Brian De La Franier and
Michael Thompson*
Department of Chemistry, University of Toronto, 80, St. George Street, Toronto, ON M5S 3H6, Canada. E-mail: m.thompson@utoronto.ca
First published on 18th September 2024
In this work the bacteria S. aureus and fungi C. albicans were allowed to interact with quartz-based biosensor devices under different flow rates, with and without an anti-fouling coating. These experiments were conducted in order to determine if the level of fouling observed was affected by the flow rate. The biosensor used was an ultra-high frequency acoustic wave device (EMPAS) for investigation of device surface initial interaction of S. aureus or C. albicans under flow of PBS buffer at flow rates between 50 and 200 μL min−1. Surface-bound microbes were also visualized by fluorescence microscopy following these experiments. S. aureus bacteria was able to foul the bare quartz sensors at each flow rate tested, with the greatest degree of fouling observed at a flow rate of 100 μL min−1. C. albicans showed far less fouling of bare devices with the maximum fouling observed at a flow rate of 75 μL min−1. Antifouling MEG-OH coated sensors showed greatly reduced fouling for S. aureus, with between a 90 and 99% reduction in observed frequency change depending on the flow rate used, and between 22 and 90% for C. albicans. Fluorescence images of the microbes following the experiments correlated well with the frequency data, showing a marked decrease in the amount of bacteria seen on MEG–OH–coated surfaces compared to controls.
Many strategies have been employed to reduce surface fouling including the imposition of various surface coatings such as polyethylene glycol, zwitterionic coatings, peptides, and polymer brushes.6 Surface topology and patterning has also been explored with respect to reducing microbial adhesion, though these efforts can be difficult to implement on real world devices as they can alter the function of the device.7 This is especially the case for sensor-based detection in bioanalytical chemistry, where changing the topology of the device surfaces can result in a complete breakdown with respect to function. As such ultra-thin and flat surface coatings are desired such that the anti-fouling coating has a minimal effect on the operation of the analytical sensor.
One such surface coating is hydroxyl terminated monoethylene glycol [2-(3-silylpropyloxy)-hydroxy-ethyl, (MEG-OH)], which is covalently bound to hydroxylated surfaces as a trifluoroacetate protected version [2-(3-trichlorosilylpropyloxy)-ethyl trifluoroacetate (MEG-TFA)] (Fig. 1).8 This coating has been studied on a variety of surfaces including polymers to prevent blood clotting9–11 and microbial adhesion,12,13 and stainless steel to prevent thrombogenesis.14 It has also been applied to high frequency acoustic wave biosensors, which use quartz-based devices as the sensing platform.
The high frequency sensor used in this work, the electromagnetic piezoelectric acoustic sensor (EMPAS), is an acoustic wave biosensor that belongs to a class of quartz crystal microbalances (QCM) and surface acoustic wave (SAW) sensors. First developed in the early 2000s, the EMPAS system is capable of operation at high frequencies in the several hundred MHz, where traditional QCM devices typically operate in the tens of MHz.15 Multiple studies have been performed using the EMPAS to study anti-fouling coatings, typically against serum in biosensing investigations and typical flow rate conditions of 50 μL min−1.16–19 The system was also recently modernized to allow for use with modern operating systems, and make it easier to operate (Fig. 2).17
Previously the EMPAS system was used to investigate the ability of Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1 to foul both bare and MEG-OH modified quartz under different flow conditions.20 This work found that typically higher flow rates reduced the amount of fouling observed by the bacteria, with the exception of a flow rate of 75 μL min−1, which was found to exhibit higher levels of fouling than the slower 50 μL min−1 flow rate. This work also found that MEG-OH coated crystals showed significantly reduced fouling by Pseudomonas with between an 85 and 97% reduction in fouling observed depending on the flow rate. This present work aims to significantly expand on this previous effort to study the effect of flow rate and MEG-OH surface coatings on the bacteria Staphylococcus aureus' and the fungus Candida albicans' ability to foul the EMPAS biosensor crystals.
The tubes containing the crystals were then submerged in a water bath held at 95 °C, and piranha solution was added (3:1 sulfuric acid:30% hydrogen peroxide). After 30 minutes the piranha solution was removed and the crystals were rinsed thoroughly with distilled water. They were then dried under a gentle stream of nitrogen, and placed in an oven held at 180 °C for 45 minutes to finish drying. The crystals were then subjected to plasma cleaning under low pressure atmosphere for 5 minutes. Bare crystals were then stored for future use, while crystals to be modified were placed in a humidity chamber held at 70% humidity to hydrate the surface overnight.
The crystals for modification were transferred pre-silanized test tubes (overnight solution of 1% trichloro(octadecyl)silane in toluene), and brought into a glovebox under inert nitrogen atmosphere. A solution of MEG-TFA was prepared (1:1000 MEG-TFA:anhydrous toluene) and added to each crystal (2 mL per crystal). The tubes were sealed and removed from the glovebox and placed on a rotator at 120 rpm for 90 minutes. Following modification the crystals were cleaned by rinsing them with toluene, followed by sonication in toluene for 5 minutes. They were then rinsed with 95% ethanol, before being submerged in a 50% ethanol solution and placed on a rotator overnight (120 rpm) for deprotection. The deprotected crystals were then rinsed with 95% ethanol, followed by acetone, and dried under nitrogen to yield MEG-OH coated crystals.
Cleaning was done by using a syringe to pass 12% bleach (1.5 mL), followed by 70% isopropanol (1.5 mL), then distilled water (1.5 mL) through the filling tubes. Air was then pushed through the filling tubing to remove any remaining water.
After staining, the crystals were imaged using an OMAX Epi-fluorescence microscope using a 40× objective lens under a green filter. Pictures of the crystal surface were taken at random locations across the surface to get a comprehensive idea of the total surface fouling.
Fig. 4 shows example EMPAS measurements of C. albicans against (A) bare crystals and (B) MEG-OH modified crystals. As with the previous case, the measurement that showed the closest change to the average was chosen for each flow rate, and the data was normalized to baseline with the injection set to ∼2500 seconds. Unlike the experiments with S. aureus far more wash off is observed for C. albicans at most flow rates.
Control measurements of LB without any microbes were previously published.20 LB over bare crystals resulted in changes of 1.26, 1.28, 1.85, 0.69, and 0.45 kHz at flow rate of 50, 75, 100, 150, and 200 μL min−1 respectively, while no fouling was observed for LB over MEG-OH coated crystals.
A minimum of 3 measurements were performed at each flow rate for bare and MEG-OH coated crystals against each of S. aureus and C. albicans. The frequency change was calculated as the average frequency immediately prior to injection minus the average frequency 30 minutes after injection. Table 1 contains the averages for these runs for S. aureus, as well as the percent reduction in fouling observed as a result of the MEG-OH coating. MEG-OH decreased the amount of fouling by S. aureus at every flow rate tested, by between 90 and 99%. Interestingly the greatest degree of fouling observed on bare crystals by S. aureus occurred at a flow rate of 100 μL min−1, while for MEG-OH coated crystals the greatest degree of fouling was observed at 75 μL min−1. The lowest degree of fouling for bare crystals was observed at 50 and 200 μL min−1, while the greatest reduction in fouling by MEG-OH was observed at a flow rate of 150 μL min−1. This data from Table 1 is visualized in Fig. 5A.
Flow rate (μL min−1) | Bare crystal Δfrequency (kHz) | MEG-OH crystal Δfrequency (kHz) | Reduction in change |
---|---|---|---|
50 | 5.40 ± 1.67 | 0.17 ± 0.17 | 97% |
75 | 6.41 ± 2.75 | 0.57 ± 0.67 | 90% |
100 | 9.01 ± 1.18 | 0.24 ± 0.28 | 96% |
150 | 5.91 ± 0.78 | 0.04 ± 0.09 | 99% |
200 | 5.49 ± 1.81 | 0.30 ± 0.30 | 95% |
The average frequency changes for C. albicans can be found in Table 2. Unlike S. aureus, a very small frequency change was observed for C. albicans fouling of bare crystals. Oddly at higher flow rates the frequency change observed by C. albicans was lower than the change for LB control runs. Despite this lower level of observed fouling, MEG-OH was still able to reduce the amount of fouling observed. The greatest degree of fouling for bare crystals was observed at a flow rate of 75 μL min−1, with the least amount of fouling observed at 200 μL min−1. For MEG-OH modified crystals the greatest frequency change observed occurred at 75 μL min−1, while the lowest degree at 150 μL min−1. MEG-OH provided the greatest reduction in frequency change at 150 μL min−1, and performed most poorly at 100 μL min−1. The data from this table is visualized in Fig. 5B.
Flow rate (μL min−1) | Bare crystal Δfrequency (kHz) | MEG-OH crystal Δfrequency (kHz) | Reduction in change |
---|---|---|---|
50 | 1.62 ± 1.59 | 0.60 ± 0.57 | 63% |
75 | 2.02 ± 0.62 | 0.60 ± 0.58 | 70% |
100 | 0.68 ± 0.41 | 0.53 ± 0.67 | 22% |
150 | 0.85 ± 1.09 | 0.08 ± 0.37 | 90% |
200 | 0.49 ± 0.74 | 0.34 ± 0.37 | 30% |
Additionally, for each flow rate a bare and a MEG-OH coated crystal was removed from the crystal holder, stained with Sytox Green, and imaged using a fluorescent microscope to visualize the microbes. Each crystal was imaged 10 times at random locations, and an example representative image for each flow rate was chosen (Fig. 6 and 7). The average amount of S. aureus seen in the images correlates well with the frequency changes seen at each flow rate. For C. albicans, despite the measured frequency changes often being lower than those of the LB control runs, a fair number of cell clusters can be seen on the bare crystals. The number and size of cultures observed on MEG-OH crystals was typically lower in the presence of MEG-OH compared to bare crystals, agreeing with the frequency change reductions measured by the EMPAS system.
For MEG-OH coated crystals a large decrease in S. aureus fouling was observed, with a frequency change reduction of between 90 and 99% compared to bare crystals depending on the flow rate. This agrees well not only with the previous EMPAS experiments with P. aeruginosa, but with previously published studies of the MEG-OH anti-fouling effect against bacteria on polyurethane.12 In that work MEG-OH was better able to reduce S. aureus fouling on polyurethane compared to P. aeruginosa. This holds true on quartz where P. aeruginosa fouling was reduced between 85 and 97%, while a similar reduction in fouling was observed against S. aureus.
Another factor to note is the control measurements where LB alone was injected over the EMPAS crystals.20 In these measurements the LB itself did foul the bare EMPAS crystals, resulting in frequency changes between 0.5 and 2 kHz against bare crystals depending on the flow rate, with no fouling observed against MEG-OH coated crystals. At each flow rate this was much lower than the frequency change observed when S. aureus was present in the injection, and account for less than 25% of the observed fouling at each flow rate. In the case of MEG-OH coated crystals no fouling was observed with only LB injected, with each signal returning to baseline after 30 minutes of flow regardless of flow rate. Even accounting for the small amount of fouling caused by LB on the bare crystals, MEG-OH coated crystals still show a large degree of anti-fouling against S. aureus bacteria.
Another area where this study compared favourably to the previous EMPAS study is the variation in signal change observed between runs. For bare EMPAS crystals the variation between runs was quite high, as much as 2.75 kHz at a flow rate of 75 μL min−1. This variation was much lower in the case of MEG-OH coated crystals, with a maximum variation of 0.67 kHz also at a flow rate of 75 μL min−1. As such not only does MEG-OH reduce the amount of fouling observed, but it allows for more consistent measurements with less variation, something very important for accurate and reproducible analytical measurements.
Unlike the previous work with P aeruginosa, this study also includes fluorescence imaging of surface bound S. aureus or C. albicans after EMPAS measurement. Each crystal had any surface bound microbes fixed to the surface following the 30 minutes PBS wash-off in the EMPAS, and was stained with Sytox Green for visualization by fluorescence microscopy. Ten images using a 40× objective lens were taken of each crystal at random location across the surface. For bare crystals S. aureus were seen consistently across the crystal surfaces at each flow rate, though some variation in the amount of bacteria was seen. The average amount of surface bacteria seen at each flow rate correlated well with the frequency changes measured using the EMPAS, with the most bacteria seen at a flow rate of 100 μL min−1, and the least at flow rates of 50 and 200 μL min−1. The bacteria was also observed to clump together more at 100 μL min−1, while more individual bacteria were seen at the other flow rates.
In the case of MEG-OH coated crystals very few bacteria were observed on each surface, with many of the recorded images showing zero or only a few bacteria within the field of view. Images where bacteria could be seen were chosen for this publication (Fig. 6). As with the EMPAS measurements, a marked decrease in bacteria was seen on the MEG-OH coated crystals compared to bare crystals at each flow rate. As well there was very little clumping of bacteria seen on MEG-OH coated surfaces, with most bacteria observed being alone where they were on the surface.
For C. albicans exposed to bare crystals clumps of cells could be seen across the crystal surface at flow rates of 100 and 150 μL min−1, with individual cells also being present. At flow rates of 50 and 75 μL min−1 there were fewer cell clumps observed, but smaller clumps and individual cells were still common across the surfaces. At the fastest flow rate of 200 μL min−1 only a small number of individual cells were observed in each image. Despite the large number of cell clumps visually observed on the crystal surfaces at the 100 and 150 μL min−1 flow rates, the frequency changes were quite low, lower than the control runs in the case of 100 μL min−1. Additionally the observed frequency change for lower frequencies was greater than these frequencies, even though far more cells could be seen on the surface visually at these two higher flow rates. This suggests that surface bound C. albicans clusters exhibit some effect on the slip of the crystal, though further work would need to be done to determine if that is the case.
For both the frequency data and the fluorescence images, a reduction in fouling was observed for MEG-OH coated crystals. The level of reduction in fouling was lower than that observed for S. aureus, with between 22 and 90% reduction seen depending on flow rate, compared to 90 to 99% for S. aureus. This is in agreement with previously published work, which demonstrated a greater ability of MEG-OH to reduce S. aureus fouling compared to C. albicans.12 This could also be due to C. albicans showing a much lower frequency change on the control crystals, so any variation in the fouling of MEG-OH coated crystals had a much greater effect on the observed reduction in fouling compared to S. aureus. The overall differences in fouling observed between S. aureus and C. albicans on bare crystals is possibly due to differences in the outer membrane proteins of S. aureus,21 and the cell wall of C. albicans.22 These 2 species use difference proteins for surface adhesion and biofilm formation, which could act differently in interactions with quartz, though further research would be needed to verify this.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |