Maria
Ramos‡
ab,
Marcos
Gadea‡
ab,
Samuel
Mañas-Valero
c,
Carla
Boix-Constant
c,
Eudomar
Henríquez-Guerra
ab,
María A.
Díaz-García
ab,
Eugenio
Coronado
c and
M. Reyes
Calvo
*ab
aDepartamento de Física Aplicada, Universidad de Alicante, Alicante 03080, Spain. E-mail: reyes.calvo@ua.es
bInstituto Universitario de Materiales de Alicante (IUMA), Universidad de Alicante, Alicante 03080, Spain
cInstituto de Ciencia Molecular (ICMol), Universitat de València, Paterna 46980, Spain
First published on 26th February 2024
The combination of specific van der Waals semiconductors in vertical stacks leads to atomically sharp heterointerfaces with unique properties, offering versatility and additional functionality for thin, flexible, optoelectronic devices. In this work, we demonstrate heterostructures built from single-layer MoS2 (n-type) and multilayer FePS3 (p-type) as multifunctional p–n junctions where robust photoluminescent light emission and broadband electrical photo-response coexist. This is made possible by the inherent properties of the materials involved and the precise energy band alignment at their interface, which preserves the photoluminescent emission provided by the single-layer MoS2 and confers exceptional tunability to the system. Indeed, through small changes in the applied voltage across the junction, the interplay between photoluminescence and photocurrent generation can be tuned, allowing for a precise control of the light emission of single-layer MoS2 – from severely quenched to an order of magnitude enhancement. Additionally, the broadband photo-response of the system presents an enhanced performance under ultraviolet illumination, in contrast to other van der Waals heterostacks containing single-layer semiconductors. Furthermore, this photo-response can be adjusted by the application of an external electric field, enabling photocurrent generation under both reverse and forward bias, thereby contributing to the overall functionality and versatility of the system.
A key parameter in the design of p–n junctions based on 2D materials is the thickness of the constituent materials. For instance, p–n heterostacks built out of multi-layer flakes generally exhibit significantly larger electrical photo-responses compared to those containing single layers, leading to superior efficiencies in energy conversion or photodetection purposes.7,8 However, devices comprising single-layer, van der Waals semiconductors may offer distinct alternative advantages, thanks to the properties inherent to the 2D limit. These unique properties encompass exceptional mechanical flexibility for ultrathin optoelectronics22 and a higher tunability achieved, for instance, by electrostatic doping via a capacitively coupled gate voltage,4,5,23 than multi-layer counterparts. Furthermore, single layers of some semiconducting transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDCs) (for instance, 2H phases of MoS2, MoSe2, WS2, WSe2) possess direct bandgaps and present robust excitonic emission, features absent in multi-layer flakes.24–26 Consequently, single-layer semiconductors can introduce new functionalities to van der Waals p–n junction devices, stemming from the interplay between electrical photo-response and photoluminescent light emission, as well as enhanced tunability through its electrical control. However, the efficient electrical photo-response of type II p–n junctions containing single-layer TMDCs typically appears accompanied by a significant quenching of their photoluminescence (PL).4,5,27 Consequently, the interplay between photocurrent generation and light emission remains rather unexplored in van der Waals junctions.
The combination of single-layer TMDCs with newly emerging 2D materials opens a window to explore interfaces with tailored electronic properties that could lead to desired photo-responses. While various p-type van der Waals materials with different bandgap-energy widths have been recently reported, such as WSe2,28 TeO2 (ref. 29) or tellurene,30 naturally available van der Waals, p-type materials are still less abundant than n-type ones (for a review see ref. 31). FePS3 is a recently reported p-doped semiconductor32,33 that has been demonstrated to be air-stable and to exhibit a broad absorption range spanning from the infrared to the ultraviolet regimes.33,34 To date, FePS3 and FePSe3 have primarily been combined with multilayer, semiconducting, n-type TMDCs in type II heterostructures, demonstrating a broadband photo-response18 and high efficiencies for photodetection in the ultraviolet regime,14,16 but lacking light emission properties. In contrast, in heterostructures made of FePS3 with single-layer MoS2 (FePS3/1L-MoS2), the photoluminescence of 1L-MoS2 has been demonstrated to be preserved,35 unlike the quenching observed in most type II, van der Waals heterostacks. This makes this system an ideal candidate to explore the interplay between photoluminescence and photocurrent generation, seeking new functionalities in p–n, van der Waals devices.
In this work, we depart from the optical characterization of FePS3/1L-MoS2 heterostructures and propose their integration in devices that can leverage the unique properties of each material and their interface. We found that FePS3/1L-MoS2 heterostructures operate as p–n photodiodes, combining a broad range photo-response with a robust photoluminescence. We explored the interplay between photocarrier dissociation and recombination and demonstrated a high electrical tunability for both photoluminescence and photocurrent generation. This allowed us to achieve a precise control of the 1L-MoS2 light emission through just small changes in the applied bias voltage across the junction. Furthermore, we observe an enhanced responsivity of the system to wavelengths within the ultraviolet regime, a feature that is absent in other heterostructures containing single-layer TMDCs and that can be tuned through the application of a backgate voltage. Overall, we demonstrate FePS3/1L-MoS2 p–n devices as multifunctional, electrically-tunable p–n junctions, where both excitonic light emission and photocurrent generation can be tuned on demand.
An energy band arrangement for this heterostructure is sketched in Fig. 1c, following the one provided in ref. 35. Single-layer MoS2 is a well-known, n-type 2D direct semiconductor with an estimated work function of ∼4.8 eV36 and a bandgap of 1.89 eV.2 Meanwhile, FePS3 has been reported to be a p-type indirect semiconductor with a work function around ∼4.9 eV35 and a bandgap of 1.23 eV33 (Fig. 1c). Based on this, a qualitative band alignment can be constructed, assuming a conventional bulk-like Shockley model (Fig. 1d). Electrostatic equilibrium at the interface requires the transfer of 1L-MoS2 free electron carriers to the available states in the valence band of FePS3. The bulk-like band alignment sketched in Fig. 1d holds for the lateral junction formed along the in-plane direction of the device, with depletion regions on both sides of the junction. However, for the region where the two materials overlap, a vertical p–n junction may form. In the vertical junction, a depletion layer is not possible at the single-layer MoS2 side, and the charge transfer at the interface results instead in a strong change in the doping level of the MoS2 monolayer (Fig. 1e).
The optical transmittance of 40-to-60 nm thick FePS3 flakes is ∼60% for visible wavelengths,33 which allows us to measure the PL emission of 1L-MoS2 underneath FePS3. Photoluminescence (PL) spectra, acquired from device A at the marked spots on Fig. 1b at the 1L-MoS2 on SiO2 and at the FePS3/1L-MoS2 heterostructure, respectively, are presented in Fig. 1f. In the heterostructure region, the PL emission of 1L-MoS2 is blue shifted and narrowed when compared to that of 1L-MoS2 directly deposited on SiO2. These changes in the PL emission arise from variations in the relative spectral weight of charged excitons, versus neutral ones. These variations have been attributed to changes in the free electron density in the 1L-MoS2 reflecting the amount of charge transferred between FePS3 and 1L-MoS2 upon contact (see ref. 35 and ESI S2†). Charge transfer between 1L-MoS2 and multilayer FePS3 was quantified by Ramos et al.35 as a function of the thickness of the FePS3 layer. Here, we find a qualitatively similar behaviour, even if, in this work, 1L-MoS2 is placed below FePS3, instead of above. The analysis of the PL data in Fig. S2† based on a mass action law model points also to a decrease in the charge carrier concentration of 1L-MoS2 when integrated in FePS3/1L-MoS2 heterostructures.
The optical characterization of FePS3/1L-MoS2 heterostructures suggests the formation of a junction with unusual properties, in agreement with ref. 35, which could reflect in their electrical photo-response. In the following, we present the optoelectronic characterization of the FePS3/1L-MoS2 heterostructure devices. Current–voltage (I–V) characteristics for the FePS3/1L-MoS2 device A are presented in Fig. 1g as a function of the applied back-gate voltage (Vg). These characteristics are compatible with the formation of a potential barrier at the interface between the materials, as sketched in Fig. 1e. At zero applied gate voltage (Vg = 0 V), the current (Isd) as a function of source–drain voltage (Vsd) follows the current rectifier behavior expected for a p–n diode (yellow curve in Fig. 1g). The application of a forward bias voltage (Vsd > 0 in Fig. 1g), promotes the diffusion of majority carriers across the barrier and the source–drain current grows exponentially with Vsd. On the other hand, the application of a reverse bias (Vsd < 0 in Fig. 1g) increases the potential barrier that blocks the passage of carriers through the barrier. Thus, the generated current (drift current) is almost negligible compared to that originated under forward bias.
Under the application of a back-gate voltage, the forward conduction of the device rapidly decreases for moderate values of Vg < 0, becoming negligible at Vg ∼ −10 V. A similar behavior has been reported for 1L-MoS2 field effect transistor devices at higher values of the applied Vg (see ref. 37 and Fig. S3†). This difference can be explained in terms of the proposed band alignment for the FePS3/1L-MoS2 vertical junction in Fig. 1e. Since 1L-MoS2 already has a reduced concentration of electrons due to their transfer to FePS3, a relatively small external electric field is enough to fully deplete the single-layer material and, consequently, to suppress conduction. On the contrary, the application of a positive gate voltage (Vg > 0), increases the free electron density in the 1L-MoS2, enhancing forward conduction.
The rectification ratio (RR), defined as the ratio between the forward and reverse currents, exhibits an increase as Vg decreases, reaching a maximum value of RR ∼ 750, at Vg = −2 V, for device A (RR ∼ 200 at Vg = −4 V for device B) and subsequently decreases for lower values of Vg (see Fig. S4†). The maximum RR values fall within the range reported for similar heterostructures in previous studies9,13,38–40 (see Table S2†).
When shining light to the entire device area (λ = 532 nm), a measurable photocurrent appears at zero and reverse bias, and grows with the excitation power (Fig. 2a). This photo-response is consistent with the characteristics of photovoltaic effects, where the separation of photoexcited electron–hole pairs is driven by the interfacial built-in electric field at the p–n heterojunction. A scanning photocurrent map at Vsd = 0 V reveals that the observed photo-response mainly arises from the region of vertical contact between both semiconducting materials (Fig. 2b). This suggests that the device's response upon illumination is governed by the built-in potential at the vertical junction. The photocurrent generated at the junction interface is not spatially homogeneous, likely due to the presence of adsorbates at the interface, retained during assembly of the device, or the formation of wrinkles during the transfer process. In contrast, no measurable photocurrent is observed in the non-overlapping region of the two van der Waals materials, nor at the lateral junctions or the metal–semiconductor contact areas. This suggests a negligible contribution from drift currents or charge separation induced by Schottky barriers to the photo-response observed under global illumination.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a) Isd–Vsd characteristics of the FePS3/1L-MoS2 device shown in Fig. 1b (device A) upon dark and illumination conditions at different incident, effective, optical powers. (b) Scanning photocurrent map of device A, at Vsd = Vg = 0 V, obtained with an illumination spot of ∼1 µm diameter and Popt = 72 nW. Scale bar: 10 µm. (c) Short-circuit current and open-circuit voltage as a function of effective power, obtained from data in panel (a). (d) External quantum efficiency (EQE) as a function of effective power for different illumination wavelengths and for Vsd = 0 V (device B). Inset: maximum EQE versus incident wavelength obtained at Vsd = 0 V. (e) Maximum responsivity R obtained at different bias (device B). Inset: maximum responsivity versus incident wavelength obtained at Vsd = −1 V. |
To further characterize the response of the FePS3/MoS2 p–n photodiode, the photocurrent at zero external bias (short-circuit current, Isc) and photovoltage with no current flow (open-circuit voltage, Voc) are extracted from the Isd–Vsd curves measured as a function of increasing excitation power (Fig. 2a). For small incident powers, Isc displays a linear dependence on the effective power (Peff = Popt × Adevice/Aspot), whereas, for higher incident power values, it follows a power law (Isc ∝ Peffα) with α < 1 (Fig. 2c). This trend is commonly observed in similar systems, and it is attributed to a progressive saturation of the optical absorption of the device, due to the occupancy of photoexcited, in-gap, trapped states.4 Trapped carriers present larger lifetimes and low recombination probabilities, contributing to a decrease of the photocurrent generation efficiency. In the range where Isc is linear with power (Peff < 4 nW), the junction behaves according to the Shockley model, and Voc follows a semi-logarithmic dependence on Peff. From this dependence, we extract an ideality factor for the junction to be nid ≈ 2 (see ESI Section S5†), which describes a junction dominated by trap assisted recombination (Shockley–Read–Hall recombination mechanism).5,37,41
To evaluate the performance of FePS3/1L-MoS2 photodiodes, we calculate their external quantum efficiency (EQE) and responsivity (R), which are defined as the ratios of collected charge carriers to number of incident photons, EQE = hc × Iph/(Peff × e × λ), and photocurrent to illumination power, R = Iph/Peff, respectively. Power conversion efficiency is also estimated in the ESI Section S6.† In Fig. 2d, EQE is presented as a function of the incident effective power at different excitation wavelengths for device B at Vsd = 0 V. For all the wavelengths, EQE increases with the incident power, reaching a maximum value before a sudden decrease at higher excitation powers. This drop in EQE with increasing power is a consequence of the optical absorption saturation inferred from the trends observed previously for Isc and Voc in Fig. 2c (for device A). In the visible regime, for instance at λ = 532 nm, maxima EQE of ∼1.2% and R ∼ 5 mA W−1 are reached for device B at Peff = 2 nW and Vsd = 0 V (being Iph ∼ Isc). Similar values are obtained for other FePS3/1L-MoS2 devices (see for instance Fig. S6† for device A, showing maximum EQE ∼ 0.8% and R ∼ 3.5 mA W−1 under similar conditions).
As a function of the incident wavelength (see inset of Fig. 2d), the photo-response of the heterojunction drops dramatically for λ ≥ 740 nm, with nearly no EQE modulation with different incident effective powers, since these photon energies fall below the absorption threshold for single-layer MoS2 (Egap = 1.89 eV, λg = 656 nm). In contrast, the EQE of the system increases as the incident wavelength decrease (see inset in Fig. 2d). While the optical absorption of MoS2 monolayers diminishes rapidly for excitation wavelengths below 400 nm,42 previous works have reported a significant photon absorption in FePS3 flakes in the near UV regime.33,34 Compared to other van der Waals heterostructures, the photo-response efficiency of FePS3/1L-MoS2 is modest for visible wavelengths (see Tables S3–S5†). However, FePS3/1L-MoS2 devices present larger EQE for more energetic wavelengths, reaching a value of ∼2% for incident light towards the ultraviolet spectral region (Fig. 2d). Furthermore, the variation in the photo-responsivity with the applied source–drain voltage reveals a substantial increase in this efficiency for negative bias, displaying responsivity values up to R ∼ 40 mA W−1 at Vsd = −1 V for λ = 385 nm. These results indicate that FePS3/1L-MoS2 heterojunction devices can serve as efficient photodetectors when operated in the third quadrant (Vsd < 0 V), particularly for detection in the ultraviolet spectral region. This feature distinguishes them from other p–n van der Waals heterostructures containing single-layer TMDCs, which typically do not exhibit significant responsivities in the UV regime (see for example ref. 2, 4, 5, 9 and 43 and Table S5† for a comparison).
While the performance of van der Waals p–n devices containing single-layer TMDCs often tends to be smaller than those of their multilayer counterparts,7 they can offer distinct advantages stemming from the single-layer nature of their components. This is also the case of FePS3/1L-MoS2 heterostructures. Devices combining p-type FePS3 or FePSe3 with multilayer n-type TMDCs exhibit better performance than our devices (see for instance ref. 14 and 16 and Table S5† for a comparison). However, in FePS3/1L-MoS2 heterostructures, electrical photo-response appears together with a strong excitonic light emission (see Fig. 1f and 3), a characteristic which is absent in their bulk counterparts. The competition between these two phenomena cannot be easily explored in bulk, inorganic p–n junctions and has been explored for organic solar cells and semiconducting quantum well junctions.44,45 However, the interplay between PL and photocurrent generation remains rather unexplored in van der Waals p–n heterojunctions. Most heterojunctions composed of light-emitting single-layer TMDCs featuring a strong photovoltaic effect, typically present a significant PL quenching.4,27,46,47 In the following, we will explore the interplay between photocurrent generation and light emission in FePS3/1L-MoS2 van der Waals structures, taking advantage of the unusual phenomena coexistence in this system.
Our results reveal a remarkable tunability of the PL emission from single-layer MoS2 as a function of the applied source–drain voltage (Vsd) across the heterojunction. In Fig. 3a, we present PL spectra acquired from an 8 µm diameter spot at the FePS3/1L-MoS2 vertical junction at different Vsd values (see Methods section for experimental details and Fig. S8† for results from a second device). A small change in bias voltage (in the order of Vsd ∼ 1 V) is enough to significantly tune (suppress or enhance) the PL intensity of single-layer MoS2 by more than ten times, a degree of tunability only reachable with large values of applied gate voltage.48 Regarding the interplay of PL and photocurrent, when Vsd is set to negative values (reverse bias), we observe a significant reduction in PL intensity (Fig. 3a and c), while achieving maximum photocurrent generation (Fig. 3b and d). As Vsd is swept from negative to positive values, the photocurrent decreases, and the PL raises. This trend continues until Vsd reaches ∼0.5 V, at which point the photocurrent approaches zero. For Vsd > 0.5 V (Fig. 3a and c), both photocurrent and PL emission increase (Fig. 3b and d).
Our findings can be qualitatively explained as follows: at Vsd = 0 V, the built-in potential at the heterointerface enables the dissociation of photoexcited electron–hole pairs, contributing to the measured photocurrent. The built-in potential generated at the FePS3/1L-MoS2 junction at zero bias may be small, due to the modest difference between the work function values of the two materials (∼100 meV).35 This may limit the photo-response efficiency, but, in turn, preserves the radiative recombination of excitons at the 1L-MoS2 side, allowing for the coexistence of photocurrent and PL emission (see sketch in Fig. 3e). At Vsd < 0 V (reverse bias), the potential barrier at the interface between the two semiconducting materials increases, favoring electron–hole pair dissociation over radiative recombination (Fig. 3f). On the contrary, when applying a forward bias (Vsd > 0), the potential difference across the junction is reduced. In this situation, the contribution of photoexcited carriers to the photocurrent at the junction decreases, promoting the recombination of electron–hole pairs at 1L-MoS2via radiative pathways (Fig. 3g). Once Vsd surpasses the open-circuit voltage (Voc ∼ 0.5 V in our case), no photocurrent is expected to arise at the junction. In fact, negligible photocurrent is observed in photocurrent maps at Vsd > 0.5 V (see Fig. S9†). The small increase of photocurrent at positive bias in Fig. 3d is likely related to photoconductivity and photogating effects. Nonetheless, this photocurrent does not seem to directly compete with the PL emission which continues to increase with Vsd > 0.5 V.
It is worth noting that the alignment sketched for Vsd > 0 V in Fig. 3g would, in principle, allow the transfer of both electrons and holes from 1L-MoS2 to FePS3 and potentially enable the emergence of electroluminescence, which has been observed for similar energy band arrangements in other van der Waals heterojunctions.43,49 However, the substantial increase of exciton radiative recombination suggests that the photocarrier transfer from 1L-MoS2 to FePS3 at positive bias must be small in our system, likely due to the momentum mismatch of MoS2 and FePS3 band structures.35 Besides, electroluminescence would not be expected to be a leading effect in an indirect gap semiconductor such as FePS3. The efficiency of non-radiative recombination processes, such as Auger50 or trap-assisted recombination,5,37,41 might also vary with the applied bias, and could explain further details of the photocurrent and photoluminescence behaviour, for example, the saturation in the PL increase for Vsd > 1 V (see ESI S13†).
Finally, we found that the photo-response of the FePS3/1L-MoS2 p–n diodes can be modulated by applying a back-gate voltage (Fig. 4a and S10†). In terms of the incident power, we distinguish two different regimes for photocurrent generation as a function of Vg. First, we observed that for low excitation power (Peff ∼ 10 nW) the photocurrent – and, thus, the responsivity – at zero and reverse bias (Vsd ≤ 0) increases towards positive values of Vg (Fig. 4b), as the built-in potential at the junction increases. Conversely, a negative gate voltage would lower the potential barrier at the junction and justify the decrease of photocurrent for negative values of Vg observed in Fig. 4b. It is worth noting that the modulation of the photocurrent at Vg > 0 is smaller in our heterostructures compared to other systems, such as BP/1L-MoS2.9 This difference could be due to the higher resistance of FePS3 limiting the overall current flowing through the device.
Typically, the diode photocurrent under forward bias is negligible in comparison to the reverse bias regime. While this is the case for Vg > 0, photocurrent generation in forward bias remarkably increases for Vg < 0 in our heterojunctions (Fig. 4b) and the external gate voltage can effectively switch the forward photocurrent generation on and off. Furthermore, for Vg < 0 and Vsd > 0, FePS3/1L-MoS2 photodiodes exhibit higher photocurrents than those obtained at zero and positive bias (Fig. 4b) and, thus, can operate as photodetectors both under reverse and forward configurations.
In the case of higher incident powers (Peff ∼ 100 nW), Iph behaves similarly to the low-power case within the range between Vg = −10 V to + 20 V (Fig. 4c). However, an interesting change in this trend appears in Fig. 4c for Vg < −10 V, with a sudden increase of Iph. To understand this behavior, we have analyzed the power law dependence of photocurrent on excitation power at zero bias and within the power range of 10 to 50 nW. In this regime, at Vg = 0 V, the photocurrent follows a power law expression, Iph = N × Pα with α < 1 (Fig. 2c), indicating relevant contributions from photo-gating to photocurrent generation.51 Photo-gating effects have been extensively reported for both 1L-MoS2 and FePS3 due to the presence of charge-trap defects in both materials. Hence, the presence of photo-gating effects in the heterostructure is expected. For positive and small negative values of Vg, α exhibits values well below unity (α ≪ 1), suggesting that photo-gating effects strongly influence photocurrent generation (Fig. 4d). However, for Vg < −10 V, α increases significantly indicating that photo-gating effects cease to dominate the photocurrent generation at larger negative gate voltages. This occurs in the same range of values of Vg at which Iph increases (Fig. 4c) and the forward conduction in dark is suppressed (Fig. 1g). Therefore, our results suggest that carrier depletion in 1L-MoS2 entails a reduction in available trap states at the junction interface, resulting in improved photocurrent generation performance.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3na01134h |
‡ Equal contribution. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |