-L3, are noticeable also from total pore volumes (Fig. 7 and Table 1). Whilst the volume of micropores, Vmi, differed only slightly (0.19–0.26 cm3 g−1), the total pore volume, Vtot, showed more fundamental differences. Networks P-Cu-L1 and P-Cu-L2 had similar Vtot values (0.39 and 0.34 cm3 g−1, respectively). A much higher Vtot was observed for network P-Cu-L3 (0.71 cm3 g−1). The explanation for these disparities in textural properties can be based on single-crystal X-ray structures of organometallic complexes (Fig. S12 and S13†). We presume (based on FTIR and NMR results) that the geometries of organometallic segments remain unaffected by polymerization. The geometry of organometallic complex Cu-L1 detected by single-crystal X-ray diffraction is more planar and may result in a tighter packing of organometallic segments in the resulting polymer network, which does not mediate the formation of larger pores (mesopores) to such an extent. This organometallic segment and its racemic mixture are built into networks P-Cu-L1 and P-Cu-L2. In contrast, organometallic complex Cu-L3 showed a spatially more demanding geometry, which does not allow such a tight arrangement of organometallic segments, resulting in the formation of a wider range of pore sizes (high extent of micropores and mesopores) in network P-Cu-L3.
The type of SALDAC isomer used for the synthesis also affected the morphology of the resulting polymer networks. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) confirmed the morphological similarity of networks P-Cu-L1 and P-Cu-L2 and dissimilarity with network P-Cu-L3. SEM images in Fig. 8 display rod-like particles of P-Cu-L1 and P-Cu-L2 networks, whereas partly aggregated spherically shaped particles were detected for network P-Cu-L3.
Moreover, network P-Cu-L1 was characterized by powder X-ray diffraction (pXRD, Fig. S21†). The pXRD pattern showed no distinct signal, indicating the absence of long-range order and confirming the amorphous character of these networks. This finding was fully consistent with the formation of irregular cross-linking during the network formation via chain-growth polymerization.
The advantage of heterogeneous catalysts based on organometallic polymer networks is their possible reuse in the reaction mixture. We tested the reusability of polymer network P-Cu-L1 in three consecutive cycles (Table S3†). The catalyst was simply removed from the reaction mixture, washed three times with dichloromethane, and used again as the catalyst for styrene oxidation. The possibility of catalyst reuse was confirmed and, moreover, an increase in styrene conversion in subsequent cycles was observed, accompanied by an increase in selectivity to benzaldehyde.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: NMR characterization, X-ray structures, UV/Vis and CD spectra, and reuse of the catalyst. CCDC 2333975 (Cu-L1) and 2333976 (Cu-L3). For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4dt01305k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |